John Swinney's Keir Starmer remark 'touched a very raw nerve' at FMQs
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 11. 2022
- Deputy SNP leader John Swinney believed he 'touched a very raw nerve' when he quoted remarks made by Labour Party leader, Keir Starmer, during a debate at First Minister's Questions over the state of NHS Scotland.
Scottish Labour leader, Anas Sarwar, criticized the SNP's 'failure to workforce plan' when he was quoted Sir Keir's remarks of 'I think we are recruiting too many people from overseas in, for example, the health service.'
Daily Record Homepage: www.dailyrecord.co.uk/
Daily Record Facebook: / thescottishdailyrecord
Daily Record IG: / scottishdailyrecord
Daily Record Twitter: / daily_record
Daily Record Newsletters: www.dailyrecord.co.uk/newslet...
You can get all the latest news, sport, showbiz and comment at DailyRecord.co.uk
LIKE | COMMENT | SUBSCRIBE | SHARE
#DailyRecord #AnasSarwar #KeirStarmer
Blame someone/thing else, SNP mantra.
Starmer is continuing the demise of Labour in Scotland, I struggle to see how anyone in Scotland can vote for them now.
Vote reform U.K. cent this cult out.
@@eleanorcrawford9978 SNP for me, the only reform of the UK I want to see is a UK without Scotland in it. Reform UK are just the latest rebranding of Farage and all the rest of the lunatics he hangs about with.
Get the GPs back working ...and get rid of all the management that's bleeding the nhs out of money ..
Too many upper management sitting on big salaries, who haven’t a clue about what’s going on downstairs, and don’t want to know either.
Couldn't agree more....
And that starts at Holyrood!!!
@Graeme Roberts
The fact it's the same anywhere else is neither here nor there, we're talking about the COMPLETELY devolved Scottish NHS here.
Stop the whitabootery, is that your only defence for the state the Scottish NHS is in?
Pathetic, laughable🤣🤣
Oh, and can you please enlighten us all on the highest percentage of the ENTIRE voting electorate of Scotland which the snp has ever achieved please.
Then tell us all they speak for Scotland.
More and more people are leaving the Health Service in Scotland and not one MP is answering why.
i know why a lot of older nurses and doctors in the nhs are leaving is because they have paid into their superannuation scheme and the government are looking at it to end so are taking early retirement and getting jobs at supermarkets, don't believe me ask the ones that are leaving and look at the age they are leaving.
@@terranceyeo3087 I couldn’t agree more but this has been ongoing for at least the last 6 years.Final salary pensions are totally unsustainable and the pensions need to be looked into.I myself was a nurse for over 50 years.Both my gran daughters are nurses and they have certainly opened my eyes to what’s now going on in the health service and it is disgusting.One of my grand daughters has left after some eighteen months due to the way the nurses are being treated by management and the staffing levels they are having to work under with no help from above or the problems being addressed and the current SNP government think everything is rosy.
@@joanrodger352 i don't know whether you have the same system as we have, a company buy things like blood cleaner for ambulances from company's where i worked and we charged them £1 a litre they sold them to the nhs for £15 litre, now if they was allowed to go to local company's to set up a regularly deliver they could save more money.
We know why.
@@terranceyeo3087 generally the NHS is know to drive a hard bargain by bulk buying. The pharmaceutical companies don't like the UKs NHS.
It's amazing it doesn't matter which parliament it is, the spout enough fertiliser to fertilise the whole of the UK
NHS staff get paid more and have less tax in England. That's the biggest issue for NHS Scotland.
They pay more tax
@@red-blue3430 Where do they pay more tax?
The Scottish are taxed heavier & get less in return.
The snp need all the cash they can squirrel for their neverendum!!
Bullshit
@@davecameron8567 they just announced a strike...
@Graeme Roberts I have to ask you the same question 'buddy' as the vast majority in England and Wales pay 1% LESS income tax than the Scottish.
Source: ScotGov & UKGov
Who's been telling you porkies buddy?
It wouldn't be the fountain of truth, the snp by any chance??
🤣🤣🤣🤡🤡
Sunak was back in parliament yesterday.Krankies still on holiday.
Look at Swinney pointing away, what a rude angry wee individual!! As for his record in office, he has been a failure in all his posts and if you can remember when he was their leader, well that went well and now because the standard of the SNP, MSP,s he’s now the deputy leader!!! As for it being the Tories Brexit, he seems to forget that the largest support for Brexit came from Labour voters, hence why Labour lost the last election!!
😂😂😂 from the first second of the video I was waiting for blaming Brexit!!
7 million on a waiting list in England
@Dirty Den bigger by 12x. there waiting list is 46x bigger 💀
@Dirty Den except Englands is 45x longer 💀
@Dirty Den AND the NHS south of the border are having to take patients from Scotland, you won't hear the sheeple mention that though🐑🐑🐑
Who runs the NHS in Scotland!!!
Striking in support of all under Westminster attacks, and Labour disrespects these actions by the Scottish NHS workforce. For the People eh????
I recall some years ago, some dumplin from labour warning that an independent Scotland would be slung out of the EU and that one of the consequences would be the loss of EU workers in the NHS.
The London Labour branch office manager in Scotland Anas Sarwar boss Kier Starmer wants to attract the Brexit supporting Tory voting ex Labour voters in the north of England with his rhetoric about foreign people working in the health service.
Many skilled European NHS workers went back to their own countries after Brexit because they didn't feel welcomed.
Now there is a problem with vacancies in the NHS and Starmer said not to attract the skilled European health service workers back to fill the vacancies. Starmer idea to solve the current problem in the NHS is to train new people that will take years to train which will not help with the problems now.
Brexit. Are you still crying about it?😂
@@gordonlawtie7237 The Brexit bounce will fund a revitalized NHS ?
But that's the problem we should be looking at,cwe shouldn't have to bring people in, if the wages reflected the hours and stress then we'd have more training!!
@@gordonlawtie7237 lol did you vote for it?
Train up your own people or are they not good enough 🤔
What a stuttering fool Swinney really is. Why is he answering questions on health issues. We have a Health Secretary “ Useless Yousaf” who never answers any questions. Wonder why?
Oh stop stop were so sick of the excuses Brexit is not to blame, nor is Covid, and most of all Westminster is not to blame.
15 years of SNPs incompetence is to blame. OMG he has always been open, one thing the SNP can’t take credit for is openness.
SNP will never take responsibility.
This is why people don't vote for Labour anymore Anas by name Anas by nature.
Perhaps another more fundamental reason is that in the post war period alone 700k Scots were forced to leave Scotland under the watchful eye of Slabour and went to shore up the acute shortage of skilled workers in the middle England where of course were at that time Labour strongholds. Better Together NOT
does Swinney like Sturgeon not actually engage their brain before opening the mouth and start talking
@rigamortice EVERY MSP is a liar it's just some more than others
Swinney we have not trained enough staff in Scotland, you need to start thinking about Scotland.
Right so meally mouthed rhetoric from Sarwar but we all know it's London who will make decisions.
How are Labour doing in Wales are their nurses not striking , let's compare their performance , it's behind the Tory rule NHS in England.
Perhaps if our finances were not reliant on what Westminster decide to give us back we would be in a better position to ensure our essential workers are paid better. Sarwar again defeats himself by arguing inadvertently for independence.
It's about time we all go our separate ways, then the right people gets the blame, NHS is devolved, but big bad WM and the English get the blame, no matter what, i don't no why the Govt put up with it, it's time all devolved nations made enough money, to stand on there own feet, Sturgeon wastes so much money, on stupid stuff, instead of looking after the Scottish people, then WM gets the blame, they should be Audited.
Whitabootery yet again🤣🤣🤣
Train up your own people.
Well done to Scotland for boycotting the World Cup, again! 😂
As we should. Trash event for trash ppl
NHS government commons private :( Supreme court, NO (England court lol)! 19th October 2023, YES!!! Freedom!!!
Don't talk rubbish the supreme court act's for the whole of the UK you are one of the small minded snp supporters.
@@robertdownie879 19th October 2023 vote, goodbye lol :)
@@KizzyKismet1 know chance I would not trust the snp they cannot tell the truth as it is now .but they can throw our money away on stupid ideas. and ferries that might sail one but not to the islands they were supposed to service .
@@robertdownie879 Goodbye Robert lol :)
Anas speak to your boss. Educate yourself.
It’s all good welcoming them into society. But they bring their society with them and we don’t want that 😏✌️
Go back to your cave man times when one of your ancestors was a neanderthal probably the male side I suspect.
We're in a catch 22 situation and something needs doing. We haven't got student medical staff because the hours and stress doesn't reflect by their pay, so we've naturally got a very small amount of students going to medical school, and if we don't take immigrants we have practically no staff. Pretty obvious what needs to be done but the Tories won't!!!
@Sir Almighty budge Would you like to be a bit more specific about which societies you're referring to, or should we just assume that you find every part of the world that Johnny foreigner comes from to be beneath us?
@@comanchio1976 They've all served this country and probably even given him medical care too!!
Who doesn't ? Your ignorance of migration and it's impacts seem rather obtuse. Think you need to see where the origins of your language, religion and culture come from.
Brexit was voted by 17.4 million people in the U.K. it was not imposed on anyone by the conservatives.
I totally agree with the Deputy First Minister - Sir Starmer was just like good ol' Boris - where they don't deal with reality in front of them - where are the people in the UK that are wanting to be recruited? Yes, nurses and doctors were crying out for need of financial support - 12 years of Tory mismanagement - that'll cause it.
As a medical student I can tell you that there are actually more medical school graduates than the number of jobs, and with each rung up the career path the number of jobs decreases - we're bleeding doctors not only because there's a terrible work-life balance in the UK (and toxic grind-for-free culture that's implemented from high up), but because the govt. are just not funding enough jobs and expansion of the NHS to accommodate the doctors from the UK or abroad (because they're actually trying to dismantle the NHS, not expand it to purpose).
Starmer's comments the other day about migrant workers was terrible though, and even though I want the Tories out, Starmer has gone massively down in my estimations and support.
Man says something. People purposefully take the wrong end of the stick.
That is all that is happening.
Keir is simply stating that we do not train enough of our own NHS staff, which is very true.
Why are people so intentionally stupid?
Why are you a brexitard 🤔
He didn't say "I think we need to make the NHS a better place to work, to retain staff, encourage more people to train, and make sure we have the training infrastructure and funding to train people in this country", though.
He, I imagine intentionally, said "we're recruiting too many workers from overseas". *Maybe*, the practical effects of any resultant policy is the same, but that framing, and the focus not on the things we can do in this country as a positive, but on the proportion of migrant workers as a negative, is divisive and racialised.
I shouldn't have to *hope* that he only made those comments to encourage racists and Little Englanders to vote Labour, and *hope* that he doesn't genuinely think that way. It's not acceptable.
How many times can the SNP blame the pandemic, the issues were also self inflicted 😂😂 if it wasn’t for the UK gorvernment, we’d probably still be in lockdown
Aye, you picked the right name for yourself, Cowboy.
@@johnscrimgeour4888 don’t even get me started on your name
Cowboy
You and three jobs Dross the London Tory branch office manager in Scotland should have a word with his London boss and the Westminster Tory ministers who have said that the pandemic has caused a backlog of people waiting for treatment by the English NHS.
England has 7 million people waiting for treatment.
Scotland has the best performing NHS of the four countries. Better than the Tory English NHS and the Labour run Welsh NHS.
@@cowboy8968 crack on fella!!
@@johnscrimgeour4888 your names shit
🙏🇬🇧
LABOUR AND FUKIN TORIES WHO !, ✊🏻🏴🏴
Spot the group give you a clue. He has not put a lot of hair
Sarwars a clown! Blaming SNP for the torries destruction of the NHS - funny how the Scottish NHS is the best performing in the UK - Thats successful mitigation - imagine what we could do if we were independant - While England sells their NHS off, Scotlands will thrief! Saor Alba!!
Could we build ferries better?
Brexit's fault again. What an absolute joke this man is. Time for a change.
From America, where is Scotland? I think I have heard of it.
Its not a real place mate.
Its like Atlantis
@@lovelybitofbugle219 Thanks dude. 👍
Or Brigadoon, you rubber knobed ami ignoramus.
@@beachcomber1able what part of Ireland are you from bruv?
The home town of sweet Molly Malone.
John Swinney is brilliant.
Are you on drugs he’s a 🤡
You think ?
Honest John 😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 John Swinney is brilliant...OH, MA SIDES! 😂😂😂😂😂😂
You need to lay off the drink jock
Get rid of the paperclips wandering round looking important doing nothing
ROLL ON SCOTTISH INDEPENDENCE ✊🏻🏴🏴
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Utter pish.
@@hughclarkson4218 fuk you ,bellend . What scares you . REALITY ?? ✊🏻🏴🏴
Well said John 👏
Lol
What did he say was right 🥴
Just sit down, red tory boy Sarwar!
Independence really can't come soon enough.
Saor Alba
Truth hurts heh baldy (lying) shouty man 🧐
It's always the same, blame Tories, Brexit, Covid.
Labour Welsh First Minister Mark Drakeford said that Tory austerity, bad handling of the economy and high inflation has cut the Welsh budget.
English councils have said that their budgets have been cut by Westminster and because of high inflation their budgets buy less.
The Westminster Tory ministers said that the pandemic has caused a backlog of people waiting for treatment.
There are 7 million people waiting for treatment by the English NHS in England.
It's not just the Scottish government that has been saying that the Westminster Tories have been bad for public services with the Osborne Tory austerity from 2010 onwards.
The Bank of England is meant to keep inflation down at 2 % but inflation is now high at 10.1% and predicted to go higher. The Scottish budget was agreed with Westminster last December when Inflation was a lot lower
Because of high inflation and increased costs of energy, wages and procurement etc. The Scottish governments budget will buy £1.7 billion less.
A lot of skilled European health services workers didn't feel welcomed after Brexit and left the NHS and returned to their own countries. With Tory control over bringing skilled worker in from abroad the health services, farmers and public and private companies who provide care have had trouble recruiting workers.
@@martindornan1667 I understand all that, but it's easy for them, to keep blaming WM, they are not running the whole of the UK, they just think money grows on trees, I think had we not had 10yrs of Austerity, we would be in a bigger mess, than we are now, the world as got the same problems, in fact the EU country's are worse than us, all it is with these devolved Govt, is blame, and divide, they are making more debt for themselves, i think now we should go our own way, let them live on what they bring in, see if they can do a better job.
Sick listening to Scotland and SNP bad prey tell me who's fault it is nurses no longer nurse they made it a degree course now all they do is paperwork auxiliaries do the nursing
Labour = Tories