Everything Andrew Yang Said at the Democratic Debate in Miami | NBC New York
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 09. 2024
- Listen to everything Andrew Yang said during the second night of the Democratic presidential debates in Miami, FL.
More on the debate: On the final night of the Democratic presidential primary debates, there were sharp exchanges over busing and segregation, a frank admission of failure on racial tensions and an attempt to open a generational divide between the front-runners and the others.
Ten candidates again faced the challenge of standing out among the crowd.
Andrew Yang, a former tech executive and political newcomer, is best known for his proposal for a universal basic income of $12,000 a year. He is calling the payments the “Freedom Dividend.”
Yang, whose internet followers are called the Yang Gang, distinguished himself before a word was uttered.
He appeared without a tie.
NBC 4 New York on Twitter: 4.nbcny.com/kAu...
NBC 4 New York on Facebook: 4.nbcny.com/mbe...
NBC 4 New York on Instagram: 4.nbcny.com/g5Y...
NBC 4 New York on CZcams: 4.nbcny.com/iTU...
#DemDebate
#AndrewYang
#Politics
#News
#YangGang
"It is not left. It is not right. It is forward, and that is where I'll take the country in 2020."
Big respect for that.
Amazing quote
ZeroOne46 , agree. Yang 2020
Getting stoked on this fella. Very intelligent and focused.
ZeroOne46 Universal income is a socialist policy tho
Flowery, meaningless bullshit. what he's pushing is far left/socialist
Yang earned the right to be heard. Censorship is toxic!
it's funny how we use China or North Korea as an adjective for censorship but really the biggest joke is America
TBTV I don’t agree with a lot of what he says but he does have that right, whenever they hear something they don’t like they just censor it
Ik right? It sucks that conservatives are being banned from social media, and that Google is targeting many conservative voices
Artificial intelligence in the hands of the IRS and Pentagon equals loss of liberty and more subjugation by the US totalitarian regime.
Arena Rat they shut his mic off what are you talking about
2hrs of fighting and you gave him a total of 4mins. Disgusting.
Not even. A little over 2 minutes
2 minutes 58 seconds
That’s because he’s Asian
@@YalamberHangRai It's not because he's asian it because Democrats are rigging this like they did with Bernie. These debates are pointless cause they want Biden or another popular Democrat with lots of friend in high power to win. That's why Hillary made it si far cause she already has established power within the core to manipulate and pull some strings.
Of course "Context should matter" is by very nature a yang supporter...... Great name choice by the way.
You guys owe a public apology to Andrew!
Not just Andrew, but ALL his supporters. They donate their hard earned money to see Andrew Yang on the stage and they muted his mic.
Because they muted his mic this makes it even more the reason why people should vote for him, so we can hear him speak for the rest of his presidency.
@@beyondintervals6606 Make it two thousand a month and I'll take a listen.
@@Pomiferous lmao
YangGang coming to burn down their MF'ing house down and steal yo wife.
Smartest guy in the room always gets the least air time.
Because they muted his mic this makes it even more the reason why people should vote for him, so we can hear him speak for the rest of his presidency! :D
That's how they sgut you up
Really they just want to hear Biden and Sanders speak. Those dudes are like the popstars of the Democratic party. Ironically, it's the same reason Bernie got shafted last time, but now he's hot shit without Hillary around. The new guy never gets acknowledged.
There are still westerners who thinks they are qualified enough to enlighten Chinese people at this point you know
Hopefully Americans are smarter to recognize this bait and switch this time.
I think the young generation does the old people don't want a futurist.
Andrew Yang is definitely the least political and most logical democrat I’ve seen on stage in awhile.
So, the government giving away $3.2 Trillion dollars (annually) to people that don't really want to work seems logical to you?
@@xr4ti548 People spend the $1000 -> Firms get more sales -> Firms get more profits -> Firms expand. In doing so they need to hire more workers. If everybody is too lazy to work, then firms will just have to raise wages to convince people to work, no?
nah, Tulsi Gabbard is
@ß0MbA Ā Beast theyll have to work alright...because their rent and goods will go up at least $1000
From his website with a lot of information about how he will use and implement UBI without borrowing a single cent.
1. Current spending. We currently spend between $500 and $600 billion a year on welfare programs, food stamps, disability and the like. This reduces the cost of Universal Basic Income because people already receiving benefits would have a choice but would be ineligible to receive the full $1,000 in addition to current benefits.
Additionally, we currently spend over one trillion dollars on health care, incarceration, homelessness services and the like. We would save $100 - 200+ billion as people would take better care of themselves and avoid the emergency room, jail, and the street and would generally be more functional.
2. A VAT. Our economy is now incredibly vast at $19 trillion, up $4 trillion in the last 10 years alone. A VAT at half the European level would generate $800 billion in new revenue. A VAT will become more and more important as technology improves because you cannot collect income tax from robots or software.
3. New revenue. Putting money into the hands of American consumers would grow the economy. The Roosevelt Institute projected that the economy would grow by approximately $2.5 trillion and create 4.6 million new jobs. This would generate approximately $800 - 900 billion in new revenue from economic growth and activity.
4. Taxes on top earners and pollution. By removing the Social Security cap, implementing a financial transactions tax, and ending the favorable tax treatment for capital gains/carried interest, we can decrease financial speculation while also funding the Freedom Dividend. We can add to that a carbon fee that will be partially dedicated to funding the Freedom Dividend, making up the remaining balance required to cover the cost of this program.
It's absolutely disgraceful how little time Andrew got on this debate.
BRUH indeed-look at wall at and big business. Laziest lot on earth.
What a pitiful mindset. With mind sets like yours the middle/working class will continue to die at the alter of the neoliberal transnational corporate capitalist economic system/neoconservative foreign policy milieu.
Extreme and systemic problems require extreme and systemic solutions.
You’re either lazy or you are not-giving legal adults “free money” isn’t going to all of a sudden make hard working Americans with ambitions, ideas, struggles, etc., etc..
Enjoy your unpragmatic dogma that will get this nation and the middle/working class no where but a ditch to rot in.
@BRUH True but at the moment we need to disperse the wealth gap.
@BRUH the real prob is not with "Yang's Policies". it is "we won't let Yang speak his policy"
BRUH you’re literally stupid. the people who are getting the free money are the wealthy by not paying taxes
@@keamsilva how are wealthy people getting free money? I mean seriously they built a business they created wealth now explain yourself.
Andrew followed the rules and never talked over others. Even with minor things like this you can tell who has real integrity and nobility
@@earlaweese what's Andrew yang's nationality?
Forever VIP american
His nationality is obviously American. How else would he be qualified to be up there
The crazy thing is. He said the least but gets 3x the views on CZcams. Ratings matters give that man more airtime!
^^^he's right you know
Nobody else is offering to pay people a minimum wage part time job salary every year... Means people wont have to work... or at least if they are already successful people, that they would get a little bonus. Though, it wont happen. He said it himself, the VAT tax would pay for less than 1/3rd of that. Im pretty sure that our money hungry federal government would have figured out how to get 3 trillion dollars extra per year by now. Its not going to happen. So... once you get the pipe dream off the table, what does have have going for him? Hes massively Anti Gun, he doesnt have good policies on most things, hes... pretty much a run of the mill leftist. "Not Left, not Right, but forward." Yes, thats a very progressive thing to say, progressive as in leftist.... You can call a cow patty a lot of things, doesnt mean its not just shit.
@@Kiba69420 We can do without UBI for the next 30 years or so. But after that, and without "new jobs" (probably government subsidized jobs) most work will be for the computers/the robots/ the AI. 40% of the work will not be done by humans. What are we going to with them? Kill the 40% economically useless class? Or do you have a transition plan? Can you invent productive work that isn't repetitive? UBI is a way to survive, not to stop people from working. He is not your candidate and thats ok. It's not my job to change your mind.
@@olger05 His UBI plan is actually to encourage work, not replace. He acknowledges the vital role work plays in our person well being and society at large. The dividend promotes work by bolstering consumer markets right at home that will make main street businesses like yoga studios, bike shops, and coffee and wine bars much more buoyant and sound. Even the smallest towns of a couple thousand adults will bring in millions of new revenue every month thanks to the dividend, which will grow regional economies by 10-15% and create millions of jobs across the country. If we don't do this, wealth will continue to leave these towns and top corporations will continue to game current taxe codes.
b. 93 Yes, initially. But how many yoga classes can you take? How many coffees can you drink? The market will be saturated with jobs only humans can do. The business you are talking about, are already under enormous pressure. More competitors doing the same thing isn’t good for the economy. Just look at African country’s with less diversity on the job market. All stability is gone. And we will all be more dependent on very few variables to be successful of to fail.
The truth of the matter is, we need diversity. A lot of people will not be working. Even if they wanted to. Except if they can invent “new jobs” that can’t be done by a machines. But that’s very interesting and difficult problem we will need to solve. But I don’t think it’s possible to solve if all basic needs are met.
Yang: Not left, not right. Forward.
Moderators: Not left? Well...you only get two questions.
Awesome Boss exaclty ughh
I did an interview with a yang supporter on my channel about the benefits of UBI
Maybe check it out? Thank you if you do lol
He said that in his closing statement. AFTER he was called on only twice.
@Ric Goesinya China's per capital GDP in 1957 is 68.2 dollars, and 2019 is 9776 dollars. As a Chinese, I thank Chairman Meow very much.
@Ric Goesinya LoL, you have no logic at all. If you want to judge someone, you need to look at the whole picture instead of just one or two things.
If you blame Mao for the people starved to death during 1960-1962. Then you should blame Douglas MacArthur for kill millions of North Korean and Chinese people, you should blame Truman and Churchill for dropping nuclear bombs on Japan.
The fact is, what happened is not done by one or two people, it is done by the whole nation, whole party.
By the way, if you want to know how 1.3 billion people feel about Mao. Come to China and ask random people.
No matter what he did, he is the funding father of PRC.
@@xiaocui4368
Mao literally destroyed the chinese culture and wealth. And killed the intellectualls and Education. You should thank Xi Jinping, he opened the country for capitalism.
I wonder how much longer this video would be if his mic wasn't turned off...
It'd be so appealing he'd end up in the white house oval office with no clue how he got there
I wonder how many more elections they can deny rigging when it's proven & gets clearer every year.
@@godspeed2145 Just put him there would be a hoot. Drain the swamp !!
I feel really bad the same thing which may happened on Bernie Sanders will happen on Andrew Yang again. I thought they learned the mistake but looks they just want to shut down the power faster ..They think that's the mistake they learned on 2016...
@@Deovera94 YEP!
Everything Andrew Yang said at the Democratic debate in Miami... When his mic was on.
Fixed it for you.
From what we know, if his mic was turned on the whole time he would have said "Freedom dividend, freedom dividend, $1000" There ya go!
@@stevejones5075 probably. Still the only one I'd vote for. I've got a feeling these debates have done more to ensure a 2020 Trump win than all the memes from
r/The_Donald ever could.
Benevolent Despot ha Yang is a kook. I’m so confident Trump will win in my home state of Michigan I don’t even need to vote for him, he’s got it in a landslide this time
@@stevejones5075 Amazing attitude! We could use less uneducated votes wherever we can prevent them!
As long as you stay close minded, we're better off as a country without the vote :)
@@justanotherone9685 Oh ok, enjoy 2020 folks, the libs will eat their candidates alive and you'll be voting for Trump over Biden. Im callin it now
he’s the only person I wanted to hear speak and debate at this event . the rest of it was theatre nonsense
So true. There should be no back and forth from the old hacks.
@Widdy
Guys.. Go check the small video when he was trying to speak and he was cut off, and Biden started looking at him.....
Plus, he got only two questions!!! and the LEAST airtime!!!
Facts
I can’t stand him. He’s too desperate. And I’m from Brazil.
MaXusPoint how is yang desperate wtf?
Moderator thinking: " I better say something to interrupt Yang before it becomes clear we are not smart enough to follow what he's saying"
I wanna like this twice
I find it amusing that a lot of people criticize the American people as being "dumb" and "not liking" candidates that are "too smart", but Yang comes along and ends up appealing to a much wider portion of the populace. Maybe part of the problem is that politicians and a certain fairly large base of voters has been underestimating the intelligence of a large portion of the population. A lot of people assume that if someone disagrees with them that those people must necessarily be unintelligent. Maybe that assumption is actually a better indicator of a lack of intelligence than anything else.
Alex Zorach amen
I think as Asians we need to be more vocal about the issues that are going on. Not being ignorantly vocal, but stating facts that are visible whether it's TV, movies, or in our daily lives. It's always unpleasant to think how movie industries portray us asians. I don't watch many movies but take these superhero marvel movies as an example, they always find these Asian stereotypical looking or at least make them look stereotypical to make us look unattractive. I can really see how Andrew is using these stereotype and owning it like in one interview he said: "You know I'm Asian, so I work hard". And when he says it, it has a positive connotation. We gotta own these stereotypes and use it in a positive portrayal. Not letting others abuse this and this it's funny.
Maybe he will get more traction if he bumps the bribe up to 5,000 a month.
Never voted for a democrat before but I like this guy a whole lot. Intelligent dude.
Good, dont start now... Hes an intelligent guy, but his policies are terrible... like... opposite of what the american people have said time and time again that they want. The only reason the guy has a following online is because of his free money. its 100% not doable. If you do the math... its completely illogical and just a pipe dream. What you are left with is a very anti gun, anti middle class, anti ... hes just like every other left leaning dem... He sounds good on stage though... very confident. heh
@@Kiba69420 NOT TRUE. You do the math, it.s explained in Yang.s website about the purpose, benefits and funding of it. It.s much more than "free money"
Obeyance DeKat how I see it, it’s fitting. It’s similar to how Alaska does it. All I know is that our current welfare system is broken and entrapping. I also recognize that technology is slowly taking meaningless jobs away. I’ve seen it first hand in manufacturing, I see it at the Walmart across the street, Taco Bell, McDonald’s, even the mall is dead here due to online shopping. The only jobs that will be left in the future are service jobs... so yeah. Plus, I enjoy the fact that he isn’t a career politician. He has some NEW ideas, America was founded on an experimental new idea as well... but I respect your opinion.
Awesome! He’s really different from most of the democrats running. I’ve watched a lot of his interviews and he’s against identity politics and is really logical instead of just pandering to people’s emotions. Universal basic income is also a pretty solid plan to transition workers into higher paying jobs as automation eliminates their old ones. I’m really surprised that none of the other candidates are focusing on such an important issue (but it’s the DNC what else can you expect)
@@Kiba69420 you have no idea what your talking about just another party clinging voter
Guys, they muted his mic and then lied about it, get the word out.
Jonathan Quarles
No they didn’t 😂
@@MMAGamblingTips Have any proof? Because you might as well be spewing bullshit without backing anything up.
When?
Yes, please point out at what time. As far as im concerned this is just a troll a this point.
Yes, spread the word before NBC shuts down these comment sections.
Notice how when Yang speaks everyone just listened. None of the candidates really interrupted
That's cause he's too intelligent for them.
I want him for president🇺🇸💪
Unfortunately he most likely will not win this popularity contest for president, but people should be listening and I think he’ll have a place in someone’s cabinet for sure.
It is hard to overcome knowledge and facts with canned sound bytes...
Most people hearing this for the first time in this way will think this UBI plan is ridiculous and stupid. Others addressing it could legitimize it for the audience.
The Only person talking about automation and Amazon paying $0 in Federal taxes.... THINK about it.
Troy Propes my coworkers 7 peoples now to one because of automation. I can see the future of our young generation gonna be hurts. Yang is the only one that talking about future.
He's the only one that has a brain and not blinded by corporate money
Yup. Just tells us their sob stories. Bring race into this debate (Harris) to rowdy up the crowd. Yang is doing what’s right.
@@Jenny-wd3hp People call him futurist, no, he is a presentist, other candidates are just stuck in the past.
Trump. Yeah i know
The only candidate who talks like a normal person.
Yes. That's so key. I don't trust ANY of the others. Least of all, Kamala. Bernie and Joe are cool but too 20th century.
It’s been 8 years since I’ve seen a candidate I can support... it’s refreshing ✊🇺🇸
Are you guys going to address the muted mic situation? .. and by address, I mean acknowledge that there are videos showing it - don't say it didn't happen, its insulting👍
Really. It is no conspiracy theory when Yang himself said it, and you can see him f#$^%#@ talking on video.
This video is propaganda to push the narrative that the mic was never cut.
@@mgenetos Should we believe the transformative candidate that is sincerely trying to help the struggling working class in conjunction with the video evidence or the anonymous dipshit on CZcams that likes his own comment....hmmm
Spartan40 who’re you trying to attack?
Spartan40
Yeah, I’m interested in whom you’re trying to attack as well.
NBC is a joke... I can’t believe yang only spoke for less than 3 minutes
Yinng-yang
cos chuck and his boyfriend with the glasses sitting besides him
I counted: 2 minutes and 37 seconds total.
Listen to Andrew Yang on Joe Rogans podcast if you wanna hear more of him. Everyone keep spreading the word about Yang because the media clearly wants him to speak as little as possible.
There are so many good interviews from Yang too with recent policy details. Literally CZcams Andrew Yang and he'll explain all kinds of great plans in a deep but digestible way
I agree about the Joe Rogan podcast. It's the best place to start. America needs someone like Andrew Yang. Mainstream media is just not doing any justice.
Mike Godette Music after JRE, FOX news has some great interviews with him too... which is ironic, because the pro Democrat channels like the debate one don’t give him a microphone. That crowd may have even sneered after one of his answers. Unfortunately for those who vote traditional democrat, it would appear that those days are over. The new position for that party is much further left than Bernie was in 2016 and too far left for the Vice President who was in office just 3 years ago.
@@earlaweese Absolutely! With the power of social media, we have the ability to spread Yangs message to tons and tons of people. If they try to pull the same crap at the next debate, I can't even imagine the shit storm they will set off on the internet. Glad to see that Yang has an army of people online willing to defend him and spread his message no matter what
And the Rubin Report! Dave asked him some good questions and follow-ups on issues many people would feel concerned or conflicted about.
I'm 15 and Asian-American, I find this truly inspirational that Yang has made it this far. Win or lose, Andrew you are a role model!
Welcome to Yang Gang I'm almost Asian but British hope you guys get him elected!
I'm glad you have someone to look up to!
Before this vid: Who is Andrew Yang?
10 hours later: Yang Gang 2020, Yang Gang 2020!!
Welcome to the Yang Gang!
i want some yang bucks
@A Oh That's totally a fine reason to vote for him. A lot of people could use the money and it's not something to feel ashamed about. the US should feel ashamed for creating an economy that makes so many people live in poor conditions everyday in fact
@@bunnyheaven27 Well said! 1000 dollars seems very small to some people but it can be a life changer for others. To me, a student, that will help me actually do laundry!
@@bunnyheaven27 I agree, we contribute to the wealth and what do we get? high debt from tuition, no stable healthcare, no investment in infrasture and communities at the expense of the 1%. It's our time we finally get a share and more Americans need to get on board if they want to their lives to be better!
The only forward thinking candidate. All the others are stuck in the Dust Bow And Jim Crow Era. He was the only one who didn’t give these lame anecdotal sob stories about racism and despair. Phew! He’s the real deal, not a fake caricature of a president.
The old days of busing denied.
@@memadman Kamala Harris' parents were upper middle class; a professor and a science researcher. She grew up in Berkeley, not Birmingham AL. She obviously got a stellar education but she wants us to think she was a compatriot of those little girls killed in the bombings in the 60s. She STOLE Andrew's time away from him with the help of bad moderators. She didn't follow the rules and she should not be invited back to the next one.
b. 93 Uh yeah, you cant say that about Bernie though
@@Jerbraska Bernie is also a millionaire pretending to be a regular Joe.
It's dismissive to say these people's stories about racism are sob stories. Let me guess, you're not a POC, so you could really careless about the racism they may have experienced because it doesn't effect you, so therefore you don't care to listen.
cowards... NBC noticed the backlash of not letting him speak last night and instead of addressing it, they make a 4 minute compilation absolutely unacceptable
It was an Asian-lash
@@rotcbear5112 you are funny!
I only watch NBC for the game shows. I get my news from other sources.
Not bad considering they turned off his microphone and gave him the least amount of speaking time.
Jj W
did they really turn off his mic?
skra skra yes
I think as Asians we need to be more vocal about the issues that are going on. Not being ignorantly vocal, but stating facts that are visible whether it's TV, movies, or in our daily lives. It's always unpleasant to think how movie industries portray us asians. I don't watch many movies but take these superhero marvel movies as an example, they always find these Asian stereotypical looking or at least make them look stereotypical to make us look unattractive. I can really see how Andrew is using these stereotype and owning it like in one interview he said: "You know I'm Asian, so I work hard". And when he says it, it has a positive connotation. We gotta own these stereotypes and use it in a positive portrayal. Not letting others abuse this and this it's funny.
Where in the debate does it prove his Mic was off
@@weltfenos1021 Did you watch the full debate? There was multiple times he tried to speak up but his mic was off
Everything Kampala Harris said - 25 k views
Everything Andrew Yang said - 165k views
Hmmm, maybe the house democrats picked the wrong candidates to back😆
Mr Clean 328 tbf CZcams’s public is relatively of a younger age that tends to support more radical candidates..
Kampala Harris LMFAO
@@myxNL We're the ones that will still be alive when the policies get implemented. I wish the older generation would stop thinking of change as something radical.
Communists everywhere watched
Robo Phobia We're Americans, if you don't like it go to a different continent. See if you like it better elsewhere.
Good luck Andrew yang. I hope America wakes up and votes for you.
A UBI is a TERRIBLE idea...
@Arena Rat remember: it's "free" money
I doubt they will. I see trump 2020 in the future.
Andrew Yang would better explain something so transformative to America, as his Freedom Dividend, if NBC didn't try to silence him and turn off his mic.
The gave him less than 3 minutes total.
DEMOCRATS
Maps Andjunk Transformative, but not good. Anyways, he was indeed treated unfairly.
I swear the Democrats are gonna be rigging this whole thing like they did with Bernie SMH
Yeah, it sucks, but he goes into full detail about it on The Ben Shapiro Show.
@@fivecentsworth-trouble9490 RATS LOL
Yang is the kind of think and act outside the box candidate who can beat trump. Candidates of establishment politics shall carry on the loosing legacy of Hillary.
hes the only one other than tulsi to have conservatives on their side. Personally, if Yang somehow is the one representing the democratic party I will vote for the Democrats just so our political parties aren't so separated and he truly thinks for the future where automation is near us.
If Yang doesn't win this or get cheated by the Democrats? I wouldn't be surprised if Trump won again cause Democrats have to much of a hierarchy/popularity within their party
No way he can beat trump he not even smart enough choosing the right party
You're an idiot.
rename the video to “the only things we let andrew yang say during the democratic debate”
The only guy with an actual brain stem. Not basing his campaign off an emotional agenda. Might be voting dem for once. Yang 2020.
only brain stem in the democrat party
@@Nullrun yep, let's hope they'll see that...lol don't hold your breath!🤣
Jesse Gonzalez rather have him then the other nutjob Bernie Sanders. If it was Trump or Yang I wouldnt care who won tbh
They all have brain stems, it's the prefrontal cortices that are not developed.
@@jesseg8298 he addressed this in literally all interviews he ever did. Take a few minutes to look it up.
If I was an American citizen I would have voted for Andrew Yang
People who are working in fields at risk of automation takeovers in the next 5-10 yrs should be worried and we need to prepare for that. Not everyone can learn a new skill or trade at age 50, people should work for their money, until people arnt needed for that job, then what?
Don't worry, I will do it for you.
CockatooDude daaaaaaamn
@BRUH most people still gotta work, $1k/month is below poverty line
As a Canadian, I wish we had someone like him to vote for. I don't want to vote for any of these guys
The BIG difference between European VAT and American Yang's VAT is Yang's VAT money would go directly to the hands of people.
Also, when he was on with JRE and with Shapiro - where he got more time to explain his idea - his VAT was designed to faze out production-side taxes (such as income tax), and the $1,000 is in lieu of all other forms of government welfare, effectively ending those programs. I still disagree for the most part, but way more moderate than every other Dem candidate on either night.
Those wellfare programs are there for the Democrats to remind the poor who to vote for. Its a manipulation tactic to keep them in power. "Look at the Republican they're trying to take alway your support system but we are not" and if Yang finds a solution to tear down those welfare program, that means the Democrats will lose some leverage over them. Yang is looking for solutions to improve the poor, Democrats want them to stay poor in order for the poor to keep asking for more help and they stay favorite for there votes.
@@Lordloss646 Well said!!!
O.K wow
@@Lordloss646 I have to disagree. The Democrats aren't trying to keep anyone poor, but they are definitely trying to help those who may need some help. The Republican party has been trying to dismantle these programs for ages, with no kinda plan to replace it with. So now ask yourself, if the Republicans had their way, these programs would be gone, and many of millions of people would struggle because they just don't have the means. So all this bullshit about Democrats using tactics to keep people poor is straight bullshit. Republicans are a selfish group of ppl who lack any morality or empathy for others. It's clear as day and evident. So miss me with your bullshit
Yang is so far ahead of the other candidates that they didn't even challenge him.
@BRUH so $1000 would cover your rent with $100 left to spare for a whole month. You would have to be getting some supplemental income to survive. Keep in mind, UBI is significantly better than welfare as well. UBI is fair, less administrative overhead, and doesn't incentivize avoiding work giving you the freedom to use it as you wish. Would giving $1000 to the homeless be that awful if they managed to live off that? As least they'll be able to take care of themselves better than they would otherwise.
@BRUH Local businesses would likely be able to pay 10-20% more an hour once the money effectively circulates through the economy due to greater demand for goods and services. More employment opportunities and greater incentives to work.
Yes and let's have some fair opportunities here NBC every candidate should get the same time and same questions.. it's ridiculous
They keep asking the same old hacks.
What’s dumb is they tried to have 20 candidates in two days. Break it up in three nights.
Yang is a threat to Bernie, Kamala, Booker, & Biden. He's doesn't fit the agenda for the left, so in order to make Sanders & gang look good, they asked the other clowns on the edge more questions & have Bernie & the gang have responses.
@@mangomath2175 He is too civilize to interject himself. The rest are Washington hacks. Too bad it's just a popularity contest and not on best candidate for the job.
He is not done yet.
“It is not left, it is not right, it’s forward” Love it!
He's got THE LEAST amount of speaking time and yet THE MOST amount of views. You guys want Karma Harris and had her video of this chip up a day earlier than Yang, but her view is only 36K while Yang's views are reaching 200K!! And her speaking time was more than triple of that of Yang's and that should say something to you establishment ppl.
Samson Su tbf CZcams’s public is relatively of a younger age that tends to support more radical candidates..
I'm Black, and Kamala is a joke. As a matter of fact, anyone talking about racism, busing, reparations or the like are taking us backward. Just stop it and realize we are living in the 21st Century. New day, new challenges, new president. Oh, and the Freedom Dividend IS reparations!
@@myxNL Yang is much more moderate than a whole chunk of the democratic candidates.
The Breeze this is a great point. Thanks for sharing it.
All the other candidates look like they are thinking... "oh, I wish I said what Yang said.."
YANG GANG. They trying to stop yang because they know if people hear his voice its over. YANG 2020
BCuda2010 he’s the only democrat up their that had an actual policy while the others criticized others and said orange man bad.
Nah TRUMP2020
@@returnofhorusthegalacticor9704 why?
they also hide his face, on NBC, when a reporter was talking about who would be at the debate, when they said Andrew Yang, his screen suddenly turned off and showed a blank screen where Andrew Yang's face would be.
trump 2020
I like Yang... I'm not sure about his whole $1,000 a month idea, but he seems to be the most reasonable democrat on stage.
Timothy Mora why not sure?
That will work, even Mark Zuckerberg is for it. He has 'friends' at Silicon valley who support his idea and even Jeff Bezos himself will definitely support him. Don't be afraid America. Last few decades policies are not working, more so for the 21st Century. Time for America to move on, and along with the rest of the world. Vote for Andrew Yang.
Couldnt you use an extra 1k a month? If you dont yoi can donate it to someone who is in a worse situation. In a way we can take carr of each other with that money. And not relying on corporations to do it.
@@skaracaesar4789 Yeah, the owner of Facebook wants it... How stupid are you?
What The what are you talking about? Zuckerberg is officially supportive of UBI, on the record.
Disgusted by the lack of time Yang got? Check out his in depth interviews with Sam Harris and Joe Rogan! He'll surely win you over.
I love his book too, "The War on Normal People"
i actually like his debate with shapiro the best
Just had one on the h3 podcast too! Watched all 3.
Cmon NBC let yang speak.. all the others kept interrupting and not following the rules
>NBC uses ignore_asian.exe
>Internet uses 'Task Manager'
-
*End Process*
-
*End Now*
>NBC takes a critical hit!
Task failed successfully
Don't need to racialize this, comments like these just come off as self-victimizing for political sake.
@@redryan20000 WORD! So non-Yanglike to automatically blame racism without no evidence. There is enough REAL racism to battle and this kind of knee-jerk thing only delegitimizes that.
NBC uses ask chinese-looking man if he'd go easy on China...v
Attack is not very effective on Taiwanese man...
It is a fair question, but the fact that they only asked him two questions and one of them was about going easy on China is a red flag 🧐
Your network cheated Andrew Yang and cut his mic. Your moderators were horrible. I lost respect for Maddow and Todd.
You had respect for them in the first place?
So your saying that you had respect for Maddow before and now you lost some??? How much respect was left after she pushed the Russia collusion bullshit they way she did for two years??? I think the answer is, it's you there is no respect for!!!!!! 🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻🖕🏻
@Leon Flames @Leon Flames, Child of the Lie!!! lol 😂
The DNC banned fox news from hosting debates. The DNC will do anything to pick their winners. Yang really needs as much airtime as he can get but they are against him.
@@worstcaseofcrabsever5510 I am a Republican however I can't help but like the issues Yang touches on. He on to something when he talks of innovation murdering the middle American work force. It makes one stop and think about the entire picture. Yang is the truth and that is what terrifies the Left, they will railroad him to death, I'm saying as a Republican and paying very close attention if I voted Democrat I would gladly vote Yang🤔
None of the candidates dared interject when Yang was speaking. That's a good sign. They know he's more prepared, is smarter than them and he would wash them.
You could really see it in the expressions of Biden and Sanders....they were like "nothing to see here move along"... they had to suffer through Yang's speaking time, absolutely harrowing for them.
@@timogen1970 That's not what was on their face. It was a "oh damn, this guy is prepared and I don't know wtf he's talking about. I better stay cool".
Why would they interrupt a guy who was given a measly 3 minutes total to speak? That would be hardcore bullying.
@@robertjenkins6132 You underestimate those vultures
Pathetic NBC... Don't pick sides! Don't cut Yang's mic. He's the only one that can beat Trump
Definitely not a democrat, but I have to agree that they did this man dirty
Stop voting for celebrities and career politicians. This time, vote for a real person with real ideas. Vote Yang!
Billy Deitz except all his other policy positions are bat shit crazy and anti American.
Ya vote Yang China2020😂 no
IMHO Yang has not shown the interest and aptitude for being president. Much of it is dealing with incoming fire. He seems mostly preoccupied with trying out his chemistry set.
BRUH in a few years if you don’t have the knowledge or skills to make more than 20$ and hour there won’t be any jobs to make money because automation will take them over
John Gault Productions he already did the math on how everyone should get 1000$ with the value added tax, if his math wasn’t correct any other of the candidates would have called him out on it. Those big tech companies have enough wealth that aren’t being taxed that can be taxed and cover the cost of the ubi, the ubi isn’t to be lived off of, its to help people pay off student loans, credit cards, etc. That’s why it’s called the freedom dividend, so it can make you free and let your life have meaning other than focusing your life on paying debt.
Andrew Yang is a candidate that actually has the entire American population as the first priority instead of the corporations. I really hope that he gets more of a chance to speak so that he can show the people who dont know him how amazing he truly is. He has the metal to back up his words, he has the facts, and even the policies and strategies needed to give the American people a great chance at making their futures brighter.
Don't understand why they only gave him 2 direct questions.
And not just that, one of those was about China foreign policy. Now, if that isn't poking at the racist bear...
"Everything We Allowed Andrew Yang To Say at the Democratic Debate in Miami"
"Everything Andrew Yang said ..."
NBC : *MUTES MIC*
Yang :
I think as Asians we need to be more vocal about the issues that are going on. Not being ignorantly vocal, but stating facts that are visible whether it's TV, movies, or in our daily lives. It's always unpleasant to think how movie industries portray us asians. I don't watch many movies but take these superhero marvel movies as an example, they always find these Asian stereotypical looking or at least make them look stereotypical to make us look unattractive. I can really see how Andrew is using these stereotype and owning it like in one interview he said: "You know I'm Asian, so I work hard". And when he says it, it has a positive connotation. We gotta own these stereotypes and use it in a positive portrayal. Not letting others abuse this and this it's funny.
Andrew Yang for US president. Hard for him to hear if the mic is off. The guy has solutions to America's chronic problems. Vote for this guy to retain American sanity which will affect other countries. Though he got the least time, still delivered a punchy last words. The best candidate and future US president ever.
He didnt even get to talk. Asked him 2 questions and you cut of his mic. Smh. Dirty again. 2016 all over again
Oh
um...what the shit, bro
Joe Barco ah, shit here we go again
Anyone else find it lowkey racist how one of the only questions that was directed towards Andrew was about foreign policy in China?
That definitely didn't go unnoticed. A complete low blow and racist as hell.
It's such bullshit, the question was obviously a curve ball towards him. They sit there and can pick all the questions for them instead of letting the candidates themselves raise their most important policies and go from there. It's amazing that a corporate media company can host these debates in the first place. it makes no sense, it should be on a nonprofit government controlled channel with hand picked hosts that has made no sign of collusion or biased views.
talkandramble I thought it made sense.
No not racist when you're actually talking to the only candidate who has a brain on that stage!
Im asian it wasnt racist. Just a simple question that others take to far
First Asian President? I'd vote for him and I'm not a Democrat
Saint3-20 so you’re voting bc of race like what happened with obama. Bravo.
@@MoarButtsecks no I was saying he has the potential to be I actually like what he's saying and I agree with what he says. Sorry I should've been more clear
TrashPosting yeah I wouldn’t vote for anyone based on representation crap but I do think yang is the best democratic candidate.
Chuck Todd is an arrogant, attention-loving host.
“It is not left, it is not right it is forward.” - Andrew Yang 2019
That’s the greatest thing I’ve ever heard
ARCANUS my channels show is called “ moderate migraines “ where we try to find moderate solutions for many political issues.
I recently did an interview with a yang supporter please check it out!
"It's LEFT, slave *cuts mic*"
- NBC 2019
Donated to Yang after reading his book "The War on Normal People", I think there is a free audiobook version on CZcams somewhere. First politician I've ever donated to.
Check him out on the breakfast club. I donated right away after listening to that.
Yup there is
Earla Weese Listen I get that you have good intentions but if anything you’re hurting his chances by being like this alright
Why only two questions for Andrew Yang, NBC?
because he isnt radical like everyone else on the stage
@@wakichunu well i wouldn't qualify Biden as a radical. Just a corporate sellout
wakichunu Kamala is more conservative then Trump
@BRUH I'm curious as to what idea you would like to see to counter the estimated 800 million jobs (around 1/3) that's going to be replaced by automation. Some might go to new jobs. But i don't see where 800 million new jobs are going to come from...
@BRUH damn you must be a wizard if you're capable of living off of $1000 a month
And if they didn't cut his mic, this video would be twice as long.
Exactly. Make no sense for billion dollar companies to pay nothing in taxes.
I LOVE “it is not left, it is not right, it is forward!” Idc about the $1000 a month. I want a candidate that does not vote D or R but for what is best for the nation!
The thing about 1000$ a month is that it would cause a massive inflation of take home products, but I do think that andrew yang is more qualified than people like sanders.
You sound like a trump voter
@@thotpolice2241 well the inflation argument is a complete myth. There are only 2 things that cause inflation. Increase in the amount of money in the US economy through the federal reserve, and when supply no longer reaches demand. The UBI doesn't print money for it, and most consumer goods are sold with a surplus. So i don't see where the inflation is coming from
Folks, the candidate with the biggest mouth, never get thing done. Andrew Yang has a clear vision for America. We need to continue supporting Andrew Yang.
I'm surprised he didn't answer 'just print more money'.....
Like someone who iffers free money to everyone?
Brian S that money isn’t going to be printed out, it’s going to be covered by big companies whose wealth isn’t being taxed. They have more than enough money that can be taxed that would cover the 1000$ a month, he already did the math, if the math was wrong another candidate would have called him out on it by now. The 1000$ isn’t for people to live on, it’s to give you the boost to pay off student loans, credit car loans, etc. That’s why it’s called the freedom dividend so it can free you of debt so your life can have meaning beside focusing all your energy on paying off debt
mdd1963 ^
@Brian S giving money to American is better than our government gove cash to warlords oversea. The US is the world richest country on earth but we have millions of people homeless. The $1000 will help the homeless, and support poor families. We have to be strong at home for us to keep being # one country in the world.
You mean everything the moderators and production team "allowed" him to say with a microphone turned on.
The only president we need. Everyone else is a waste
Andrew yang is the only Democrat worth listening to.
We want more Andrew Yang. Don't cut his mic again.
@NBC - all the comments here are your feedback. Make sure y'all read it and make the adjustment accordantly. 😉
Food Nation check out my interview I did with a yang supporter on my channel about the benefits of UBI
Why did Yang mic turned off? Don't cheat. That's pathetic. Are you really that scared of Yang, that you have to use dirty disgusting tactics to shut him down?
They are scared!
It's very obvious and clear that it was rigged.
THEY CHEATED bernie in 2016 and look what happened.
Democratic party play dirty, and America get Trump. It is the Democratic fault if Trump get re-elected.
Wait a minute. Does the democrat elitists actually intentionally let Trump win?
Gerald L hopefully Yang runs again. I feel that if he doesn’t get more recognition the second debate he’s done for this election. I’m still voting for him
He is going to get such increased support because of this lol.
TinnieTa21
Someone wrote that it was the "Streisand Effect'.
Yang's ending statement was really good, I hope next debate he is in that frame of mind the whole time.
Only candidate that uses the most up to date scientific consensus and data driven policies. Everyone else just uses easy to understand intuitive identity politics.
Andrew yang needed way more time then this
Should be 3 min answer from each and no banter !!
He'll get more time. He's already stated he didn't know he would be treated like this and will work his way around it in the July debates. Plus as September comes around the amount of candidates will dwindle to something actually digestible.
@@earlaweese Say my name, say my name !!
this video is 4:47 minutes,wheras yang only got 2:58 minutes lmao
Yang is the only candidate talking about the real threat to livelihoods of millions of Americans! We need this front and center everyone before it really hits the fan!
The PEOPLE want Andrew Yang....the people NEED Andrew Yang. I pray to God that he is the nominee.
He's going to have a tough time becoming the nominee, but if he was to be the nominee I think he'd demolish Trump with ease.
@hello
If you can vote, help nominate him by registering to vote in the Democratic primary.
@@artsparadisopracticaleduca4378 already registered
America please endorse this man. We are crying out for a politician like this across the pond, the world needs someone focused on problems, not all the other BS.
Why are Yang fans not raising more stink about the muted Mic?
they are
We are. They keep muting our mics though.
Check Twitter. Even Shapiro is talking about it
#2 on trending in Twitter, in the U.S. at least.
Yang calls them , YangGang
A 3 hour debate and this man gets to talk for less than 5 minutes. Shameful, MSNBC. Just shameful.
not even 3 minutes
This guy seems really cool. No emotional bullshit, just cold hard facts.
LET ANDREW YANG SPEAK. We don't care about Bernie, Joe, or Kamala yelling at each other. We KNOW you turned off his mic!!!
Video title is deceiving. Since his mic was frequently turned off, this couldn't be 'Everything Andrew Yang said' because a lot of what he said could not be heard.
They meant to title it "Everything Andrew Yang said while the mic was on"
Yes! A breath of fresh air. Yang2020
They barely let him speak! Not enough fresh air coming out of Yang's mouth. :/
Ying-yang.
I watched the debate last night and I could see his mouth moving and putting his hand out to interject but couldn't hear anything. I was wondering what was going on with that but now I know they had his mic turned off. It's despicable.
I'm a Trump man, but at least Yang has some serious policies. He has more to say than 'Orange man bad.'
This video is longer than the amount of time he was given to speak
We're gonna have to show up at all the other candidates rallies and start chanting Andrew Yang while live on tv. It's the only way
I didn't even know he spoke lol, they did him dirty.
1 minute per hour, I don't blame you, it's easy to miss.
@@djmuscovy7525 I probably wouldn't vote for him, But I like Andrew yang. Seen him on the Joe rogan show before anything.
Ying-yag
"Mr. Yang, you propose to give every American $1,000 a month, which cost an estimated $3.2T. How would you do that?"
But Bernie's $32T healthcare plan is okay?
SPPSports but health care still costs 32 trillion Bernie is just replacing that
No candidates healthcare plan costs 32 trillion, that figure is complete bogus (not to mention completely unrealistic as annual government revenue is about 4.5 trillion). Currently we spend twice as much on healthcare per person as other countries that have socialized healthcare. Studies done on the feasibility of universal healthcare in America show that it would cost about half of what we spend on healthcare now, which is 1.1 trillion a year. So we'd end up saving about 500 billion a year on healthcare as a nation. Yang and Sanders are in agreement about this.
Nbc: let's ask the asian man about technology and China 🤦🤦🤦
I know right, that was blatantly racist.
This guy is getting my vote. I donated to Yang's campaign too.
Simple explanation for anyone who doesn't get how the VAT would work. Yang already said the VAT will not apply to everyday essentials like food and diapers. The VAT under Yang's plan would be around 10%. Imagine you getting a $1000 a month and you buy a $600 big screen TV with the 1000 from Yang's UBI. That means you will pay a VAT of $60 plus sales tax around 8% which would be $48. That still leaves you $292. Now imagine buying a big screen TV every month. You'd still have something left over every month. No matter how you calculate it you're still coming out on top.
Charles Lee The problem I have with the VAT is that instead of taxing The corporations he loves to attack, he proposes a tax on all of us. Why not tax the big corporations like he said?
@@jfcha744 This is taxing the corps. the most. He's just using the VAT as an unbiased way to tax everyone more fairly.
@@jfcha744 because taxing corporations directly is harder to do. Even Bernie Sanders doesn't have plan on how he'll tax rich people and corporations. There are too many loopholes that keep corporations from paying taxes. For example Jeff Bezos the richest man in the world only reports an income of $80,000 a year. Even if he pays 100% of that it's nothing. If you try to impose a high corporate tax and close every single lope hole they just move the operation over seas into tax friendly countries.
If every person gets $1,000 a month, you'll want to discourage irresponsible spending on things you don't need right? While encouraging spending on the things you do need, such as new training and education. That's the purpose of VAT here
@@jfcha744 On one of his interviews, he described something like an automation tax for companies like amazon for every automated activity. That alone almost pays for the UBI. The VAT is the proposed solution to make sure that EVERYBODY pays taxes. The richer you are, the lesser taxes you pay. Wealthy people spend a lot of their money on luxury and that is how you tax them.
So refreshing to hear new ideas coming from that stage. You got my vote mr. yang
it is not left. it is not right. it is forward.
Andrew yang 2020, room went silent when he speaks, he's light years ahead.
LMAO!
I really hope Yang is the nominee... He's seems like the only one who is not bat shit crazy
You can help nominate him by *temporarily* register as a "Democrat," vote for him in the Democratic primary, and then switch back to whatever party you align with right afterwards.