The Choice is Easy! - Amaran 60x S vs Zhiyun Molus G60 & X100
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 06. 2024
- Amaran 60x S vs Zhiyun Molus G60 vs Zhiyun Molus X100
** BEST PRICES I FOUND HERE **
Zhiyun G60 - geni.us/xFjA
Amaran 60x S - geni.us/Bp9AoUK
Zhiyun X100 - geni.us/BLe2
GEAR I USED TO MAKE THIS VIDEO
VIDEO GEAR:
A Camera - geni.us/fCo6 or howl.me/ckVm0lD1bLa
A Lens - geni.us/w3Oak or howl.me/ckVmU6LbhHv
B Camera - geni.us/3deXcAQ or howl.me/ckVm4MAPaVI
B Lens - geni.us/GYI9p
On Camera monitor - geni.us/ZJVKX
The LUTS I used for this video - transactions.sendowl.com/stor...
AUDIO GEAR:
Microphone (Studio) - geni.us/Tj8RI
XLR Audio Recorder - geni.us/yDUf
USB Audio Interface - geni.us/ZdN1a
Wireless Microphone (out of studio) - geni.us/XFnz
Podcast Mic - geni.us/QVZHLG0
Podcast Boom Arm - geni.us/J7Fp
Editing Headphones - geni.us/WmwFC
Editing Speakers (super cheap but awesome) - geni.us/wfLkz
LIGHTING:
Main Light (Key Light) - geni.us/waB7lTp
Main Softbox - geni.us/UJPXnec
Light Stand (for Key/Main light) - geni.us/y4HuK4R
Background Light - geni.us/R2OK
Hair Light - geni.us/waB7lTp
Stand for Boom Mic and Overhead Camera - geni.us/8O8UtdY
COMPUTER AND EDITING:
Monitor - geni.us/AG7b6u
Computer - geni.us/zUcZO
Keyboard - geni.us/bA16W
Touchpad - geni.us/PLaLMh
Editing Software I Use - www.apple.com/au/final-cut-pro/
Awesome Free Editing Software (Pros use it!) - www.blackmagicdesign.com/prod...
* Some links are affiliate links, you do not pay any extra, but I may get a small commissions. Using these links allows me to make more videos like this one.
00:00 - It Should Be Easy
00:12 - Does Wattage Equal Brightness?
00:48 - Bare Bulb Test
01:10 - Softbox Test (Real World Results)
02:49 - How Many Watts Do You Need?
03:41 - Portable vs Studio Lights
04:38 - Bowens Mount vs ZY Mount
06:28 - USB-C Power
07:36 - Sony NPF Battery Power
08:28 - How They Are The Same
08:51 - Pricing and What You Get
14:23 - My Conclusion - Jak na to + styl
*** BEST PRICES I FOUND HERE ***
Zhiyun G60 - geni.us/xFjA
Amaran 60x S - geni.us/Bp9AoUK
Zhiyun X100 - geni.us/BLe2
I’ve used the Amaran 60x for 18 months and it’s stood the test of time. The included Bowens mount and v-mount plate make it immediately more useful than the Zhiyun lights. I know photographers who handhold it while shooting. Trying to rig a ISB-C battery is janky and unreliable.
The stand mount is solid metal and is very had zero issues with holding a 24” softbox. My only complaint is it threads into the bottom which means it can come unscrewed.
Finally someone compared the actual light emission instead of the usual BS about these zhiyun lights. Thanks. This is real help if one is about to buy them
Amaran 60X is the goat! The fact that it has a built-in Bowens mount and is still pretty dang, portable is why I went with it. I’ve been using it since it came out for small productions and weddings. This thing has been through it all. I’ve had gas knock it over on light stands During receptions, and the thing still looks brand new. One time a guest even knocked it into a piece of cake 🤣🤣🤣.
Pretty much all of my lights are from Aperture at this point (other than a few) and having all your lights in one ecosystem is really nice especially with the Sidus link app.
I’ve used both the zhiyun x100 and g40 and liked both lights however the x100 with all the added adapters was a no go for me and it really isn’t that portable if you want to bring the kit. For most professional workflows I think that aperture 60X will fit in better especially if you already have NPF/V-mount batteries.
thanks for this again man I've come back to this video like 3 times now
Thanks! It took a lot of work, so that's good to hear.
Awesome video, Mark. The little Zhiyun lights are great little lamps. After using them in a couple of paid gigs, they work a treat.
Yah, they are the real deal. They are so small, I think it can be deceiving, they can be used for “real” stuff, they aren’t toys.
Thanks for the review! Much appreciated
13:56 only if you take zero accessories for the x100 like the bowens mount. I’m sticking with the 60x but I almost grabbed the zhiyun x100 after trying out a friends at a wedding. It’s definitely a cool concept but I really like having the built in bowens for when I need a modifier.
One exception to this, though, is if you shoot with umbrellas. If you shoot with umbrellas, then the x100 would probably be the go to aside from price But if you if you use bowens at all stick with the cheaper more flexible (as far as power options) 60x
Such an easy to follow video - thank you!
Going for full portability :)
Great video Mark, I’ve seen some hate and some love for these lights but no one explained better than you 👏🏼✨ it would depend a lot of your needs, not just how bright the lights are 👌🏼 I personally love portability so I think I’ll spend the extra money for the Molus x100 with the battery
I have a mate that works in video production, and since getting the X100, it comes to every job.
This was the light review we've all been waiting for. Thank you!
You are most welcome. Yes, I felt there was a needed video, just a more objective view, with supporting facts.
@@markwiemels I ended up buying the Zhiyun G60 for yet another reason. My studio setup is in our living room, and I needed something that wouldn't make the room look like a garage studio. The G60 is cute enough to leave setup 24/7, and the space still feels inviting for everyone else.
Totally, tuck it away in an corner and you wouldn’t even notice it.
The Amaran 60x is still extremely portable. I can stuff multiple of them into my photo backpack. The fact that you can use the 60x with v-mount and NPF Batteries is amazing. I often use it with the Aputure Handheld handle attached on the bottom and the Aputure Mini Dome 2. Definitely my favourite light to carry around all day on a shoot.
Just bought the G200 … 2 of them.. I think that would put enough light for almost all of my needs
I had not decided to buy Amaran or Zhiyun for a while. Which one fits me and meet my needs. This video is one of the best review i have ever watched so far. It is very useful for me Thanks Mark!
such a clear and thorough review ! thanks a lot
Thank you so much!
Finaly a review with light output readings and not adjectives. I suggest you give the camera settings when doing light tests as well as distance from light to subject
Best comparation video is here!🤙🏻 i think im going for the amaran 60. I want to start my “small” studio” with this lights
Thanks. It’s a great light.
great and very neutral review! I will go for the Amaran 60x. Furthermore, your lighting and camera setting of your review was phantastic, it charmed my eyes.
Thank you for your kind words!
Totally agree!! i boutht myself for the x100 and use it with westcott compact umbrellas. A killer tiny setup
For sure. I'm thinking the same for travel.
thank you so much for this excellent review video 👏👏👏
How about the fan noise difference? I'm keen on the Amaran 60s but a lot of reviews suggest it has a pretty loud fan.
Best review on youtube for those popular lights, love the real life tests!
I wanted more power then my Amaran 60d - but it seems that the 100x would be just slightly more powerful then 60d (but it is quite a bit more powerful then 60s thou...)
Great comparison Mark!
Thanks!
Great review, what about zhiyun 20c for an outdoor photography and video
If you want to power the Molus, you have to have a powerful external battery and that will run you at least 150 bucks. I've found that the battery that comes with it is a great idea, but only gets you about 30 min full go, and its not easy to get extra ones.
you didn't mention the benefit of Siduslink to control amaran lights
Mark, do you ever teach tips on how to use lenses and features to those needing?
I have, and I plan to do a lot more of that in the next year.
Really great comparison. Not sure why it took CZcams a month to recommend me this haha.
I do like our Amaran 60x’s, they just about squeeze into a lens slot although the separate battery plate can be a bit annoying and some v-locks the bowens Mount gets in the way of the d-tap.
I’m tempted to pick up the x100 because of its extra power, size and most importantly USB PD. I’m not sure why every device under 100w can’t be powered by that now days as it’s so useful.
The G60 would be really good if only they could have fitted an umbrella mount to the light itself. It could have been an awesome ultra compact solution, unfortunately that mount looks pretty big and slightly defeats the point.
Thanks, good insight. I’m sure CZcams didn’t recommend this to you because I’m not very good at CZcams, but I’m doing my best.
One of the better, more objective reviews of these lights. I ended up getting both Zhiyun lights. The added portability is more useful to me.
Thanks, yes, I was trying to provide a more fact based analysis. Thanks for the comment.
does anyone know beam angle of molus x100 reflector? cause the amaran has a 15 degree tight beam angle but what about the others?
You didn't mention Bluetooth controllability. I know the X100 does, as I have one, but what about the others please Mark?
As a wedding videographer I bought Last year the Godox ml60bi instead the amaran. I liked more the form factor of the amaran but the Godox ml60 bi in 100% i ged 1.30 to almost 2 hour’s without 2 8800 npf batteries. For meeting it’s important to get 1.30 with 2 npfs. I doubt The newzihyun lights last so long.
Your videos are fantastic. Subscribed.
Thanks.
Great Video!
Very solid comparison.
Thanks.
Thanks for doing the comparison.
I’ve got questions about the metering. What cheap meter are you using? What type is it (incident or spot)?
Typical cheap Incident light meter, off Amazon.
One thing I don't quite understand about the Zhiyun lights is that, while small is good- most high quality light modifiers are massive! They need to be in order to create nice diffuse light. Unless you are needing to stack the lights together on a single flag, or use them as practicals, the margin of return for smaller actual lights drops off a cliff.
Yes, in that sort of key light roll, I think they add the most value used in run and gun, or "content creation" setups, when you might use them bounced off a ceiling or as a supplemental light to natural light. If your primary use is a 90cm softbox, then yes, less value.
These are meant for portability, traveling, etc. If you need a light for large modifiers why would you ever buy one of these when for the same price you get more powerful studio lights. These are meant for the small softboxes. The fact that the Zhiyuns have the Bowens mount adapters is just a perk but not intended primary purpose.
How many times you've heard you look like Hugh Laurie. Great video!
For me a Bowens mount is an automatic win.
You didn’t mention fan noise. Just wondering why? It’s the main reason I stopped using the Amaran.
Thanks for sharing that. I will include that in a future videos. Maybe I didn't run the Amaran with enough power to crank up the fan, they were all pretty quiet to me. The G60 and X100 are dead quiet.
Hi Mark, I have a Amaran 60x (first version). I would like to buy another light. Should I buy another 60x or a 60xs? Are they going to work well if both used on same subject?
The safe bet would be to go with the older model.
X100 is so good I’m buying a second one.
It doesn't have any less output then any other 100w right?
How's the heating issue
Chinese tip: "Zhiyun" is pronounced, at least in Beijing-dialect Mandarin, as if the first syllable Z-H-I is the first syllable of "Journey" or "Jersey" - Jer-yoon.
I like pronounce it 45 different ways, they are all wrong ;-)
GREAT VIDEO..!!
Thanks!
There is a very interesting and cheaper light than all of these, it has the same power as the Amaran Amaran 60 light, it is the Colborn Cl60, it is small and weighs only 500g
Yes, I hope to have a look at that one. I think there are some compromises with that light, but need to get my hands on it before I can comment more.
recently ordered it but i got the Daylight variant since i don't use warm light to film my videos anyway. hopefully, it will be alright when i get it. :D
5:38 'proprietary' scares me.. you end up with a bag full of bit's that don't talk to each other..proprietory
Now there's a Smallrig with built in battery.
As a wedding photographer/videographer I have the Amaran 60x. Aputure LS 60x then moved to Stella Reflex S then moved to the Zhiyun Molus X100, F100 and M40...
I'd have to say that Aputure/Amaran has a lot of catching up to do...
negative !! we do 100 weddings a year and Amaran is king don’t know where u get your information
a second Aputure LS 60x would have been enough. M40 can light 50 people without problem though.
The G60 zhiyun should be $120
Agreed, I was able to grab one one a good deal for 165
> 1:50 . Amaran is the better light. End of story. Thanks Mark
zhiyun have brought an excellent industrial design to these
Agree.
Colbor cl60, cl100x
cl220m cl330. they come close in price with the full extra zhiyun/amaran.
Very useful content, Mark! Thank you. I'm light shopping now and your review really helps. I think this video has the lowest "sort of" count per minute of all. Kudos! BTW - When is a door, not a door? (Nice affect.) Ask any 5-year-old. Hahahahahaha
Thanks!
Why does no one speak about the light output at lowest setting. The portability becomes useless if you need to carry a separate light with a LOWER low output setting. If doing a shoot with both moody and bright scenes, the lowest output also becomes important.
That’s a good point.
@@markwiemels thank you! I ordered the x100 and the amaran so I can compare. Appreciate all you do for the community with your tests and videos. Sending positive energy!!
Following up I was thinking this is kind of like light resolution. Lux high vs lux low. Because I think some brands make their 1% crazy bright just so people go “omg look insanely bright even at 1%”… which is actually a terrible trait for a light. While maybe unrealistic from a electronic board perspective, an ideal light would output approximately 1% of the lux it does at that light temp at 100%…. I can’t imagine throwing the x100, for example, to boost the light thrown onto a wall in the back or a dark scene that we’ve lit with a practical.
@@ro8144 agree.
the zhiyun is crap, is not the brightest light, there are full reviews showing all these lights side by side and the Zhiyun X100 is a full step lower than the Amaran 60 and that one the double the price...
and with battery and softbox is not small, just expensive and dark..
Those videos are inaccurate. I used an actual lux based light meter to give real results in this video. One stop would he 1/2 the light, which is not what is happening at all, using a photography light meter does not work for accurate measurement. If you want real numbers for brightness and size comparison, they are all in this video.
great video thank you sir
Thanks!