What I like about this version/video is the explanation given at the beginning. Much better than seeing English translation written throughout the video. Good rollicking tune.
Vous avez raison! de tous ses enregistrements, cette version au Carnegie Hall est la meilleure jamais chanté de sa part...et Dieu sait que j'en ai écouté....la voix casse et l'émotion et à son summum. Elle chantait aussi une époque révolue, un Paris de petites gens....Les historiens auront beau nous raconter l'histoire....le ressenti, l'ambiance et l'émotion disparaîtront .....avec ceux qui partiront à leur tour. On ne peut transmettre que des faits ou des monuments....pas des émotions!
I'm sorry ,but that is not the case... It's not even the voice of Piaf, but the french singer Jil Aigrot's voice was used in that scene.. a great scene though!
It's info you can read in (www.imdb.com/title/tt0450188/faq#.2.1.4 ) for instance... found this info for you a moment ago. Besides, if you remember the scene well, you know she faltered ,stammered and collapsed on stage while singing this chanson. That's why they needed a "stand in "voice,in the Carnegie hall recording she sings it so perfectedly well and was in her very, very best voice and form. I have seen and heard her Live in Amsterdam in '63...a tremendeous experience but she was already very sick and weak (she died 8 months later) Her voice was darker,lower and yet it was still an amazing miracle to witness that little force of nature. I hope this was a bit helpful to you Brian, cheers!
@@peter47ish Envy, of someone who actually saw her! Even if past her prime. As you say, a little force of nature. Little singers have that something, don't they: Piaf, MiMi, Lulu, Cilla, Paige ... especially the first two.
Elle était, elle est, et restera la plus grande Dame de la musique de tous les temps!
The best version of l'accordeoniste, I love it!!
3:52 ARRÊTEZ! This is one of the most emotional song endings I’ve ever heard (the other one is Five Years by Bowie)
What I like about this version/video is the explanation given at the beginning. Much better than seeing English translation written throughout the video. Good rollicking tune.
I had been trying to find the recording of this performance, fantastic!
Vous avez raison! de tous ses enregistrements, cette version au Carnegie Hall est la meilleure jamais chanté de sa part...et Dieu sait que j'en ai écouté....la voix casse et l'émotion et à son summum. Elle chantait aussi une époque révolue, un Paris de petites gens....Les historiens auront beau nous raconter l'histoire....le ressenti, l'ambiance et l'émotion disparaîtront .....avec ceux qui partiront à leur tour. On ne peut transmettre que des faits ou des monuments....pas des émotions!
czcams.com/video/6thiGy2TD70/video.html
Che voce...merveilleuse
à jamais dans mon coeur la mome PIAF!!!!!!!!!!!!💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💗💗💗💗💓💓💓💔💔💔💔❤🔥❤🔥❤🔥❤🔥🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I love this song!
In memory of my French mother - 11/3/29 - 11/11/79.
Que Hermosa canción¡¡¡¡
Thank you FOR THIS❤️❤️❤️
Love
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I think this is the extract of audio used in the scene of La vie en rose.
I'm sorry ,but that is not the case...
It's not even the voice of Piaf, but the french singer Jil Aigrot's voice was used in that scene.. a great scene though!
Peter Schneider Really? How do you know that? thanks !
It's info you can read in (www.imdb.com/title/tt0450188/faq#.2.1.4 ) for instance... found this info for you a moment ago.
Besides, if you remember the scene well, you know she faltered ,stammered and collapsed on stage while singing this chanson.
That's why they needed a "stand in "voice,in the Carnegie hall recording she sings it so perfectedly well and was in her very, very best voice and form.
I have seen and heard her Live in Amsterdam in '63...a tremendeous experience but she was already very sick and weak (she died 8 months later)
Her voice was darker,lower and yet it was still an amazing miracle to witness that little force of nature.
I hope this was a bit helpful to you Brian, cheers!
@@peter47ish Envy, of someone who actually saw her! Even if past her prime. As you say, a little force of nature. Little singers have that something, don't they: Piaf, MiMi, Lulu, Cilla, Paige ... especially the first two.
Jil Airgot has about the closest sounding voice to Edith that you’ll ever find…
amazing What year was this?
+Peter Schneider: 1956
@@peter47ish this was the 1956 Carnegie hall. When she sang in 1957, she sung slower
that "r"
Mimi (Mireille Mathieu) has kept the r tradition going!