Rafi sahab se koi bhi singer ko compare Kiya Nahin Jata Hai Rafi sahab se Kishor Kumar Achcha singer hai Rafi sahab se Kisi Ko copy Kiya Nahin jaega❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
In 1969 se Rafi sahab ka 19 month gap. No singing. Un donoko competator bana diya. Pehle eisa nehi tha. Jo hua accha hua. Kishore da patri pe aa gaya. They both are the greatest and No. 1.
@@manoj_agr sir ek request tha.90's ke 2 great singer kumar sanu vs udit narayan pe ek video banaiye na.in dono singers ke fan mein bhi kau better hai yeh lekar bahes hai.argument hai.
Actually rafi sahb was technically correct and classical ahead but kishora da was much fluent and versatile so both are great and we all are blessed to hear the voices of the two as we may call two were mountain peaks
For playback singing Kishore Kumar is probably better although i agree Rafi was melodious. Even Lata Ji and Asha Ji said the same thing. Kishore was an actor himself and his expressions were always spot on. Kishore upstaged Rafi on many songs they sang together. Tum bin jahoon Kahan is a good example. Rafi's version was great and melodious but Kishore's presentation starting with the humming stole the show.
किशोरदा versatile पर्सन थे versatile singer नहीं थे, उन्होंने सिर्फ कॉमेडी, हॅपी और sad हिट साँग गाए है जबकी रफीजी ने भजन गजल कव्वाली बच्चोंके गाने क्लासिकल गाने रोमँटिक सोलो,डुएट इतने सभी प्रकार के हिट गाने गाए है, ऐसे हिट गाने किशोरदा ने नहीं गाए है, क्या किशोरदा के सभी फॅन्स को उनके ऐसे सभी टाईप के गाने मालूम है? उनके सभी फॅन्स तो सिर्फ आरडी किशोरदा के गाने ही सुनते है उनको तो किशोरदा के पुराने ब्लॅक अँड व्हाईट गाने भी पसंद नही आते है, वो सिर्फ एक ही टाईप के गाने सुनते है सीधे सरल आसान आरडी किशोरदा के गाने
Yeh perception pehle tha ki kishore sirf ha ha hu hu kism ke gaane ga sakte hain lekin baad mein sab ne unki pratibha ko pehchana. Aap yeh kutch gaane suniye aur dekhiye ki woh bhi ek behtareen singer the czcams.com/video/AGrMahsk3Bk/video.htmlsi=8CxXf5QH9h0Hc3R6 czcams.com/video/-OUiQFr4j1k/video.htmlsi=rkG4Efai8LJa7qyP czcams.com/video/rsuzrIVoFYY/video.htmlsi=1Mkzhd_DgN8NiBUx
@@manoj_agr This is what I was trying to say by 'ulterior motive',defending or trying to placing him at par with Rafisaab,which isnt required,in the first place.Now,take Asha with Lata.Even if Lataji is considered best,Ashaji has her own place.
Lata ji and Asha ji case is different because Lata ji was always at the top. Rafi Sahab ruled the air waves in 50s-60s, but then Kishore da became the top billing in the 70s-80s. That's why there is bad blood between the fans of both. My only motive was to bring the music fans together. Like I said in my video, "You may prefer one over the other," but as a music fan, we should be able to appreciate both (and other greats) without biases and silly comparisons.
@@manoj_agr May be you are right about Lata-Asha part but ulterior motive of trying to place them at par,or mainly trying to prove,in both parts, that KK was equal is obvious.Both had thier own styles and there is nothing wrong in anyone preferring one over the other.
Good analysis sir! But I would like to say, class of MD. Rafi and Kisore Kumar is not alike. Kisore Kumar was versatile, holder of baritone voice, he was an actor, musician, singer, producer, director, script writer.... He was a total artist in India. On the other-hand, MD. Rafi was an unparalleled classical singer in India. His voice was silky, sweet and also romantic! He could sing based on all RAGA-RAGINI. He sang very very tough songs very easily which had not been possible without himself. Beauty of his voice was, that had not broken when raising in the top and sublime position! (Baiju Bawra, Mahua, Neelkamal, Dosti, Pakeeza, Kagaj ki ful etc.). These eqniques will remain till Indian Music world sustains! I think Rafi and Manna Dey were the same style singers in our country. Sir, myself is a music lover, therefore, I expressed it in accordance with my capacity, my view. I may be wrong, if any wrong you denote, please rectify the same. Thanking you sir, I convey my best regards to you.
किशोरदा versatile पर्सन थे लेकीन versatile singer nahi थे, सिर्फ comedy,sad aur happy song ही उनके हिट हुए, रफीजी ने तो सभी प्रकार के हिट गाने गाए है, जैसे भजन, कव्वाली, क्लासिकल, गजल, कॉमेडी साँग,बच्चोंके साँग,sad song, duet romantic hit songs गाए है जबकी किशोरदाने इतने सभी टाईप के हिट गाने नहीं गाए है, क्या किशोरदा के सभी फॅन्स को उनके भजन गजल कव्वाली क्लासिकल बच्चोंके गाने मालूम है?
Another tasteful talk, vivid and unambiguous. My comment will fall short if i dont use my favourite word for thingd that i really like..... Mazedaar. Lol. Keep it up sir, no doubt coffee and tea can nvr b compared. My compliments from accross the border, cause music has no boundaries.
Dont think this 'clarification' part was required.People with reasonable knowledge could see the ulterior motive behind the 1st part,and 2nd part is just an extension of the same thought that both Rafisaab and Kishore Kumar were equal in talent for singing.(which wasnt so,in my view).We know your true liking(nothing wrong about YOUR preference)due to your earlier well made video 'Apni Car Aur Kishore Kumar'.
Not sure what you mean by "ulterior motive". Like I said in my video, neither Kishore da nor Rafi sahab need my promotion. Maybe you missed my other song czcams.com/video/kuK2WfZT6_w/video.htmlsi=5jcQIbr8RCMydmXE
Mohammad Rafi is best of the best. Top 10 indian singers of all time. 1)Mohammad Rafi 2)Lata Mangeshkar 3)Kishore Kumar/Kj yusudas 4)Sonu Nigam 5)Shreya Ghosal 6)Udit Naraine 7)Alka yagnik 8)kumar sanu 9)Asha Bhosle 10)Arijit Singh
Comparison of Rafi sahab with kishore kumar is itself baseless. How can anyone compare Rafi Sahab with anyone. Just by singing romantic, soft peppy number can't make you the greatest
No sure what you mean. Are you saying Kishore da sang only soft romantic and peppy songs because if you are then that is not correct. Watch what Lata ji has to say about him czcams.com/video/ybymSfOyE8Y/video.htmlsi=EDiiAleRRtN99MVx Also, search for javed akhtar and Asha Bhonsle on Kishore da.
Filmi dunya men ek mard aadmi tha Manna da jisne saf kaha Rafi sb is 1number baqi filmi dunya se Jude sare hijre hain jo Rafi sb ke moqable kk ko khada kerte hai,kk aoor kaka accidental hiro aoor accidental gaekar hain pahle apisod men aapne kuch gano ki misal di jo Burman da kk aoor Rafi sb tak simit thi ,isse andaza lagta hai aapki ki language aoor gaeki ka tajurba simit hai
The first video was more balanced, and in this one, I am only responding to the comments that were mostly critical of Kishore da. Hence, it may appear that way.
Kishore Kumar can't sing classical song as good as Rafi. Rafi Can't Sing Intehaan Ho Gayi,Roop Tera Mastana,thodi si jo pee li hai,pyar hume kis mod pe le aaya as good as Kishore Da.
@@maheshbrar Bro, please…if you're a fan, stay a fan and don't act foolish. Not every song suits every singer's voice. This song won't sound as good in Rafi's voice. For example, Sonu Nigam is the best singer today, but his voice wouldn't suit "Saada Haq," just like Mika's voice wouldn't suit "Abhi Mujh Mein Kahin." And historically, if a song has been sung by Kishore Kumar, Lata Mangeshkar, Rafi, and Asha Bhosle, Kishore Kumar's version has often been the bigger hit.
Sir i am from Karachi The kishore is master piece of the singers
Yes, I love both.
Maine video k dono part dekhe very good analysis both singers are great
Very Good Video 👌 Thanks a lot Sir 🙏
Great review
Both singers are legends 😊
Film Beju bawara
Film Gopi ke songs, Mohammed Rafi is god of voice ❤
Both singer were no 1
Rafi sahab se koi bhi singer ko compare Kiya Nahin Jata Hai Rafi sahab se Kishor Kumar Achcha singer hai Rafi sahab se Kisi Ko copy Kiya Nahin jaega❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
They were both uniq singers in their time and that is what makes them in comparable.
Well said 👏
In 1969 se Rafi sahab ka 19 month gap. No singing. Un donoko competator bana diya. Pehle eisa nehi tha. Jo hua accha hua. Kishore da patri pe aa gaya. They both are the greatest and No. 1.
Well said…
Sir apki awaz sach mein bhut achi hai
Thank you 😊
@@manoj_agr sir ek request tha.90's ke 2 great singer kumar sanu vs udit narayan pe ek video banaiye na.in dono singers ke fan mein bhi kau better hai yeh lekar bahes hai.argument hai.
Actually rafi sahb was technically correct and classical ahead but kishora da was much fluent and versatile so both are great and we all are blessed to hear the voices of the two as we may call two were mountain peaks
For playback singing Kishore Kumar is probably better although i agree Rafi was melodious. Even Lata Ji and Asha Ji said the same thing. Kishore was an actor himself and his expressions were always spot on. Kishore upstaged Rafi on many songs they sang together. Tum bin jahoon Kahan is a good example. Rafi's version was great and melodious but Kishore's presentation starting with the humming stole the show.
किशोरदा versatile पर्सन थे versatile singer नहीं थे, उन्होंने सिर्फ कॉमेडी, हॅपी और sad हिट साँग गाए है जबकी रफीजी ने भजन गजल कव्वाली बच्चोंके गाने क्लासिकल गाने रोमँटिक सोलो,डुएट इतने सभी प्रकार के हिट गाने गाए है, ऐसे हिट गाने किशोरदा ने नहीं गाए है, क्या किशोरदा के सभी फॅन्स को उनके ऐसे सभी टाईप के गाने मालूम है? उनके सभी फॅन्स तो सिर्फ आरडी किशोरदा के गाने ही सुनते है उनको तो किशोरदा के पुराने ब्लॅक अँड व्हाईट गाने भी पसंद नही आते है, वो सिर्फ एक ही टाईप के गाने सुनते है सीधे सरल आसान आरडी किशोरदा के गाने
Well explained ....
Why should we go for comparision in between of these two legendary singers. They were all above these comparision.
Ha ha hi hi me Kishore hai per mushkil classic gane Rafi sahab hi hai khoon nikal ke gana Gaya Aisa koi ga nahi sakta
Yeh perception pehle tha ki kishore sirf ha ha hu hu kism ke gaane ga sakte hain lekin baad mein sab ne unki pratibha ko pehchana. Aap yeh kutch gaane suniye aur dekhiye ki woh bhi ek behtareen singer the
czcams.com/video/AGrMahsk3Bk/video.htmlsi=8CxXf5QH9h0Hc3R6
czcams.com/video/-OUiQFr4j1k/video.htmlsi=rkG4Efai8LJa7qyP
czcams.com/video/rsuzrIVoFYY/video.htmlsi=1Mkzhd_DgN8NiBUx
Aap kyo unko clarification de rahe hai...murkh ko clarification de kar koi fayda nahi..
@@manoj_agr This is what I was trying to say by 'ulterior motive',defending or trying to placing him at par with Rafisaab,which isnt required,in the first place.Now,take Asha with Lata.Even if Lataji is considered best,Ashaji has her own place.
Lata ji and Asha ji case is different because Lata ji was always at the top. Rafi Sahab ruled the air waves in 50s-60s, but then Kishore da became the top billing in the 70s-80s. That's why there is bad blood between the fans of both. My only motive was to bring the music fans together. Like I said in my video, "You may prefer one over the other," but as a music fan, we should be able to appreciate both (and other greats) without biases and silly comparisons.
@@manoj_agr May be you are right about Lata-Asha part but ulterior motive of trying to place them at par,or mainly trying to prove,in both parts, that KK was equal is obvious.Both had thier own styles and there is nothing wrong in anyone preferring one over the other.
Good analysis sir! But I would like to say, class of MD. Rafi and Kisore Kumar is not alike. Kisore Kumar was versatile, holder of baritone voice, he was an actor, musician, singer, producer, director, script writer.... He was a total artist in India. On the other-hand, MD. Rafi was an unparalleled classical singer in India. His voice was silky, sweet and also romantic! He could sing based on all RAGA-RAGINI. He sang very very tough songs very easily which had not been possible without himself. Beauty of his voice was, that had not broken when raising in the top and sublime position! (Baiju Bawra, Mahua, Neelkamal, Dosti, Pakeeza, Kagaj ki ful etc.). These eqniques will remain till Indian Music world sustains!
I think Rafi and Manna Dey were the same style singers in our country.
Sir, myself is a music lover, therefore, I expressed it in accordance with my capacity, my view. I may be wrong, if any wrong you denote, please rectify the same. Thanking you sir, I convey my best regards to you.
किशोरदा versatile पर्सन थे लेकीन versatile singer nahi थे, सिर्फ comedy,sad aur happy song ही उनके हिट हुए, रफीजी ने तो सभी प्रकार के हिट गाने गाए है, जैसे भजन, कव्वाली, क्लासिकल, गजल, कॉमेडी साँग,बच्चोंके साँग,sad song, duet romantic hit songs गाए है जबकी किशोरदाने इतने सभी टाईप के हिट गाने नहीं गाए है, क्या किशोरदा के सभी फॅन्स को उनके भजन गजल कव्वाली क्लासिकल बच्चोंके गाने मालूम है?
Another tasteful talk, vivid and unambiguous. My comment will fall short if i dont use my favourite word for thingd that i really like..... Mazedaar. Lol.
Keep it up sir, no doubt coffee and tea can nvr b compared. My compliments from accross the border, cause music has no boundaries.
Thanks again!
Dont think this 'clarification' part was required.People with reasonable knowledge could see the ulterior motive behind the 1st part,and 2nd part is just an extension of the same thought that both Rafisaab and Kishore Kumar were equal in talent for singing.(which wasnt so,in my view).We know your true liking(nothing wrong about YOUR preference)due to your earlier well made video 'Apni Car Aur Kishore Kumar'.
Not sure what you mean by "ulterior motive". Like I said in my video, neither Kishore da nor Rafi sahab need my promotion. Maybe you missed my other song czcams.com/video/kuK2WfZT6_w/video.htmlsi=5jcQIbr8RCMydmXE
Mohammad Rafi is best of the best.
Top 10 indian singers of all time.
1)Mohammad Rafi
2)Lata Mangeshkar
3)Kishore Kumar/Kj yusudas
4)Sonu Nigam
5)Shreya Ghosal
6)Udit Naraine
7)Alka yagnik
8)kumar sanu
9)Asha Bhosle
10)Arijit Singh
Asha Bhonsle on number 9? Shows your bias.
@@manoj_agr She might be a good singer, but very communal, and biased towards Rafi.
Comparison of Rafi sahab with kishore kumar is itself baseless. How can anyone compare Rafi Sahab with anyone. Just by singing romantic, soft peppy number can't make you the greatest
No sure what you mean. Are you saying Kishore da sang only soft romantic and peppy songs because if you are then that is not correct. Watch what Lata ji has to say about him
czcams.com/video/ybymSfOyE8Y/video.htmlsi=EDiiAleRRtN99MVx
Also, search for javed akhtar and Asha Bhonsle on Kishore da.
Filmi dunya men ek mard aadmi tha Manna da jisne saf kaha Rafi sb is 1number baqi filmi dunya se Jude sare hijre hain jo Rafi sb ke moqable kk ko khada kerte hai,kk aoor kaka accidental hiro aoor accidental gaekar hain pahle apisod men aapne kuch gano ki misal di jo Burman da kk aoor Rafi sb tak simit thi ,isse andaza lagta hai aapki ki language aoor gaeki ka tajurba simit hai
Kishore Kumar asli mard hai rafi jahil hai ❤❤
Comparison barabar walon ka hota hai, agar comparison karna hai tau Rafi aur Tansen ka karo.
arey kishore k samney rafi kya duniya k sab ganey wala bachha hai o khud upar wala k awaz tha
Rafi sahb kishore kumar dono dost they.is liye Rafi sahb dosti nibhane ke chakkar me kishore da ko mauqe dete the .
Useless review.! Although you are claiming not doing any discrimination but you are favouring Kishore Kumar.
The first video was more balanced, and in this one, I am only responding to the comments that were mostly critical of Kishore da. Hence, it may appear that way.
Kishore Kumar can't sing classical song as good as Rafi.
Rafi Can't Sing Intehaan Ho Gayi,Roop Tera Mastana,thodi si jo pee li hai,pyar hume kis mod pe le aaya as good as Kishore Da.
Rafi ji can’t sing inteha ho gai? Top tera mastana? These songs are left hand job of Rafi sahib. Think of something better
@@maheshbrar Bro, please…if you're a fan, stay a fan and don't act foolish. Not every song suits every singer's voice. This song won't sound as good in Rafi's voice. For example, Sonu Nigam is the best singer today, but his voice wouldn't suit "Saada Haq," just like Mika's voice wouldn't suit "Abhi Mujh Mein Kahin."
And historically, if a song has been sung by Kishore Kumar, Lata Mangeshkar, Rafi, and Asha Bhosle, Kishore Kumar's version has often been the bigger hit.
@@rishabhadarsh5227 never ever will anyone come even close to Rafi Sahib
@@maheshbrar Did he stink that dirty...?🤣
Jaise Ki Main Pehle V Keh Chuka Hu Fan Ho Fan Raho Bhutiye Mat Bano.