Her fans want her to sing a song thats around two decades old and expect it to sound EXACTLY the same? Bit unfair. She can still sing and she sang live. Have some realistic expectations people.
Aaron Mountford-Myles It's not her fans that have unreasonable expectations, it's those 'vocal experts' on the Internet that claim that she sounds horrible compared to her prime. Her fans are appreciative of what she delivers now because she tries her best all the time.
i love how she did the adlibs in the end!!! she knows how to make her song still sound good even at times when her voice isnt in great condition! voice is her gift. singing is her talent
Despite her voice sounding extremely damaged here compared to the Tokyo 1996 version, I still loved the way she sounded here, it's obvious that even SHE wishes she could still do it like she used to. I loved this because it points out the fact that the human voice can sound so many different ways, good bad or indifferent.
she was like 25 or 26 when she performed that song shes was 42 on this video. and her voice is damaged because shes drinking too much and doing too much whistle notes....
All of the hate in the comments. She's giving her all and her best! Plus, she sang part of this acapella in 2013 and sounded virtually the same as 1995....her voice was in much better shape in 2013. Mariah hasn't lost her voice. It's all about lack of consistency due to those darn nodules. Both a blessing and a curse. Love Mariah regardless!!
I disagree, her voice was in better shape in 2012. The reason of this performance was because she was singing on top of a mountain and the cold temperature and altitude affects your voice. Meanwhile her voice in 2013 gave more performances similar to this or worse than this without singing on top of the mountains. And her voice was a little too heavy and dry in the Triumphant Tour.
My God is this possible? This woman and best of all it will always be my queen of love but Underneath The Stars did not believe it when I saw this video love you very very much but you and the perfection Mariah Kisses from your Brazilian LAMB
IF YOU ARE TRUE LAMBILY YOU WOULD APPRECIATE THIS PERFORMANCE BECAUSE SHE ALWAYS GIVES HER BEST.......REMEMBER MARIAH HAS NODULES SINCE SHE WAS A KID H THIS IS NOT A BAD PERFORMANCE HER NODULES JUST SHOWED UP....SO JUST APPRECIATE THIS PERFORMANCE...KUST SAYING😂😂😍😍😘😘
People are cruel and stupid, they don't sing a shit, but they want Mariah Carey to sing with the same voice as twenty years ago, crazy people, so sad. Wake up, Mariah Carey is a international Icon and unique treasure.
it wouldnt be depressing if you just be a true fan and love the old AND new mariah and hope and pray that her voice stays just as beatiful as it still is, mabey if all of her so called "fans" werent always calling her washed up and saying they missed her old voice their prayers and wishes could come together and bring her voice back. nothings impossible you just have to have an open mind, unlimited love, and hope
Simply beautiful! I remember her mentioning she was gonna sing this live at one of the Angel Advocate tour dates but she never did. I'm glad she's finally done it. She needs to sing more like these, the fan favourites. Crybaby or The Roof next please!!!
you depress me!! Mariah just sang so beautifully on this song....a very difficult song to sing live..and it has to be miked a certain way..the song is very whispery and light...its not a power ballad and the approach is different....and her voice sound raspier cuz it happens as a singer....i sing and this song is sooo difficult....you cant lose it and sing this song..impossible...she just did a difficult and hard thing and did it well and is still gets the negative....yeah thats depressing
Thanks for sharing this. I love this song and I'm so glad she sang it so beautifuly. Also that she's slowly bringing back some oldschool songs to the setlist. I know she wasn't at her best in this particular concert and you can hear it in her voice, but hopefuly she sings it again soon and it sounds even better.
Beautiful queen 👸 Mariah I love you so much that I can ran 🏃♂️ to you when I hear you sang this song because I need to be drifting with you under neat the stars 🌟
This Vocal Goddess is an absolute treasure and those who don’t cherish her can get the fuck out. Anyone who hates on this performance doesn’t deserve rights, as if any of the little girls today can even sound half as good as this MARIAH CAREY THE SONGBIRD SUPREME 🙌👑💖 Her whisper was beyond gorgeous, I loveeeeee UTS and she looks so stunning 😍😍
Her voice still sounds great!! Its the song itself..on the record its whispery , light....you have to have the microphone a certain way..to get sound you want...there were no real mistakes on here...
Everytime I read comments like yours, I shake my head. Everyone is entitled to have their opinion. This is a free country. If you disagree...that's great!!! Just disagree and keep it moving, it's not that serious!!!
Bobby Ramos I don't think so. Generally royalties are paid to writers and publishers, not labels (unless they own the copyright or publishing designee). I figure she can still perform her old songs since she wrote a huge chunk of them.
Don't be a hater! Why are you so cruel? Look, it's very hard to sing in a cold place due to the fact that a singer may get laryngitis in a place like that. This swelling leads to hoarseness of the voice. The vocal cords can be greatly damaged if the singer exerts his voice too much. So that, she must save the little voice she's got now.
Evolving is not always a positive thing. There is nothing wrong with staying true to what you like and who you are. For example: reality TV has become very popular but in many cases, it shows adults cursing and fighting and making fools out of themselves. It sets a horrible example for our youth. No matter how popular it becomes, I will always consider "some" of it trash. In terms of music, and TV shows, the quality is not what it used to be. But we are all entitled to our own opinion.
This women is a national vocal treasure. The flawless vocals she has delivered throughout her career have earned her a pass for every note she sings…
Amen❤️❤️
This>>>>
Obviously
" I sing this because i love u"
Her whisper register sounded so silky and beautiful in this performance.
Her fans want her to sing a song thats around two decades old and expect it to sound EXACTLY the same? Bit unfair. She can still sing and she sang live. Have some realistic expectations people.
Aaron Mountford-Myles It's not her fans that have unreasonable expectations, it's those 'vocal experts' on the Internet that claim that she sounds horrible compared to her prime. Her fans are appreciative of what she delivers now because she tries her best all the time.
Aaron chill out dude 🖑
Who exactly said that lol no one
i love how she did the adlibs in the end!!! she knows how to make her song still sound good even at times when her voice isnt in great condition! voice is her gift. singing is her talent
You can see it in her face and her expressions she truly loves singing that song
Despite her voice sounding extremely damaged here compared to the Tokyo 1996 version, I still loved the way she sounded here, it's obvious that even SHE wishes she could still do it like she used to. I loved this because it points out the fact that the human voice can sound so many different ways, good bad or indifferent.
she was like 25 or 26 when she performed that song shes was 42 on this video. and her voice is damaged because shes drinking too much and doing too much whistle notes....
Ashton Pure lies theyre damaged because of her nodules
Cool Guy drinking can play a part as well.
stfu
Dante E is extremely damaged!!? She sounded great in this performance!
She looks so amazing. Her voice is incredible! I love that
Vincent Nguyen I agree. That hair is givin me life
All of the hate in the comments. She's giving her all and her best! Plus, she sang part of this acapella in 2013 and sounded virtually the same as 1995....her voice was in much better shape in 2013. Mariah hasn't lost her voice. It's all about lack of consistency due to those darn nodules. Both a blessing and a curse. Love Mariah regardless!!
I disagree, her voice was in better shape in 2012. The reason of this performance was because she was singing on top of a mountain and the cold temperature and altitude affects your voice. Meanwhile her voice in 2013 gave more performances similar to this or worse than this without singing on top of the mountains. And her voice was a little too heavy and dry in the Triumphant Tour.
My God is this possible?
This woman and best of all it will always be my queen of love but Underneath The Stars did not believe it when I saw this video love you very very much but you and the perfection Mariah Kisses from your Brazilian LAMB
A bit emotional at the end, I ssooo love the song, reminds me of my first love when I was in high school.
I still love Mariah Carey, then and now.💖
This was my JAM back in the day! So glad she brought back this underrated gem.
One of my favorite Mariah songs of all time! It’s rare to find a live version. Thank you.
I love her deep voice, love it!
She sing with her heart.... Go on girl !
still my favorite song! all these years later
Love this performance. Love this song. So glad Mariah performed it. 😍
from a singer like me this is GOLD LISTEN THREW THE SOUND AND BAD QUALITY AND FOCUS ON HER VOICE WITH SOME GOOD HEAD PHONES AND SHE SOUNDS WOE
IF YOU ARE TRUE LAMBILY YOU WOULD APPRECIATE THIS PERFORMANCE BECAUSE SHE ALWAYS GIVES HER BEST.......REMEMBER MARIAH HAS NODULES SINCE SHE WAS A KID H THIS IS NOT A BAD PERFORMANCE HER NODULES JUST SHOWED UP....SO JUST APPRECIATE THIS PERFORMANCE...KUST SAYING😂😂😍😍😘😘
i agree real fans should not say anything negative. She still sings better than most its July 2016 btw
even with nodules, this sounds great.
👏👏👏👏👏
This is a hard song to sing and she killed it
People are cruel and stupid, they don't sing a shit, but they want Mariah Carey to sing with the same voice as twenty years ago, crazy people, so sad. Wake up, Mariah Carey is a international Icon and unique treasure.
The drifting drifting drifting ad libs at the end omg yessss Mariah! 🔥
i will still love her no matter what...even if her vocals are totally gone...period!!!! i will continue supporting her!
love the quality and the sound... LOVE MC FOREVER!!
It's a shame she didn't sing my favourite part of the song :(
who the fuck are u
@@jillvalentine7672 lmaoooo
@@jillvalentine7672 for that u just have to read ;)
it wouldnt be depressing if you just be a true fan and love the old AND new mariah and hope and pray that her voice stays just as beatiful as it still is, mabey if all of her so called "fans" werent always calling her washed up and saying they missed her old voice their prayers and wishes could come together and bring her voice back. nothings impossible you just have to have an open mind, unlimited love, and hope
I love when mc adds to the songs !
I'm melting!!! She's so gorgeous 😍😍😍
i think she sounds really good
One of my favorites songs from her 100%
I love love love her voice here
wow she sang it beautiful...i miss her old music like this one.. loveyamuch MC
Fav song off that album 💖💖💖💖
Amazing ! I love it! Just for the nostalgia
This was sublime 😍
goshhh im gonna cryyyy it's unbelievable
so pround of u mimi!!
THIS TONE!! And the headvoice is IMMACULATE!! And the transition at 2:16
Mariah is back.. ♥
awww this is such a lovely performance MC.
OMG! that was beautiful
Thank you very much for posting. I never been close to see her singing like this. Thank you for your HD camera, too. ^^ Miss you, Love you, Mariah
Thanks for posting!! This song is very important to me
Wow simply breath taking!!!
So soothing 😩❤️
Simply beautiful! I remember her mentioning she was gonna sing this live at one of the Angel Advocate tour dates but she never did. I'm glad she's finally done it. She needs to sing more like these, the fan favourites. Crybaby or The Roof next please!!!
This is the first time I saw this. Thank you!
you depress me!! Mariah just sang so beautifully on this song....a very difficult song to sing live..and it has to be miked a certain way..the song is very whispery and light...its not a power ballad and the approach is different....and her voice sound raspier cuz it happens as a singer....i sing and this song is sooo difficult....you cant lose it and sing this song..impossible...she just did a difficult and hard thing and did it well and is still gets the negative....yeah thats depressing
isso é muito bom, que voz. que canção, que cantora!!!!
I like you.. Mariah CArey!
so gorgeous!
Thanks for sharing this. I love this song and I'm so glad she sang it so beautifuly. Also that she's slowly bringing back some oldschool songs to the setlist. I know she wasn't at her best in this particular concert and you can hear it in her voice, but hopefuly she sings it again soon and it sounds even better.
GOD is good❤️❤️❤️
Thanks so much!! I wish the other videos had this quality
Mariah queen!!!!!!!!!!!
Her hair... 😍❤️🔥and this was a great performance...
she never sings this ❤️
Thank u for the upload! Love love love her!
Beautiful queen 👸 Mariah I love you so much that I can ran 🏃♂️ to you when I hear you sang this song because I need to be drifting with you under neat the stars 🌟
Still sounds amazing
Lo mejor para dormir. Buenas noches
This Vocal Goddess is an absolute treasure and those who don’t cherish her can get the fuck out. Anyone who hates on this performance doesn’t deserve rights, as if any of the little girls today can even sound half as good as this
MARIAH CAREY THE SONGBIRD SUPREME 🙌👑💖 Her whisper was beyond gorgeous, I loveeeeee UTS and she looks so stunning 😍😍
This is the best vid here!
Her voice still sounds great!! Its the song itself..on the record its whispery , light....you have to have the microphone a certain way..to get sound you want...there were no real mistakes on here...
Her mic must’ve turned off when she did that driftinggggg belt
Underneath the stars and Melt Away
thank you.
Great quality!!
Ok this was good!!
Plus, she did it well!
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW - NICE I love it
I reckon aye!! about time MC
Mariah is singing right now in Morocco!!!!
ohhhh nice song its beatiful just like you mimi mariah :D
Hard to believe this was the same MC from 96..
amazing
Anyone know what note she hit when she was doing the "I was drifting, drifting, DRIFTINNNNGG" part at the end?
Everytime I read comments like yours, I shake my head. Everyone is entitled to have their opinion. This is a free country. If you disagree...that's great!!! Just disagree and keep it moving, it's not that serious!!!
Good performance. Im sure she doesn't like to sing her older songs because each time she does her old label gets a royalty
Bobby Ramos I don't think so. Generally royalties are paid to writers and publishers, not labels (unless they own the copyright or publishing designee). I figure she can still perform her old songs since she wrote a huge chunk of them.
Not true in her case because Mariah wrote/co wrote all of her songs except the covers. So the royalties are hers
i think the music engineer was not prepared that mariah is going to lip that part, and forgot to play the pre recorded high belt. haha!
No D5:(
Don't be a hater! Why are you so cruel? Look, it's very hard to sing in a cold place due to the fact that a singer may get laryngitis in a place like that. This swelling leads to hoarseness of the voice. The vocal cords can be greatly damaged if the singer exerts his voice too much. So that, she must save the little voice she's got now.
Okay mario
she attempted to lip the high belt at 2:58 but the pre recorded track failed to play. lol
WOW!!!!
SO Dreamy.... This is better that the Mawazine's version..... In the Mawazine's version was Asrul
I LOVE U!!!
Evolving is not always a positive thing. There is nothing wrong with staying true to what you like and who you are. For example: reality TV has become very popular but in many cases, it shows adults cursing and fighting and making fools out of themselves. It sets a horrible example for our youth. No matter how popular it becomes, I will always consider "some" of it trash. In terms of music, and TV shows, the quality is not what it used to be. But we are all entitled to our own opinion.
this is possible? The fact is this song is freaking hard to sing! You have to sing in falsetto throughout the song
O feliz siesta
💯💕💞
OMG
🔥🔥
when i see her face live
What colour is her hair here
She use the whisper un this part
did she actually sing the drifting part live?
my opinion is no, because we can’t hear it in the recording. x
Not a horrible performance.....try a horrible recording!! Get your life
The playback didn't came out so good on 2:57 lmao
10% volume 💀
@@inactivechannel5384 stooop😂
anyways she looked like Butterfly Era here
She didnt have to do that..and thats no easy song
2:58 did she attempted the Tokyo Dome run ?
She fkd Tokyo up with this song SMH
Curse those nodules of Mariah 😭😭 her upper belts are locked forever
this isn't liped for me.
The recording isn't to blame...she's fine at her whisper singing but she completely mimes the upper notes and lets the CD vocals take over...