Maruti Dzire Vs Tata Tigor Vs Volkswagen Ameo: Which Is The Best Compact Sedan?
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 08. 2017
- The competition in the compact sedan segment is heating up. After Volkswagen Ameo and TataTigor, Maruti has now launched its new offering in this space- Dzire. But which of these three cars suits your needs best, watch the video to find out.
Subscribe to Express Drives: bit.ly/2uHycWT
Express Drives is one of the fastest-growing digital automotive publications in India, brought to you by The Financial Express. We are a team of automotive enthusiasts with a difference. Our Automobile reviews help you buy the right vehicle while having fun seeing the video.
Follow Us:
Facebook: / expressdrives
Twitter: / expressdrives
Website: www.financialexpress.com/auto/ - Auta a dopravní prostředky
Tata cars-Great support from people but no one will buy. Dzire-all people against it but every one will buy......what a mind...
Agree, but I find that Tata interior is bad for starting to mid segments and when you take all these things into consideration it's obvious you will finally go with maruti because of sale and service and benefits are good.
All of them saying maruti cars are tin ki Dabba but still it keeps increasing sales every month, mostly people bother about mileage and maintenance factors , out first priority should be safety.
One thing to accept that maruti offers most reliable engines and service all over the country. Tata cars are good but i don't feel the premium interior and Tata car designs looks odd to me except harrier.
Fiat cars have strong build quality with most reliable engines but interiors just okay .
VW cars are good in both looks and safety.
Maintenance is same as maruti but spare parts are costly. Drives smoothly on highways but not a right car for bad road conditions.
My first gen Swift which clocked nearly 6 lakh kilometers but still runs good .
My VW polo TSI was fun to drive car & I only use this on highways.
My everyday car was flat linea with solid build quality and engine but not a premium car.
It's all about priorities and choose the right car that suits your lifestyle
In our country car size determines the status of a person right , that's why SUV sales are getting higher .
We all separated in many different ways as possible and now these brands separating us . 😐
True but tigor rear is ugly af
And premium feel is missing in tata
Tigor for who loves looks comfort, dzire for whose who looking for long term service reliable car and last and important VW Ameo best for those love best in class built quality finish and something like matured car
Y would you even compare Indian cars with a German car....
There is nothing to compare with Volkswagen in terms of power and safety
*japanese.
A japanese car with a german car.
You are really correct
Promote this girl. She is in a class of her own. Confident, fluid, smart and to the point. Also the production quality has improved a lot. Great job.
Pravin Patil chutiya
Pravin Patil agree...
She has lots of confidence...
Over confidence perhaps. If a presenter takes Ur attention away from what she is talking about to how she is talking about it, I believe you just failed Ur job then. Focus should be on the product instead.
Personal experience .... Ameo best car .. fuel efficient . Comfort . Performance . Amazing . Only problem is with rear seats. It also gets cruise control . 16 inch alloys . And much more features
If you want to prefer a good car in diesel engine VW Ameo is a good option. It gives you solid 1.5 TDI engine which is similar to VENTO TDI where you can get same engine and power as vento in Semi sedan version. No doubt Ameo is not good in looks i.e boot shape but it comes in premium class where you can see every VW car has same front look as like other premium brands. You can get good resale value as there will be no facelift kinda thingy will happen as like other brands, which can decreases resale value of old version cars. Another imp thing you can drive VW with no risk of dying. As it comes with ICRS system which means intelligence crash response system. As if your car crashes or get caught in fire or get drown in water, their windows automatically opens up and unlocks the door and also it cuts fuel supply just for a safety purpose. The only concern is higher maintenance cost. You need to pay almost 10 to 13K for servicing cost which comes once in every six months. It is bit higher than other brands.
music too high..voice is not audible or hard to listen..not good
Shaival Nagarsheth feedback noted Sir. Please subscribe to the channel and share your valuable feedback on the upcoming videos
Shaival Nagarsheth gunbarrel
May be ameo is the overall winner here, but as far as the review presented, ragini has stealed the show. Looking forward to see more from you.
lady presenter VOICE is perfect....keep it up ExDr will definitely hit 1M+ Subscriber
I noticed that.....
After 4 years.. Not even 100k
80% of Indian buyers look for mileage first
Then looks
Then features
At the end comes performance which mostly ignore since India is a huge country and you have to drive.
So Ameo sale is least may be. But if you really need fun,power,comfort and build quality...VW is always the best.
Volkswagen = Safety
😂😂
This is the first time I am seeing your reviews it is very brilliant. The briefing of the details of each car is short and crisp. I am looking forward to watch more of your reviews of all the new cars. Well presented good luck guys.
Prformance facility safety compare then go for ameo or ford aspire diesel only
Tigor is best ...NYC look n features ,even best in price segment..desire front Luk is yuk.. old ammasdor....
Rohit Verma
underpowered mess'dup dynamics weird rear styling (jaguar xf typel)
Rohit Verma you dont know what is a car......
You could have included Xcent, Amaze & Aspire also. Please do a comparison.
Tata togor is best
But it's still a tata....
cptmiche tata is better than suzuki
What about safety? And Why Aspire is missing in the comparison?
Checked your channel today! Good going!
Nicely done video.. Not much dramatic entrance and music... Simple and straightforward.. Loved it..
What I like in this video is the last moment (recording part) nd it's really enjoyable... Rest the car comparison is concerne it was pretty much helpful for a buyer who r really confused which one he should go for... Good job guys.
Though we own a Punto evo,....but this Tigor has definitely got a space in my heart and I just feel attracted to its design
You completely skipped the rear seat review ! :@
Yes, point noted Sir but we also had to ensure the video didn't become too long. I hope you'll continue to provide feedback on our future videos as we try and improve with every video.
great video. you have 1 more subscriber added...but the video quality in not upto the mark...the music was loud but great effort. looking forward for your future videos.
What about the backseat comfort?
Superb video cinematography
As well as nice detaling comparison
Review is good.nice editing. but please do reconsider abt d continue background same music track in ur next video its irritating .
Tata tigor is best! Tata is back in game
testdrive tigor bro! & you will came to know how great this car is...
Do not ever go for TATA. I bought the Tigor 2 months ago and since then my peace of mind has gone. Everyday the car comes up with a new issue. And above all, the main attraction, the music system with touch screen went off. The entire system is down. So many noises from the car. My older car was far better than this one and making less noises even after 6 years. Tata guys just waste time on call. No outcome yet. Worst service. Zero Cool is absolutely right.
Yash Dave chalane आती हे क्या तुझे गाडी, कुछ भी bake जा रहा हे, मेरी tigor to bohot achhi chalti हे aur looks bhi sexy he
Tigor top end model 2.5 lack kam he बाकी cars se aur best he
Yash Dave bro my tigor is also working very well , I think you have got a defective piece 😂😂
The kind of review that I wanted. This is a completely unique style of reviewing. Good job
Wonderful video guys . I really appreciate the efforts you put into this video to make it.
This video would have been more interesting if you guys would have talked more about technicalities of the engine , maintenance cost , resale value and fuel economy , considering the indian buyers .
Tigore is sexiest of all... ❤️
JJAJAJAJAJAAJAJAJAJAJ JJAJAJAJAJAAJAJAJAJAJ JJAJAJAJAJAAJAJAJAJAJ JJAJAJAJAJAAJAJAJAJAJ AJAJAJ JJAJAJAJAJAAJAJAJAJAJ JJAJAJAJAJAAJAJAJAJAJ JJAJAJAJAJAAJAJAJAJAJ JJAJAJAJAJAAJAJAJAJAJ JJAJAJAJAJAAJAJAJAJAJ AJAJAJ JJAJAJAJAJAAJAJAJAJAJ DO YOU HAVE ANY IDEA OF WHAT A CAR IS THE TIGOR IS WITHOUT A DOUT ONE OF THE UGLIEST CARS IN THE WORLD
+OPTIMUSYAN 25
if I m not wrong , U r from Nigeria.
More Saiyan 😂 kid
I like the music....your channel is subscribed....keep up guys.
Good review and smooth presentation by all.. cheers
Hi do camparsion between toyota platinum etios v and maruti suzuki dzire v amt in term of features amd safety . Which car should i buy?😀
good to see with rides and nice background music to feel the roar
Please also try with petrol variant and tell, why only diesel variant , bcoz in petrol variant TATA TIGOR Car is the KING of all the car
Very poor comment
Tigor engine is waste
In petrol tigor is no where even near
elite i20 asta petrol vs
dzire zxi petrol vs
aspire petrol
which one buy ?
need performance.
Please suggest which one is good in terms of milage.. I m am looking to by tigor but I m not sure on how it performs over milage.
Plz mention rear seat comfort
Tigor is tiger👌 Finally tata did something great with sedan
Nathan Drake tigor sucks
Pramit Nandi how it sucks???
Bhai engine bekaar he..
Music killed the video! Good job on that video editor!
Nice review.. u got new subscriber guys... 🤘
Hey guys can you help me with aspire (titanium opt) vs tigor(XT or xz)
Nice plz make like this video of new Hyundai Verna vs Honda city vs Maruti ciaz
Should i Bs6 Tigor petrol xz+ or honda amaze ?
why the hell the background music is kept... it's disturbing
Point noted Sir. Future videos will reflect the change. Thanks for your feedback.
What about safety features. How does these 3 stack up in terms of that.
I want to go for aspire diesel.but is there a chance that ford will leave india like chevrolet?
Excellent presentation. Just loved it.
In Ameo, the features like cruze control, auto-dimming rvm etc got missed .
awesome work folks. keep it up.
Hello, i am a regular viewer of your channel and i have one request . If it is possible to make a comparison video between tigor , amaze and dzire again in 2021 so it will be great for so many people. Thank you
What about safety features? Would the average and comfort compensate the buyer's life?
Bgm is good...can anyone share that link
Guy's please work on the sound re recording. Otherwise awesome vid
nice,but i think this would have been add more details will made it awesome
Nice review 😊... small observation .. Swift dzire boot size is not in sync.. voice says something text in video shows something ..
Thanks Sir! Yes, as pointed by you there is a mismatch of 2 litres. We can't change it in the video now but will take care of it for future videos. Thanks for pointing it out.
I own the Dzire AMT-- and it's a fun car to skim past the daily traffic. Easy on the gas and extremely driver-friendly, the car is by far the most aggressive mid-segment pick on the offer. Boot space is family-centric, and the back-seat looks plush. I love the infotainment, passing music control through the steering. Am I forgeting something? Oh yaah! The chase with Baleno-- Had an option, picked this over the hatchback. Great job Maruti Suzuki. BTW-- Dipayan and Ragini-- Great job on the presentation! Let me know If I could be there too with you guys!
nice interface and sound also
Thanks!
The presentation is crisp and well structured, and kept me glued to the end(quite an achievement),
the male anchors need a stylist or atleast a good shave/trim.
The dudette is just too good.
The colors look crisp and video has pretty good dynamic range
The wireless mic mess at 3:04 is either due to a phone in the anchor's pocket or another wireless mic beaming on the same frequency.
The adrupt VO at 5:00 just doesn't match. You could've got the anchor herself to do the VO in similar outdoor settings.
Overall a great presentation.
Subscribed!
Today i learnt 1 thing subscriber count is not the parameter of good channel...superb video.totally awesome
Dipayan Dutta welcome
Bought a DZIRE ZXI+ today..
And its too good😍
Nice presentation!!
What about safety.....which one is good
You ppl are good keep it up frends
Sir,Can you plz make a comparison video between Honda City diesel vs Hyundai verna diesel MT....
U should have included Figo aspire in this comparison..it's way better than Tiago, built well and seems to be value for money
Loved your video , only one request buddy can you please mute that background music shut or lower the volume much low so that we can hear you guys more clear.
Should have chosen Petrol Variant as TIGOR diesel engine is underpowered and no match to competition.
Petrol is more balanced and better looking with diamond cut alloy wheels.
Apne petrol varint liya hai...kya petrol varint shi work kr rha hai
utkarsh katiyar
Yes.. bought in June, car runing fine. Loving it have no qualm..
Is it good to by before Diwali or now
And tata tigor/Celerio cng/petrol/ignis? Tigor bec of looks
5members in 4months goes Chandigarh to hissar
I m a teacher so kam he chalna hota.
Very important you missed about mentioning the leg room
Thanks for the video guys .. Some quick suggestions - Too loud music .. and background noise is way too high (above acceptable level) .. camera quality seems pretty cheap ..
Tigor is definitely winner because it's made to medile class indian family
comparison of cars
way of speaking
way of design video
such a awesome anchors
Superb video brother
You missed Tata zest..it's best segment in Tata..one of the best for highways..
Which is one is best ameo or dezire.... Petrol.... Plz revert
Plz work on bgm its dominating the voice while they were presenting.
Tigor k sath wo driver bhi aati hai kya ??
where is honda amaze and the new excent??
its hard to decide between tigor n dzire.....rocking presentation dudes!!!
Good one! All 3 of you did well.
Can you be straight forward and plz tell me which car should i go for Ameo or Tigor? Service cost I can afford. But I want it for longitivity and looks . And I have drove Ameo . I am satisfied with it's power . Plz answer. And yes I need rear seat comfort. Comfortably 3 people should sit.
Have money ? Go for Ameo TDI DSG
Not enough money ? Go for Tata Tigor. Best value for money proposition.
Have too much money to buy shit? Dzire😁
Wait, want something between Tigor & Ameo? Aspire is the best option out there.
manoj saritha Get into a VW. Feel the fit & finish and then try driving a VW TDI or one with a DSG, you'll know what I'm talking about. It worked for me, sure it'll work for you:)
sharath budannavar Hi Sharath, today only I sat inside a Dzire ZDI+ AMT and must say that the finish and the materials quality was top notch. The cabin was airy and pleasing. MS has surely churned out a winner here!
Athul Krishna It all comes down to personal preferences. I personally like a solid build, good engine. Hate for MS is because they throw safety to air when it comes to bringing cars to India. Not talking about ABS & Airbags, there's more to safety than just airbags, ABS. When MS brings any car to India, they almost strip it to nothing to bring down costs.. Imagine, petrol variant of DZire weighs 860 kgs! That surely might will help them show good mileage figures but it's coming at the cost of lives...
Athul Krishna The reason why a VW fan would never prefer a MS is simply because of the level of satisfaction. You drive a MS you are happy, you drive a VW you are blessed. That's the difference.
Again safety is a bigger concern with MS here.
I have seen one myself as a ciaz hit an amaze in the back on Meerut highway ended up minor paint job to the of amaze against an entire bonnet and hood replacement for ciaz.
Athul Krishna yea sure. No argue with that
Nice bgm .. I can hear only that
Good review, specially the lady's voice is the best I'd seen so far in auto reviews
Wait. Dzire is built ground up? And not based on a hatchback swift??
Horrible. You don't talk about safety. Dzire weighs only850 kg. How about crash test scoring
Selva Kumar weight has little to do with safety. F1 cars weigh even lesser but are safe after a crash even at 200+ kmph. Material science has improved a lot and we are no longer in the 80s. We'll cover safety too in detail in the next comparo. Time constraints limit us.
Selva clearly you are not from science back ground....
Arpit Mahendra Don't compare the complex technology behind in formula one car with plastic shit maruti Suzuki
I didn't compare, just made a reference to highlight that weight alone does not make a car safe/ unsafe.
Rightly said! The common perception is that heavier the car, the safer it is, which as you pointed out is completely wrong. The idea of bringing in F1 cars was just to highlight that light cars aren't unsafe.
Great reviwe but music is too high plz keep it low in your future reviwes
Dzire's front reminds one of the Ambassador? I doubt that! But what it does remind me of the Ford grill which itself was inspired from Aston.
You forget one important person in this party...Ford Aspire...
Aspire doesn't sell well. So it can be avoided. Ford needs to works on its service provided by dealers in 2 nd and 3rd tier cities.
R u joking.. anyways ur vedio ur review...:)
Not my video dude....hahahaha. I am just here to comment.
and yeah Aspire doesn't sell coz service is poor. What is the joke?
Incognito Juggernaut
so wat it ford doesnt sell.btw how much does tigor sell??
super enjoyed video
Mileage of tigor in city?
i20 vs Dzire (petrol) which is best?
What about figo aspire!!
nice review
Great job
good work guys
It would be better if you also talk about the Safety Features each car is offering because they play a major role in emergencies
No sir, you are WRONG when you mentioned what you did at 9:08 . People line up at maruti showrooms blindfolded. They do not care what the car is. They just know that a workshop 5 meters from their homes will fix it, deti kitna hai, that the service cost is one of the lowest, and that it is a MARUTI !!!! And Suzuki better live up to this expectation as I feel they are not doing their bit recently and looking more towards how to rake in more money.... I recently drove Ignis.... all that hype..... and it felt like a tall Alto.... Just that moment made me realize what Suzuki is doing in India..... and why not, public ko C bana lo wo banti bhi hai .....
Vishal Prakash I saw a ford collided with old swift desire ... ford was marginally damaged where 0.1 mm steel sheet chutiya maker suzuki was totalled.
Maruti is most deadly in its segment 😅
what was other wise a good review was affected by the loud background music that should have been reduced a notch when the explanations are being given, which affected the hesitant and less fluid reviews by Arpit and Dipayan... hope to see lesser 'loud' reviews in the future! All the best guys!
You should also consider Hyundai xcent and Honda amaze
Is this music video
Why is music so loud amd continuous
You need to cut the background music to ensure audio quantity