Hollywood Undead - Black Dahlia [Lyrics]
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 08. 2012
- Artist : Hollywood Undead
Song : Black Dahlia
Album : Swan Songs
Label : A&M/Octone
Support the band by buying their music.
itunes.apple.com/us/artist/ho...
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Follow me on Twitter :
/ dannyteu
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Join my Fan Page :
/ theextremeundead
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Why don't you subscribe my channel?
It's only few seconds, but it means a lot.
Click to subscribe :
czcams.com/users/theextre...
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
This is made on non-profital basis and should stay that way.
It is uploaded for entertainment purposes only.
All rights reserved.
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ - Hudba
![Hollywood Undead - Rain [Lyrics]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/69fABjgxtXw/mqdefault.jpg)
![Hollywood Undead - Rain [Lyrics]](/img/tr.png)
![Hollywood Undead - This Love, This Hate [MUSIC VIDEO] 4K](/img/n.gif)
The emotionality in J3T’s part is super underrated. He sounds like he has also been deeply damaged and seems as if he’s about to break down. People don’t give his part nearly the credit it should get.
The Hambone Right? B-day always gave more emotion
Jacob Evingham I totally agree
Preach it...all of Johnnys lines just touch my soul man . Idk if we grew up similar or what but fuck yes he does not get the credit he deserves
Ong
Johnnys got a way of vocalizing his pain, i resonate with it
Deuce - Acceptance, Apology
J-Dog - Depression, Regret
J3T - Anger, Hate
hey man dont forget about funny man
@@daysofcollin7367 he doesn't appears in the song
Echinox i think J-Dog's lines of depression and regret are perfect because he says "Pull up my sleeve and see the pattern of my cuts"
Deuce or Danny
@@fo2dzvideos Danny
Who is still coming back to this song.
Me
Never left
Me bro it’s 2020 that’s crazy I remember listening to them like 7 years ago 😣
Alex johnson sane
trollolol same
J-Dog's part gets me every time. These emotions. He sounds like he's about to burst into tears.
It's absolutely incredible how much emotion he can put into it without completely loosing his sanity.
@@kalith_agar wtf lol
Ikr
Ya same if I did it I'd let.
It out or kry
I like how this shows the stages through a breakup
J3T - Anger
J-Dog - Depression
Duece - Acceptance
It's fucking beautiful
I'm not surprised karma akabane listens to this...
we just need bargaining, and denial, and we have the grief model
hell yea
The 5 stages of grief
Matt angrily screaming
I think I know the pattern of the song. Deuce's part I think is the acceptance. J3T's part was anger and J-Dog's part was depression.
never thought of it like that until now..
that makes a lot of sense actually
awesome insight
that might be right
sounds like it
"I used to be love struck, now I'm just fucked up"
My life right now, summed up in one line
Rey of Jakku literally same
Legit? If so, feelsbadman
Rey of Jakku relatable
Same except add "roll up my sleeves and see the pattern of my cuts" in fact they forced me to in gym and they almost sent me to the hospital over it
Same
8 years later and it still gets to me.. how can some people treat others so poorly. Cheating, violence, mistreated.. what's wrong with this world now-a-days.
Lack of God and morals.
Now a days, you clearly have no idea about history lol... good start go look up Henry the VIII and his wife's xD
@@michaelbowler1600 It was fucked up then, fucked up now. Humans are just fucked.
@@michaelbowler1600 wives*
im pretty sure this is about him killing someone he loved....... regardless its a good song.
J-Dog's part always gets me.
same here
j-dog is the shit.
Man I know I been there
J-dog is epic
J-Dog is my favorite. Followed by Deuce and J3T. I'm glad that this song only features them. c:
Am i the only who thinks the sad songs are the better songs HU has made?
No i think so too 😄
Gage Bradley Besides comin' in hot, I agree
***** cant tell if sarcasm or not because this is the internet but im not very fond of it
AdventureTiem:) alot of there party sings are good too but for some reason the sad songs kinda reinstate if thats the right word what type of music type they origanally were which was rock/ alternative metal but the party songs are still really good :)
Gage Bradley HU sad songs are amazing but they're not better because of one fact: usual suspects :p
When I was younger, I'd sing this song like nothing. Now this hurts. After abusive relationship, family, manipulation, obsessions over people, giving in your all. In a way, this feels like a "people pleaser song". We wanted to please them.. But in the end we just got hurt, over and over again.
Everything time nd now I'm just afraid of all well. abash the devil stood, nd felt how awful goodness is.
The beauty of life !
Makes sense
Facts!!!
You never really understand the song until you go through it yourself
Amen
Facts
Yeah. Dont know when exactly you wrote this, but close to a year ago is when i was listening to this song because it was speaking what i wanted to say
Completely agree. Until you live through it you cant possibly understand the range of emotions you go through when you get f@*& over like this
Hunnid percent.
Hollywood undead always helps me when I'm feeling depressed. their music has helped me when I was 15, I'm 23, their older music still hits my heart hard!
Just turned 24 and there music had saved my life more times than I can count.
Saaaaame bro
Same. Linkin Park too
Hollywood Undead have been there for me when my family and friends found it difficult to, they helped me feel less alienated and dehumanised for nearly 15 years, and I still look up to them today as they saved my life like musical therapists.
I hope you've changed.
"It was my heart, it was my life, it was my start, it was your knife. This strife it dies, this life and these lies. And these lungs have sung this song for too long.. And it's true, I hurt too remember I love you"
Woah this is so creepy.... I was just scrolling randomly through comments and i read this one right as the line was sung.... cool
"And I've lost it all, fell today, it's all the same. I'm sorry oh I'm sorry, I'm sorry no. And I've been abused, I feel so used because of you. I'm sorry oh I'm sorry, I'm sorry no."
@@RandiTheMarioFan64 i was reading the comments to, seeing people going wow read this one as the lyrics was going on, when reading yours those lyrics were going on
@@assassinace2110 Aw thanks
Isn't it strange how when we are young we try and make the songs fit our lives and situations, and when you get older and mature and go back and listen, everything literally fits perfectly and it's disgusting
thought becomes reality
feel the same and i didnt even listen to what they sing back then xD
The entire comment section in a nutshell:
1. MY PARTNER CHEATED ON ME I'LL NEVER BE THE SAME THIS IS MY LIFE RIGHT NOW.
2. *Pitying J-dog*
p much
Yah when your faithful for yeats then they just constantly lie and talk behind you back. To be expected
It takes parts of u and all u do is just all everyday wonder will I be norma again u feel like nothing and the u is trap in this way back darkness and doesn’t kn if it’s gonna be able to just do anything but knows it should
3. I LoVe BoTh DanNy AnD DeUcE lol PeoPle StOp sAyIng tHaT yOu hAtE One Of ThEm aLsO iTRieD toKilL mYsElf LasT NiGht
J-Dog always has and always will be my favorite HU member. he always puts the most emotion in his parts.
he's my least favorite OOF
I like j3t
I love how J-dog has the personal anguish going on, it's pretty relatable.
YES! This in my opinion shows in every song he's in... J3T as well
Smoke Bullet I agree. J3T grits his teeth when he sings which makes his stuff believeable. I know these guys aren't like depressed when they write songs or sing, but if it helps me to get pumped up or to just sit down and listen to good music, then ya I'm all for it. I'm not depressed, I just like the music ya know. :)
WWIIMed20 but they are depressed when they write and sing the songs... All emotional songs from this album were written by different members who have suffered through the story of the song. That's why it's so good
WWIIMed20 i can relate to the anguish
Its happened to me before
Can we mention how deuce is apologizing for being abused
@Ahloura Meatheringham yeah I know it's a very sad cycle my friend
Fr like this wasn't deep enough without that aspect
@damionbordelon2194 fr it just made it cut so much deeper
" It was my heart, it was my life, it was my start, it was your knife."
Cristina 🔪🔪🔪🔪
2020 still here haha
Only HU. "I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry." Psych, "We don't apologize, and that's just the way it is!"
Hahaha true!
Best song ever
I just read that comment like "oh that's pretty cool." *scrolls down*
"Wait! That was my name!" O.O
Same thought when I heard it
J3Ts verse drives me insane. It's so fucking emotional.
I think he had high emotions for his ex, so this song might've been personal for him
u r right he spits rhymes
***** agreed
+Katie Night J-Dog's verse its amazing too, in my oppinion its better than J3T
Raul Rusan yes J-dog's verse was good. but i just get more emotional on J3T's
This isn't my normal type of music, but the words and the emotion behind it has me coming back every time.
Hearing their voices makes me think how many times they broke down trying to make this song, when an artist or artists or band, gives it their all it wants to make you cry; their voices sound like they are on the verge of breaking, and that's crazy and yet so sad but their so strong, so please give credit to them all they deserve it.
tbh i put this loud in my headphones (hearing problems) and one kid told was like "what are you listening to?" and i said "Hollywood Undead?" and all i saw was his face morph into the happiest face and he just started rambling about how much he loved Hollywood Undead and other bands. now we're best friends. its gr8 and i love how we met just over an amazing song
+MCEdgy My Chemical Romance This just makes me so damn happy.. :)
+MCEdgy My Chemical Romance :)
all I can say this one of my favorite songs ever ! I played it for my ex five minutes before I walked out the door ! we had be through so much shit , and I made a place for us live and she used me for 4 and a half years ! after the song was done , I kissed her on her forhead and told " I'll always love but can't do it anymore , good luck in life " ! So this is my fav. now ! though I do like a lot of there other ones ! Sorry to ramble just wanted to comment !
I remember always listening to hollywood undead when I was a young 10 year old, I didn't really understand the lyrics but now I do and it's amazing.
same
+james - hd 60FPS Saaame dude
+james - hd 60FPS I understood it when I was like 7 xD
I listen to Hollywood Undead since I was 10 too. (I'm 11)
AmandaStampy// AmandaTheKiller lol i'm 15 now
Welp here in 2019, reliving my past. Damn, I love Hollywood Undead. 💙
Me too
Same but in 2020
Melanie Clare same
2021 man still goin strong
@@maskedsavages2289 2022 still fucking awsome
This song is everything I want to say to a friend who betrayed me in the worst way. Ironically this used to be her favorite band.
I'm sorry about your friend man
"Hey there Dahlia, what's in like in New York City..."~♪
It's Delilah.
*ヅ*
No shit
Hello
supernatural undead WHY HELLO THERE
j-dog's part makes me want to cry
i know right
Ya same
same
I'm in that exact spot right now and it numbs the body till you don't know how you feel.
I just love how he says "I used to be lovestruck now I'm just fucked up"
J3T's part hits home for me..after she left me I was angry and in tears at the same time..she hurt me so bad that I never really got into another relationship..a broken spirit that was fueled by anger and rage as motivation
Duece is on *FLEEK* here. His voice brings back memories that HU helped me get through.
I feel like J3T and J-Dog are equals when it comes to their rapping. They both have very meaningful lyrics, the difference I think, is when J3T raps you feel his anger and just the anger put into those lyrics, as for J-Dog, I feel that you can feel his agony or pain when he raps. I love them both equally that's just something I picked up on.
I noticed that now...
You're J3T has anger in his lyrics while J-Dog has pain. But still I fuckin love this band!
Smithy Pow Same here
Yeah i know what you mean by hearing the difference J3T still has meaning to the rap but he's just aggrivated the whole time it sound when he sings his part while in j-dog you can hear him being mad but he's mainly all emotional a heavy voice that wavers
J-3-T is anger and pain and J-Dog is the confusion of emotions in general to me.
It's funny how before this song was just catchy and had a nice tune and after I figured out my partner had been lying and cheating for over 5 months this song actually isn't just a catchy tune, it's a song that has some truthful lyrics...
The lyrics that really get me are: I wish I could have quit you, I wish I never missed you, and told you that I loved you, every time I fucked you.
Because fuck, this really relates to my position right now...
When we're happy we enjoy the song
When we're upset we understand the lyrics
+Sean Coponen
A-fucking-men
Guess im not the only one......Hope your ok :)
Sean Coponen way to put it
Makes me think of my stupid fucking ex.
Fucking fucker.
He didn't cheat, but he told me he didn't love me anymore.
And same, those lyrics get me too.
I feel like if you've been cheated on, you have a deeper understanding with this song. It definitely hits close to home for me.
HU will always be my comfort music
fr 😔💯
Honestly, Hollywood Undead songs have triggered the most emotion out of me than any other band could ever imagine... I mean, I love other bands
Some song.. Lol a bunch are about ass n tits tho lol like everywhere I go or coming in hot bunch of other ones
Alyssa Luna love this song
Nik B Yeah, but there are also a bunch about sadness depression, etc. that help me. Idk why they do, but they do. There are some real emotional ones. And i bet you there are more about this kind of things than sexy stuff.
Alyssa Luna U have got big true ! They are sing my life ! Everything what happend in my life I can find in their songs ! Amazing, Thanks HU... ♥
I Love Punchline Yes, Hu is amazing
You can argue all you want, Duece had the best voice for these kinds of songs, IMO.
The chorus he is the best, j dog sounded like he was actually crying tho So i like j dog IMO
+On Sight Games j dog is my favorite 😍
The songs with Deuce are the ones I like the most. no doubt.
he's good but live? its shit
+Paul also true
2023 in to 2024 I still come back to this album. The soul of this song and altogether the album can’t be beat ❤
Fr.
The chorus in this song is one of the best I’ve ever heard, I never get tired of it
I know this song is old, but its still one of my favorite songs!
Akame Stoff Same ^-^
Akame Stoff same
Akame Stoff this song ain’t old lmao, Snow (Hey Oh) by red hot chili peppers is old
Me too kurwa
who said that the old songs are worse than the new ones?
There's never gonna be an album like Swan Songs ever.
CT x Clan right cuz da kurrlz left and deuce left but maybe some day they’ll all get together and make an album
CT x Clan so true its that good
Its not even that good of an album. Notes from the Underground is better.
@@Cyaneth Your opinion is not fact. I think Notes from the Underground is trash, does that make it fact? hell no. neither is yours.
@@notmyrealaccount2876 he never said it was a fact he was just putting his opinion in on the video since he has the right to do that and that's the point of the comment section
It’s weird but this album will always be one of my childhood classics
Just means you have good taste ❤
Still get chills hearing this shit, brings me straight back to middle school, thanks Hollywood undead for being such a big help to so many fucked up kids out there
A lot of people are talking about their ex but then I'm just like:
"Isn't Black Dahlia the name of a murder case? Nice." 😂
Edgy, kid.
Skiddlez Guy tru
I'm just imagining a fight between two characters... I know I'm odd.
Levi Ackerman Hella relatable
trueeeee
Am i the only one who 1. Thinks all their songs sound good no matter if it is danny or was deuce?
2. Think danny and deuce some times sound the same?
3. Love them just for their music not coz of there looks
I love them coz of the meaning behind their songs 😍
Nope same here
They rarely show their faces anyway
As long as they got Charlie j3t and the homie funny man im good
When I first started to listen to HU it took me like six months to be able to discern when it was Danny Charlie or deuce
no you not same here
When I'm at my worst and feeling like nothing is left in life to smile about I find myself listening to Hollywood Undead
Me too
Ah when you were once young and sang along with the lyrics although you know completely almost nothing of it. Now that you're more matured since the world threw the shit called 'reality' to you, you understand the shit that's on the video.
Been an adult for too many years, and I have to say I've never had this kind of experience.
I grew up listening to this kind of songs, and hearing and feeling the deep broken emotions of the singers I think made me a person who's really careful at avoiding this kind of things.
I've dated a couple of people who became more and more toxic, even twisted, and I think they could have really made my life miserable... But at those times I always remember songs like this, and I think to myself "I'm not gonna let that happen to me."
It's amazing how their songs help the ones who feel the same way as them, but also how they can maybe help others avoid relationships with bad endings.
I knew this stuff when I was young. Reality hit hard but gave me sparks
I Iove J Dog's lyrics
Last two lines are the BEST
+bambolove AJ - i like oranges ikrrrr
+bambolove AJ - i like oranges Yes also J3T
+Asher Paal (Asher50203) no he means the sound an meaning of his lyric are what he likes
+Asher Paal (Asher50203) yes
Both of the rap verses in this one are very good, better than Duece's singing in my opinion
This song is incredible for break ups
XD i run into you on all the music i listen to kind of funny cause i watch more of your vids then other music e.e
It's about a breakup
Allen Gordon No it's about J3T fucking Charlie's sister.
Cassie Myers u understand that was a joke right? :P
Josh Cloherty Yes and you understand I was joking right?
Ah.. nostalgia. MySpace days when they went Hard.
Was just a grom promoting their shit, demos.. sk8 round late late nights slappn bumper stickers upside down backwards on cars lol.
Miss their old shit.
Jdogg n shady jeff n scene were gnar brahs.
Miss old days n old them.
Swan Songs will forever be the best album from HU
when my ex and I broke up, he told me he "feels bad" "feels sad" and my reaction was what J3T said, " Im sorry hell no fuck that
my my you have life all figured out Lol
Wolf Man Fitness Well duh. lol
I don't know why, but i feel like i need to share.
I had this amazing friend, she was my most favorite person in the world. She was truly the best person in the world. I had no feelings for her in that kind of way. And i valued our friendship so much, until one day she decided to get a BF. I was so happy for her you know, but not even 2 days later she was ignoring me, not answering my calls. She has made it clear to me that i should stay out of her life. This saddens me A LOT! But thanks to Hollywood Undead, I manage to cope!
Thanks for reading.
ChrisCross Rebel glad I'm not only one only she was cheating on me and just completely forgot I existed.. Life is fucked up sometimes
Almost the same thing happened to me except she told me we couldn't be friends i fell inlove and fell hard i cried but as of today we are friends again those events i spoke of took place 6 months ago.
ChrisCross Rebel im sarry that happen but hang in there bud😸
ChrisCross Rebel damn dude I literally had the same exact damn thing happen bro. But my friend's name was Claudia buuuut she a hoe now. Literally after the second day they were dating they fucked I'm like: you didn't even know him for a fucking month buuuuut it's whatever
Chrisjan Rebel I'm so sorry that happened to u
Coming back to this while I recover from a break up yet again.
This makes me think about my ex girlfriend. How I gave her everything while she only gave half her all in the end. When she broke up with me on Sunday, she pointed out ever single mistake I made. She guilt tripped me with everything while she was the one that also fucked up as well.
I grew up so much since this song came out. (27 now) Still love it so much.
21 🫀
"I used to be love struck now I'm just fucked up! "
My favorite line
Everyone's favorite line lol
Hella damn. Deuces voice is pure
It hits you differently after your bf/gf says "I don't know if I love you anymore"
"Goodbye, [My name]. Never speak to me again."
8 years later, and this song still slaps harder than my dad.
Ohh shit
relatable
same buddy, same.
This song is basically my life right now.
Jack Skatter. Fast food looks like your life right now you fatass emo
That_One_Fuckboy Wow fatass i've never heard that before XD
Jack Skatter. hope it gets better man
I resort to this song when everything goes awry. Just hang in there.
Same. This is happening to me right now and I need this song so bad.
200% volume = 200% more amazing.
yeah it's way better!
Say it to tour doctor
Man, this song still gives me the feels and nostalgia to when I first heard their music. I think back then I pushed my family away more than I do now.
love this song always and forever hits so close to home💜
I think when he says "and your tears are dried up now, you just lay without a sound" he's referring to him killing her and his "fears are over now"
OMG THIS START.
+Skyler hello :)) :3
Hi there
+Skyler hello
hello
Hey
I remember listening to this song back when it first came out This brings back a lot of memories nine years after🥺
This song came out in 2008 lol
Omg! I remember this song! I’ve been listening to a lot of the music that introduced me to metal and rock and it’s so much fun re-discovering these amazing songs.
this song makes me emotional.
ikr especially with current life
It's an emotional song.
This fuckin song gets to you, man. This song is perfect. I'm going through some tough shit and this song makes me all the better.
yes yes it does.
Right, it makes you feel like "fuck everything"
yes
•Madi• Agreed.
Stay strong brother.
I’ve never heard Johnny scream before, it really adds that extra anger to his verse.
Man it's been so long, years of not thinking about it. All of a sudden, it pops back into my head.
I just love the way J-dog says ''pull up my sleeves and see the pattern of my cuts'' its just so emo and edgy and teenagy its so cringy its lovable...
HISSSS 'o'
j-dog is my favorite outta the band
SAMEEEE
I'm like that too
same.
"I used to be lovestruck, now I'm just FUCKED UP!"
Same man, same.
UGHHH SAME
The cake was definitely a lie
This song helped me get through one of the toughest break ups..the lyrics seemed like someone else knows exactly what I'm going through
Damn, this band takes me back when I was kid in middle school.
I wasn't depressed or moody, I just played the Rock Band series with my siblings and some of the songs from this band were there and I quickly loved their first two albums.
old ass songs brings back memories
Oh, you have no idea...
This song isn't old though
fek u
@@ouddaboks9131 this song is gonna be 20 years old in a few years
reminds me of Myspace days.
J-Dog has so much emotion and passion in his verse. Is this based on a personal experience of his? It just seems like he owns the whole song.
RIP DEUCE! WE MISS YOU
Ye, we miss him
Hes not dead
He alive he just left to start a solo career
Bro scared me for a sec
@@ryanchristopher2403 might as well be
9 years and I can still sing along to the whole song.. this is love ♡
That moment when you are screaming J3T's verse and then you take your headphones out and the whole house is staring at you....
"I wish i could've quit you, I wish i never missed you and told you that i loved you, everytime i fucked you, the future that we both drew and all the shit we've been through, obsessed with the thought of you, the pain just grew and grew, How could you do this to me? Look at what i made for you, it never was enough and the world is what gave you, I used to be Lovestuck, Now im just Fucked up, Pull up my sleeve and the pattern of my cuts!!!"
that part...
You missed "see" before "the pattern of my cuts" :p
+erez shaharabani Lol... I feel like its fine!!!😂😜
Thanks, I came to a lyric video just to look at comments telling me the lyrics
MorphoPRF Get used to it, It happens all the time...
Need bangers like these again mann 💪💪💪
Man this brings me back to being a heartbroken 16 year old, there was something visceral about how painful that was.
Didn't realize how much I actually relate to this song until listening to it again...
I feel more emotion during Johnny's verse. He sounds more emotional to me.
h00d3dn1nj4 same
h00d3dn1nj4 Sounded like J-Dog was crying in this song, I think he was more emotional imo
I do agree, but that's not to say j didn't have a lot of emotion
Exactly. He almost moves me to tears each time.
+h00d3dn1nj4
J-Dog and J3T sounded the most emotional in this, Deuce sounded like a whining dog or some shit idk
Love this song so much
Your hard work, dedication, and spiritual endurance are truly appreciated, and I am incredibly grateful for them. Your efforts have made a significant impact. Thank you for all that you do!
am I the only 1 that likes Hollywood Undead just because theyre music is good and not just because its meaningful and that it saved a persons life ect.?
That makes both of us
Thank you! Finally, like, another person like me.
It saved my life. The music is good no matter what
+shadow77281 I like it because it has meaning, but it didnt save my life or some stupid shit like that
+Hizukashi Yugure
If music save your life that its not stupid shit
If j-dog was on fire.....would he be a ...hot dog?°3°
Was that a pun? Because that was funny XD
flippers 101 I'm a straight male and even i can say J-Dog is one hot dog ;D
+UndeaDSoldieR Totes
No he'll be a fire.....doh
Duh*
This is a 10/10 song every verse is great the hook is amazing and the instrumental fits this song perfectly
2019 and still in my heart... ❤❤
this song is my life right now...
Grow a pair
i was a fan..
but now i'm an air conditioner
Amen
+Arno Enzoo Made my day =))
hahahah :)
still one of the best songs in my opinion!
lol
I get goosebumps each time I hear this "pull up my sleeves and see the pattern of my cuts"
this song gives me chills!!!! its that good!!!! 😍
Honestly I am in love with this song. Who's listening to this in 2k16??
Noone of course.
madi faith edgell 2k17
madi faith edgell 2017
Still listening to this in 2018 :)
"I loved you,
you made me,
hate me,
you gave me,
herpes."
lol
haha
Lol...
Yeah... that sounds about right LOL
that right there just made me fucking smile. damn man
Haven't listened to this song in 11 years and I still have been singing it in my head for so long
ugh they touched my heart with this one