What If the Jedi Never Blamed Ahsoka for the Temple Bombing
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 10. 2023
- Ahsoka's accusation at the hands of the Jedi Council was another massive failure to uphold order in the republic. What if they didn't blame here for the bombing? Would Ahsoka still be at odds with the Council and the Order? Would she be able to find peace? How would the Clone Wars end differently?
Support the Channel: / ppsw
PODCAST: open.spotify.com/show/4T2dHne...
Twitch Account: / pentepatrol
Community Discord: / discord
THUMBNAIL BY: RenderDriver: renderdriver?ig...
Support My Other Channels!
Support This Video's Musicians!
The Way of Water - • 🎥 Epic & Trailer (Free...
In Search of Solitude - • 🌳 Classical & Cinemati...
Permafrost - • 💭 Meditation (Free Mus...
Fire & Thunder - • ⚡ Free Epic Music (No ...
Unexplored Moon - • 🌙 Copyright Free Orche...
Eight Mountains - • Eight Mountains by Savfk
The Epic Hero - • 💪 Orchestral Trailer P...
Dunes - • ⏳ Soundtrack (Free Mus...
Refusing the Ultimatum - • 😟 Tense & Orchestral (...
Passage of Time - • ⏱️ Cinematic & Backgro...
Love - • ❤️🔥 Romantic & Piano ...
What Happens When We Die - • Sad Soundtrack (Free M...
The Preparation - • 🔭 Soundtrack (Free Mus...
Eglair - • 🚤 Epic & Cinematic (Fr...
Instructions for Living Life - • 🎹 Piano Instrumental (...
Terminus - • 🎖️ Free Epic Heroic Mu...
Still A Long Way To Go - • 📽️ Free Film Orchestra...
Magic - • 🍬 Free Classical Fanta...
Long Way to Go - • ⛓️ Sad & Beautiful Orc...
Age of Wonder - • 🌁 Cinematic & Epic (Fr...
#StarWars #starwarswhatif #ahsoka #anakinskywalker #clonewars #ppsw #skywalker #ahsoka - Zábava
What if Anakin was born a Chiss? Being born so far outside the reach of the Jedi and Sith, would be interesting.
That would be good
Yes
Broooo thrawn's intelligence + the chosen one midichlorians. Unmatched
@PentePatrolStarWars PLEASE DO THIS!
Wouldn’t that be super similar to what if Anakin never left Tatooine? I mean I am sure there could be a story but it’s too similar to that what if.
What if Anakin "got" the Vader suit during the clone wars.
I mean there's potential to get this done in many ways: Dooku deciding "you know what screw Anikin" (lightning damage instead of fire), another happy landing, getting caught in an explosion on the battlefield. Or just sustaining injury after injury battle after battle. Slowly becoming more machin than man.
So basically he gets greivoused?
So like Wilhelm from borderlands pre sequel
@@sokkaoncactusjuice9474 pretty much
@@sokkaoncactusjuice9474 He's no match for my four lightsabers
@@lancelot365ethat, wow dude.
Ya know that was something that was a major plot hole. How the hell did Barriss sneak into a highly secure military prison, Force Choke Letta and then escape without anyone seeing her?
If somebody has a plausible explanation, I'd love to hear it
Oh! Oh! I have a plausible explanation! It's because, Barriss Offie is a Jedi!
@@wayward5219Oh my word. Why didn't I think of that one?! You're a hero!
It has been suggested that the three clones she killed in the corridor was manipulated through the force to give her access. She then killed the witnesses and Fox fired in anger at Ashoka.
@@erikthomsen4768All this time I just assumed she was in the vents or something.
@@kennethsatria6607almost as if *Gasps* she WAS, and these people are straight *Yapping*
What If the Jedi Temple Bombing never occurred?
What If Ahsoka, Barriss and Ventress joined forces in The Clone Wars?
What If Bastila Shan trained Anakin SkyWalker?
What If Satele Shan trained Luke SkyWalker?
Great story idea's.
yo
Barriss and Ahsoka get to talking about the failings of the Jedi and the hypocrisy of the clone wars. Barriss is tempted to do something crazy, but Ahsoka convinces her that they should just quit the order instead. They team up with Ventress and become an unstoppable team of force wielding vigilante bounty hunters.
I never got how Ahsoka could be blamed for this. I could see her getting blamed for Force choking Letta, but she was off world defending Cato Neimodia when the temple bombing went down.
@@wanck I think they saw it as Asoka orcistrated it, Letta acutally did it, and Ahsoka killed Letta to not let her expose herself
For the record, when an officer of the law, IE fox, has someone in their custody who is not under arrest but also "not not " under arrest, that is called being detained. It essentially means just as you described; they must stay in the general facility of the officer until the investigation is complete.
What if Grevious’ attack on dathomir failed
What if Anakin remained a Padawan in the clone wars
What if dooku founded his own “Jedi” order
What if Asajj Ventress and savage opress killed dooku
I love this story, not only because it is incredibly written, but because it's an amazing example of how to write a story rather than a concept.
most what if videos just say "this happens instead of this" whereas here, a reason is given, Ahsoka decided to catch the perpetrator rather than assist the woman, which was the catalyst, which compared to other people's stories in which she just inst charged, like they give me reason, she just isn't.
What if instead of just leaving the order ahsoka demanded an apology from mace windu determining whether she stay or leave
Only found this channel like a week ago and I am addicted. Also got an idea for ya.
What if the Jedi Order survived Order 66, but fled into hiding to make Sidious think they were all destroyed? Would be pretty interesting to see an Empire where Jedi move between the shadows, doing good everywhere they can. Maybe even hiding themselves from the Rebellion, as well, just to make sure they stay safe until they can come back.
What if the Empire won the Battle of Endor, but the Duel on DS2 still ended like it did in our timeline?
Like vader and sidious still dead?
@@supervegito2277nope because "somehow papa Palpatine lived"
@@supervegito2277 Like Vader redeemed, Sidious dead. The moment they exit the room things go differently because of the simple fact that troopers and staff weren't running to save their lives.
@@idiocrat3744 this sounds good
Ooh that’s an interesting premise… like how would the Empire be run? If it’s legends, Thrawn would probably make a play for the Emperor-ship but in canon he’s hanging with Da Nightsisters on Planet Mortis Gods-Turtle Snail People
She shouldn't have been blamed in the first place. Ahsoka was off world at the time of the bombing. The fact that the council were like oh well we found her with the same bombs used at the bombing makes her the numero uno suspect. The logic in the council is dumbfounded to me
Well the argument of her being the one who planned it or somhow assisting could be argued.
Just as well they were all slaughtered.
This is like literally the best outcome if Ahsoka never was accused for something she wasn’t even near. I mean couldn’t the council figure out that Ahsoka was literally on another planet for how long, when the bombing happened? I mean use your brains, omg.
What if 3 Knights + 3 Masters + 3 Masters with Padawan + 3 Grandmasters = Jedi Counsel?
What if Quentin Trembley filled the high council with younglings?
what if anakin told mace about what happened on tatooine and mace decided to help him
This plz I want a what if with windu being a better Jedi and person
What if the clones inhibitor chips all malfunctioned half way through the war and all clones attacked the Jedi generals
bruh
What if Anakin became a way seeker Jedi after being knighted? I think it would lead to him doing what he wanted to do as a child freeing the slaves of the galaxy. I believe it was the will of the force to make Ahsoka, Anakins apprentice so she would join him.
I like how Grievous not knowing about Palpatine led to his death.
What if Tarkin died at the Citadel?
I’m imagining hooty saying this which just makes this funnier
Ahhh yes the good ending
our position is correct, but yes Alderaan
2:24 I love how every time he brings up Ashoka’s situation he always makes it very clear that she was and also was not being arrested.
Love how you changed the war in this one. I hope to see more of these type of twists in the future. Lol
Nobody:
The trade federation and techno union in this timeline: “f*ck this shiiiiiiiiiit!”
Especially the trade federation after Anakin destroys their spaceship for the second time in the same manner like when he destroyed it in Phantom Menace 😂😂😂
What if anakin had a father and was still the chosen one
What if anakin was not a slave
Palpatine dying because Grevious grabbed him by the neck and too hard is honestly hilarious. Not bad, but funny.
I giggled so loudly when Palpatine died so unceremoniously
What if the Rebels targeted the imperial mining operations on Illum after reviewing the death star plans ?
What if Anakin was elected Supreme Chancellor?
What if Count Dooku was biologically related to Anakin through Shmi?
What if Tarkin was framed for the temple bombing?
what if Tarkin died in the temple bombing?
WHAT IF SHMI raised Luke & Leia? (plus she lives yay)
What if grevious survived and joined the rebellion after discovering the betrayal of sidiouse
I have a couple of suggestions, what if Darth Marr's force ghost trained Anakin. what if Anakin made a cured hilt lightsaber (for some reason i feel like yoda or windu would be uneasy due to what happend to the last person with a curved hilt). You could also do a joke video of what if darth jarjar trained Anakin.
"Now this is Podracing!" -A boy from Tatooine, Probably XD XD XD
I love this moment as it echos the first time he destoryed a lucker hulk.
What if hondo never tried to hold the Jedi hostage and the trade for dooku fully went through
This one is good, Palpatine would probably kill him in transit, or save him with a CIS fleet
@@eyelesstexas6318 yeah palps would’ve definitely either killed him or got him out then punish him later for being a dumbass
What if the Nightsisters killed Grievous and Dooku during the attack on Dathomir?
I loved how delightfully positive this story went. And what happened at the end.
27:21 it did just occur to me that anakin would have completed ashokas training in only 3 years (assuming she was still a youngling untill 14 somehow)
What if the Clone Wars reached earth during WW2?
AKA what if Anakin and Ashoka's plot armor was extra thick.
Thicc
how could you spell Ahsoka's name wrong?
I like how some ideas that sound like a trivial difference can have very different outcomes.
What if Sheev found a way to Clone Yoda and train him to be his ultimate apprentice, tool, pawn, weapon, second in command and so on in Yodas physical prime and full potential?
but the clone wouldn't have as many midichlorians
Damn papa palpatine really died in a 'Crushing' way 🤣🤣
What if the Mandalorians conquered the galaxy prior to the prequel era.
They almost did Mandalore the pervserer said the sith empire would be able to fully challenge the the Mandalore republic empire fully. This was something tbe sith did not want to happen. But I imagine the republic would be more militarized while the jedi be very divided some would be angry they didn't save rhe republic others would feel if they dod it help the sith.
@@eidoneverchoosen1171 ok
What if ahsoks tano become a vampire
My favorite one you’ve ever done. Thank
You.
One of your best "What ifs" yet! Keep up the great work!
Please do what if grievous lost on darthomir to ventress
Nuh no you didn't know that you are wrong just now I mean there's potential to get this done in many ways: Dooku deciding "You know what screw Anikin" (lightning damage instead of fire), another happy landing, getting caught in an explosion on the battlefield. Or just sustaining injury after injury battle after battle. Slowly becoming more machine than man. My favorite one you’ve ever done. Thank You. What if the Nightsisters killed Grievous and Dooku during the attack on Dathomir? I have a couple of suggestions, what if Darth Marr's force ghost-trained Anakin. what if Anakin made a cured hilt lightsaber (for some reason I feel like Yoda or Windu would be uneasy due to what happened to the last person with a curved hilt). You could also do a joke video of what if Darth Jar Jar trained Anakin. I love your channel keep up the great stuff if Grevious survived and joined the rebellion after discovering the betrayal of Sidiouse I love this channel so much more accessible fanfiction. I appreciate the work you put into the videos. That was a really good one. And a wholesome story about my favorite character.
What if the clone army becomes vampires and finds mates I saw your next video of Venom and Anakin I was like didn't this man say he doesn't do cross overs, but here's my idea what if Noble 6 and Noble 2 survived the events of reach And escaped into hyperspace and ended up in the clone wars Oh wow, this was so good What if the Mandalorians conquered the galaxy before the prequel era. What if Shimi became a forced ghost? What if Ventress survived the Clone Wars. there are so many comments saying ‘what if’ and I get that’s his channel but the theory is amazing and there aren’t enough compliments on it imo (: DAY:38 Here are some what-ifs. 1. What if the Rebel Alliance was crushed on Hoth? 2. What if the Trade Federation peacefully resolved the Naboo crisis? 3. What if Qui-Gon Jinn had trained Darth Maul as a Jedi? 4. What if the Yuuzhan Vong invaded during the time of the empire? 5. What if Leia became a Jedi Master in the sequel trilogy? and finally 6. What if the Jedi and Sith coexisted peacefully? PLEASE DO ONE OF THESE THEY ARE SO INTERESTING🙏🙏🙏 an extra one: what if Yoda was the chosen one I have a deep dive video that would really be an interesting butterfly effect. What if Plo Koon trained Count Dooku? Leta looked like she was addicted to death sticks Please do what if Grievous lost on Darthomir to Ventress I Only found this channel about a week ago and I am addicted. Also got an idea for ya. What if the Jedi Order survived Order 66, but fled into hiding to make Sidious think they were all destroyed? Would be pretty interesting to see an Empire where Jedi move between the shadows, doing good everywhere they can. Maybe even hide themselves from the Rebellion, as well, just to make sure they stay safe until they can come back. What if instead of just leaving the order Anakin SkyWalker demanded an apology from Mace Windu determining whether she stay or leave What if Tarkin died at the Citadel? Ya know that was something that was a major plot hole. How the hell did Barriss sneak into a highly secure military prison, Force Choke Letta, and then escape without anyone seeing her? If somebody has a plausible explanation, I'd love to hear it "Now this is Podracing!" -A boy from Tatooine, Probably XD XD XD What if Anakin told Mace about what happened on Tatooine and Mace decided to help him is done okay so I am working on something you miss about Anakin SkyWalker Death this week he as kid okay there still there in the episode okay is not a joke that is not funny haven spoken is true on live chat he talking just now asking them to know by Tarkin family is tell the truth he asking you okay let me know by the Anakin to work with his role okay take look on youtube easter egg's okay let me know to work on with him he crying about is my take in the episode 9 and episode 8 you miss.
Grevious carelessness and not being in the know of the plot costing Palps was hilarious.
What Luke Skywalker married the Strandcast clone “Daughter” of emperor sheev palpatine?
What if Ahsoka Tano went to Tattooine and reunited with Obi Wan “Ben” Kenobi?
What if Grugu was Yoda’s son?
What If Luke and Leia were both sent to Tattooine together?
What if Ashoka Tano and Luke Skywalker worked together found a grey Jedi style force group that would replace the Jedi and Sith?
What if the original Sith (alien species) returned during the clone wars?
how does that make sense at the end there? Padme was already pregnant with Luke and Leia at the time of revenge of the sith.
What if Baylan Skoll found Kreias personal diary.
What if Shimi became a force ghost?
Who would have thought the best timeline just boiled down to Ashoka not flinching when she should have scurried.
Amusing the chancellor just straight up died.
Where'd you get the idea for Anakin's first child?
what if anakin and padme didn't go to geonosis
What if the clone army becomes vampires and find mates
What if the Younglings had visions of order 66 and saw their deaths?
Day 2;
What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?
I love your channel keep up the great stuff
What if tup revealed what was happening to him.
What if order 66 only killed the ones in the temple.
What if the Jedi were never apart of the war
What if Anakin Skywalker was born a girl and Padme Amidala a boy?
How would *Revenge Of The Sith* change in this scenario?
It would be cancelled because girls get away with so much fucking more than guys.
Another cool one would be:
What if the clones all learned how to cure advanced aging or the kaminoans stopped or slowed their aging once at peak condition.
1.What if Dart Vaider was the father Anakina and not Like type, Shmi married a jedi, from whom she had a son Anakina.
2.What if Anakin had a younger sister.
3.What if Anakin, Like, Leia were born as triplets.
1:47 "Wasn't under arrest but also wasn't not under arrest" I think we call that "Detained"
Okay this story was very good I did enjoy it I do wish it was a lot longer also I hope you come back and make a part 2 and keep up the good work
Got an idea I think could be interesting.
What if Chancellor Valorum didn't get replaced by Sheev Palpatine?
I find it funny how Sideous/Palpatine died not to a battle against jedi, sith, or clones in this story. No it was by Grevious's hand accidentally....whats next him dying to Jar Jar being clumsy? Him dying to R2-D2?
I think it wouldve been funnier if our best boy chopper got to him lol.
The Tecno Union stepped out? WHAT ABOUT ECHO!? The 501st found Echo because of the familiar battle tactics, which led to Rex looking into the whole situation and finding out that Echo was alive because he managed to send a transmission out with his CT number! Without the battle tactics, *Echo doesn't get found, he's still left in that tank for the Union to experiment with! WHAT DOES THE UNION DO!?*
What if Ahsoka was trained by Shaak-Ti. I believe it would be an excellent tale.
I've some ideas for What If:
- What if Qui-Gon managed to cut through the door before the Droidekas arrived?
- What if Palpatine wasn't elected the chancellor of the Republic in Phantom Menace?
- What if Anakin became friends with Iskat Akaris?
- What if Mill Aliberth (the Youngling from the Brotherhood book) became Anakin's Padawan?
- What if Anakin's bombing run managed to kill Grievous on Malevolence
- What if it was Saw and not Steela who died on Onderon?
- What if Anakin killed Dooku in their duel during the Rako Hardeen arc?
- What if Tarkin died in the Citadel meaning there would be no Tarkin Doctrine for the Empire?
- What if Qi'ra joined the Galactic Empire with Han perhaps becoming an ISB agent?
- What if Han killed Darth Vader during the battle of Yavin?
- What if the Ashmead's Lock's prisoners succeeded in assassinating Mon Mothma meaning that Leia would become chancellor and the New Republic wouldn't demilitarize?
i love this channel so much more accessible fanfiction. I appreciate the work you put in to the videos.
That was a really good one. And a wholesome story about my favorite character.
DAY:38 Heres some what ifs. 1.What if the Rebel Alliance was crushed on Hoth? 2.What if the Trade Federation peacefully resolved the Naboo crisis? 3.What if Qui-Gon Jinn had trained Darth Maul as a Jedi? 4. What if the Yuuzhan Vong invaded during the time of the empire? 5.What if Leia became a Jedi Master in the sequel trilogy? and finally 6. What if the Jedi and Sith coexisted peacefully? PLEASE DO ONE OF THESE THEYRE ARE SO INTERESTING🙏🙏🙏 an extra one: what if yoda was the chosen one
What if Plo Koon went with Quigon Jinn and Obi-Wan to Naboo to face the sith?
Day 5: What if Palpatine was sucked out of General Grievous’s ship when he broke the window?
What if Ahsoka joined the darkside after leaving the order
What if the jedi had a secret clone army of there own
What if Anakin refused Padme at the Arena on Geonosis? It could be interesting to have him refuse her, possibly even countering her statement of them pretty much being destroyed.
What if the sith empire returned during the clone wars
What if Anakin Skywalker vowed loyalty to the Zygerrian queen
What if Anakin Skywalker was accused of the bombing at the jedi temple
What if Ezra was born before the clone wars and Anakin Skywalker trained him
What if the younglings survived order 66
What if Anakin had found and fixed up HK-47 instead of building C3-PO, before the event of Phantom Menus.
Anakin would be the new master of HK, HK would tell Anakin about his assassination protocols after seeing Anakin and his mom where slaves. I wonder what such a young boy with that power and hatred would do?
Sorry if I missed this, but why was Captain Tarkin court martialed exactly?
What if Anakin began to change the Jedi code during the Clone Wars with Obi-Wan and Ahsoka's help
What if doku and qui gon opened yodas eyes to the failings of the Jedi
What if Battle-droids never targeted Civis?
I really liked this one where Ahsoka stayed and the Trade Federation left the war and the rest followed.
Luke and Leia would still be born, but with Anakin there they would be named Jinn, after Qui-gon, and Shmi, after Anakin's mother.
Padme would not let the Jedi take both the children, but might let them take Jinn, as he could be raised by Anakin, who would later tell Jinn the truth, and Padme could raise Shmi, although Anakin would leave Corunstant from time to time to spend time with Padme and Shmi, and Anakin would later take Jinn as his apprentice and take him to Naboo to see Padme and Shmi now and then.
What happened to fives tho because Jesse wasn’t an arc trooper during the battle of ringo
What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin was an Jedi bounty hunter
I absolutely love your videos and would like to share some ideas for you.
You ever thought of doing a crossover with another franchise, like Marvel for example?
Noice as always Pente!
Day: 24: What if Talzin raised Maul?
Alternate title "what if the jedi council didn't let itself get pushed around by the Republic Government." XD
What if Hondo raised Ben Solo and Rey? And about the lifespan plot hole that scenario creates, let’s just say Weequays have a longer lifespan than humans.
What if Anakins mother was a extra Sith Lord?
What if Ahsoka fell in love with Barris Offee?
What if Anakin was found as a adult. It wold be cool to see what the Jedi and Sith would do
I saw your next video of venom and Anakin I was like didn't this man say he doesn't do cross overs, but here's my idea what if noble 6 and Noble 2 survived the events of reach And escaped into hyperspace and ended up in the clone wars
What if An'ya Kuro trained Anakin Skywalker?
What if anakin had psychometry
What if Anakin was a bounty hunter
What if palpatine and Darth sidious were separate people
What if master fay trained anakin
What if Cal killed vader in fallen order
What if ashoka turned Vader back to the light
What if obi wan turned ventress to the light
What if jango killed padme
What if the nightsisters won the battle of dathomir(ventress kills grevious and talzin kills dooku)
What if luminara was alive in star wars rebels
What if dagan gera woke in the clone wars
What if dagen gera joined Cal
What if Ventress was Anakins adopted sister.
Oh wow, this was so good
Anakin casually killing dooku and grevious in 1 fight
1:53 fox, you putz