Are you going to talk about the ongoing WAR between Azerbaijan and Armenia? For a great analysis of the Conflict between these two nations, it's origins, future and possible SOLUTIONS check out: czcams.com/video/2oAyBHztqxY/video.html&ab_channel=MyTake
I know this an unrelated note, but was i the only viewer of this channel that noticed a video from this channel about michigan today? When i tried to open it, it was listed as a private video? Because I'm from Michigan and i was looking forward to get this channel's perspective because i respect a lot of the work out of this channel and was a bit disappointed that i wasn't able to view it.
@@joshlewis575 As if the Americans don't launch cyberattacks of their own lol. One of the most infamous cyberattacks of all was carried out by the US (stuxnet), and that's just one of the ones we've heard of.
@@ichirokawuchi7603 it ain't like he chose the president or that the president has anything to do with the actual people anyway. Just look at the US president...
@@ichirokawuchi7603 Duarte did for a while…but that was under Obama. Under Trump he switched sides. He finally renewed the agreement with the US recently. So it’s Vietnam, Japan, South Korea, Malaysia, Philippines, India, Singapore. Taiwan, Indonesia and Australia against China
I think of them now as the Asian Yugoslavia (or vice versa). Only difference is the Vietnamese to my knowledge don't have ethnic strife. Both peoples also stood up to other Communists and tried to get on better terms with the West (Yugoslavs to Stalin and the Soviets, Vietnamese to the Chinese).
So I heard on my first full day in Viet Nam. These moves China is making is just reinforcing the mistrust Viet Nam has for China. In 1979 China claimed a province in Northern Vietnam. There was a short war where Vietnam kicked China's PLA's butt. As part of their culture the Vietnamese are willing to die to keep Vietnam; is the PLA conscripts willing to do the same for China's Imperial interest?
Same here. But I don't want USA to butt in yet again. Vietnam is our best hope in SA. They are the most freedom loving people. And I just wish Vietnam to become the next power in the South China Sea. Not USA or China.
I lived and worked in Vietnam for 2.5 years. It is a very young country. Most born after the war in the 70s. Everyone I met loved the United States and Americans. They also greatly disliked China. Lots of distrust. In fact, each time a Chinese flagged vessel came within 50 miles of their shore Vietnam would send out armed SU-27 fighters to circle or harass that ship. Their military presence along the Chinese border is quite large. I enjoyed Vietnam and the Vietnamese people. They are great allies against China as that country flexes it’s muscles throughout the world.
Vietnam and China had been fighting though out the history, at least 2000 years. Whenever a new dynasty is established in China, they always try to invade Vietnam at least once. The Vietnamese people nowadays, especially the elder, are very against the China and Chinese products, though the younger generations are much more open-minded. Politically speaking, it is also because of anti-communist propaganda of the Western media (from the South Vietnam refugees in the US, Canada, Australia, ...). Ordinary Vietnamese people (who have no political knowledge) are often anti-communist, or at least anti the government. So they hate the communist government of China and also as a consequence, the communist government of Vietnam. The opposite side of communism is capitalism, and the big boss of capitalism is the United States. That explains what you experienced in Vietnam. In fact, most people here don't hate the Taiwanese although genetically they're Chinese. It's both because of Western propaganda and the aggressiveness of the CPC.
Ngọc Phát Hùng vietnam is just a great chilled out country, great people... vietnamese people did talk as you say, anti vietnam government and anti china
@@diegoaespitia i cant believe it wat u say bro. Pls be polite. I think everyone has their way, thought, genitive and the life doesnt just working. We live to have experiences and to be happy, until we feel enough so we can return to our home
vietnam is really improving though they suffered lot economically and infastructurely during long vietnam war. They did very well in preventing covid19 patients
@W.A M.P Japan and South Korea rebuilt their country with the economic and military support from the USA. Vietnam meanwhile after the Vietnam War they have to went through another Third Indochina War, which overthrew the Khmer Rouge and protecting their territory against China, and the war with China was not a small one, it was a really serious problem to Vietnam. The year that all peace treaty signed and Vietnam started to went into a peaceful era was 1992, when the last Chinese soldiers withdrew from Vietnam territory, Vietnam was exactly the poorest country on Earth at that time, with the GDP per capita less than $100. Only when the embargo was ended by the United Nation in 1995, Vietnam economy started to grow steeply
@J C there covid but very minor,several outbreak happen but it mostly back to normal now,life is back to normal though border security have been increasing do to high rate of chinese fleeing to vietnam via illegal border crossing,likely the source of the recent outbreak
Vĩnh Long 永隆 yeah, and Vietnam is now a fast growing successful economy because they dumped communist and have pivoted to a capitalist economy. Same with Ethiopia. Same with Poland. Etc You ever ask yourself why communism always fails? It failed in the USSR, China, N Korea, Vietnam, Cambodia, Cuba? And don’t say because the rest of the world didn’t trade with them. Indian was a major trading partner with the USSR. USSR, China and India and 3 of the top 3 to 5 most resource rich nations which means they had the resources available.
@Chí Phèo nguyễn you aren’t very smart if you think communist countries like the USSR, China etc didn’t interfere with capitalist nations. Both sides did the same...and who easily won? The capitalist west because their economic policies were more successful
China has 12 times the population of Vietnam. But Vietnam is the only country in SE Asia that has the guts to stand up to China. China and Vietnam has been at war for 4000 years. So this is normal for Vietnam.
Read your history. Vietnam has basically been in the shadows of China since its inception 4500 years ago as a small village. And has been at war with its northern neighbors ever since.
4500 years ago, VN may not have been at war with the China that we know as today. But they were at war with a lot of the same tribes that eventually became China. If you take a look at Chinese histories, you will note that the Chinese has always referred to its Southern neighbors as the Southern Bavarians.
I visited Vietnam in 2016 and recognize the big circle in Ho Chi Minh City (aka Saigon). Vietnam did actually dislodge the most genocidal regime on a proportionate basis in history, the Khmer Rouge. It's good that this video acknowledges this fact. The Vietnamese feel some resentment that they have never been acknowledged for this great contribution to humanity.
In fact, the time we fought with pol pot, mostly every country didn't give a shit about it but focus on calling us invader. Then when law shows how horrible the Khmer Rogue is, the whole world (once again, surprisingly forget about us and impressively focus on pol pot and his government. We feel disappointed about it, so much, but so happy that some people still know the truth. This video and this comment is an example
Keep in mind, Vietnam as a policy does not ally with foreign powers and the United States as a policy does not ally with Communist nations. However, both are pragmatic and understand that China is a threat and if anything were to go down Vietnam would be a likely battleground. So it is in the best interest of everyone that everybody gets on the same page.
Japan, an enemy that actually attacked us first quickly became our major ally in Asia. Germany, who started world war 2 European theater was also a major ally shortly after. It happens
@nhà độc tài Yang Wen Li US gave Vietnam patrol ships, the only country to have provided military aids to Vietnam over the last 20 years. For weapons from Russia, not only that Vietnam has to pay fully for, Hanoi is also required to pay weapon purchase debts from Soviet Union era, nothing was free but the truth was hidden! mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/idUSKCN1RD1YA
@nhà độc tài Yang Wen Li Bullshit you are in highland country side?, in 2017 , just little people in highland and poor people don't have Internet and smart phone, over 50% Vietnamese people also have even countryside in 2017, just highland is hard to set up internet on mountain.The truth that Vietnam is one of country have the percentage of internet user highest in Asia. Even smart phone is higher. You don't know Vietnam and USA is cooperating in oil and gas field on south china sea ?, Exxonmobil and many capitalism companies of USA have many projects about energy in Vietnam that mean Vietnam will sell energy for USA in the future. Vietnam don't need ally with USA in military, You can see USA oil companies working on south china sea,That is big problem for china more than military base. USA will have a reason to active military on south china sea.
@@datodaisuke2315 why? Vietnam wanted the US out of it's business. Fine. now they want to pull us into something that doesn't concern us. deal with China by yourself!
I am a Native American who lived in the middle of Little Saigon for many years and have Vietnamese family now and I love the Vietnamese People and Stand Ready to Defend their interests against the CCP Mafia.
How could you not mention the thousand years of conflict between the Vietnamese and the Chinese? The ancestors of the Vietnamese people have been fighting and resisting the Chinese since the beginning of history and got pushed all the way down to the corner of Southeast Asia. It has been really hard for our people to live under a giant but for now, we need to thanks China for being a force that united our people and mends the wound from the tragedy of the last century. Hopefully, the growing threat from China will propagate our nation to become a regional powerhouse.
As a American I would rather buy American and I do as much as possible. However as most products are made over seas I will happily buy from anyone other than China!
the US and Vietnam had been growing closer for a long time, basically the entire point of the TTP that people hated was to to bring the US, Japan, Vietnam, and Taiwan closer together and lay the groundwork for weakening China's influence in the region... but protectionists forget that there is more to trade than money..
TPP was supposed be a way to outmaneuver China without needing to go head to head with them which would damage both of our economies… so we threw out TPP and did exactly that.
As a person of mixed heritage, part Chinese-Vietnamese with a higher mix of Chinese, I have never had a reason to distrust a Vietnamese and had a lot of reservation with Chinese. Vietnamese valued family and trust, Chinese valued wealth and pride. Never once have I felt unsafe in Vietnam
You are stereotyping too much. It is just like saying blacks are taller and more athletic than asians because it is part of their culture and genes. To overgeneralize an entire people is not right. To say that every vietnamese is good because it is part of their nature is an oversimplication in my opinion. Every person is different. Never overgeneralize. Eventually you will find a black swan even if you think all swans are white.
@@cloudperson890 and what strugglers, you wanted capitalist then there you go dog eat dog , if you are sheep you strugglers, it the same in any country in this world now day stop being cry baby and start work your ass off
@John Smith you are wrong about a lot of things in your comment, but i will concentrate only on your last sentence. The actual fact is viet nam won the war with china in 1979. Because the main purpose of china when invaded vietnam was helping polpot , but it was failed because they stopped the war very hastily, they couldnt make much damage to us. They said that their purpose was fulfilled but actually not. Viet nam army was still actived in cambodia untill 1989, to help cambodia people defeated polpot, stop the genocide committed by polpot. That was ten years after the conflict with china.
Great video. Few things worth mentioning though: 1) Vietnam had been fighting for independence against China for more than 1000 years (179 BC - 938 AD). 100 years (1858 - 1976) of the French colonization and the Vietnam war were brief compared to that. Thus, the US might be Vietnam's worst enemy IN MODERN HISTORY, not in its entirety. 2) Vietnam allegedly launched cyber attacks on the Chinese government agencies in Jan 2020 in an attempt to uncover intel on the coronavirus. A right intention doesn't justify bad actions, but it somehow shows the Vietnamese government's distrust in the CCP. 3) Regarding the South China Sea territory, it would be great to explore the legal perspective. Most countries in the disputed areas claim their territories based on the UNCLOS 200 NM exclusive economic zone. Meanwhile, China & Taiwan claim based on the undefined and vaguely located demarcation line called nine-dash line. There's also The Hague ruling regarding the Philippines v. China (PCA case number 2013-19) on this case brought by the Philippines.
Both the ICJ and the PCA are located at the Hague. However, the PCA is not a UN court. The ICJ is. ICJ - UN Agency PCA - UN Observer Some media call the PCA "UN Court". But actually it's not true.
@John Smith Vietnam had been fighting for independence against China for more than 1000 years ----------- In terms of culture, Vietnam belongs to the Sinosphere, which is affected mainly by China, as same as Japan and Korea. Chinese characters are used widely in this culture block, with many variants in different countries. Only the government installed by the Chinese loyal to the Great Han dynasty, but the people did not, they always fight for their independence for thousand years. Despite the Vietnamese haven't invented their own writing system until 14th century, they still preserved their ancient speaking language and Chinese people can not understand it. Until 938AD, Vietnam have completely gained independence from China, not until the day that French came Vietnam attacked Cambodia ----------- The Khmer Rouge attacked Vietnam first on 5th April 1975, less than a week after the Fall of Saigon and they continued to attack several border districts of Vietnam until Vietnam declared Khmer Rouge as an enemy of Vietnamese people in 1977. Vietnam have prepared for a war with the Khmer Rouge since 1977, however, as they recognized China was standing behind the Khmer Rouge, they also have to prepared for a war against China. Until 24th December 1978, Vietnam launched an operation to recapture the areas which were lost to the Khmer Rouge from 1975 On 28th December 1978, Vietnam crossed Cambodia border On 7th January 1979, Vietnam entered Phnom Penh On 8th January 1979, the PRK, a pro-Vietnamese government founded in Phnom Penh On 17th January 1979, the last town of Khmer Rouge captured by the Vietnamese .... On 17th February 1979, China with 300.000 soldiers launched an attack of Vietnam border while Vietnam have only 50.000 militiamen, including women who joined the defense. On 6th March 1979, Vietnam called for the mobilization, prepared for a large-scale war against China, China immediately withdrew its troops from Vietnam, Vietnam decided did not trace the Chinese for later peace negotiation. The furthest point that Chinese army reached were not more than 10km inside Vietnam border, despite 6:1 ratio and modern army
@nhà độc tài Yang Wen Li Yes, they are, go and see some groups on Facebook who always complain about government policies, if the government doesn't want so they have arrested all of them. Don't speak stupidly
Incase of a war india will definitely stand with Vietnam. We have also enhanced the sale of brahmos missile to Vietnam to directly hit Chinese mainland cities in case Vietnam's sovereignty is under threat.
@@nayelhuda6945 I hope not the CCP commies!!....India's only problem is they have been way too relaxed and reliant economically on Chinese and China could deal a heavy blow to India's economy because of the reliance and the same is true even for Germany, Australia etc...but that is slowly changing and the world is waking up to the yellow bully dogs in Beijing..
@@ameyas7726 you understand that 70% of indias population is dependent on china for water right? China can win a war against India with no casualties by merely increasing the power of their dams in tibet, causing a drought in India.
@@ameyas7726 aslo china isnt exactly communist at this point and actually have original tech companies as opposed to being just a workshop for outsourcing like india
get real, stop living in the past Viet Nam could not win the wars without the help of Russia and China. It is time for Viet Nam allies with the USA, Japan, India and Australia (the Quad) against China, don't let China bully our country.
When World War 3 broke out: Nam: "Never thought I would die, fighting side by side with the Yanks" Yanks: "How about side by side with friends?" Nam: "Aye, I could do that"
@@fullmetaltheorist eh we vietnamese dont wanted to be super power country or world police all we wanted is to be left alone and respect like uncle ho say to able to stand equally to the country of 5 continal
@@yoface938 Probably not, young S.Vietnamese nowadays want to have normal relationship with us mainland Vietnam. However, that doesn't means we still get hate from them. I still get racial slurs (like why, racial slurs, we are literally same Asians) from pro-RVN on the Internet.
While they can't be conquered, it'll still bring lots of casualties. Vietnam still needs strategic allies. Remeber that Communist Vietnam almost failed had the British continued their pursuit against Ho Chi Mihn before it became popular.
Benson Chan you mean pushing smart economic and political agendas? Surely you can actually explain what they got wrong in the video rather than just saying it’s pushing a neoliberal agenda
As a Canadian Vietnamese I'm very proud of how Vietnam has progressed through the years although Vietnam is communist the people are happy they have access to the world and are not censored like China
@@outgoing4696 until they have their foot on Vietnam doorstep and the Vietnamese will send them back to wherever they belong... the chinese will never learn.
I live in Vietnam, I need to correct you that the 'anti-China' protests weren't supported by the government, they were in protest of the Vietnamese government's intended actions. The protests started when the government announced plans that would allow China (and other foreigners) to lease areas of Vietnam for 99 years. Protests aren't legal in Vietnam, so there was a crackdown, but the bill was abandoned due to the backlash. The government definitely were not in favor or supportive of these protests.
Vietnam government are not fond with protest since other country could spread false rumor and interfer to make it a violence protest but aleast in that protest they are not harsh on the civilian... Also the 99 yrs lease are just false rumor since Vietnam are not intended for the lease to actually happen, people are mostly protest about the incident where China kill Vietnamese soldier on Vietnam island
But that doesnt mean the vnese government like the chinese tho. They have raised their defense budget over 600% during 2006-2020. And remember, all the hatred towards china is from the history between vietnam and china ( which is taught by the gov’s educational system). The government main goal is not letting vietnam turns into a dangerous threat for china’s security, while still keeping an eye on them. Peace among countries is always the goal for this war-torn country.
As a Vietnam Vet I was glad the NVA went into Cambodia in 79 to end Pol Pot. That's when the CHinese incurred into the North. After all the NVA troops were in the south.
China to Pol Pot: Alright, Vietnam just suffered 20 years worth of bombing, this should be easy. You go harass the south and i'll take the north Vietnam: I like those odds
As a son from a Vietnamese Mom and a Chinese Dad, I remember our family were very political. Remember they are fighting quite often about the political issues with this two countries. This is why we are grown up in Germany. For the US, my enemy of my enemy is my friend.
because you were ally of soviet union, you got a lesson in 1980s, hope Vietnam learning somthing from history, otherwise another war would happen again
@John SmithVietnam and USA is cooperating in oil and gas field on south china sea. Exxonmobil and many capitalism companies of USA have many projects about energy in Vietnam that mean Vietnam will sell energy for USA in the future. Vietnam don't need ally with USA in military, You can see USA oil companies working on south china sea,. USA will have a reason to active military on south china sea to protect their companies like Colonizer did in Colonial era. That is a smart stagegy of Vietnam , because Vietnam promise that "Vietnam don't let any foreign military base on Vietnam land to threat other countries".
@@otsa120 Most Vietnamese people dont like china. For Donald Trump vs Obama is the mixed feeling. We have both Obama "fan" as well as Donald Trump " fan". The people are more influenced by the media would be more likely to be Obama "fan".
@@otsa120 - About Chinese: Vietnamese doesn't carry any haste again the "people", but Vietnamese will not shake hand with Chinese gov without a knife hiding somewhere. - Hongkong: we know Hongkong hate China, but Hongkong use to back US again Vietnam and spread fail information about Vietnam attack Cambodia. So we didn't see Hongkong as "trust worthy alliance" either. Maybe good trade partner, but not political partner. - Donald Trump / Obama: Vietnamese don't want and will not get involve into any conflict outside of Vietnam. And both presidents paid good attention to Vietnam. So we don't have any reason to hate any of them. If we have to pick 1, then Trump should be good. I know media hate Trump but as Vietnamese POV, Trump vs China conflict make Vietnam fat. Both China and Trump want to win Vietnamese favor so Vietnam can get more and more benefit from both side. Vietnam is key for the "Quad" to launch attack to the South of China. Vietnam also the key for China to gain control over the ASEAN area. In the past, China control Cambodia but history prove that Cambodia can't give them enough advantage over Vietnam, they need Vietnam. Vietnam is no longer a weak Pawn but rather a Pawn that very close to become a Queen.
They did not belong to any country as they was no inhabitant. However, the French claimed it and after Vietnam was divided, those islands belonged to the South Vietnam who built army base there. South Vietnam went to war with China in early 1974 over these islands. When the North Vietnam won, they claimed these islands when China said a North Vietnamese official signed a document that those islands belonged to China.
Just remember that In name of the protectorate of Vietnam, France officially occupied not only Vietnam and Spratly islands, Paracel islands but also Laos and Cambodia (vassal state of Vietnam).
@@sgcl10658 The diplomatic letter sent to China is a tactic to push USA and China in direct colflit. Today China mentions this letter as proof it is only to manipulate the Chinese people. The Chinese are not stupid and believe that this letter has legal value ...
I'm a descendant of Vietnamese who was born at the end of the 70s in Thailand. My mom was born in Laos and immigrated to Thailand at age of a few years old with her relatives. My family taught me no hate, or racism but to look at others equally. Here are my own views: 0) ChinaGov's attention is never pure. 1) Both Chinese dictators: Mao & Deng betrayed their allied partner based on Marxism ideology in the case of a dispute. 2) The U.S. picked the wrong side. 3) Khmer Rough did wrong things. 4) Thailand'Gov was unfair & threatening all the Vietnamese refugees, immigrants before rehabilitating the relationship btw Thailand & VN
Good coverage but you missed the part when Vietnam was divided, South Vietnam goverment took control of these islands and built military base there. However, China went to war with South Vietnam directly in the sea in January 1974 over these island disputes while supporting the Northern Vietnamese troops. China won and took control of these islands and the South Vietnam did protest to the United Nation but China blocking it with their veto power in the UN council. After North Vietnam unified the country, Communist Vietnam decided to claim these islands back.
Relations between Vietnam and China have deteriorated since General Secretary Le Duan and Deng Xiaoping took power (replacing Ho Chi Minh and Mao Zedong, when the two countries were close friends). Le Duan (who Ho Chi Minh chose to succeed in 1960) was a very solid national stance. He said that China helped Vietnam in the war against the US, but the CCP wanted to dominate Vietnam (like 2nd North Korea ). Therefore, Le Duan had a very tough policy towards the chinese vietnamese , forcing them to return to China and whoever chose to stay, their property was confiscated, assimilated into the Vietnamese, ... leading to the Vietnam - Khmer Rouge and Vietnam - China war. a few years later. Le Duan is a symbol of the war against the US, reunification, the designer of the South Vietnamese liberation strategy. Vietnamese people have a funny sentence, "Chuẩn như Lê Duẩn" (meaning Exactly like Le Duan =))))). I think many foreigners think that Le Duan's decision at that time was wrong. The Chinese have reason to hate him, but me and many Vietnamese still think it's right: v Vietnam - China relations are just a policy issue between the two countries. The Chinese are very talented and likable. Maybe on the Internet, many Vietnamese express their hatred for China. But in real life, Vietnamese people and Chinese people are quite similar. Vietnam has always learned a lot from China. (like the Vietnamese feudalism "learn" Chinese feudalism :v)
You are one of the sounder Vietnamese than the anti-Chinese Vietnamese person with illogical hatred comments posting on CZcams about China. They based their comments on how they feel rather on truth. The reason I’m saying this is because you express more on the fact side than the feeling side. However, agreeing or disagreeing about your comment is a different issue but I’m one of them that hears what you are saying.
If I had to wager, I'd put my money on Vietnam. They repelled multiple Mongol invasions. They launched an insurgency during Japanese occupation and, after the end of WWII, defeated the French. Likewise, they outlasted us Americans during the Vietnam War. After that, they essentially faught the People's Liberation Army to a draw in 1979, which is pretty good, considering the disparity in size between China & Vietnam.
okay. at 4:06, I have some input. Vietnam actually gained Independence from La France on 2nd September, 1945. Vietnam's independence inspired many other French colonies worldwide to rise up against the colonial govt. France came back trying to take over Vietnam again. 1954 was when France lost la bataille Điện Biên Phủ and Vietnam was divided into two under the Geneva Accord.
Incorrect, Vietnamese Communist known as Vietminh proclaimed independence in 1945 but it was not recognised by France or internationally. The communist forces at that time only controlled some rural areas of North Vietnam and were fighting the French until the battle of Điện Biên Phủ. The defeated France was forced to sue for peace in 1954 in Geneva, which created North and South Vietnam. North Vietnam was controlled by communist known as Socialist Republic of Vietnam, and South Vietnam was a new non-communist country known as Republic of Vietnam. That was the prelude for a civil war and later American involvement (much like North and South Korea situation) made it into what we have known as the Vietnam War.
Wrong. Ho Cho Minh got his inspiration of violent struggle for independence from France by learning from Haitian Revolution which overthrew French Rule in 1804, 150 years before your beloved Ho Cho Minh could repeat the success of the Haitians. Your Ho Cho Minh did not inspire any one to rise up against the conolinal French. It was the Haitians. Do not waste time on CZcams with ignorant comments in the future. Go back to school. Remember to eat those smelly French cheese.
@@cuongquan1633 I do not care about your rice. I care about your education. Remember, the Haitians rose up to overthrow French Rule in 1804, 150 years before that idiot Ho Cho Minh could follow in the footsteps of the revolutionary Haitians.
@@karllarsen8797 Wrong again. Ho Chi Minh did not get his inspiration from the Haitian Revolution. The Vietnamese got their inspiration of violent struggle for Independence to overthrow French rule from the very people who subjugated them. The Vietnamese were forced to learn French, French history, and you guessed it, the French Revolution (in 1789, which predates the Haitian Revolution). If the French underclass could rise up with subversion and wage a revolution against its own government and aristocratic elites why couldn't the Vietnamese do the same with the French ruling class at the time on their own land. Because of their arrogance, the French digged their own grave with that move, and that was the beginning of the undoing of the French colonial government, a double-edge sword if there ever was one. Next time take it back a notch if you're going to spread misinformation, ignorance, and name call. It was unnecessary to disrespect Ho Chi Minh. And if you're going to come at it like that, one ought to look no further than the current state of Haiti.
Your detail is wrong You must know Polpot is from Thailand. China agree with Thailan to support Polpot in 1979 1991. Thailan support Polpot to throw Cambodia president democracy regime before 1975 Then In 1975 1979 Thailan country order polpot to disappear Cambodian and Vietnamese because Thai want to disappear Cambodia population and stop Vietnam influences in Cambodia from Cambodia getting closer to Vietnam and develop relationships with Vietnam regime then Thai plans to make Cambodia state of Thailan. Only Vietnam help Cambodia regain independence from Polpot agent of Thai government in 1979 and 1991 but Cambodia never appreciate Vietnam saving and look at Vietnam as villain. Thailan scared to face Vietnam military’s wrath in 1979. So they don’t stop support Polpot to 1991
Everything is Chinese ancient territory hahaha 🤗Even if they told Vietnam they are our socialist brother, their imperialist ambition will never change. China attacked Vietnam approximately once every dynasty back in feudal time. No surprise if they will attack again in the near future, that's why our military initiated a modernization process recently
This is the kind of video I follow this channel for; I genuinely feel like I understand this region better than I did before I watched it. I really appreciate that you went over some of the history of China, Vietnam and Cambodia instead of just focusing on China's current expansion.
Vietnam has only developed safely since 1995 after being free from embargoes and hostility by many major countries. Apple, Samsung, LG, Pegatron, Foxcon, Luxshare, Hyundai, Lotte, Panasonic, GM ... Many multinational corporations are investing heavily in Vietnam. Large energy projects, electronics manufacturing plants and heavy industry. Vietnam will be the next big production engine. Their domestic corporations are growing fast: Viettel, Vingroup, FPT, Contecons, Sungroup ... Vietnamese children have a very high IQ. Vietnam may be the next dragon in Asia
The genocide under the rule of the Congo Free State has been estimated to be half the population of Congo. 10 to 20 million people are the range of estimates. That was about 10 to 20% of Africa's estimated population back then. Pol pot's reign of horror was nothing compared to Leopold II's torture machine that was the Congo Free State.
@DatManDaz Kurupt A horrible act, still not near the brutality of the Congo Free State though. For Leopold the the Congolese people was a resource to be exploited to depletion.
@@scott2452 The 20m estimates comes from 1904 book by the name: King Leopold's Rule In Africa. There has been a wide range of estimates. Though the ones bellow 10m has been widely questioned due to the lack of demographic data and the fact that they them selves claim to have likely heavily underestimating the actual death toll. The 20m is not very reliable either. The 10m is the one that is mostly accepted, included by the Belgium government since 1924. I am not really in the mood of giving you a long list of books and papers to read. Wikipedia is your friend.
@@phuctrinh2589 Nah, I'm Swedish. I was told about it in high school under the topic of imperialism/capitalism. But I also hade a pretty great history teacher. People should also remember that the Congo Free State was a privately owned company.
A lot of misunderstood about our country, Vietnam and I would like to clarify. As you known Vietnam is a one-party country aka communism state but the way we doing thing here is different, our economic is capitalist system, even our politic system tend to be capitalist. One-party system will help us prevent a lot of chaotic and defend all the enemies, just because our geographic is so sensitive. Being a communist country is not really as bad as you think, it not like we don't have a voice or freedom or anything, we can said and do pretty much whatever we want here. Again, it is just a label, we even found more freedom than you will ever know.
@@trungdung1822 They not gonna arrest you just because you don't like something...lol. Stop lying sir. You can like or dislike and talk about it if you want, make sure what you said is the truth, not personal attack on a person or government. Every countries acted the same way, not only Vietnam.
Might be because Vietnam has been fighting of Chinese occupation attempts longer than the United States has existed. France had a war, it lost, it admitted defeat and opened diplomatic relations. The United States had a war, it lost, it admitted defeat and opened diplomatic relations. China has declared war, not admitted defeat, opened two-faced diplomatic relations that barely amount to more than threats then try to occupy the land only to lose and have the cycle start all over again. It's been that way since before the west showed up in the region, it went back to that when the west lost there. We were, at best, an alien invasion showing up in a region and at the center of a conflict that had a much longer history than many of our governments. It's a pity we didn't learn this lesson then but maybe we can make up for it a bit by working with the Vietnamese these time around.
As a Vietnamese, to answer your question at the last minutes of video, I would say probably not. Because the sovereignty does really matter to Vietnam now, and it likely outweighs than the universal human right. Vietnamese people were resilient in war, that's right. But Vietnamese people are also tired of war. So, universal human right and war, as long as we can endure, you know the answer.
Thank you for an information-packed video. However, I would want to add some information: 1/ Sine Nguyen Dynasty, Paracel islands have been a part of Vietnam territories (appear in maps and records which still preserved until today). The French when they come to Vietnam also noted and keep records that recognized the Parcel Islands as a part of Vietnam. On March 13, 1988, China attacked and massacre 48 Vietnamese soldiers station on Gạc Ma island with warships and machine guns without warning. Recently, there are many attacks in which China warship sunk Vietnamese fishing boats and leave the fisherman to dead on the sea. 2/ This is the most unforgiving. You failed to mention about Khmer rouge attacked and genocide of Vietnamese citizens (not even women nor newborn babies was spared) which happened prior to the event of Vietnam attacked Cambodia (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ba_Ch%C3%BAc_massacre) and turn the invasion into a purely political ideology conflict. (Edit: Grammar)
The Geneva Accords1954, which had China, Soviet, USA, France as an official attendant, also recognizes Vietnam’s sovereignty over the Paracel and Spratly Islands. The Accords asked attending countries to respect independence, sovereignty and national unity and territorial integrity of Vietnam. Therefore, China’s statement of sovereignty over the two archipelagos is invalid under international law.
lots of information which you have given here contains a lot of incorrect information. Vietnam was independent in 1945, not 1954. The Paracels and Spratlys have never been recognized internationally as China's. The Qing Dynasty of China did not recognize China's sovereignty over the Hoang Sa and Truong Sa. There is a document that the Qing Dynasty does not recognize the sovereignty of the two archipelagoes that are still kept in the British Royal Family. The French have never recognized China's sovereignty. During the colonial period, the French always recognized the two archipelagoes of Truong Sa and Hoang Sa as belonging to Vietnam. so did the Americans and it was the Americans who kept the Spratly and Paracel Islands for Vietnam from 1954 to 1974. Please find out more accurate information before posting it to the public, to avoid misunderstandings.
heritage/cultural-connection between vietnam and china makes things difficult to describe. viets are yue, as VIETnam is YUEnan in chinese. the people in guangdong and some neighboring provinces are considered Yue Chinese; cantonese is a Yue language. Gin people are basically vietnamese people living in china, as they speak the language but the written form is not the latin version, it's still the one using chinese characters. vietnam is not part of china and shouldn't be, but the connection is clearly there. song dynasty and the dynasties before always go after Dai Viet (vietnam). yes, china did attack korea, central asia, and other places, but not every dynasty tho. for the most part, the unified china would go after viet land. yuan, ming, and qing had different reasons for attacking. the dynasties before attacked as "reconquest" technically. i do know that before qin/han dynasty, southern china used to be populated with full-blooded yue people, but after qin/han conquered yue tribes, the yue people were pretty much mixed after a while. vietnam considers Kingdom of Nanyue as a viet dynasty, but it's half-half (han and viet). it's a weird situation.
@@zgt8838 Not by choice. So I do think a lot Southern Chinese believe they are Han but they are 100% Han, definitely have Yue blood. Take ppl of Hainan Island for example, their language sounds very Filipino but they claim they Han.
Good news to hear that Vietnam despite the past conflicts, it's on its way to rapid progress. Now coz of China, part of its precious money will go to military hardware.
I learned so much watching this video. I kind of thought I was knowledgeable about the subject, but now I realize I wasn’t as knowledgeable as I believed..
Wow! I haven’t been to this channel before, I think I will come again, definitely a better use of time to come here and learn about why stuff is happening than switching on 24-hour news and watching people speculating about stuff that might happen in the future, especially when those people don’t know what they’re talking about.
Vietnamese history is organized by periods of northern (China) domination and resistance. Even though we expanded south, fought, and taken over territories of the Khmer and Champa kingdoms, but we only focus on one enemy in the history book, China. This could be the result of propaganda policies going back more than a millennium as Vietnamese dynasties (sometime of Han Chinese ethnicity: Ngô, Lý, Trần) sought to maintain independence from Chinese dynasties that persistently sought to recreate the empire of the Han and Tang dynasties, which included the area of present day north Vietnam. Oversea Vietnamese hates Communist Vietnamese because of the war, but they are united in their support for Trump because they believe that Trump is f’ing up China.
Ngô, Lý and Trần dynasty are not Han Chinese. They are Vietnamese living in Southern China ( used to be Baiyue land and Vietnamese is one of Baiyue ethnics).
@@traaotuong6107, Technically the story tells us that Vietnamese (Kinh) are from two Baiyue tribes, Âu and Lạc. The DNA shows that they are related to the Dai people who is also related to the Thai. As for Ngô, Lý, and Trần dynasties, you might need to do some more research to add to your understanding. Millennia of propaganda can steer you away from a lot of information. But identity has more to do with what people believe rather than what actually happened. So you’re welcome to continue to believe that there is no Han Chinese dynasties in Vietnamese history and a millennium under Han Chinese rule, from the Han to the Tang dynasties, has no impact. I do have doubt if the Lý dynasty was Han Chinese since Lý Công Uẩn was an orphan, so who really know about his parentage or where his family from. In reality we are all human and what separates us is very tiny. What we think separates us beyond the physical exterior is reinforced by what we think is our culture, language, and history. Those factors can be shaped and influenced for any purpose.
Speak for yourself. I and the vast majority of overseas Vietnamese hate Trump. He's a white supremacist, a pathological liar, a con artist, and a man without a moral compass. It's only Trump worshipping Vietnamese that support Trump. They turned from a pro-democracy anti-VC movement into an anti-democracy anti-China (and therefore pro-VC) movement for Trump. The VC is supposed to be their #1 enemy, but bc of their blind love for Trump, they justified Trump's closeness with the VC by making China their #1 enemy. They even went to DC to attack to the seat of US democracy.
@@phan1182 “Speak for myself”???LOL. All you need to do is look at your own family and I guarantee you’ll find at least one trumpeteer or Q “Annam” devotee. “I and the vast majority of overseas Vietnamese,” really??? Speak for yourself LMAO. Go to little Saigon and see how many Vietnamese there support Trump... Learn how to read with your eyes rather than your emotion, it seems to me you think I’m a Trump supporter. Sure, my previous comment is a bit of a generalization because not all overseas Vietnamese support Trump, I guess that’s why you got a bit sensitive, but the fact is that the majority of the overseas Vietnamese community supports Trump. The majority of them have always been Republicans due to their anti communist stand and they blamed the Democrats for the fall of Saigon. Their support for Trump is not a surprise, they voted for Republicans before, and they still do now. For decades I have heard former officers of ARVN espousing fascist sentiments as they vowed to stamp out any narratives that put them it a poor light with their fist. Their victim-hood narrative is on par with Versailles Treaty for the Nazi and the Black Shirt, “đâm sau lưng chiến sĩ.” I’m old enough to remember them calling up the youth stomp out counter protestors supporting freedom of expression at the Hi-Tek protest in Bolsa. Back in South Vietnam when they were in power, their only interest was to protect the status quo with the elite ruling a corrupt regime. They did little for the people but expect them to bleed for them, “hy sinh vì tổ quốc.” They failed, or didn’t give a fuck, to protect the poor from both the Viet Cong and the American troops. Leaving them to be extorted by the VC at night and burned out by American napalm during the day. Their only fucking excuse was “tại vì lúc đó là chiến tranh.” If you want to know how incompetent the vast majority of those ARVN fuckers were, all you have to do is look at Black April to see how quickly Saigon collapsed. The only people worth memorializing is the 18th Division. It’s really easy for a bunch of fascists to support a fascist. He speaks their language, and I’m not talking about Vietnamese. Anyway, check yourself. GTFOH with that “I and the vast majority” bullshit, and you telling me to speak for myself SMH. Look, I’m glad y’all fucking progressive and all. It’s great to see that since the Vietnamese overseas community is not exactly a bastion of liberalism.
Throughout history, Vietnam has always been invaded by China. China is 30 times bigger than Vietnam, its population 15 times, has lots of nuclear weapons and you said " they fought many times against each other ". That is false and not logical. Only China has attacked and INVADED Vietnam for many thousands of years in history, and they have always done so.
I remember watching "The Killing Fields" when I was about 10 yo. To say this movie didn't have an effect on me is an understatement. Worth a watch if you haven't see it.
Pol pot was a psychopath. There was a policy for soldiers not to waste bullets on children. What they did was to grab babies by their feet and smashed them against a large tree. This is beyond cruel.
During pandemic I learned so much about human history. And it's soul crushing. Throughout history every country, race, religion has committed countless actrocities. And they still happen to this day. Where is the Utopias and paradises scifi movies promised us?
Life is: promises n promises & nothing. You work your ass off to try to make a living and make a life for yourself and your family and then some schmuck for another country comes in and kills you and takes your s*** oh wait a minute they did that to their own people and their own country. How many millions did mao kill?
from perspective of Vietnamese: Cambodia attacks Vietnamese border after Vietnam reunification because back in the day the Me Kong delta was belong to Khmer empire, so they want it back.
I support the US but not to defend Vietnam. Right now it is a good opportunity to promote democracy in Vietnam. The defense of Vietnam will come after Vietnam becomes a democratic country.
The US will never havr to defend VN because VN will never ever ask for outside help, it's always been their policy. But the two countries need each other as strategic partner in the region, not a military ally.
Download Newsvoice for free: newsvoice.com/visualpolitik
Let’s fix the news. Together!
Are you going to talk about the ongoing WAR between Azerbaijan and Armenia? For a great analysis of the Conflict between these two nations, it's origins, future and possible SOLUTIONS check out: czcams.com/video/2oAyBHztqxY/video.html&ab_channel=MyTake
The idea of the unbiased news app sounds good but upvotes on Reddit made it largely biased.
I know this an unrelated note, but was i the only viewer of this channel that noticed a video from this channel about michigan today? When i tried to open it, it was listed as a private video? Because I'm from Michigan and i was looking forward to get this channel's perspective because i respect a lot of the work out of this channel and was a bit disappointed that i wasn't able to view it.
@Covid 19 ist Fledermaus-Superaids. No, it is not simon, btw, simon has a new channel. Whether, he is still with this channel, i don't know.
Hey there, just a fact check - Vietnam population certainly did not rise on average 7% per year, at least not the last decade.
"Vietnam launching cyber attacks on China..."
America: Hello there! Wanna be best friends for life?!
Bet the ccp didn't like that too much. Although they're habitually doing it to western countries. Go figure
If they're named internally as Knights of Hanoi, I'mma laugh hard for that.
No one is a permanent friend or a permanent enemy in this world. It just depends on the circumstances.
@@joshlewis575 As if the Americans don't launch cyberattacks of their own lol. One of the most infamous cyberattacks of all was carried out by the US (stuxnet), and that's just one of the ones we've heard of.
Josh Lewis I bet in your mind, John Biden is bad etc etc etc while Trump is the best etc etc etc
Get a new processor for your head please
As Filipino, I support our neighbor Vietnam against China.
But your President support china.
@@ichirokawuchi7603 it ain't like he chose the president or that the president has anything to do with the actual people anyway. Just look at the US president...
@@ichirokawuchi7603 I encourage the world to ignore our president
China is not the one impulse to expand.
@@ichirokawuchi7603 Duarte did for a while…but that was under Obama. Under Trump he switched sides. He finally renewed the agreement with the US recently. So it’s Vietnam, Japan, South Korea, Malaysia, Philippines, India, Singapore. Taiwan, Indonesia and Australia against China
Vietnam ...We are with you from India...
Thx brother we will end this Chinese thread together
Nah dude, they despite the Indian from their core lol.
@@maxzmarx9159 what no we don’t, why would we hate Indian people 😆
We chinese will conquer all asia. India ans veitnam will be deated!!! Great china again🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳💪💪💪💪💪💪💪
@@user-gy7ih4tw4q ur ego XD
Vietnamese people are some of the toughest resilient folks on the planet.
@@Channel17961 So you are saying you are not tough. You been invaded many times and still resilient as hell. Most respect.
@@Atclav 🙏 thank you. She meant that we re peaceful people and don’t like war
I think of them now as the Asian Yugoslavia (or vice versa). Only difference is the Vietnamese to my knowledge don't have ethnic strife. Both peoples also stood up to other Communists and tried to get on better terms with the West (Yugoslavs to Stalin and the Soviets, Vietnamese to the Chinese).
The war with the US was just a minor interlude in Vietnam's 1,000 year war with China according to the Vietnamese I know.
This is true
The story of a rebellious son against his father.
So I heard on my first full day in Viet Nam. These moves China is making is just reinforcing the mistrust Viet Nam has for China. In 1979 China claimed a province in Northern Vietnam. There was a short war where Vietnam kicked China's PLA's butt. As part of their culture the Vietnamese are willing to die to keep Vietnam; is the PLA conscripts willing to do the same for China's Imperial interest?
@@SprDie The Vietnamese are NOT HAN. China is Not the Father.
and the US should not get involved with Vietnam again. let the 1000 year war continue for all i care. China can nuke them for all i care.
As a fellow southeast asian and remembering their struggles in the past, I’m with the Vietnamese 100% 👌
Fully support these Asians fighting against each other. 😘😘😘
@gallya Wumao detected!
@@TPerm-hj4sf asia for asian
Thank you friend!
Same here. But I don't want USA to butt in yet again. Vietnam is our best hope in SA. They are the most freedom loving people. And I just wish Vietnam to become the next power in the South China Sea. Not USA or China.
I lived and worked in Vietnam for 2.5 years. It is a very young country. Most born after the war in the 70s. Everyone I met loved the United States and Americans. They also greatly disliked China. Lots of distrust. In fact, each time a Chinese flagged vessel came within 50 miles of their shore Vietnam would send out armed SU-27 fighters to circle or harass that ship. Their military presence along the Chinese border is quite large. I enjoyed Vietnam and the Vietnamese people. They are great allies against China as that country flexes it’s muscles throughout the world.
Vietnam and China had been fighting though out the history, at least 2000 years. Whenever a new dynasty is established in China, they always try to invade Vietnam at least once. The Vietnamese people nowadays, especially the elder, are very against the China and Chinese products, though the younger generations are much more open-minded.
Politically speaking, it is also because of anti-communist propaganda of the Western media (from the South Vietnam refugees in the US, Canada, Australia, ...). Ordinary Vietnamese people (who have no political knowledge) are often anti-communist, or at least anti the government. So they hate the communist government of China and also as a consequence, the communist government of Vietnam. The opposite side of communism is capitalism, and the big boss of capitalism is the United States.
That explains what you experienced in Vietnam.
In fact, most people here don't hate the Taiwanese although genetically they're Chinese. It's both because of Western propaganda and the aggressiveness of the CPC.
@@ngocphathung4463 Not all older people are against as my late parents were not. My uncle is though and it is annoying!!
Ngọc Phát Hùng vietnam is just a great chilled out country, great people... vietnamese people did talk as you say, anti vietnam government and anti china
@日月所照 We're not allies yet, the government are (probably) neutral while the people loves the the Americans, what's wrong with that?
Let us hope all World come together and break China to pieces
I am an American living in Vietnam and feel so fortunate to be here!
You're a fortunate son, eh?
@StanislavyeungHK wassup ?
Go home English teacher. get a real job
@StanislavyeungHK good morning
@@diegoaespitia i cant believe it wat u say bro. Pls be polite. I think everyone has their way, thought, genitive and the life doesnt just working. We live to have experiences and to be happy, until we feel enough so we can return to our home
Vietnam be like : I'm communist, but with more capitalist thingy
Communist with Capitalist Characteristics
USA be like, we are against Islamic dictatorship > support Saudi Arabia, we are against communism > support Vietnam
@Ryūjin Grad a totalitarian Kingdom is a form of dictatorship.
pretty sure china is way more capitalist xDD
@Ryūjin Grad you just described a dictatorship
vietnam is really improving though they suffered lot economically and infastructurely during long vietnam war. They did very well in preventing covid19 patients
lovely Afrain #JustMonika #LarryLawton
@W.A M.P Japan and South Korea rebuilt their country with the economic and military support from the USA. Vietnam meanwhile after the Vietnam War they have to went through another Third Indochina War, which overthrew the Khmer Rouge and protecting their territory against China, and the war with China was not a small one, it was a really serious problem to Vietnam. The year that all peace treaty signed and Vietnam started to went into a peaceful era was 1992, when the last Chinese soldiers withdrew from Vietnam territory, Vietnam was exactly the poorest country on Earth at that time, with the GDP per capita less than $100. Only when the embargo was ended by the United Nation in 1995, Vietnam economy started to grow steeply
@J C there covid but very minor,several outbreak happen but it mostly back to normal now,life is back to normal though border security have been increasing do to high rate of chinese fleeing to vietnam via illegal border crossing,likely the source of the recent outbreak
Vĩnh Long 永隆 yeah, and Vietnam is now a fast growing successful economy because they dumped communist and have pivoted to a capitalist economy. Same with Ethiopia. Same with Poland. Etc
You ever ask yourself why communism always fails? It failed in the USSR, China, N Korea, Vietnam, Cambodia, Cuba? And don’t say because the rest of the world didn’t trade with them. Indian was a major trading partner with the USSR. USSR, China and India and 3 of the top 3 to 5 most resource rich nations which means they had the resources available.
@Chí Phèo nguyễn you aren’t very smart if you think communist countries like the USSR, China etc didn’t interfere with capitalist nations. Both sides did the same...and who easily won? The capitalist west because their economic policies were more successful
You forgot pol plot killed vietnamese people in Cambodia. That's what also sparked vietnam to invade.
They also killed people in the border villages.
The Khmer Rouge killed around 2 millions people including it own people and other races, and the PLA help them.
What actually spark the invasion was Pol Pot killing Vietnamese in Vietnam...
they crossed the border and they murdered whole Vietnamese in the village
@@mrpuss2519 In my hometown, Ba Chuc, An Giang in Vietnam pol pot killed millions of people 😭😭😭
USA ain't propping up nothing. The best way I could describe Vietnam is that "the juice ain't worth the squeeze". Love to Vietnam from Ireland.
There's a similar expression in Chinese, 鸡肋, or chicken rib, which implies there's not much to eat while seems a bit wasteful to ditch right away.
Combining with Taiwan, Japan, Philippines, and South Korea, there you have it.
China has 12 times the population of Vietnam. But Vietnam is the only country in SE Asia that has the guts to stand up to China.
China and Vietnam has been at war for 4000 years. So this is normal for Vietnam.
4000 years??? What are you talking about?
just 1000+
Read your history. Vietnam has basically been in the shadows of China since its inception 4500 years ago as a small village. And has been at war with its northern neighbors ever since.
@@skygrey7237 4500 years ago,China was just several cities situating in the Henan province today which is thousands of kilometers away from Vietnam
4500 years ago, VN may not have been at war with the China that we know as today. But they were at war with a lot of the same tribes that eventually became China. If you take a look at Chinese histories, you will note that the Chinese has always referred to its Southern neighbors as the Southern Bavarians.
I visited Vietnam in 2016 and recognize the big circle in Ho Chi Minh City (aka Saigon). Vietnam did actually dislodge the most genocidal regime on a proportionate basis in history, the Khmer Rouge. It's good that this video acknowledges this fact. The Vietnamese feel some resentment that they have never been acknowledged for this great contribution to humanity.
Now Vietnam is helping Africa by building internet infrastructure
@@bamboo9666 if you know Quang Linh Vlogs channel on CZcams you'll know what Vietnam's doing for Africa more
Nah it's okay :D
I'm Vietnamese btw, our teacher said we do that to make sure our country safe, even everyone thought we invade, we still do it
In fact, the time we fought with pol pot, mostly every country didn't give a shit about it but focus on calling us invader. Then when law shows how horrible the Khmer Rogue is, the whole world (once again, surprisingly forget about us and impressively focus on pol pot and his government. We feel disappointed about it, so much, but so happy that some people still know the truth. This video and this comment is an example
Funny enough Vietnam is America's strongest ally in Southeast Asia. That's so weird to think about.
Keep in mind, Vietnam as a policy does not ally with foreign powers and the United States as a policy does not ally with Communist nations. However, both are pragmatic and understand that China is a threat and if anything were to go down Vietnam would be a likely battleground. So it is in the best interest of everyone that everybody gets on the same page.
Japan, an enemy that actually attacked us first quickly became our major ally in Asia. Germany, who started world war 2 European theater was also a major ally shortly after. It happens
@nhà độc tài Yang Wen Li US gave Vietnam patrol ships, the only country to have provided military aids to Vietnam over the last 20 years. For weapons from Russia, not only that Vietnam has to pay fully for, Hanoi is also required to pay weapon purchase debts from Soviet Union era, nothing was free but the truth was hidden! mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/idUSKCN1RD1YA
@nhà độc tài Yang Wen Li Bullshit you are in highland country side?, in 2017 , just little people in highland and poor people don't have Internet and smart phone, over 50% Vietnamese people also have even countryside in 2017, just highland is hard to set up internet on mountain.The truth that Vietnam is one of country have the percentage of internet user highest in Asia. Even smart phone is higher. You don't know Vietnam and USA is cooperating in oil and gas field on south china sea ?, Exxonmobil and many capitalism companies of USA have many projects about energy in Vietnam that mean Vietnam will sell energy for USA in the future. Vietnam don't need ally with USA in military, You can see USA oil companies working on south china sea,That is big problem for china more than military base. USA will have a reason to active military on south china sea.
@@DragonflyPlus both US oil and Russia oil companies
This just proves how useless the Vietnam war was
No, it's mean a lot for Thailand, South Korean, HongKong and specialy Singapore.
If the US leaves VN alone with its own problems, maybe now we are richer than Japan and Korea combined, and may become closest US ally
@@TonyLePM Vietnam has nothing to offer the US. stupid to get involved in a dispute between them and the PRC. let China have it's way.
@@paulroese1376 wow, such a 1st world comment.
@@datodaisuke2315 why? Vietnam wanted the US out of it's business. Fine. now they want to pull us into something that doesn't concern us. deal with China by yourself!
"only we can save us, Any help has a personal benefit" VNese always understand that
stop corruption that will save Viet Nam,
I hear you brother
That same rhetoric should echo in the internal affair.
"A friend in need in a friend indeed" hard to tell
@@LELE-qm3tv stop corruption, that will save the world from a lot of hardship
I’m glad Vietnam is one of the few countries that can see past China’s lies.
@林清醒 Because your goverment is corrupt. I don't want VN and China to go to war because it will harm the chinese
What lies ??
@@davidnguyen2474 harm the vietnamese u mean. I am sure Vietnam and china can be friends as vietnam has been influenced by Chinese culture.
@@mrcool2107 *harm both of the country
@女版阿伟 xue hua piao piao
2:42 “ Some Vietnamese hackers stole data about covid 19 from the Chinese government”
Rest of the world: I see that as an absolute win.
This video is full of shit and lies
well good for the hackers
@@d4songcan Yeah for real they really stole nothing
I’m more impressed that Vietnam has computers.
@@whatfreedom7 Do you live under a rock?
I am a Native American who lived in the middle of Little Saigon for many years and have Vietnamese family now and I love the Vietnamese People and Stand Ready to Defend their interests against the CCP Mafia.
How could you not mention the thousand years of conflict between the Vietnamese and the Chinese? The ancestors of the Vietnamese people have been fighting and resisting the Chinese since the beginning of history and got pushed all the way down to the corner of Southeast Asia. It has been really hard for our people to live under a giant but for now, we need to thanks China for being a force that united our people and mends the wound from the tragedy of the last century. Hopefully, the growing threat from China will propagate our nation to become a regional powerhouse.
Johan Phan So stop copying China
Quasar Copy what?
@Tao Xu better than those who don't know where their roots come from, only know that they are Chinese. LOSER
@Tao Xu wait that. South china and north china belongs to china itself
But China has influenced Vietnam with its culture
Buying tech stuff made in Vietnam, is much better alternative.
czcams.com/video/Td08ovJ9M00/video.html
As a American I would rather buy American and I do as much as possible. However as most products are made over seas I will happily buy from anyone other than China!
@@jbird4461 ty
the US and Vietnam had been growing closer for a long time, basically the entire point of the TTP that people hated was to to bring the US, Japan, Vietnam, and Taiwan closer together and lay the groundwork for weakening China's influence in the region... but protectionists forget that there is more to trade than money..
Common sense always wins. Pity not much of that to be found in the US.
The fact we have this coalition without copyright r@ping half of Asia shows we made the right call.
💯 💯 💯
TPP was supposed be a way to outmaneuver China without needing to go head to head with them which would damage both of our economies… so we threw out TPP and did exactly that.
As a person of mixed heritage, part Chinese-Vietnamese with a higher mix of Chinese, I have never had a reason to distrust a Vietnamese and had a lot of reservation with Chinese.
Vietnamese valued family and trust, Chinese valued wealth and pride. Never once have I felt unsafe in Vietnam
You are stereotyping too much. It is just like saying blacks are taller and more athletic than asians because it is part of their culture and genes. To overgeneralize an entire people is not right. To say that every vietnamese is good because it is part of their nature is an oversimplication in my opinion. Every person is different. Never overgeneralize. Eventually you will find a black swan even if you think all swans are white.
Where in Vietnam? Dont just say "Vietnam" lmao, u could spend your entire life in quận 2 and not know of the strugglr of the common people.
@@cloudperson890 and what strugglers, you wanted capitalist then there you go dog eat dog , if you are sheep you strugglers, it the same in any country in this world now day stop being cry baby and start work your ass off
@@nganguyenthi4736 Please do làm ơn try to be coherent, I understand english is not your first language, we are all vietnamese here.
@John Smith you are wrong about a lot of things in your comment, but i will concentrate only on your last sentence. The actual fact is viet nam won the war with china in 1979. Because the main purpose of china when invaded vietnam was helping polpot , but it was failed because they stopped the war very hastily, they couldnt make much damage to us. They said that their purpose was fulfilled but actually not. Viet nam army was still actived in cambodia untill 1989, to help cambodia people defeated polpot, stop the genocide committed by polpot. That was ten years after the conflict with china.
Great video. Few things worth mentioning though:
1) Vietnam had been fighting for independence against China for more than 1000 years (179 BC - 938 AD). 100 years (1858 - 1976) of the French colonization and the Vietnam war were brief compared to that. Thus, the US might be Vietnam's worst enemy IN MODERN HISTORY, not in its entirety.
2) Vietnam allegedly launched cyber attacks on the Chinese government agencies in Jan 2020 in an attempt to uncover intel on the coronavirus. A right intention doesn't justify bad actions, but it somehow shows the Vietnamese government's distrust in the CCP.
3) Regarding the South China Sea territory, it would be great to explore the legal perspective. Most countries in the disputed areas claim their territories based on the UNCLOS 200 NM exclusive economic zone. Meanwhile, China & Taiwan claim based on the undefined and vaguely located demarcation line called nine-dash line. There's also The Hague ruling regarding the Philippines v. China (PCA case number 2013-19) on this case brought by the Philippines.
Good additions.
I don't think Taiwan necessarily unanimously supports the 9 dash line, I've heard it's just the KMT party which leans more pro China unification.
Both the ICJ and the PCA are located at the Hague. However, the PCA is not a UN court. The ICJ is.
ICJ - UN Agency
PCA - UN Observer
Some media call the PCA "UN Court". But actually it's not true.
@John Smith
Vietnam had been fighting for independence against China for more than 1000 years
-----------
In terms of culture, Vietnam belongs to the Sinosphere, which is affected mainly by China, as same as Japan and Korea. Chinese characters are used widely in this culture block, with many variants in different countries.
Only the government installed by the Chinese loyal to the Great Han dynasty, but the people did not, they always fight for their independence for thousand years. Despite the Vietnamese haven't invented their own writing system until 14th century, they still preserved their ancient speaking language and Chinese people can not understand it.
Until 938AD, Vietnam have completely gained independence from China, not until the day that French came
Vietnam attacked Cambodia
-----------
The Khmer Rouge attacked Vietnam first on 5th April 1975, less than a week after the Fall of Saigon and they continued to attack several border districts of Vietnam until Vietnam declared Khmer Rouge as an enemy of Vietnamese people in 1977. Vietnam have prepared for a war with the Khmer Rouge since 1977, however, as they recognized China was standing behind the Khmer Rouge, they also have to prepared for a war against China.
Until 24th December 1978, Vietnam launched an operation to recapture the areas which were lost to the Khmer Rouge from 1975
On 28th December 1978, Vietnam crossed Cambodia border
On 7th January 1979, Vietnam entered Phnom Penh
On 8th January 1979, the PRK, a pro-Vietnamese government founded in Phnom Penh
On 17th January 1979, the last town of Khmer Rouge captured by the Vietnamese
....
On 17th February 1979, China with 300.000 soldiers launched an attack of Vietnam border while Vietnam have only 50.000 militiamen, including women who joined the defense.
On 6th March 1979, Vietnam called for the mobilization, prepared for a large-scale war against China, China immediately withdrew its troops from Vietnam, Vietnam decided did not trace the Chinese for later peace negotiation.
The furthest point that Chinese army reached were not more than 10km inside Vietnam border, despite 6:1 ratio and modern army
@nhà độc tài Yang Wen Li Yes, they are, go and see some groups on Facebook who always complain about government policies, if the government doesn't want so they have arrested all of them. Don't speak stupidly
Incase of a war india will definitely stand with Vietnam. We have also enhanced the sale of brahmos missile to Vietnam to directly hit Chinese mainland cities in case Vietnam's sovereignty is under threat.
bruh india vs china lmao. i know who im putting my bets on man
@@nayelhuda6945 I hope not the CCP commies!!....India's only problem is they have been way too relaxed and reliant economically on Chinese and China could deal a heavy blow to India's economy because of the reliance and the same is true even for Germany, Australia etc...but that is slowly changing and the world is waking up to the yellow bully dogs in Beijing..
@@ameyas7726 you understand that 70% of indias population is dependent on china for water right? China can win a war against India with no casualties by merely increasing the power of their dams in tibet, causing a drought in India.
@@ameyas7726 aslo china isnt exactly communist at this point and actually have original tech companies as opposed to being just a workshop for outsourcing like india
Vietnam always LOVES India!
China, don't mess with Vietnam.
Just ask France and the US.
get real, stop living in the past Viet Nam could not win the wars without the help of Russia and China. It is time for Viet Nam allies with the USA, Japan, India and Australia (the Quad) against China, don't let China bully our country.
@Tong Su lol shut up 50 cent, ur comment is worthless. Like 1 billion of your.
@@LELE-qm3tv
- What make you believe the Quad will help Vietnam ?
- Remember Philippine ?
- Remember both USA and China supported Khmer Rouge ?
My dude. China was the first to know the consequence.
China could ask itself for that matter. It got its ass kicked more than France and the US combined!
When World War 3 broke out:
Nam: "Never thought I would die, fighting side by side with the Yanks"
Yanks: "How about side by side with friends?"
Nam: "Aye, I could do that"
#MilkTeaAlliance 👍 .
🇲🇾 💞 🇻🇳 💞 🇺🇲 🤜 🇨🇳 .
Enemy of my enemy is my friend 👍 .
Ừ, chắc đồng chí không biết chứ mình và Mỹ sát cánh từ tận ww2 rồi
Alliance, kids.
The enemy of my enemy is my friend
Or the enemy of my enemy is my enemy.
An enemy today may become a friend tomorrow if a new power threatens you tomorrow.
Enemy of my enemy is my other enemy - USA.
@@fullmetaltheorist eh we vietnamese dont wanted to be super power country or world police all we wanted is to be left alone and respect like uncle ho say to able to stand equally to the country of 5 continal
Im from indonesia
New a dude from Vietnam who was in one of my classes in highschool, love to Vietnam 🇻🇳 from Canada 🇨🇦
If he’s an immigrant his family would probably take offense for using that flag lol.
@@yoface938 Probably not, young S.Vietnamese nowadays want to have normal relationship with us mainland Vietnam. However, that doesn't means we still get hate from them. I still get racial slurs (like why, racial slurs, we are literally same Asians) from pro-RVN on the Internet.
The US defending vietnam is pointless. You can't defend something that can't be conquered.
Leonardo Franzin Ribeiro chinese have been trying for 4000 years. Actually vietnam is in war against china since its creation
While they can't be conquered, it'll still bring lots of casualties. Vietnam still needs strategic allies. Remeber that Communist Vietnam almost failed had the British continued their pursuit against Ho Chi Mihn before it became popular.
@@stinkybg Hot damn. After 4000 yrs of Vietnam vs the world, how is Vietnam still standing and winning?
@@stinkybg No they haven't. It's been about 1000ish years.
@Finn Hansen Yeah i know, same goes for indochina. But you know, memes.
My money is on vietnam.
Me too
Thanks let beat these coro China
As tough as Vietnam are this is not the Vietnam War against the West Vietnam has a border with China which is a big f****** problem
My money is on the sandal warriors too.
Vietnam is not only much smaller than China. But per capita, is also much poorer. Vietnam is like a mini India.
Whoever is making your thumbnails deserves a raise!
i love this really really informative
And extremely biased... always pushing some sort of neoliberal agenda...
69th like. Here you go.
FR
Benson Chan you mean pushing smart economic and political agendas? Surely you can actually explain what they got wrong in the video rather than just saying it’s pushing a neoliberal agenda
I just can't get over the fact that you sound exactly like Trump when you say ChAina. :)
Ha I noticed that too
He needs to see the dentist too
@The Gentle Guy he isn't english and don't you dare call a scottsman english!
@@twohorse123 he smokes a lot.
Trump's mother is Scottish. The host has a Scottish Glasgow accent.
*China is threatening Vietnam*
Vietnam: Did we just become best friends?
USA: Yep
*China glaring at the new friendship*
Starts at 1:08
*salute*
This is the most important comment of the video.
I see your comment when im at 1:06
Love Vietnam from the Philippines
As a Canadian Vietnamese I'm very proud of how Vietnam has progressed through the years although Vietnam is communist the people are happy they have access to the world and are not censored like China
access to the world? what do you mean? have you mix china with north korea?
@@jacoblam8433 sorry to be more specific meaning freedom of information
@@khanhcongle8701 oh please. they have access to pornhub too. if that is what you are worried about
We are pretty damn luckier than the Chinese
@@dangle3392 sure. tell that to the vietnamese on the countryside
Vietnam needs to put the country’s economy first and create peace around the world. No conflict, no wars, it has already affected enough Vietnamese
Unfortunately not as you think because my country Vietnam is always invaded by China
Unfortunately, Vietnamese do hope for peace, but fuck no
God: "There will be war, for my own shit and giggle"
@@outgoing4696 until they have their foot on Vietnam doorstep and the Vietnamese will send them back to wherever they belong... the chinese will never learn.
I live in Vietnam, I need to correct you that the 'anti-China' protests weren't supported by the government, they were in protest of the Vietnamese government's intended actions.
The protests started when the government announced plans that would allow China (and other foreigners) to lease areas of Vietnam for 99 years. Protests aren't legal in Vietnam, so there was a crackdown, but the bill was abandoned due to the backlash. The government definitely were not in favor or supportive of these protests.
Vietnam government are not fond with protest since other country could spread false rumor and interfer to make it a violence protest but aleast in that protest they are not harsh on the civilian... Also the 99 yrs lease are just false rumor since Vietnam are not intended for the lease to actually happen, people are mostly protest about the incident where China kill Vietnamese soldier on Vietnam island
You aren’t wrong.
But that doesnt mean the vnese government like the chinese tho. They have raised their defense budget over 600% during 2006-2020.
And remember, all the hatred towards china is from the history between vietnam and china ( which is taught by the gov’s educational system). The government main goal is not letting vietnam turns into a dangerous threat for china’s security, while still keeping an eye on them.
Peace among countries is always the goal for this war-torn country.
Vietnam: *puts on schoolbag*
"Here i go fighting gigantic empires again..."
New Simon is coming along nicely.
Better than the other guy. Him n his hawking bunk chinese products.
we will watch his career with great interest
Shiney* new Simon
I still like Simon more ... 😢
Where is old Simon?
No lasting friends.....no lasting enemies......only lasting Interests 😓😓😓
As a Vietnam Vet I was glad the NVA went into Cambodia in 79 to end Pol Pot. That's when the CHinese incurred into the North. After all the NVA troops were in the south.
China to Pol Pot: Alright, Vietnam just suffered 20 years worth of bombing, this should be easy. You go harass the south and i'll take the north
Vietnam: I like those odds
As a son from a Vietnamese Mom and a Chinese Dad, I remember our family were very political. Remember they are fighting quite often about the political issues with this two countries. This is why we are grown up in Germany.
For the US, my enemy of my enemy is my friend.
As a vietnamese living in Hanoi, I can confirm that this is true
because you were ally of soviet union, you got a lesson in 1980s, hope Vietnam learning somthing from history, otherwise another war would happen again
May I ask, how do Vietnamese view Chinese, Hong Kong and Donald Trump / Obama?
@John SmithVietnam and USA is cooperating in oil and gas field on south china sea. Exxonmobil and many capitalism companies of USA have many projects about energy in Vietnam that mean Vietnam will sell energy for USA in the future. Vietnam don't need ally with USA in military, You can see USA oil companies working on south china sea,. USA will have a reason to active military on south china sea to protect their companies like Colonizer did in Colonial era. That is a smart stagegy of Vietnam , because Vietnam promise that "Vietnam don't let any foreign military base on Vietnam land to threat other countries".
@@otsa120 Most Vietnamese people dont like china. For Donald Trump vs Obama is the mixed feeling. We have both Obama "fan" as well as Donald Trump " fan". The people are more influenced by the media would be more likely to be Obama "fan".
@@otsa120
- About Chinese: Vietnamese doesn't carry any haste again the "people", but Vietnamese will not shake hand with Chinese gov without a knife hiding somewhere.
- Hongkong: we know Hongkong hate China, but Hongkong use to back US again Vietnam and spread fail information about Vietnam attack Cambodia. So we didn't see Hongkong as "trust worthy alliance" either. Maybe good trade partner, but not political partner.
- Donald Trump / Obama: Vietnamese don't want and will not get involve into any conflict outside of Vietnam. And both presidents paid good attention to Vietnam. So we don't have any reason to hate any of them. If we have to pick 1, then Trump should be good. I know media hate Trump but as Vietnamese POV, Trump vs China conflict make Vietnam fat. Both China and Trump want to win Vietnamese favor so Vietnam can get more and more benefit from both side. Vietnam is key for the "Quad" to launch attack to the South of China. Vietnam also the key for China to gain control over the ASEAN area. In the past, China control Cambodia but history prove that Cambodia can't give them enough advantage over Vietnam, they need Vietnam. Vietnam is no longer a weak Pawn but rather a Pawn that very close to become a Queen.
Correction Vietnam gain their independence form Japan, the French got on their knees and handed Vietnam over to the Japanese.
The thumbnail is straight outta ricefield.
As someone who has lived in Asia, and still regards the area as home, I found this report really interesting. Thank you very much.
Before France occupied these islands, it belonged to Vietnam.
They did not belong to any country as they was no inhabitant. However, the French claimed it and after Vietnam was divided, those islands belonged to the South Vietnam who built army base there. South Vietnam went to war with China in early 1974 over these islands. When the North Vietnam won, they claimed these islands when China said a North Vietnamese official signed a document that those islands belonged to China.
Just remember that In name of the protectorate of Vietnam, France officially occupied not only Vietnam and Spratly islands, Paracel islands but also Laos and Cambodia (vassal state of Vietnam).
@@sgcl10658 In a written text in Vietnam, Quang Trung, a Vietnamese king back in the 18th century had already taken claimed and used those islands.
@@sgcl10658 The diplomatic letter sent to China is a tactic to push USA and China in direct colflit. Today China mentions this letter as proof it is only to manipulate the Chinese people. The Chinese are not stupid and believe that this letter has legal value ...
@@91Supernova Just bring Vietnam to the court and prove how legal values it is
I'm a descendant of Vietnamese who was born at the end of the 70s in Thailand. My mom was born in Laos and immigrated to Thailand at age of a few years old with her relatives. My family taught me no hate, or racism but to look at others equally. Here are my own views: 0) ChinaGov's attention is never pure. 1) Both Chinese dictators: Mao & Deng betrayed their allied partner based on Marxism ideology in the case of a dispute. 2) The U.S. picked the wrong side. 3) Khmer Rough did wrong things. 4) Thailand'Gov was unfair & threatening all the Vietnamese refugees, immigrants before rehabilitating the relationship btw Thailand & VN
Good coverage but you missed the part when Vietnam was divided, South Vietnam goverment took control of these islands and built military base there. However, China went to war with South Vietnam directly in the sea in January 1974 over these island disputes while supporting the Northern Vietnamese troops. China won and took control of these islands and the South Vietnam did protest to the United Nation but China blocking it with their veto power in the UN council. After North Vietnam unified the country, Communist Vietnam decided to claim these islands back.
Relations between Vietnam and China have deteriorated since General Secretary Le Duan and Deng Xiaoping took power (replacing Ho Chi Minh and Mao Zedong, when the two countries were close friends).
Le Duan (who Ho Chi Minh chose to succeed in 1960) was a very solid national stance. He said that China helped Vietnam in the war against the US, but the CCP wanted to dominate Vietnam (like 2nd North Korea ). Therefore, Le Duan had a very tough policy towards the chinese vietnamese , forcing them to return to China and whoever chose to stay, their property was confiscated, assimilated into the Vietnamese, ... leading to the Vietnam - Khmer Rouge and Vietnam - China war. a few years later.
Le Duan is a symbol of the war against the US, reunification, the designer of the South Vietnamese liberation strategy. Vietnamese people have a funny sentence, "Chuẩn như Lê Duẩn" (meaning Exactly like Le Duan =))))). I think many foreigners think that Le Duan's decision at that time was wrong. The Chinese have reason to hate him, but me and many Vietnamese still think it's right: v
Vietnam - China relations are just a policy issue between the two countries. The Chinese are very talented and likable. Maybe on the Internet, many Vietnamese express their hatred for China. But in real life, Vietnamese people and Chinese people are quite similar. Vietnam has always learned a lot from China. (like the Vietnamese feudalism "learn" Chinese feudalism :v)
Sợ trung quốc lắm mai mốt sợ trung quốc vs vn
because the US did want an agreement between Viet and China: all of them chased US ouft of the Viet
You are one of the sounder Vietnamese than the anti-Chinese Vietnamese person with illogical hatred comments posting on CZcams about China. They based their comments on how they feel rather on truth. The reason I’m saying this is because you express more on the fact side than the feeling side. However, agreeing or disagreeing about your comment is a different issue but I’m one of them that hears what you are saying.
@@manl7982 the hatred isnt illogical. It is justified.
@@shadowblitzo123 Your hatred is based on feelings which, therefore illogical.
I really like when I buy something electronic and its made in Vietman its sooo cool! I hope they make more stuff. :)
If I had to wager, I'd put my money on Vietnam. They repelled multiple Mongol invasions. They launched an insurgency during Japanese occupation and, after the end of WWII, defeated the French. Likewise, they outlasted us Americans during the Vietnam War. After that, they essentially faught the People's Liberation Army to a draw in 1979, which is pretty good, considering the disparity in size between China & Vietnam.
The VN, China and US dynamic reminds me of Tom and Jerry. VN being Jerry, China being Tom, and US being the bulldog
okay. at 4:06, I have some input. Vietnam actually gained Independence from La France on 2nd September, 1945. Vietnam's independence inspired many other French colonies worldwide to rise up against the colonial govt.
France came back trying to take over Vietnam again. 1954 was when France lost la bataille Điện Biên Phủ and Vietnam was divided into two under the Geneva Accord.
Incorrect, Vietnamese Communist known as Vietminh proclaimed independence in 1945 but it was not recognised by France or internationally. The communist forces at that time only controlled some rural areas of North Vietnam and were fighting the French until the battle of Điện Biên Phủ. The defeated France was forced to sue for peace in 1954 in Geneva, which created North and South Vietnam. North Vietnam was controlled by communist known as Socialist Republic of Vietnam, and South Vietnam was a new non-communist country known as Republic of Vietnam. That was the prelude for a civil war and later American involvement (much like North and South Korea situation) made it into what we have known as the Vietnam War.
Wrong. Ho Cho Minh got his inspiration of violent struggle for independence from France by learning from Haitian Revolution which overthrew French Rule in 1804, 150 years before your beloved Ho Cho Minh could repeat the success of the Haitians. Your Ho Cho Minh did not inspire any one to rise up against the conolinal French. It was the Haitians. Do not waste time on CZcams with ignorant comments in the future. Go back to school. Remember to eat those smelly French cheese.
@@karllarsen8797 Yep we did not take back our rice from the France it was the Japanese's nazi
@@cuongquan1633
I do not care about your rice. I care about your education. Remember, the Haitians rose up to overthrow French Rule in 1804, 150 years before that idiot Ho Cho Minh could follow in the footsteps of the revolutionary Haitians.
@@karllarsen8797 Wrong again. Ho Chi Minh did not get his inspiration from the Haitian Revolution. The Vietnamese got their inspiration of violent struggle for Independence to overthrow French rule from the very people who subjugated them. The Vietnamese were forced to learn French, French history, and you guessed it, the French Revolution (in 1789, which predates the Haitian Revolution). If the French underclass could rise up with subversion and wage a revolution against its own government and aristocratic elites why couldn't the Vietnamese do the same with the French ruling class at the time on their own land. Because of their arrogance, the French digged their own grave with that move, and that was the beginning of the undoing of the French colonial government, a double-edge sword if there ever was one. Next time take it back a notch if you're going to spread misinformation, ignorance, and name call. It was unnecessary to disrespect Ho Chi Minh. And if you're going to come at it like that, one ought to look no further than the current state of Haiti.
Your detail is wrong
You must know Polpot is from Thailand.
China agree with Thailan to support Polpot in 1979 1991.
Thailan support Polpot to throw Cambodia president democracy regime before 1975
Then In 1975 1979 Thailan country order polpot to disappear Cambodian and Vietnamese because Thai want to disappear Cambodia population and stop Vietnam influences in Cambodia from Cambodia getting closer to Vietnam and develop relationships with Vietnam regime then Thai plans to make Cambodia state of Thailan.
Only Vietnam help Cambodia regain independence from Polpot agent of Thai government in 1979 and 1991 but Cambodia never appreciate Vietnam saving and look at Vietnam as villain.
Thailan scared to face Vietnam military’s wrath in 1979. So they don’t stop support Polpot to 1991
Polpot is from your bottom end
I'm with the vietnamese on this one, though I trade with China good merchants ,Its just the politics that is concerning
Everything is Chinese ancient territory hahaha 🤗Even if they told Vietnam they are our socialist brother, their imperialist ambition will never change. China attacked Vietnam approximately once every dynasty back in feudal time. No surprise if they will attack again in the near future, that's why our military initiated a modernization process recently
They invaded Vietnam everytime and they all got their asses kicked.
China: ***invades Vietnam***
Vietnamese trees: "Let's play how to spot the Vietcong Soldier."
This is the kind of video I follow this channel for; I genuinely feel like I understand this region better than I did before I watched it. I really appreciate that you went over some of the history of China, Vietnam and Cambodia instead of just focusing on China's current expansion.
Vietnam has only developed safely since 1995 after being free from embargoes and hostility by many major countries. Apple, Samsung, LG, Pegatron, Foxcon, Luxshare, Hyundai, Lotte, Panasonic, GM ... Many multinational corporations are investing heavily in Vietnam. Large energy projects, electronics manufacturing plants and heavy industry. Vietnam will be the next big production engine. Their domestic corporations are growing fast: Viettel, Vingroup, FPT, Contecons, Sungroup ... Vietnamese children have a very high IQ. Vietnam may be the next dragon in Asia
The genocide under the rule of the Congo Free State has been estimated to be half the population of Congo. 10 to 20 million people are the range of estimates. That was about 10 to 20% of Africa's estimated population back then. Pol pot's reign of horror was nothing compared to Leopold II's torture machine that was the Congo Free State.
@DatManDaz Kurupt A horrible act, still not near the brutality of the Congo Free State though. For Leopold the the Congolese people was a resource to be exploited to depletion.
The Congo Free State was awful...but can you source your 10-20 million estimate?
(The sources I’ve found cite a range between 1 and 15 million)
@@scott2452
The 20m estimates comes from 1904 book by the name: King Leopold's Rule In Africa.
There has been a wide range of estimates. Though the ones bellow 10m has been widely questioned due to the lack of demographic data and the fact that they them selves claim to have likely heavily underestimating the actual death toll.
The 20m is not very reliable either.
The 10m is the one that is mostly accepted, included by the Belgium government since 1924.
I am not really in the mood of giving you a long list of books and papers to read. Wikipedia is your friend.
Wow we never learned that in schools. Are you from africa
@@phuctrinh2589 Nah, I'm Swedish. I was told about it in high school under the topic of imperialism/capitalism. But I also hade a pretty great history teacher.
People should also remember that the Congo Free State was a privately owned company.
We support vietnam. Lots of love from India🇮🇳 ❤
czcams.com/video/M0pMkwwFGmA/video.html
I wish that India will be a super power. The world can live in peace with a strong India.
But the world will live in fear with a strong China!
Damn ! China really knows how to make Enemies.
Not better than Suckmerica.
A lot of misunderstood about our country, Vietnam and I would like to clarify. As you known Vietnam is a one-party country aka communism state but the way we doing thing here is different, our economic is capitalist system, even our politic system tend to be capitalist. One-party system will help us prevent a lot of chaotic and defend all the enemies, just because our geographic is so sensitive. Being a communist country is not really as bad as you think, it not like we don't have a voice or freedom or anything, we can said and do pretty much whatever we want here. Again, it is just a label, we even found more freedom than you will ever know.
Not sure, if you told something make government don’t like, they arrest you, it’s just the way they do
@@trungdung1822 They not gonna arrest you just because you don't like something...lol. Stop lying sir. You can like or dislike and talk about it if you want, make sure what you said is the truth, not personal attack on a person or government. Every countries acted the same way, not only Vietnam.
China has always wanted to annex Vietnam, so it is the best ally of US !
The US, in its present form just wants everyone to trade with it. So whether you want to be friends with China or the US seems like an easy choice.
Might be because Vietnam has been fighting of Chinese occupation attempts longer than the United States has existed. France had a war, it lost, it admitted defeat and opened diplomatic relations. The United States had a war, it lost, it admitted defeat and opened diplomatic relations.
China has declared war, not admitted defeat, opened two-faced diplomatic relations that barely amount to more than threats then try to occupy the land only to lose and have the cycle start all over again. It's been that way since before the west showed up in the region, it went back to that when the west lost there. We were, at best, an alien invasion showing up in a region and at the center of a conflict that had a much longer history than many of our governments. It's a pity we didn't learn this lesson then but maybe we can make up for it a bit by working with the Vietnamese these time around.
As a Vietnamese, to answer your question at the last minutes of video, I would say probably not. Because the sovereignty does really matter to Vietnam now, and it likely outweighs than the universal human right. Vietnamese people were resilient in war, that's right. But Vietnamese people are also tired of war. So, universal human right and war, as long as we can endure, you know the answer.
Well the thing is that Vietnam is heavily influenced by Chinese culture. So I don't think Vietnam and china wants to fight with each other
The Vietnamese government would definitely not want an all out war with China but it’s certainly not because of culture influence.
Thank you for your dedicated videos, Vietnam clash with China is 2000 years stories already. We have a big noisy neighbor to look after.
1:50 Hoang Sa and Truong Sa of Vietnam, please 🇻🇳
Belong to* đéo phải of
@@tunguska2370 ngôn ngữ là tiếng để hiểu, viết người ta hiểu là được, đừng theo khuôn mẫu
@@KVKVlogs okay sorry sorry
Vietnam be like : every country can't hate me too much.
Thank you for an information-packed video. However, I would want to add some information:
1/ Sine Nguyen Dynasty, Paracel islands have been a part of Vietnam territories (appear in maps and records which still preserved until today). The French when they come to Vietnam also noted and keep records that recognized the Parcel Islands as a part of Vietnam. On March 13, 1988, China attacked and massacre 48 Vietnamese soldiers station on Gạc Ma island with warships and machine guns without warning. Recently, there are many attacks in which China warship sunk Vietnamese fishing boats and leave the fisherman to dead on the sea.
2/ This is the most unforgiving. You failed to mention about Khmer rouge attacked and genocide of Vietnamese citizens (not even women nor newborn babies was spared) which happened prior to the event of Vietnam attacked Cambodia (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ba_Ch%C3%BAc_massacre) and turn the invasion into a purely political ideology conflict.
(Edit: Grammar)
The Geneva Accords1954, which had China, Soviet, USA, France as an official attendant, also recognizes Vietnam’s sovereignty over the Paracel and Spratly Islands. The Accords asked attending countries to respect independence, sovereignty and national unity and territorial integrity of Vietnam. Therefore, China’s statement of sovereignty over the two archipelagos is invalid under international law.
the opening of news voice actually tricked me into thinking of old simon
There's a new Simon?
I was a lil worried when simon left the channel but honestly im loving your style too dude, i hope you continue to grow with your channel.
Where did Simon go?
lots of information which you have given here contains a lot of incorrect information. Vietnam was independent in 1945, not 1954. The Paracels and Spratlys have never been recognized internationally as China's. The Qing Dynasty of China did not recognize China's sovereignty over the Hoang Sa and Truong Sa. There is a document that the Qing Dynasty does not recognize the sovereignty of the two archipelagoes that are still kept in the British Royal Family. The French have never recognized China's sovereignty. During the colonial period, the French always recognized the two archipelagoes of Truong Sa and Hoang Sa as belonging to Vietnam. so did the Americans and it was the Americans who kept the Spratly and Paracel Islands for Vietnam from 1954 to 1974.
Please find out more accurate information before posting it to the public, to avoid misunderstandings.
heritage/cultural-connection between vietnam and china makes things difficult to describe. viets are yue, as VIETnam is YUEnan in chinese. the people in guangdong and some neighboring provinces are considered Yue Chinese; cantonese is a Yue language. Gin people are basically vietnamese people living in china, as they speak the language but the written form is not the latin version, it's still the one using chinese characters. vietnam is not part of china and shouldn't be, but the connection is clearly there. song dynasty and the dynasties before always go after Dai Viet (vietnam). yes, china did attack korea, central asia, and other places, but not every dynasty tho. for the most part, the unified china would go after viet land. yuan, ming, and qing had different reasons for attacking. the dynasties before attacked as "reconquest" technically. i do know that before qin/han dynasty, southern china used to be populated with full-blooded yue people, but after qin/han conquered yue tribes, the yue people were pretty much mixed after a while. vietnam considers Kingdom of Nanyue as a viet dynasty, but it's half-half (han and viet). it's a weird situation.
Yue becomes part of Han, that's the so called national amalgamation.
@@zgt8838 invasion*
@@zgt8838 Not by choice. So I do think a lot Southern Chinese believe they are Han but they are 100% Han, definitely have Yue blood. Take ppl of Hainan Island for example, their language sounds very Filipino but they claim they Han.
Good news to hear that Vietnam despite the past conflicts, it's on its way to rapid progress. Now coz of China, part of its precious money will go to military hardware.
🇻🇳 ❤️
Well we Vietnamese don't need to have a democracy since we're already so free.
"Chớ dại dột đụng đến đất nước này! (Do not be foolish to mess with this country!)" - Vietnamese propaganda tagline, 1975.
Vietnam enjoy at least 5000 years of being neighbors of China and I can recommend the book UNDERSTANDING VIETNAM by an american (Neil something)
I learned so much watching this video. I kind of thought I was knowledgeable about the subject, but now I realize I wasn’t as knowledgeable as I believed..
Wow! I haven’t been to this channel before, I think I will come again, definitely a better use of time to come here and learn about why stuff is happening than switching on 24-hour news and watching people speculating about stuff that might happen in the future, especially when those people don’t know what they’re talking about.
Vietnamese history is organized by periods of northern (China) domination and resistance. Even though we expanded south, fought, and taken over territories of the Khmer and Champa kingdoms, but we only focus on one enemy in the history book, China. This could be the result of propaganda policies going back more than a millennium as Vietnamese dynasties (sometime of Han Chinese ethnicity: Ngô, Lý, Trần) sought to maintain independence from Chinese dynasties that persistently sought to recreate the empire of the Han and Tang dynasties, which included the area of present day north Vietnam. Oversea Vietnamese hates Communist Vietnamese because of the war, but they are united in their support for Trump because they believe that Trump is f’ing up China.
Ngô, Lý and Trần dynasty are not Han Chinese. They are Vietnamese living in Southern China ( used to be Baiyue land and Vietnamese is one of Baiyue ethnics).
@@traaotuong6107, Technically the story tells us that Vietnamese (Kinh) are from two Baiyue tribes, Âu and Lạc. The DNA shows that they are related to the Dai people who is also related to the Thai. As for Ngô, Lý, and Trần dynasties, you might need to do some more research to add to your understanding. Millennia of propaganda can steer you away from a lot of information. But identity has more to do with what people believe rather than what actually happened. So you’re welcome to continue to believe that there is no Han Chinese dynasties in Vietnamese history and a millennium under Han Chinese rule, from the Han to the Tang dynasties, has no impact.
I do have doubt if the Lý dynasty was Han Chinese since Lý Công Uẩn was an orphan, so who really know about his parentage or where his family from. In reality we are all human and what separates us is very tiny. What we think separates us beyond the physical exterior is reinforced by what we think is our culture, language, and history. Those factors can be shaped and influenced for any purpose.
Speak for yourself. I and the vast majority of overseas Vietnamese hate Trump. He's a white supremacist, a pathological liar, a con artist, and a man without a moral compass. It's only Trump worshipping Vietnamese that support Trump. They turned from a pro-democracy anti-VC movement into an anti-democracy anti-China (and therefore pro-VC) movement for Trump. The VC is supposed to be their #1 enemy, but bc of their blind love for Trump, they justified Trump's closeness with the VC by making China their #1 enemy. They even went to DC to attack to the seat of US democracy.
@@phan1182 “Speak for myself”???LOL. All you need to do is look at your own family and I guarantee you’ll find at least one trumpeteer or Q “Annam” devotee. “I and the vast majority of overseas Vietnamese,” really??? Speak for yourself LMAO. Go to little Saigon and see how many Vietnamese there support Trump... Learn how to read with your eyes rather than your emotion, it seems to me you think I’m a Trump supporter.
Sure, my previous comment is a bit of a generalization because not all overseas Vietnamese support Trump, I guess that’s why you got a bit sensitive, but the fact is that the majority of the overseas Vietnamese community supports Trump. The majority of them have always been Republicans due to their anti communist stand and they blamed the Democrats for the fall of Saigon. Their support for Trump is not a surprise, they voted for Republicans before, and they still do now.
For decades I have heard former officers of ARVN espousing fascist sentiments as they vowed to stamp out any narratives that put them it a poor light with their fist. Their victim-hood narrative is on par with Versailles Treaty for the Nazi and the Black Shirt, “đâm sau lưng chiến sĩ.” I’m old enough to remember them calling up the youth stomp out counter protestors supporting freedom of expression at the Hi-Tek protest in Bolsa. Back in South Vietnam when they were in power, their only interest was to protect the status quo with the elite ruling a corrupt regime. They did little for the people but expect them to bleed for them, “hy sinh vì tổ quốc.”
They failed, or didn’t give a fuck, to protect the poor from both the Viet Cong and the American troops. Leaving them to be extorted by the VC at night and burned out by American napalm during the day. Their only fucking excuse was “tại vì lúc đó là chiến tranh.” If you want to know how incompetent the vast majority of those ARVN fuckers were, all you have to do is look at Black April to see how quickly Saigon collapsed. The only people worth memorializing is the 18th Division.
It’s really easy for a bunch of fascists to support a fascist. He speaks their language, and I’m not talking about Vietnamese. Anyway, check yourself. GTFOH with that “I and the vast majority” bullshit, and you telling me to speak for myself SMH. Look, I’m glad y’all fucking progressive and all. It’s great to see that since the Vietnamese overseas community is not exactly a bastion of liberalism.
“China and Vietnam improved their relations, collaborating on projects like this one ...”
Ad “100% flame grill beef ONLY at Burger King!”
But BK is not that good tho, at least in my country. I prefer McDonald and Popeyes.
The Vietnamese and Chinese were never actually allies they fought many times against each other
Throughout history, Vietnam has always been invaded by China. China is 30 times bigger than Vietnam, its population 15 times, has lots of nuclear weapons and you said " they fought many times against each other ". That is false and not logical. Only China has attacked and INVADED Vietnam for many thousands of years in history, and they have always done so.
@@nguyenthang8414 Vietnam was a part of China before, but then it was separated
@@user-yg3jw3uf9d You can say the whole earth is part of China. The moon and sun too.
@@user-yg3jw3uf9d If your wife, your child is that of your neighbor. Say what is not mine is mine. That is a thief.
@@nguyenthang8414 This is not my nonsense. This is the history. Whether you like it or not, it was called Jiaozhi 2000 years ago
The world supports Vietnam. Down with Chiyyyyyna
Don't worry India is with Vietnam
@Finn Hansen Can you get me the stuff that you're smoking ?
czcams.com/video/M0pMkwwFGmA/video.html
So many many indians support vn. I dont know. We also luv indians
I remember watching "The Killing Fields" when I was about 10 yo. To say this movie didn't have an effect on me is an understatement. Worth a watch if you haven't see it.
No effect, damn you are one cold blooded psychopath.
I watched it around that age as well. Good movie. That movie gets repeated in Aus once or twice a year back in the days.
@Mycel That would be my parents. I enjoyed the film but is was one that left me with plenty of questions when the old man said this is a true story.
My parents had it on VHS so as I got older I did appreciate the film but it did not make it less shocking.
Vietnamese in America will vote for the Republicans then. 😁
They intent to as a matter of fact. But they are divided as Democrat provided more benefits to migrants.
True, most Vietnamese would vote for Trump/Republicans.
Anyone with a little commonsense would vote trump/Republican this election
Id vote for Democrats
@@unserkatzenland8884 Then that is your choice, there is nothing wrong with that.
Pol pot was a psychopath. There was a policy for soldiers not to waste bullets on children. What they did was to grab babies by their feet and smashed them against a large tree. This is beyond cruel.
Philippines:Hey Vietnam if we both ally with each other we can.
Vietnam:*Allies With Usa
Philippines:Nevermind. We are already BFFs now.
During pandemic I learned so much about human history. And it's soul crushing. Throughout history every country, race, religion has committed countless actrocities. And they still happen to this day. Where is the Utopias and paradises scifi movies promised us?
Life is: promises n promises & nothing.
You work your ass off to try to make a living and make a life for yourself and your family and then some schmuck for another country comes in and kills you and takes your s*** oh wait a minute they did that to their own people and their own country. How many millions did mao kill?
We'll all reach eternal peace, innit?
Utopia and paradise don't exist. And you need to turn off the TV.
from perspective of Vietnamese: Cambodia attacks Vietnamese border after Vietnam reunification because back in the day the Me Kong delta was belong to Khmer empire, so they want it back.
So they have a good reason?
@@gonzalos4379 nah that reason was stupid because it would be like Italy claiming half of Europe because they once belonged to the Holy Roman Empire
you are wrong. Đừng ăn nói bậy bạ. Khơ me đỏ giết 3000 người Ba Chúc, Kiên Giang và nhiều người ở Tây Minh. Rồi Hunsen nhờ giúp đỡ nên mình mới giúp
@ANH DAU , cả 2 lý do.
@ANH DAU lol, try to forget bad memories but go full gansta anti-US on 30.4 omg. Then lick Capitalists money from head to toes lol.
It’s not the South China Sea. It’s the Vietnamese East Sea.
its south east asian sea we don’t claim the whole sea we just claim the islands
I support the US but not to defend Vietnam. Right now it is a good opportunity to promote democracy in Vietnam. The defense of Vietnam will come after Vietnam becomes a democratic country.
The US will never havr to defend VN because VN will never ever ask for outside help, it's always been their policy. But the two countries need each other as strategic partner in the region, not a military ally.