Gas Vs. Diesel On Bigger Boats

Sdílet
Vložit

Komentáře • 92

  • @TM-tw1py
    @TM-tw1py Před rokem +4

    Thanks for this video - better info here than I have seen almost anywhere.

  • @johnthomson8332
    @johnthomson8332 Před 2 lety +2

    Love you're boat, one day I will be out there with a similar one.

  • @Huggybear101
    @Huggybear101 Před 11 měsíci

    Thanks. That was informative.

  • @brandonleckie8548
    @brandonleckie8548 Před 2 lety +6

    Great Video. My 7.4's on my 340 Ray have 1,300 hours and are still running great with great compression. Just like anything in regards to boating if you take care of it, it'll last.

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před 2 lety

      No doubt. Thanks for watching.

    • @Subaruej20
      @Subaruej20 Před rokem +1

      ​@@gregbrigman543 hi Greg, how would a single 454 go in a 28 Sundance? Consumption wise and can you just cruise them to just reduce that so it's more affordable..love you video😁

    • @Subaruej20
      @Subaruej20 Před rokem

      ​@@gregbrigman543 hi Greg..love your video...how would a single 454 go in a 2850 dancer? What fuel consumption would I expect to get?

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před rokem +1

      @@Subaruej20 Thanks for watching. From what I hear, you get better mileage with twins say V-6's as they don't have to work as hard as one bigger motor. Always go with 2 if you get the chance.

    • @Subaruej20
      @Subaruej20 Před rokem +1

      @@gregbrigman543 yeh true...and also you have a backup motor on a long trip...that's a great comfort I feel. I'm looking at a few with twin 5.7s and as you said in the video they are a cheaper boat to buy due to the petrol motors. I'm looking at 30 ft plus so I'm tipping the 5.7s would be better but if a twin V6 setup comes along I would also have a look...over here in Australia were seeing mainly V8 twins and not so many V6s. thanks heaps for your reply and enjoy your beautiful boat 😀

  • @robertocruz0577
    @robertocruz0577 Před 2 měsíci

    Great input Greg, really appreciat it. Wonder if the gas consuption mentioned goes for both engines conmbined

  • @corvetteguy1980
    @corvetteguy1980 Před 10 měsíci

    I have a 2004 340 Sundancer with the 8.1s in it.

  • @jonsm114
    @jonsm114 Před 3 měsíci

    Have FOX gateways on my 400EC. Great product! 96 with 7.4mpi power. Plenty of power.

  • @alfredofernandez8036
    @alfredofernandez8036 Před 11 měsíci +1

    I owned for 10 years a 2005 searay 340 sundancer with 8.1 vdrives and my experience was a best cruise of 22-23 knots with 0.65 nautical miles per gallon at full fuel and water and a 10.5 dinghy hanging out the back. The vessel was cruised from Florida to ábacos and Bimini in the Bahamas. When sold in 2020 with 1100 hours on the engines compression 185 even on all cylinders. When purchased with 200 hours compression was 195 all around. They were trouble free engines with basic routine maintenance. I saved a lot of money not buying a diesel boat. I would buy Gas again up to 38 feet.

  • @asdfbc
    @asdfbc Před 10 měsíci

    Thanks for taking the time to post your vids wrt your Sundancer. I am contemplating purchasing 1999-2001 Sundancer. Was wondering if you had any words of wisom/suggestions/guidance on purchasing a 20 year old or so boat. Things you'd pay upfront for, upgrades to conisder and cost, etc. Much appreciated.

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před 10 měsíci

      Hello, thanks for watching my videos. Regarding a 20 YO boat, depends on the manufacture and how well it's been taken care of. Obviously I'm a Searay guy - love them. I have really never had any major issues, so make sure the boat is clean, well maintained and get a good survey. I'd recommended a 1999 Searay all day.

  • @GoldenCroc
    @GoldenCroc Před rokem

    Interesting video and good data, however, there may be one oversight that I spotted: I take it you havent done a 1:1 comparison to an example with diesels? In that case there is the possibility that the "1mpg" figure for the diesels isnt any morre accurate than the ".5 mpg" some give for the gas engines, I.e the diesel might in reality also be a bit higher? Certainly normally I would expect at least a small bit larger difference, though that is compared to more modern diesels to be fair. Anyway, cheers mate!

  • @user-gq2vn1xj2r
    @user-gq2vn1xj2r Před 11 měsíci +1

    You need more rocker switches.

  • @thetattooedladyfan
    @thetattooedladyfan Před rokem

    I'm intrigued by the Fox Marine interface. Would love to have that same setup on my 2001 Maxum with twin 7.4l's. Out of curiosity, did you do the install by yourself?

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před rokem

      Hi Jim,
      I highly recommend the Fox Gateways. They are easy to install. You have to have an engine controller to plug the Gateway's port into, but it's easy. The hardest part is running the NEMA 2000 cable up to your dash to connect to your hopefully NEMA 2000 GPS. The owner of Fox is really helpful and can also answer questions. Let me know if you want to install yourself and I can answer any questions you may have.

    • @thetattooedladyfan
      @thetattooedladyfan Před rokem

      @@gregbrigman543
      Thanks Greg. Hope to say hi someday on LSC. I’m on the Clinton River.

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před rokem

      @@thetattooedladyfan Yeah Jim, I'm at Macray's.

  • @Soundsofthewood
    @Soundsofthewood Před rokem +2

    I work on boat diesel for a living.
    I wish I got more gassers because alot less weight and I don't have to put the owner through a mini heart attack when I give them the bill.
    I work down in West SoFlo. I have started recommending gassers to the owners because most don't really use a diesel to its full extent.
    Most would be just fine with a gasser for what they use them for.
    A rebuild on a diesel cost upwards to two complete power-packs on a gasser.
    I got a current customer that is trying to sell the boat, but he left it sit in the same spot for about a decade and didn't start the engines.
    Now the fuel has Algae in it and they need to get the tanks polished. You can't let diesel sit for long without treatment. Gas turns to varnish, but it's alot easier to remove and replace compared to diesel.
    That algae gets in all the lines and injectors, so you have to flush the system and get new injectors on top of that. It's about $250.00 per injector by a reputable shop to do it. So about $4,000.00 for a set of V8's, then you have to pay for a person to install and adjust the rack(if it has a rack).
    You also have to make sure that everything in the engine works properly if it sits for long. I mentioned a rack before. Detroit 2 strokers are mechanical for the most part. If the rack is stuck and you start it, then it will scream to the heavens and you can't shut it off without a flapper or pull cord. If run for too long like that. It will wash out the engine and it will need an overhaul.
    I have worked on a few gassers and they can do pretty much the same that the diesel can do for what the owners use them for.
    It would cost them far less and alot easier to work on.
    The resale value will be lower, but you will never get the money back out from a liveaboard in the long run.
    It's kinda similar to the "diesel truck vs gas truck". It depends on what you do with it.

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před rokem +1

      Agree 100%. What you say makes a lot of sense. Thanks

  • @robertconway3519
    @robertconway3519 Před 10 měsíci +1

    Very helpful video... I'm looking into the 370 Express cruiser of a similar vintage. a boat with twin 8.1 Horizons is close to half of what a boat with the CATs is asking. This is surprisingly respectable, my only concern is the range. To be distance cruising or offshore canyon fishing you;d want to make the most of the fuel capacity. What's the GPH between 3200-3600?

    • @Lerman610
      @Lerman610 Před 10 měsíci +2

      Probably look at anywhere from 36 to 40 gallons an hour at those rpms basing this off of a 1998 40ft with 8.1s in it

    • @sharonbraselton3135
      @sharonbraselton3135 Před 15 dny

      New 37 fit exiess cruser outbards better nogs outbards

    • @robertconway3519
      @robertconway3519 Před 15 dny

      @sharonbraselton3135 not reasonable for my planned usage, or budget. I can purchase and repower a gas 37EC with diesels for half or less than a comparable new outboard powered version. Manufacturers have turned almost allboats in this class to glorified day boats with a bunk. No thank you

  • @hildablanco1591
    @hildablanco1591 Před rokem

    If its a inbourd out bourd with bravo 2 drives it gets up and goes fast but duel props is a gear box nightmare

  • @CaptainTodd
    @CaptainTodd Před rokem

    Hey Greg, thanks for the video. Do you know what your gallons per hour would be? Thats the only data I know how to obtain on my SeaRay

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před rokem +1

      Hello Todd, If you have a way of knowing how many gallons per hour you are burning, just divide your speed in miles per hour by how many gallons you are burning to get your miles per gallon. That's the important one. If I cruise at say 20 MPH, I typically burn about 26 gallons per hour.

    • @CaptainTodd
      @CaptainTodd Před rokem

      Wow, thanks for that piece of info. I've always thought I got great gas mileage, and this solidifies it. 18-19 gallons per hour at 26 MPH. Around 1.44 gallons per mile. I just completed an 8 day trip, across, down and back up the Chesapeake Bay on 1 fill up!!! I am considering a bigger boat and will lose the fuel economy for sure.

  • @jonathonkennedy9321
    @jonathonkennedy9321 Před rokem

    In Michigan I wouldn’t have diesels. Most people don’t go that far. I understand that you can on the big lakes. I travel 50-100 miles one way in alaska sometimes. Outboards or diesels only. Diesels are nice but I ran a 30 ft aluminum with twin 250 Suzukis all summer getting 1.3mpg at 28knts and 1.6 at 24knts. Sweet boat.

  • @JohnBaxter-kn5zf
    @JohnBaxter-kn5zf Před 3 měsíci

    Id like to take out my 5.0 and put in a small Cummins, i fished on a boat w Cummins and when others broke down we fished

  • @germanlopez4134
    @germanlopez4134 Před 6 měsíci

    hi greg super great video i have a,1998 maxum 37. ft wich is like 39 ft weight 21000 lbs and have twin 7.4 horizon mpi im in miami i ren 26 miles total and used 58 gallon in total mean 30 gallon one tank and 28 the other tank what will be my fuel consumption in gallon per miles please help

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před 6 měsíci +1

      Hello, 26 miles divided by 58 gallons is 0.448 miles per gallon. Your boats should get about 1 mile per gallon at a cruise speed of about 24 MPH at about 3200 RPM. You were either going way too fast, or you badly need a tune up. I'd recheck that next time you get a chance, or install the Fox Gateways and you can see real time. Thanks

  • @tomdavis8757
    @tomdavis8757 Před 4 měsíci

    I actually used to prefer gasoline for various reasons but the whole ethanol thing ruins it for any gasoline engine that doesn’t see regular use.
    Cheers

  • @jonwallace7015
    @jonwallace7015 Před 7 měsíci

    If you wax the bottom of your ship with bee's wax before you go out it makes a good difference. I do it every time i go out .forget about antifouling thats old fashioned. I hope this helps.

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před 7 měsíci

      John, It's a 40' boat in a well. How am I supposed to wax the bottom?

    • @jonwallace7015
      @jonwallace7015 Před 7 měsíci

      With a aqualung buddy .it's a nightmare but worth it

  • @avioncamper
    @avioncamper Před 11 měsíci

    Your gas engines got .75 mpg, you stated the diesel Cats got 1MPH? Not that much difference, also diesel cost more. Those huge Sea Rays are not fast boats like Fountain or Cigarette. Your engines sounded sweet. Greg from NC. Best wishes.

  • @Fleetwoodjohn
    @Fleetwoodjohn Před rokem

    Same boat same motors same lake. 800hrs. I see a little better speed at given rpm’s. When I calculated it years ago running downtown and back it I burned around the .7mpg mark.

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před rokem +1

      Yep, sounds about right. Thanks for watching.

    • @kdub5397
      @kdub5397 Před rokem

      Same boat same power. I also get a bit more speed at those rpm’s. I might also add I have had big groups of friends aboard for dinner cruises and the boat does not even notice the xtra weight.

  • @hildablanco1591
    @hildablanco1591 Před rokem

    Best diesel is a push rod diesel a catapiller is better and if its gas go for 460 ford big blocks for endurance

  • @shilosheena
    @shilosheena Před 11 měsíci

    Glad i bought 25 footer 5.0 merc single 1.72 litre fuel today going to windsor tomor boat detroit river prob not go bankrupt lol

  • @C5Katech
    @C5Katech Před 11 měsíci

    Nice vid, keep it up, but your counting is way off. I timed your 5 second count to plane, and it was about 10 seconds.

  • @CruisingCalypso
    @CruisingCalypso Před 2 měsíci +1

    You make some correct points in your video. I have a 400 Db with 3126 Cats. I have seen boats from 37 to 42 perform quite well with the 7.4 ltr motors. Plenty of power and torque for the boat. However you damaged your credibility when you made the quip about gas prices "thanks Biden" Im hope your smart enough to know that no president effects gas prices. Gas price is a function of demand and supply. There is plenty of oil flowing to make enough gas to keep the price low. Suppy is only only limited by oil producers who artificially limit availability to push prices up.

  • @debeeriz
    @debeeriz Před 2 lety

    l have never seen a diesel fueled boat explode, l have seen petrol boats explode how ever, with petrol inboards you nee to be very vigilant of leaks and fumes

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před 2 lety +1

      I keep the blowers on all the time.

    • @ronschwolsky1626
      @ronschwolsky1626 Před rokem

      @@gregbrigman543 All the time? BTW, great video. Thanks for posting!

  • @hildablanco1591
    @hildablanco1591 Před rokem

    Diesel gets 3 miles per gallon and gas gets 1 mile per gallon

  • @CapnCody1622
    @CapnCody1622 Před 4 měsíci

    Thanks, Biden, for bringing those gas prices down 😁

  • @LarryButler-kp3se
    @LarryButler-kp3se Před 10 měsíci

    There's a reason for diesel. Gas evaporates into explosive gas to blow the boat and your family to hell. If diesel leaks, you need a mop.

    • @gregbrigman543
      @gregbrigman543  Před 10 měsíci

      Yeah you're right Larry, happens all the time. That's why 90% of boats have gas engines.

    • @donb347
      @donb347 Před 10 měsíci

      WW 2 they had gasoline for small warships guarding convoys. Use good practice it works safety wise.

    • @Adam-en4zm
      @Adam-en4zm Před 8 měsíci

      And if you don't smell the gasoline before you start the engines, you probably were being negligent. I personally always go into the engine room and check both motors before cranking them. Oil, coolant, trans fluid, etc. And to open the seacocks. Doing all that I would notice a gas leak for sure. Then there are blowers to make double sure it's safe.

  • @donb347
    @donb347 Před 10 měsíci

    A lot of the poor reputation that gas motors got is from the days when fuel was cheap and gas motors were made as cheap as possible. Modern gas motors with fuel injection and other modern tech is much better.

  • @Naturalchorus
    @Naturalchorus Před 3 měsíci

    Wow, fuel is really cheap now! Thanks biden!

  • @portfoliofotoz
    @portfoliofotoz Před 2 lety +18

    The President of the United States has, at most, a negligible effect on fuel prices. Your gratuitous comment lessens your credibility.

    • @MrSalmonDaze
      @MrSalmonDaze Před rokem

      Don't be a dolt. The biden puppet closed pipelines under construction, added restrictions on new development, and has leveraged all federal bureaucracies to squeeze oil companies. Of course he has a direct impact on supply and thereby, price.

    • @brucemiller1696
      @brucemiller1696 Před rokem +13

      So what you are saying is that the day he got into office, he shut down the pipeline. That didnt raise the fuel price? 🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @portfoliofotoz
      @portfoliofotoz Před rokem +4

      @@brucemiller1696 Yes. Tell us, what did the "pipeline" have to do with the global price of petrol?

    • @brucemiller1696
      @brucemiller1696 Před rokem

      @@portfoliofotoz are you saying that there was NOTHING that biden did that raised the fuel cost in North America?

    • @portfoliofotoz
      @portfoliofotoz Před rokem +1

      @@brucemiller1696 I believe that in my original comment I used the term “negligible.” I stand by that.

  • @gerardweber9218
    @gerardweber9218 Před 6 měsíci

    Well that goes to show you that if you think Biden controls gas prices, your not someone anyone show taking advice from.

    • @marclawson3853
      @marclawson3853 Před 2 měsíci

      Yeah shutting down domestic drilling and production didn't effect gas prices. 😂