Automated and easy 3D scanning with OpenScan Mini - Guide and test
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 06. 2024
- Check out my 2nd channel, TT Racing: / @ttracingyt
UDPATE: Article from OpenScan addressing the discussion in the comments about whether or not this is Open Source: www.openscan.eu/post/is-opens...
A 3D scanning photogrammetry rig that automates image capture and post processing, for free, and open source! It sounds too good to be true, but based on my testing it’s not. After you purchase the hardware kit, everything is free.
I’m not a patient person when it comes to prep for painting or 3D scanning, so the fact that my results were impressive tells you that this product is easy to use for almost everyone.
Most of this hardware was provided free of charge by OpenScan for the purpose of making this video. It was tested in accordance with my review policy. All opinions expressed are my own. teachingtechyt.github.io/revi...
I was so impressed by OpenScan, I made a donation here: www.buymeacoffee.com/openscan
0:00 Introduction
0:50 Types of 3D scanning
3D scanning comparison video: • 3D scanning + 3D print...
1:48 What is the OpenScan Mini?
OpenScan website: en.openscan.eu/
OpenScan GitHub: github.com/OpenScan-org
OpenScan documentation: openscan-org.github.io/OpenSc...
3:02 Hardware purchasing options and unboxing
4:28 Firmware preparation
5:14 Printed parts
6:09 Assembly
6:39 First run and tour
7:42 How to achieve best results
OpenScan photogrammetry guide: openscan-org.github.io/OpenSc...
AESUB Blue 3D scanning spray: core-electronics.com.au/aesub...
9:55 3D scanning workflow
Meshmixer: meshmixer.com
Meshmixer 3D scan clean up tutorial: • How to clean up 3D sca...
13:11 Other 3D scan results
15:37 Strengths and weaknesses
OpenScan Patreon: / openscan
18:04 Conclusion
Models scanned in this video:
3DBenchy - www.3dbenchy.com
Orc chief bust - www.myminifactory.com/object/...
Nature's Wrath - Genir Ancients Bundle - www.myminifactory.com/object/...
Teaching Tech Makercoin - www.printables.com/model/1801...
Buy quality and affordable filament from X3D. Buy 3, get 1 free and a free sample pack with every order: www.x3d.com.au
Get Quality Resins from 3D Printers Online. 5% off storewide for Teaching Tech subscribers [Code: tech5]
3dprintersonline.com.au/
Take a look around and if you like what you see, please subscribe.
Support me on Patreon: / teachingtech
THE CLOUD SERVICE IS OPTIONAL!
Honestly, I'm very frustrating reading so many comments saying the cloud service is a deal breaker for them. In the video I explained that you can download the files from the pi and process them locally, which I did for every part for comparison. The cloud service is fantastic, but the scanner 100% works without it.
UPDATED articled from OpenScan: www.openscan.eu/post/is-openscan-an-open-source-project
If I watched this video 4 years ago, I probably wouldn't have known that it was possible to connect two devices over LAN through a web browser.
I would have thought that the scanner was sending your images to the cloud, and your browser was downloading those images back off the cloud.
It would be nice if they gave you the option to run a desktop OS on the PI, so you can plug in a screen and mouse, and manually move the files to a USB storage device. That way people could use this who are uncomfortable with networking or who don't have access to a WiFi network. (and maybe they already did and I just didn't research it thoroughly enough)
@@WindyLion You don't have to use their pre-prepared Pi image. Instructions are given for those who want to start with their own os and install the components necessary for the canner. So what you are saying should be possible.
Then it would have benefited you to be more clear about that.
that’s awesome! I am planning on getting one after your video, the cloud service wouldn’t have bothered me too much but knowing it’s local is even better!
everyone should support these open source projects
You’re also missing the point. If the cloud software is 50% better than all other competing packages then you’re basically forced to use the cloud service. It is weird because dude is t selling it. Is’t charging for it. But refuses to give you that software to run locally. Quite frankly, puts me off donating. “I’ll make everything open source, except for the one critical piece that actually works better than everybody else’s software.” 👎 That he doesn’t even realize this is very strange. Or, get ready for subscription lock-in in a year.
'After you got the hardware, it's completely free to use.' 20 years ago nobody would understand this sentence.
And the same will ring true in 20 years
I only Trust this sentence once the "Cloud" part also becomes Open source. No Cloud runs free.
@@David-ty6mycloud is optional, run something yourself if you want
@@David-ty6my Ollama AI will run on a Pi5, no internet needed, yippee. "I don't need your cloud, I have my own" someone soon.
20? Hell it’s yesterday already and I still don’t understand it 🤷♂️
Michael, thank you so much for bringing our scanner to a wider audience in a very understandable way. As a former teacher myself, I know of the difficulty of breaking down a complex topic without missing any details; you absolutely nailed that! I will definitely forward this video to our collaborating schools as a great introduction to the subject!
are there differences in the Classic vs Mini scanner aside from the size and the polarizer module? I want to buy one but I'm not entirely sure which to get
@@alksmdlaksin short: mini is much easier to start with, classic is more versatile and larger scanning volume. but both use the same parts/firmware (except for printed parts), so you could switch to the other version at any time
@openscan_eu Should I wait for the Mini v2 version, or does it look like the Mini V1 will be a "compatible" kit which can be upgraded to v2?
also can I use any camera or is the machine made in a way that incorporates these small cameras. would there be a way to use something like a mirrorless camera
@@alksmdlaksyes, the classic version can be used with almost any camera! Many dslr can directly be used through USB or via remote wired triggering
I find that mixing Non-Talc Baby Powder (50%) with Iso. Alcohol (50%) in a small spray bottle makes a good DIY spray for scanning. The alcohol evaporates, leaving just the powder, and that wipes off really easily.
great tip!
Yep, that's what I use and it works pretty well
Alcohol and electricity... 😮
@@cyberlaurent2101 What electricity?
As someone who's been making his own photogrammetry scan rigs I would say that this is quite a nice overall product. There are a lot of things you can improve on in workflow and a few things that could (and I think should) be changed in the hardware/software and proposed workflow for this rig.
Generally though: If you have the polariser add-on you should use it. And only use that. Turn off all other lights, as the main point of the polariser is to get rid of reflections. Other lights won't help since they don't turn with the model any ways. You're actually making it worse by having changing light situations over the model + you create more reflections that aren't polarized. The ring light will light the model as flat as it can so you don't end up with shadows and you get the overall best surface texture. Depending on your model and the color, scanning sprays are not always the best option. You can do much of the same with fine powders and a soft brush (baby powder, flour, etc). Reflections have been taken care of by the polariser, so what you want the spray or powder for is creating detail on the model - and that works best with a mix of coarse and fine details. Scanning sprays tend to be very even but can work at small scales like that.
Also, ideally for turntable scans, you want to get rid of any background details. The lack of depth of field in this tiny scale helps the software to not take any background details as tracking sources but ideally you would want a black background. The arm could be modified to hold a black matte surface that rotates with it and thus always makes sure the background won't be caught by the software.
Polarizers are super helpful for soldering with a microscope as well, it's truly revolutionary how much better the image looks with one installed
@@FowlerAskew That's true, though depending on the joints it can be helpful to see the highlights on the tin to see the shape of the joint. I did have cross polarisation on my microscope for a while but for smd stuff I find it easier to see cold joints without.
There’s a dome addon that can be printed to block light and serve as an uniform background. It’s very useful.
@@DisruptingScanner Good to know, thanks for the pointer :)
Last year my daughter was in a trampoline accident and broke her two front teeth(one was embedded so deep in her friend's skull they had to use a tool to pull it out) which has led to a whole host of issues including needing a "flipper"(a partial denture). She recently had to get it replaced and instead of doing impressions like before they did a 3D scan. The machine they used was a photogrametry machine and it was honestly amazing.
It was using the camera on a positionally tracked wand to take dozens of pictures a second creating model of her mouth live. They scanned her top and bottom teeth making two separate models then they scanned the front of teeth with them closed and it used that third model to combine the previous two models into a full model of her mouth with her correct "bite". The whole process took maybe 10 minutes and was much easier than doing impressions. It's also going to be ready faster and the dentist said most everyone says they fit better too.
Thanks for sharing this amazing story. Sorry to hear about your daughter's accident.
Friends don't bite friends
Oh I used that before. I think it's made by Straumann right? It's an extremely expensive setup though. Costs about $15,000 and $5,000 per year. The dentist I was working for ended up selling it though because traditional plaster molding is actually faster and more accurate. The only dentists who use them are the ones who don't have the skill to do the traditional way because in dental school now they aren't teaching how to save teeth but how to extract the most money. So the standards are significantly lower than two decades ago where you could not graduate unless you knew how to do it correctly manually.
@@newolde1 Well you know how relationships go, sometimes they just go up and down
Getting impressions suck as a kid, had to get a retainer in the 80s and ended up puking on the dentist from him taking the mold. So it's great to hear they have a better process now, more convenient for the kids and saves the dentist too
Years ago, after watching some of your content, I bought my first printer-a Creality CR-10. You taught me how to upgrade every part, and later, I bought a Sidewinder X2 and a FLSun delta and fearlessly tinkered with them, Klipper firmware and all. I built a Prusa Mini clone and, after that, a Voron 2.4. Along the way, you taught me some 3D modeling and recently inspired me to build this project. These parts were printed on my Bambu X1C, but I know any of the aforementioned printers would have handled the job with aplomb after all of the refinings. I value every hour that I've spent following your content. Thank you for all you do.
Absolutely fantastic results with fraction of the cost of other units. Great job by the developers.
My profession is foundry model making and this is one of the best 3D printing channels.
4 years ago you made that video that reached me how to print.
Thanks for keep making good quality videos!
Honestly, these results are absolutely astonishing. Normally 3D scanning anything with holes is just not going to work out great. So the fact you got the benchy and various figurines to such astonishing detail even with holes and features hiding behind features is nothing short of mindblowing. I've owned multiple Einscan scanners that costs thousands of dollars each. I tried scanning a key recently and despite trying baby powder mix, it just couldn't accurately get the details of the key. I think the key, if you will excuse the pun, is this Openscan mini's ability to automate the imaging in all angles with a camera that rotates, where as myt Einscan is still turntable based with a fixed camera. Of course I did do multiple passes by manually repositioning the object, but humans are lazy, and after a few positions, I just don't want to keep doing it. So this Openscan's automatically moving camera is brilliant.
I would be interested in you testing various scanning spray alternatives, since as you pointed out, AESUB is very expensive.
I have been using the OpenScan Mini for about two years, and I can attest to its greatness! I recommend printing the black half-sphere to get even better results! Excellent product!!
"black half-sphere"? 🤔
You mean the non reflective material?
Sounds amazing, some very clever people out there giving there time freely to come up with this stuff. They are to be commended.
Story of my life: finally have a epic workstation at home -> everything goes cloud based 😂
@@tomaszkarwik6357 then i should look in to it more, didn't find that when i tried to rtfm
Cool! I really appreciate your hard work in presenting this! Thanks so much and keep up the good work Michael.
Glad you enjoyed it!
Thanks a bunch, Michael! Really interesting process indeed!!! 😃
Stay safe there with your family! 🖖😊
that sounds pretty neat, thanks for showcasing the project!
Wow, great video as always.
Impressive project ❤
Thanks for sharing your experience with All of us👍😀
Great results! I will definitely be trying the larger version when it is done.
This is insanely good results, especially for an open and relatively cheap solution. Can't believe its so much better than most of the consumer grade products currently available.
Amazing product. Great review thanks for putting this video together.
Wow, this video came at just the right time for me! Definitely going to get one of these
I’ve used the Mini with Agisoft Metashape and the results are amazing. Highly recommended!
Very interested in building something like this would probably need to pair it with a much larger design as some objects I work with are up to 220mm tall. Will keep an eye out for the midi and his other designs. Very impressed with the tech and product.
Well done Michael and the creator of the Openscan
Wow, best scans that I have seen for a hobby scanner. It is a bit too small for my needs. but as you say they are working on a larger unit. So, keep us informed if you get to try out the bigger scanner. Thank you for sharing with us.
Thanks for the great summary. I’m incredibly impressed by the results!
This looks great! I've played with photogrammetry a little bit but this looks like a superb option for the small parts i want to scan.
I like that you added ‘in accordance with my review policy’ to show full disclosure. Unlike many many reviews these days that are ‘influenced’ by the company requesting the ‘honest’ review. I bought the Einstar and I am about to loose my patience with it scanning small things (yes I know its not for small things), and this may be an alternative solution for smaller items such as plugs etc for cars.
I think this is an incredible project, thanks for bringing it to my attention. I'll probably wait for the larger version, but definitely interested to get one in the future.
I seem to remember that the Raspberry Pi cameras take a second or two to auto focus before taking an image. That might explain some of the lag between adjusting a setting and seeing the result in the preview
Thanks for the quick but thorough review. This looks like a nice tool to have next to the 3D printer. I think I'll order me a kit :)
This is very cool! I’m inspired to purchase this kit!
Incredible results!!!
I ran across the OpenScan a couple weeks ago but thought the scan volume was a little small. It's good to see they are working on a larger version.
Great video, thanks for the investigation. Fantastic news on the progress of Photogrammetry when used with a setup like this. That's really impressive.
This is what I'm thinking. Finally, you did it. This will motivate me to improve my project also.
Fantastic video buddy, delivered really well with a good amount of engaging content. It ended without me even realising I had watched for that long. Great work 👏 👍
this is going to start another revolution like reprap did. Great job!
Awesome scannning what a marvel ofndesign
i used to operate an industrial 3d scanner (rexcan 4) & im impressed by the level of details openscan mini can deliver ! awsome for home projects
Ive been looking for a cheap scanning option for so long, thx teaching tech.
Thanks for sharing Michael!
This is the first 3d scanner (that I've seen) that really copy with cirurgical precision and doesn't cost a lot
Very nice project!
Thanks for showing it.
very good glimpse into DIY 3D Scanning with the help of 3D printing!!!
Thanks for the great review.
Thomas has done a wonderful job of the scanner. I would buy one if I needed a scanner.
Truly amazing fine details with the Pi camera
Just bought one because of your video.
I’ve been using an OpenScan Mini for about a year now to scan small figures (1/32 and 1/24 scale) and it’s outstanding. I paint everything Tamiya flat Hull Red (XF-9) and dust lightly with foot powder (Lotrimin spray can) and use it in low light conditions...it’s flawless! The software is modestly finicky but nothing too hard to work around. All things considered I love it and highly recommend it.
How does a red base coat compare to black out of curiosity?
I definitely need this in my life! I've been looking for a use for my spare Pi.
It’s so small and cute. I run a CT scanner so I love these videos. I have a Metrotom 1500 and an 800.
I've been wanting to build one of these for a while now and got excited to see your video on it, I was hopefull that you would show where we could source all the parts cheap and within Aussie. Thx for the video though, confirms that the scanner is capable for what I want to use it for.
it is awesome, I am still with the classic version, pretty happy
This looks fun to build.
Those were some really good results. I'm kinda tempted to get one for myself but I probably don't have any use for such a small scanning area. I usually need to scan bigger surfaces to fit prints in.
I am following the subject of photogrammetry for a couple of years now and the quality of the scanned objects shown here is really among the BEST you can find out there. I am absolutely surprised! The only drawback is that it only scans relatively small objects.
an exciting project that should be tested further and further
Very good video!
Photogrammetry can be really incredible with the right camera and lens.
A larger version would be really interesting.
If you did a review on that, I’d definitely watch it.
Thanks for all of your efforts.
🇦🇺🍀🤜🏼🤛🏼😎☮️
I made one a couple of years ago (video on my channel) which does a similar thing with an Arduino - obviously nowhere near as professional as this as it was just for personal use, and tbh this really impresses me. Small objects close to the camera can be a right pain, especially the lighting, but this seems to combat that quite well. Yeah, good stuff!
Wow, very impressed.
just an idea to optimze the scan of tube parts, shown in the video. tilt it 30-45 degrees on that sticky subtance. i think then the reflections are good for the scan, because they are moving now. i never tested it, but its worth a try
Well that just seems awesome!
I often find myself looking into 3d scanning by never end up pulling the trigger on a setup to scan with. After watching this I'm reminded of how many times object size is an issue for my needs. I often want to scan a smaller part of something larger. It got me thinking about some sort of photogrammetry drone or robot that could move the camera around and object to provide images from as many angles as needed. Like DJI drones have with being able to orbit and object by setting a midpoint and a distance from that point to orbit. With options like half circle or semicircle I think I could capture all the angles I would want without getting the issues I typically do with attempting a hand help photogrammetry scan.
One day I will be able to scan something I need to make a part conform to. I'm not sure yet if it will be photogrammetry or some sort of ir/laser scan yet. The prices are getting more in the range of my hobby interest these days though.
For precise slider control in the Openscan software, click on the slider ball and then use the left and right arrows on your keyboard to move a single step at a time.
I was looking at this in the past and wasn't sure how realistic their claims were.
Turns out pretty realistic, I just wish I could host the software on my hardware.
W0w is right! Incredible!
Such a cool video. Do you think we'll be able to 3D print prescription glasses? That would be amazing.
Awsome. I want one, now !
I've been very interested in scan software and component as a scultor. Being able to scan the things I make and scale up or down as needed with the geometry would be a very nice tool to have.
There's some really clever people in this world
Been eyeing something like this off for a while, just moved house, my workshop/lair is still being sorted. I do have the old xbox one and xbox 360 scanners too, with their PC adapter cables and the microsoft SDKs.
Amazing! This looks like my next project, one thing I didn’t get is how is the processing happens ? I mean does it matter if i use cloud vs local processing, how to do the local processing, this project is what we print for tbh its amazing
Recognized that camera instantly. Perfect timing, got my Pi5 yesterday so I have a spare Pi4 now. Now if only I had a 3D filament printer. Got a resin printer, can I print a filament one?
wow... just wow!
Okay after doing some digging. Anybody who's turned off this project because of the raspberry pi part. Just do the open scan regular version. it works with smartphones DLSRs and a raspberry pi camera. Not to mention it's just bigger
Not sure if mentioned elsewhere, but gold bond or other shoe/foot spray works well for only a few dollars. We use it in our metrology lab for any high gloss parts.
It's a shame that everything is a cloud service these days, but otherwise this is a really cool product
I totally agree, but we keep the cloud optional, as there are several free and paid offline photogrammetry options available. As part of our core philosophy we won’t sell out nor charge for the free/donation based cloud service at any point. We already have a couple of years under our belt and scalability is already implemented :)
@@openscan_eu Unfortunately, that's what every service says right up until the day they start charging. Nobody admits it ahead of time.
@@AndyLundellthis service has been running since ~2021 and I am happy to be reminded of my statements in 10 years ;)
@@openscan_euare private donations enough for bandwidth and CPU time, or is there external funding from corporate sponsors? Feels like this would be a lot of data to crunch through, and cloud servers don't run for free.
Minor correction. Shutter speed is inversely proportional to brightness. You'll notice the Shutter setting in the interface is measured in milliseconds. So decreasing that value is actually increasing the shutter speed thereby making the scene darker because the sensor is exposed for less time.
Thats amazing. Im building one.
Awesome!
I loved the video
great video.. i have been looking at this system for a while as i use a lot of scanners.. but since i 3d print items.. its a shame you had the textures on.. as they do not show the true model.. would love a little update of the models shown without the textures.. i would only save the textures if i was going to use them as a displacement map to use in ztool to add details to a model.. but still an interesting video i have used a lot of photogrammetry in the past. now tend to use structured light. etc but i also like the idea of plug and play.. its all the setting up that puts me of getting one. :)
I think I like this enough to want to try it. Aside from the software issues that you mentioned, the only thing I noticed in this video, hardware related, is that when the part that moves the camera moves, it seemed a bit jerky. Did you notice this, and did this cause any issues??? GREAT VIDEO!!!!!!!!!
Extremely impressive results, really interested in the larger V2 option in the future.
I clearly understood the cloud features were optional by the way you distinctly and directly said it's optional and the output of the scanner can be processed locally on your own machine.
I feel like the people in the comments either A, didn't watch the video, or B, are just being snobs about the fact that this guy isn't giving away for free that one component.
I will absolutely be building a V2 of this if the build volume suits my needs.
The classic version of the scanner suits larger models of up to 18x18x18 cm and can be modded to fit even larger models
@@openscan_eu thanks for the reply, I'll look into this and measure up what I have that I would like to scan!
I would be very interested in a larger version for scanning automotive components such as interior trim.
Impressive
I appreciate this detailed review. I use photogrammetry, 3DF Zephyr Lite, to scan plaster casting of baby hands and feet for bereaved families that lost a baby. I then 3D print more durable copies they can hold and share. I'm very interested in this project and how it might allow other volunteers like me to scan molds for families where they live. I am limited geographically to working with local families because I simply don't want people shipping me their irreplaceable molds, rather I do in person dropoffs. I'll definitely be testing this project for an affordable solution, whereas my investment in photogrammetry has me well into thousands spent on computer, camera, and 3D printing equipment.
Feel free to reach out directly and we can definitely talk about options for your very interesting project.
It will be interesting to try this with the autofocus camera, I got one but never used it and it seems depth of field can be an issue reading the blog. Will be interesting to see where this project goes with the Pi5 having two camera inputs. Hmm I think I need another Pi5, too bad the 1- 2GB ones are not ready yet.
Résultats incroyables ! Bravo et merci pour cette decouverte.
Babe, wake up. Teaching tech dropped a new video
I'm curious about the meshroom use. Since the indexing of the file names seem to represent the position of the camera and angle of rotation for the turn table could this meta data be fed into it for more accurate reconstruction so it's not trying to calculate the camera positions and angles?
Theoretically, you could use the positions to skip the alignment step in the software (which is only ~1-5% of total reconstruction time). The problem lies in the accuracy as the measured coordinates are far off the calculated (through photogrammetry), latter are within 0.01mm or less. Ah and the scanner does not know its position in the current form.
Looks neat, though I have no idea what to use it for.
Need a rig like this to scan HO scale trains and rolling stock. I’ve had no luck getting the ones on my iPhone to come out as good as these.
We've got to be so close now to combining hardware like this to an AI system that will vastly improve the results.
That's my hope at least. I'll be making one of these regardless to see what it can do.
Your key results look awesome. Did you print it to see if it worked? (haven't finished the video yet so apologies if you showed that.)
Thanks as always for your very clear descriptions and instructions.
We could use several fields to scan or a single scanner with multiple integrated sensors so the differences can be used and combined to make a better model. Like an electron microscope that uses the electrons to create a field, scanning the object, taking the differences and creating a model. Could just use magnetic fields and tune the sensitivity.
Surprised this worked so well. It wobbles so much when the arm is moving but that does not seem to impact the final product. I would guess it waits long enough for vibratins to stop before the pic is taken. How long is the scanning process for the default number of pics?
Any idea if schematic and gerber files for those boards are available? Or what sort of linear polarisation filter is needed? Without that, it's not really open source ;)
BluTak is potentially an unappreciated tool for DIY. Juanito Moore turned me on to using it to hold parts for soldering. I love it for "helping hands" applications.
Is there a time-line for the MIDI version? The mini will be to small for my use, but I definitely be onboard when the maximum size will increase.
Should there be ringlight around camera for good and equal lightning?
I'm looking forward to the larger scanner. Most of the stuff I need to scan is around 4 inches long.