You Could See the ACL Pop - Doctor Explains Jameson Williams Knee Injury
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 06. 2024
- Thank you Warby Parker for sponsoring this video. Try 5 pairs of glasses at home for free at warbyparker.com/brianmd. Home Try-On Kits are offered in the US only. No international shipping.
Alabama star wide receiver sustained a severe looking knee injury during the national championship game. In this video we'll review what happened and explain the pop that you could see on replay.
NFL and Football Videos:
• NFL and Football Injuries
NBA and Basketball Videos:
• NBA and Basketball Inj...
UFC and Boxing Videos:
• UFC and Boxing
MY MUSIC:
Epidemic Sound - Sign up with this link for a FREE 30 day trial!
www.epidemicsound.com/referra...
Follow Me on Twitter!
/ briansutterermd
I'm a doctor and a sports fan and this channel is dedicated to exploring the unique medical side of the world of sports, including NBA, MLB, NFL, UFC, and many more! Breaking down the biggest what ifs, historical injuries and stories, and making learning about medicine fun and relevant for all sports fans!
Anatomy images: www.biodigital.com
DISCLAIMER: Content not intended to be taken as medical advice. Opinions are my own and do not represent those of my employer. I have not personally treated or evaluated the individual(s) discussed in this video. Content used with educational and transformative intent within Fair Use Guidelines
Content owned and produced by Brian Sutterer LLC 2022 - Sport
this happened like an hour ago this guy is amazing with it
He has Google alerts to get notified wherever injuries happen
Still hurts
As someone who has torn their ACL and has done a lot of CZcams searching, this is absolutely the best explained video. Thank you!
Hope this young man makes a full and complete recovery.
I’m not a doctor myself but yes you can walk on a torn ACL. Tore mine in a non contact play play few years ago. Walked right off the field . 110% he tore his acl.
Agreed, I shredded my acl but had a relatively stable joint due to tight hamstrings.
@@m4yd0g I tore mine similar to this play. When I planted my right leg , my leg was too far out when I tried to cut and just fell on my own. Hurt right when I tore it but after that it felt like just another injury …. The hardest part for me was 2 weeks right after surgery . Very painful. I got cleared within 5 1/2 months.
klay thompson just came back from a torn acl
I agree. I completely tore mine and still was able to walk home. Heck it even took almost 6 months (because of school and covid) before I got my surgery. So I was practically walking around with a completely torn acl (and partial meniscus tear) for almost 6 months
@@MadGio100 that sounds so bad
Great vids doc ...interested in seeing one on quadre diggs safety for Seahawks ..poor guy was having a good season
Right when it happened I knew it was the ACL. Then someone told me there's no way he's walking like that. But having experienced it before, I know that if it's not swollen yet then it can feel completely fine when walking
Yea, I tore mine playing basketball I finished out the game and it had just started. Depending on ur adrenaline and pain tolerance you couldn’t honestly never even realize that it’s torn. I only found it was torn cause at the end of the game I tried to do a quick stop and my knee slid and I fell and broke my arm lmao😭
@@chromedomo4826 damn that’s tuff pa not just one but two injuries
@@chromedomo4826 don't worry, always remember Anthony street clothes Davis exists, he gets 10 injuries per day
Thanks for the quick upload Doc! Appreciate the breakdown
I watched this happen and as soon as it happened I knew you would post.
But I feel so badly for Williams if it is an acl tear. Terrible thing to happen to a great, young college player. And, if it is a tear, it really hurts the rest of his career. Get well soon, number 1!!
He's hardly limping, so I doubt it's a full tear
@@jeffgayzose8129 Everyones different bro, people tear their acl sometimes without even knowing. But hoping its not too bad.
@@jeffgayzose8129 Look at Klay after his. Dude was jumping and running after his ACL tear
So quick with it Doc. Another great one.
Incredible work. Very bright future Brian
I can tell I’ve really been learning a lot from these videos, because I was able to watch the replay once and see all of these mechanisms, and had a good understanding of what the likely injury was before this video was posted! I came here to confirm, so it is really cool having a bit of a deeper understanding of these things after watching you for a few years!
Love these videos as a PT student. Super helpful for reinforcing my ortho knowledge and demonstrating real-world case studies of common MOI. Thank you!
I love these videos and I’ve learned so much from it. I wouldn’t have know for sure what happened a few years ago but after just one replay I instantly recognized the mechanism and knew what it likely was, even before I saw his tibia pop back. I always look forward to these and it helps keep me safer in my own life knowing how these injuries happen
The guy was laying on the ground grabbing his knee, im pretty wure an 10 yEar old could of told you he tore his acl. But hey im glad you are such a smart youtube doctor😂
@@matthill2957 that was completely uncalled for man, just cause someone is grabbing their knee doesn’t mean that it could only be an ACL. They way his knee fell in could have also been an MCL, the sever extension of the joint could damage the meniscus, or snap the patellar tendon too.
Strong work Doc. Love your stuff
Great Vid Doc! Could you also make a video on Cam Akers returning from an achilles tear and playing in less than 5-6months?
I second that, 6 mouths seems fast
Damn 6 months that's some rehabilitation right there
Wasn’t sure if I was the only one completely shocked by that. I always thought it was around a year recovery.
Actually having ruptured my Achilles back in October, and to my surprise, rehab protocol does say a full return to sports and activity in 6 months. But I’m sure there’s a big difference between Cam Akers rehab routine and our routines.
Can’t even wait for the game to before before he uploads man you are quick! (Not complaining just impressed)
holy quick upload the game is still going my guy😂😂❤️
You always know when you have watched a good video, it's over before you know it. Great stuff as always.
hope for a full speedy recovery 🙏 that slow-mo was pain 😩 nice LT jersey DOC ⚡❄⚡
Hope he rests up. Get well soon
Called it as soon as I saw it live. The replay confirmed it for me. Prayers to him
Precise the update doc, prayers for jw 🙏🙏
Awesome video Doc. I would love to see you explain the physiology and repair of a hamstring ruptured away from the hip. Thanks for what you do
As a med student studying for Step, I can't express how grateful I am for your videos. Such a relaxing way to enjoy some guilt free youtube content.
Holy smokes..they still doing press conference! Good stuff doc
Wow! Thanks doc!
This is so painful to watch for someone who had an ACL reconstruction. But this had help me understood how my injury happened. Thanks Doc
Charger fan here… love the LT jersey and I love your content! ⚡️
I saw the ACL pop in real time on TV, your channel has turned me into an expert!
Same! So many ACL tears I’ve seen on live tv now just because of this where I see it and then end up seeing the next day or days later that they ended up tearing ACL
Can you provide analysis on Quandre Diggs injury in the Seahawks win over the Cardinals?
My man don’t miss a beat it’s only been like an hour😭
Can you discuss what athletes (pro, college, and rec) can learn from this in terms of avoidance? The amazing athleticism and skill put him in a position to continue the play while moving with extreme momentum downfield. His awesome athleticism and keen skills allowed him to decide to try to slow down and cut back to the right to avoid the defender. But it was this decision combined with the massive energy and the angles he had to plant with that exceeded the maximum tension of his joint. Do you find that athletes need some guidance on how to avoid these type of injuries? As an aging athlete and referee, I know there are situations where my brain wants my body to do risky moves. My awareness of this enables me to attenuate the stopping or acceleration or turning rates to de-risk the maneuvers. Seahawk Tyler Lockett seems to navigate the field more carefully but no less skillfully or quickly since his injury a few years ago. His injury was contact induced, but it seems like when he is in fraught situations he ensures he secures the catch and falls in ways that reduce injury potential. Should young athletes be trained in injury avoidance?
better shoes would prevent injury. I would evaluate shoes on different turfs. less cuts on artificial turf.
This comment needs more visibility. I believe it is imperative that they be trained in injury avoidance. I believe artificial turf has a hand in this as well. I found an article saying that artificial turf seems to cause injuries more and this encompasses ALL sports that use it such as Soccer as well. Grass is ONLY worse in the condition in that it's not maintained properly. I think there should be some pushback against artificial turf and athletes need to be trained differently to avoid these injuries.
Praying he is feeling better soon.
Bolt up! Love the Tomlinson jersey in the back!
This guy is a beast. If I was a GM, he would be high on my list for team doctor.
great stuff, thx. just wondering what software do u use to do the split screens in ur videos?
First love you Brian. Can you break down Quandre Diggs injury
The game isn't even over, my man is quick!!
Really enjoy this vids and explanation, Brian! It's understood that misfortune will happen to athletes, but I wanted to ask you your opinion as to what you think they can do to strengthen knee joints, elbow joints and the ligaments within these areas to withstand taking on extreme pressure when making these cuts/shifts in movements? Is it just inevitable these injuries will happen, which lead to surgery and recovery? You mentioned a hope that Jameson is really "flexible", but I'm sure no athlete wants to base his future on that hope alone. Thanks.
These kinds of things are why I don’t blame players for opting out of bowl games, I actually encourage it especially if they are projected to go high in the draft
I feel like if I was the actual athlete in the video I would watch it to see what happened lol. You do such a good job explaining!!
Wheres federico chiesas injury vs roma yesterday? I was waiting on it?? Dr brian
That jersey in the background! LT 🐐⚡️⚡️⚡️
This man is the TMZ of injuries lol. On it before you know it
My doctor had told me that partial tears can be a lot more painful in the aftermath than a complete tear. Something about nerve endings still sending signals to the brain with a partial tear. Could be why he was able to walk seemingly painless afterwards and same with Tom Brady in ‘08.
That was true for my achilles. The partial hurt way more than the full rupture.
about a week ago, i had a bad knee injury where i couldn't stand and fell right after the popping noise happened on my right knee.. I haven't checked to the MRI yet since it's still swelling right to this day. Since a torn acl can still walk right after it pops, is it safe to assume partial can't move after it pops? it's because i literally couldn't move because of the pain.. I don't know if people generally have different levels of pain receptors, but mine hurt a lot.. I'm really hoping that it's only a partial tear from the symptomps that i feel..
He's quick with it
I had and ACL while water skiing. it was swollen big time I walk 3 miles home on it from my girl friends house afterwards. Funny thing is I have never had a operation on my knee and it took about about 6 months for it to heal up. I do feel it every once in a while but it has never slowed me down.
As someone who tore their ACL, I remember how it felt in real time. I watched this play and said immediately, “damn”…
With that being said, same thing just happened to his teammate Metchie. Do you feel like the turf is unforgiving? ACL tears just seem to be so common on them.
I saw that live and thought something popped too. Very noticeable.
I tore the ACL in my left knee, along with the meniscus, when I was 25 and walked around for two months before surgery. Knee was not stable, but I was able to walk almost normally.
My first love was playing Basketball. Tore my ACL playing a pickup game. Fully recovered but Never played again as mentally i was too scared to jump or make sharpe cuts.
Took up distance running as it's basically just running straight lol.
does a partial tear actually hurt more than torn? i hurt my knee really bad a week ago, and i couldn't walk like other people does when their acl got torn, hence the pain. Does that mean i hurt mine worse or less?
If u can, can u please cover Federico Chiesa's ACL injury from Juventus (soccer). Massive Juve fan and he's a crucial player for us. Thank u so much and love ur vids keep it up
First Metchie, now Williams /:
Do you feel turf is causing more injuries in football?
Yeah some people can definitely walk after an ACL. My dad tore his ACL snow skiing and was able to get back up and ski down the mountain. By the time he got to the bottom it was the size of a grapefruit. It was only later he learned that he tore it
Can't wait til I see the Dr. on a broadcast one day.
I understand that you _can_ walk with a torn ACL but does it increase damage? Or should you stay on the ground/let others help you walk off?
I was in the stadium and saw it happen live. I knew as soon as he went down it was an ACL tear, it was the same instant reaction as metchie. Hurts to think about how we could’ve done had they been healthy, but their recovery is more important than a game
odds he stills goes to the draft after this?
go dawgs!
@@bendy113 I think he will, he’ll probably make a full recovery so if that goes well his draft stock won’t go down too much
@@bendy113 he's still going to the league, no question
That's why I don't blame some of these athletes who declare for the draft, sitting out these bowl games. His draft stock just plummeted!! SMH
Bottom of the 1st round to a contender. Could be worse!
Ur almost as amazing as ur hair bro! Great content!
Would natural grass have caused a different outcome with his injury?
My son walked around with a torn acl and meniscus for 3 weeks before he had surgery. It is definitely possible to walk around with an acl tear. And tbqh he never even complained about having any pain.
Nice & quick upload with quality info! Looked nasty live and wishing for a quick and speedy recovery ❤️🩹 🤞🏿
Appreciate it Doc!
Wish he would do the quandre diggs injury this fast cause his looked ugly asl
Brian, would the forward movement of the tibia also stress the popliteal ligament and displace the patella too?
Doc watching the national title game nice
Been there, done that multiple times. Soon as it happened. "Blew his ACL". So common in football. I see one or more a week watching games.
Brian, you did a good job of showing the classic mechanism but we've published a paper on why it happens. Check it out. The tibia was forward because his quads fired anticipating footplant when that didn'thappenthe quads pulledthetibiaforwardandthen when footplant occurred the bone bruises occurredand the knee bent further which tore the ACL and then the joint reduced. Read our paper..
The game is still on.. your so fast 😳
Tore my 7 years ago have never got it fixed they said it’s not completely torn but hanging by a thread. Don’t know when I will ever get it fixed
Get well
Go Dawgs
LT jersey in the back ⚡⚡
Hey doc can you do quandre diggs injury he suffered a bad injury against against the cardinals 🙏🏽
hey sir, can you make a video about Federico Chiesa’s injury?
Can you do I video on Quandre diggs injury?
You should do Marcus lattimore he had a pretty crazy tear a few years ago
He’s the best Receiver in college football too.
He is one of the best, not the best! May he get well soon!
Ouch 🤕
Can You do quandre diggs broken leg
upload speed on this channel is nuts
No matter who you pull for, no one wants to see a player get hurt like this.
I love how the skeleton's shirt just disappeared during the sponsor
If you haven’t already, you should do a video about the difference between natural turf and artificial turf and improvements that have been made to artificial turf
Can you do federico chiesa? He tore his acl recently
As someone who’s torn both ACL’s…watching this injury over and over again in slow motion is making the hairs on my arm standup. 😬😩
that hurt me
Don’t forget about Chris Godwin the all thought it was a minor injury until a couple days later and a mri showed a torn acl
Ouch, that pop tho
literally not even halfway through the 3rd quarter when he posted this
Focusing on what is going on with his foot (i.e the bottom of the kinetic chain), it seems that the turf and shoe failed him as much as what is going on up the chain.
Your sponsors better be paying you bank! Because you just got them so many views by this quickly put out video
Talk about his graft options. Pretty sure he's getting patella vs. hammy or cadaver. Gotta protect that speed.
Tore my ACL in 2007 and no one can really explain the extreme pain when it initially tears. I've been stabbed broken nose from boxing and torn rotator cuff and the acl tear was the worse. Everytime i see someone tear the acl it makes me. You can still walk but have to be very conscious of not pivoting or squatting. Lol just walk straight.
Jesus dude what is your life
@@danielsaleman506 lol early nineties boxing and unfortunately the gang stuff, that's where i got shot at and stabbed, broken nose from boxing, tore acl in soccer , rotator cuff in 25 yrs of being a ups driver
As a football fan I can now stop an ACL tear whenever I see one cuz they can be easily seen in the leg motion and generally it’s a non contact injury
That was nasty, I wouldn't be surprised if it's a full tear. It's crazy how easy it is to tear considering the pivotal part it plays in everyday function.
He shouldn't have cut back in.
explain quandre diggs
Immediately called it when I saw it
acl's pop everyday B. you tough right Jamo? Detroit lions gonna need ya champ
Nice. What's up with Jimmy G's thumb?
Whenever I hear anyone talking about ACLs and walking or not I remember DeJuan Blair playing several NBA seasons without them in both knees
I didn't not have surgery for 2 months after tearing my ACL. It's sore, but you can definitely walk
I’m here doing research on Behalf of the Philadelphia Eagles