Parkland judge slams lawyers for 'unprofessional' and 'unacceptable' behavior in courtroom

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 31. 08. 2022
  • Parkland trial Judge Elizabeth Scherer, upon return from the lunch break, ripped into Nikolas Cruz's attorneys and the prosecution lawyers for what she called "rude" and "disrespectful" behavior from the lawyers while court proceedings are ongoing. The judge admonished both sides to cut out what they are doing and have respect for the courtroom.
    Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! czcams.com/users/livenowfox?su...
    Where to watch LiveNOW from FOX: www.livenowfox.com/
    Follow us @LiveNOWFOX on Twitter: / livenowfox
    Raw and unfiltered. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Limited commentary. No opinion. Experience LiveNOW from FOX.

Komentáře • 2,1K

  • @MrJTProductions100
    @MrJTProductions100 Před rokem +4819

    She sounds like she’s talking to a bunch of grade schoolers. Pretty sad she has to do this. Good for her for doing that.

    • @wellbeing2193
      @wellbeing2193 Před rokem +110

      you're right. Her speech takes me back in time when I was in elementary and when students needed discipline

    • @cindyk6140
      @cindyk6140 Před rokem +23

      I agree with you 1000%

    • @valkyrie4340
      @valkyrie4340 Před rokem +44

      Exactly my thought. I teach middle school. I have a similar lecture apparently scheduled for every Monday because the kids forget how to be civilised over the weekend.

    • @bethwatters1785
      @bethwatters1785 Před rokem +37

      She’s the judge it’s her job to keep structure. Order in the court! Should be common sense.

    • @shivanagireddy6522
      @shivanagireddy6522 Před rokem +10

      she luks like a grade school teacher may be why the lawyers dont feel like someone is in charge….

  • @ellaholland3675
    @ellaholland3675 Před rokem +2292

    The fact that she has to talk to them like they’re children. Absolutely ridiculous. This judge is a badass

    • @tylerj2113
      @tylerj2113 Před rokem +21

      She's a damn good judge!! I'm proud of that fact she put them in place and let them know whose in charge way to go Elizabeth 🎉

    • @goldenboyi1989
      @goldenboyi1989 Před rokem +7

      This Judge is VERY RUDE-How did she become a Judge? These are Lawyers with Kids and Familes not a bunch of kids in ELEMENTARY SCHOOL

    • @middle11
      @middle11 Před rokem +19

      @@goldenboyi1989 dude it's a courtroom... the fact that they have kids and families and can't be civil and respectable knowing full well how strict their environment they're in is is what is rude

    • @user-zt9tl4ow6j
      @user-zt9tl4ow6j Před rokem

      @@middle11 But it's kind of fun to play in a courtroom, but maybe not in this trial

    • @kellywelsch7235
      @kellywelsch7235 Před rokem +11

      @@goldenboyi1989 no...the defense wasted so many people's time, not calling half their witnesses, then the prosecution side was NOT ready after they just decided to rest their case. It's unprofessional and stupid. On top of that, the defense was being rude to the judge. They deserve being called out. The lawyers KNOW how to conduct themselves-they know better.

  • @haleyboo5617
    @haleyboo5617 Před rokem +555

    I absolutely love her. She's right this is a case that needs to be handled much more professionally. They need to be more respectful to the courtroom and the families of the victims. Sad she has to tell these lawyers how to act.

  • @reminiscer15
    @reminiscer15 Před rokem +288

    You know you've taken things too far when the judge no longer allows you to get up without permission. In all videos showing court cases, lawyers get up and move around freely but they're still professional, clearly these lawyers weren't so she has to lecture them and treat them like kindergarten children.

    • @kyndkristen
      @kyndkristen Před rokem +9

      Ha. You’re so right. I’m a court reporter and I smile inwardly any time a judge has to reprimand attorneys like children. It’s so pathetic but it’s fun to witness.
      Edit - And I have had a few judges who have shut attorneys up and not allowed them to speak or approach. That, or my ever favorite “I ask the questions. You are to answer yes or no and only when asked. Nothing more.”

    • @reminiscer15
      @reminiscer15 Před rokem +6

      @@kyndkristen Yep sounds like an elementary classroom at times. I would smile inwardly too since some attorneys deserve it.

    • @novascotiaskater1868
      @novascotiaskater1868 Před rokem

      It actually depends on the Judge…some Judges allow the attorneys to stay seated when conducting witness questioning, some require attorneys to stand up …some judges allow attorneys to walk around between the attorneys’ tables and the Judge’s Dias while others require them to ask permission but all Judges require that attorneys ask to approach the witness or to approach the Bench and that’s because the courtroom deputies need to be paying attention to that interaction in case violence erupts.

  • @nicolemay4427
    @nicolemay4427 Před rokem +3034

    It’s sad that professional lawyers have to be reprimanded by the judge is a shame

    • @tele68
      @tele68 Před rokem +48

      The professional part is the missing piece. Elite attorneys would know better.

    • @eucliduschaumeau8813
      @eucliduschaumeau8813 Před rokem +18

      They need to take all but one person from the defense team and have them in court, while the rest of the defense mob is sent back to the office to do their work. Defense needs to be ONE person to lead.

    • @DrummerJacob
      @DrummerJacob Před rokem +3

      I mean, thats why they have a judge. They dont decide the verdict, they just make sure procedures are followed.

    • @bellamia-susiep.3550
      @bellamia-susiep.3550 Před rokem +16

      The world needs to learn that “Respect Matters”.

    • @nancygreen3705
      @nancygreen3705 Před rokem +13

      She's having to reprimand them like they're in school.

  • @jessaguilar4747
    @jessaguilar4747 Před rokem +1949

    Good for her, I’m so glad she is scolding them.

    • @3rdreichball525
      @3rdreichball525 Před rokem +9

      Its what i hate about american courts. They are more interested in procedure, and how the courts look than they are the actual truth. Its why so much corruption is in the judicial system because it is a playground for the judges and lawyers. Ive always wondered just who the preceedings are for actually because it looks to me that justice is the last thing on all their minds

    • @mechaelculbreath2290
      @mechaelculbreath2290 Před rokem +10

      Sad, she gotta talk to grown man-babies like that! She's not gonna let them goofys turn her court into a circus...great job judge!!

    • @jewishwaffle3527
      @jewishwaffle3527 Před rokem

      @@3rdreichball525 oh yeah cause you 3rd Reich nazis are so corruption free?

    • @ryanmurphy5472
      @ryanmurphy5472 Před rokem +6

      Why? The judge messed up during jury selection that’s not professional

    • @kevinfrench239
      @kevinfrench239 Před rokem +4

      @@ryanmurphy5472 the judge don't pick the jury all on her own the lawyers are part of the process so if she messed up so did they.

  • @haileyiris2025
    @haileyiris2025 Před rokem +104

    I have been watching this trial for the most part, hours upon hours. The attorney’s really have been getting progressively more unprofessional. This conversation was extremely needed. They should feel embarrassed as they are on live TV and this is an extremely serious trial.

  • @sarahcahoot5444
    @sarahcahoot5444 Před rokem +74

    This truly is sad. The fact the judge has to tell grown adults who are lawyers how to behave in a court room is just unbelievable. Professionalisms needs to be taught in schools because obviously people aren’t learning this at home.

  • @themilkkmaid_
    @themilkkmaid_ Před rokem +1753

    This is embarrassing shes even having to say these things to "seasoned lawyers" like seriously. I would be ASHAMED to be the folks shes referring to. 🤦🏻‍♀️

    • @lucy2014
      @lucy2014 Před rokem +15

      Me too. In the beginning I wasn't crazy about this judge. But she has definitely let these attorneys know whose in charge. The fact she had to scold them like they are children is ridiculous. These attorneys know better. I think they'll think twice before getting out of line again!

    • @graciemontes4801
      @graciemontes4801 Před rokem

      @@lucy2014 m

    • @graciemontes4801
      @graciemontes4801 Před rokem

      @@lucy2014 i

    • @DomManInT1
      @DomManInT1 Před rokem +3

      What makes you think they are "seasoned lawyers"? All I see are college trained lawyers. All of them need to request to have their tuition returned.

    • @trapmafia4716
      @trapmafia4716 Před rokem +6

      @@lucy2014 I think a lot of people and women, in particular, are over-critical of her because she's so good looking but please ladies, don't be so jealous and childish, enough of the school yard spite, take her on her merits, she might be a great looking bird but don't be so superficial in your assessment, she's a very intelligent and capable young woman

  • @cherryhappily
    @cherryhappily Před rokem +962

    Wow she has to talk to them like she’s a teacher in grade school! Absolutely ridiculous!

    • @raieful
      @raieful Před rokem +1

      Exactly🤣🤣🤣

    • @AngelofAnguish
      @AngelofAnguish Před rokem +3

      In my opinion, welcome to "modern society!"

    • @suzannebert3652
      @suzannebert3652 Před rokem +5

      The atty's are children

    • @Riana.dS.
      @Riana.dS. Před rokem +8

      No, it is not ridiculous at all. You seem ignorant about Court procedure.
      Lawyers are trained to be professional and respectful in Court - If they fail to do so and display "grade school" behavior, the Judge is obliged to address that - In this case the Judge handled it very firmly and professionally.

    • @AnastasiaBeau0
      @AnastasiaBeau0 Před rokem +7

      @@Riana.dS. You must not have understood the comment

  • @user-of7pv6fj8h
    @user-of7pv6fj8h Před rokem +22

    I absolutely love this judge and how she handles her court room ! It’s a court of law not a playground !

  • @marimullan4012
    @marimullan4012 Před rokem +4

    I have never seen such unprofessional behavior as those defense attorney's have displayed. That Tamara Curtis flipping the bird as the victims families are sitting there. She is a complete disgrace to that profession. This Judge should never have had to stop & lecture them on their behavior.

    • @isabelnecessary9416
      @isabelnecessary9416 Před rokem

      Agreed. I could not believe what I saw - utterly reprehensible behavior of a lawyer.

  • @christophermillett2273
    @christophermillett2273 Před rokem +1097

    As a judge, you need to show them who's court room you're in!! So glad she has a backbone and let the attorneys know who's boss.

    • @colaboytje
      @colaboytje Před rokem +7

      It's the public's courtroom. The courtroom is not from a judge.

    • @ethanh8791
      @ethanh8791 Před rokem +12

      ​@@colaboytje There shall be order in the court! Who usually says that w/ the gavel again?

    • @colaboytje
      @colaboytje Před rokem +2

      @@ethanh8791 The judge. Did you even read what I wrote?

    • @edmunddonnelly3881
      @edmunddonnelly3881 Před rokem +5

      It seems the defense lawyers, particularly the lead attorney, don't respect this judge. She's been sensing it and has had enough.

    • @ethanh8791
      @ethanh8791 Před rokem +8

      @@colaboytje I reread it and now it even makes less more sense. Cheers.

  • @Jennylouise87
    @Jennylouise87 Před rokem +779

    The families of the victims deserve better than this. Good job by the judge!

    • @Thomas-he1ee
      @Thomas-he1ee Před rokem

      The families don't matter. It's the law that matters the most and this judge is an idiot

    • @Shevenmayes
      @Shevenmayes Před rokem

      She got off the case “disdain” she was completely unprofessional.

    • @princesspanda12012
      @princesspanda12012 Před rokem

      @@Shevenmayes no she was NOT

    • @Shevenmayes
      @Shevenmayes Před rokem

      @@princesspanda12012 yes she was told to leave the case for disdain but she is refusing to get off the stand which will lead her into trouble since this is her first homicide case.

  • @DrSonus
    @DrSonus Před rokem +6

    Imagine at this stage, with all these lawyers and professionals who've been highly educated with hundreds of thousands of dollars in tuition, need to be disciplined like school children. Way to go, Judge!

  • @misslen575
    @misslen575 Před rokem +101

    She doesn't even sound like she is yelling at them. She looks and sounds like she has her emotions in check and the disrespect she gets for being a respectful judge is just bad. I wonder if it's because she is pretty that those lawyers do this

    • @twilit
      @twilit Před rokem +5

      she’s not holding authority. people don’t listen to men or women who speak quickly with a high strident voice. she needs to lower her voice and speak slowly and clearly about what she expects and what the consequences will be if it doesn’t happen. when someone speaks like that it creates a situation where people don’t respect their position not even by choice but just by instinct.

    • @misslen575
      @misslen575 Před rokem +14

      @@twilit I'm pretty sure that's just her voice though

    • @haroldharold9042
      @haroldharold9042 Před rokem +17

      @@twilit If the lawyers are incapable of respecting her based on the sound of her voice, they’re incompetent.

    • @roselynquinn8060
      @roselynquinn8060 Před rokem

      I thought the same thing.
      She was a mentor for prosecutor

    • @elliottnolasco.
      @elliottnolasco. Před rokem

      ABSOLUTELY IN REGARDS TO THE FACT THAT SHE IS "PRETTY." ITS UNFORTUNATE BUT IN FACT VERY MUCH TRUE PPL DON'T TAKE YOU SERIOUS AT TIMES IF YOU ARE "ATTRACTIVE". ESPECIALLY IN CERTAIN WORK ENVIRONMENTS AND BEING FEMALE AS WELL.

  • @876noortje
    @876noortje Před rokem +848

    The fact that at the end of the video, the judge asks one of the defense lawyers a valid question and she gets answered ‘sure’ instead of ‘yes your honor’ means that they did not get the message. This needs to be over already, in my opinion if you deliberately kill more than 2 people or 1 child, the death penalty should be given without. You kill 17 people you have given up all your rights.

    • @GrumpyCat-mw5xl
      @GrumpyCat-mw5xl Před rokem +17

      If they are guilty beyond a reasonable doubt or confess them all should get the DP. Like if they are on film doing it then that’s it. No chance of getting the wrong person. Get it over with.

    • @TheAwesomeTolga198
      @TheAwesomeTolga198 Před rokem +6

      Yeah, the Supreme Court abandoned that approach long ago. The penalty phase is a constitutionally required element of a capital case.

    • @GlamorganManor
      @GlamorganManor Před rokem +39

      When she asked the defense who is going to take responsibility to address the question, they all sat there like bumps on a log. That law firm is messed up.

    • @retafelberg3203
      @retafelberg3203 Před rokem +3

      @@GrumpyCat-mw5xl people have made false confessions before.

    • @japeter89
      @japeter89 Před rokem

      I don't think he should get the death penalty. He was a crack baby, sexually abused, got no help, no early intervention. It's the system that failed and his prostitute mom that failed. He deserves life

  • @thirdborn333
    @thirdborn333 Před rokem +1498

    I like her. She’s no nonsense, competent. And for the people saying she has a “bad attitude” I wouldn’t expect it to be too pleasant considering the type of trial that it is. I feel like because she’s female that she’s being judged more harshly than if she were male. I have yet to go in front of a judge that’s been all fuzzy, nice and welcoming.

    • @Whynotcreate
      @Whynotcreate Před rokem +100

      That's definitely true. If it was a man using that tone no one would have an issue with it

    • @cherithmarcum523
      @cherithmarcum523 Před rokem +42

      I agree most people in that profession are very thick skinned and have the same type of attitudes as this judge maybe even more strict and harsh. Law ain’t for the weak or the meek!

    • @jonquiljones
      @jonquiljones Před rokem +89

      It's absolutely because she's female, and the fact that she's young and beautiful only adds to the disrespect she has received.

    • @Grace4_All
      @Grace4_All Před rokem +4

      There is a way to be inviting and stern at the same time it's a a balancing act that only Judges can do. That's why there Judges. You can't emotionally distraught and have outburst. Gotta keep it keel and keep it moving. She's right this trial is a mess. She let it get to this point. So she needs to take accountability

    • @jonquiljones
      @jonquiljones Před rokem +71

      @@Grace4_All You are only referring to her as "emotional" because she's a woman. Woman don't run around mass murdering people. That's "emotional". Having to ask, repeatedly, for order and respect in her own courtroom is not.

  • @ashersmith3655
    @ashersmith3655 Před rokem +15

    Its truly pathetic that the judge has to call so called professionals down like a bunch of kids being loud or something it shows what the system is comeing to and how unprofessional they really are

  • @tabithastudios
    @tabithastudios Před rokem +6

    I literally have the same exact conversation with my elementary students every once in a while. It’s ridiculous that she has to lecture them like this.

  • @ChristopherMichael180
    @ChristopherMichael180 Před rokem +509

    Yes! Taking back control. I feel like she has been so patient, but enough is enough.

    • @Sunn777
      @Sunn777 Před rokem +7

      She had to since she knew how incompetent she is.

    • @roomcguire
      @roomcguire Před rokem +3

      @@Sunn777 annnnd you say that based on…?

    • @godsu
      @godsu Před rokem +2

      @@Sunn777 Stop crying 😂😂

    • @anyITsolution
      @anyITsolution Před rokem

      I felt like I went back to Highschool “no manners! No manners ! RIP mrs Santiago.. I’m not a pizza delivery boy thanks to her. Nothing wrong with delivering pizza “she just always said I don’t want y students deliver my pizza” that stuck with me…

    • @princesspanda12012
      @princesspanda12012 Před rokem

      @@Sunn777 cry

  • @patrickbeck3285
    @patrickbeck3285 Před rokem +289

    As lawyers, they know how they should conduct themselves in a court of law. Yesterday, the lead defense attorney made a motion for a mistrial while sitting down. That was rude and disrespectful to the court. Bravo to the judge for setting both sides straight.

    • @salvaged_wretch
      @salvaged_wretch Před rokem +8

      yes !! I thought that was unusual as well. the defense seems lazy and desperately seeking a mistrial.

    • @tedhart4468
      @tedhart4468 Před rokem

      It’s not unusual she told the they didn’t need to stand every time a discussion about something took place the only time they need to stand is when there’s a objection and they give a reason for the objection

    • @kellywelsch7235
      @kellywelsch7235 Před rokem

      exactly!!!

    • @theroadless
      @theroadless Před rokem +2

      In all honesty, she's missing that intimidation factor that's usually accompanies judge's. She needs to control the court room and it doesn't seem like they respect her all that much.

  • @gennabennetts705
    @gennabennetts705 Před rokem +7

    Not the lawyer saying “sure” instead of “yes judge” after the judge has JUST spoken about being professional and respectful

    • @Samm.A
      @Samm.A Před rokem

      that lawyer thinks she rules the world…

    • @gennabennetts705
      @gennabennetts705 Před rokem

      @@Samm.A nah, they’re at a trial where 17 lives have been lost and his lawyers are talking and messing about like this is nothing - she needed to say something

    • @haileym444
      @haileym444 Před rokem

      Judge has been unprofessional this whole time

    • @beckydiaz365
      @beckydiaz365 Před rokem +1

      @@haileym444 then you be the judge

  • @gigieyre
    @gigieyre Před rokem +5

    Ridiculous! This is how I have to speak to my elementary students. These lawyers are on tv. Everyone can see the unprofessionalism. This will end up being grounds for a mistrial. Outrageous.

  • @justhearmeout3959
    @justhearmeout3959 Před rokem +490

    I've seen comments around the web about the judge's "attitude." It's interesting, because I've seen male judges speak the same way and they get lauded for it.

    • @kristenbarker29
      @kristenbarker29 Před rokem +1

      Of anything she has been patient. There is only so much bs you can take. Male judges can be the biggest assholes and no one blinks an eye

    • @justhearmeout3959
      @justhearmeout3959 Před rokem +33

      @@kristenbarker29 I like to question my own potential implicit biases. So in my head I imagined the same words, same tone, but in a bassy baritone man's voice. My reaction made me... uncomfortable.
      I'm working on it. I like doing that because it helps me guage if my reaction to something is real or simply programmed by societal pressures

    • @robertparsons313
      @robertparsons313 Před rokem +14

      Many people are praising her. Some are not totally impressed with her at all times. That's the same thing that happens to men.

    • @nenej12
      @nenej12 Před rokem +6

      its clear biased towards the judge in the comment section i try not to look at it

    • @natsvsam1933
      @natsvsam1933 Před rokem +2

      So true

  • @jeremy144713
    @jeremy144713 Před rokem +329

    The defense lawyers are so unprofessional, she literally asked “who’s the point person” and no one said anything and she singled one of them out and she still tried to play dead like uhhh sure

    • @cynthiaandena3350
      @cynthiaandena3350 Před rokem +9

      Totally agee with u

    • @deniserossiter1059
      @deniserossiter1059 Před rokem +23

      I know. It should’ve also been: “Yes, your honor or no your honor”!! But they just sit there. Like,” I dunno!!”

    • @omarmercado7788
      @omarmercado7788 Před rokem +4

      watch it again she didn’t single anyone out that lady said she could do it

    • @jeremy144713
      @jeremy144713 Před rokem +13

      @@omarmercado7788 “she could do it” bruh. Have you ever worked a job where you’re trying to impress the boss? You’re the first one up like I can help with that. That’s how every single one of those lawyers should of been. They all tried to dodge the work and play dead until she LITERALLY singled one of them out and the lawyer was like sureeee and the judge said “I’m asking” and she said uhhh sureee. Like she didn’t want to do the work. It’s petty and unprofessional.

    • @Peterpeterpumpkineater1000
      @Peterpeterpumpkineater1000 Před rokem +6

      It’s like the the study group who did no work for the project lol

  • @caitycregss
    @caitycregss Před rokem +1

    Girllll she really said “ sure” in reponse to the judge??? BALLS!!!

  • @marvink.9369
    @marvink.9369 Před rokem +1

    It's like a teacher telling her class to behave back in high school.

  • @kevinhornbuckle
    @kevinhornbuckle Před rokem +318

    The judge was concise and emphatic. Decorum is required for the administration of a fair trial.

    • @SuperBlueeyes89
      @SuperBlueeyes89 Před rokem

      He shouldnt get a fair trial he admited so he is sentenced to death end of story. Russia has got it right u kill u get killed. I wish u can kill someone more then once cause a mass shooter can only die once but killed 100

  • @lizard928
    @lizard928 Před rokem +384

    This judge is not messing around she will have law and order in her courtroom or she will bring the hammer down on people, I'm surprised these lawyers are acting this way in a courtroom.

    • @Frontdesk99
      @Frontdesk99 Před rokem +4

      It's clear that she has been messing around way too long.

    • @lizard928
      @lizard928 Před rokem +3

      @@Frontdesk99 Most judges don't tolerate nonsense wonder why she waited so long to say something.

    • @pigtailsandteddybears
      @pigtailsandteddybears Před rokem +5

      She's starting to be more assertive the further this goes on and it's nice to see. This monsters lawyers make Amber Turd's lawyers look like geniuses.

    • @trapmafia4716
      @trapmafia4716 Před rokem +1

      @@pigtailsandteddybears I think she's very emotionally upset about the case and maybe takes the weight of it and the victims heavy on her heart, plus she seems maybe a little to "nice" if i can say that combined with the fact people can't see past her great looks and take her seriously, it's very sad because she deserves better! She's just a sweetheart really, to fair to everyone

    • @danielrudolph3252
      @danielrudolph3252 Před rokem

      Probably talking about how hot she is.

  • @476233
    @476233 Před rokem +3

    I’m so glad she put her foot down. All of these attorneys have acted so childish and inappropriate. I’ve heard the printer in the background and chatter multiple times. I’m glad she finally addressed it.

  • @AlexHurleyMusic
    @AlexHurleyMusic Před rokem +1

    Its giving teacher in high school fed up with the class, only with PROFESSIONAL ATTORNEYS.

  • @Dspalten
    @Dspalten Před rokem +323

    Good for this judge. For those who doubted this judges abilities to handle this trial were quick to judge her. She is more than capable of running her courtroom.

    • @Frontdesk99
      @Frontdesk99 Před rokem +8

      If she needs to start ranting like this so far into the trial, she clearly is not capable.

    • @LMCSM
      @LMCSM Před rokem +6

      It's a bit late. Choosing to act professional at the END of the trial? Yeah good one

    • @haileym444
      @haileym444 Před rokem +4

      Nah she’s been unprofessional in this case plenty of times, unnecessarily rude all the time yet now she’s telling other people that they’re being rude

    • @MrsznewyawkRN
      @MrsznewyawkRN Před rokem +2

      @@haileym444 hit the nail on the head 🎯 ; ive commented before the judge acts like a dang teenage girl going through puberty 🙄

    • @mrniz461
      @mrniz461 Před rokem +4

      @@haileym444 lol being rude to the lawyers defending a murderer? Lmao

  • @bellamia-susiep.3550
    @bellamia-susiep.3550 Před rokem +74

    The world needs to learn that “Respect Does Matter”.

  • @nucflashevent
    @nucflashevent Před rokem +5

    Speaking to the Judges statement "I've never been one of the Judges who require permission to do every little thing", I believe her Honor now understand **WHY** other Judges do exactly that.

  • @laurieconklin9765
    @laurieconklin9765 Před rokem +1

    Absolutely right! Make them respect the decorum of the court!

  • @mariemanuel4428
    @mariemanuel4428 Před rokem +135

    Right on Judge. Apparently, the judge has had enough.

  • @anjaxtv
    @anjaxtv Před rokem +52

    You tell them off judge 👏🏾👏🏾!! I adore her no nonsense approach

  • @stunner672
    @stunner672 Před rokem +1

    Well said Judge! I’ve been watching this trial from day one. There are two attorneys with the State that needed to be called out, they are both rude and unprofessional.

    • @Shevenmayes
      @Shevenmayes Před rokem

      The judge was rude that’s why she was DISMISSED FROM THE CASE hahaha

  • @n.e2099
    @n.e2099 Před rokem

    Definitely on point ... have respect for the families

  • @therrykeasberry425
    @therrykeasberry425 Před rokem +145

    Good for her, this is a judge with more ‘balls’ than most of those lawyers in the courtroom!!!

  • @andrethomas4048
    @andrethomas4048 Před rokem +39

    This was needed. I've been looking at this whole thing as a joke due to their behavior. You can't bring justice with behavior like this

    • @Shevenmayes
      @Shevenmayes Před rokem

      The judge was unprofessional and was dismissed from this case. The lawyers did good, she just wanted her fame since this case is really important.

  • @alieubah8865
    @alieubah8865 Před rokem +2

    If there's anyone that's unprofessional in the court room is that Judge.

  • @fatoujammeh5069
    @fatoujammeh5069 Před rokem

    Well said thank you

  • @djs8538
    @djs8538 Před rokem +85

    I totally agree judge totally 1 million percent it's like dealing with kindergarten children in an unprofessional atmosphere. The fact that you have to talk to them is disgusting they should know better they're grown this is not a playground this is not an amusement center this is a court of law seeking the righteous Justice for the victims and their families

    • @cyberdefault
      @cyberdefault Před rokem

      You say that now but this can easily be fuel for a mistrial on a death row case

  • @christineperez7562
    @christineperez7562 Před rokem +189

    What is unexceptionable is this trial is still going on.

    • @chuckfan1
      @chuckfan1 Před rokem +33

      What's unacceptable is your spelling
      Figure it out
      I gave you a hint

    • @22KingRancher
      @22KingRancher Před rokem +24

      @@chuckfan1 youre such a hero. you must be Captain Perfect. have they given you a key to the city yet?

    • @alfobootidir2474
      @alfobootidir2474 Před rokem

      No. It’s good. America needs to see the effects of a mass shooting. Not just a yearbook page full of pics of dead kids. We need to see the brutality and pain, and the way the bullets ripped them apart. Shouldn’t be voting on gun rights without viewing this trial

    • @kevinfrench239
      @kevinfrench239 Před rokem +12

      @@chuckfan1 why didn't you finish you're message with a period Mr perfect😂🤣

    • @DrummerJacob
      @DrummerJacob Před rokem +10

      What do you mean? Why wouldnt we have a trial? That makes no sense. Also unexceptionable makes no sense.

  • @dhines3804
    @dhines3804 Před rokem +1

    Sounds like what I have to say in my classroom every once in awhile to get things back in control! 🙂

  • @robertferreiro3466
    @robertferreiro3466 Před rokem

    Well said....give them your mind..

  • @MrGriff305
    @MrGriff305 Před rokem +88

    It's sad that she has to be a mother/school teacher in a mass murder trial. Show some respect for the court and the victims' families.

  • @katherinealamillo4416
    @katherinealamillo4416 Před rokem +13

    I can’t imagine how stressed and irritated the judge has to go home everyday 🤦🏻‍♀️

  • @Joker96624
    @Joker96624 Před 2 dny

    If you shut your eyes and replace ‘courtroom’ with ‘classroom’, she sounds like a 2nd grade teacher.

  • @JBoo
    @JBoo Před rokem

    FINALLY waited for the judge to say how disrespectful they been.

  • @stacyeandrew2
    @stacyeandrew2 Před rokem +80

    You can tell she is a good judge and they had started to take advantage of her lax rules. But this is why courtrooms are so serious. This is peoples lives. For victims and the accused. So it needs to be serious

    • @lionr1470
      @lionr1470 Před rokem +1

      She will be a good judge only when she will show mercy and give the easy way out by the death panelty other wise it is for you to judge.

    • @gemmacook1753
      @gemmacook1753 Před rokem +3

      @@lionr1470 what are you even trying to say?

    • @matt_canon
      @matt_canon Před rokem +1

      @@lionr1470 That's for the jury to decide, not her.

    • @lionr1470
      @lionr1470 Před rokem

      @@gemmacook1753 Death pantley is the easy way out and thats what he should get very simple but i know you dont see it that way so im saying it and again give hime death panlety send him just wher he sented those 17 kids to death

  • @JRS7777
    @JRS7777 Před rokem +3

    Someone has P M S. Holy cow.

  • @renegadethedestroyer
    @renegadethedestroyer Před rokem +1

    You don’t have to ask permission to move in a courtroom

  • @yanisfra3029
    @yanisfra3029 Před rokem

    Well spoken!

  • @dannigro8794
    @dannigro8794 Před rokem +70

    These lawyers are grasping at straws and the judge is very professional she has a great career ahead of her.

  • @MariaM-fu6wm
    @MariaM-fu6wm Před rokem +7

    This judge is terribly bias and unprofessional

    • @amandashook5092
      @amandashook5092 Před rokem +1

      100% I can't lie, I do think there's been points where she has gave reason for an appeal for sure.

    • @HybridSpektar
      @HybridSpektar Před rokem

      How?

  • @Rajeev_kumar991
    @Rajeev_kumar991 Před rokem +1

    This mindset of killing at such a young age
    With this heavy weapon he killed 17 and injured so many
    Death penalty will make a statement then many young minds will fear to commit again

  • @Sessamagno
    @Sessamagno Před rokem

    This whole situation is a mess and so is the people and lawyers! I’m glad she put it down.

  • @CaliforniaDreamin.
    @CaliforniaDreamin. Před rokem +22

    Good for the judge!

  • @sagatuppercut2960
    @sagatuppercut2960 Před rokem +15

    If adults are behaving this way, imagine how their children behave at school.

  • @lorigovi718
    @lorigovi718 Před rokem

    Wow! Literally sounds like the procedures and expectations I have in place for my 7th grade junior high school students and that I have to remind them of. Smh

  • @Bella-ez3hl
    @Bella-ez3hl Před rokem +1

    she’s acting like a teacher which is a cold reminder of the monster those lawyers are representing

  • @Highland_Moo
    @Highland_Moo Před rokem +155

    The more I watch this case, the more I love that Judge. She had to deal with the defence lawyers trying to have her removed from the case. She’s constantly having to deal with their petulant and rude behaviour. Not a thought for how their actions are making the whole thing even harder for the families involved. The lead counsel for defence needs to give herself and her team a good kick up the arse. I don’t have much respect for them at all now and I genuinely tried to have an unbiased view of them from the start….I know they have a job to do and in this particular case I assumed it wouldn’t be very pleasant for them. However, as the weeks and months have progressed, I’m astounded at their lack of respect for the Judge and court.

    • @claudiacanales2662
      @claudiacanales2662 Před rokem +6

      It’s the opposite for me; the more I see this judge, the more I shake my head. This needed a seasoned judge! She comes across like she’s a beauty pageant contestant. The fact that all of these people have been acting disrespectfully for weeks tells you she never established order from the beginning!

    • @deezelkane
      @deezelkane Před rokem

      @@claudiacanales2662 this judge was hired purely for internet views - tell me they didn’t think how attractive she is, would garner more viewership. It’s literally the only reason I clicked on the video.

    • @yennyku5240
      @yennyku5240 Před rokem +22

      @@deezelkane or maybe she's a judge that is taking on this case because you know.. she is a judge

    • @deezelkane
      @deezelkane Před rokem

      @@yennyku5240 yeh, keep telling yourself that.

    • @yennyku5240
      @yennyku5240 Před rokem +4

      @@deezelkane so.... you're saying she is not a judge? Yikes the judicial in a lot of trouble I suppose

  • @tinacathey8241
    @tinacathey8241 Před rokem +19

    Good for you judge!!
    It's about time judges say it's enough.
    Thank you

  • @bossin_up_888
    @bossin_up_888 Před rokem +6

    I have crazy respect for this judge 👏
    I have never, ever seen a court force a trial on someone after they've pleaded guilty and waived their right to trial. I can understand a hearing and sentencing hearing where the victims have the opportunity to speak but, it literally blows my mind that this is even happening like, from a law standpoint as well as the constitution of rights go. Js

  • @peacelovetennis10
    @peacelovetennis10 Před rokem +1

    Oh no high school flashbacks!! It’s so sad that she has to do this. “Please do not get out your seat unless you ask” Exactly what one of my teachers said

  • @cecisharp
    @cecisharp Před rokem +4

    I don't love the inflammatory, scandalous, TMZ style titles on these videos.

  • @charlottelovato5770
    @charlottelovato5770 Před rokem +39

    What a shame there behaving like children. She did the right thing letting them know it's a courtroom not a playground.. Grow up kids geeze! 🤣🤣

  • @misshoneychurch8153
    @misshoneychurch8153 Před rokem +1

    It’s terrifying to me how terribly this courtroom has turned into a free for all.

  • @roxannemoser
    @roxannemoser Před rokem +5

    It truly is sad that she has to talk to these adults like kindergarteners. Even though she reprimanded both sides, this actually helps the defense. Oh goodness, I don't agree with the DP, but this kid has proved he is not remorseful at all.

  • @gaildunne8307
    @gaildunne8307 Před rokem +8

    Good for this judge , they should be respectful of this judge . 👏🏻

  • @MFord99
    @MFord99 Před rokem +3

    Why has this serious trial become a freaking classroom??!!

  • @nicoles2289
    @nicoles2289 Před rokem +1

    Who is paying for all of these lawyers?

  • @kdjec16
    @kdjec16 Před rokem +1

    It's sad the professionals have to be told to be professional

  • @kylespencer1169
    @kylespencer1169 Před rokem +45

    Love her! I’m surprised she hasn’t held one of them in contempt yet!

    • @Monkey-fc9nc
      @Monkey-fc9nc Před rokem +2

      She's horrible yelling at lawyers like children. This is this judges First DP case.

    • @Shevenmayes
      @Shevenmayes Před rokem

      @@loneliestsweetpotato_ they wasn’t acting badly at all she just is a Karen

  • @cm1642
    @cm1642 Před rokem +5

    Can the judge possibly wear any more makeup for the cameras?

  • @colombiawithanita
    @colombiawithanita Před rokem

    After seeing several judges in USA the family court and on TV, this is really a tremendous honorable profession and I’m amazed on all the judges I have seen that they are extremely empathetic and take seriously their job, that’s why they ask for silence, and they are very good with math.

  • @dannyrichards6233
    @dannyrichards6233 Před rokem

    Thx 4 sharing

  • @alecgonzalez6910
    @alecgonzalez6910 Před rokem +71

    Throughout this whole case from the beginning she definitely doesn’t play around or neither wants to put up with the bs with the defense team for this monster she’s a legend I got respect for this judge 👩‍⚖️.

  • @YaYa-ke1zr
    @YaYa-ke1zr Před rokem +88

    I feel ashamed for those lawyers. I didn’t even do anything and I feel called out. I couldnt even look at the screen after the first minute...
    I’m sorry Judge. I’m gonna do better.

  • @beautiffullove4812
    @beautiffullove4812 Před rokem +1

    Because they don’t respect you as a judge.

  • @doracampos2088
    @doracampos2088 Před rokem +2

    All these “professionals” are an embarrassment!

  • @realherefordtimes.8159
    @realherefordtimes.8159 Před rokem +6

    poor choice of words from an terrible judge...school shooting and she uses the term "playground" pathetic

  • @pineberry7586
    @pineberry7586 Před rokem +9

    Props the judge for keeping order in this chaos!

    • @DrummerJacob
      @DrummerJacob Před rokem +1

      That is their job. LOL They dont decide the verdict or ask the questions, they just make sure court is run properly. Thats all they do.

  • @Michelle-CA-USA
    @Michelle-CA-USA Před rokem

    👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 Way to command a court! ~ Michelle, CA

  • @kimhaughey9161
    @kimhaughey9161 Před rokem +3

    Judge - you go girl! Shame you have had to go at a bunch of so called professionals to know how to get on with their job😱

  • @XlogicXX
    @XlogicXX Před rokem +9

    This aint gonna work, Judge. So, time out for the next atty who interrupts when you are speaking? Sounded more like a power trip to me. Sorry.

    • @eucliduschaumeau8813
      @eucliduschaumeau8813 Před rokem

      You think the defense is being adult about this? They act like they are in kindergarten. Judge had to scold them like the little children they are. GOOD on her. The defense is so weak that they need six of them to do the job of one.

    • @XlogicXX
      @XlogicXX Před rokem

      @@eucliduschaumeau8813 ok?

    • @allysonh6410
      @allysonh6410 Před rokem +1

      @@eucliduschaumeau8813 No. This is Sadly going to be declared a mistrial. Watch. And it's all because this judge is in over her head

    • @XlogicXX
      @XlogicXX Před rokem +3

      @@allysonh6410 TBH that's exactly the sense I got and I haven’t really been following the case. She comes across as quite defensive when the attys raise issues b4 her. Perhaps she's a new judge?

  • @paulofreire9174
    @paulofreire9174 Před rokem +18

    I wish she would lead by example with respect to professionalism, but her court, her rules.

    • @Georgia-bt2fc
      @Georgia-bt2fc Před rokem

      In what way?

    • @vp0617
      @vp0617 Před rokem +3

      @@Georgia-bt2fc In a way where she relays her message with respect and understanding, not like she's fed-up with the unruly class.
      From the sounds of it, it seems like this is the first time she's addressing these issues, so she should have said it with a bit more tact.

    • @boomds5602
      @boomds5602 Před rokem +1

      @@vp0617 no. These are grown seasoned attorneys. She isn’t their mommy

    • @vp0617
      @vp0617 Před rokem +2

      @@boomds5602 sounds like she's trying to be by the way she is talking to them.

    • @sabinesteil4690
      @sabinesteil4690 Před rokem

      @@vp0617 I think she was very patient and very respectful. In fact I think she could have been much more firm in het use of voice ánd words.

  • @RATsnak3
    @RATsnak3 Před rokem

    This Judge is really great. I don't think we could have asked for a better judge.

  • @marshalldannon5593
    @marshalldannon5593 Před rokem +1

    Good for this judge but man any lawyer that has to be kept straight like this ain’t worth a damn penny.

  • @princesssadieloo
    @princesssadieloo Před rokem +5

    Do it! It’s your court room and they need to act like adults!

  • @FPChris
    @FPChris Před rokem +36

    She’s been the one that says 10 minute break that takes 20. Giving 1.5 hours for lunch. Then everybody still not back on time. Total waste of taxpayers money this trial.

    • @boomds5602
      @boomds5602 Před rokem +1

      It takes 20 because people aren’t back on time

    • @matt_canon
      @matt_canon Před rokem +8

      'Total waste of taxpayers money this trial.' -- Taxpayer money is always going to be wasted. Even if this trial wasn't happening, it would be wasted elsewhere.

    • @63076topher
      @63076topher Před rokem

      @@boomds5602 Say what you mean the defense team.

    • @geoffpoole483
      @geoffpoole483 Před rokem +6

      Time management is very poor on her part. The chaos in the courtroom is her fault. She's very unprofessional.

  • @nikkicohen126
    @nikkicohen126 Před rokem +2

    For a case of this magnitude, its shocking what these clowns are doing. I feel for the families of the victims

  • @Theturthwill
    @Theturthwill Před rokem +2

    It’s good to know that the lawyers are not taken there job seriously. Hope the families were there to see how careless these lawyers are about there deceased kids

  • @mre1995
    @mre1995 Před rokem +6

    Damn felt like being back at primary school for a minute there, embarrassing.

  • @yarelybanuelos1004
    @yarelybanuelos1004 Před rokem +6

    Sounds like an 8th grade teacher mad at disruptive student lol

    • @Judas1911WR1
      @Judas1911WR1 Před rokem

      i said it befor and i say it again... if anything goes wrong in this case it will go wrong it will be the judge fault... feels like its the first day of the job and she cant handle it!!! "... i need to do one thing at a time... why dont you make a clean copy for me ...i will be right back so i can consentrate!" ...and storms out of the court room

  • @cre8mus1c
    @cre8mus1c Před rokem

    As if you should need to be told!!! How embarrassing...good on you Judge

  • @flower_goddess1279
    @flower_goddess1279 Před rokem

    Sad it has to reach this level ! Shame on you attorneys !