Why the German Army is Rebuilding (again)
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 06. 2024
- PDS Debt is offering a free debt analysis. It only takes thirty seconds. Get yours at PDSDebt.com/task23
The German government recently released this historic paper: it's their first ever National Defense Strategy. Its 76 pages outline a radical new plan for how to confront the new security challenges they’re faced with. It’s kind of like a vision board where you share all your aspirations and goals but for a bureaucracy.
Written by: Chris Cappy and Justin Taylor
Video Edited by: Michael Michaelides
This was paired with a revolutionary increase of $107 billion dollars in military spending over the course of 3 years. But why all these drastic changes all the sudden ? German defense official Eva Hoegal, warned they “Have too little of everything” including spare parts, tents, modern radios, body armor, tanks and even submarines straight across the board.
In fact, multiple reports have claimed that if a war were to break out tomorrow, Germany would only have enough ammunition to last for about two days of fighting. In response to the German government plan to start reversing this trends by growing from roughly 180,000 to 203,000 personnel by 2031.
F-22 Super Raptor: • The Super F-22 is Abso...
Join the Task & Purpose discord Server: / discord
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @taskandpurpose
MERCH: task-purpose-shop.fourthwall....
Task & Purpose is a military news and culture oriented channel. We want to foster discussion about the defense industry.
Email capelluto@taskandpurpose.com for inquires.
PDS Debt is offering a free debt analysis. It only takes thirty seconds. Get yours at PDSDebt.com/task23
What happened to the hostage rescue video, are you on other platforms?
@V.B.Squire as Voltaire said, "to learn who rules over you, simply find out who you are not allowed to critique".
Some how I can not imagine panic in the Kremlin. 12,ooo troops increase over 7 years ... When Russia has 1,500 volunteers per week....
🇩🇪
typo in the title
The big problem was that politicians thought the Bundeswehr was no longer necessary. The position of defense minister was given to incompetent people.
Kohl reduced the defense budget by two thirds in the 1990s.
I had conversations with friends that believed a strong army is not necessary for small countries like The Netherlands. I believed it was. Netherlands is twice the size of Israel and has twice the population so they could in fact have a decent army.
If all of Europe would have a mandatory service it would help. I know it is not great but it is a necessary measure. I now live in Israel so I am not saying this because I want to sound cool. It costs a lot of people when the war is actually happening but you want your population to know how to fight.
(Yes, my kids will be soldiers as well. My friends and family are going in and out of rotation. I know what I am talking about when I say it is not great but necessary.)
@@gdrop6623 It is better to have a strong army and not need it than not to have one and need it
It’s not a German thing. All of NATO disarmed for the peace dividend.
And Germans follow the Americans. Note they refused to send tanks until the US did. But the US doesn’t acknowledge it’s leadership of the free world anymore.
@@gdrop6623 the difference is that Iseral is located in an warzone, Netherlands on the other hand is surrounded by stronger, wealthier allies
“Third time is the charm…” 🗿
Yes - but this time, Germany is on the right side, helping the rest of the world fight against fascism.
God damnit. -_-
History happens in prequels and sequels not trilogies.
I would love to see a strong, conservative Germany.
🍷🗿
A big problem is that the german defence industry is providing equipment for half of the continent. Around 53% of military hardware in all of europe is german, factories, workshops and shipyards are completely clogged up with orders. Its essentially stuck between a rock and a hard place. If it fulfills these orders first, Germany will be criticized for not rebuilding its army quick enough, if it chooses to pause these orders and rebuild its own stocks first, it’ll be criticized for not supporting their allies in times of need. Looking at you, Poland.
For example because Germany couldnt deliver more new tanks, the polish have chosen to buy more american Abrahms and Korean K2 tanks. Their first choice would have been the Leopard. But it could not be delivered in an acceptable time frame.
So in my opinion its equally important to strenghen the Bundeswehr but also increase germanys military production capabilities for tanks, IFVs, APCs, spare parts and ammunition. Many allies are relying on supplies produced in germany.
First come first serve. Germany's need for a military is to support allies in need to begin with, surely just fulfilling their orders would be the best start.
@@hanswurst6712 Or some new defense industries are needed in NATO.
@@dfcx1 Thats the public consensus over here. Most want to first work through present orders because, well, contractual obligations. But instead of waiting until these are through, we want to increase national military production capabilities so that its possible to supply both allies and ourself at the same time.
Germanys recent (last 2 months) shopping list expansion (in addition to ongoing precurement):
- 105 Leopard 2A8
- 20 Eurofighter
- 123 Boxer IFV
- 1,511 logistics vehicles (trucks)
- 19 Skyranger (shorad)
- increased it's order of F126 frigates from 4 to 6
- (plans to) increase it's order of F35 fighters from 35 to 43
- increased it's order of patriot systems from 4 to 8
- artillery shells for 8,5 billion €
They are also looking into buying 148 more boxer IFV's and up to 168 Boxer artillery systems
that's all ... I think-
That's great.
What did they order for commo?
Poland: aw shit here we go again
@@bedtimegaming0313No. We are arming ourselves to stand shoulder to shoulder with our Polish friends in the event of an alliance ;-)
In addition, the Poles are arming more heavily:
500 HIMARS missile launchers
1000 K2 main battle tanks
672 K9 self-propelled howitzers
288 K239 Chunmoo rocket launchers
48 FA-50 fighter jets
Germany, Italy and Japan are increasing military capabilities....
"Oh no"
But they're on our side this time.
"Oh thank god"
Italy was always a wild card
For now
Lol
My thoughts exactly
Italy is currently ruled by the far-right party “brothers of italy”with clear connections to Italys fascim, and the even-further-right “Alternative for Germany” just got second most votes in the EU elections in Germany, despite a core personnel and many supporters with straight up nazi ideology. Politics are wild in Europe at the moment.
Served with German Soldiers in Kosovo. Good Soldiers, hard working. I remember getting a care package from some Soldier caring group back home that sent us some Black Rifle coffee and other goodies. They were bewildered, the company commander even saying "we don't have anything like that back home". The biggest problem they had (back in 2012 at least) was that so many German civilians were afraid of them and were so afraid of becoming the "fourth reich" that they were looked down on.
The commander of NATO forces there, the "COMKFOR" was a German 2-star General, an old tanker. Good dude, from northern Germany somewhere.
I got to drive a Fuchs ("Fox" 6-wheel APC) out of that deployment. Thing drove like a Mercedes, lol.
We drank and had a lot of good times. I miss those guys and hope they are all doing well. (and yes I am aware that General Order 1B was in effect, but I was on a remote base 1.5 hours from the nearest American so what happened on that camp, stayed on that camp 😉)
There is a German 1SG that still has my American DVD of "Full Metal Jacket" that I would like back, btw! 😂
I read the comments always for. Stuff like this
Funny because I thought they were useless and dog shit in Afghanistan.
Storys from Prizren ;)
It's wild how much the Germans have been taught to hate themselves.
@@Sebidkk I had to see a doctor on the German base in Prizren. Beautiful place. The nurse was so pretty, I blushed when they said I had to take off my pants (to examine my knee). XD
As always, awesome episode! You've come so far since I first started watching you! Those phonics deep dives obviously paid off! ;P Anyway, keep it up. You're my go to guy for this side of things.
👋👍
Great job making this video! I really love all the proverbs fitting the context.
As a German I find it funny to read articles every 5 years about how our army is “rebuilding.” You can go back to 2010 and read articles about how we’re now “rebuilding”. I’m not convinced, mainly because being in the military in Germany still just isn’t competitive enough in terms of social status, or in terms or remuneration. With a masters degree your starting salary as an officer in training will be around 30-36K, and you will have to sign a 12 YEAR CONTRACT. Any takers? If Germany modeled itself more after the US in terms of compensation, perks, social status, shorter contracts I think it would have more luck.
I am pretty sure at least the social status aspect has drastically changed for the better.
@@highdefinist9697 it’s gotten better in the sense that most people seem to realize that the military is necessary on some level since Russia invaded Ukraine but I wouldn’t say drastically. This is of course very subjective person to person but I wouldn’t say being in the German military is really regarded as that glamorous by most of the young people I know. It’s not like we have the military at our football games or in our popular culture. It’s more something regarded as a necessary function but still comfortably tucked away from the popular imagination.
@@SGee882 Nobody doubts sewage workers and garbage cleaners are neccessary, too. Doesnt mean it got them any level of prestige.
also german here. compared to 2010 the situation has fundamentally changed - back then everybody spoke about a big army not being needed anymore because we were surrounded by friends. now i hope politicians have recognized that this is not the case and furthermore that situations can change very rapidly so that keeping your army in good shape and capabilities ist always a sensible approach to safety.
Yup, German military is completely inept at many things. I am a physicist and I gave them a try twice. Got denied twice for really dumb reasons that were on their side not mine. They also don't wanna pay me like the rest. Pardon me? They can be lucky if anyone wants to join those morons. Under the last ministers corruption has spread like wildfire. More incompetent people were hired because of nepotism. Millions and millions of euros disappeared into nothingness. They would need to exchange most people but because of laws they cannot. The free market is laughing about the people at the military and how dumb they are.
Luckily at the end of WW2, us Germans have managed to hide one single villager - took a while but now we are just rebuilding everything.
😂😂😂 snap
AOE reference ?
What Weirdo?
Was hast nen Sockenschuss?
:chuckles: Stealthy and ingenious :)
Oh yea? WOLOLO
ngl having the Warsaw Pact on our side now is pretty awesome. I haven't watched your Poland videos yet but this one has been fabulous!
Wow, that’s a well researched piece of journalism you put up here. Well done!
you are too generous 😉
As a German Veteran (Gebirgsjägerbrigade 23) with 2 Tours in Afghanistan and 1 in Kosovo i'm happy to see you do a Video on this Topic. There is a ton of Misinformation out there about the German Military so it's good to see a Video putting Things clear, at least most Stuff!
Prost & Cheers from Berchtesgaden in the Bavarian Alps
Ich will nach Berchtesgaden 😅
Dank euch konnte unser Burger King, am Bahnhof, endlich renoviert werden. Haha. Bin nur neidisch auf eure 10% Rabatt Marschverpflegung dort.
@@hfdcjiirjmcfi Tbh, immer wieder schön zu hören.
@@hfdcjiirjmcfida gibt’s außer Schönramer eh nix da gehst zum Sterben hin sonst nix
Das poopenfarten?
The sentence "surrounded by allies" was often used in Germany as "von Freunden umzingelt", what even is more drastic, because "umzingeln" tends to be used even more in military vocabulary, and isn't that neutral as "surrounded". It's like "Encircled by friends"
That's really more of an Austrian motto. I believe that Germany has been more responsible than that for quite a while.
@@highdefinist9697 thats right. germans dont think any agressive push from its borders would be possible. simplay because we are friends with everyone. We dont see it sceptical as the poster above is suggesting.
surrounded heißt übrigens "umgeben/umringt" und so ging auch der Spruch, umGEBEN von FREUNDEN...nicht UMZINGELT lol---
'von Freunden umgeben' would be a perfectly neutral way to say this in German.
Bundeswehr: we plan plan to increase our combat strength to 200k.
World: 🤯
Meanwhile the Kaiser: 1 million soldiers combat ready, 3,5 million in reserve.
Mustache man: 1,8 million combat ready, 7 million in reserve (waffen SS not included).
The Wehrmacht had a peak strength of around 12 million soldiers at its height, if I remember correctly.
@@Melior_Traiano13
The old euro mass conscript armies are huge. Few nations use them today.
1980s : 550000+500000 reserve.
2500 Leopard 1 + 2500 Leopard 2.
1000 fighter aircraft.
2024 :
185000+30000 reserve. ( 200000+50000 reserve are planned) ,300 Leopard 2 A7 ( +400 older Leopard 2 A4 and 100 Leopard 1 A5 in storage), (100 brand new ordered by Rheinmetall) .200 fighter aircraft.
From where did u get the Leo1 storage numbers?
Appreciate your good work! 👍🏼
In the middle of the 80s, when I did my military service, the statement was:
The (only) task of the Bundeswehr is to delay the Warsaw Pact for three days,
so that the USA, GB and France can set up a proper defense on the Rhine.
So much for the quality of the Bundeswehr in the 80s ....
Volker Pispers: Die Bundeswehr ist dazu da den Feind so lange aufzuhalten bis Militär kommt. Man muss ja sagen in den 80ern war dier Bundeswehr ja noch TOP equiped. Ich hab 2002 meinen Dienst verrichtet. Da war nix mehr da .......... ich war 2 Jahre lang Grenni, in den zwei Jahren hab ich NICHTS gelernt. Heute schau ich mir ein 10 MIn Ukraine Kampfvideo an und weiß mehr über Krieg als ich in meiner Bundeswehrzeit je gelernt habe. Heutzutage könnte selbst die DDR die Bundeswehr von heute in Tagen überrennen.
its interesting the leadership across NATO still talks about the same aspect, they plan to do a retrograde movement back at the start of any conflict
Father served in the Fulda Gap area in the early 70s (US Army artillery commander). His instructions were basically "survive long enough to lob your nukes" (back when 8" guns were NBC-capable), but, they were otherwise expected to amount to little more than speed bumps.
Credit where its due, a lot of the OR research and analysis I've read of the CW Bundeswehr give it a lot of praise for its abilities and professionalism. I'd strongly advise the book Battlegroup by Jim Storr on the subject.
A few years ago, a former general of the Bundeswehr stated the hard facts. The army of the GDR was organized, trained, and equipped as an offensive army. The Bundeswehr knew that the GDR army alone could completely overrun them within a few days.
“The boys are back in town”
Is that a reference to the Polish reenactment video? Lmao that vid is hilarious
It's great to see that Germany is moving beyond its pacifism, and that the rest of the free world welcomes a more responsible Germany.
You mean- Nazis 😂
Nah, they completed the focus “fan Prussian Militarism”
You mean "in" town.
Great research and good summary!!👍
21:31 “Everything has an end, only the sausage has two” 😂😂
Thanks for putting that Song back in my Head "Alles hat ein Ende nur die Wurst hat ZWEI!" haha
But seriousky, as a German Veteran (Gebirgsjägerbrigade 23) with 2 Tours in Afghanistan and 1 in Kosovo i'm happy to see him do a Video on this Topic. There is a ton of Misinformation out there about the German Military so it's good to see a Video putting Things clear, at least most Stuff!
Prost & Cheers from Berchtesgaden in the Bavarian Alps
@@chartreux1532Kosovo?!
Yes my darling, it’s over!
@@user-om9dz9nn4k via KFOR
@@chartreux1532 danke für deinen Dienst!
your first try on "zeitenwende" was half decent, but it went straight south from there :)
The more I hear him say it the more convinced that I am dyslexic (and blind) and the word may actually be spelled Seißenwendah
The "Bundeswehr" which become more "-wahr" over time was also notable ^^
@@highdefinist9697 Boondasswear
Sigh-Dan-Wayne-Day
@@felixhammerl2700 too difficult, take it back to the drawing board.
Wow you did your homework😮💪🏻 Very very good work guys, thank you!
Thank you.
Good report!
I love how my guy pronounced “Bundeswehr” different each time he said it. So good!
Einfach schrecklich!
Eh, he's from New Jersey forgettaboutit!
@@chrisstrawn4108hey! I‘m wehring here!
same with the word "zeitenwende"
Incredibly impressive how quickly y’all got this video out after the other one was restricted by CZcams. The spare parts army appreciates you
So why is CZcams soft on the Russians?
Wait what did i miss? What was in that vid?
@@thomaskalbfus2005They are not "soft on the Russians" they are very jumpy when it comes to certain words and topics
"Who rests, rusts" (wer rastet der rostet) is just the inverse of "a rolling stone gathers no moss".
There is this ongoing talk about the percentage of GDP Germany spends on defence but here is the thing:
Germany still spent 66.8 billion in 2023 compared to, say, France's 61.3 billion. While I for one, and I am German, am glad that defence spending will be increased it is not just a matter of how much is spent but also HOW it spent. Germany has no nuclear arsenal, no aircraft carrier or anything bigger than a frigate and a relatively small number of personnel. Germany has very few bases outside of Germany. These are things that contribute massively to the US defence budget. The Bundeswehr SHOULD be in far, far better shape but money has been wasted hand over fist for decades.
As a typically non-proud German, I'd like to thank you for calling it "historical" pacifism. Pacifism, curiosity, and the idea of a brotherhood of Europe is what I grew up with, but obviously there is a much darker side to be found to German history and you do not have to look far. So calling German pacifism "historic" feels exactly right and it feels like a compliment at the same time.
Also, I would like to commend you on your pronunciation of the word "Zeitenwende"! Especially the "Z" isn't easy and I think you have earned it to say it as often as you wish ;)
Are you from the German language police? Gosh, you guys should be more relaxed if it’s about the pronunciation.
@@iche9373 he complimented him? calm down
Y’all should really work on your demographics!! Your being replaced and out bred by migrants, worried for y’all!
@@iche9373 kopp zu
@@gunslinger0963 no u
"Remember who you are"
-Mufasa, The Lion King
This is way funnier than the likes demonstrate 😂
-Martin Luther King
@@AC-hj9tv *Michael Luther King
@@quadrasaurus-rex8809 Michel Luthier King
@@AC-hj9tv guitar you talking about?
The West Germans didn't have to "look" across the Berlin Wall to see hardships in East Germany. My Aunt was born and raised in Berlin. Her cousins lived in East Germany and my aunt Hilda found herself near Munich at the end of WW2 (she spent time in the Dachau concentration camp and later escaped and hid out on a farm until the end of the war). Later she married my uncle Calvin who was stationed in West Germany in the US Army during the Cold War. Every so often my aunt would fly to West Germany and take the train to East Germany. Often, she was required to bribe the border guards to be let into East Germany. Since exchanging money was technically illegal, she would often use items not commonly found in East Germany to bribe the guards. The most common items she used were American cigarettes and bananas were another popular item she would bring over along with toilet paper.
"Toilet paper." The pop-conservative writer P.J. O'Rouke wrote that it took Communism to make Germany broke. My observation is the closer in proximity one gets to being forced back into some kind of Warsaw Pact the more strongly the opposition to Russia. Germany's been able to play the middle for 30 years now but that time is at an end. And not just with Nord Stream. Germany is confronting China trying to run it out of car manufacturing. All of this because of the invasion of Ukraine, which will be the significant strategic event of our Gen X children's lifetimes.
In 1981 I watch a made for TV movie with my mother, about Masada, whereas my mother said, "look how brave those people are, they can get up at a moments notice, then out the door, if it was us, the first thing we would have to grab is the... toilet-paper" Cheers!
I was stationed in West Germany just before the West/East Germany reunification in 1990. Traveled into E. Germany, Czechoslovakia, and Poland and the toilet paper in those Warsaw Pact nations was terrible! The old joke was to call John Wayne Toilet Paper - "It's rough and it's tough and it doesn't take any crap off of anybody."
Likewise, the towels of my Prague hotel room in 1990 were pure polyester and didn't really absorb water. The wise Western traveler learned to bring their own soap, shampoo, towels, toilet paper, toothpaste, and so on. The Communist garbage was worse than stuff from a Dollar Tree store in 2024. Much worse.
@@amerigo88 I understand, and say, thank you for your... service!
@@amerigo88LOL!
As a German, I'm extremely happy about this development. Finally Germany realizes that our naive pacifist view was foolish. I never understood this mentality tbh. *Especially* because of German history we have a moral and practical responsibility to stand up against evil and tyranny and defeat it. This can only be achieved through strength, not weakness and nice talks. Germany should absolutely be the most powerful military force in Europe.
Sehe ich eins zu eins genauso.
Diese pazifistische Haltung von Deutschland seit ein paar Jahrzehnten und die dazugehörige Vernachlässigung der Bundeswehr regen mich so extrem auf. Bin ehrlich froh dass so ganz langsam und allmählich selbst der letzte Politiker begreift, dass eine schwache BW nix bringt.
Und am meisten schmerzt es mich, zu sehen, wie viel Potenzial bei der BW vergeudet wurde und immer noch wird.
Die Technik (d.h. viele Fahrzeuge, Waffensysteme und Ausrüstungsgegenstände) ist oftmals echt 1A und im internationalen Vergleich auch relativ weit vorne dabei, also sehr fortschrittlich.
Nur funktioniert sie leider selten bis gar nicht, weil Ersatzteile fehlen oder bei der Produktion gespart wurde.
Dasselbe gilt auch für so manche organisatorischen Sachen oder was die Ausbildung dort betrifft
As an American I agree with what you say -& want our countries to always be allied in mutual defense.
Germans are a gelded nation who have been taught to despise themselves and have been a vassal state to the US since the end of the 2nd World War. Even if you rearm a slave army will never be victorious and your immigrant replacements won’t die for you because you don’t respect yourselves.
Hitler had a lot to do with that. Now with the AFD rising. I still do not trust Germany.
Great video thank you.
I can already hear a song about fluttering bees and beautiful white flowers.
*Ein Lied!*
Auf der Heide blüht ein weißes Blümelein...
...und das heisst:
ERIKA!
@@AceofAllAcesJames5558 BUM BUM, BUM BUM
Ich habe kein problem mit das, kameraden. 👍
Again, good Journalism here. You took a technically complex document full of jargon and turned it into something easily understood by most people regardless of their aptitudes. Well done, keep up the good work. Thumbs Up 👍from me.
You do a great job Chris! Very talented and proficient.
Excellent work, great research and presentation of facts.
Perun’s video on German defense economics would be a great follow on to anyone interested in this video.
I feel like it 'highly inspired' this video
It's interesting how outdated Peruns video has become in some aspects, because so much has changed just last year.
Perun's videos are a great follow up to any video you watch^^
And Perun effortlessly can pronounce "Bundesamt ffür Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung" :D
Regarding the issue of public support - I have a lot of left leaning German friends in their thirties and below who have changed their mind on Germany's pacifist stance, in contrast to those older.
I think what's happening is that the older generations believe that war in Europe is impossible, as it's a solved problem where the younger people never saw that "fix" when it happened and feel the elders are being naive.
War is inevitable
Another own goal by Putin.
Germany on Pacifist track.
Now nudged into fighting path.
He has awakened Europe so no more suprise attacks
But there is also the rise of the people influenced by Russian propaganda, who see anything involving the military as declaration of war to Russia.
@@Alexvondark I am a young German male and I agree.
Von Der Leyen had a history of failure in every post she occupied in the German Government but she was Merkel's pet protege. She became the German Defense Minister in 2013 to 2019 and spent millions on over priced equipment that never materialised and the various consultancy firms got paid further millions for their procurement 'contracts'. In other words she completely wrecked what was left of the German Military power to the point where the army don't even have working rifles, before resigning and becoming head of the EU. Now she wants a European army which she will also disarm. Her medical doctorate, received in 1991 was found to be plagiarised to the tune of about half the actual content in 2015. At best, she is inept and utterly incapable of running anything. At worst its hard to tell if she is a marxist working for the WEF or the CCP. Most of this comment is taken from The SPECTATOR 27TH March 2021 'Failing Upwards: The Story Of Ursula Von Der Leyen'. If I was German, I would be paying attention to the views of those raised in East Germany who actually know what they are talking about. As do the people in Poland and we can all see how they are acting..........do likewise! That goes for the rest of Europe as well.
Great vid!
love this guy. high quality content
very good summarize of the Bundeswehr Situation. Hit the spot. greetings from an Panzergrenadier on Marder in the 2000ies
"Er ist kein Mensch, er ist kein Tier, er ist ein......"😅
Thank You for your service.
"Dran drauf drüber"
@@Bigsky1991 er ist ein Panzergrenadier - und es gab auch - Trete nicht auf jeden Stein - denn es könnt ein Grennie sein
@@georgewilkie3580 very appreciated - i was in the Unit that serves now also in Lithuania -so called Nato Quick Response Force - i had assignment in Yugoslavia short after the war
I've enjoyed many of your videos, but this one takes the cake. You clearly explained why the Bundeswehr has to play catchup now after several decades of neglect by the politicians. As a German who did his 15 months of military service in 1983/84 as a Panzergrenadier (mechanized infantry), I have been frustrated for years by this. Then "West Germany" with 60 million inhabitants was clearly able to afford a fully equipped 500K military without making anyone suffer. The "paradox" of why a large majority of Germans support increasing the size of the Bundeswehr while rejecting Germany assuming a leadership role in military affairs is easily explained: We want Germany to again be able to defend itself, while clearly anchored in NATO as a major contributor to the alliance. Germany has no overseas territories (unlike France and the UK) or old obligations or interests in former colonies, so the defense of Germany and its neighbors and allies is the main task. This is best achieved in agreement with the alliance partners, first and foremost the United States. The peace, freedom, and prosperity postwar Germany enjoyed until now is the best proof that this policy is working. A final comment on why Germany did not send troops to the first Gulf War in 1991: It literally would have been illegal, since the constitution (Grundgesetz) clearly forbade any military involvement outside the defense of Germany or a NATO ally. That was changed in later years to allow missions like Kosovo and Afghanistan. The Grundgesetz was proofread and signed off on by the United States before the founding of the Federal Republic of Germany in 1949. I remember there were a lot of people upset back then because the German government and the Bundeswehr massively helped the US Military anyway with logistical support in Germany during the first Gulf War, and that there were German officers working in NATO AWACS planes over the Gulf.
*you forget a critical point why germany was able to finance and support such a massive army until 1991.
Taxes.
Under Kohl in the early 90´s, ALOT of taxes were cut back or even voided.
Top Tax rates for Income and Turnover were cut from 53% to 42% while the tax bracket threshholds were lowered, resulting in higher taxes for lower incomes.
Wealth Tax and a few other taxes were completely abolished.
We are talking about MASSIVE tax cuts for the rich.
The 1989 federal tax revenue was inflation adjusted up to 15% higher than the 2024 federal tax revenue when seen in Proportion to the GDP, meaning the german State could fund and finance a very large military with ease and have still billions to spare for infrastructure and required investments, unlike today, where the federal budget gets strangeld by the Schuldenbremse (debt brake) and the tax cuts of the 90´s under the CDU/FDP.
@@zhufortheimpaler4041 That, plus conscription. Nowadays, Germany has some of the lowest tax rates for top earners and super rich in all of Europe, which makes financing incredibly difficult, especially in combination with the debt brake - and it's hard to get new recruits for an army with a poor public image due to being underfunded and underequipped.
@@Rabascan conscription is quite worthless for a modern day miilitary, unless you want to fight a war like russia does. (meaning sacrificing 500k men for next to nothing)
@@zhufortheimpaler4041 I disagree. First, you get a larger part of the population exposed to the military. Many career soldiers in Germany of the last decades joined because they were conscripted and took a liking to the job. Second, you can hand over less important tasks to conscripts - non-frontline-duties - to open up the professional soldiers for more important tasks. Third, you build up a reserve of people with basic military skills, which can be drafted and trained to make up for the inevitable losses during actual war.
Great info
Fantastic info, thanks
Very nice coverage on this piece!
Love your content, btw you slaugthered the word "Zeitenwende" :D greetings from germany
In the Bundeswehr there was already a shortage of ammunition and spare parts back in the late 80s and 90s. During my one year of military service in the 90s, I fired less than 100 rounds during the 3 months of basic training and none afterwards. And because there wasn't enough money for training-hand grenades we pretended to pull the ring from dummy grenades before throwing them. During a 5 day exercise everybody got 20 blanks, the MG gunner got 200, which he spent with the first few bursts. It was so bad that during my first time of guard duty I didn't get any ammunition at all.
One of the major problems of the Bundeswehr is that because of WW2 soldiers are not well respected in modern Germany. Therefore it is hard to get the necessary funds. And during the time of von der Leyen's time as minister of defense, lots of the funds went into the pockets of external advisors. Another mistake was reducing the duration of the compulsory military service first from 18 to 12 and later to 6 months, and then completely suspending it.
Thank You for your very informative, and valuable input. And, Thank You for Your service
My dad had his mandatory service right when the wall came down.
2 G3 magazines and one 50 round MG3 belt over the entire year
Man that's rough. I fired 90 rounds in 10 minutes a couple weeks ago for fun during our annual repetition course in the Swiss army. I think the Soldats (privates) had to waste 10,000 rounds last week because we had requisitioned too much for their training. We thought we'd be training around 50 privates, but only 30 could show up for the exercise.
@@fluffypancakes7626 Congress on your victory today man well done
@@fluffypancakes7626 This hardly compares. ;-) You probably know well that up to 2007 the Swiss army gave their reservists a sealed box of live ammo home. Imagine a country in which every man not only has the right to bear arms but has to be armed - what this implies in terms of civic virtue, cohesion and decency - in Germany there would be full auto fire all day.
The British Army was supposed to be out of Germany by 2020. I'm a reservist; I was there in 2019 and recalled seeing tanks, armoured vehicles, and regulars withdrawn back to the UK. I returned last year before deploying overseas. I saw more challenger tanks and personnel taking up residence. Not just us, but plenty of American, Estonian, and Slovak troops around, too. I asked some of the locals, and they said their military is far too small, and with the threat of a resurgent Russia, they appreciated allied countries maintaining a presence. A little ironic when the British Armed Forces are at their smallest levels since the end of the Napoleonic wars. Our regular colleagues are under more pressure and are having to rely on us more often.
all european countries have to step up now.
I expected a lot more from the UK since its the only european country that guaranteed ukrainian sovereignity. 100 years earlier the UK declared war on Germany for a similar guaranty for Belgium. :p
to be fair, britain has it good. its defacto the hardest place in europe to invade, and even if anyone got close, they have an entire continent of allies to deal with first. To be honest, theyre probably fine with a 200k strong force, if it were defensive only. Unfortunately, like you said, britain is taking on an increasingly more responsible role in NATO. Their role wasnt to invest in the army, but to invest in the aerospace realms, and technology sectors. Now that russia has shown its true face, britain is in the unique position of being able to send its small army to the main land while still being relatively super safe. To be honest, if britain steps up now, that 200k force can sit its butt in europe and they can raise a further 300k at home. Here in the USA we have a million man military, but not a lot of people know, we have over half stationed in the US at all times. Theres hundreds of thousands of us at the ready when europe needs it, but europeans should certainly use this time to take advantage of that fact and start raising bigger armies simply to deter russia. It will be too late if they start doing that when the USA is already on the front. It needs to happen before that.
@@ludwigneigl891 > I expected a lot more from the UK since its the only european country that guaranteed ukrainian sovereignity.
The Russians also guaranteed Ukrainian sovereignty. Well, were supposed to according to the treaty.
The British still have an army? Im sorry but you all will be SEVERELY embarrassed if any real war goes off in Europe. What are the statistics right now? GB cant even actively use the navy theyre so sjort manned.
Trump tried to tell y’all.
You've notched up to be my number one on CZcams. ❤
Great video
Once a Phonics addict, always a Phonics addict. Stay strong Cappy
Excellent video 👍
Good content 👍
Your appreciation for the countries and cultures you speak about is something I really like. Keep the good work up!
Thanks for sharing Cappy
Seeing my neighborhood in one of your videos is my personal Zeitenwende :D
Good video!
In 2011, conscription was suspended. Now there are discussions about reintroducing it.
There's no discussion. It was reinstated on Wednesday with some conditions.
@@gregoryaparker lmao, isn't it ironic that an "pacifist" country needs conscription, when an more war incline nation like the USA doesn't? maybe Germany should first have people who want to fight for their own country instead of forcing them to join the military like slave masters. decades of being an socialist state, and barely anyone likes the country enough to avoid reinstating conscription
@@gregoryaparker Was laberst du, es wurde grade mal ein Plan zur wieder Einführung vorgestellt
@@stefthorman8548 Are you a troll or just dumb af?
The English pm is talking about it
Hey brother, I love the way you violently throw those quotes from things semi-related to the subject matter. Now just end the show with a random thought/quote you enjoy. One of my favorite ones.
“I am a warrior, so that my son may be a merchant, so that his son may be a poet.”
― John Quincy Adams
and the poet ensures his son needs to be a warrior
Pretty sure that was just John Adams
@@ashardalondragnipurakeyeah because of that “soft men make hard times” Nonsens?
If that’s true… why is living in Germany still better than in most other countries and why isn’t Kongo the best country in the world by now?
Always these easy-to-debunk-by-basic-logic one phrasers…
@@Grimshak81 why did rome collapse
you wouldnt accept why kongo is a sht place
always this eagerness to cling to your blindfold
@@ashardalondragnipurake Not because it lacked a strong military. Mainly because of the 3 kingdoms, it collapsed under its own weight. Please use question marks if you are asking questions.
Great video, as always. Thanks. You mentioned that Luftwaffe will acquire Eurofighters to complement the F35 in EW warfare (to replace Tornados) Worth to mention is that these Eurofighters are to be equipped with the Swedish Gripen E's EW-suit Arexis. So Gripen seem to have something that F35 and Eurofighter lack. :-)
Hey Chris, jsut a quick information, that you can take on long term investmensts with plans for multiple years, its also is encouraged since it makes you edilible for more funds in the next year
Thanks another interesting show, and a good lead in to another video.
Excellent video like always :)
Excellent! As a German, I haven’t heard a better compilation of facts and intelligent analysis of the situation on this topic yet. Well done, „average infantryman“!
nice video!
Great analysis as usual.
Another very good and informative video from Chris Cappy. Well done. I just missed seeing Cappy in the commander hatch/ cockpits of the vehicles or aircraft.
"I just missed seeing Cappy in the commander hatch/ cockpits of the vehicles or aircraft", 😅 I think that will have to make a comeback VERY soon! Stat tuned!
6:14 yeah, like the claim of 1,000 combat aircraft or the navy having 'destroyers' in 1989. 😊
The two-syllable joke is the best. Love you Chris Cappy ! 🙏❤️
The puma problems were kinda overblown. Some of the problems were crewmembers forgetting to turn on the heating
As a Polish citizen i am happy for German people to get their Army together it was long time that we had need for that , it was 3 generations of peace and prosperity, but eventually people forget and the sabers are rattling again. "If you want peace prepare for war" Hopefully this will deter anybody because when the s*** hits the fen say goodbye what we have build and achieved over this peaceful times, back to the stone age we go.
5 billion dead in 72 min
and the rest will envy the dead
Peace to all and God bless everyone.
A polish guy cheering for Germany's military built up a sight i never thought i would see 😂😂😂
@@josephgeorge641 We are brothers nowadays.
Thank God for Poland!! Without Poland, Putin could send the Moscow Fire Brigade to Conquer Berlin, that´s the Situation of German´s Forces. And as "usual" Poland is saving Europe: After Vienna against the Ottomans, 1919-1920 against the Red Army of the Soviet Union, in 1939-1945 against the Nazis on Allied Sides.Nowadays because of Poland , Germany is save.
So, as a German I can only say: LONG LIVE HOLY POLAND!!!!!!
PS: Inside Germany we have now the Enemy Inside with the Refugees, some Mistake Poland never did!!!! LONG LIVE HOLY POLAND!!!!
Love your videos big dawg
Thanks for the video. Very comprehensive analysis of the German Defense situation. Greetings from Mexico City.
The first post war German forces were the Bundesgrenzschutz (1951) in the western zone and in the eastern zone Kasernierte Volkspolizei (1952) both were ostensibly police forces but were armed, equipped, and trained as combat troops.
Pls do a video about the kf51 and 41 ty, as an ex soldier im rly excited for my country to get such a modern technology, and i think a new generation tank since the 90s rly worth a video from you guys !
The benefit of being an American & your country being in some kind of war constantly since WW2, is I never worry about our government not spending enough on the military or equipment/kit shortages
I feel like that's one of the greatest shortcomings of American culture - the over-reliance on military strength, while neglecting the importance of having an effective government.
The best military in the world is useless if the political system governing it is so fragile, that it can be rendered ineffective, as a consequence of state-sponsored troll-armies riling up both parties to gridlock each other.
The social and jurisprudential fabric of ww2 America might as well been an entirely different nation, we’ll see how the warrior heritage class performs after decades of browbeating
We're the eye of war, we have patrols, send troops to our interest, but to catch our eye is death.
Notice we don't have to start wars to be involved in them, Wars just happen and the United States gets involved, other countries think they can conquer the World and then the United States has to go in there and show them they are wrong!
Never served have you
6:24 love the idea that neither side really new how strong they or their enemy really was
I appreciate your willingness to talk so openly about dependency on phonics. I also was hooked on phonics.
very well researched
spc thx 4 that, I was in this army 30 years ago, and it was a nightmare back then, short of everything, bureaucracy to death and into oblivion - unbelievable.
30 years ago you barely were in any serious mission under live threatening conditions.
There’s nothing worse than old guys from the exercise army back then telling young veterans who were in really dangerous missions “how much harder it was back then”.
Impressive video.
Interesting info.
I enjoy all of Task & Purpose videos
Hey man, thank you. Your videos are always great, well researched and funny. And as a German I absolutely appreciate the efford you put into pronouncing those words 🙂
03:18 backroundmusic cinda off, does not fit 04:20 like 20 DB louder all of a sudden, what happend here?, 06:48 louder again but this time its not so bad. Thats all I got, such a good and well rounded eddeting. always a pleasure to watch.
sehr gutes Video! / Very good Video
Dieser Kommentarbereich ist nun eingentum der Bundesrepublik Deutschland 🇩🇪
Bayern ist aber besser.
@@highdefinist9697I love Germany bro
@@danLTa1 i am sorry for you
@@highdefinist9697 Träum weiter. Bayern haben wir seit 1871 im Sack.
@@highdefinist9697 Bavaria is going to be annexed by Austria.
No chance keeping the hostage video online?
I might be able to post it in a week , im working on it
@@Taskandpurpose hopefully it works at some point - thanks for your efforts, dude! :D
@@Taskandpurpose My guess is you’re getting mass reported by bots and activists. Which is disappointing as you really do a great job with honest reporting and being upfront with your bias.
@@Nathan-vt1jz reporting shouldnt be taken seriously, it should merely be a call to action for youtube to put a human infront of the video to ascertain whether it really deserves to be removed instead of being an automatic AI generated response like they have in place right now.
@@paddington1670 I agree. I see why they do it given the volume of videos uploaded on the platform, though it makes sense for verified accounts like Task and Purpose to be immediately reviewed before taking down any videos.
10:25 the part about the burden being shifted to Poland is a good point as we can now see Poland heavily investing in military
Будет смешно, если Польша захочет больше, чем просто Данциг. Но да ладно, раз немцы отказались от своего социалистического прошлого, то меня их настоящее мало беспокоит.
@@HoBoeBpeM9l sorry man I only speak English so idc
Well done on regarding the historical background. As for procurement, it's a bit more complicated:
- Nobody expected a war or a Zeitenwende, so for the first 9 months of the war, Germany's DefSec was some recently divorced cat lady who only took the job to be in the cabinet until the Sec. of the Interior would run for another position, allowing her to slide over and occupy her chair in the Cabinet. If you're watching this video, there's a substantial chance that you know a lot more about the military than Mrs. Lambrecht.
- Eventually Scholz had to send her on a mission to find a big shiny pearl in the Arabian desert and made the last common-sense, competent man left in the SPD defense secretary. (Oskar Pistorius) He went from "Who?" to most popular politician within 8 weeks.
Procurements so far:
- 6 F-126 frigates, the biggest warships built since the war
- 3 Type 212 CD submarines with another 4 going to Norway, our new best friend (they opened their natural gas floodgates when Putin tried to blackmail us, God bless 'em)
- 2 ARROW III ballistic missile defense batteries from Israel, each of which could cover the area from Finland to the Black Sea,
- 4 new Patriot batteries
- 19 Skyranger 30 mobile Boxer platforms that have the same radar/optoelectric drone detection and AHEAD gun system as Skynex
- 8 Iris-T SLM medium range air defense batteries and 16 Boxer-based Iris-T SLS mobile air-defense batteries,
- 123 IFV-Boxer with Lance turret, produced at Australia's licensed Boxer production center of Tank competence in Boxer excellence (I forget the real name)
- 130 IFV Boxers with the Puma's revolutionary turret (and without the revolutionary crap below the turret that doesn't work),
- 150 RCH-155 wheeled howitzers (guess if it's based on a Boxer chassis!) that have a fully automatic AGM (automated gun module) based on the Panzerhaubitze 2000 and only need to slow down to fire without ever fully stopping,
- 5-10 new K-130 corvettes
- 60 Chinook-H helicopters
- 62 H145M light attack helicopters (we wanted the Bell Vyper but that would have pissed off the French)
- just a couple days ago we re-introduced limited conscription based on the Swedish model to get back to over 200k and expand the active reserve every year.
If the traffic light coalition (red-green-yellow (liberalitarians)) should come apart and the CDU gets back into government, you can expect significantly accelerated rearmament and increased defense spending. If the coalition holds until the elections - those three parties have gone from well over 50% in the last elections to 35% or less, while the CDU gets 31% and could probably govern with the Greens as junior coalition partner - and they're among the most hawkish when it comes to supporting Ukraine.
The GWOT was one thing but the Ukraine war really gave a more accurate picture of modern combat which will change anyway given the capabilities of the participants. Drone warfare will be normalized and considerations for countering drones will be critical. Therefore moving supplies might be far more difficult, manning bunkers or fixed positions and the like will be far more difficult. It will take layers of defenses never seen before to counter the possibilities.
After watching an FPV drone play around with a lone soldier before the operator decided enough games and went in to kill him, I knew war was never going to be the same.
Yeah the great thing that comes with standardized ammunition for various equipment across NATO is that yes if one unit runs out of ammo another nearby unit can supply them even if they are completely different countries.
Will they also have spare soldiers to replace the dead ones.
@@tsailor100Only if they introduce conscription
@@tsailor100 yeah, you ^^
Thank you for summarizing this again. Even as a German, I didn't really have that on my radar.
Please do a review of the Canadian Military. I would greatly appreciate your analysis 🙏
Have you guys given up on uploading the last video? I was wanting to watch it later😢
Excellent video, greetings from Germany (:
Zeitenwende :D
How you pronounce it wil want to sa: "Bless you." but great video. Seems so far everything right, nothing i could controdict, exept that at 23:23 you point at the wrong corner. ( I would say, all in all, that is a good compliment from a german)
Thanks for giving an unbiased and factbased take on the matter. Too many times in recent years the only thing Europeans and especially Germans would hear from the US was slander for not maintaining a huge army and instead giving wealth to it‘s people in times of peace.
Thanks for adding the historical perspective and the reasons for the underfunding, especially for american viewers. As a German, I can state that your analysis is absolutely correct, there's only few information to add: Germany is facing several problems, e.g. demographic change, immigration, old infrastructure (roads, bridges, rail, phone/internet, ...), high costs for public administration. All this leads to a lack of funding in all ministries, since there has been made an addendum to the Grundgesetz (the equivalent to other countries constitution) in 2009 which prohibits a deficit in the federal budget (the so called "Schuldenbremse" ~ "debt brake"). Unthinkable for US citizens, I know. Hope you can understand why we're struggling
Thank you for you informative information.
My God, that Hooked on Phonics reference has got tumbling headfirst down memory lane.
Another problem is the Bundeswehr Beschaffungsamt, the procurement office. Its a bureaucracy nigthmare so waiting times on new material of all kinds is endless