Hardshell VS Soft-Sided Carry-On
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 07. 2024
- I will compare a soft sided versus a hardshell carry-on suitcase with travel tips about their features for packing. I bought my first hardshell carry-on and did not like it so I knew what features I needed for the new one. A tip for you is to make a list of what you want and what you need in your carry-on suitcase. The number one tip is to get a carry-on that has an outer pocket feature.
Travel tip videos:
bit.ly/TravelCrossbodyBags
bit.ly/TravelHacksHotelRoom
Suitcase: bit.ly/HardShellCarryOn
Code Laurie10
Newest suitcase 2023: bit.ly/3IWA2ZE
My carry-on items:
Blue hardshell suitcase: bit.ly/3yuNqz4
Silver hardshell suitcase: bit.ly/3knoWkB
Soft-sided suitcase: bit.ly/3EBx4pI
Optional: bit.ly/3O4otkf
My shirt: bit.ly/3aApEcw
My bracelets: bit.ly/3uTPAIz
My ring: bit.ly/3iYB5ME
My rings: bit.ly/2ZA3qlq
My personal item tote bag ($20 off):
My backpack: bit.ly/3rnqUmR (size 15.6)
Compression cubes: bit.ly/2GC9xNi
National Park cubes: bit.ly/3EdPzBv
Pouches: bit.ly/3mSJmAJ
NEW CHANNEL MERCH: bit.ly/ShopLaurieShirts
Chapters:
00:00 Hardshell versus soft-sided suitcase
03:00 Compare space
05:20 Compare features
08:20 Other carry-on features
09:27 Most important tip
Thumbnail by: designlab4 on Fiverr
POP over and say hi:
Instagram: @TravelTipsByLaurie (My former channel name was LauriePOP Ideas That POP, but now I produce travel tip videos only)
Occasionally I use affiliate links, and all opinions that POP into my head are my honest ones.
Need Overhead Bin Space? Watch this: bit.ly/NoOverheadForBag
I have a hard-sided case I've never traveled with. I default to my soft-sided case because I know how to pack it. A tip for your small purse for essential items (Credit cards, ID, Passport, house/car key) is to use it for a week before travel so you know which zipper/pocket has what. I'm so used to my regular purse, that when traveling with all my important items reshuffled, I get flustered.
What a great tip!
That’s a good idea because I get flustered too in heat of moment.
I will soon be flying for the first time in nearly 10 years. I went way back on your videos one night and got caught up on dos and don'ts. You have given me the confidence to commit to carry on only with a back back. Thank You for passing on all the knowledge you have collected. I like that you overlap info repeating little tips you have found important across your entire catalog of videos. Happy travels.
Thank you so much for all of the views!
Thanks for the great video, as always. As a senior citizen, I don't do a carry-on simply because of having to lift it to the overhead bin. I do have a hard shell checked piece, which I prefer over soft-sided and use a backpack as my personal item. And those spinner wheels are the best invention ever!
I agree. Plus if the cases are left out on the tarmac in wewt weather chances are the things in the hards casr will stay dry. In the soft case clothes will get wet.
I use a hard shell case carry-on and rely on the exterior pockets of my backpack for all those papers, passport, etc you refer to. My husband has a soft sided carry-on and does the same with his backpack. By the way, I usually pack for both of us and find either one easy to pack using packing cubes. I have been watching you for a few years and have really appreciated all your tips . . . have even sent your link to my traveling friends.
Thanks for watching Deborah!! Have a great trip.
Thanks for the comparison, Laurie. I would have liked you to cover the topic of weight - hard vs soft.
As you mentioned, the ease of rolling a spinner down the airplane aisle is THE reason I got a spinner. But! I have a soft sided spinner with telescoping handle from Biaggi, which is the best of both worlds. It’s called the lift-off underseater and it expands to carryon size. Pushed and pulled it all over London, York and Edinburgh cobblestones this June- No issues with the wheels! Thanks for sharing your tips, I ❤️ your videos!
For older folks and folks with bad backs, three criteria: The weight of the suitcase itself (empty), exterior handles (one on each side is ideal) and very sturdy wheels.
Great point!
This is why I’m coming back to TravelPro after trying hardshell for a number of years. The Maxlite5 is nice with the spinner wheels. It has a side handle as well as a bottom handle like my old Swiss checked bag.
Hi Laurie! Always enjoy your videos. I am 80 yes old, and find my 4 wheel spinner,, under seat, hard sided works best for me....can use like a cane if necessary. 2 wks in Ha....had all I needed! G
I have a hard shell suitcase with 4 wheels for my main check in luggage. I love it. Best suitcase Iv ever owned. But for my mini suitcase intake on a plane sometimes it’s a 2 wheel soft shell (plus I have a backpack with multiple pockets).
Thanks Laurie for the suggestion of the packing cubes. I ordered one set for my husband and one for me. Now we are looking at hard shell luggage!
You really have to see if you like to travel like that. Maybe just get one hardshell so you can see if it fits y'all.
I use a expandable soft side with outside pocket, but with four wheels just for helping with that roll down the aisles. It is a game changer.
Loved this comparison video. My rationale for not purchasing a hardside carry on was the same as yours, no outer pocket. This comparison was so informative and thorough. Our softsided TravelPro carry on spinners still have many good miles in them. When looking to replace, I'll definitely use this video as a guide. Thanks, Laurie.
Yes I will use this soft sided again and would love to work with TravelPro because I love this bags so much.
Hi Laurie. Love your videos. I really would like the 360 spinner suitcase to make it easier going down the aisle of the airplane for sure! Also great to have a personal item that slips on the handle. I did buy the compression packing cubes and they seem to help. Thanks for all of your tips!
Thank you Laurie that was an excellent comparison … I just bought my first hard sided carry on luggage unfortunately it does not have an outer pocket.. that would be perfect, but I will try my new one soon on my next trip. Thanks for the tips!
My hardshell did not come with an outside pocket but I really love it. It just seems to keep me better organized. I keep my socks, underwear,pjs etc on the zip side. My tops in a compression cube,pants, sweaters on the other side. I keep any essentials that I would need to get into, in my personal item. But it looks like it would be very cool to have that outside pocket. Maybe when this one ever breaks. Thanks for your tips.
Yes if you have one you like, keep it!
I bought my hard shell set years ago!
( missing the newest idea of the outer flap!)
Our reasoning was we were so tired of our soft sided luggage being soaked in the flordia rain !
But I always wanted that outside pocket!
There for my personal bag had to carry what my hardshell carryon could not!
( belt, electronics, id etc)
Great reason! Just saw pics the other day of the Tampa airport.
I have an older travel pro platinum elite 21 inch expandable roller board that I absolutely love. In my opinion it fairs better when it needs to be checked over hard sided bags and being only two wheels actually gives you more interior space than it’s hard sided counter part. I also love the included suiter for those rare times I need to carry a dressier item.
Love the space in my TravelPro!
@@TravelTipsbyLaurie hello.......... going to start to travel again - and looking at Carry on.......... We're travelling with Air canada and can only do a 21.5 inch. grrrr - Looking at the Away (.1 cm too big - but i think it will be fine), Monos - which is .5 inches too big and not sure what other ones i should look at.................. would any of you have a wonderful recommendation???
@@mmorden9938 Hi, did you notice the suitcase I talked about in this video? All links are in the description box under each video. You get there by clicking show more or the upside down carrot. Here is the one in the video I hope you watched: bit.ly/3yuNqz4 (Only 7 left)
I do check a bag-but I pack smarter thanks to your tips Laurie!-but have a small “Daily Carryon” bag from Away that I use for my camera & emergency clothes. I wanted hard sided as I think it provides more protection for the camera but it also has an exterior pocket w/2 slots where I can keep my travel documents &/or my iPad until I’m at my seat. And it’s easier for a senior woman to get into the overhead bin.
And OF COURSE I’ve had to sit on a suitcase to close it! I call it “the Ethel Mertz Maneuver” from an old “I Love Lucy” episode. 😂
Hahaha my mom loves checking a bag. To her it’s less stress.
Thanks for this video about hard vs soft sided! I just purchased my first hard shell and I like the soft sided since has a single deep pocket versus 2 smaller pockets on each side. I had the same issue so had a hard time packing one side at time.
Yes!!
When I chose my old carry-on, soft-sided type, I grabbed a luggage scale and made my way around this department. I got the lightest one I could find. With age catching up to my body, my carry-on now contains CPAP, a ton of meds and jewelry. That’s it. Great video!
Yay carry-on. Remember your cpap does not count as a carry-on to the TSA or airline. You can buy a J hook for the suitcase handle so you do not have to carry it.
We are Canadian! They still get you to remove our shoes when we get a flight to the U.S. On top of that, I usually have a better half complaining about everything I have to make my way to a cruise ship, including the 10 bags (50 pieces per bag) of maple candy that I have distributed in all my suitcases. I keep a bag of maple candy in my purse to give to people who have not tasted maple before.
@@camilledextraze7104 ohh maple candy! What kind? Is it avaliable in the US?
You can find it on the internet. It looks like a miniature maple leaf. On the Byward market, here in Ottawa, you can get a bag of 50 pieces for about 10$…pre-pandemic price. The great thing about maple products is the following: sugar is sugar, no matter the form. However, maple syrup, compared to an apple, a slice of bread and an egg, contains an incredible amount of essential minerals.
@@camilledextraze7104 I have seen those before, but everywhere I see them, they are crazy expensive. I will definitely have to try them now! Love Real Maple. We don't use that corn syrup in our house, we are fortunate enough to live around the Mennonites and Amish so the make and sell it at their stores. Albeit the don't mind charging. They are kind of notorious for over charging for stuff. But it's too good not to buy!
Have a Tutto Medium Machine on wheels that I travel with. Yes, I have a Singer Featherweight sewing machine that fits inside with fabric and clothing for a weekend away. This is easy to roll the plane isle and fit under the seat and overhead. I am short enough that I always have to ask for help putting a bag overhead.
Yes but when you pull the 2-wheel behind you, you get like 3feet of personal space where the hurried passenger behind you can’t press up against.
Good tip. I like to push my 2 wheeler in front of me to keep am eye on my personal tote that i have in top held by the trolley handle. I could pull it if I was in the situation you mentioned. Thanks
Also, Lori I know it’s a bit off-topic but could you please address a important issue that I think a lot of us might have. That being, when you approach the seat that you are assigned to sit in and somebody else has taken the overhead bin. And there is no more space for your carry-on what do you do? They want to check your bag for you but honest to God, if everybody just adhere to the rules and placed their own carry-on above their own seat we wouldn’t have that problem. It’s so annoying
I also want to know
Me too
Me too
Good question 🙋 Does the planes actually have enough overhead bins for 1 carry on for each passenger? The rules are very specific, 1 carry on at a certain size and 1 personal item goes under the seat in front of you.
There is not a space for everyone as the flight crews have 2 full bins with their safety items so that does cut back on space
Thanks for this one. I'm still undecided which I prefer. I can't do a regular size carry on because of a messed up shoulder (can't hoist it overhead) so I use a backpack and medium size travel purse. I have both hard and soft checked bags and both have +/- features. Agree with you carry-on needs outside pockets!
hope it gets better for you! do the attendants never offer to help you?
@@iloveAllah802 thanks, very kind of you! I've never asked them, I just feel it's my problem 🤣. I'm sure fellow passengers would help if asked nicely. 😊
I prefer the soft carryon because the one I have has several pockets on the outside AND it has four wheels. The wheels are 360. I can grab it from three different sides. Top, bottom and the side (left side). I have no trouble lifting it.
When you find a good carry-on, it’s the best for a trip!
Which one do you love Sushi?
This was great, thank you! I'll be traveling for the first time with a hard shell front open carry-on soon. Our hotel is small so I didn't want the kind that open in half, we'll see how it goes. And yes, I have also sat on a suitcase to close it before 😅.
One thing I learned from my surgeon after I had a knee replacement, was to use a 4 wheel case. Pulling two wheels behind you unbalances the body and can tear the area around an artificial knee. If you haven't had surgery I am sure people will notice they have more upright posture with a case at their side rather than behind.
Ooh good to know! I have a bad knee.
It is indeed frustrating when you have to stow your carryon several rows back. I feel like a salmon swimming upstream with grizzlies waiting to pounce if I dare to try to claim my bag before people behind me get off. Ugh.
@@bethfoley4470 Well, yeah. You are fighting the stream and making it darn tough for grizzlies to get off the plane. IMHO, if you opt to put the suitcase downstream, you have to wait till those behind you have cleared the aisle.
@@markmarz, I would much prefer that my bag be above my seat, as I am sure that you also would. But when others seated elsewhere have already stashed their bag(s) in the compartment above my seat, it becomes a problem not of my making. I don’t choose to sit in back with my bag stowed up front just so I don’t have to roll or carry it along the aisle, like some apparently do. It’s inconsiderate for everyone else.
@@bethfoley84 It may be a problem not of your making, but it is a problem. By choosing to fight the stream rather than wait for those downstream to clear the aisle, you're making your problem their problem as well.
Yay Laurie, I’m back here. Finally going to the UK in September when our 2020 holiday was cancelled. It’s so exciting getting ideas from your channel. 👏
Yay have a lovely trip!
This has really made me reconsider carry-on vs checked! Ive never been a fan of soft-sided luggage - it always gets torn. But i love the hard- side with the front pocket! Thank you! ❤
I loved the idea of hard sided luggage and purchased one many years ago. I used it once and the whole corner with wheel broke off and that was it. I find clamshell suitcases totally impractical. Having to have space to open the whole thing up is very inconvenient, as well as the weight of half your contents on one side making it unwieldy. Hardshells are now evolving and they have one side open hard shells now, with a front flap, so I’m thinking about getting one. My soft side has spinner wheels so that’s not an issue and it can also be dragged behind me. My partners hard shell carry on is more knocked up looking than my soft side but my soft side is dirtier. They both have pros and cons but to be honest, I don’t see any advantage to hard side. He has a $1000 Tumi bag that got lost when he checked it and it got pretty scrapped up. We now have a cover for it. I don’t even know why I am thinking of getting a hard shell except maybe because it’s prettier.
My husband and I toured Europe in May. I had one of each. I really like the ease of pushing the hard shell suitcase next to me. It is more difficult to pull the weight of a soft sided suitcase behind me. I think I can put more in the hard shell even using the packing cubes…one of the many great tips I got from your videos before my trip. I agree with you about the outside pocket.
I’m supposed to go to Europe next year, not sure which airline, what size suitcase did you use? I will be going to several countries on a WW 2 tour.
There are 4-wheeled softside spinners as well
Nearing the end of last year I watched all of your videos, I had not traveled by plane since those "scary" and cautious years. But last year December specific was a family wedding and reunion. My husband is well traveled due to his type of work and he talked me through since he was not going to be with me. I was uneasy, I felt so inexperienced because of the changes. I panicked thinking omg, I am taking a hardshell carry on and I have to pack my wedding outfit, a few dressy outfits, some in between because the weather was unpredictable in AZ, shoes & my head was spinning. Well let me thank you, I purchased that slip-on the handle tote which seems to be like the Mary Poppins bag of totes! I sailed through security check points, had more than enough packed & room to spare & believe me I am a person who is not a minimalist in fashion or essentials. I had people asking me questions saying I looked like a well traveled person, LOL. I just was so organized and prepared, everything else was a facade, hahahahaha. I think hardshell also keeps clothes better since it stays true to form where as the soft sided can become rounded as did one of my sister's and her clothes although packed well seemed to have wrinkled. Off to a family vacation next month so I will be reviewing and watching closely here for any tips or neat items you have to share. Thanks again, wishing you and yours the best!
I have them both in carry-on and weekend sizes. depending on my travel plans that’s was I use.
In days of yore, we only had hard shell and they were so heavy. Weight of the bag itself matters to me, I can't lift overhead very easily and also may travel internationally some day again. I think for those two reasons, I'll stick with my trusty soft-side, which has two outside pockets and two handles to lift it with.
Yes! My first luggage was American Tourister hard sided, with small wheels, and you pulled with that little strap. It was red, and I felt so grown up(I was in Junior High School), using it! I never carried on anything but a purse then, either. I think I still have one of the keys that went with that set, too.
I imagine I’m not your average subscriber . . . I stay w/ my (adult) son when he’s in hospital . . . 3 hour drive . . . and it seems that only the children’s floors take care of parents/guardians/caregivers. So, I’m on my own. Since most of his surgeries are emergencies, I now have a pre-packed carry on size bag and a list of reminders. He needs a weighted blanket that I even take to his appts, just in case he needs a spur of the moment CT or MRI. The “stand by” bag is for everything. It has a wonderful side pocket for power bank w/ cord and external outlet, room for 10# blanket, individual vacuum sealed (homemade) peanut butter/Rice Krispies treats (I eventually need energy and they stay fresh forever), empty water bottles, and light blanket for me.
Thanks to you, I now use packing cubes and I’m saving up for a front-opening hard suitcase.
After 100+ surgeries, I’m happy that I can still learn and you’ve given great suggestions for every kind of “traveler.” I’m so very grateful!! Thank you muchly!
Ooh those Rice Krispies sound fantastic!!! I am proud of you mama!!
Some really important tips. Never thought of the handles and what side there on! Thank you
So many times I do not know until I travel with an item.
I started using spinners about 15 years ago after a few trips to Asia (Japan and HK). In super busy stations (like Tokyo train station) there are soooo many people literally rushing around in all directions and when I had my 2 wheeler that needed pulling behind me, people would constantly be bumping into it and almost tripping over it. I realized they found it hugely annoying as they were all used to seeing the 4 wheel spinners next to people so they could see the bag and walk around it. They literally didn't know it was behind me when they passed by until it was too late! It was a really interesting observation into social travel norms of a different place. I immediately switched to spinners for all my bags when I got home.
They are very convenient!
Hi Laurie, I've travelled all my life with a hard-shell check-in medium sized luggage (Antler) which is great for packing lots of stuff but I agree that it can be inconvenient to have to open up the whole thing on the floor to get to things. I recently invested in a soft-shell cabin bag (American Tourister) cos I'm keen to try the 'travel with only cabin bag' style to avoid the baggage carousel delays which seems to be the norm now. The saleslady advised that having only 1 bag (side/container?) makes it easier at security checks, which I agreed with, but I still found it a bit of a challenge to pack for a 6-nights trip. The good thing though is that it did have 2 outer zipped pockets that allowed me to stash some metal items that may have required pulling out. I think it will take me some getting used to.
Yes, after 20 years it's taking a few trips to get used to hard shell.
Briggs and Riley. High end but no comparison. I have 3 bags- 21,22 and back pack. If you travel enough and want the investment, you will not be disappointed.
Love the idea of keeping travel documents in the outside pocket of the suite case.
I spent 25+ years as a frequent flyer. My favorite carry-on is a soft sided bag with spinners. You do give up some internal volume, but the right personal item bag can compensate. My favorite brands are Victorinox, Briggs & Riley, and Travelpro.
Yes I love TravelPro too!
So glad I found your channel! I rarely travel but since the arrival of my first grandbaby yesterday, I anticipate lots of east coast to west coast US trips in my future!
Oh how exciting!
Congratulations!!
You are correct. I also have a hard case suitcase without the outer pocket and I do need it!
Hi Carmen!
At my age, I just can't lift the hard side and I don't like having to lay it flat to access both sides. For me, the soft-sided just works best, but my sons both like the hard sided. It isn't so much about how much I can get into it, just ease of handling alone.
I love the idea of hard sided cases but I’ve never found one where I love the interior layout. Like you mentioned, I tend to put my suitcase on the luggage rack and prop the top up against the wall so I can see everything I’ve packed. My current one is by a soft sided American Tourister bag with 4 wheels.
Yes if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it
I travel with Rimowa hard sided suitcases and I love them. It took a little getting used to packing differently, but I can fit so much more in them than I ever could my soft-sided. No, mine doesn’t have an outside pocket, but I manage just fine putting things I need easily accessible in my personal bag.
Thanks for sharing! Experience is the best teacher.
We flew a week ago and I used your tips for jewelry after TSA checks and it was my five year old first flight 😃, very excited and proud for him. I like how your son is creatively hiding his face in your videos 😆👍🏻
Haha!
Thank you for all of the tips. They have given me more insight into planning for overseas trips.
Oh good! Hope it's a wonderful trip.
I just purchased my first hard-side luggage. I like it because each side is one layer deep, so you don’t have to dig through everything or take things out in order to get to things that are underneath.
Yes that shallow depth is helpful when packing.
I've always traveled with a backpack (hiking pack or travel pack) but I think you've convinced me to get a rolling suitcase for certain trips!
You truly can be hands free though with a backpack. Hard decision!
One of the perks of a backpack is that you can put it under the seat in the event of the overhead bins are stuffed
Re: Overhead bin issues onboard, carryon baggage and general trip travel preparation.
Aim to plan ahead.
Sometimes the bin storage above your seat obtains crew baggage.
Especially if crew jump seats are near your seat.
Crew must keep their items close for security reasons and to be able to access emergency manuals easily.
Other bins could be filled with emergency safety equipment. For example; life vests, halons, smoke hoods, oxygen bottles, first aid kits, survival kits, etc.
Emergency equipment must be easily accessible and not covered by a passenger’s belongings.
Other items filling bin space could be catering items, tarmac delay items, toiletry supplies or trash compactor boxes.
If the bin is full above your seat, try to store your bag forward of your seat so when you deplane you are moving in the forward direction.
If the aircraft bins are full at the back of the aircraft turn around and move forward through the aircraft looking on both sides until you can find an available space for your bag. Note the bin number. If most passengers have already boarded, there may be space left in premium or business class that the crew could allow you to use before offloading your bag to cargo.
If your carryon bag doesn’t fit anywhere, and you don’t have a connecting flight, carry a fold up bag in your backpack that can be removed and used to store your travel documents, passport, health and vaccine info, medication, electronics, lithium batteries while onboard the flight and gate check your larger bag.
Take your carryon to staff and request a baggage tag.
Ensure the tag has the correct locator code of the airport you are traveling to.
Always have your name and contact info clearly labeled outside and inside any baggage.
Use baggage security locks that customs can open if required.
Consider purchasing Apple Store “trackers” to place in your bag, backpack, or purse, to help locate your bags if they are lost during your travels.
It is not appropriate to angrily remove a random bag that was placed in the overhead bin above your seat and place it on the floor for staff to check.
Bags must first match up with the passenger in order to be checked. It would be completely unacceptable to offload another passenger’s bag without their knowledge.
Never leave the overhead bin you placed your bag in until you are sure the bin will shut and you have confirmed the bin shuts with your bag in it.
Many passengers on boarding, open a bin, rearrange bags in different directions, place their bag inside, then leave a bin that doesn’t close. Then, bags need to be removed and stowed elsewhere. Then, the passenger must be located who belongs to the removed bag.
If your bag is not labeled, it is an issue.
Know how to identify your specific bag.
One black backpack looks like the rest.
Take note of the bin number you stowed your bag in for arrival.
Double check you have all belongings before leaving the aircraft.
Use the time you have while waiting to deplane.
If you are sitting at a bulkhead or an exit row, your purse, laptop and personal belongings must be removed from the floor area.
Avoid hiding your purse or backpack on the floor behind your ankles or under a coat covering your ankles. All these items must be stored for takeoff and landing.
Avoid waiting to store your items till all the overhead bins are full and the demo starts or you leave the crew scrambling at the last minute to try to locate extra space.
Learn to travel with carry on items only.
Don’t wait to pack till the last minute.
Roll your items to fit more.
Always pack your passport, Identification and wallet in the same place every trip.
Have your headsets handy on boarding if you want to watch the inflight entertainment.
Have your credit card handy if you want to purchase headsets or food on domestic flights.
No debit cards. No hybrid cards. No cash.
Only credit cards or prepay for your meal when booking your trip.
Don’t wait for the bar and meal trolly to arrive at your seat and then ask the Flight Attendant to retrieve your wallet from your coat or backpack while others are waiting.
Think ahead.
Be respectful.
If you are required to wear a mask, wear it properly over your nose, mouth, chin and beard.
Expect delays.
Practice patience,
Arrive early.
Allow enough time to get to the family celebration, fishing, hiking trip or cruise you planned two years ago.
Leave “multiple days” ahead.
Expect the unexpected and plan for it.
Consider travel and trip interruption insurance.
Pick the easiest and most convenient airports to travel through.
Expect to wait in long lines for check-in, baggage drop off, security, customs, cabs, customer service related to flight cancelations and delays, Starbucks, Tim Horton’s or any restaurant.
Be kind.
Thanks for your travel tips!
I will be traveling with only a carry on and personal care item for the first time for my upcoming 5 day trip to Aruba. I feel very comfortable doing this now that I have spent hours absorbing all your wonderful information.
EEEK have a wonderful trip!
This video was so spot on and needed. You brought out several things that I have not considered. I am so excited to check out the items that you linked. Thanks so much for this helpful video!
Hi!! Do not miss the one I just uploaded about What’s in My Backpack: bit.ly/EssentialsInBackPack
I have a four wheel soft side. Love it
Hi, juts started watching your channel. I have a Samsonite which I believe has spinner wheels. But my favorite is definitely the outside pocket and that you can definitely squish it when you need to. I just bought a hardshell, but yet to travel with it yet.
another great video Laurie. Appreciate all your tips as always!
Good video, the last travel tip of moving the suitcase down the isle was the game changer idea and selling point for me. Thanks for posting this video!
I really think that may be why I will mostly travel with that one.
You always have the best tips! I could never fit everything that I "thought" I needed into a carryon until I started following you.
So glad! Experience helps me know what to pack and what really is not needed. Glad my tips helped you!
@@TravelTipsbyLaurie you are very much our inspiration!
Great video! I have a Briggs and Riley soft sided 2 wheels that I've had for nearly 10 years. I love it. It has a front pocket that I store my laptop and a few random pockets that can hold my passport and miscellaneous items. I actually put my suitcase ahead of me when boarding/un-boarding then right as I'm getting off I do a quick switcheroo. Easy Peasy!
When you find a good suitcase, it’s wonderful!
I have a soft sided, two wheel Briggs and Riley, too, that I bought many years ago at Costco. I love it but I noticed that my husband's soft sided, two wheel TravelPro is a little narrower so he has an easier time walking down the airplane aisle.
@@lindachafetz2670 Yes I can pull mine behind me on most airplanes, but pushing the hardshell is so nice!
I use a hard shell carry on by London Fog. It’s amazing. 360 spin and several pockets inside. Not having an outside pocket is something that’s never bothered me.
@@MichaelTheophilus906 My meds don't even come close to fitting into my personal item (wish they did, but they don't - only 1 day's box fits) - I have no choice but to put them either in my carryon or in a 3rd bag with the rest of my medical stuff.
Laurie….I prefer the soft carryon. The reason is that the hard shell you need to open in the floor the two half’s and is completely difficult in the restricted space of small hotel rooms. The soft is easier since the top is flexible, has ready to reach pockets and can expand much bigger than the hard shell ones
Yes, I talked about not liking that as well.
My soft sided hand carry also has four wheels. Very excited to pack it up for my up coming trip to UK.
I am so happy for you!! Have fun.
Hi, Laurie thank you so much for making this video because I’m in the market for a hard shell. We have soft shell and I just don’t like them can’t put my fingers on why. 🤷♀️BTW I have used that striped backpack for work and love it. Thank you.
I just traveled around the world for 6 months with the smallest Away carry-on suitcase, and I swear by it! I never had to be afraid that I had over-packed and it wouldn't fit in a smaller plane's overhead. It helped me simplify what I took and what I bought overseas. (I sent parcels home whenever I had purchased presents for my family.) The handle was so sturdy, I was never afraid it was going to break, and the same with the spinning wheels. I had to go over some hard terrain with that suitcase, and it came through it like a champ.
this has really helped me - couldn't decide which one to go with........ was looking at Monos (which is a smidge bigger) and Away
I love hearing this info about your bag!
@@mmorden9938 The budget airlines' plane in Asia and Europe have low carry-on weight requirements too, usually just 7kg. So having a small bag really helps save you the extra cost of checking a bag.
@@latebloomerabroad we have a couple that I think work for that if we fly with them. Air Canada has a size but not weight requirement for carry on…. Thank heaven!!
I use a hard shell suitcase. I got Samsonite some time back and that is what I fly with, no matter how long my trip is. And if I travel overseas (mainly to the US), I always count with needing additional piece of luggage for my way back 😀
I like the idea of the pocket on your suitcase but because of the ticket I usually get, I tend to end up having to check in my carry on (be it directly at the check in counter if I have to use it, or before boarding) and that would mean transferring all my electronics and valuables into my smaller item anyway. So, I’ll stick with the hard shell suitcase I have, and keep using a backpack as my personal item 😊
Thank you for sharing your perspective. Hope you get to travel to the US again soon.
Thanks for the great video. I am going on a cruise in 2 months and plan to only use carry-on luggage because the airlines are having so much checked luggage issues. I may buy that hard shell carry on and give it at try.
I used soft-sided for years and gave hard-sided a try. I really liked it until I returned from Orlando and the bag was completely crushed. I found out there is no way to repair it. It was incredible how damaged the bag was. The sides were completely deformed. I did get compensation for it and luckily it was my trip home so I didn’t need the bag to be usable to return home. So now I have a TravelPro Maxlite 5 soft-sided 4 wheel spinner that I love.
TFS as I was considering a hard-sided one.
I had a similar experience and swear by soft sided rolling carryon and checked bag.
I really like the new hard sided TravelPro with the outside pocket but bought the soft sided because the hard sided is almost 5 lbs heavier. The airline might not care how heart the suitcase is but saves me lifting an extra 5 lbs
I have a soft sided TravelPro and I love it!
Which soft-sided TravelPro's do you guys have? I'm thinking about getting one when my current 19" carryon (already almost 11 years old, and has sustained some damage to key parts from careless baggage handlers, though thankfully my dad was able to fix it) wears out.
@@SnowySpiritRuby Many people love the Travelpro Maxlite 5. It's inexpensive and you can find lots of video reviews online from seasoned travelers.
I decided to go with the more expensive Travelpro Crew Versapack - have both 4-wheel and 2-wheel versions - because of better reviews, better wheels - "the best on the market"- zip-in dividers and more space (it's wider).
But it's heavier so I also bought the Travelpro Maxlite 5 spinner. It's fine even though it probably won't last as long. Just be sure to check reviews before buying.
@@citybright8925 Awesome, thanks.
Thanks for sharing, Laurie! I always enjoy watching your videos, and I love your accent! All right, I own both a soft and 2 hard-sided carryon luggage, including one with outer pockets, but I’m not very fond of that one as it tends to get a bit bulky. I travel mostly for business so I prefer the “discipline” of the hard-sided carryon. Anything I need to access- my iPad, a book, snacks- are usually in my tote that fits under my seat as I don’t care to get out of my seat to get to the overhead for anything, so if it’s not in my tote, so be it… For me, the worst thing about the spinners (which I love!) is that they don’t perform well on carpeting unless you pull the luggage behind you…
Ooh, good things to think about!
Laurie thanks for the video. I have to buy new luggage and the video has help me to decide on my purchase.
I have the best of both worlds. Hays carryon case with top side soft, bottom hard with spinner wheels. Pockets front and back :) I have had the case for over 10 years and done long trips every year. I travel out with it as a carry on and have the option to expand and check it on my way home.
Thank you so much for your in-depth reviews! I just love your videos. You are the best!!!
Thanks Diana!
I've never had a hard she'll, unless it's lighter my canvas is very durable and has plenty of pockets and tie downs. Do want to go a little smaller though. 👍👍👍
I used soft for years with 2 wheels. Loved them! Then I switched to hard with 4 wheels but not spinner. I found them bulky and heavy before packing. I now have soft with 4 spinner wheels. I checked my carry-on coming back from Puerto Vallarta in April. I watched the poor thing get body slammed as it was being loaded on the plane. I'm still not sure which one is better!
Great comparison. I wasn't familiar with hard-sided luggage features. The tips about the outer pocket and the way the spinner luggage wheels work were very helpful
I agree! I didn't know the hard sided carry-ons have an outside pocket. Will think about that the next time I am in the market for one.
@@cherylkern3288 Most don't have them - Laurie's is the first one I've personally ever seen that does.
I got the Backpack you have and it is excellent actually bought the large for travel and the medium for daily work
Cool! Thanks for your experience.
I used to use only soft sided cases and loved them but, on my last few trips, if the airplane looked to be too full for carry on luggage my bag was one of the first to be flagged for the ""complimentary check" while hard case travelers behind me were still allowed on with their similarly sized luggage. I think it may be due to the soft sided bag looking bulkier despite not being filled all the way and squishing easily. I'm going to try my first hardshell carry-on for this upcoming trip and see how it goes.
I hear ya!
New subscriber here! Great video! I have travelled with a soft sided Travelpro carry on with spinners for 8 years, and just ordered my first hard shell carry on. It does not have a front pocket, but I'm okay with that as I utilize the pockets in my personal item for that purpose. I'm looking forward to trying it out on our next trip! ✈️
Ooh that sounds exciting! It took me a few trips to get used to this carry-on.
Great video Laurie - I just faced this decision when my soft side handle broke after years of service and I had to purchase a new case; wish I had seen this video earlier. We just returned from a 14 day, 12 state DRIVING vacation to visit 2 of our 3 children. I just purchased a hard side for the first time because I thought it would stand up to baggage handlers better the next time I fly. I will say I didn’t like the hard side at all mainly because I am used to a deep case with a small “flip top” of the typical soft side. I hated opening the case every night and having to lift 1/2 of my belongings that were packed on the left side. You talk as though all hard side have spinner wheels and all soft side have in-line wheels, but I was jealous of my husband on this trip who not only had the lighter soft side suitcase, but he had spinner wheels as well. I am looking for a new soft side, with outer pockets and spinner wheels for my next trip! Thanks for a great video.
I realized that while making this video too. Ooh yes I do enjoy the depth of my soft sided bag.
Get a hard sided clam shell design. Love mine!
I dislike hard sides for that reason…I use a soft carryon always.
Great tips as always! We just returned from a trip to San Diego and I’m so glad I watched your channel. My husband couldn’t understand why I was always watching you lol! Anyway the packing cubes you recommended were a hit. We didn’t need to take out our liquids bag for TSA (new machines I guess?). Anyway, even if that changes I would still put all my liquids in the sturdy liquids bag you recommend. Thanks again!
That is awesome!
I have a soft sided suitcase with outer pockets and spinner wheels. I believe that I get all the perks of your hard shell suitcase. I will never again travel with a bag without spinner wheels. My shoulders would take a beating from pulling my bag
I often worry about hard shell suitcases popping open at the zipper. It happened to my daughter when she had to check her bag. (Those new colorful straps would be helpful I’m sure).
Thank you for sharing your knowledge Laurie
I would think the straps would help. I've never thought about that either. I do love the spinner wheels now.
For your clamshell style bags, place it on the luggage rack with the wheel facing away from you (so rotate it by 90 degrees from how you normally havevit). That way it lies flat. 👍
Love that tip!
I used to have a soft side case but then when we started travelling with hand luggage only more we bought better quality hard cases with 4 wheels. I find it much lighter & easier to wheel it on smooth surfaces but I have to often pull it behind me on uneven pavements & cobbles which is heavy. I find the two sides easier to pack & be organised. In Europe many airlines are very strict re size & weight of your carry ons so expandable suitcases are not always a good idea. I do often have to sit on my case to close it though.
Hello Laurie. I have a Delsey international with front pocket. I put my rain jacket, nightie, 1 pr undies and my Travelon toiletries bag open in the outside pocket. I need a cleanup and short nap after those overnight flights.
Also, the large garment folder fits perfectly over the “open” side of my suitcase. It goes over the other stuff and I strap it down.
I frequently pack mine expanded, zip, and then sit to close down expansion.
I have this same exact suitcase. I tend to use it when I travel for short trips for work. I put my laptop in a slim padded case with a strap in the pocket area. if I am forced to gate-check the suitcase I can pull the laptop out and keep it with me.
I did like their folder thing-didn't come in my silver one. Nice to know they have an outer pocket on some.
Took a flight with soft side carry-on packed to the max and a back pack just a few weeks ago. My friend also went. She had a sleek hard carry-on and a personal items bag with the sleeve to fit on the carry-on handle. She had a lot less bulk than I did. The backpack was a pain. Next month going on another trip with new Monos Pro Plus and sleeved personal item bag. I'm expecting it to go more smoothly. I'm now a NO BACKPACK lady. Thank you for the tips 😊
Yes yes, I will only carry a backpack or tote with a trolley sleeve. They're awesome aren't they! Have fun and let me know how you like the suitcase.
I love my hard shell 4 wheel spinner carry-on cash. I paid US$23 for it in Brooklyn in 2018 and it has held up well over the years.
The best!
Laurie- great info! I still don’t like that the hard shell has to open like a clam shell, but like your idea of how to pack it. I also liked the idea of the side pocket to throw things. I also don’t wear accessories until after TSA.
In a luggage video for this coming weekend I challenge my viewers to invent a less awkward luggage rack for hotel rooms specifically for these book-opening suitcases lol.
Great tips thanks. Just replaced our soft sided cases for hard as I always over packed the soft sided and in UK so size and weight are very important. Its easier for me to keep within regulations with the hard sided cases.
That makes sense. If you need some hacks for packing, this is a new video: bit.ly/8CarryOnPackingHacks
Hard shell, older Eagle Creek (two sided, flat opening) they don’t make anymore. Love it and packing cubes! Thanks to you, going to re-evaluate toiletries and how to pack differently. Re: using a hotel luggage rack, I turn my case so the hinge is in the middle of the rack (vertically across the rack), that way both sides can open flat. Granted, if the rack has that back handle it’s trickier. Usually there are other options like top of the dresser, the bed or table. Once unpacked, no problem. If I don’t want to unpack, there’s usually a place to keep the suitcase out of my way, even if it’s the floor. Another good reason to use packing cubes, as they keep clothes clean. Thanks for helping me get ready for upcoming trips to Seattle and Europe after 3 years staying home!
Yay bon voyage! Cheerio!
I was looking for the delsey review
And I found you.
Very helpful!! GRACIAS 🙏🏼
Hope it helps! Delsey is a great brand; I just need an outer pocket.
I have a trip next month that has air, rail, bus, even a ferry, plus motels. Figure to do a fair bit of walking, so I opted for a travel backpack everything. Easier than lugging a bag around
We need to get a new carryon suitcase and we have never before used a hard shell….we just might try a hard shell one because you brought up a lot of good points!! We are from Ottawa, Canada…so don’t want to check our luggage any more as it takes up too much time…and then I over pack! Lol!
Thanks for the tips, really helpful.
Thank you!
The hardside ones that expand, you can pack while expanded and then zip down when closed as a way to compress your packing
I have a 15yo TravelPro soft carryon that I love! It’s a 2 wheel case, not a fan of 4 wheel, and it’s so well made that I hope it lasts another 15 yrs
Yes! That was mine-I replaced my first one after 12 years and still going with this one in the video. I did not think I would like the spinner but do. It is just smaller.
Thank you so much for your video 😊.
I appreciate this video so much! ❤️❤️
Thanks for watching!
Another advantage of soft wheeled bags is that many of them have a backpack option with hidden straps. That's not really possible with a rigid bag. I recommend the Black Wolf range. They are very versatile, pockets galore. Very well designed. One of mine even has its own raincoat.
Thank you for your thoughts!
Check out Solgaard suitcases. They don’t have an outside pocket but all of their other features make up for it.