The Insane Complexity of the India/Bangladesh Border
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 04. 2021
- Watch the Nebula-exclusive bonus video to this one in my Modern Conflicts series on the Armenia-Azerbaijan War here: nebula.app/videos/real-life-l...
Please Subscribe: / @reallifelore
Select video clips courtesy of Getty Images
Hey y'all! Just letting you know that I created another almost 20 minute long video explaining how the complex borders/geography between Armenia and Azerbaijan led to war between them last year, but that video could never, ever be monetized on CZcams and because of that, CZcams would never even send most of you any notifications or alerts if I uploaded it. So instead, I uploaded it to Nebula and the link is here: nebula.app/videos/real-life-lore-modern-conflicts-the-2020-armeniaazerbaijan-war
The best way to get access to Nebula is through the CuriosityStream bundle deal linked above, and it's less than $15 a year. I'll be posting new videos in this Modern Warfare series every month on Nebula, so if that sounds like something you'd be interested in go ahead and check it out!! Thanks :)
Im from Bangladesh
cool, but did anyone ask
So you are saying all that matters in the end is money.
Ok
@@khandakerrashid2270 good for you
Imagine you're playing cricket or football with your friends in Bangladesh and your ball ends up in India
Edit: People don't get the joke. You are in one of of those exclaves. To get the ball you need to go to india,to go to india you need visa, to get a visa you need to go the the embassy and to get to the embassy you need to drive through india.
and rolls back into bangladesh
Time to cross international borders to get a ball!
@@TheZPTR Only they can say "I literally went to another country to get a ball back"
The Britishers left India leaving their shitty incorrect maps behind.
And it seems to have been done purposefully.😑
Because *India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal* all are given different maps.
And everyone believes theirs is perfect.
Foolish us☹️
@@rameenaayan3248 "I went through 5 international borders to get a ball"
The British in India honestly drawn the borders like a connect a dot kids book
People complained about straight lines though at least some effort went into this
@@Lorddonen it ok bro 🙃🙃
@@Lorddonen its fine ig
@@Lorddonen question is why to brits do that
Agreed
India and Bangladesh: “Can you distribute our borders evenly”
The Guy that never been to India: “Yes”
That was the british who asked😐
Neither India nor Bangladesh asked but the British did love ruining peoples' lives
@@sagarikasuresh Pakistan asked
@@mayazchowdhury7862 Pakistan asked
@@sagarikasuresh pakistan asked and get in mess lol
So my grandmother was born in British India 1935, grew up in East Pakistan (1947 to 1971) and now lives in Bangladesh (1971 to present day)..... To make it clear. She never actually left her village. She was always in the same place, just the country changed hands so much.
So hearing about that crazy border situation does'nt surprise me at all.
Damn
Dang
Talk about nationality, damn.
Dmm
Before 1947 - I am Indian
1947 - I am Pakistani
1971 - I am Bangladeshi
@@ritik1413 😂😂😂... Yep
My dad once said, "If there is something weird or odd in anything international it is 90% British fault, and 9% Belgium's, and rest is other European countries"
He did not mentioned France, who messed up Africa, Central America, Central Europe and the Middle East (at least).
And America
And Portugal who occupied Goa for 450 years as a part of 'metropolitan portugal' until Indian forces liberated its people.
And Spain that colonized my country🇨🇷
@@navyseal1689 and the caliphate
The enclave citizens being legally unable to leave has the same energy as that "need experience for job, but need job for experience" meme.
Catch 22
Or the: At least 5 years experience with 'something'
'Something': Came out 6 months ago
"Can't get a girl 'cause I don't have a job
Can't get a job 'cause I don't have a car
Can't get a car 'cause I don't have a job
So go find a girl with a job and a car!"
-Alice Cooper
Ok *...*
@@Anttianttiantti We need proof of 6 months experience Catching 21 first then we'll allow you to Catch 22.
RLL: The craziest border in the world
Me: Why?
RLL: Well the British….
You, me and the rest of the world: make sence
@@gabrielavillanueva3606 Meanwhile some random British dude told to draw a line on a map: …
It’s always the British
what about their stupid bengal ancestors?
@@TheOGDisco 🤣🤣🤣 pretty much just threw 2 darts at the local maps and drew the lines
As a Bengalee person living pretty close to the border in the Indian state of West Bengal, I can certify this mess is real. There are rivers or canals (sometimes even ponds) with two nations on two sides, villages halved, and previously there were some households with the border going literally through them. Thousands of people cross the border daily both legally and illegally to go to school, hospital, place of work, or to visit their relatives. Thanks to British, it makes no damn sense. People on either side of the border, living close to it, look nearly the same, speak nearly the same language (or atleast understand each other's dialects), have similar cultures, and of course, shared history.
Apni ki Jalpaiguri te thaken?
@@sauptiksaha4875 Tai mone hoi
Correction: thanks to India being too proud to swap enclaves if it meant giving up any territory overall, it makes no sense. If Britain had drawn a simpler border and told people to move if they wanted to stay part of "their people's" territory, today they'd be blamed for how they'd done that.
Those mf britishers made all mfing disputes
@PrezVeto "being too proud"?? india just didn't want to give up land that's rightfully theirs, would u like it if someone randomly came and took 400 dollars from ur money?
I finally can understand what our grandparents talked about when they said that they used to cross borders to go to school
Lmao😂
What are you talking about ? They didn’t just cross borders but also rivers, islands, hills, mountains, seas, oceans and planets
You forgot about the crocodiles and snakes in their way .
The southern US version I'm familiar with is along the lines of "in the snow, uphill both ways."
@@chewinggum5550 you forgot they have to cross a 3 light year river and got wet by an acidic rain
"Where Do you Live??"
"India🇮🇳🇮🇳"
"OH COOL!!!, Which Part??"
"The One which is in Bangladesh which is in India which is in Bangladesh"
🤣🤣🤣
Oh bhai!
🤣🤣🤣🤪
Is it in 4th dimension?
😂😂
Good job to both Bangladeshi and Indian government to resolve the issue peacefully.
The funny thing is the issue could have been solved way back but wasn't because of indian local politics
@@shakunimama936thanks the Congress
@@gamerz000. Yeha congress who gifted land to shrilanka unnecessarily while keeping Bangladeshi issue which allowed them to enter india almost like they were destined to ruin india
@@shakunimama936 well atleast it's fixed now
@@gamerz000. Anyways bro election is comming let enjoy drama for few days everyone knows who is going to win
I feels good that my country didn't chose violence and also thanks to India for that.
❤ from 🇧🇩
Your welcome from 🇮🇳
thanks to Bangladesh too
well Why would Bangladesh choose violence. India is the one who helped to liberate from Pakistan.
@@amitgond7950 true also we are not hooligans like China and other countries 🤣 also our military power is not so great compare to India so that would be so stupid on Bangladesh side to go into war for a simple thing lol
❤️ from 🇮🇳 as well :)
Me, a Bangladeshi: this is the *least* bizzare thing you’ll find in Subcontinent.
Indian subcontinent is full of surprises
@@rahulgm1685 It's beautiful too.
অামিও বাংলাদেশী।I am also Bangladeshi.Nice to meet you.
@@tausinahmed2666 glad to know
@@mushfiqurrahman1107 অাপনি কোন জেলায় থাকেন?
I can only imagine the stories that the parents of the children living in the enclaves cooked up for them in order to showcase how hard it was for them to go to school. "Son, did you know? I had to cross multiple international borders without a visa to just attend School."
@bouytt guyt 😞😞
That is true.
I believe that is actually the case with a small U.S enclave in Canada where the people have to go through Canada to get to school.
@bouytt guyt hahahahahah 😂🤣😂
lol as a Bangladeshi i can confirm thats a common stories for parents even besides the enclave people
As a Bangladeshi, i wanna say that i love indian people🇧🇩❤️
Same here ❤️
@@catination8443 d’you live in Kolkata? Since the retirement of the Ind-pak rail route, the Ind-Bangladesh route remains the only international rail route serving India. The maitree express runs this route.
love frm india
No we dont love Bangladeshi shit jihadi country🤮🤢🤮🤢
@@PJ-im3ss man, you must be miserable in your life,
“Britain decided to give India independence” no we had to fight for it. It wasn’t just given to all 3 countries.
Everytime there is a border problem
British: They'll remembering us only.
The vast majority of borders created by the British in the early 20th century stopped many existing conflicts and wars, including Pakistan and Bangladesh. The real cause of having borders in the first place was Islam, and Islamic religious violence.
@@tubester4567 Millions dying due to the partition of the British Raj: we'll just ignore that.
@@tubester4567 now you blaming Muslim world instead of british. Nice. Keep jocking.
There is no reason to blame British anymore.
India and Bangladesh have to sign new Border treaty without enclaves and exclaves.
Also Border treaty with Pakistan, China, Nepal, Bhutan, Myanmar,
Prakash Sawan the British didnt only cause a border crisis. That was one among the millions of other irreversible problems they forcefully rooted into not only the south subcontinent but many other countries in the global south
You will be even more surprised to know that there is a house in Bangladesh, whose bedroom is located in India and kitchen is located in Bangladesh😂
I live in Dhaka the capital city of Bangladesh and I heard this from my brother
Your name is interesting. How you got that inter-religion name?
@@dobronx5270 I have to ask my mom & Dad 😅
@@dobronx5270 it's not much common but muslims do keep names apart from arabic/persion ones
Muslims in kerala keep malayali names
In bengal they keep bangla-sanskrit related names
In Indonesia you'll find alot of Sanskrit(indigenous mythology) & their regional language related names
Cultural connection is important, people need to rethink about their roots. Our recent history is blurred by various wars and stuff. Need to see beyond that.
@@mohituddin5332 😂
So he is a bangladeshi when cooking and Indian when sleeping.
*The Bri'ish Empire, always fucking up everywhere they pass by*
If by fuck up you mean civilies then yes
@@DaDoM123 your ignorance must be blissful
@@DaDoM123 come on don't be ignorant. India started civilization way before you guys even started anything.
@@timelord2024 And yet we conquered India with far less of a population
@@DaDoM123 by lies, deception, manipulation and backstabbing people. If you're proud of that so be it. And not to mention looting from common people.
I'm proud to be a Bangladeshi 🇧🇩 I just love our Indian brothers and sisters. And this border issues are solved now. 🇧🇩🇮🇳
We Indians like Bangldeshis a lot but feels hurt when you guys prioritise Pakistan over us .
@@s9ka972 i think they hate pak as much as we do because the people who wanted to live in Pakistan were denied and given a new country Bangladesh
@@s9ka972 becoz of muslim religon they like pakistan
Love form India bro
@@hiteshpatel5823 naah those snakes forgot 1971 when their mothers and sisters were r@ped by their own army
when their brothers were killed publicly in front of everyone
what they just remember is that india is a hindu majority country and pakistan is a muslim majority country and they think india is a bully in south asia
Man: I wanna move out
Authorities: No, You need a visa for that
Man: Can I move out to get a visa?
Authorities: No, You need a visa for that
Man: How do I get a visa?
Authorities: You need to move out.
online
Underrated 😂🤣
India the " EMPEROR WITH NO CLOTHS" ... India should become part of Bangladesh. .. So, lives could be saved & people could be better off with good housing, healthy food & better infrastructure, world class health care system not to mention with free world class education for everyone.
INDIA-
SUPA' POWER: 2020.
SUPER BEGGAR: 2021.
DELHI: "R AP E CAPITAL" of the World became " DEATH" CAPITAL of the World.
@@akhanddbangladesh8274 No bruh
@@akhanddbangladesh8274 if India is a beggar than why it's the 4th largest GDP 🤣
I am from Bangladesh and every information given here is correct.
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇮🇳🇮🇳
I'm from bangladesh and I agree
🤗🙏🏻
Pakistan should follow Indian-Bangladesh diplomacy
Bangladesh is so op :)
@@computerscience2589 yeah hope so
This border was designed by a British named Cyril Radcliffe. (Everyone hates him) He took only three days to make it and he had never been to India before. So he did not know this part of the world. After making the map the British hurriedly left the country and civil war properly broke out. Lots of people had to leave their homeland and a lot more died in the war. In 1947.
it was 5 weeks 1st correct yourself
@@krish5860 he was given 5 week but he finished it in 3 days and went to vacation
@@techteaser9826 not correct he even demanded 2-3 years to draw perfectly
we lost lahore because of that guy 🥲
@@randomhooman3236 you can blame the British government Radcliffe himself stated it was insane to draw a border in 5weeks next was the fact he was given free reign by both Hindu and Muslim representatives the man himself actually wanted the process to be done properly not by himself obviously but none followed his advice and he didn't like Indian climate so if none wanted to cooperate he simply saw fit to draw as fast as he can
*British just before leaving India: "im gonna draw some wierd shit"
The British with math and science: It's big brain time
The British making borders: *I am smort*
Yo Kim Wassup 😅
H-h-hey! How a-are y-y-you 😅
hey, when will you reunite with south korea?
Not everyone gets to draw a line at the 38th parallel and call it good enough.
what happened to the nuke i ordered?
I have heard the word "Bangladesh" more in this video than in my 26-year life
American? 😂😉
Not surprised...People think us a part of india all the times :)
Not surprised at all, even though we're the 8th most populous country in the world and have over 100 million internet users (which is respectively the 8th most internet population) we're still overlooked on the web and irl.
Very much aware of Bangladesh but the amount of times it (and India as well) was said in this video in a short amount of time amazes me hahaha
@@con.doriano5008 ikr its like bangladesh never existed to americans
I got a headache looking at that map 3:50
I'm absolutely floored by your videos of various countries....I just love your content, please continue doing your good work!
"let me take you back 6 years, in 2015" that hit me hard
Yea ikr. Time flies 😭
bruh i felt that
Time go brrrrr
Time be like : GAS GAS GAS
Modi ruined everything
Okay so I'm from West Bengal and my school teacher (who grew up in those border areas) always made jokes about how he every morning takes his toothbrush and brushes his teeth while taking an international walk to and fro.
why all teachers tell same toothbrush story 😂 is he a Bengali teacher?
Must have been a pretty cool teacher
I'm from BD, I went to Tentulia border for a govt. project. Since the Indian fences are always inside 100 mtrs from starting of their own line, I stepped into Indian land and saw some BD boys were playing cricket there. Also the tribal people specially Garo, from both countries has unofficial free access to the both countries, they go to the local bazars and visit relatives without any issue, both BSF and BGB approve it. I have seen it with my own eyes in different districts like Tentulia, Mymensingh.
@@mirishtiaquddin1711 Yup it's there even in india Myanmar border also..
@@mirishtiaquddin1711 Good to know armies actually caring about people enough to not trouble them over some stupid border system and giving them the freedom they deserve. There's no bad blood on ground level.
British in other countries: Just draw a straight line border.
British in India: Nah, I have Parkinson's disease 😑
😂😂
Very underrated yet Most Informative Channel✨️🙌
"so, where do you live?"
"it's complicated"
its across india 3 times and in the 4th bangladesh we come across, thats inside india in bangladesh.
Then my address will be
4-Ty, Villa Apartment, XYZ village, India, Bangladesh, India, Bangladesh.
“It’s in India in Bangladesh in India in Bangladesh
The good thing is that India and Bangladesh don't use violence they get rid of these problem peacefully. 🇮🇳🤝🇧🇩
Yeah, our relationship is surprisingly peaceful politically.
Not like pak
Pak always chooses violence
Love from Bangladesh ❤️❤️
Yeah, Just because Bangladesh is a small and wise country, knows that it would be crushed if it goes to war against India.
While Pakistan is comparatively big and doesn't understand that and ofc unwise and practically dumb.
Very interesting. The graphics were really good and really helped me understand the commentary. Thanks.
Americans would never understand Asian landlines. It was easy for america to divide a new land among themselves. But Asia has a very complex and long history. So this dispute is understandable.
Man!
it was British shit not Americans.
@@explorer063 you didn't get my comment.
Praying for all our Indian neighbours in these tough times 🙏🏼 love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩❤️
Please pray to get rid of our dictator. Thank you.
❤️❤️❤️
Thnx
@@alex-sv8ru People voted for him. I know it's hard to digest but it is what it is. Cry more :)
@@alex-sv8ru just Google what a dictator is first, secondly after 70 years of Congress no one will EVER vote for Congress again. If modi was a dictator, you wouldn't be able to comment and Muslims would be diminishing in India but they are growing more than ever for a reason...please educate yourself instead of just wanting to always see liberal
Jokes aside, I gotta respect this man for choosing both quality and quantity when it comes to uploads.
Having a team of editors will help that
@@joshuac837 yeah
im gonna be famous
you havent even watched the full video
The Britishers left India leaving their shitty incorrect maps behind.
And it seems to have been done purposefully.😑
Because *India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal* all are given different maps.
And everyone believes theirs is perfect.
Foolish us☹️
Thank you for making this video! I've always been curious about the India/Bangladesh border but I had no idea about these counter enclave situations!
Btw did you make a video about China's awkward eastern arm that slices through North Korea and Russia? If you have, I am curious on what your take is! If you haven't, I suggest looking up Fangchuan village in Hunchun, Jilin. It's a Korean part of China if that makes sense
Why did you stop making videos?
Wow, great video and the pictures really make everything easy to understand. Can you also maybe do a video about the disputed durand line?
Hi to my Bangladeshi brothers from an Indian Bangali.
Jai hind 🇮🇳
Joi bangla 🇧🇩
@@stephandihead4516 bangladesh literally started a war against pakistan for independence we are basically still enemies with pakistan. We are taught everywhere that bangladesh hates pakistan. BUT SURE I MUST LIKE PAKISTAN BECAUSE OF RELIGION. Ignorant.
@@stephandihead4516 both countries suck. Bangladesh politically is a mess. India politically is also a mess. Both countries are highly corrupt.
@@wh2960 India is the largest democracy in the world. She is the only country that provides a true and free opportunity to her people to speak against the government whenever they wish. Whereas you will be prosecuted in other countries if you do so.
@@stephandihead4516 bro we Bangladeshis don't hate Indians. We hate Indian politicians. But that's not our fault as we also hate our own politicians. 😅 Most of them are corrupt
@@wh2960 bro same thing with Pakistan too
Britain did the literal geopolitical equivalent of farting in an elevator as they were stepping off the elevator
Britain, India, Bangladesh: in an elevator
I/Ba: needs to go to floor 19
Britain: needs to go to floor 6
Britain: farts enclaves everywhere
I/Ba: FTW?
"Bengal sultanate" or modern day Bangladesh produced 52% of Mughal Empire GDP & 33% of Worlds GDP. Bengal or modern day Bangladesh was first to fall to The East India Company at the Battle of Palashy/Plassey. .. that's why British East India Company HQ was located in Calcutta in undivided Bengal. ..Narayanganj Distric just 10km south to Dhaka in present day Bangladesh was the hub for the British trade & used to call "Dundee of the East". .. Since Bangladesh has the most fertile soil in the World British East India company cultivated opium in a district call "Nilphaamari" in present day Bangladesh 200+km north to Dhaka & delivered to China which was the sole reason for Opium wars.
The Bengal Presidency or modern day Bangladesh at the height of its territorial jurisdiction, it covered large parts of what is now South Asia and Southeast Asia ( From Afghanistan to the west to Singapore to the East). Bengal was the economic, cultural and educational hub of the British Raj .. Historically, Bengal or Bangladesh has been the industrial leader of the subcontinent & produced 52% of the Mughal Empire GDP & 33% of the world GDP during British Raj & & fueled the First Industrial Revolution in Europe & America in the period from about 1760 to sometime between 1820 and 1840 particularly with the proto-industrialized Mughal Bengal ( modern day Bangladesh), through the activities of the East India Company. ... Bengal or Bangladesh produced Tea, Jute, Opium (( Opium was produced in a district call 'Nilphaamari' in Bangladesh which was supplied to China by The East India Company & the sole reason behind The Opium Wars.))
The region is one of the largest rice producing areas in the world, Bangladesh being the world's 3rd largest rice producer & West Bengal being India's largest rice producer. Other key crops include jute, tea, sugarcane,wheat,etc. There are significant reserves of URANIUM, limestone, natural gas and coal in the districts of Sylhet, Meghalaya & Assam in Bangladesh. Major industries include textiles, leather goods, pharmaceuticals, shipbuilding, banking and information and communication technology.
When Bengal was reorganized, Penang, Singapore and Malacca were separated into the Straits Settlements in 1867. British Burma became a province of British Raj. Western areas, including the Ceded and Conquered Provinces and The Punjab, were further reorganized. Northeastern areas became Colonial Assam. The Partition of British India in 1947 resulted in Bengal's division on religious grounds.
@@Lorddonen We're not sorry, stop being so self hating
@@silliestsususagest3276 stfu loser
@@akhanddbangladesh8274 ok
3:06 I see an amogus in the red square on the left
THANKS FOR SYMPLIFYING .......love from BANGLADESH
RealLifeLore uploads a video on Bangladesh and India
Me as a Bangladeshi: it's my time to shine
Me as a Indian: it’s my time to shine
British : it's my time to sh... Nevermind
@@sharthok Don’t, just don’t
সব ঠিক আছে তো?
Me as an Indian Bengali : it’s my time to SHINE AND SPARKLE
Actually your work is very valuable to let the world understand more the situation around the world. I have never known this before and learn great deal. Thank you for your great work.
The town of Baarle-Nassau on the boder of Belgium and the Netherlands has a similar ridiculous pattern of encvlaves within enclaves.
On a subnational level, the border between the German states of Hessen and Baden-Wuerrtemberg above the town of Laudenbach has another pattern that makes no sense on a map, but actually follows logical landmarks on the ground.
Map Men did an episode on this! Also I'm glad this got solved. I lived not too far away from this border situation, it was a nightmare. Half the people living in these enclaves didn't even know if they were Indian or Bangladeshi. Anyways, I hope for great Indo-Bangladesh relations! Peace 🇮🇳🇧🇩
Indo
@@agustiaraelakh3623 What else would you call it?
@@AidenR19 when i saw indo-bangladesh, the word indo is more well known for indonesia 😂
@@agustiaraelakh3623 indo means India
@@agustiaraelakh3623 Indonesia itself means "Indian islands" derived from the Greek words Indos (meaning Indian) and Nesos (meaning islands).
Respect to the poor guy at google for having to accurately put the borders onto google maps and earth (and also sam's editors)
Sam who?
@@manswind3417 oops wrong person XD
@@theEWDSDS Lol did you assume him to be Wendover?
@@manswind3417 yeah I think I had just watched his 'how the election works' video
So proud of India and Bangladesh for solving the crisis through diplomacy rather than violence.
Thank you very much for this video. I am a Bangladeshi but my head used to spin a lot whenever I tried to understand about the enclave issues back in my social science and geography classes at my school 😂
Whatever it is, we won't fight or war between us. Bangladesh is a good neighbors county and India is our friend . We prefer peace, not a war. 🌱
Wish Pakistan was like this
@@mohammednajad8675 DANG 🤣
Actually India need war , Not Pakistan., why India always try to interfere in Neighboring Countries.
The biggest problem is Hitler Modi.
What India is doing with Kashmiri Muslims, Pakistan can’t tolerate it.
Kashmir will be free from India.
@@khurramawan4559 yea ik modi is trash but why does Pakistan keep bombing kashmir and scaring and killing the people in kashmir and trying to capture kashmir
@@khurramawan4559 Here comes the as usual triggered Pakistani with his rant.
The Map Men said it best:
*"Like a Tic-Tac inside a Polo inside a bagel inside Bangladesh"*
@Avery the Cuban-American hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
Haha I remember.
I am an Indian till this video I can't see any video on border issue this much clarity and nuance way, I deeply appreciate your efforts❤
I like your youtube videos beacause they are really informing and free. Nebula thing contradics the idea. If I wanted to pay I would go to the library or search for th information myself. As a student my financial capacities are limited so. Sorry I could not support you in an other way. Good luck and keep the good work!
Even as a Bangladeshi, this is absolutely bizarre to me....
I didn't knew the full story untill now. Just knew that this was there and it was gone then
@@nabibbs7937 This was created by Brits . We Indians are ready to give Indian enclaves inside Bangladesh to Bangladesh & if Bangladesh is ready to give us their enclave inside us , we ll accept ( only if they are ready ) . These type of non sense are created by Brits purposefully to damage our South Asian peace .
@@s9ka972 we already exchanged enclaves
@@s9ka972 bruv, is it 2014 at your place?
I'm a Bangladeshi. This was never a serious or complex matter for this two countries. The people living there had no citizenship of neither Bangladesh nor India. But there was no violence, people were living peacefully. Luckily it got solved in 2015 and the land area of Bangladesh grew also the population as most of the people wanted to be citizens of modern Bangladesh.
Hey weird question, but did u guys feel like India was being kind and did smthing to benefit the pple, or was it all just political behind the scenes, just ur opinion would be nice thx
@@flowerisim I don't know about their feelings. In our Bangla language there is a term which means 'People with no citizenship or land' So we used to call them that. They were not citizens of Bangladesh, so the government never worried about them neither the Indian government. They had no legal rights in either of this two countries.
@@shovonshovon9003 oh wow that's tough
@@trollrat2828 Actually they only had those enclaves in papers only. Nobody sent any force to claim the lands. It was like no mans land. I am happy for those people that they got citizenship, an identity in the world.
@@flowerisim there are people, who live near Myanmar border with India and they got citizenship of both countries even tho, India has no dual citizenship policy.
My Brain hurts after hearing “Bangladesh” and “India” like 99999999999999999 times
I have visited the last enclave and that was really awesome to see India and Bangladesh sharing the weirdly complex ground, it's just a tiny road that separates both countries. At the center there are millitary gurdian, you can go visit the place as a tourist but the best thing is if you just crossed the 20 ft road you will end up on different country.
“The borders were decided with chess matches between two kings”
Norway: *it’s showtime*
*Magnus Carlsen enters the room
Russia have most gms
@@teal1787 Norway has the best in the world yet
@@aman_singh__ yes
India invented chess...
Love and respect to all Indians 💖
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Respect from India 😘
Please stop
Love❤ from India🇮🇳 to Bangladesh🇧🇩
@@LoveBD153 ok..
Love from India to Bangladesh 🇮🇳❤️🇧🇩
❤️
My dad was born in what is now Pakistan in 1944 and is a refuge. I remember learning some of this, never to this extent though. Thanks for the video.
The photo that you showed while saying Indian government at 6:56 is Vidhan soudha [house of government of Karnataka]. Karnataka is a state in India..
My god, this video must haven taken MONTHS to make, props to RLL for the research, script and editing!
They probably copied from two other similar videos made by map men and geography now
well prob the animation
He literally showed paintings of Sikhs instead of Mughals. He literally couldnt fact check his images showing he literally got them off of one simple Google search. Not High quality at all 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
Bruh this video contains only simple basic information about the situation which are easily available. As far as the script and research is concerned, anyone could do it easily.
1:29 A piece of India, which is in Bangladesh, which is in India, which is in Bangladesh, which is insane
Map men
The fact that there's no fight between India & Bangladesh regarding the border.just proves how close these nations bonding is !! 🇮🇳❤️🇧🇩
I think india should invade bangladesh
@@koto7858 Do they have enough might to do that?! 🤔
@Ankur Kumar how?! Tell me 🤔. How much army can you mobilize in eastern border? Will you bring all the arsenal from pak-india, china-india border?! And one more thing its not sikkim or hydrabad.
@@arifshahariar4519 why war we are brothers a lot Bangladeshis are here in my state Kerala ❤️
@@arifshahariar4519 why not we have 12 lakh troops . Marcos , rastriya rifle would be enough and who need men who you have brahmos
Im from bangladesh and i watch ur vids as soon as i saw this in my recmndation i clicked ferrari fast
Now this is going to be complex.
Definitely
Yes
ᵐʰᵐᵐ
The problem has been already solved
This problem has been solved in 2015
Britain: I just do whatever, i gave u independent, ur business now
@Mysterious lol
@Mysterious They got lucky with the gun powder and steam engine
Nothing personal kid, but Imma want that land
Our ancestors did, please don’t hold average Brits responsible for the sins of our fathers :(
@Mysterious they took it personel with India
Banglafesh & Indian Superb Politicians now resolve this Critical Border land Problem.
Hundreds of Thousands people now getting proper Education & Medical from This two friendly Contry.
Long live Bangladesh India Friendship.
Joy Bangla...
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Imagine solving it with pakistan 🇵🇰
1:04
That's a fractal
"To leave, they'd need a visa . . . Which they'd need to get from an embassy . . . Which are all in their countries mainland . . . Which they'd need to leave to get to . . . Which they'd need a visa for . . . "
*Franz Kafka likes this 👍*
@@praj1636 ?
An infinite loop
@@praj1636 thanks sir
@@praj1636 his literature is insane. everyone should try reading metamorphosis at least once and get their minds bamboozled.
Britisher making map: I'm gonna close my eyes and draw blindly.
This reminds me of the exact same situation between Holland and Belgium. There are pieces of Belgium inside pieces of Holland, which are inside of Belgium. That is what is called Baarle-Nassau (Dutch Baarle, belonging to the Nassau family, the royal family of Holland) and Baarle-Hertog (Belgian Baarle, belonging to the Duke of Brabant - Hertog is the Dutch word for Duke.)
Ok. I am from Coochbehar and i knew the complexity of this place but your video get me more about it. My grand parents came from bangladesh to india. We loss land and everything that my family had.
Despite this, there is no dispute over land between india and bangladesh
that is called true friendship 🇮🇳❤🇧🇩
Other countries fight
@@xilon7970 North Korea vs the whole fucking world
But Bangladeshis are illegally entering india and causing to increase more population
@@smoothaf5160 bro you will find bad people and criminals in every country and those people are danger for both nations so both countries have to be together to solve this problem
@@ikpb1652 wdym To be together
Take a shot every time he says “India” or “Bangladesh” sounds like that happens a lot.
came here to comment exactly the same thing :D
no do it every time he says enclave
"Bengal sultanate" or modern day Bangladesh produced 52% of Mughal Empire GDP & 33% of Worlds GDP. Bengal or modern day Bangladesh was first to fall to The East India Company at the Battle of Palashy/Plassey. .. that's why British East India Company HQ was located in Calcutta in undivided Bengal. ..Narayanganj Distric just 10km south to Dhaka in present day Bangladesh was the hub for the British trade & used to call "Dundee of the East". .. Since Bangladesh has the most fertile soil in the World British East India company cultivated opium in a district call "Nilphaamari" in present day Bangladesh 200+km north to Dhaka & delivered to China which was the sole reason for Opium wars.
The Bengal Presidency or modern day Bangladesh at the height of its territorial jurisdiction, it covered large parts of what is now South Asia and Southeast Asia ( From Afghanistan to the west to Singapore to the East). Bengal was the economic, cultural and educational hub of the British Raj .. Historically, Bengal or Bangladesh has been the industrial leader of the subcontinent & produced 52% of the Mughal Empire GDP & 33% of the world GDP during British Raj & & fueled the First Industrial Revolution in Europe & America in the period from about 1760 to sometime between 1820 and 1840 particularly with the proto-industrialized Mughal Bengal ( modern day Bangladesh), through the activities of the East India Company. ... Bengal or Bangladesh produced Tea, Jute, Opium (( Opium was produced in a district call 'Nilphaamari' in Bangladesh which was supplied to China by The East India Company & the sole reason behind The Opium Wars.))
The region is one of the largest rice producing areas in the world, Bangladesh being the world's 3rd largest rice producer & West Bengal being India's largest rice producer. Other key crops include jute, tea, sugarcane,wheat,etc. There are significant reserves of URANIUM, limestone, natural gas and coal in the districts of Sylhet, Meghalaya & Assam in Bangladesh. Major industries include textiles, leather goods, pharmaceuticals, shipbuilding, banking and information and communication technology.
When Bengal was reorganized, Penang, Singapore and Malacca were separated into the Straits Settlements in 1867. British Burma became a province of British Raj. Western areas, including the Ceded and Conquered Provinces and The Punjab, were further reorganized. Northeastern areas became Colonial Assam. The Partition of British India in 1947 resulted in Bengal's division on religious grounds.
@@akhanddbangladesh8274 Wikipedia is alive and it's making CZcams comments!
@@akhanddbangladesh8274 I think the Bengal sultanate first messed up by introducing Islam to Bengal and the British add more problems on top of it
One of these enclaves reamain near my home.I watch your every video from Bangladesh
Excellent video
Love to brothers and sisters in Bangladesh inside India inside Bangladesh which is inside India and located in Bangladesh. Thats inception happening in border.
My brain hurts 🤣🤣
Indians and Bangladeshi: “This is madness!”
British: “Madness...THIS IS YOUR BORDER!”
*proceeds to spartan kick them through each country three times in quick succession*
Stay well out there everybody, and God bless you friends 😄
If you did not separate greater India into a Hindu Muslim, then we are making useless rubbish here?
@Himallo Grey I apologize for any inaccuracies there. Truth be told, I know very very little about this issue. I just thought it sounded like a funny joke.
@Himallo Grey
Can't expect that from the Mughals of 1850 vintage (not even from the Brits then).
@@Numba003
Yeah. A practical joke on a few million people.
@@MrPoornakumar I apologize if the joke was offensive. I meant no offense.
Tnx man...I didnt know this kind of border thing when i live in Bangladesh ..
The british basically handed a toddler a sharpie and told him to draw russian nested doll and called it a day.
"This is the most complicated border that has ever existed in history"
HRE: Hold my beer.
What is HRE?
@@rogaineablar5608 yeah, I thought it was netherlands and belgium border for a second.
@@rogaineablar5608 Holy Roman Empire
Holy Roman Empire is complicaded
😆😆
Good to see my own motherland of Bangladesh in your video. Love from Bangladesh.🌹🌹❤️ Thank you for the appreciation for the diplomatic relationship between Bangladesh and India.🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩💐💐❤️🌹
Fardin Al-Nabi
Well said, Bro.
Dalal jokon border manus horta kora bangladesh k soto kora ai apna der jornoi
Lots of Love ❤ from India
I am happy seeing your development .
But don't know why many Bangladeshi hate INDIA 😕
I don't know why , But I will definitely say that No one couldn't do what India did for bangladesh in 1971 .
I am from ODISHA and we easily understand your bengali language.
Love from ODISHA
JAY JAGANNATH ❤🙏❤
ଜୟ ଜଗନ୍ନାଥ ❤🙏❤
@@abhijitparida5093 becoz they hate kaafirs
@@md.shahin6180 bitter truth bhai 😞
Actually before bangladesh india took over west pakistan and named it east Bengal. Then named another contry West Bengal in the east because it was west to east Bengal. Then east Bengal turned into bangladesh and India has still not changed West Bengal's name.
*So my grandmother was born in British India in 1935, raised in East Pakistan from 1947 to 1971, and now resides in Bangladesh (1971 to present day)..... To be specific. She never even left her village. She was always in the same area; it was simply that the country changed hands so frequently.*
As a Bangladeshi, this is the first time I've ever heard something like this
Same
same
It's normal for someone to not know if he/she is young because this situation is solved now
Same as an indian
@@skrpis550 because we never learn this in school
I appreciate and respect you chosing to work with Curiosity Stream and Nebula as sponsors instead of schilling for Raid type games like so many others. Thank you for the great content too! 🍻
Hey @RealLifeLore, or anyone lol. Could you say where you find your music? There are many songs that would be good fun to study to. Thank you!
Sir you are Excellent..i got lots of knowledge
''It's very simple to understand''
**me who failed algebra:**
🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Me, who doesn't speak english as my first language 😭😂😂
Me who still can't figure out the difference between ex and en
@@trollrat2828 r/wooosh
As an Indian,we like Bangladesh..it's the opposite side border we have problems with.
Lol but majority of the Bangladeshis hate India tho.
@@xuserakx thats not true. most of us bangladeshis can speak their language and even watch indians shows or movies more than our own ones. we also eat food that are similar to indian food such as rice, paratha, dal, bhaji etc. the only differences between us and them are language and religion.
@zebja. Yea well I live in the UK.
@zebja. Bangladesh was not created for Muslims and it is secular. East Pakistan was created for Muslims but Bangladesh is not "East Pakistan" anymore.
@zebja. The official name of Bangladesh is "The people's Republic of Bangladesh".
The building in 6:50 is in Bangalore which is way far from Bangladesh
Bruh that's the supreme court of Bangladesh. I literally went there a lot of times.
@@yourdad602 6:58 he means this one lol.
Me as a Brit hearing about a border issue anywhere in the world: ‘it’s gonna be us isn’t it? It’s us, I just know it’
You: two local kings were responsible.
Me: hey, look at that. I was wrong.
You: but, then the British got involved.
Me: FFS.
Lmao
😂😂😂
Aww man,now i am feeling bad about the new brits
Sorry mate u always have to hear those for ur ancestors who aren't even alive😂😂😂
Sykes-Picot: "Could we have made a more complicated border?"
India-Bangladesh: "Hold my beer"
Hold my cows
it's those British colonizers that made it complicated
Britishers drew the border, not Indians or Bangladeshis
Hold my trashes 😋
@@high1719 hold my bat
Praying for India from Bangladesh. 🇧🇩🇮🇳
🇮🇳❤🇧🇩
Dalal Rajaker
Dipuet on there no war in India and Bangladesh ❤️
🇮🇳 🇧🇩
From West Bengal 💚🇵🇰🇧🇩🇵🇰 💯
British didn't decided to give independence to India. We took independence from them.
"Freedom is not given, It is taken"
It was all thanks to Germany and Japan who weaken Britsh and british Didn't had the power to rule India anymore
If there was no WW2 There Won't be any independence for India, Pakistan or Bangladesh
Your leaders Didn't do anything.
@@hewas_chewasky lmao I thought british were afraid of mutiny inside british indian army
Rise of azad hind
And violence inside india during ww2
@@hewas_chewasky wow u ppl managed to win bcoz of indian troops now u using ur enemies involvement in our independence
@@cabpenguin. Yeah because that's a Fact
Have you done the Minnesota Angle? (USA / Canada) That's a weird one. Really curious about your take on that