Just them as two Guardsmen having a conversation talking about some of the Tom and Ben Yourhammer as if it's real history before the camera pans to somebody else just shaking their head like they're idiots and then 'correcting' their lore with something even more ridiculously untrue to make the point to the audience that this is a joke and that the average Imperial citizen doesn't know very much
The problem with the Fall of Cadean is not just the obscene lore dump but also the fact that at its core it would be a last stand/army movie. Could they make it as good as Fury? As All Quiet on the Western Front? 1917? Full Metal Jacket? Saving Private Ryan? I feel like it would be so easy to make a middling war movie and then slap a sci-fi warhammer on it and make it a little worse because it would be confusing.
I'm excited for this as it seems he will have more control on this project and something that's always been great is how you can tell he respects the I.P. I think exploring the guardsmen would have the broadest appeal, it's almost WW2 it's an aesthetic more people can cling to, then you can explore the space marines more which will lean into the weirder shit
Astartes was a great little mini series with almost no talking and no “human” POVs, no exposition dump at the beginning of the episodes, and there was enough appeal to non warhammer folks that a bunch of my friends got into the game based off of Astartes alone. So there’s no fucking way that Amazon can make something worth viewing. ROP and WOT are such hot trash rushed “original” titles and that’s what Warhammer will turn out to be
I tried searching for the bad Henry news every bodies talking about and I didn't find any. I guess you guys just read headlines and not the actual articles. None of them say he did bad stuff. If anything it's literally the opposite. He refused to do "spicy" scenes in the event he could get into situations. Man tries to not be misogynist. Get's called one by the media anyways.
Considering some of the people you follow, I'd say that we aren't going to see eye to eye. Ever. Weird how the channel filters directly referencing their side. So I will have to call them *"opposite of near opposite of left"*
@@beardedbear9901 I see you're one of those Believe All Women people. As for the people I watch, they have different beliefs, but you probably believe anyone right of you are part of the same group. You know you can watch people and not agree with everything they believe. If you couldn't tell by the fact that I also watch Tom and Ben.
If you wanted Mass appeal wouldn't you have to start with the heresy and like the rise of the emperor otherwise no one's going to know what the hell is going on no matter where you go.
@@adhararadhara4173 race-swapping main characters that do not retain to the lore. inserting political social justice messaging that is in our world that is not in the 40k universe as a whole. Keep it dark keep it helpless. keep lore accurate...
@@adhararadhara4173 What does it mean to "wokify" anything? Women, LGBTQIA or black people existing in the show. That's literally the only caveat. The anti-woke crowd gussy it up behind all these other smoke screen arguments, but it's just racism, homophobia and sexism.
@@YangKos5000 No, the filters can absolutely be changed on a channel by channel basis. This channel has filters that make it harder to criticse the "not near not left" and I believe that's deliberate. It can't not be. That serves your interests as someone "not near not left" but I won't support a channel to which I would be ideologically opposed.
@@YangKos5000 That doesn't actually alter my point though. We may be tripping the same word filters or different. I know for a fact, certain words are filtered. And those certain words being filtered is a red flag.
@@beardedbear9901 You're point doesn't stand. We literally don't know if VOD Gobbo has a channel thingy. But it's common knowledge that CZcams does. I can see one of you're hidden comments, you wrote JP. I wonder who's "side" is being muffled or if it's just CZcams doing a blanket hiding.
"but but he's the golden boy and everyone says he's nice that's impossible! next you'll say that Leo 'the Nardo' Caprio only dates women in a very specific age range!!"
So... Is that a problem? She was well over the age of consent (16 in the UK). DiCaprio is dating 22 year olds in his almost 50s. Al Pacino had baby with 29 year old in his 80s. Jay-Z started dating Beyonce when she was 19 and he was 31. Is that wierd? Yes, but they are all consenting adults, so why should you care? Why should Tom and Ben care?
I now have a _ridiculous_ desire to see a Muppets Warhammer starring Henry Cavill.
Chris Pratt: "Piss for the piss god, marrow for the bone throne!"
I doubt it'll ever happen, but I'd love it if Tom and Ben got to kameo in the background of a single scene in the show. I can dream.
Just them as two Guardsmen having a conversation talking about some of the Tom and Ben Yourhammer as if it's real history before the camera pans to somebody else just shaking their head like they're idiots and then 'correcting' their lore with something even more ridiculously untrue to make the point to the audience that this is a joke and that the average Imperial citizen doesn't know very much
That "Harvey J. Yogscast" edit wasn't missed. :)
Danny Devito commissar. Get these guys on the writers team!
“I’m the troll guy?”
“I’m the control guy?”
Just make the main character a Guardsman played by Rupert Grint xD
A Gaunt's Ghost's style story would probably be the easiest to start with.
GUYS WAIT what if it was an alpha legion show & Cavill plays EVERYONE
The problem with the Fall of Cadean is not just the obscene lore dump but also the fact that at its core it would be a last stand/army movie. Could they make it as good as Fury? As All Quiet on the Western Front? 1917? Full Metal Jacket? Saving Private Ryan? I feel like it would be so easy to make a middling war movie and then slap a sci-fi warhammer on it and make it a little worse because it would be confusing.
I think a gaurdsmen story or an inquisitor story would be cool with a much more human story
fingers crossed this turns out good
“I heard the Emperor’s real name is Jimmy”
I hope they go in the Andor type show, show that side of the empire, featuring Space Marines at some point
The orks should be Jim Henson puppets.
Ive learned all my wh from Tom and Ben so I literally didn't know they were called Perpetuals. I would have taken a while to understand it in the show
If they covered the Horus Heresy, that'd be one of the only cases where I'd want the director to just throw out and ignore all of the books.
Swedish Chef is Konrad Curze
Wait... is Lister from Red Dwarf a perpetual???
I'm excited for this as it seems he will have more control on this project and something that's always been great is how you can tell he respects the I.P. I think exploring the guardsmen would have the broadest appeal, it's almost WW2 it's an aesthetic more people can cling to, then you can explore the space marines more which will lean into the weirder shit
I just cant imagine Henry as anything other than The Emperor of Mankind
A rogue trader TV series could be really cool/good.
Didn't Henry Cavil drop out of the project after the FemCustard event?
Henry Cavill would make a greak Karl Franz, I know its gonna ba a 40K show but still.
Imagine someone sending this vid to the producers.. ''here use their ideas''
the ultramarines movie only real negative is the visuals lol, the writing is typical dan abnett stuff so i dont know why they hark on that.
Neverdies, do they mean perpetuals?
Classic tom and ben get excited and then ruin it for themselves
I have high hopes, but can Henry hold off Amazon. They already destroyed Rings of Power and Wheel of Time.
Get Guy Hayley and Dan Abnett in the writing team
No, Danny DeVito as a nurgling!
Astartes was a great little mini series with almost no talking and no “human” POVs, no exposition dump at the beginning of the episodes, and there was enough appeal to non warhammer folks that a bunch of my friends got into the game based off of Astartes alone. So there’s no fucking way that Amazon can make something worth viewing. ROP and WOT are such hot trash rushed “original” titles and that’s what Warhammer will turn out to be
I tried searching for the bad Henry news every bodies talking about and I didn't find any. I guess you guys just read headlines and not the actual articles. None of them say he did bad stuff. If anything it's literally the opposite. He refused to do "spicy" scenes in the event he could get into situations. Man tries to not be misogynist. Get's called one by the media anyways.
I don't think you understand how Hollywood works. Especially not when it comes to rich and powerful people, especially Men, silencing the truth.
Oh. You're subbed to some real far right creeps. I can see this would be pointless.
Considering some of the people you follow, I'd say that we aren't going to see eye to eye. Ever.
Weird how the channel filters directly referencing their side. So I will have to call them *"opposite of near opposite of left"*
@@beardedbear9901 I see you're one of those Believe All Women people.
As for the people I watch, they have different beliefs, but you probably believe anyone right of you are part of the same group. You know you can watch people and not agree with everything they believe. If you couldn't tell by the fact that I also watch Tom and Ben.
@@beardedbear9901 And btw "seeing eye to eye". This isn't about that. It's about you spreading false Henry news.
Never understood the hate for the Ultramarines movie. Sure, the CGI isn't the greatest, but alking it down like THIS? No, going too far.
If you wanted Mass appeal wouldn't you have to start with the heresy and like the rise of the emperor otherwise no one's going to know what the hell is going on no matter where you go.
Whats up with the shape of Bens head?
lets hope they dont wokify it...
what would it mean to "wokify" warhammer 40k?
@@adhararadhara4173 race-swapping main characters that do not retain to the lore. inserting political social justice messaging that is in our world that is not in the 40k universe as a whole. Keep it dark keep it helpless. keep lore accurate...
Six people liked this comment. That's creepy.
Are they not aware of who The Yogscast even are?
Spoilers, they're pro LGBTQIA
@@adhararadhara4173 What does it mean to "wokify" anything? Women, LGBTQIA or black people existing in the show. That's literally the only caveat.
The anti-woke crowd gussy it up behind all these other smoke screen arguments, but it's just racism, homophobia and sexism.
@@adhararadhara4173 If they put anyone who isn't a white heterosexual man in it. That's always what "woke" boils down to.
Getting some real bad vibes on words that trip your channel filter. I think I'm out.
It's not VOD Gobbo. It's CZcams. I've had to reword all my comments to you.
@@YangKos5000 No, the filters can absolutely be changed on a channel by channel basis. This channel has filters that make it harder to criticse the "not near not left" and I believe that's deliberate. It can't not be.
That serves your interests as someone "not near not left" but I won't support a channel to which I would be ideologically opposed.
@@beardedbear9901 I just told you my comments are also getting hit, but okay. Believe whatever you want.
@@YangKos5000 That doesn't actually alter my point though. We may be tripping the same word filters or different. I know for a fact, certain words are filtered. And those certain words being filtered is a red flag.
@@beardedbear9901 You're point doesn't stand. We literally don't know if VOD Gobbo has a channel thingy. But it's common knowledge that CZcams does. I can see one of you're hidden comments, you wrote JP. I wonder who's "side" is being muffled or if it's just CZcams doing a blanket hiding.
Everyone just forgetting Henry Cavill dated a 19 year old while he was in his thirties then?
"but but he's the golden boy and everyone says he's nice that's impossible! next you'll say that Leo 'the Nardo' Caprio only dates women in a very specific age range!!"
didn't hear of that. googled it and oof
I was hoping ben and tom would at least mention this, I guess they just don't know or something.
Adults are allowed to have relationships with each other. It might be weird, but not morally wrong.
So... Is that a problem? She was well over the age of consent (16 in the UK). DiCaprio is dating 22 year olds in his almost 50s. Al Pacino had baby with 29 year old in his 80s. Jay-Z started dating Beyonce when she was 19 and he was 31. Is that wierd? Yes, but they are all consenting adults, so why should you care? Why should Tom and Ben care?
Get the guy who made Astartes to write and direct.
There is no 'writing' in Astartes.