‘Huge disagreement’ as Israel ignored US military strategy for its war on Gaza: Analyst
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 05. 2024
- William Lawrence, a professor of international relations at the American University, says the US commander who oversaw the Battle of Mosul to defeat the armed group ISIL (ISIS) was sent to advise Israel’s military on how to conduct the Gaza campaign without the mass killing of civilians.
Israel’s leadership, however, “didn’t take that strategy to heart”.
“While they do have mechanisms to avoid killing civilians, they didn’t implement their own policies either. There’s a huge disagreement on strategy now,” he told Al Jazeera.
He noted the United States has given Israel “carte blanche up till now”, and continues to ship light weapons to its military during the ongoing campaign in Gaza.
“From a Palestinian perspective, it’s absolutely clear the US is doing next to nothing to save them from the onslaught of the Israeli forces,” said Lawrence.
Subscribe to our channel: bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#WarOnGaza #GazaWar #UnitedStates #Netanyahu #JoeBiden #Israel #USIsraelRelations #USForeignPolicy #IsraelGazaWar #GazaBombardment #USMilitarySupportToIsrael #USArmsShipmentToIsrael
Israel relies on US like a beggar. The Palestinians rely on courage like true warriors.
So... they are warriors being slaughtered now? civilians or warriors what is it..
Idiot 😂 who's supplying weapons to Hamas? Without lies, Islam die. Try get sense next time fool
@@jfern6673 palestinians blood are not cheap for you to screw around with, get lost
You're right. Israel are mooches taking advantage of American taxpayers.
@@Truthfulness7575 and Nazyyahu w/ Nazyyahu...
"Israel is a settler colonial project that is nearing its end,as colonial projects reach their final phase become more brutal and ruthless." - llan Pappe
Just think for a while IF Izzrael did not exist or get 0bliterated by league of Arabs in 1948 W0rs, you guess who will be in-charge of Paleztine Land? Do you think Paleztinians will be in-charge? NO! A thousand time NO!
Paleztine land will be ruled by either Egypt/Jordan/Syria. They had the armies and distinct PA did not have proper army!
Gazza used to be ruled by Egypt!
Why should Egypt hand Gazza over to Paleztinians?
West Bank, East Zerusalem used to be ruled by Jordan.
Why should Jordan hand West Bank, East Zerusalem to Paleztinians?
Paleztinians would have ruled no land had not Izzrael handed Gazza over to Yasser AraFart in 2005!
“Other people who were less oppressive might have ruled them anyways! WHAtS tHE pRoBlem???”
@@BeeBee-ck8bc "Paleztinians would have ruled no land had not Izzrael handed Gazza over to Yasser AraFart in 2005!"
Reality:
The United Nations, international human rights organizations and many legal scholars regard the Gaza Strip to still be under military occupation by Israel.[4] This is disputed by Israel and other legal scholars.[5] Following the withdrawal, Israel continued to maintain direct control over Gaza's air and maritime space, six of Gaza's seven land crossings, maintains a no-go buffer zone within the territory, controls the Palestinian population registry, and Gaza remains dependent on Israel for its water, electricity, telecommunications, and other utilities.[4][6]
Source: Wiki-Pedia -> Israeli disengagement from Gaza
@@BeeBee-ck8bc " They had the armies and distinct PA did not have proper army!"
Just because the israelites only attack civilians doesn't mean that the palestinians don't have an army.
it's like any 'thief', say, when a bank robber is about to meet armed swat, are his hostages 'more' likely to survive, or less (if any)..
Unbelievable, that this person is allowed to spread misinformation about UN revising the number of deaths. For clarification, the number of deaths has not changed, the revised number refers to those who have been identified as opposed to those who have yet to be identified. Do not be fooled. We are all so tired with the carnage. We are psychologically prone to want to believe something that provides relief don’t be taken advantage of. Stay diligent.
That's exactly what I think. Pathetic little liar
Well said.
@@dancingclairThe way I’ve been filtering Iz propaganda is to check all claims for whether they are pushed by a swathe of Iz citizens who’ve pushed other false claims getting stories published in western media. If so, I wait for the real story from real journalists.
I hate it that I see this lie repeated everywhere, and now on Al Jazeera the last place where I would expect to hear it. U.N. has already released a clarification a while ago but still detractors just keep repeating it.
He is lying
Palestinians are very courageous. They're not afraid to fight for freedom and justice.
Courageous soldiers wear uniforms
@@ilovetech8341 courage isn't defined by uniform ?
@@ilovetech8341 We all saw a video on the news of Israel soldiers disguised in women's clothes some with wheelchairs and medical staff uniforms to access a hospital in the West Bank where they proceeded to execute 2 Palestinians in their hospital beds in broad daylight.
@@ilovetech8341 Speaking of terrorism, The British administrative headquarters for Mandatory Palestine, housed in the southern wing of the King David Hotel in Jerusalem, was bombed in a terrorist attack on July 22, 1946, by the militant right-wing Zionist underground organization Irgun during the Jewish insurgency. 91 people of various nationalities were killed, including Arabs, Britons and Jews, and 46 were injured.
@@ilovetech8341
The Diaper Brigade of Israel???
Stop genocide
United States still is siding in the systematic killings of civilians
thank you
Which one?
Palestinians have the right to defend itself
The number was NOT reduced. That is only the number who have been IDENTIFIED.
Who cares? The dead?
Saying Israel can defeat the resistance is like saying biden can run up the stairs without stumbling. 💪🇾🇪🤝🇮🇶🤝🇸🇾🤝🇱🇧🤝🇮🇷🤝🇵🇸
😂😂😂
😂😂😂@@MMAAllDayEveryday
Actually, they did defeat the resistance. U must have forgotten 1948
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Israel derrotar a resistência? Né no tempo dos antepassados aconteceu isso, meu filho.
It is perhaps the entitled callousness of the Israelis that most puts people off; to deny there is intentional targeting of civilians and aid workers, and so many other war crimes, though it is all documented on film. It is a sort of criminal insanity on the Israeli side.
The sheer cruelty and the lack of any regard for non-Israeli life has shocked so many in the West who were only vaguely aware of the injustices suffered by the Palestinian people before this conflict.
About the Jews nothing? Keep quiet and nobody will notice how stupid you are!
No. Wrong arguments.
USA is fully involved along with few leading western allies like UK, France and Germany.
WTFyu keednapp Germans, French, Amerikkans, Argentinians, Thais, Filipin0s, Nepalese..?
UN did not revise the number. They said they can't properly identify the rest of the deads beause they ripped into pieces. What is the matter with people who make things up as they go? Stéphane Dujarric, Spokesman for the Secretary-General was asked about this by the journalist and that is not what he said. He said the never has not been revised.
1.5B shias and sunnis. 10M Israelites.
Yep, I picked up on that as well. There was also a mainstream media surge yesterday with a video released of Female IDF soldiers and perhaps a few female civilians who were taken by Hamas that was a bit graphic. But nothing like we see here of seriously injured women and children in great numbers and so much horror. The US media won't show any of that.
@@ilovetech8341 1.5b don't have the economic power of the 6.5 m
its a pretty small number when you think how many Jews were killed in the holicost!
A modern army fighting refugees in a prison camp is losing on the battlefield and around the world.
Yes, but, they have high tech sandles, IOF seeking rocks, and they are mean ( remember Oct 7TH) . Israel is just too moral,
Lolz 🤣😃😄
Bet the Pier is for a special delivery of heavy equipment not needed aid to citizens.
no, it's an exit route that avoids the problem of locals theoretically being entitled to request asylum if they step on egyptian or IL soil. it's an emigration port.
no, it's for emigration.
Military siege from all sides? US military base?
@@tomjones9082 the US doesn't want to send its military in, it's not needed, and IL wouldn't even want it there because the american soldiers would be too likely to object to the local customary degree of criminality in military conduct. in so far as this pier has other purposes than emigration, which is sure to be the primary one because enabling emigration without letting people enter the jurisdictions of either egypt or IL is the only major change brought about by a port, the point is for the US to have a special "aid" supply project that they can point to to say that they really tried. they're aiming to reduce legal exposure, sending in troops would increase legal exposure.
the US is certainly actively participating by providing signals intelligence and satellite and drone surveillance, and allegedly even fire missiles from their reaper drones, but all that can be kept very difficult to prove. basically they would need to be unlucky enough for the involved military or more likely CIA sections to spring a leak - the CIA actually has its own small army of special forces and a little air force and a large portion of the US attack drone fleet, and they can be reasonably assumed to be to ones running most of the US armed involvement because if such involvement is happening, it's small enough to be covered by the CIA, and such things really only get handed off to the military that can't keep a secret for sh°° if the operational requirements get too big.
8000 Children Identified not murdered. There is a huge difference.
Left up to the average person and not the elite and politicians, none of this would ever have happened. Protests are having an impact along with social media awareness. Praying that all is resolved soon, including arrests of those driving this horror.
The strongest people on earth with dignity and pride 76 years under occupation and apartheid still resisting
courageous people deserve to be free
Sad that they repeatedly rejected their own state.
@@user-oz7hu3sb8l did they rejected?
@@naymatunc-rc6vs In 1937 the Peel Commission proposed a Jewish state and an Arab state. Jews agreed, the Arabs said no.
In 1947, the United Nations also offered Jews and Arabs their own state. The Jews accepted, the Arabs said no.
1967, following the 6-Day-War Israel offered to trade land for peace and was met with the 3 Nos of Khartoum-no peace with Israel, no recognition of Israel, no negotiations with Israel.
2000-the Oslo process. Ehud Barak offered all of Gaza as well as 94% of the West Bank with East Jerusalem as their capital. They said no. Even Bill Clinton got fed up with them; U.S. President Bill Clinton, “Arafat was here 14 days and said no to everything.”
2008-Ehud Olmert offered even more land than Ehud Barak and Abbas said no.
100%
They dizplay their dignity for the whole world to see on 0kto7!
These recorded videos will be a future documentry for the whole world to study "PA Dignity", once upon a time in Gazza
They can't never ever defeated resistance fighters.
Your wishful thinking. In case you forget, resiztance fighters like the Al-Keda network is IMPOTENT now after Amerikka eliminated their top leaders.
Now you never heard of Al-Keda ops in the world.
Their core leaders were ELIMINATED!
One can never eliminate a legitimate resistance.
Palestinian People are legitimate People’s of Palestine. They have a right to livelihood and Freedom
I think Israel lost more than 600 soldiers
Well it depends how you look at it. They have excellent medical .. but blinded, brain damaged, paraplegic .. some might count those also as a man lost eh?
They never achieve anything.
They lost the war
Believe me, Israel doesn't even know how Hamas look like
-big
-scary
-dimly lit
-long beard
-angry
-shouting arabic but sounding austrian
-scary
@@Rename_July not any scarier than your average hick biker
@@Rename_Julyand what about iof ?? ugliest creatures on the 🌎
thank you
Anyone not in IOF uniform?
Libya 🇱🇾 support Palestine 🇵🇸
Italy 🇮🇹 support Israel 🇮🇱
Salute to Libya 🇱🇾
Italy 🇮🇹 always on the wrong side of history
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
AIPAC
Can Al Jazeera report on their role in the conflict
"American intelligence"? Isn't that an oxymoron?
Long live the resistance!
Thanks Al-Jazeera News Channel for updating truthful news, especially About Middle East, Hope and Pray for all Success, Allah may protect you and your entire team, Al-Jazeera Paying Price for its truthfulness, Allah Protect all staff and all entire team, Aameen.
Funded by Qatar who is friend of terr0rizzz head hiding in Qatar!
A question that arises do politician serve their own interest or the interest of it's voters? How is it possible that a small low funded group fighting for it's own people against occupation and apartheid is still able to fight against a country known to have the best military in the world, best solider and unlimited foreign financial funding and support of weapons and support of western powers is still not able to bring this war to an end. Why target children, women and it's infrastructure if harmas is the real target. So many questions and nothing but lies and Propaganda for global civilian audiences. So many un answered questions
the reality is Israel can move without US help fact on the ground since the war on Gaza Israel has benefited from its mass killed civilians nothing achieved besides when your policy depends on hate and ethnic cleansing it is difficult to achieve your goal
Israel dose not exist without u.s.
How do you estimate everyone still under the rubble? There should be a multinational investigation into the Gaza invasion because neither side is trustworthy. Aid and journalists need to be let in immediately.
Lloyd Austin criticized Israel for not taking back land it once controlled? Do you mean Palestinian land? Isn't it good that Israel did not take more Palestinian land?
Alhamdulillah ❤️❤️❤️
YOU CANT ELIMINATE THE RESISTANCE GET IT RIGHT YOU 🤬
Free palestine
America's Hypocrisy. Bombs to one side. Food and medicine to the other.
Imagine arming someone only to find afterwards you enabled fatal rogue behavior.
US intelligent said 35% hamas killed 😅 they count 15000 Childers of Gaza as Hamas member 🙄 they also consider 35% civilians houses as Hamas tunnel 😊
UNited states of Israel.
Columbia Paleztine
A 230 million pier which was used just today to deliver arms and equipment to israel.
Really? Where did you see or hear that?
Defies everything good humans believe in
Thank you so much Al Jazeera for the great analysis. ❤❤❤❤❤❤
😢😮😮😮😮😮Can someone please explain to me again why no European nation including the US wanted these people in their country before during and after WWII????? What did they know that we are now finding out???? 🤔
Well Jerusalem is in the middle east unfortunately and not in the heart of Nebraska so they consider that their holy land.
US has never won any war, except for probably, Indian wars . They are definitely in position to advocate lessons learnt , in these lost wars
Ww2?
@@ilovetech8341it was the Russians
@@ilovetech8341 hahahahahaha! Britain fought alone for years, and Russia was mainly responsible for the victory. Hollywood isn't reality.
@@ilovetech8341 During years the europeans asked for help from the USA. They refused.
Only when the nazis were losing baddly and the russians were advancing into Germany the USA decided to intervene to try to take as many spoils it could get from the victors
US defeated and conquered Iraq, 4th biggest military, in 6 weeks
US defeated and collapsed the Japanese empire
US defeated and collapsed the Spanish empire
US defeated, annexed, and conquered the capital of Mexico
US defeated and removed itself from the British empire
US defeated and pacified Libya
US defeated and collapsed the Soviet Union without firing a single shot
US saved South Korea when it was surrounded by enemies
US has successfully invaded and conquered multiple small nations such as Panama, Geneva, Haiti, Serbia, Eastern Syria
US has successfully launched coups and rebel fighting in multiple countries.
Thats not even mentioning Native wars, and WW1 WW2 occupations of France, Italy, West Germany and Northern Africa
In less than 250 years of life....
Imagine getting millions of dollars and still losing 🤣
"If you don't run away now, you will run away from our children" Ali Mortada. These words haunt me.
Thank you, Professor William Lawrence at American University, for your kindness and support.
God bless you 🙏 🙌 👍
Free Palestine from Hamas and the UN occupation
A friend always loves,
however, in times of need, he becomes a natural brother.
This men saying truth full spooky 😢
Not interested in IDF/IOF footage.
Mr. Lawrence was spot on
Onlyb25% of Americans are disgusted? That's not enough to maintain the disgust till Nov to make a point
Who's worse
Genociders
And
Terrorists?
Speaking of terrorism, The British administrative headquarters for Mandatory Palestine, housed in the southern wing of the King David Hotel in Jerusalem, was bombed in a terrorist attack on July 22, 1946, by the militant right-wing Zionist underground organization Irgun during the Jewish insurgency. 91 people of various nationalities were killed, including Arabs, Britons and Jews, and 46 were injured.
The un has not revised down the number!!! 8000 is the number identified. The other 10000 are unidentified
Israel is in a lose lose
So the numbers in the rebel battalions might actually be bigger than 7 months ago? Well can't say I'm surprised :)
William Lawrence, a professor of international relations at the American University, says the US commander who oversaw the Battle of Mosul to defeat the armed group ISIL (ISIS) was sent to advise Israel’s military on how to conduct the Gaza campaign without the mass killing of civilians. The Americans would get attacked from a building then airstrike it.
Did ISIS hide behind their W0men&Cildren when fireee at their enemies?
Where are the Hostages ?
There is no disagreement, but a ploy the keep the world guessing. All is a big show off.
The anchor should let the guest speak without interruption, jesus lady
Those recruitment of Hamas fighters came at the results everytime when there is ceasefire through tunnels that are connecting from Rafah to Egypt, foreign fighters are joining through tunnels.
Changing sides at last moments hurt both sides... US keep continuing weapon sale... otherwise people would love US...🤦
The US government only had to say to Israel to reinstate AP in Israel tout suite and what happened, they immediately allowed AP back in. Anyone who thinks Israel is refusing to listen to the US government is not paying close attention. If US admin wanted Israel to stop the war and make peace, there would be peace. What Israel is doing is permission based (from the US admin).
It doesn’t matter how many children
Freedom doesn't come with ease
Uncle Satan thinks they own the world, but think again. 😅
1.5B shias and sunnis. 10M Israelites. Africa, Middle East, India, Indonesia, versus... one little strip of worthless desert that imports 90% of its food.
That’s truly what Israel needs to be concerned about, the next generation of angry, resentful Palestinians, that is being created, who will be as extreme or even more extreme, than those now
Huge disagreement on strategy but USA will still blindly obey the orders of Israel and will keep defending ODF's actions despite these purported disagreements.
The DC dude is LIEING!
He is lying
Will boycott ALL USA and Israeli products and services for EVERRRR....i will NEVER forget. Already have cancelled Disney, Amazon, Gaia and many products.
🇵🇸🤜🏼🇮🇱🇮🇳🇺🇸🇬🇧🇯🇵🇹🇼🇦🇺🇵🇭🇨🇦
As a Canadian it makes me sick to see my flag with is Israel's. I definitely do not support any of what my government has been supporting.
I consider this as all drama.
Why are the IDF casualties always given? But not Hamas casualties?
h@m@zz wear T-shirts & Jeans. If they K.I.A, they are counted as civillians. Thats why!
❤
Why all this people choose their words carefully what to say 🤔 🙄 and not what to say 🤔 just say it how it's is the truth and the truth will set you free
Why the bullshit us revised what
Only 25% ?
that no in genocide happen in modern world
Liar!
Us had lost its importance in whole world because Israel always ignored US so other nations also started ignoring it.
Its credit goes to Israel
ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕਾ ਖਾਲਸਾ ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕੀ ਫਤਿਹ!🤔
American like step civilian in their own 😅😅😅
Whoever thinks IDF will leave Gaza soon or later is completely mistaken,vthe the war would have ended long ago if IDF had started with Rafah to avoid supplying of weapons from Egypt, now no more penetration into Egypt... let's how it ends
Gaza doesn't have any frontier with Egypt.
@@arturferrao7353 it does underground...you must have heard the 50tunnels IDF found entering Egypt... you only believe that whatever IDF says are lies, and that's completely fine
😮
This dude is just shameless.
David 921 BC killed Goliath Jalut Palestine King and occupied Palestine. Palestinian people and Nebuchadnezzar destroyed Solomon kingdom and liberated Palestine.
The British mandate of Palestine 1921 and the Haganah forces committed injustices against Palestinian people for 27 years. The British army left Palestine 1948 after the UN 1948 approved the occupation of Palestine.
Never heard of any current distinct Paleztinians talk about their ancestor story to their children that one of their ancestor Goliath was chopped by David.
Nor do they talk about Paleztinian people in the time of Nebuchadnezzar.
Even Quran not mentioned them once but mentioned Israel 40+ times.
They only existed after a bunch of Arabs migrated to Paleztine Land during the British mandate.
PLO leader Yasser AraFart was born on August 1929 in Cairo, Egypt!
later he migrated to Paleztine land.
And he started fantasizing he was the indigenous people of Palestine.
Then he tell all the gullible people he was the native Palestine. Actually he was an Egyptian!
The Palestinian talked about all those. They have the spring and place called after their king called the spring of Jalut.
Google Ain Jalut.
The quran also said about David and Goliath Jalut see chapter two the story of David.
The quran also said about EZEKIEL.
Ezra who returned with his donkey from Babylon after the fall of Solomon kingdom.
EZEKIEL 38 wars to protect the occupation of British mandate. Destroyed countries Somalia Sudan Libya Yemen Afghanistan Iraq Syria Lebanon Palestine Russia Rohingya Uighur Kashmir Kosovan.
CZcams EZEKIEL 38 wars
🇵🇰❤️🇵🇸🤜🏼🇮🇱 🇮🇳
War began and is about to end, Al Jazeera has achieved absolutely nothing 😅..
Al Jazeera has achieved everything. They have brought the truth from Gaza to the world.
Izr👁️le is loo$ing Biggly 😂
Israel can not defeet hamas weither usa give support or not becouse of they are defeeting foreign enemy from their country and religion
Israelis are wise .🇮🇱🇿🇦
Vote Vote. Evry Zionest supporters out of the House and Senate
Vote
You have to be at least uninformed to compare fights from Iraq against isis with the situation of Gaza where terrorists are mixed with civil population in a densely populated area where Hamas builded a stronghold using, hospitals, mosques, schools. Is very simple to say how not to solve a problem, especially if you are interested not to solve it.
Speaking of terrorism, The British administrative headquarters for Mandatory Palestine, housed in the southern wing of the King David Hotel in Jerusalem, was bombed in a terrorist attack on July 22, 1946, by the militant right-wing Zionist underground organization Irgun during the Jewish insurgency. 91 people of various nationalities were killed, including Arabs, Britons and Jews, and 46 were injured.
Did he state 8k more it should have been?
Jews
This "professor " in DC is bullsh!t
TAKEEEAAAABBBERRRRRRRRR... ALOHAAAAAA SNACKKKKKBBBBAAARRRRR.......
1 samuel 15
@@fidelcatsro6948 Ayat2💣💣💣 - Surat Al Baqarah ayat 216- surat Al Anfal ayat 12- Qs 47:4 - Surat At-Taubah ayat 9: 111- Surat Muhammad ayat ke 4 - surat At-taubah ayat 5- Surat At-Taubah ayat 29- surat As-Shaff ayat 4....
@@mrniceman8683 naaaah Quran has no verse asking to murder babies and women like in the bible
Hamas and you guys want to prosvoke Israel military, and very soon they will start crying 😭😭😭
No cease-fire
1.6B shias and sunnis. 10M Israelites. Africa, Middle East, Eurasia, India, Indonesia, versus one little strip of worthless desert that imports 90% of its food. Africa is 3x larger than Europe.