All private employee’s should form an employee union. We should identify a union leader at state level to voice out our concerns- - extra working hours, work life balance, equal pay parity, Tax burden, employment opportunities, skill based trainings and leads should be discussed. This way we will be able to form a group to respond back strongly to gov of india - Please remember things wont change when you vote out BJP the newly elected party will continue to harass in the same way -Finance minister should be answerable to tax payers on spends - Its we who pay them and its we who should take charge of even a penny to the govt.
Don't blame her. If someone makes me a Finance Minister, why would I say no? So it's not her fault. Ask why such ministers are selected. Apart from 2-3 (Goyal, Gadkari etc.) remaining 20 ministers are useless. If you disagree, show me what they have done in 10 years. Can you show?
@@SanjayGopi-nc9sk for people like you. common man is starving. So the comment prevails: Taxes are imposed like Developed countries but the quality of life and expenses are like Somalia
Our most responsible finance minister Mrs Nirmala Sitaraman, when she's asked about Onion price rise she said that she's not coming from the family which consumes onion and garlic, when she's been asked why the GST for foods and restaurant are high she said why you people are eating in the restaurant plz have your own cooked in your homes. When she's been asked why the gas cylinder prices were high she said if you cant afford LPG eat from the restaurants. Very much committed to the citizens of our nation India
What are you talking about when Modi Government has made progress on massive infrastructure developments and made India 5th economic power and this shows ignorance on things done by Modi from warfare schemes,free nations building many toilets and Look at roads and New railways and Metros and Nehru even did not built toilets
@@kishorraja370Infrastructure? Say collapsing infrastructure.Newly built Parliament building Ram Mandir are leaking. Bridges are collapsing in under construction stage. Just image what would have happened if these were to collapse after opening to public..And toilets ? You have to pay even to relieve yourself and thank the FM that GS T has not been levied on this service. And ,5th bigger economy. ??Do you think a 300 - kg obese person living on 5 kg free rations is healthy?? Have a look at our bulging foreign debt financing our so called lopsided development.
@@narayanathota4318 but you are not comparing with past under Nehru Gandhi dynasty and what they had done was seen until Modi improved India to 5th economic power with massive infrastructure developments and people elect leader on developments and delivery so you have to understand democracy.And Modi will make 3rd economic power.What did Nehru was blunder on China and Kashmir policies.His dynasty following socialism destroyed India and Narshima Rao and Manmohan Singh came with new economic policies and Modi strengthened it when India massively improved
The problem with most elected reps is that they cringe before you for your votes. After the election, they don't care for you. It is as simple as that. But then, pride comes before a fall. If you continue your arrogance, a fall is imminent and you won't know what hits you when it hits you. About unelected reps, please remember Manmohan Singh was unelected rep and he did a pretty good job, considering the various pulls and pressures from within his own party and from the Opposition. The fact is if you are honest and you have a GOOD HEART, it doesn't matter if you are elected or unelected
Honesty is good and all but when ur making decisions for a billion people u should be 'capable' Nirmala is not even qualified for this fm role Manmohan Singh did a good job as a finance minister because that's what he's good at but he was terrible pm I would rather choose subramani from bjp itself as finance minister rather than Nirmala sitaraman
Above all , any minister , would be good and honest only if they have a humility to feel responsible to people who have a democratic right to question them . Both BJP as a party and their ministers are arrogant and lack the basic humility to accept their blunders , which are multiplying by the day .
I 100% agree with you. Have been finding it really hard to understand why arrogant and ignorant people can be FMs now. She should be immediately removed.
People of India a extremely timid to protest against such a draconian rule... We should take a lesson or two from the brave students and public who are currently protesting against the fascist rule in Bangladesh
When Kalam was President. People were criticizing why someone needs that many skills to be president. At the end the colour of cat doesnt matter to catch a rat😂
This is true, instead of this FM, we can make good beuracrat. Useless FM who cannot sense the feeling of normal people, only work for PM and Elite people.
Don't blame her. If someone makes me a Finance Minister, why would I say no? So it's not her fault. Ask why such ministers are selected. Apart from 2-3 (Goyal, Gadkari etc.) remaining 20 ministers are useless. If you disagree, show me what they have done in 10 years. Can you show?
Idiot he is pm and pm cannot be elected. Pm is selected by winning party with most MPs U may ask wt about modi. He voluntarily stood as mp in varanasi He was elected as mp of varanasi not as pm. Once bjp alliance got more votes than india bloc, only then the entire nda alliance unanimously chose modi as pm. Its a personal choice whether to stand as mp or pm. Sitaraman was just fm She has to be responsove to people, as she is fm fpr all 140 crore people She comes from ruling party Ruling party is answerable to people While addressing people, u have to be polite and understanding Sitaraman is anything but kind (far detached from reality, very rude) This kindness is possible only when you are elefted by people or you are connected tp ground reality, met people before and heard their woes like how rahul gandhi did in bharat jodo yatra. Nirmala doesnt have such qualities.
He was an Economics expert, unlike the former sales girl. Manmohanji expertise Economics from the same country where the present FM worked as sales girl. 😀
Absolutely Doctor, hats off to you to speak for the emotions of people of india in a public forum like this..fms unfit for the position..God only can save the nation..
Don't blame her. If someone makes me a Finance Minister, why would I say no? So it's not her fault. Ask why such ministers are selected. Apart from 2-3 (Goyal, Gadkari etc.) remaining 20 ministers are useless. If you disagree, show me what they have done in 10 years. Can you show?
Very very true. You just spoke your heart, and I can definitely relate, boss. The attitude of hers is the blocker here and it will get us nowhere unless she is changed.
Very interesting video from your end.. As a senior citizen of India of aged 68 now....and being a tax payer for last 40 years... I did not know I can balance my ITR in a coloring book until I retired with no benefit for next few years of my living. Government has made almost all digitalized, but as a senior citizen it's nothing works when required. My suggestion..... As a tax payer let govt give freebies in insurance on motor vehicle, toll tax, life time tax extended on vehicles personally owned. With GST introduction life has become very costlier. As a middle man cannot buy site of 1000 swift for less than one crrore in metros and 50 lakhs in villages.... Everyday the pulse rice cereals vegetables fruits rates are touching per kg 200.oo and fifty rupees and 100 ruppes notes are vanishing....
She is the scapegoat of the modi government.Modiji knows it best.The people who suffers may not he voting..the uneducated and poor dont have to worry due to new tax rules..they were anyway suffering, without even realising..
Unelected PM where ruling the country from 2004-2014.. Point is not about it, who could understand layman's issues should come as a Finance minister...
Do u know his qualification ? He was a senior lecturer of economics at Panjab University from 1957 to 1959. He served as a reader in economics at Panjab University from 1959 and 1963,and from 1963 to 1965, he was an economics professor there He went to work for the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) from 1966 to 1969. Later, he was appointed as an advisor to the Ministry of Foreign Trade in recognition of his talent as an economist. From 1969 to 1971, he was a professor of international trade at the Delhi School of Economics, University of Delhi. In 1972, he was chief economic adviser in the Ministry of Finance, and in 1976 he was secretary in the Finance Ministry. In 1980-1982 he was at the Planning Commission, In 1982- 1985, he was appointed governor of the Reserve Bank of India . He went on to become the deputy chairman of the Planning Commission (India) from 1985 to 1987. Following his tenure at the Planning Commission, he was secretary general of the South Commission, an independent economic policy think tank headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland from 1987 to November 1990. He returned to India from Geneva in November 1990 and held the post as the advisor to Prime Minister of India on economic affairs In 1991, he became chairman of the University Grants Commission.
You have rightly said, bhayya. FM is not from people, doesn't feel the pain of the middle class. She behaves as if she came from a far away land from India and above all hates common people. God save India for another 5 years😢😢
God Bless You, Sir! No one describes like you describe! No any other psychologist like you on the whole planet Earth! Keep it up, Sir! Hope one day you will achieve your Red diamond button from youtube company!
able to feel people are feeling the heat and a strong sense of basic rights being tampered. Hope people likely minded will unite and rise sooner than before to avoid further unethical and barbaric acts by government. when is the time i think, its already high time.
Valid points. People should get right to pull back public reps. Every legislation and policy should go through all stakeholders. People should have ability to penalize public reps not just once in 5 years but more often. Pub reps should not go against people mandate. Like surprise policies and jumping parties AFTER getting elected. Lay down your intention and policies and affiliation ahead and stick with it else automatically pulled back. If you dont support the rajyasabha candidate, dont support those state reps who voted for that Rsaba member. The member might get thru via other state. But eventually they will get your point. All this may be practically not possible. But hope u get my drift
Incompetent people in high positions consider the power vested in them a perk. They, therefore, place themselves above others and lash out at their critics as a matter of prerogative. Our Hon. FM. Is following a long and cherished tradition.🍀
Sir I'm psychology in Tamil subscriber i will watch every video of you... where ever you post what ever the language is..... We will support you.. .keep doing..
Hard truth is that "Every finance minister will be mocked by the people after every budget" . It is not about Elected or selected whether BJP or congress.
Ok Mr. Sangi, I understand just going to schools won't make you educated. Political people can wash your mind anytime. Sangis are the best examples for this
True . Also The government always makes a budget according to people from whom it gets most of its votes . These new taxes are anyway not going to affect the lower middle class or poor category people, which vote the most .
Very apt and appropriate view.. The finance minister, when he/she holds the position, is totally responsible for the people of the country, irrespective of the categories and to satisfy the questions without any arrogance or superiority... She should also keep in mind that the entire nation will ask questions on every deed according to their needs every time... Here, whenever she is not able to satisfy the people' for their queries, may be blaming the predecessors or the earlier policies...that irks everyone...
PM is fake tea seller. He did not even sell tea, that is also a lie. The railway station where the PM was supposed to sell tea, was built after he left his hometown and he had joined the R S S. The railway station did not exist when he was a kid, it was built later.
I learned a lot of finance topics and got a lot of share market related knowledge from his free youtube videos, i think he severed more than enough to the society especially to psychology and finance in tamil.
@@Monashaa09 yes, good question, as a tax payer everyone has the rights to criticise FM( even as a citizen of india we have the rights), but guys like this sramasubramanian are attacking the question persons, i'm giving a polite answer also you can give slipper shot answers to these guys if you wish.
@@gnanadurai7900 we talk about common people whose tax burden is reduced comparing to last year. My opinion is not about people who buy and sell shares every minute based on his advice and expect zero taxation. By the way we understood your shit gutter back ground from your reply language.
Your Excellent comments are Highly appreciated Sir! Please bring your valuable comments to the CJI, Supreme Court! So, that we may get at least some justification. I respect your bold comments in the interest of of INDIAN Citizen. Sir, there is no genuine ministers including PM in BJP/RSS Persons. They don’t know the administration, except enjoying their lives with their family with INDIAN Government money with very luxurious. They are very much fond of their lifestyle with Govt. Money, The Minister and PM are least bothered to look after the welfare and their right in this Nation. There is no democracy except to pull the poor and real Scholars into in big troubles and years together in Tihar Jail with trial in the Court of Law. Police persons are under their full Custody and in their grip. They can not do their duty faithfully as per the Indian Constitutional Law., because these political power. Even SC & HC Judges are also afraid of Modi Power Politics. So No Justice to the poor and innocent people who were forced to be put in Tihar Jail either our any change sheet and Trials in the Court of Law. I am crying to see these worst administration against poor people and middle class people who were victimised by this governments.
I think you got it all wrong about indexation benefits - What FM has done is, the new system applicable for the people who bought houses after 2001 will attract 12.5% capital gain tax (which is less than the previous 20% tax with indexation) - So there are no much changes to whole taxation, but it is now streamlined across the border to all asset class, except for short term traders.
I don’t think you are right in saying 12.5% without indexation is less than 20% with indexation . Indexation table shows an increase of 5% every year. With LTCG lock in period of 2 years, my purchase price would have increased by 10% while my actual reduction in tax due to this new policy is only 7.5%. We end up paying more. Much worse, we end up paying taxes for our losses due to inflation if the appreciation of the property is not above the indexation line.
Everything happening in this world has a psychological perspective..... I believe if we are able to understand that, we can achieve far more good to the entire manhood....... Thank you Sir for bringing up this topic and giving a great msg "To be kind to people"
Hi Jitendra- I used to watch ur tamil channel. Today came across with this episode in English channel. Mostly agree with u except one point... either elected by people or by their representative, the Govt should understand people requirement.. there is a gap or once they elected they think worlds most powerful person and people should come forward understand the Govt's reforms... This is highly ridiculous... Unfortunately it's not reaching them
completely agree with you sir. it's stupidity to tell only elected person should become a minister. otherwise we wouldn't have got a greatest EAM of all time. also we know how our pseudo democracy works.
I hv just watched TMC mp Mohua moitra speech abut the budget 6Aug in loksabha. U are absolutely right. Shoddy job of budget by a incompetent mins. And a government insensitive to ppl. Educated ppl in India will also find a heroic solution like done Bangladesh I hope pray and wait.
I agree with that bro, but i mentioned one think in here its not depend on people elected or non elected for example we have one of the best foreigner minister mr jayshankar what about your concern about, i am not supporter of any party but i really like your confident and polite speach over this plotform,
@@srikanthsv79 No one wants indian citizenship except some people from India's poor neighbouring countries . I don't think this should be a point of outrage. Only dynasty politicians have their children in india , because their children will lead those dynasty parties in the future . Jaishankar is not a politician. He was the executive who is given the responsibility of FM
Very well put. Appreciate the fact that your video was respectful and not a troll video. There is a lot of anger and feeling of unjust in people like us. This will come out definitely but not in the shape of trolling but next elections.
Manmohan Singh had been the prime minister for ten years as a rajyasabha mp ( unelected representatives). But same people saying fm is not elected what a hypocrisy.
@@mastkalandar3200 yes , nirmala sitaraman budget is way more good than that of manmohan singh. She is brought india 3 trillion dollars economy , and protected economy during covid lockdown from recession , where even developed economies like uk , Germany faced recession like suitation . Its way more better than manmohan singh's LPG for imf loans.. its very lately happened.
For the person who earns less there is no much tax , in fact in new tax regime tax is reduced( most of the people are finding loop holes in old tax regime)
What about the indirect tax, we are not only paying taxes on our income. We also pay taxes @18-28% GST when we spend the remaining money after paying the income tax. In return we don't get quality Education and Healthcare, we need to go to Private. The Medical Inflation in India is 14% which means the cost of treatment and medicines goes up by a minimum of 14% every year. How can a middle class person afford it if everything is private but still have to pay high taxes?
You people are stealing our tax for more than 70 years and showing no results. If the state is stealing, then CAG should find out, but we are way ahead of you in many areas.
Not any opinions, you speak all the truth. But now who will hear and keeping it in our mind do the best in future . Nobody ,.... We all are nonsense........
Why do I want to compare? Are you middle class? If so, then you will understand the pain of this stupid budget. Even if we all paying such huge tax, we are not getting proper health care, water, roads, etc. On top of that, after I pay all tax and I invest or do savings, return on those also taxed. It's literally government is looting the public money in the name of tax.
An appointed FM without any banking and finance knowledge and without any responsibility to the electorate has ruined the banking economy and life of the people during the ten years of Modi's misrule..it is well explained
100% correct what I thought was the same from the mind of yours also. It looks like Nirmala ji is appointed as a financial head in a firm and she is doing favour her proprietor.
Do you Know Dr Manmohan Singh was selected and not elected as PM and FM previously short of memory by you Measure a person by performance it seems you are Narrow minded ok
@@srikantsubramanian4886 there is nothing wrong in paying taxes if you have capital gains. But, here in this case I have to pay tax for my loss if my property appreciated is below the indexation line. Would you call it smart taxation?
Valid points. People should get right to pull back public reps. Every legislation and policy should go through all stakeholders. People should have ability to penalize public reps not just once in 5 years but more often. Pub reps should not go against people mandate. Like surprise policies and jumping parties AFTER getting elected. Lay down your intention and policies and affiliation ahead and stick with it else automatically pulled back. All this may be practically not possible. But hope u get my drift
The politicians, elected or unelected, must maintain dignity, humility and human values. Degeneration of our value system due the unadulterated opportunism of our politicians is the bane of our democracy. You have rightly assessed the reality.
All elected people behaving correctly? Is anybody in our country electing the person based on their quality and capability? Please mind your words. She is our FM
Thank you even the same is in many peoples mind.she is not elected by people and the problem is she never gone to people and found the public opinions and their needs and feelings ,She is just like a professor who give his speech and just leave the gallery .they dose not bother about wheather they understood it or not.she is intelligent but not practical.may be she was guided by some norms. If she can understand people she will be the best.if not nation suffers in many ways.
For a change, personal corruption/ favouritism is not the issue for the last 10 years she has handled the ministry. First the nation should appreciate her for that, as even elected representatives have failed in the past. She is as good as her team which includes the party view.
Dear Friends, All your comments have been answered in my following videos. Let's keep the conversation going!
czcams.com/video/bfRfFcVMuQ0/video.html
All private employee’s should form an employee union. We should identify a union leader at state level to voice out our concerns- - extra working hours, work life balance, equal pay parity, Tax burden, employment opportunities, skill based trainings and leads should be discussed. This way we will be able to form a group to respond back strongly to gov of india
- Please remember things wont change when you vote out BJP the newly elected party will continue to harass in the same way
-Finance minister should be answerable to tax payers on spends
- Its we who pay them and its we who should take charge of even a penny to the govt.
If you are not a financial expert, please keep your mouth shut.
@@doraiswamir3011 One need not be an expert to air public grievances. Are ministers experts ? Anyone is becoming any minister in India.
you seem to be biased and therfore a fool
are u a crypto fraud pavadai ?
The way she answered to the people during floods in Tamil Nadu with arrogance people will never forget
She is enough to pull down whole BJP. She should speak more so everyone in India get irritated to the core
@@lakshmiebenBut andhbhakts are not so intelligent to know the reality behind these people.
Bro she is your lady I mean she belong to ur tamilian root. Please take her to ur state. Karnataka is fed up of this attitude lady.
Don't blame her. If someone makes me a Finance Minister, why would I say no? So it's not her fault. Ask why such ministers are selected. Apart from 2-3 (Goyal, Gadkari etc.) remaining 20 ministers are useless. If you disagree, show me what they have done in 10 years. Can you show?
Don’t blame her. She is only the HIS MASTER VOICE. She may not even know what is in the Budget.
😂😂
Real Bhakths problem
Very Rightly said 👌
Her Master's Voice!!!
better resign and go.
Taxes are imposed like Developed countries but the quality of life and expenses are like Somalia
Free loader ranting!!!😂😂😂
really.have you been to Somalia?
This comment has now become a cringe.
True
@@SanjayGopi-nc9sk for people like you. common man is starving. So the comment prevails: Taxes are imposed like Developed countries but the quality of life and expenses are like Somalia
Our most responsible finance minister Mrs Nirmala Sitaraman,
when she's asked about Onion price rise she said that she's not coming from the family which consumes onion and garlic,
when she's been asked why the GST for foods and restaurant are high she said why you people are eating in the restaurant plz have your own cooked in your homes.
When she's been asked why the gas cylinder prices were high she said if you cant afford LPG eat from the restaurants.
Very much committed to the citizens of our nation India
Wait ru trolling or did she really said that?
Sitharaman ki c.
This reminds me of an English song: There is a hole in the bucket,dear Liza,....
You forgot when asked about why Rupees value is weak and she replied its actually Dollar which is strong. What a bullshit fm
@@Life_is_miraculus I know she said the thing about onions so the rest must also be true
We are suffering from 10 years due to finance minister 😢😢😢😢
What are you talking about when Modi Government has made progress on massive infrastructure developments and made India 5th economic power and this shows ignorance on things done by Modi from warfare schemes,free nations building many toilets and Look at roads and New railways and Metros and Nehru even did not built toilets
@@kishorraja370Andh bhakth is poo.. ping his gobar knowledge from whatsapp university. 😂
@@kishorraja370Infrastructure? Say collapsing infrastructure.Newly built Parliament building Ram Mandir are leaking. Bridges are collapsing in under construction stage. Just image what would have happened if these were to collapse after opening to public..And toilets ? You have to pay even to relieve yourself and thank the FM that GS T has not been levied on this service. And ,5th bigger economy. ??Do you think a 300 - kg obese person living on 5 kg free rations is healthy?? Have a look at our bulging foreign debt financing our so called lopsided development.
@@narayanathota4318 but you are not comparing with past under Nehru Gandhi dynasty and what they had done was seen until Modi improved India to 5th economic power with massive infrastructure developments and people elect leader on developments and delivery so you have to understand democracy.And Modi will make 3rd economic power.What did Nehru was blunder on China and Kashmir policies.His dynasty following socialism destroyed India and Narshima Rao and Manmohan Singh came with new economic policies and Modi strengthened it when India massively improved
@@narayanathota4318 and in floods in west, china USA all had seen massive intrafracture destructions so why are targeting India
The problem with most elected reps is that they cringe before you for your votes. After the election, they don't care for you. It is as simple as that. But then, pride comes before a fall. If you continue your arrogance, a fall is imminent and you won't know what hits you when it hits you.
About unelected reps, please remember Manmohan Singh was unelected rep and he did a pretty good job, considering the various pulls and pressures from within his own party and from the Opposition. The fact is if you are honest and you have a GOOD HEART, it doesn't matter if you are elected or unelected
Honesty is good and all but when ur making decisions for a billion people u should be 'capable' Nirmala is not even qualified for this fm role Manmohan Singh did a good job as a finance minister because that's what he's good at but he was terrible pm
I would rather choose subramani from bjp itself as finance minister rather than Nirmala sitaraman
Above all , any minister , would be good and honest only if they have a humility to feel responsible to people who have a democratic right to question them . Both BJP as a party and their ministers are arrogant and lack the basic humility to accept their blunders , which are multiplying by the day .
You are more than 100 percent correct.
Not a pretty good job, he did an excellent job, especially when there was a recession world over.
I 100% agree with you. Have been finding it really hard to understand why arrogant and ignorant people can be FMs now. She should be immediately removed.
Even her husband is against her views. He knows very well her stupidity, arrogance and emotional quotient. Unfortunate for Bharat or India.
You are absolutely correct. This lady does not deserve to be a FM of the country.
Lady with no knowledge of finance matters.
.
Elected or Selected makes no difference, it's ultimately the leadership which matters.
She's rude person who don't have sympathy or empathy which is essential for a leader
Its the people, who matter. People make leaders. Period.
People of India a extremely timid to protest against such a draconian rule... We should take a lesson or two from the brave students and public who are currently protesting against the fascist rule in Bangladesh
When Kalam was President. People were criticizing why someone needs that many skills to be president.
At the end the colour of cat doesnt matter to catch a rat😂
Sad reality 👍👌🤝🔥😢Tax increased but we are not getting back it even 50% with quality😢
💯💯💯
Yes
New parliament house constructed but Delhi city water drainage system was not improved
Good Job. Keep exposing Governments & Raise Voice again High Taxes & GST
This is true, instead of this FM, we can make good beuracrat. Useless FM who cannot sense the feeling of normal people, only work for PM and Elite people.
Don't blame her. If someone makes me a Finance Minister, why would I say no? So it's not her fault. Ask why such ministers are selected. Apart from 2-3 (Goyal, Gadkari etc.) remaining 20 ministers are useless. If you disagree, show me what they have done in 10 years. Can you show?
Manmohan Singh ji also not directly elected. It is the personality who guides the entire process makes diffrence
Idiot he is pm and pm cannot be elected.
Pm is selected by winning party with most MPs
U may ask wt about modi.
He voluntarily stood as mp in varanasi
He was elected as mp of varanasi not as pm.
Once bjp alliance got more votes than india bloc, only then the entire nda alliance unanimously chose modi as pm.
Its a personal choice whether to stand as mp or pm.
Sitaraman was just fm
She has to be responsove to people, as she is fm fpr all 140 crore people
She comes from ruling party
Ruling party is answerable to people
While addressing people, u have to be polite and understanding
Sitaraman is anything but kind (far detached from reality, very rude)
This kindness is possible only when you are elefted by people or you are connected tp ground reality, met people before and heard their woes like how rahul gandhi did in bharat jodo yatra.
Nirmala doesnt have such qualities.
He was an Economics expert, unlike the former sales girl. Manmohanji expertise Economics from the same country where the present FM worked as sales girl. 😀
furtherm he was defeated in Loksabha elections before
Spot on Sir.. I've felt the arrogance in answers earlier as well.
Well articulated without taking sides
Absolutely Doctor, hats off to you to speak for the emotions of people of india in a public forum like this..fms unfit for the position..God only can save the nation..
Shame on government
Don't blame her. If someone makes me a Finance Minister, why would I say no? So it's not her fault. Ask why such ministers are selected. Apart from 2-3 (Goyal, Gadkari etc.) remaining 20 ministers are useless. If you disagree, show me what they have done in 10 years. Can you show?
Increasing the long term capital gain tax is the worst decision which directly affect the true investor
Sir you address the real position of the middle class people suffering towards this budget Thank you sir.
😢😢😢 tu😊
2 yrs later..... welcome back sir...
Pscho came back from asylum😂
Exactly. Only a psycho can see another psycho.@@vijayanand3111
@@vijayanand3111says the one who shared the bed with him
@@vijayanand3111ok for 1 comment pay 5Rs GST 😂
Why you still didn't??@@vijayanand3111
Many ministers are selected not elected, this massage should go to ground level people.
Very sensible and logical. Thanks for sharing your point of view.
Very very true. You just spoke your heart, and I can definitely relate, boss. The attitude of hers is the blocker here and it will get us nowhere unless she is changed.
It totally makes sense. She's nor answering our question instead she's only answering media person....... great analysis bro
Very interesting video from your end.. As a senior citizen of India of aged 68 now....and being a tax payer for last 40 years... I did not know I can balance my ITR in a coloring book until I retired with no benefit for next few years of my living. Government has made almost all digitalized, but as a senior citizen it's nothing works when required. My suggestion..... As a tax payer let govt give freebies in insurance on motor vehicle, toll tax, life time tax extended on vehicles personally owned. With GST introduction life has become very costlier. As a middle man cannot buy site of 1000 swift for less than one crrore in metros and 50 lakhs in villages.... Everyday the pulse rice cereals vegetables fruits rates are touching per kg 200.oo and fifty rupees and 100 ruppes notes are vanishing....
She is the scapegoat of the modi government.Modiji knows it best.The people who suffers may not he voting..the uneducated and poor dont have to worry due to new tax rules..they were anyway suffering, without even realising..
You hit the Bulls Eye. Very nice to see such sensible videos
When a person with Sales background performs a Finance role, Nation suffers.
Unelected PM where ruling the country from 2004-2014.. Point is not about it, who could understand layman's issues should come as a Finance minister...
You corrected the present bro. Why did you go wrong and justify the wrong as right. Lol sanghi😄😄😄
Do u know his qualification ?
He was a senior lecturer of economics at Panjab University from 1957 to 1959.
He served as a reader in economics at Panjab University from 1959 and 1963,and from 1963 to 1965, he was an economics professor there
He went to work for the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) from 1966 to 1969. Later, he was appointed as an advisor to the Ministry of Foreign Trade in recognition of his talent as an economist.
From 1969 to 1971, he was a professor of international trade at the Delhi School of Economics, University of Delhi.
In 1972, he was chief economic adviser in the Ministry of Finance, and in 1976 he was secretary in the Finance Ministry.
In 1980-1982 he was at the Planning Commission,
In 1982- 1985, he was appointed governor of the Reserve Bank of India .
He went on to become the deputy chairman of the Planning Commission (India) from 1985 to 1987. Following his tenure at the Planning Commission, he was secretary general of the South Commission, an independent economic policy think tank headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland from 1987 to November 1990.
He returned to India from Geneva in November 1990 and held the post as the advisor to Prime Minister of India on economic affairs
In 1991, he became chairman of the University Grants Commission.
@@thambiraj4853
Idiot
first learn how to write a proper sentence 🤦
You have rightly said, bhayya. FM is not from people, doesn't feel the pain of the middle class. She behaves as if she came from a far away land from India and above all hates common people. God save India for another 5 years😢😢
God Bless You, Sir! No one describes like you describe! No any other psychologist like you on the whole planet Earth! Keep it up, Sir! Hope one day you will achieve your Red diamond button from youtube company!
able to feel people are feeling the heat and a strong sense of basic rights being tampered. Hope people likely minded will unite and rise sooner than before to avoid further unethical and barbaric acts by government. when is the time i think, its already high time.
Rightly and sensibly said brother......
For the past 70 yrs ,,,middle class will be middle class
Middle class will become lower clasd
Exactly
Past ten years middle class become lower middle class sir.
Now middle class becoming lower middle class
@@Ak20231
Yes correct ,,,,,,,sir
Valid points. People should get right to pull back public reps. Every legislation and policy should go through all stakeholders. People should have ability to penalize public reps not just once in 5 years but more often. Pub reps should not go against people mandate. Like surprise policies and jumping parties AFTER getting elected. Lay down your intention and policies and affiliation ahead and stick with it else automatically pulled back. If you dont support the rajyasabha candidate, dont support those state reps who voted for that Rsaba member. The member might get thru via other state. But eventually they will get your point. All this may be practically not possible. But hope u get my drift
Incompetent people in high positions consider the power vested in them a perk. They, therefore, place themselves above others and lash out at their critics as a matter of prerogative. Our Hon. FM. Is following a long and cherished tradition.🍀
Sir I'm psychology in Tamil subscriber i will watch every video of you... where ever you post what ever the language is..... We will support you.. .keep doing..
Here is an I…t from TN following this CZcamsr I…t?
There are thousands of examples showing decline in ethical value but true leadership always follow ethical rules.
you are not being personal, rather specific. That is appreciable.
Good Video👍...truly FM is not fit for this role
TM. Tax minister
fact .. boldly portrayed . 👍
I get fear when I look our finance minister, especially when budget comes
Doctor sir. Pls also explain why Manmohan Singh was 2 times prime minister without contested in lok sabha polls🤔.
Exactly ! 👍☺
Also he was fm.This fellow Italian family congress bonded labourer
There is a special hell reserved for people like the honorable FM
all ur fathers will be there
@@user-pf1ci2lk5h Cuz ur mother will be waiting there with her legs spread wide open ..
Sir, thanks for your open hearted message to people of INDIA
For the very first time you spoke like a common man than phycologist, Well done, keep posting more videos like this😂
Hard truth is that "Every finance minister will be mocked by the people after every budget" . It is not about Elected or selected whether BJP or congress.
Ok Mr. Sangi, I understand just going to schools won't make you educated. Political people can wash your mind anytime.
Sangis are the best examples for this
Congress was much better. At least micro level things were not ignored. Last 11 years no benefit has been given to Middle Class.
True .
Also The government always makes a budget according to people from whom it gets most of its votes .
These new taxes are anyway not going to affect the lower middle class or poor category people, which vote the most .
Very well spoken. People are looked down upon rather than ......
Pa chidhambaram also elected by people what he done.......full of corruption
He made LTCG tax zero and didn't remove indexation benefits in any asset class.
@@religionofpeace782ha ha ha komali ranting 😂😂😂
@@religionofpeace782 its just 12.5 per for your ltcg.... Pa chid sold our printing machine..... I will give my money insteed of correption
He already answered for this question, listen the video first carefully
Very apt and appropriate view..
The finance minister, when he/she holds the position, is totally responsible for the people of the country, irrespective of the categories and to satisfy the questions without any arrogance or superiority...
She should also keep in mind that the entire nation will ask questions on every deed according to their needs every time...
Here, whenever she is not able to satisfy the people' for their queries, may be blaming the predecessors or the earlier policies...that irks everyone...
Its not big surprise as her boss is a tea seller😂
He is not criticizing lol understand what he is saying😂
@@rohithgovindaraj1318ofcourse he is criticizing, may be not harsh
PM is fake tea seller. He did not even sell tea, that is also a lie. The railway station where the PM was supposed to sell tea, was built after he left his hometown and he had joined the R S S. The railway station did not exist when he was a kid, it was built later.
A new perspective ✨️ 👌 The FM when told about rising cost of Onions says she doesn't eat Onions 😂😂😂Namaskar
Dr Jitendra what you have done to the society !!!!! Plz list it we want to know your little bit services to the society.
I learned a lot of finance topics and got a lot of share market related knowledge from his free youtube videos, i think he severed more than enough to the society especially to psychology and finance in tamil.
@gnanadurai7900 yes, I agree. By the way why do we need to serve society to post a video on FM. We are paying huge taxes already.
@@Monashaa09 yes, good question, as a tax payer everyone has the rights to criticise FM( even as a citizen of india we have the rights), but guys like this sramasubramanian are attacking the question persons, i'm giving a polite answer also you can give slipper shot answers to these guys if you wish.
@@gnanadurai7900 Yes, I know. They do not have reasoning power, so they will not understand our arguments.
@@gnanadurai7900 we talk about common people whose tax burden is reduced comparing to last year.
My opinion is not about people who buy and sell shares every minute based on his advice and expect zero taxation. By the way we understood your shit gutter back ground from your reply language.
Very Apt Analysis!
You hit the nail. Very apt and true analysis
Your Excellent comments are Highly appreciated Sir! Please bring your valuable comments to the CJI, Supreme Court! So, that we may get at least some justification. I respect your bold comments in the interest of of INDIAN Citizen. Sir, there is no genuine ministers including PM in BJP/RSS Persons. They don’t know the administration, except enjoying their lives with their family with INDIAN Government money with very luxurious. They are very much fond of their lifestyle with Govt. Money, The Minister and PM are least bothered to look after the welfare and their right in this Nation. There is no democracy except to pull the poor and real Scholars into in big troubles and years together in Tihar Jail with trial in the Court of Law. Police persons are under their full Custody and in their grip. They can not do their duty faithfully as per the Indian Constitutional Law., because these political power. Even SC & HC Judges are also afraid of Modi Power Politics. So No Justice to the poor and innocent people who were forced to be put in Tihar Jail either our any change sheet and Trials in the Court of Law. I am crying to see these worst administration against poor people and middle class people who were victimised by this governments.
I think you got it all wrong about indexation benefits - What FM has done is, the new system applicable for the people who bought houses after 2001 will attract 12.5% capital gain tax (which is less than the previous 20% tax with indexation) - So there are no much changes to whole taxation, but it is now streamlined across the border to all asset class, except for short term traders.
I don’t think you are right in saying 12.5% without indexation is less than 20% with indexation . Indexation table shows an increase of 5% every year. With LTCG lock in period of 2 years, my purchase price would have increased by 10% while my actual reduction in tax due to this new policy is only 7.5%. We end up paying more. Much worse, we end up paying taxes for our losses due to inflation if the appreciation of the property is not above the indexation line.
Everything happening in this world has a psychological perspective..... I believe if we are able to understand that, we can achieve far more good to the entire manhood....... Thank you Sir for bringing up this topic and giving a great msg "To be kind to people"
Exactly, every thing depends on the mental behaviour of the persons .
Hi Jitendra- I used to watch ur tamil channel. Today came across with this episode in English channel. Mostly agree with u except one point... either elected by people or by their representative, the Govt should understand people requirement.. there is a gap or once they elected they think worlds most powerful person and people should come forward understand the Govt's reforms... This is highly ridiculous... Unfortunately it's not reaching them
completely agree with you sir. it's stupidity to tell only elected person should become a minister. otherwise we wouldn't have got a greatest EAM of all time. also we know how our pseudo democracy works.
She was appointed and works for A1 & A2. She work from Parliament due to Situation that it was built by Modi.
Exactly true . Elected representatives are preferable in democracy; Or empathy/compassion is required even for technocrats.
I hv just watched TMC mp Mohua moitra speech abut the budget 6Aug in loksabha. U are absolutely right. Shoddy job of budget by a incompetent mins. And a government insensitive to ppl. Educated ppl in India will also find a heroic solution like done Bangladesh I hope pray and wait.
I agree with that bro, but i mentioned one think in here its not depend on people elected or non elected for example we have one of the best foreigner minister mr jayshankar what about your concern about, i am not supporter of any party but i really like your confident and polite speach over this plotform,
Foreign minister whose kids don't study in India & don't want Indian citizenship?
@@srikanthsv79
No one wants indian citizenship except some people from India's poor neighbouring countries .
I don't think this should be a point of outrage.
Only dynasty politicians have their children in india , because their children will lead those dynasty parties in the future .
Jaishankar is not a politician. He was the executive who is given the responsibility of FM
@@sidy6526 a person who has no faith in India will dictate India's diplomacy?
Very well put. Appreciate the fact that your video was respectful and not a troll video. There is a lot of anger and feeling of unjust in people like us. This will come out definitely but not in the shape of trolling but next elections.
Manmohan Singh had been the prime minister for ten years as a rajyasabha mp ( unelected representatives). But same people saying fm is not elected what a hypocrisy.
The hypocrisy is in equating Dr. Singh's budgets with those of Nirmala Sitharaman.
@@mastkalandar3200 yes , nirmala sitaraman budget is way more good than that of manmohan singh. She is brought india 3 trillion dollars economy , and protected economy during covid lockdown from recession , where even developed economies like uk , Germany faced recession like suitation . Its way more better than manmohan singh's LPG for imf loans.. its very lately happened.
Very good observation. It is so commendable. Thank you that someone speak the truth on the fave of the Government.
Which elected representative talked down to people in Tamil Nadu?
All including CM. When any rain comes, they are the first people on the street
Almost all,you don't see Stalin or minister takes this tone when addressing in public forum
You echoed my views and feelings, 100% !
For the person who earns less there is no much tax , in fact in new tax regime tax is reduced( most of the people are finding loop holes in old tax regime)
What about the indirect tax, we are not only paying taxes on our income. We also pay taxes @18-28% GST when we spend the remaining money after paying the income tax. In return we don't get quality Education and Healthcare, we need to go to Private. The Medical Inflation in India is 14% which means the cost of treatment and medicines goes up by a minimum of 14% every year. How can a middle class person afford it if everything is private but still have to pay high taxes?
When GST introduced the minimum tax was 5%, now?
The real truths that U narrated, TQ for awareness of public.
U r talking about taking salary & not about stealing public money in ur state
You people are stealing our tax for more than 70 years and showing no results. If the state is stealing, then CAG should find out, but we are way ahead of you in many areas.
The term unselected is a misnomer.then pass a law that the ministers should be only from loksabha members.
Dr.Manmohan Singh is elected or selected??????
Selected!,
Watch once again video. Dr is addresing the problem of crook minds of sanghi like you.
Poor and middle class are suffering because of the Finance Minister who cannot make proper budget and lacks financial knowledge.
Toolkit is operational
Very Nice Sir, Her responsibility now atleast to feel the pulse of people
Bold and clear.
Not any opinions, you speak all the truth. But now who will hear and keeping it in our mind do the best in future . Nobody ,....
We all are nonsense........
Sir super, also put a video of unelected become PM...
That unelected PM was an accomplished expert in his domain.
@@mskumarsothersidein bootlicking domain u mean 😂😂
@jaihind3595 when savarkar was PM?
Before commenting here, everyone should compare the budgets 2013-2014 and 2024-2025
Why do I want to compare? Are you middle class? If so, then you will understand the pain of this stupid budget. Even if we all paying such huge tax, we are not getting proper health care, water, roads, etc. On top of that, after I pay all tax and I invest or do savings, return on those also taxed. It's literally government is looting the public money in the name of tax.
Sir sathyama onnume puriyale
An appointed FM without any banking and finance knowledge and without any responsibility to the electorate has ruined the banking economy and life of the people during the ten years of Modi's misrule..it is well explained
Unelected FM much better than the unelected PM in UPA regime😂😂
That's y UPA lost third time in a row.by the way atleast unelected PM was able to give 110 press conference in 10years.
@@jones.g9079😂😂 Italy
👌👌👌
और तो और दुसरी नापास चुनाव से जित कर आया हुआ सब से अच्छा।
मंंदभक्त सदाटुन
100% correct what I thought was the same from the mind of yours also. It looks like Nirmala ji is appointed as a financial head in a firm and she is doing favour her proprietor.
23rd July to 31st July - 90% become economists;
1st August onwards - Status quo restored- only 20% qualified economists in India.😂😂😂
The real fact, very well explained. you have echoed my thoughts. thank you for taking such topics
Do you Know Dr Manmohan Singh was selected and not elected as PM and FM previously short of memory by you Measure a person by performance it seems you are Narrow minded ok
Un elected and unqualified for the post is being appointed. Emotionless because she doesn't eat onions which bring tears to the eyes!
I know she has taxed heavily on one of your ltcg asset 😅
hahaha... very true.. people should pay taxes joyfully and willfully when they have capital gains.
@@srikantsubramanian4886
Yes, may be Andhra and Bihar can be joyful now not other states are not joyful in paying heavy taxes.😅
@@srikantsubramanian4886 there is nothing wrong in paying taxes if you have capital gains. But, here in this case I have to pay tax for my loss if my property appreciated is below the indexation line. Would you call it smart taxation?
Valid points. People should get right to pull back public reps. Every legislation and policy should go through all stakeholders. People should have ability to penalize public reps not just once in 5 years but more often. Pub reps should not go against people mandate. Like surprise policies and jumping parties AFTER getting elected. Lay down your intention and policies and affiliation ahead and stick with it else automatically pulled back. All this may be practically not possible. But hope u get my drift
No, you are not being rude. You are spot on. She has to address the concern, so right.
The politicians, elected or unelected, must maintain dignity, humility and human values. Degeneration of our value system due the unadulterated opportunism of our politicians is the bane of our democracy. You have rightly assessed the reality.
She has been selected to dance to the tune of a few in the Govt
Very true statement young man God bless
V Dillen
Thanks Dr.Jitendra
All elected people behaving correctly? Is anybody in our country electing the person based on their quality and capability? Please mind your words. She is our FM
Thank you even the same is in many peoples mind.she is not elected by people and the problem is she never gone to people and found the public opinions and their needs and feelings ,She is just like a professor who give his speech and just leave the gallery .they dose not bother about wheather they understood it or not.she is intelligent but not practical.may be she was guided by some norms. If she can understand people she will be the best.if not nation suffers in many ways.
Nation has to seriously reflect & questiin what services they receive in return for paying such exorbitant taxes.
For a change, personal corruption/ favouritism is not the issue for the last 10 years she has handled the ministry.
First the nation should appreciate her for that, as even elected representatives have failed in the past.
She is as good as her team which includes the party view.