Caledon man sentenced to 17 years in prison for deaths of Karolina Ciasullo and her three children
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 05. 2022
- Brady Robertson will be behind bars for 17 years after the 2020 deaths of Karolina Ciasullo and her three children. Ciasullo and her kids were killed their car was struck by a vehicle, driven by Robertson.
This guy killed four people, and didn't get the sentence requested by prosecutors? What possible mitigating circumstances could there have been for the judge to refuse imposing the higher sentence?
the kids not white so it would be constitutional racism to impose the law
@@godyea6141 Everyone involved here was white. What are you on about?
I can guess his age is prolly a mitigating factor. And even with the mitigating factors 17 years is still alot
that guy should be sentence to death
@@amadeovalentino2088 A lot? I disagree. A woman and three children died because of the actions of this guy. Imagine if this were your wife and daughters. Seventeen years is a pittance.
Kind of a joke of a sentence. Theres footage of him driving high and recklessly/idiotically literally the day before he killed the family (he was also apparently fleeing for police before the crash). He is careless. 17 years for 4 lives is...nothing. Imagine how the father/husband feels right now...
How about 2.5 years with a possibility of early parole?
This raises a moral question , is the driver to blame or is it the alcohol store including the LCBO that should face scrutiny for promoting alcohol sales along with their strong lobby groups that basically have a monopoly at almost every major grocery store , I think that is the big elephant in the room that no one wants to talk about , people would rathe sweep that question under the rug
@@sinabagherisarvestani8924 ...was alcohol even involved? High levels of THC was mentioned I don't recall alcohol being mentioned.....but okay.
one thing ill never understand about canadians/americans is their thrist for revenge. do you seriously not think 17 years is not long enough for someone to be sentenced? imagine taking your whole childhood up until university and keeping you locked up in a cell for that long. thats how long these people are being locked up for, its more than enough. i swear it seems like all you people want is to just punish and completely abandon these people. isnt the point of punishment so that the person learns their lesson and moves on with their lives? become useful productive members of society? how is that gonna happen with them being in a prison cell for more than the already 17 years and you want more. people like you only think of revenge, not how to actually fix these issues. you just want to punish, not rehabiliate. disgusting attitudes
@@yidavv plenty of people have been punished far worse for much less. You have a good point though. It's about rehabilitation. Way it's done in USA/Canada is terrible. Europe has a good system when it comes to rehabilitating people. What do you this is a suitable punishment for this person?
…should be 4 life sentences…instead of merely 17 years. This clown (driver) knew exactly what he was doing by getting behind the wheel of his dated sh*tbox on that particular day. Moreover, the clown’s insurance probably maxed out in terms of his small/inadequate auto insurance policy. The victim’s husband/family should pursue all available legal options against this clown to the Nth degree.
Car was not a shitbox, hot take tho.
@@mikeb5567 its definitely a shitbox now.
He got 17 years
What was wrong with the car, exactly?
This is in Canada. No consecutive life sentences, maximum 25 years and most times get statues dangerous offender. meaning they will 100% be in prison for 25 years, then after that they can eligible for parole and can “make a case” for their release and need to prove they are no longer a dangerous offender. Based on their crime in most cases they won’t be let out anyway meaning they can be kept in prison up until their death if not deemed safe a dangerous offender and have their parole denied. An example is Paul Bernardo.
17 years with time served, so 14 years and 2 months. With only a 20 year driving ban that he will 100% breach. Marco Muzzo is already out so I dont expect him to serve more than 5.
big facts.. Muzzo has a lot more money though & he also received 12 year driving probation.
They're trying for 8 years so his sentence would be 1/4 over already. Broken system!
This raises a moral question , is the driver to blame or is it the alcohol store including the LCBO that should face scrutiny for promoting alcohol sales along with their strong lobby groups that basically have a monopoly at almost every major grocery store , I think that is the big elephant in the room that no one wants to talk about , people would rathe sweep that question under the rug , it wasn't that long ago when alcohol was illegal in the United States
Your so right Marco Muzzo should have done way more time then he did.
@Water King correction… Canada is out of whack period.
He'll be out within 5 yrs and will be back on the road with in 7. Lifetime driving ban ha! Should be lifetime jail time.
He took about 200 years of life away from the 4 of them. That should be the sentence.
This is Canada's justice system at it's finest. No accountability, should get 4 life sentences period end of story.
This raises a moral question , is the driver to blame or is it the alcohol store including the LCBO that should face scrutiny for promoting alcohol sales along with their strong lobby groups that basically have a monopoly at almost every major grocery store , I think that is the big elephant in the room that no one wants to talk about , people would rathe sweep that question under the rug , it wasn't that long ago when alcohol was illegal in the United States
@@sinabagherisarvestani8924 You keep trying to make this argument, it still doesn't work because the stores don't FORCE their products on you. Keep proving that you lack any semblance of grey matter.
Scary how quickly life can get taken away, leave your house expecting to come back safe and sound, and gone just like that, we take life for granted far too much,
Ahhh 😔
Not our fault, but the frigging judicial system and the spineless judge's fault FAILED us!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This sentence is a complete joke! 17 years, is all he got & he'll be out in 5 years, driving around in the same neighbour-hood where he committed the crime! Where is the justice in this dam country, ffs!
Canada is a wonderful country, but unfortunately the politicians ruin it. This shitbag should be behind bars for the rest of his life.
This is nothing do you guys remember the guy who cut a passenger's head off on a Grayhound? One of the arresting officers ended up taking his own life due to PTSD and yet the court found him not criminally responsible, put him in a psych ward and he was out less than 4 years later as a free man. I'm punished worse for divorcing my wife smh.
@@haitianxu that man has incredible mental illnesses... hence not being criminally responsible
Canada is one of the softest countries in the world on crime.
Yup, out with a name change and a new lease on life. Considered not to be a threat to the public SMH
He will be out in 4 years.
What a joke that 17 year sentence is…….a complete insult to the memory and family of those lost.
A family destroyed because this waste of skin thought the rules didn’t apply (he had 15 driving infractions in the 2.5 years prior to this crash) while out driving under TWO driving suspensions.
He’ll be 35 when he’s released as he’s being credited with almost 3 years time served and that’s IF he doesn’t get early release (which he almost certainly will)
Canadian justice at its finest 😡
i've always said we dont have a criminal justice system, we have a justice for criminals system
23 year prison under our joke of a punishment system is more like a few years then get's probation, thats right folks, 4 lives for a few years , let that sink in
No kidding, those precious babies and their mother deserves true justice.
Agreed
This TRAGIC had affected me in a way that NO WORDS absolutely no words can ever describe. I am not the same person anymore. I think about Karolina, Klara, Lilia, Mila every single day. This type of tragic is not something you can move on from. God, please help Michael, their family, and everyone affected by this as this is beyond belief! I go to the crash site and pray very often
Miss read the title, thought it was "Man to be sentenced to death..."
Same here, it should of been that
THAT would be justice.
There’s no question about him being guilty. He murdered an entire family.
Canadian citizens should take the law into their own hands and get this guy when he is released.
There’s always prison justice. Hopefully…
@@vstar7196 he can bribe those inmates.
FFS he got 4 years per death, 3 years time served leaving 14 and will probably be released much sooner then that! 😤
Seems like a slap on the wrist.
so he will be released by the age of his late thirtees for killing 4 lives? that ain't enough. should be at least 30 yrs jail time.
i am glad people are bringing up Marco muzzo,he got a slap on the wrist also. these guys should be doing life.
Bleeding heart judge.
23 years for 4 lives is the minimum, thank goodness I am not the judge or jury in this case, I would have put his behind in prison for the rest of his natural life ... Arguing for 7 years instead, what joke!!!! There should be no negotiating down a sentence ... a sentence is a sentence.
Lock him up forever!
Life in prison is not enough
25 to life for the goof
wow... he ended the life of 4 people; those kids will not grow up and enjoy their life as HE will...
And he only get 17 years. What kind of joke sentence is that?
He should get 3 to 4 life sentences because he took away three little girls lives and their mother’s life
we call this justice?
Well Canadian "justice" strikes again - The Judge gave the defendant 34 months credit for "just under two years" pre trial custody...WHY! Well because in a bleeding heart country like Canada all judges are mandated to do everything in their power to lessen all sentences in many different ways. The defendant has "14" yrs left of his sentence however he will most likely be out in about half that because of all the other loopholes etc. Also what prompted the Judge to give him a 20yr ban from driving again as opposed to a lifetime ban, guess the Judge would have gotten in trouble from the Liberal Govt.
Sadly, the driving ban is irrelevant because idiots like him will drive with or without a license. Only way to prevent this from happening again is to impose a longer prison sentence and keep him off the streets and where he belongs.
ALL SPINELESS JUDGE!
He should never be allowed out again.
17 years what a joke should be life
The law here is a joke. RIP to the victims.
Canadians can't rest under the current system!
Without question, the gravity of this criminal act was entirely deserving of life imprisonment with no chance of parole, but the Canadian legal system has major flaws in many areas (not unlike the Canadian Constitution itself).
The other issue is that at the time of this fatal crash, the convicted killer was being pursued by police in a high-speed chase, which clearly contributed in creating the conditions for a disaster like this to potentially occur.
A serious discussion should be had on outlawing high-speed police chases, especially around innocent people in residential areas (this crash did not occur on a highway, but at a busy intersection).
Officers in pursuit could have just recorded the license plate number of the fleeing vehicle, and later set up a sting operation for surveillance of the car's registered owner.
That doesn't let this reckless criminal off the hook, but matters were clearly made worse here by the high-speed police pursuit.
I've been saying this for years these police chases need to be stopped that woman and those beautiful girls may have been still alive....so so so sad.
@@leeannconnolly1955 Why is it the police fault for chasing the bad guys, and its the bad guys who are fleeing capture. They are choosing to run, the police are doing what they can to catch them (As society demands). However!! I agree that residential chases should be limited when there are alot traffic in the area. Recording the plate is one thing, unless the car is stolen. Best thing i can think of, is to create a boundary and block them in, catch them once they slow down.
Its a catch 22 because it also sends a message to would-be criminals that to get away all you have to do is drive fast and they stop chasing!
It really is a catch 22 on this one.
@@daryldiamond500 That was my thought in my statement, that rather than just let them go ,and hope to catch them later, they can radio ahead, corner them in and if they run, then a foot chase is alot safer. Dosent take long for a few cop cars to come and stop traffic or block up coming intersections.
He should be released just as soon as the victims come back from the dead.
17 years is not enough.
4.25 years per life. That's the value of a human life? He'd better have to complete an awful lot of anti dangerous driving courses, or what's the point at all?
Should get 10 times that in years...
at least 4 life sentences!
I cant believe his lawyer had the actual nerve to say, in court...on record, that any sentence over 7 years would be, and I quote..."An undo hardship on a youth offender"
Undo hardship?...He took the life of a mother and 3 young daughters away from a husband who has to live out his life without them! THAT, is "undo hardship" and the victims don't get parole!
His reckless, wanton actions took 4 lives that can never, and will never be replaced or forgotten. Justice demands that his sentence should reflect his actions. He is NOT a child in my mind, a 17yo who is able to get a licence to drive on the roads, knows DAM WELL whats right and wrong.
Even 17 years, minus the time hes already spent....minus good time in jail, and hes out in 5-6 years. Still able to live his life. There are no winners, thats for sure. Only justice now, should be the winner if there is one at all.
add a 0 to the end of that sentence and then we're in the ballpark of around fair, but still not enough punishment.
Meanwhile Marco Muzzo is already out of prison, it's great how we apply the law differently if you're rich.
Thank you for reminding me this case. I thought we wouldn't see this killer for years, but... he is out of prison?! After killing all these children and their grandpa? Unbelievable.
That is so sad 5 people lot there lives if he was wealthy from Toronto 3 years
This makes me remember the dad. I cannot even imagine what he's going through. Canada, you've failed him, just like you've failed many.
If I was the dad. That person would never see inside of jail. I would tear their heart out though their mouth.
@@kajzersoze8051 You can't since hes already arrested, I can't imagine you breaking into jail and tear his heart out... that's probably not possible but yeah I get what you mean.
if the driver had run a stop sign and killed 16 people and injured 13. he would get no jail time like the guy who actually did that. How does that work ? There is no rational explanation possible
Karla Homolka received 12 years in prison.
Brady Robertson should have received less than 12 years in prison.
170 years is ok, 17 years is too less.
eligible for parole in like 2.5 years smh
I really feel for that guy. Yes, that guy. Her husband. Their dad.
I'm with you on that. He lost his entire family in the blink of an eye because of a worthless piece of 💩. The murderer should have gotten the max sentence.
He should be locked in jail forever together with Marco Muzzo. Lucky Muzzo his grandpa is a billionaire who can buy 'justice'
He took four lives, seven times four lives, 28 years seems more appreciate.
5... The father's life is ruined too. I cannot imagine having a life after that...
I have 4 children and I know I would not be able to live after such a tragedy
He should have gotten what the prosecution asked for.
I, wonder how many drivers are out on the road while high and/or have THC in their system?
Only 17? A joke.
I read it as men sentence to death
Wow they get murdered he gets back out in 17... hah what a system.
Uhm... Marco Muzzo is living in an apartment in a community facility.
Unbelievable justice system. What a failure ? Back in my days, you can barely see a 20 years old with a car. The insurance by then for those under 25 was above $400. Back then $400 monthly was a fortune that no 20 years old could afford unless they have a good reason. Insurance for over 30's was a reasonable $500 annually. Today everyone pays around $150 no even with good driving history. Our government is busy regulating industries that do not need regulation, and allowing insurance companies to set the rules that suits them. Why would a 20 years old looser have a car insurance in the first place ?
If there weren't cops, judges, lawyers, politicians, and members of the media drinking and/or driving high, guarantee the sentences would be much much tougher
Well whats the sentence. Click bait misinformation
This video is from before the sentencing
8X the thc limit haha what even is a THC limit
the same thing as a blood alcohol limit, turdsack.
You ppl. complaining about a mere 17yr,s.. A 21yr. old in prison for killing a women and her three children. His sentence will be PRISON Justice for which a great% of you would want him freed if he lives through a round of welcoming in there.
No we wouldn't want him freed, just because you lack any form of education or a brain doesn't mean everyone else does too.
Easy way to make him pay a life sentence for his crimes - street justice when he gets out. Just sayin'. He better watch his back.
How much you bet he out in 6 yrs
3 years!
Alcohol is guilty. I'm banning it from my life.
This accident happened in my neighbourhood, and people did not come together .
This tells me the value of any single individual in Canada, great country indeed.
Canadian laws encourages criminals , these laws are against the intrust of the people.
Person who is judge in the right mind would definitely give government the shot to change it but it’s not being done and this proves the criminalization of judiciary against public and more over public does not demand justice they are sleeping.
More control on your feelings.
Quit the fear narrative display.
Bring back Capital Punishment!
death penalty
Why can't I see the reply? Is YT playing foolery?
Jesus Christ
Lol hope he gets out soon. Good on ya champ hahahaha, mow em down buddy mow em down.
What color is he
What?
he's white but why does that matter?
Why are you asking?
And where are you from?
America?
OK then where are your ancestors from?
Europe?
OK where before that?
Oh why am I asking such irrelevant questions you ask? I can ask you the same!
Racist.
God bless the victims and their families. Most people who enjoy alcohol are responsible, but there will always be tragic situations where innocent people lose their lives. All it takes is one person to cause this level of damage, this is the cost of having alcohol in our society.
About Trudeau's plan to legalize marijuana....
Marijuana wasn't driving a car dipshit
You're not allowed to criticize your emperor. There are harsh punishments for that!