PGA Tour 2K23 Review
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 10. 2022
- PGA Tour 2K23 reviewed on PlayStation 4 by Matt Paprocki. Also available on PlayStation 4, Xbox, and PC.
Even after a year off, PGA Tour 2K23 returns offering minimal progress from its preceding, prior-generation edition. A new three-click swing is an unforgiving mess, it’s somehow worse at emulating the look and feel of televised golf, and the few spurts of personality that’ve been layered on can’t counter developer HB Studios’ penchant for preserving pro golf’s elitism above all, or the apparent terror of breaking from that form. At least PGA Tour 2K23 can define itself through the properly challenging golf sim at its heart and the barebones career mode that stands all but alone in its menus.
#IGN #PGATour - Hry
This might be one of the worst reviews of a game I’ve ever heard… it’s basically his opinion that golf is for the elite and he doesn’t like the menu music 😂
Golf is for the elite (more than any other sport in america), and the menu music is pretty bad.
But these should not be high priorities for the review, and they definitely seem to be.
2k21 was shite. We need the mcilroy game back
Learning it has no premier courses was helpful
@@xEKOy mclroy was garbage too
It’s because there are 7 year olds complaining how hard some golf games are
Get the guy who hates golf to review the golf game. Brilliant.
"This golf game is about golf. 6/10" - IGN
Lol you got me, 10/10 comment sir
Then gives madden 23 a 7 😂😂
Real golf is a 4/10
This reviewer would take points off of MS Flight Simulator for not playing like Ace Combat.
Oddly enough, there is a Top Gun mode in Flight Sim now so...some excitement does sell...ha
Right. Like bro it’s a golf sim. He’s talking about it’s boring and uneventful as he’s putting for bogey. 🤦♂️
@@joshramirez7 Is there dog fighting?
lol yeah this is a simulator golf game, not an arcade one
@@Kefka. no, but there is whackamole lol
I've never heard of game being reviewed as "elitist" before, bizarre
He should stick to golden tee, more his speed
What were you expecting? Super Mario to POP in and spice things up with a yellow star power up?
Ahahahahahahahaha!!
Yes!
Have you played the game? Even the tutorial is nearly identical to the tutorial from TK21. The game really is maddening.
Well the Tiger woods series from over 15 years ago were more fun to play. Yeah there were some superhuman swings possible but it was fun.
@@marcusarelius have you played madden? It's been the same game since 2015 lol
Did this man seriously call this an "elitist golf sim"?
3 times!
Golf isn’t just for middle aged millionaires ya know
@@theonewhocooks111 Just the affluent ones.
Reviewer was expecting Bugs Bunny and Daffy Duck to pull Michael Jordan thru the hole
“Silent, calm, bland, proper”. Bro, that sounds like golf and I’ll be purchasing this as soon as I’m off work. It looks amazing!
Riiiight? Lol.
LOL!!! You got it bro!
Maybe a LIV golf game might be more up this review’s alley
Take a shot everytime this guy calls golf "elitist"
The guy clearly doesn't know what he's talking about and how to play the game.
The most San Fransicoist streetist elitest review ever.
So the game achieves what it wanted to, but not what the reviewer was expecting... You cannot go watch Saving Private Ryan and complain that it was nothing like a romantic comedy and totally missed an opportunity. C'mon man.
Preach brother
This game is terrible. The $100 edition is barely worth $30. There is literally nothing to keep you playing.
Except maybe the thousands of courses that will be created over its lifetime for you to play with your friends over some beers
Absolutely, sound like someone that doesn't like golf
@@cysticjediits golf dude.. either you like it or you don't. Its like complaining that there isn't much to do in bowling lol......
Tell me the reviewer has never played a single round of golf without telling me the reviewer has never ever played a round of golf.
Awful review.
Game modes issue aside....
Wtf.... Is this guy serious? Seems like He hates a golf sim because it looks, plays and sounds like a golf sim??
If you don’t want to play a golf simulator or realism play Mario Golf.
1:03 "...stuffy, elitist..."
1:10 "...the pomposity..."
What?
Try telling me you don’t know what words mean when you pause before really pronouncing them lol @ign, not you
It’s a golf sim that’s the purpose lol
Ya but it gets boring quick .
@@krisnauffts5787 sounds like golf alright lol
@@krisnauffts5787 ITS GOLF. You just described golf.
@@Hard1Gamers You really think playing golf is as boring as a golf video game or watching on tv? If so...play golf. It's fun.
@@krisnauffts5787 Not if you like playing golf.....
What an awful review
IGN needs new reviewer’s
Except for Luke Reilly, IGN’s racing game critic, he’s great so keep him and replace the rest of ‘em.
Badly. The site is so dang bad now.
Ign shouldn't even exist!
@@anmeme6579 definitely. Even before Greg and Colin left.
Agreed too many activists who can't stop being biased on reviews.
Utterly ridiculous review: the very worst of IGN. The reviewer criticises a golf sim for being a golf sim and for using an appropriate soundtrack and challenging mechanics. Presumably he wanted an arcade game with pop music, gimmicky mini games and some fps gunplay inbetween holes. The fact that the putt preview is on throughout the clips says everything. This guy doesn't like golf. As a golf game for golf fans, it's brilliant.
worst review ever. putt preview. smh. disgraceful review
What odd complaints for a golf game.
It's IGN they barely speak english, it's all nerd talk
He wanted signature NBA "2k" rap music blaring and flashy micro transactions popping on the screen.
😂
Remember Tiger Woods 2004? One of the greatest games ever made. Soooo epic
Used to love that one!!! Controlling the spin was huge!!!
‘05 was also great.
They were fun games bro
The freaking best game ever for golf
If only EA would only remaster it
Coming from a reviewer that’s probably never played a round of golf, let alone a sport, in his entire life 👍🏻
That’s a little presumptuous surely? 🤔
@@ACameronUK If someone consistently calls golf "elitist" then yes, they haven't played a round in golf. Hell, go look at a lot of golf youtubers they're not even remotely "elitist" by any means. People still think golf is in the 1940s when it really isn't even close to what people think it is.
@@snoozley853 Please don’t tell me you’re one of those guys that thinks lifting weights makes you an athlete
@C S exactly. People act like golf isn't one of the more accessible sports today.
Why are you defending an overtly mediocre game and developer studio. Brainless stan
IGN once again shows why they should never review a sports game. Nonsense complaints that have nothing to do with sports!
and then give a score that doesn't relate to what was just discussed. But its ok, "its a step in the right direction"
That but keep the guy who reviews the FIFA Legacy edition games.
The only person at IGN that should review sports games is Ryan McCaffrey. He at least is a fan of sports.
Lol, maybe the worst review ign has ever put out. The final preview for the game felt more like a honest review than what ever this was.
Yeah the preview was much more informative. This review just felt it was by someone who doesn’t even like golf anyway.
@@ijjysmith Not to mention it sounds like he hadn't played 2k21 to draw comparisons from, let alone any golf game in the last 20 years.
Can someone who doesn’t just hate golf actually provide a review on whether the game is an upgrade from the 2021 version?
How is it “elitist”?
Thats what I’m wondering 😂 i mean actual golf can be but how is this 😭
Because he (along with many) is a dude who has a preconceived notion about golf and simply can't let it go. If people actually think Golf is this super elitist sport, they've clearly never even remotely step foot on a golf course. Maybe private ones are but 99.9% of people aren't going to play on those courses anyway. Long story short, golf isn't what people want it to be just so they can complain about politics
One playstyle in Career mode? Aren't there like 5 archetypes??? Wtf is this guy talking about...?
Did this man just call The Detroit Golf Club a second tier golf course? Quite sure this guy has never put on a pair of spikes in his life.
Not sure what he expected but this is a solid game just like in the past. The courses are gorgeous, it's difficult and there's an awesome course creator. 8/10
Btw, if you actually did some research you'd see they're adding Pebble Beach, Torrey Pines and Spyglass Hill as free DLC. So much for those "second tier courses". 🙄
It's been 5 months and they haven't added them yet
Wow
LMFAO!!!!!
@@everyone1liesd459I just played pebble beach last night.
So the golf game is too real?
Right!
2nd tier courses??? Bayhill and Sawgrass are NOT 2nd tier courses, imagine getting someone to review a golf game that knows nothing about golf…
Actually the access regular people have to golf makes the claim that golf is for the elite sound weird.
Wow, seems like the team got a staunch COD enthusiast to review a golf game.... :(
Reviewer made this game look sick while trying to bash it ..
pretty critical, but yet doesnt say anything remotely relevant to making the game better. Hard to respect.
In no way is this a perfect game. But this guy clearly knows zero about golf. Ign is horrible.. how can they let this guy review the game
Matt Paprocki - please never review a game again!🥱
IGN need new reviewers,so it plays like real golf sim ! What do you want it to do,be over the top
Like tiger woods jezz
Let's have the guy who hates golf review the new golf game. Useless review.
Dude should not review sports games, terrible
So yeah, won’t claim on ps plus 🎉🎉🎉
This reviewer must work for EA Sports lol
So it's like actual golf?
Not really. Real golf is walk, explore the course, manage it along with golfhouse, find the ball. They're still keeping teleportation between a shot and another with static crowd around. Lame.
@@modder1975 wow what a terrible take. So you want to walk to your shot? enjoy your 5 hour round of video game golf.
@@modder1975 In video game format thats never been an issue dude because that could make the experience tedious to thw point were your not getting straight to the action in getting the ball after one swing. Sorry pal, but your take dint make sense about this.
@@modder1975 Wow dude, you're dumb AF.
You say all that crap then you give it a 6 if you’re gonna go on about how bad it is give it a 4, I swear ign doesn’t go below 6 and above 8 for all media
Someone wanted a LivGolf 2K23 me thinks.
Holy crap it is golf. 1:13 in and any attempt at a honest review was gone.
Well.. guess my dream about seeing a game like the old "Tiger Woods PGA tour" game for the PS2 wont ever happen..
Where when you unlock clubs and stuff like a glove gave you stats!
And most important of all.. a campaign that played out over several years! And if you didn't qualify you'd have to get better untill the next year!
That's all we want really a similar game
Dono why EA doesn't remove that buttplug, hit Tiger up and make game that can blow our damn socks off
This is a decent golf game. Don't let this clown fool you. This guy is out to hate this game no matter what!
You can do all of that in this game.
DAMN YOU IGN THIS IS GOLF! NOT A ROCK CONCERT!!
Nobody at IGN knows anything about sports
is that supposed to be Jordan?
The reviewer mentioned golf is boring and game didn’t make it fun. If you don’t like golf in first place then why are you reviewing this game?
Sounds like an incredible game tbh.
It is.. it's a brilliant golf game.
@@adambrock284yup yup 🔥
well by default it gets a leg up on 2k21 since you can actually PLAY as a PRO tour golfer. maybe a 7 out of 10 is a bit more fair
Geez this was a terrible review.
6/10?
Imagine if this was E.A?
100/10
“Really makes you feel like Tiger Woods” -IGN
Played the game, still dont have tons of mistresses
Are there ANY game reviewers for IGN that actually play golf?? Wtf is this guy saying?? It’s NOT Tiger Woods PGA Tour 2003…. That’s kinda the point. You can’t play Godzilla in Madden 2K23 either…. So it plays like a golf game…. Kinda think this is what EVERYONE is wanting besides this guy. 🤦🏼♂️
How can a game be snobby?
IGN pre-release preview of the game: "This game looks super promising and super fun!"
IGN post-release review of the game: "This game is so bad, OMG, ugh... terrible..." 😂😂😂
It's a golf game.... What the hell did you expect?
Sounds like you're just bad at the game
@@13cody3 did u reply to the wromg comment
they just need to make an improvement to tiger woods pga 2003, still the best in my opinion.
Loved that game......remember the Emerald Dragon course?
how do you show the predetermined putt line before you actually swing? is that only on easy mode or something?
Nothing will beat Tiger Woods PGA Tour 2004 on the PS2. Perfect. Chefs Kiss.
This is better except for the courses
2006 will
Going back through the eras to beat the greats was amazing and then the main menu music changing with the Era ❤️❤️
Bad take. Do you like golf? No. We can tell.
You can tell that this was written by someone who wouldn't bother to play this for more than a day, not to mention his complaint about course diversity and quality when there is literally thousand's of top quality custom user made courses you can access, which includes incredibly accurate replicas of all the courses he said you could not play, (of which he only mentioned briefly). Plus his mention of this being an elitist and pompous game is quite silly, when most of the cult following these games have are just gamer's who like a decent golf sim, not middle class Englishmen with their clubs permanently placed in the back of their BMW M5's
Bro where the hell do they get these reviewers man?
"dude they just make you hit this little ball with a stick all game its dumb"
I'm leaning towards waiting for EA to come out in spring because I'm more familiar with there product. Also, there are three quick sling is a whole lot better than what I've seen on this game which looks like a complete cluster $#-&
EA lost the licensing rights to 2k a few years ago
@@willeymunda they are coming out with a new game in 23. They released the trailer the day this game came out and it will have the masters and the other 3 majors
This guy is expecting this to be LIV 2k23
if its 2k its garbage to ign , but if its ea........
EA got that bag for IGN.
It’d be awesome if Happy Gilmore was actually in the game.
send them a email 👍
What will Lion Trees do after he sees this review?
How are you finding this game? I'm struggling to enjoy it ive put about 20 hours into the game please tell me it gets better haha
The irony of talking about second tier course, when TPC SAWGRASS is right in the middle of the screen haha
“Retain their dazzling authenticity” A bit of a leap, but ok.
You don't punch out from under hazards for crying out loud. Stick to Mario Golf for your pizazz.
It's nice that it will carry over my level from my PS5 and PS4, but the constant internet connection is unnecessary.
This reviewer has never swung a golf club in real life, the lack of appreciation for this game shows that.
An elitist video game? What does that even mean??
The reviewer was right; this game is nothing like World of Warcraft, so we should all go play Hello Kitty's Island Adventure.
Tell me you know nothing about golf without telling me you know nothing about golf.
If you can't shank your caddie then what's the point?
The reviewer must be fun at parties
The three click makes the swing so much easier. Especially online on pro difficulty. Mama didn’t play the game
The gameplay of the review is shocking
a new low for IGN, jees.
People don't want real life golf. The Tiger Woods series was an arcade style that people loved! Thr music, spin on the ball and atmosphere was great
@IGN Never let this person review another game
We need another tiger woods game!
he unfortunately signed a deal with 2k so we will not get that road to the masters is awesome minus the putting and golfers available. The create a golfer is also lacking.
It looks like the ball stops rolling too quickly.
At least no micropay to win 😅
Forgive me for being blunt but you're clearly not a golf fan. There's a reason why The Golf Club and it's iterations have been overwhelmingly successful. The reason is that golf fans like to ...... shocker incoming .... play golf. We want the sim to be as accurate as possible and don't what some ridiculous arcade action forced upon us. There are plenty of other faux "golf" games that can fulfill that need.
Golf fans don't need and have never needed the manufactured excitement, action and hype that have taken over every other sport (both online and real life). We enjoy the game itself.
This reviewer is clueless. Please get someone who is knowledgeable about sports to review sports games in future.
Thanks for the Review I'll stick with Tiger Woods 2005! The bomb music and gameplay!
Hey Reviewer Guy, just stick to "Everybody's Golf", OK ?
A perfect example of getting the wrong person to review a game.
Would be a great game if it wasnt for the constant server freezes. Playing on a fast internet and an XBOX X, had 5 different matches end up a loss because the game froze on the server
Mine freezes too. That's my only real complaint.
This review was the reason for youtube no longer showing the number of dislikes.