Myths of Goa's Inquisition | E 1. Talk with Tyson feat. Mathew Almeida
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 05. 2022
- This show Talk with Tyson all about getting you a wide range of knowledge to which you may able to fill in the gaps. We want our viewers to think for themselves, interpret reasonable, discus or even debate and draw conclusions with a common consensus. We believe that all our viewers are literate and educated. Educated enough to think for themselves and not be brain washed even by what they may hear on our channel. We always remain open to what the other has to say.
This show tries to attempt to answer Subhash Bhaskar Velingkar and Shefali Vaidya. We have tried revisiting the facts they have taken and checking it and reading it for ourselves. What you find for yourself can at times surprise you. We do not deny a bad past of the Portuguese rule in Goa but what alarms us today is some have chosen to dig in the past out of the blue and create an unrest among the Catholics, Hindus and Muslims.
We respect the sentiments of all religion and do not desire to cause hatred among religion.
We have tried to have a dialogue rather than a monologue.
Anyone interested in having us interview you for a relevant and current affairs related topic that has not been touched upon kindly email me on:
hansometysonn@yahoo.com
costatys@yahoo.com
Listening. Please do subscribe to this channel.
Mathew's Research paper:
mathewsophia.wordpress.com/20...
Mathew's Response to Velingkar about Goencho Saib:
• 5 reasons why SFX is c...
Glory Apologetics:
• F2F || Eps 6 - Goa Inq...
Music Provide By: Friendly No Copyright Music
Your ancestors faced these tortures and you came to defend those monsters.... think once.... be a human and it's upto you what you want to be.
Let them live fancyland 😂😂😂
Its hard to accept the reality the blood-bath your arrogant forefathers the bhramins carried out be a human like ambedkarji who exposed your blood thirst forefathers bhramins of their dark side...
Idiotic comment. The Inquisition was carried out by the Vatican, not the Portuguese government! Also St. Francis of Xavier wasn't even Portuguese, but born in Spain. These types of comments show a hate and ignorance beyond belief in modern times, especially, since when has there been religious peace in India?!
Bammans are the real culprits and twisted the history. Bammans are afraid to speak against the Moguls who 8cr of our people
For Mathew Almeida, Hinduism is equivalent to Human sacrifice , witch craft & black magic,.
He is forgetting that Hinduism was the religion his ancestors followed before they converted to Christianity. From the video, Mathew appear to be of Indian Race.
Yes and trying to justify the act of inquisition, actually it happened with his ancestors also
Yeah So?? Just because our ancestors were Hindus, doesn't mean we should follow Hinduism. I am glad my ancestors were brought to the truth, by the Goan Saints, Priests and Martyrs. It's because of them I do not have to worship or believe in made up Gods who are animated characters. We do not have to succumb to the Brahmin system of Slavery. I am glad the Portuguese came to Goa and abolished the crimes and murders the Non-Catholics committed.
Bammans have created Hinduism to exploit the lower castes people
@@nathangomes8381wow 😂😂😂😂 what a logic 😂
Thousands of Goud Saraswat and Saraswat brahmins fled from Goa during the Portuguese rule and settled in different place of costal Karnataka and Kerala. To say that they fled simply because of rumours about forced conversion and brutality by the colonialists seems too simplistic. People rooted to a place for several centuries don't flee so easily due to rumours leaving behind everything they built. What could be the reason they fled if not for forced conversions, confiscation of property and some cruel measures that may have been taken by the local Portuguese Govt? Wish you would have covered this point as well. Will surely study your research paper.
Your free to find out. You may have your point but well we never know until we find out the truth and come to some consensus
Any evidence??
I understand confiscation..... But was it because they were hindus?? ...
The court of Naiks
What evidence u have to say that Saraswat brahmins ran away due to Inquisition??... How come tthere wa
Even French man also mentioned about Goa Inquisition in his Book (Inquisition of Goa) he saw all those brutal things live with his own eyes.
That is exactly what i have mentioned.... Have u read the French man's account?
Where is this French man?? Based on the discussion on the video. Inquisitions was for Christains to ensure they aren't committing heresy. So let me get this: Was Galileo or Copernicus, hindus??? They faced the heat of inquisitions, too. But fellows like u add fuel to the flame of facist hindutva groups who want to expel Christians & Christianity from the Indian subcontinent.
Charles (Claude) Gabriel Dellon, the Frenchman
Moguls ruled India for 600yrs and finished 8cr of our people and took our mahilas like rundi
False lies. Don't talk without proofs
But the question is initially no one was Christian, they were converted forcefully by all means right.
N then they were tortured if they didn't follow Christianity.
How can you imply everything was done by force? Am I forced to still follow my faith? My answer is NO. I love my faith. I praise and thank God for the faith i am in. Learn to live with the community around you my dear. The lies no room for any question unless someone is displeased to live the faith he or she is living. Choice is yours.
@@talkwithtyson1949 because that's how christianity imposed, that's Its history and the way it perpetuated. Thats how abrahamic religions always spread.
@@xiuhcoatl4830 check your sources
@@talkwithtyson1949 I did. From Constantine, Theodosius and similars, all to XXth century christofascists and today's persecutions, like in Brazil.
@@xiuhcoatl4830 oh very good. Cherry picking
I cant see why your religion should make you feel offended by your history. But thats the power of religion. To make you blind to your own past.
Can someone from Goa explain the history of " haat kaapo khambo" ?
That was the level of punishment during Portuguese rule.
Ok,if church is peaceful, why there are mass graves in Canada missionary schools???
EVERYTHING WAS GOOD AND PEACEFUL UNTIL THE PORTUGUESE CAME.
My response: well everything was good only for the high caste especially the brahmin. They exploited the lower caste and lived luxurious lives. Christianity became a challenge to this dreadful system when many lower caste became Christians and challenged the system. So also there were practices existing in India which were dangerous for human life which were reformed by the Buddhists, Mughals, Portuguese, British and other movements within Hinduism.
FRANCIS XAVIER WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE INQUISITION.
Well I have dedicated a whole section in this article to explain how he is not responsible for the inquisition and even if he mentioned about it nobody knows where he meant it and what version of Inquisition he desired.
THERE WERE FORCED CONVERSIONS, OR CONVERSIONS OUT OF ALLUREMENT OR BRIBE AND NOT OUT OF CONVICTION.
This is a pure radical hatred to Christianity and the missionaries. As I have mentioned that the Miracles done by St. Francis Xavier and many still experience the power of his intercession was also a great factor. After his incorrupt body was brought in Goa it was the key point of astonishment and wonder which contributed to the choosing of the faith. So also the edict of the king of Portugal in 1567 and the records given by the then historians are proof that forced conversion was not always a regular event.
THE HINDUS WERE FALLING BACK TOT HEIR OLD PRACTICES OUT OF LOVE FOR IT SINCE THEY STILL LOVED IT.

This is silly. As it is proven Hinduism is not one particular religion and it has its many faces. In Goa people were used to some superstitious practices and even black magic, animal offerings and even child offerings. These were the major reasons which Portuguese did not separate from Vedic or Brahminical Hinduism.[62] Such practices are still prevalent in Goa.[63]
INQUISITION WAS A FORM OF CHRISTIAN RADICALISM
Certainly not! As we have seen the church and the state were one and the same. when we say state that means church played a important role in the political area as well and it influenced political administrations. Therefore, in those circumstances, the inquisition was a part of the law of state and religion was an integral part of the state. As we have also seen how there were strict conditions on the use of torture it solely depended on how the inquisitors carried out the executions. However, it has been made clear that the history of the inquisition is manipulated and tampered with by the Protestant viewpoint and documentations of history show a different viewpoint and lives many questions unanswered.
CHRISTIANITY DESTROYING CULTURE.
Not at all. I have already given the statement for that in the above topic of inculturation. Infact I would like to remind that the very first freedom movements were started by Catholics and in fact by Catholic Priests the protest against Christian in equality by Fr. Mathew Castro, The famous Pinto Revolt in 1787 by three Catholic Priests, who can forget Dr. Francisco Luis Gomes who was a Goan Parlaimentarian who demanded freedom of India from British and the Portuguese, then Dr. T B Cunha who was the one who suggested the Goa should be part of the Republic of India. Also cannot forget Dr. Jacque Sequeira who fought for independent state of Goa when the Maharashtra Gomantak Party along with Janata Party wanted to merge Goa with Maharashtra.
ONLY HINDUISM BELONGS TO INDIA.
This is a total radical idea. Hinduism alone has not influenced the Indian society and its reforms. Much of it has been also a contribution from other religions and philosophies. Hinduism alone is no the only religion that originated in India nor it has its original roots on Indian soil though it is the majority contributor yet drastic major changes have been brought by others. Hinduism itself has spread beyond the boundaries of India. No religion belongs to one place of region. If we look at every religion it has a universal message to the all the people and therefore missionary in some way. Mirabai spread her devotion to Krisna. Guru Nanak spoke about his God experience to others. Buddha preached about the Nirvana to others. Mahavira spoke about the Moksa to others. All these religions and spiritualities have spread all over by way of preaching to others. Swamy Vivekanand also is a great example of this practice of preaching and many of the Gurus and Baba even to this day. Therefore, blaming Islam and Christianity alone for its preaching and missionary work is cruel and unjust.
THE POPE SHOULD APOLOGISE TO PEOPLE OF GOA AND INDIA.
In they year 2000 itself Pope John Paul II apologised for the Inquisition announcing the day of Pardon and penance for the Church. He changed the whole viewpoint of the Church and also the people changed their mind and attitude towards the Church. Pope Benedict XVI and also Pope Francis also have apologised time and again for the crimes done by Church leaders and inquisition itself.[64] However, the People of Goa have never made such demand from the Church and have forgotten the past. The Hindus and Christians in Goa live peacefully to the extent that many Hindus revere and pray to Christian saints, have great devotion to St. Francis Xavier, to Mother Mary and Jesus himself. They honour the Catholic Priests and nuns and live in harmony. Therefore if the people of Goa themselves don’t demand something like this why should and outsider and a person never having lived in Goa properly insight it. The picture of Goa is different then that of the other parts of India.
Coz of some stupid people
N before the church came... Do u know what the society was like
How true is that story??
Whhat has the church to do with it?? Ask the government of Canada??... And yes of course... There were timmes when church power was misused
Probably and hopefully you and a lot of people will realise the truth when the Pope finally apologizes for the atrocities.
You got it all wrong.
You cannot live like an ostrich. My love to all goans, Hindu or not Hindu.
@@gigir987 eh? Make sane statements instead of just being mean. You don't like the truth than move on. We respect your feelings but your not o point at all. Much to be discussed it looks like you have already made your judgements.
@@talkwithtyson1949 You are talking in a mirror I hope
@@gatocachorro7998 you definitely are.
Very informative podcast. I really liked it.
You are playing the same card over here that Europeans played. Divide and rule. You are trying to paint a picture over here that Brahmins are bad and they are trying to impose their thoughts and ideologies on others. I am also a Hindu(not Brahmin). We no longer buy these things which you are trying to sell.
Knowing our history is important and that's what is happening at present. But some people can't accept this change. They are naming it intolerance and communal. Shame on such thinking. The whole episode is build by taking someone's name...that shows the motive behind this video. I don't think any hindu from Goa has hatred towards todays christians as they are not responsible for what happened in the past.
You spoke based on your facts and research. Shefali is speaking based on what she has researched. And good thing over here is she didnt take anyone's name to talk about past atrocities.
'Those who don't know history are doomed to repeat it.' - Edmund Burke
Thanks for sharing your opinion
Making people fool and justifying the malicious activities of Portugal by giving different narrative. What else can be expected from u
That shows you haven't understood the talk. Nobody justifies their actions. Listen to it again for that matter. Cherry picking is not needed here.
@@talkwithtyson1949 oh only on the rumours of forced conversions so many hindus migrated from Goa. They left their land where they were living from so many years. What about the hath katro khamba which even today exist in Goa?
@@GautamBuddhaSiddarth well, we had covered in that topic too. Another channel should be coming out with that video too. Don't worry. And yes, Inquisition which meant inquiry on the Christians who were already converted. Not on Hindus
@@talkwithtyson1949 First of all they were converted forcely. They were Crypto Hindus, who disguised themselves as Christians to save themselves from persecution. Also if they were Christians and were practicing their some previous rituals then why an enquiry on them? Isn't it a type of dogma?
@@talkwithtyson1949 Inquiry in itself is a non-sensical concept. If some one is Christian and like some ritual of any other religion tumhare pet me kyun dard uth rha hai?
PS: Caste comes from the Latin word Casta . It was a slave social system invented by Portuguese and Spanish imperialism in Latin America and its colonies. There was no caste system, but 2 non Sanskrit words introduced by Christian Portuguese colonial invaders into medieval India. It is not a Hindu system nor did there ever exist any Hindu caste system on the Indian subcontinent ever until European colonialism invaded her shores . Christian propaganda to shame and blame Hindustan for Christian supremacy and their crimes against humanity
You are right! caste came from Latin word "Casta". But that doesn't eliminate that early Indian and modern Indians do follow Jhati pratha as per the sacred scriptures of Brahman dharma or hinduism. I can cite numerous verses from Purana, Vedas, Smritis to Dharma-Shastras. For instance I explain you briefly; Parusha sutra is said to be the root of caste system in Hinduism, it is mentioned in Rigveda 10:90:12
@@tantrum17 you should do research on slave bible too...
@@maruthumuthu4526 Research? Dude I have a PHD in this subject. You are the same kind that says "rEad gIta brO, wE hAve siaence in it". I have humiliated kinds like you. So don't speak with your WhatsApp history knowledge.
@@tantrum17 + Dear Patrick , whatever existed , is not the abrahamic invaders to decipher and tell us what we are . There were tribes all over the world . We are like current and waves . Are you going to change the current. But the animosity to divide and rule as well as shame us when this is exactly what is getting on all over the world specially when it was invented and practiced by the hypocrites who call themselves Roman Catholics is an insult . First the commandants say thous shall not lie . Then not only they lie , but they pretend that something existed prior to the invasions and they are here to save the Hindu pagans . As an ex Roman Catholic , the church 1 st needs to own up to its lies and crimes against humanity. Then stop interpreting other civilizations
@@LuzianJ + Your sarcasm is an image of your brainwashed mentality that enslaved men for 2000 years , then butchered its way through history. You can’t follow anyone . It’s your slave currents that form the waves .
When you leave your dirty laundry on someone else’s land , then pretend that oh we just changed the name of something that was already there , it shows that you are following only a pedophile church and not Jesus . You cannot follow him and white wash your sins . Caste was invented to subjugate , invade colonize the world by the church , divide and rule , create disharmony, no Jesus involved . Clean up your mess and learn that the earth is not flat to follow someone. . It’s cyclic. Jesus did not ask you to follow him and he himself was a part of a tribe which Is all over the Bible . Which ended up into kingdoms and empire and 2000 years of crimes against humanity.
This guy is such a liar.. how he distorted what shefali vaidya had told in her interviews.
This guy says books f 19th century were nonsense and he is the only person who saw what happened during inquisition. Full of nonsense he speaks.
The way it looks like u lost hair on ur head... Probably u even lost ur brains
I did not say 18th century books are nonsense... Which are those books???... And of course there are more books each one has its own side
This guy is communist refers only mrxts books
Digging deep into history and accumulating facts and assessing them from the myths takes a lot of hard work and courage given the gravity of this topic. I wish most of us Catholics do the needed research rather than falsely bearing the blame put by the accusers. This also helps us understand the difference between christ's divinity and its followers. We can have unity even without having false ecumenism(this I believe priests all over the world need to emphasize on)
Thank you Mathew for your efforts, it has certainly encouraged me to dig deeper and analyse the facts and I hope it encourages others.
Very true my friend. Thanks for your positive feedback.
You are most welcome
Lol
Totally false information. We Kunbis never faced any problems with other castes. Portuguese fooled you.
I doubt this history because there are lots of mistakes.
Sonda King gifted his regions in 1726?
Firstly the regions of Pernem, Bicholim and Sattari were under control of the Kingdom of Sawantwadi till 1783.
The region Ponda (Antruz), Sanguem, Quepem and Canacona were controlled by the Sonda Dynasty from Sadashivgad Fort Karwar and was vassal of the Maratha Confederacy from 1674.
Kingdom of Sawantwadi ceded Pernem, Bicholim and Sattari in return for help against Kolhapur. Now this is not a gifted lands. But Portuguese captured by taking advantage of someone's weakness.
Now talking about Sonda, it's not in 1726.
When Marathas were at war with Hyder Ali at Savanur in 1764, there were high chances that Ponda, Sanguem, Quepem, Canacona and Karwar could fall in the hands of Hyder Ali on the counter, as Marathas had already one front open the desperate Sonda King fearing the defeat fled to Portuguese territory and controlled this region from Ponda under Portuguese in return of stipend and protection till 1791 until "Ponda was TAKEN from the King of Sonda" by the Portuguese. Now again it was not gifted but it was made look like it was gifted.
Gifted isn't the right word but rather ceded to the Portuguese in return for their help against the Muslim army in South Canara but it doesn't change the fact that this was done while the inquisition was still ongoing.
@@clobo01 not south North Canara
You guys running Propogenda without any fact any evidence..
Yeah Goa inquisition was not terrible, It was a reformation a result of which I sit here converted and defend it😂
Inquissition hass nothing to do with conversions....
Good job but your research is one sided and prejudiced. One has to scrutinize the other side of history. You'll can't go on indefinitely burying the truth... It will rise out of the grave one day.
Not at all Reuben. No one is burying anything. In fact we are digging much more than what is found.
I think you should read my research paper well.....
Or may be you can do a better research
Your hard work in research
Excellent research
History is not an easy subject. People have systematically manipulated it over the years.. so take it with a heap of salt. Truth can never be known or understood completely, except for the parties involved(dead long ago), we only derive from what we understand partially, thus giving the opportunity to fight against eachother
Exactly. Hope we quit fighting and move on.
@@talkwithtyson1949 Move on? Did the community move on when the Japanese persecuted 200 Christian missionaries/fathers between 1617 and 1632? Heck, Martin Scorcese's movie 'Silence' was based on it - so if you think people can 'move on' from this you're just kidding us at this point.
@@adisanil we have all moved on. But one community keeps bragging about it. We respond to that community that brags all the time. It's fine once or twice but it is also politically supported. Very sad but it's a reality.
@@talkwithtyson1949 Because its politically supported you are spreading wrong version ?
@@LuzianJ Yeah. When you blind you think entire world in Dark. That's not your problem that's problem with Christianity. But dont worry, see the world with naked eye by removing Christianity glass. By saying RSS, Gobar Susu like such non-sense words
"When the whole village was baptised, Xavier would get them to pull down their village temple and break into small pieces the idols itcontained.He did this at a time the Tiruvadi Raja of Quilon had given him 2000 fanamsto build churches. The poor fishermen were in no position to resist himbecause the Portuguese pirates were always at hand to assist the missionary.
If the people converted...to christianity ...is the temple of use to them??? It's their property...they would do what they want
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357 Avoid defending the Portuguese for their wrongdoings. If temples were not desired by the people, the inquisition wouldn't have been enforced.
@@Rahul-hq1dd Hindus too should repent for the wrong doings done to Jain's n Buddhists.
@@andreamessiasgomes7118 Again a scripted tale. I can understand the kind of hatred for Hindus and love for your accidental ancestors
@@Rahul-hq1ddbro Colonial converts have their Vatican version story😂
Good points:
1. Quite well researched
2. Honest
3. Well contemplated
Stupidities:
1. Agenda to disrespect Hinduism
2. One must never rely on ones own data alone. Best is check oppositions data about them. You are relying on Church data about them
3. Saraswat Brahman has nothing to do with Saraswati river
4. Ambedkar got his name Ambedkar due to help from a hindu. So cannot blame Hindus for his lack of right mindset
4. Still stuck in tribal mindset. Even 5000 years back many of Indians had already evolved into academics of spirituality. Religion is merely an intellectual way of managing emotions. Can never be holistic.
Well it is best pondered together. All our points are open for debate which is of no issues to us. But again, let us leave History to be taught to us by Historians. Our response was to a particular book that also has the same "stupidities" as mentioned above. So yes, with all due respect, we don't wish to disrespect any Hindu community but a particular mindset that lingers which is debatable.
It's very sad that inspite of me telling repeatedly to read the research paper I hve written in which citations are well mentioned n in the video too I have mentioned the sources such a comment should have come. My sources are not only churchy sources but no have used the same sources used by Anant Kakba Priolkar and extra more.... If I am accused of being too church centred... Hasn't Priolkar done the same.... I think sir u need to watch the interview with Mr. Dale Luis Menezes and Ms. Amita Kanekar as well.... And then watch al zulaij channel And of course Shefali Vaidyas videos....
There is no equality due to terrible castes system
@@Johnny-pi1vk religion has braught more conflict not caste.
@@SalgaokerJIXX Bammans made castes system to exploit the lower castes people and made them gulami. If you are sc st you should leave it
You quoted, you are not with such forces like ‘Bajrang dal’ and all, but isn’t it hypocritical that you are justifying ’Inquisition’? In real, neo-Christians were never convinced with new faith and that is why they were falling back. But the important question is, why did they get converted if they were not convinced? And the answer is, People were converted with the help of unethical forces. If Portuguese can apply ‘Inquisition’, they can apply other similar unethical forces to convert.
How am I justifying inquisition?? In fact... Do you know what is inquisition...
It's not never convinced of Christian faith but they would rather be syncretic Or agnostics
Justifying inquisition??? There is no even need for it
All rice bag
@@jaimatadiplynwood1004No, just a recognition that Firangi Mlecchas are superior to Dharmic Brahmins and so the decision to follow them instead. Why can't Hindus accept this harsh truth? If you don't believe me then you can go observe the long queues for US/UK/EU visas outside their consulates and embassies in India, those queues are full of Hindus only too happy to break their own religion's rule against foreign travel and leave India permanently. Or those Hindus who live in Goa. (Over 75% of them have their origins in other states of India, but they lie that they're Goans because they find their own real native places to be inferior.)
Your research is quite illustrative and detailed, God bless you for this masterpiece brother 👏🏼👏🏼
In those years the ottomons ruled and lost control areas in Spain and Portugsl.. Religion and politics a bad mix.. Even today.. History keeps teaching us this.. Lest we forget.
Noday is perfect in this world hence we do not go muvh deeper in the history of religious
My question to Mathew. While i agree with you that the tribals and their religion were the originals of GOA, what about konkani ?. In Goa the GSB or Saraswat is called kONKNO by other konkani speaking people. Even here in Mangalore the GSBs are called konknyanchim by the konkani speaking catholics. Does it show that konkani came to Goa with the Saraswats?
Everybody was called konknno even the Goan christians. Since hinduism is not one religion but there were many religious grouos and others had converted...the name christian existed and therefore they could be categorised as kristao....but not the other non christians....konkani speaking people.......so the name konknno remained
@@mathewalmeida1937 i think you didn't get the point. When one konkani speaking person refers to another konkani as konkno or konkani speaking person, it definitely refers to the latter's religion. Which raises the doubt that the original settlers of Goa may have first recognised these new people by their language konkani and later learnt it themselves due to imposition.
@@naveenroche8444 i think u did not get my point....its not only GSB who were called konknno but even other non christian Goans.....even today...the gauddi and velip hindus are called koknne......unless u r not Goan and dont know it
@@mathewalmeida1937sir, in my initial query i mentioned my place as Mangalore. Mangalorean catholics are not Goans but of goan descent. It is mostly during inquisition that our ancestors migrated to then Canara. St Francis Xavier is revered by us and we have churches in his honour. We fondly call GOA as mai Gaon or malgadyancho Gaon. So i am surprised when you ask me if I am Goan. As a reseacher you should know better. Unless your intention was to insult me which i hope not. During my stay in Goa for sixteen years i have been asked this question umpteen times but my humble answer has always been, no i am not a goan, but a Ghati. Kindly forgive me if i have offended you in any way and share me your email ID .Maybe i have failed to convey my view properly on this forum.
@@naveenroche8444 I am really sorry for getting u wrong.... I did not mean to offend u.... And by the way I do not use the word ghantti anymore.... We are human beings.... We have our own culture and history n I respect that... What I want to tell u is that in goa all hindus irrespective of any caste are called konknne... N not only GSB.... In mangalore situation could be different.... Another thing is that goans migrated to Kanara and mangalore not only during inquisition but also before that... The brahmins were also traders and merchants..... I think Mr. Alan Machado will be in better position to explain deeper
Great video, well researched. I cannot understand why something that took place a few hundreds of years ago is causing so much bad blood now. The need of the hour is unity and respect of all religions. Whether our ancestors were forcibly converted or not what difference will it make to anyone? Why cant we just live our lives peacefully with one and all. Some of the comments are low in character and only speaks badly of those posting such demeaning posts. We must let bygones be bygones and help make Goa a beautiful state and India a first world country to be proud of.
It makes a hell lot of difference. Religion binds people together stronger than a nation. That's the whole reason people get converted at a global scale. There's a reason for that.
When your turns comes you want peace but you fail to understand the pain experienced including your forefathers at that time.The worst part is the converts still trying to convert.
@@nathant382 if there is any proof of forced conversions then why don't you go to the police with the proof. India has strong rules against forced conversions and action against these so-called forced conversions should be taken. But just taking in the air and falsely accusing a community is absolutely harassment of Christians by you.
Even I don't understand why the pope apologised for wiping out millions globally. After all they weren't bastovs like RB convert s here on the sub continent.
@@philomenasequeira6083see this RB. Your mummy Sonia and gang propagate. The pope apologises.
When it comes then don't go running to Portugal.
Jn.17:17. Father, sanctify the Christians of Goa,?through thy truth: thy word is truth. Amen.❤❤❤.
Are you suggesting everything told by Shefali Vaidya on conversion, torture, punishing, controlling and killing is not true? And there are documents of tools used for torture. Everything is false ?
Pretty much. Shefali Vaidya is a Hindu Brahmin with serious psychological issues, because the Hindu Brahmins lost money and prestige in Goa after the overwhelming majority of Goans became Christian. The Christian Goans are also generally more educated and prosperous than the Hindus, leading to envy and resentment. Hence these repeated attempts to humiliate and demoralize them by various Hindus. Vaidya's main source of information is a 20th century polemic by a Brahmin named Anant Priolkar, and his sources weren't the auto-da-fe records kept by the Inquisition tribunal or any Portuguese government records. Even his narrative of the 1510 conquest of Goa in his book was complete nonsense. (The English translation of Afonso de Albuquerque's "Commentaries" has been available since the 1800s, but Priolkar never used it. Priolkar also claimed to be fluent in Portuguese, but he didn't use the Portuguese language sources either.) An investigation into the records kept by the Portuguese in Lisbon has been carried out in recent years by a Mangalorean Christian of Brahmin origin named Alan Machado (he was curious to know about the story of his ancestors in Goa and if they were victims of the Inquisition), and he recently released a book using the Inquisition documentation showing that most of what has been taught in India about the Christianization of Goa is not true.
He is just lying coz his ass is burning
@@jaimatadiplynwood1004Nope, all the historical records have shown that Shefali Vaidya is lying because she can't face her Dharmic Brahmin caste having lost status and influence among Goans, being rejected in favour of firangi Mlecchas.
@@cg8397 she lying and missionary spitting fact huh 😂
she is lying coz she is upper caste wow what a logic
@@jaimatadiplynwood1004 there's no use of replying to these people. They just want to be ignorant of History. They will ignore everything that's written. If you carefully examine their replies...it shows how they are trying to neglect what Shefali Vaidhya and ANand Priolkar said in the book by raising that they are Brahmin. They still feel that hindus can be bullied by playing the card of cast... Just as a reminder to them....NOT ANYMORE!
The year mangeshi fell into the hands of the portugues is 1763 by Wikipedia.Until 1763 the land was governed by a hindu king so no one could touch the temple,that's how it is surviving and by the time the land was given to the portuguese they actually became tolerant towards hindusim so that's why the temple was noy destroyed this was according to Wikipedia
Nonsense... Sondhe Rajas gifted Ponda to portuguese during inquisition time
And wikipedia is a non trusted source... No scholar would site it
That land was gifted to Portuguese.... When inquisition was going on
Nonsense.... The area was gifted to portuguese by the same hindu kings when inquisition was going on
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357 can you share your sources??
How come human sacrifices stopped in other parts of country when Inquisition was only imposed on new Christians and only in Goa
Thanks for shedding light amongst the hate! We need to bring peace back to India, not division because of Religion.
EDIT: sad to see so many hate comments against Christians. :(
Ye bichare rice ka karz aaj tak chuka rahe hai
EVERYTHING WAS GOOD AND PEACEFUL UNTIL THE PORTUGUESE CAME.
My response: well everything was good only for the high caste especially the brahmin. They exploited the lower caste and lived luxurious lives. Christianity became a challenge to this dreadful system when many lower caste became Christians and challenged the system. So also there were practices existing in India which were dangerous for human life which were reformed by the Buddhists, Mughals, Portuguese, British and other movements within Hinduism.
FRANCIS XAVIER WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE INQUISITION.
Well I have dedicated a whole section in this article to explain how he is not responsible for the inquisition and even if he mentioned about it nobody knows where he meant it and what version of Inquisition he desired.
THERE WERE FORCED CONVERSIONS, OR CONVERSIONS OUT OF ALLUREMENT OR BRIBE AND NOT OUT OF CONVICTION.
This is a pure radical hatred to Christianity and the missionaries. As I have mentioned that the Miracles done by St. Francis Xavier and many still experience the power of his intercession was also a great factor. After his incorrupt body was brought in Goa it was the key point of astonishment and wonder which contributed to the choosing of the faith. So also the edict of the king of Portugal in 1567 and the records given by the then historians are proof that forced conversion was not always a regular event.
THE HINDUS WERE FALLING BACK TOT HEIR OLD PRACTICES OUT OF LOVE FOR IT SINCE THEY STILL LOVED IT.

This is silly. As it is proven Hinduism is not one particular religion and it has its many faces. In Goa people were used to some superstitious practices and even black magic, animal offerings and even child offerings. These were the major reasons which Portuguese did not separate from Vedic or Brahminical Hinduism.[62] Such practices are still prevalent in Goa.[63]
INQUISITION WAS A FORM OF CHRISTIAN RADICALISM
Certainly not! As we have seen the church and the state were one and the same. when we say state that means church played a important role in the political area as well and it influenced political administrations. Therefore, in those circumstances, the inquisition was a part of the law of state and religion was an integral part of the state. As we have also seen how there were strict conditions on the use of torture it solely depended on how the inquisitors carried out the executions. However, it has been made clear that the history of the inquisition is manipulated and tampered with by the Protestant viewpoint and documentations of history show a different viewpoint and lives many questions unanswered.
CHRISTIANITY DESTROYING CULTURE.
Not at all. I have already given the statement for that in the above topic of inculturation. Infact I would like to remind that the very first freedom movements were started by Catholics and in fact by Catholic Priests the protest against Christian in equality by Fr. Mathew Castro, The famous Pinto Revolt in 1787 by three Catholic Priests, who can forget Dr. Francisco Luis Gomes who was a Goan Parlaimentarian who demanded freedom of India from British and the Portuguese, then Dr. T B Cunha who was the one who suggested the Goa should be part of the Republic of India. Also cannot forget Dr. Jacque Sequeira who fought for independent state of Goa when the Maharashtra Gomantak Party along with Janata Party wanted to merge Goa with Maharashtra.
ONLY HINDUISM BELONGS TO INDIA.
This is a total radical idea. Hinduism alone has not influenced the Indian society and its reforms. Much of it has been also a contribution from other religions and philosophies. Hinduism alone is no the only religion that originated in India nor it has its original roots on Indian soil though it is the majority contributor yet drastic major changes have been brought by others. Hinduism itself has spread beyond the boundaries of India. No religion belongs to one place of region. If we look at every religion it has a universal message to the all the people and therefore missionary in some way. Mirabai spread her devotion to Krisna. Guru Nanak spoke about his God experience to others. Buddha preached about the Nirvana to others. Mahavira spoke about the Moksa to others. All these religions and spiritualities have spread all over by way of preaching to others. Swamy Vivekanand also is a great example of this practice of preaching and many of the Gurus and Baba even to this day. Therefore, blaming Islam and Christianity alone for its preaching and missionary work is cruel and unjust.
THE POPE SHOULD APOLOGISE TO PEOPLE OF GOA AND INDIA.
In they year 2000 itself Pope John Paul II apologised for the Inquisition announcing the day of Pardon and penance for the Church. He changed the whole viewpoint of the Church and also the people changed their mind and attitude towards the Church. Pope Benedict XVI and also Pope Francis also have apologised time and again for the crimes done by Church leaders and inquisition itself.[64] However, the People of Goa have never made such demand from the Church and have forgotten the past. The Hindus and Christians in Goa live peacefully to the extent that many Hindus revere and pray to Christian saints, have great devotion to St. Francis Xavier, to Mother Mary and Jesus himself. They honour the Catholic Priests and nuns and live in harmony. Therefore if the people of Goa themselves don’t demand something like this why should and outsider and a person never having lived in Goa properly insight it. The picture of Goa is different then that of the other parts of India.
@@LuzianJ hindi belt wale kabhi bhuke nai Mar sakte till we have maa ganga🙏 aur dusri baat you are brain washed slow poison to indian culture and society
@@LuzianJ aapse behes karna meri sehat ke liye accha nahi hai. Aap bohot ameer ho, waqt bataega. Chawal pe bike hue log chawal ugane walo ko piche nai chhod sakte.
Aur aapka kaam hi debate karna hai
😂🔥
Thank you for the video
V nice. Congratulations good information. All the best
Thanks alot Father. God bless you
Converted once will always fight for there colonial masters 😅 aise gaddaro k hote dushmano ki kya jarurat
Conversion ka sach pata karo internet par information hai, gaddari NA hone ki thekedari tumhare pass NAHI hain.
The sound 🔊is very low
Thanks. Noted Abbaas.
Well done to you both for conducting this topic and it was very informative.I hope it's good enough explanation to listen.
Thanks alot and God bless... We tried our best... Spread the message and awareness...
This presentation would be far more credible if it were to focus less on personal reactions or folklore and more upon well researched, documented historical facts.
There is a vast body of scholarly literature on this subject starting with the infamous Papal Doctrine of Discovery, to the expropriation of the lands and resources of Non-White Peoples through European colonialism, and the conversion of “pagans” to Eurocentric norms of “civilization”.
Research is strongly recommended on this crucial subject.
We appreciate the comment. Well somethings are really difficult to put across. We will get someone on our show who has recently published a book on the same topic.
Perhaps you should have done it sir
Gen.03:01. And the serpent (lying tongue) said unto the woman, Yea, hath God said, You shall not eat of every tree of the garden? Today, the lying tongue says, you may read every book of knowledge, but the Holy Scriptures,which redeems Christians from abominable worship of pagan gods that have invaded the peace ful shores of Goa that is God’s heritage.❤❤❤. Amen.
Great information, basis of records, logics, assumptions that made sense etc but yea overall endless debate as religion is always a cross question for every religious person to put across, but yes thanks for the interview and the lots of unknown information. hats off for your time u've invested in researching and providing good amount of knowledge to the world! Lastly the interviewer has to brush up the skills a bit in terms of energy, expression, acknowldging and focusing on the person talking and talking along abt punche marks etc.
Thanks Darren. We are happy you enjoyed the intellectual journey in search of Goan inquisition.
With regards to my skill I will definitely work on it.
Also, we did not realise that the topic would go this lengthy. It was impromptu.
One needs to think what they say on camera. It cannot be mere utterance of words. Words with careful logic and statements.
Or else someone will quote me wrong in the future.
@@talkwithtyson1949 why not just ask the Portuguese for the videos they have of breaking temples n forceful conversion this Goan historian Sawani who comes on Ranveer Allahabadia (beer biceps) channel , abhijeet chavda just ask her she has given full inquisition story she might know and has said the Portuguese had shown proof. That even in an American newspaper it had reached. Just ask the Portuguese so once and for all its settled.
Excellent research Matthew. Thank you❤
If inqisition was for christians only,werent all converted christians following hinduism before.I have accounts of many people among my friends ancestors who say that they were forcefully converted.Portuguese followed convert or flee principle,tax and land ownership benifits after conversion .So bascically inqisition was for hindus and christians.Also why should christians have to suffer inqisition fate they converted from other religions only to face this wrath.There is no denying the fact that cruelty of inqisitiion afftected goans at that time.Btw I have nothing against sfx because he was and always be goincho saiba.Also I will not agree with speakers like subash etc nowdays just taking history out of context just to create communal disharmony.Its one thing to know about our past but now we should see what we can achieve in future with all people coming and building our nation instead of spreading hatred.
What is hinduism..???
People can make up any nonsense about family histories without evidence. A good example is Dayanand Bandodkar. His parents came to Goa from Maharashtra, nobody knows their real surname but they called themselves "Bandodkar" after arriving in Goa to give the false impression that they are originally from Bandora, and gullible Goans believed them. It was only after Bandodkar became CM that the harsh truth was revealed, his family were Marathi kalavants with zero links to Goa (their family goddess is Bhavani of Tuljapur).
Same with Zantye cashew factory, the family claims on the website that they are natives of Bicholim and built their factory from nothing. But if you examine the historical records then you find that Harish Zantye was a Marathi born in Malvan during the 1930s, came to Goa in the 1950s to work as cheap manual labour in the cashew factory that had been built and was run by White Europeans, and he grabbed the factory using Marathi goondagiri in the 1960s. (Bandodkar and his MGP government helped a lot of Marathi migrants steal lands and businesses in Goa after they came to power.)
Best of all is the Mangeshkar family describing themselves as "Maharashtrian Brahmins" (they're from Gomantak Maratha Samaj a.k.a. kalavant community of Mangeshi village in Ponda). Lata Mangeshkar's biographer Harish Bhimani even wrote that Lata's paternal grandmother Yesubai was her paternal grandfather Ganesh Bhatt's wife. (Harsh truth is that Ganesh Bhatt was already married to a Brahmin lady, Yesubai was his kalavant mistress, so Deenanath Mangeshkar didn't inherit his father's caste and surname.) So when Lata asked permission to perform rituals in Mangueshi temple, the Brahmin temple management refused citing "caste concerns".
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357when you don't know what Hinduism is then why are you talking nonsense about them.
There are nazis who deny holocaust. So depends who you ask.
The problem was politics and religion were intertwined. Take the great Schism of July 15/1054 when the Church broke into Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox. It was purely political. The Church had 5 Patriarchs before Constantan becoming Christian the Church was controlled by an Oligarky of five Patriarchs, Constantinople (todays Estanbul,) Jerusalem Antioch, Alexandra and Rome. Constantan wanted to make his man the Patriarch of Rome (pope) top man so we had the great Schism,
Please read books about conversion by the Portuguese and there christisn missionsries. The Goa Inquisition
Book by Anant Priolkar
There is another detailed one come out by Goan Inquition Facts and Fictions by Alan Machado
If you are sc you should be happy to be saved from Bammans castes system
@@Johnny-pi1vkGood point..
Thank you for putting this out here
It was our pleasure to do it. God bless
Very informative! Thanks 🙏🏽
Glad it was helpful!
Distorting Abrahamic religion is heresy . That women Shefali called to doing Hindu things as Heresy, I died a month ago and they broke my ribs when they revived me I am also 78 years old and by memory is not what it used to be so if I have defined Hersey wrong please correct me . I faintly remember that was the meaning of heresy I was taught in Seminary about 55 years ago.
Lol...source: Trust me Xavier...
Thanks for sharing your research Mathew. Very illuminating.
Indeed Father. ❤ thanks alot Father
Completely fake history for self satisfaction
Father, what is first for you. Nation or Religion
@@Rahul-hq1dd nation
I am a Goan btw and I only have love for all Goans. But please don't be in denial. Confront the truth or stay in your deluded state forever.
So why Bruno burned by Chruch ? if they are so soft on society and say sorry after many years ?
EVERYTHING WAS GOOD AND PEACEFUL UNTIL THE PORTUGUESE CAME.
My response: well everything was good only for the high caste especially the brahmin. They exploited the lower caste and lived luxurious lives. Christianity became a challenge to this dreadful system when many lower caste became Christians and challenged the system. So also there were practices existing in India which were dangerous for human life which were reformed by the Buddhists, Mughals, Portuguese, British and other movements within Hinduism.
FRANCIS XAVIER WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE INQUISITION.
Well I have dedicated a whole section in this article to explain how he is not responsible for the inquisition and even if he mentioned about it nobody knows where he meant it and what version of Inquisition he desired.
THERE WERE FORCED CONVERSIONS, OR CONVERSIONS OUT OF ALLUREMENT OR BRIBE AND NOT OUT OF CONVICTION.
This is a pure radical hatred to Christianity and the missionaries. As I have mentioned that the Miracles done by St. Francis Xavier and many still experience the power of his intercession was also a great factor. After his incorrupt body was brought in Goa it was the key point of astonishment and wonder which contributed to the choosing of the faith. So also the edict of the king of Portugal in 1567 and the records given by the then historians are proof that forced conversion was not always a regular event.
THE HINDUS WERE FALLING BACK TOT HEIR OLD PRACTICES OUT OF LOVE FOR IT SINCE THEY STILL LOVED IT.

This is silly. As it is proven Hinduism is not one particular religion and it has its many faces. In Goa people were used to some superstitious practices and even black magic, animal offerings and even child offerings. These were the major reasons which Portuguese did not separate from Vedic or Brahminical Hinduism.[62] Such practices are still prevalent in Goa.[63]
INQUISITION WAS A FORM OF CHRISTIAN RADICALISM
Certainly not! As we have seen the church and the state were one and the same. when we say state that means church played a important role in the political area as well and it influenced political administrations. Therefore, in those circumstances, the inquisition was a part of the law of state and religion was an integral part of the state. As we have also seen how there were strict conditions on the use of torture it solely depended on how the inquisitors carried out the executions. However, it has been made clear that the history of the inquisition is manipulated and tampered with by the Protestant viewpoint and documentations of history show a different viewpoint and lives many questions unanswered.
CHRISTIANITY DESTROYING CULTURE.
Not at all. I have already given the statement for that in the above topic of inculturation. Infact I would like to remind that the very first freedom movements were started by Catholics and in fact by Catholic Priests the protest against Christian in equality by Fr. Mathew Castro, The famous Pinto Revolt in 1787 by three Catholic Priests, who can forget Dr. Francisco Luis Gomes who was a Goan Parlaimentarian who demanded freedom of India from British and the Portuguese, then Dr. T B Cunha who was the one who suggested the Goa should be part of the Republic of India. Also cannot forget Dr. Jacque Sequeira who fought for independent state of Goa when the Maharashtra Gomantak Party along with Janata Party wanted to merge Goa with Maharashtra.
ONLY HINDUISM BELONGS TO INDIA.
This is a total radical idea. Hinduism alone has not influenced the Indian society and its reforms. Much of it has been also a contribution from other religions and philosophies. Hinduism alone is no the only religion that originated in India nor it has its original roots on Indian soil though it is the majority contributor yet drastic major changes have been brought by others. Hinduism itself has spread beyond the boundaries of India. No religion belongs to one place of region. If we look at every religion it has a universal message to the all the people and therefore missionary in some way. Mirabai spread her devotion to Krisna. Guru Nanak spoke about his God experience to others. Buddha preached about the Nirvana to others. Mahavira spoke about the Moksa to others. All these religions and spiritualities have spread all over by way of preaching to others. Swamy Vivekanand also is a great example of this practice of preaching and many of the Gurus and Baba even to this day. Therefore, blaming Islam and Christianity alone for its preaching and missionary work is cruel and unjust.
THE POPE SHOULD APOLOGISE TO PEOPLE OF GOA AND INDIA.
In they year 2000 itself Pope John Paul II apologised for the Inquisition announcing the day of Pardon and penance for the Church. He changed the whole viewpoint of the Church and also the people changed their mind and attitude towards the Church. Pope Benedict XVI and also Pope Francis also have apologised time and again for the crimes done by Church leaders and inquisition itself.[64] However, the People of Goa have never made such demand from the Church and have forgotten the past. The Hindus and Christians in Goa live peacefully to the extent that many Hindus revere and pray to Christian saints, have great devotion to St. Francis Xavier, to Mother Mary and Jesus himself. They honour the Catholic Priests and nuns and live in harmony. Therefore if the people of Goa themselves don’t demand something like this why should and outsider and a person never having lived in Goa properly insight it. The picture of Goa is different then that of the other parts of India.
I am still waiting for hindu brahmins to say sorry... At least the church said sorry
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357 For What they need to say Sorry ? People who protest against those discriminations also bhramhins many times. The one who helped Ambedkar to educate also a Bhramhin. What is the need for that ?. Chruch Says sorry because they are the higher authority who decide what to do why to do such a thing. But there is no such thing in Bhramhins. Now they have associations. It's required for people who want to increase their community to accuse one group or sects of people.
I am asking When Chruch says sorry they did wrong in the past as an association like burning someone in public place as a punishment. That's says Chruch's are not soft peoples. They have more cruelty then Kings and Chruch's have high influence over the rule of kingdom. That's the point I want to discuss. You want to divert things into wrong discussion. They said sorry to Bruno. But not for many of their mistakes did in other countries..
@@LuzianJ Yeah people like you are so dumb by thinking Christian Machineries are only have soft corner on the world and all other religious are cruel people. Thats what the selling point of Christianity and Muslim community.
They have duel rules for these community when they are in minor and when they are major in society.
"Hindu kings would cut people's noses and ears and would burn people at the stake, and trample people under the feet of elephants" -- Just giving statements will done a dumb people only. Wise people come with proper evidence.
@@LuzianJ No need to explain them they know how the Christianity spread over the world. by killing local race or by making slaves. You are the one who not really see the true colors of the Christianity's true nature in the world. Vandalized temples in Western countries is not happen because those are believing in democracy not in Christianity. Christianity already failed in many places to rule with the Christianity domination in many nations. especially in America. That is the reason America got freedom earlier then any other country. With that experience Britishers not poke on local beliefs with force. But they did make vulnerable of the beliefs and scriptures to weaken the society. and that's continue now with people like you.
Don't worry about spoon feeding to me. But before you ask me to google. Why dont you google about the same thing what this guy said is wrong. you will get plenty of it what is Goa Inquisition ? You didnt' find anything different ? people like you backing-up Christianity because you believe they did social services to the nation. But you never realize that that is part of their game of spreading their religion.
They destroy the education system which is available for everyone and given their education system which usually give it to their lower class people to us.
You are talking about Genoside on minority people in India. Really funny you are saying that. Which religion is dominating in Nagaland now ? Have you ever see in Kerala they prohibited "kaashaaya" color in Hindu festivals ? Have you ever hear anything Christian Chruch Fathers force convert any people ? have you never heard any incidents which are not happen on Hindu people ? What is the Christianity % when we have Independence ? and What is their % now. How many people are Changing Religion and following Hindu benefits ?
So, Don't dare to say the word hypocritical. That's only suites you.
India is not democrat country not only after independence. Jews came here 500 BCE and after 1 CE. Indian kings helps them to settle in some palaces. Muslims are invaded our countries still we are used to mingle with them. Christianity also came after Britishers. Still we are be patience with them. It doesn't mean that what ever you said is true. If you really think Goa Inquisition is just on enquiry on people who follow Christianity that is your biggest metaphor you ever live in. You will never come out of it until you are comforting from that and you never see a Reality.
Wow I was so zapped to hear all this, I thank the Lord for Tyson and Mathew for giving us so much knowledge about our religion and conversion. I hope we can bring Shafali to test, for bringing so much of negativity to Goa. I too have commented on her saying that thank God our ancestors even if we’re forced to convert, we who are now living know Christ and have Everlasting life.May the Lord be with youll. Thank you once again.
Thank you Estefania. Means alot. Yes. We do not like the current mindset going on in our nation. Hopefully we bring awareness to people who are being brain washed
Thank you so much
@@talkwithtyson1949 Indeed, I am glad that we Hindus are being brain washed. This is helping us to understand our history and what our people went through.
The only change that our nation is experiencing is that we Hindus have started taking our Dharma seriously and with all sincerity and trust me it will only increase. Perhaps this surprising change is not being digested by you.
@@ameyakatrekar7509 I am happy that your taking your dharma serious. Hopefully you keep getting better at it. Don't worry. We don't feel any indigestion of any sort but i guess some people feel the indigestion when guys like us speak the truth when facts are getting distorted. Sometimes it seems like we are community who is against another. That's your portrayal. But sorry my friend you are no ways close to even being a Hindu. That means you have got your dharma wrong.
@@ameyakatrekar7509Stop lying. If Hindus were taking their Dharma seriously, then they wouldn't be anywhere near mleccha territories like Goa or Western countries.
I always had a question to ask. Who remains the owner of the structure when whole/majority of the people of the village get converted to other religion? Does it go to other who are not of that village? And I think you answered it right in this video. Thank keep going.......
Thanks Joao
All Portugues we're saints😅😅😅
No need for your jokes , you wait , Hindus are gonna be exposed too as to what happened to Jain's and Buddhists then we want to see you laughing
How come wrong map?
👌very informative!!
Thank you Nerissa
Very knowledgeable of history. Msthew keep it up.
The infamous Francis Xaviers and Martin Alfonso were sent to Goa by King John III of Portugal in 1542 to initiate the process of converting Goan residents to Roman Catholicism. On their arrival in Goa, they were enraged by the New Christians of Goa secretly practising their previous religions (either Judaism, Hinduism or Islam), while also upholding their Hindu values and traditions.
The infamous Francis Xaviers and Martin Alfonso were sent to Goa by King John III of Portugal in 1542 to initiate the process of converting Goan residents to Roman Catholicism. On their arrival in Goa, they were enraged by the New Christians of Goa secretly practising their previous religions (either Judaism, Hinduism or Islam), while also upholding their Hindu values and traditions.
Hindus were forbidden from holding any public office, inheriting their father’s property and testify as witnesses in courts. If a Hindu child was deemed to be an orphan by the colonialists, the child was ‘seized’ by the Society of Jesus (founded by the not-so-saintly Francis Xavier) and made to change his religion. Clear discrimination was seen in social life, where Hindus were forced to sign public documents only after Christians and couldn’t be clerks in village offices.
In 1567, a law banning Christians from employing Hindus in the colony was introduced. (Ref: Teotonio R. De Souza, The Portuguese in Goa, pg 28-29). The inquisition office even questioned natives who were suspected of following their previous religions in private. Over a span of 214 years (1560-1774), 16,172 natives were questioned and often tortured for following a religion other than Roman Catholicism.
To be questioned by the inquisition office, a mere rumour of practising idol worship in private or chanting a Hebrew prayer would suffice for the missionaries to drag the native to the office.
Hindu children were sometimes taken away from their parents and burnt in front of them, with the parent being tied and forced to witness his child being burnt alive until he accepts to convert to Christianity. Over 4,000 non-Christians were inflicted with such punishments during the course of the inquisition
In inspiration of the Muslim invaders, the missionaries imposed the Xenddi tax on the Hindu population, similar to the Jaziya tax. (Ref: Sarasvati’s Children: A History of the Mangalorean Christians, Alan Machado Prabhu, I.J.A. Publications, 1999, pg. 121)
ishwarsharan.com/features/the-goa-inquisition-t-r-de-souza/
Why does God not transfer monthly requirements of money into each account?
You should know better being Hindu doing all that spiritual work , why don't yall enlighten us! Since y'all know everything right!?
@@andreamessiasgomes7118 braaa zill zingalala🤣
@@andreamessiasgomes7118 the same spiritual places plays important role in our economy.
Good Mathew God 🙏👍
Hats off to Bab Mathew and God bless him. Hope other youth will take some inspiration from him
Thanks Menino. God bless you too. Please do share our content to all your friends and relations. In this way we can get a wider audience. God bless you once again.
17.20. The Lord Jesus Christ answered them and said, The Kingdom of God cometh not with observation: 21.Neither shall they say, Lo here or, lo there! for behold the kingdom of God is within you. Amen.❤❤❤.
How can one even defend the Goan inquisition
I wish history was so easy 😄👏👏 good work Mathew
❤
We need your support:
If you like our initiative of bringing out good content you can support us in helping us producing more such content.
Any amount big or small will really be much appreciated.
The funds will be used for travelling, research and editing. God bless.
Gpay : 9762331336
UPI ID : costatys321@okicici
Ask Jesus to help...surely your god is a loving one right
Ask Portuguese like they helped the fake story tribes 😂😂😂 Portuguese & Xavier was is will be tyrant European colonizers
@@HINDUTVASAVARKAR dude wait when soon Hindus too will be exposed!
Video muito bom. Excelente conteúdo. Eu Sou português. Abraço fraterno de Portugal!
Very good video. Excellent content. I am Portuguese. Fraternal hug!
The request for an inquisition was intended only for Muslims who prevented religious worship and kidnapped peoples under Portuguese rule. With the inquisition, the government of Portugal only wanted peace, tranquility and freedom for the peoples of the territories under its domain, in order to freely exercise their religions. Its objective was not directed against pagans or Hindus, because the latter did not harm Christians. Even because Afonso de Albuquerque encouraged the marriage of Portuguese with Hindus without regard to religion, which continued until December 1961. It should be noted that Muslims in goa who did not interfere with hindus and christians because of religion were not hit by the inquisition.
Peace and Happiness!
Portuguese people are ignorant about the Portuguese Inquisition and its various tribunals because of the Leftist takeover of Portugal's government, media and academia. You also need to read the "Comentarios" of Afonso de Albuquerque, or even "Conquistadores" by Roger Crowley. Hindu women converted to Catholicism before their marriage and the children were raised as Catholics. Also, read the recent book by Alan Machado Prabhu where he investigates the Inquisition records. The original targets were the Jews and Muslims who moved from Portugal to Goa while falsely claiming that they were Catholics. This was regarded as a security threat due to the reputation of Jews and Muslims in the Iberian peninsula collaborating to overthrow Christian rulers.
Lmao! are you joking ?
@@SubstratumMaxima nope it's the truth ,just because of a few don't exaggerate. Indians are known to exaggerate alot.
23:07 Columbus, who in 1492 was the first European to reach the islands, called them the West Indies because he believed he had arrived near India by travelling westward. not just the europeans . every other invaders wanted to find India because it was a paradise. they arrived and rest is history. _ refer shashitharoor speech on what the europeans did
Looks like you are overwelhmingly glorifyimg India
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357 well you feel so because may be your overwelhimingly glorify europeans. 🙂
@@krishnadasmg6006 you cannot stay in one corner of the country without meeting me in GOa and pass a judgement
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357 Well how can you stay in one corner of the country and pass a judgement on me then.
@@krishnadasmg6006Shashi Tharoor also glorifies Europeans more than he does Indians. It's why he attended Montfort School, Campion School, St. Stephen's College and Tufts University instead of regular Indian institutions. Goans don't listen to what ghanttis say, but observe what ghanttis do.
👍 your channel is amazing and great job Tyson👍 Goycho Saibh amcho Saibh..... 💐 May St. Francis Xavier pray for us.....! 🙏
Thank you so much Afzal. Hope you have benefited much from it
@@talkwithtyson1949 ya bro....!
जय श्रीराम ❤
Great research God bless you
Thanks alot Franklin. God bless you. And please do share and subscribe
Converted people's more religions than the original because they think we have eat shit is the sweetest😅😁
Good work. Ignore the blind hate and make more such expose videos. Lot of blind hate towards Christians nowadays. Imagine blindly hating a true minority which has indiscriminately done so much good for the country 🤦🏻♂️
Great well done Mathew
❤
Good research hope people understand and open their eyes and minds god bless you....
Thank you for your positive feedback 😇
@@talkwithtyson1949 why is nobody exposing the Hindus???? How they tortured Jains and Buddhists!!! Let the Hindus know what they got was Karma.
Watch , What every Hindu should know about Christianity.
Killing girl child was not in Goa. It was happening in Rajasthan.
I am so relieved after seeing this video, Praise God! I was extremely troubled when I watched Shefali Vaidya’s accounts on the Goa Inquisition. And I was told by my father our ancestors were Hindus, many years before he passed away. But didn’t know how it was relevant to me cause was too young to understand, but good that we are becoming aware of our past and getting the necessary clarity of our very existence. We are not glorifying the Portuguese here, but the atrocities or restrictions as claimed by Shefali that were carried out by the Portuguese king’s presentative were borne by our Ancestors and not hers. Our Ancestors should be thanked for the choices they made and not berated, they deserve respect. They did what was best! Hope Mam Shefali and those who hold such views on our community like her have or will watch this video and make peace with the truth. We are at peace they need to accept this. Praise God once again, all glory is his❤
Very well said Savitri. Yes. We need not worry about the inquisition anymore as it is all sorted. No amount of research done can really bring the so called "truth" what she thinks to be true. Anyways, we rest our case only to the experts and that is the Historians. Watch our next episode and that is with Dale Menezes - The Historian's craft. Later watch the interview with Ms. Amita Kanekar.
thank you so much. please share the info to ur contacts
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357 film "Goa file" banani chahiye... Research ke sath.. 🙂
@@rupeshg.3327 Exactly... U will realisethathindusareth e culprit
@@rupeshg.3327 My dear Bratra shri! I want that to happen so I could troll y'all more on how ignorant one can be. Please make it as fast. I would love a laugh while watching the level of IQ y'all posses. Can't measure the serenity of that moment ♥️.
This is a informative video , there are some people who spread wrong information and bring disharmony among public, these people should know the truth will never be hidden.
I agree with you. Hence, Christianity is struggling in Europe !
@@ameyakatrekar7509 religion is another thing and Hinduism is not any better, day will come when Hindus will be exposed to the world how much atrocities done to Jain n Buddhists. So this was just karma for y'all so don't yapp rubbish to us. All propoganda is happening because of these Hindu groups, have some shame atleast.
Very helpful ❤
Kashtam
Please read Marathi book Tandav by Goan author Mr Mahsbaleshwar Sail. This book is based on real incidents of crueal atrocities commited by Portuguese rulers to convert Goan hindus.
I would love to read this book if there is an accurate translation of it in English but have read the synopsis and the author mentions the role of the Inquisition by SFX which has been elaborately discussed in this video through discussions of his own letter. Second, through the synopsis, it mentions how Hindus were forcefully converted to Christianity which in recent years in academia we know wasn't entirely the case, forced conversions did play a huge role but many also converted for benefits, better social status, and with the lower caste they converted entirely as a village once the villager leaders converted, so to say everyone converted forcefully is totally false. If that were the case Goan Catholics who moved to Mangalore during the period of the Inquisition would have renounced their former religion in the mass and reverted back to their native religion. Second at the end of the inquisition in Goa itself Goan Catholics would have started to convert back if it had been forceful, this is what Anant Priolkar heavily mentions in his book which is a very simplistic view of the events if one has to critically analyze it and going by Charles Dellon's own account in Priolkar's book he mentions that the inquisition was never ever for them. I would suggest you read the book Conversions and Citizenry by Delio Mendonca wherein he studies the anthropology of the time and its primary sources to talk about this topic and I'm not aware of anyone who has been able to critically debunk his work from the sources.
It's just fictional and kutil
@@Johnny-pi1vk
Fictional? You are not accepting the bitter truth that the Portuguese had tortured and forcibly converted Goan Hindus. Whether you accept or not, the truth is not going to change. Shamelessly vindicating and justifying the misdeeds of Portuguese missionaries. Also, Study the history of Saint Xavier, you will come to know one of the most heinous historical truths. By the way, the ancestors of many Muslim and Christian people were Hindus. I am sure you will not accept this truth and will return here with stupid arguments. Good bye.
@@Johnny-pi1vk
Fictional ? You Can't accept the bitter truth and most black history of Portuguese missionaries. I don't discuss and argue with hypocrites. Good bye.
@@viki6619 why not talk of the original people of India??? A day will come when soon Hindus will be exposed for what they did, then you sit there n cry.
Quite a research. Great work Mathew. Thanks Tyson
Thank you very much 🥰
Good research done , Velinkar ,Vaidia ect heavy fist punch of Tyson😀
Hehe... We hope to spread awareness
Atleast get the spelling right !! You are children of the only God that exists, right?...
The church committed sins! Wow seriously! Tell me more.....
Hindus and brahmins committed sins... Tell me more
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357 When did I say we committed sins, you guys said it in the video.
@@monsterclaws11 everyone of us have committed sins. None of us are perfect. Are you telling me that if I go in police stations today, I won't find hindu brahmins and would only find Christians?
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357 oh wow , the brahmin allegation again ?
Brahmin were retrded no doubt but they didnt invalidate others religion. Caste is bad no dount. Dont act like upper caste hindus didnt support Shudras in their protest
But you guys are still converting tike zombies
Being a liberal hindu I apologise to all the Christian brothers and sisters in the behalf of that Hatemonger lady...🙏
Hey. Don't worry. 😀 you don't have to. It is a kind gesture on your part but according to what Christ would teach Christians she is already forgiven.
Much appreciated.... But it's not hindu Christian... It's just politics
@@talkwithtyson1949 Just because of few radicals we don't need to forget Universal brotherhood..
@@unknownid2002 exactly... Thank you so much.... Let love prevail
@@talkwithtyson1949 Speaking Truth is Now spreading Truth🤣🤣🤣.🤡🤡🤡Rice Bags
Christians won't accept that they killed half the World Population.
Read the Book of Richard Zimler to know more😂😂😂
Ignorant People in the comments
Wow talking like a true rice bags
Wow I’m replying to a gobarbhakt!!😂😂 at least rice all living beings can eat. But cow’s gobar 🤮. Tell me 1 thing andbhakts aka gobarbhakt. A cow’s baby calf doesn’t eat nor drink their mother cow’s crap nor piss. But y do a large majority of u guys do this kind of nonsense, as if the world already doesn’t complain that Indian smell like crap. If they only knew that manwadis do such kinda thing…..😂😂😂
If I was rice bag i wohof have my own house
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357"Paul Steiner" is a ghantti Hindu or a Jew. He doesn't know that Goans grew their own rice, no need for handouts unlike ghanttis.
Lk.17:20-21. And when the Lord Jesus Christ was demanded by the abominable idol worshippers, when the kingdom of God should come
Your english language is very good
How many baby body he found under hindu House ?
If you visit rural Sattari, you can find burial places of Dhangar community where the widow was buried alive with her dead husband's body as part of Sati by live burial practiced by that community.
@@cg8397 you have visited or witness ?? Outsiders distroyed our culture gave us imputed culture Goa never come of colonial mind's we still nameing our place in there language we want there pasport
@@artbaba2065Plenty of Goans have seen those burial sites, sati was banned in the Novas Conquistas after the Portuguese takeover but the burial sites have been preserved by the Dhangar community. The Portuguese even recorded one such incident of sati of a Dhangar widow by live burial in the Codice Casanatense. Societies built by Hindus have always been inferior to those built by Western Christians: It's why you can observe Hindus breaking the rules of their own religion and immigrating permanently into mleccha territories like Goa and Western countries even after being told repeatedly that they're not welcome.
@@cg8397 your superior western use. The burn female in the name of witchcraft Church killed many scientists in the name of religion
How you forget about the slave
01.Jn.5:07. For there are three that bear record in heaven, the Father, The Word, and the Holy Ghost.: and these three are one. Jn.01:01.;Rev.19:13,Jn.10:30.❤❤❤. Amen.
Please.. Study Christopher Columbus before remarking that for Europeans everything was India.
Columbus was in search of india
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357 really? Thanks for telling me... One of the worst event which led to killing, raping, burning of crops, torture of entire populations of indigenous people in South America in the name of Jesus.
That does not seem to connect with your comment... Sir however I suggest you to watch the documentary on spanish Inquisition by BBC.... Named... Myths of Spanish Inquisition..... Would you want the Aztecs of those days back who sacrificed a human being everyday to the sun??
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357hath kapro khamb kide tar
25:35 Inquisition was stopped for 4 years. You make it sound like it was stopped for 100 years or something..
1812
Jn.17:02-04.Father, as thou hast given the Lord Jesus Christ, power over all flesh, that He should give eternal life to as many as thou hast given him. 3. And this is life eternal, that they might know thee, the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom thou hast sent.4. Father I have glorified thee on the earth: I have finished the work of glorification, which thou gavest me to do. Amen.❤❤❤.
Portuguese apologist... Do you agree that your forefathers where Hindus, if yes please explain how did they convert to Christianity.
Why so much hate from Brahmins here? Very scary to see people will forget humanity and desire to hate others because they changed their religion.