He did the encore because the people, -who he is singing for, really- are the ones who wanted to experience again the utter brilliance of that song, and the way he sang it. Performers could not exist without the people to watch them, remember that. Every time I hear this song, I feel lifted to another place in my mind and heart, so in person, it must have been explosive and the people could not let it go. Do not make this trivial, it means something to people, enjoy it, because it is so special.
Completamente vero. Best singer in the world. I like Puccini too and i recommande you to listen Offenbach (les contes d'Hoffman), George Bizet (Les pecheurs de perles, with Gilles Dubois). Ciao
I think this performance is an excellent answer to his critics who say he could not act, that his voice was past it by the late 80s, and that he ought not to have tackled heavy roles. I think this was beautiful, and obviously so did the audience there.
Seriously, I watched this video for at least 50 times with goosebumbs and tears in my eyes. I am addicted to his powerful, emotional voice. Mille grazie, Luciano!
Just the fact that he would do it again, at 55, at the end of a long opera, and such an aria as this, says alot about the man as well as the singer. Manys the tenor would not have bothered, or risked it.
One of the great tenors in the whole world - Maestro LUCIANO PAVAROTTI ! RIP MAESTRO . This is one of the best renditions of E lucevan le stelle from Tosca by Puccini. I want to thank to ILoveTobin for this post!!! This is great, great art, great video for us. Bravo Luciano, for us , you will be always in our minds,in our hearts! We will not forget you and your lovely voice . Good posting!!! Great audience there,great public!!! Bravo for the BIS!!!
You bring up a good point-that the audience desperately senses the inevitable, that this may be the last time they'll see their beloved tenor sing at the top of his game. For me, I would prefer the encore to take place after the show, but I understand that's just not how it's done in opera, only every other music form.
BRUTAL....and twice! .....the encore was even more heart wrenching....and then we die. BEAUTIFUL UNFORGETTABLE PERFORMANCE NOBODY CAN DO IT. ONLY YOU Where's the Kleenex at?
Look at the joy on this man's face! They won't let him go... God, how they love him! NEVER a more loved Tenor. He is the most amazing voice of a lifetime. There will NEVER be another one for me.
@raphael44ify As Bono oft said "Others sing opera, Pavarotti WAS opera!" That is why he "owned" most of the roles he performed--he WAS the character. He didn't just sing or act the role, each character WAS a part of either his own personality or a part of his life. Therefore, he wasn't just "acting out" a part but reliving the part of himself the character represented.-----gee I miss him so!
Just amazing, Pavarotti eeks the last ounce of emotion with that trademark tone and ringing top register. Many wonderful tenors will abbreviate some of the notes ans still move you, but the Maestro has the lungs of a giant and such heart. Unique.
When I watch this, I cry. When I listen to this I forget to breathe. I remember what Dame Joan Sutherland said. "Don't forget to breathe!" Never a true word spoken.
@@zmznzbzvzmznzb And when he came in as a young inexperienced tenor, he stood behind Dame Joan Sutherland as she sat on a bench, and when he began to sing, she forgot a couple of her prompts and missed some parts. Her husband said, Joan thats not like you to ever make that mistake. She said, oh mon dio, his voice his voice!!!!!
You say that because you probably don't know the italian culture ! That's the way it goes, if people enjoy things they express it and it's the beauty of those moments !!! Each concert becomes unique ! We are not in an american professional musical where you'll be able to see the exactly same show four times a day ( emotion against perfection ) ... Grande Luciano, Grande Italia ...
Simplemente me encanta ésta interpretación de Luciano... de las casi 100 veces que lo he visto, no me canso de seguirlo escuchando una y otra vez... que maestría...
WONDERFUL. There can be only one... and Pavarotti was That One. Our 20th Century Caruso, Gigli et al - and all combined in one man. He will be forever missed.
It's an encore - that means, that the crowd applauded and asked him to do the aria again. You should definitely watch this opera, it's usually a sopranos' opera, but Pav stole the performance.. ha-ha!
I saw this on an arts channel, and I'd have to say this is my favorite performance of "E lucevan le stelle." The audience gave Pavarotti a three-minute standing ovation! Miss you, Maestro!
I wish a video existed of the time he got 165 curtain calls, and the audience applauded for well over an hour, how could you clap that long, you could if it was Pavarotti, and I never got to see him live, never even knew he existed. I cant imagine seeing him in person, I think I would implode, evaporate, etc.
Офигительное исполнение! Я много переслушала вариантов этой арии, но Лучиано никто не перепел. Слёзы льются от переполняющих сердце чувств, музыка гениальна! Обсолютно заслуженные, несмолкаемые овации.
Thanks for a great production ultimate collection of the best of classical OPERA- most tenor delight by PAVAROTTI, MISS MY FRIEND God BLESS HIS SOUL WORTHY OF HIS GLORIOUS PARADISE…..
I keep returning to this video ,please never ever remove it. Must find a way to get this video out to everyone. Good things are worth repeating over and over....
E lucevan le stelle... ed olezzava la terra... stridea l'uscio dell'orto... e un passo sfiorava la rena... Entrava ella, fragrante, mi cadea fra le braccia... Oh! dolci baci, o languide carezze, mentr'io fremente le belle forme disciogliea dai veli! Svanì per sempre il sogno mio d'amore... L'ora è fuggita... E muoio disperato! E non ho amato mai tanto la vita!...
First time i heard maestro singing this aria I was frezzed , couldn't explain my emotions, iI could make mess i room break things or sing loudly , only a maestro could do this :D
from Jose' "Timo" Sepulveda.......I am devoted to Placido Domingo and consider him to be the greatest tenor of his generation.......BUT DEAR GOD, LUCIANO WAS OTHER WORLDLY!!!! That mighty voice will outlive Caruso's....unbelievable. Puccini stands head and shoulders above all other operatic composers.
Placido Domingo knew he was no match for Pavarotti. He is not the greatest, you can talk about anything to compare, but no one compares with Pavarotti, more tears cried for his performances than any other will equal, no. matter how long they sing.
Watch 5:33 ff., this is how we artists celebrate the long applause! Close your eyes, hear it, feel it, suck it inside, keep it, that is what leads us on the stage!
Il rimpianto della mia vita, è esser nato troppo tardi, e non poter più ascoltare dal vivo quella voce celestiale... spero solo di poterlo sognare un giorno...
Piango ma sento allegria. I sit quietly in reverence listening to this voice, this interpretation and feel that we are so blessed to have witnessed the genius and power of Pavarotti. A voice like this, a power of interpretation like his, live forever.
REMEMBER THIS IS AN OPERA, VIRTUALLY UNHEARD OF WITHIN CONTEXT OF OPERA. EVEN CONDUCTOR OREN WAS AMAZED. Tosca usually is the soprano's opera, however this Time PAVAROTTI Stole the performance. Notice when he acquieced how the applause increased. He sang the encore just as 'FULL OUT' as previously done. Difficult to do he returned into the character when he moved from the wall at the pivotal time. Completion he received almost all the bouquets and another standing OVATION.Ihave on LASER DISC.
What I like best about 'Big Pava' is his uncomparable voice. You make a good point though, he showed up the critics who were all waiting to to fault him.
Pavarotti was and is my inspiration, But there will be others. Not like Pavarotti, cause we already had one. But there will be others that will be legends too! I hope so ,for the opera profession we need them for are art to survive the MTV culture! I like MTV , but are art requires audience particpation and focus.. and well its hard to get the 17-30 yr olds to focus for 2 hours!! We will need voices like Prices and Pavarotti's to continue this art. And we will have them. God bless you Maestro !!
The time of this performance was sure past Pavarotti's prime. And he had become the most popular operatic artist in the world. He sounded great. Performances then, when he wasn't "climbing up" any more, were for audience's entertainment. He was terrific. So why not encore?
Who Gives a Rat's ass, with whom he sang.. Im just glad he was able to share his voice with the Millions who enjoy his music.. Im not an Opera Expert... i know this.. but i dont have to be to enjoy true Talent.. This Man Had Talent..
He did the encore because the people, -who he is singing for, really- are the ones who wanted to experience again the utter brilliance of that song, and the way he sang it. Performers could not exist without the people to watch them, remember that. Every time I hear this song, I feel lifted to another place in my mind and heart, so in person, it must have been explosive and the people could not let it go. Do not make this trivial, it means something to people, enjoy it, because it is so special.
Pavarotti and Puccini, a mix of the gods
Lucas Vernieri imagine if Puccini were alive to hear him
Completamente vero.
Best singer in the world. I like Puccini too and i recommande you to listen Offenbach (les contes d'Hoffman), George Bizet (Les pecheurs de perles, with Gilles Dubois).
Ciao
Yes, also carreras is Jesus.
This is absolutely marvelous! Since his passing, the world seems to have a huge, silent void. I miss him.
I think this performance is an excellent answer to his critics who say he could not act, that his voice was past it by the late 80s, and that he ought not to have tackled heavy roles. I think this was beautiful, and obviously so did the audience there.
Seriously, I watched this video for at least 50 times with goosebumbs and tears in my eyes. I am addicted to his powerful, emotional voice. Mille grazie, Luciano!
Agree totally!
Again, I'm crying with this guy. Nobody could do this to me. He's magnificent. There's nobody on the planet to compare.
Moi, aussi, monsieur!! This is my favorite aria in all of opera. I tear up throughout. And, Luciano was magnificent.
@@oleflogger6828 I can watch it every hour, every day. Too bad he's gone.
C'est plutôt une communion entre un public connaisseur et un génie de la scène. Avec un plaisir réciproque évident. L'opéra doit être vivant.
Italy , say what you will but it is unarguably an amazing culture of arts and lifestyle
im a spirit enthusiast and all i can say; this is like taste a 35 year aged scotch whisky, pure quality, perfection, simply amazing! Rip Maestro!
Just the fact that he would do it again, at 55, at the end of a long opera, and such an aria as this, says alot about the man as well as the singer.
Manys the tenor would not have bothered, or risked it.
Yes! Yes! 💗💗💗
One of the great tenors in the whole world - Maestro LUCIANO PAVAROTTI ! RIP MAESTRO . This is one of the best renditions of E lucevan le stelle from Tosca by Puccini. I want to thank to ILoveTobin for this post!!! This is great, great art, great video for us. Bravo Luciano, for us , you will be always in our minds,in our hearts! We will not forget you and your lovely voice . Good posting!!! Great audience there,great public!!! Bravo for the BIS!!!
It's apparant that he feels the words he's singing. The audience is wildly applauding.
You bring up a good point-that the audience desperately senses the inevitable, that this may be the last time they'll see their beloved tenor sing at the top of his game. For me, I would prefer the encore to take place after the show, but I understand that's just not how it's done in opera, only every other music form.
BRUTAL....and twice! .....the encore was even more heart wrenching....and then we die.
BEAUTIFUL UNFORGETTABLE PERFORMANCE NOBODY CAN DO IT. ONLY YOU
Where's the Kleenex at?
Look at the joy on this man's face! They won't let him go... God, how they love him! NEVER a more loved Tenor. He is the most amazing voice of a lifetime. There will NEVER be another one for me.
Never a more loved Tenor? Have ye not haird of a guy called Caruso?
Te amo ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Bis indeed! The audience couldn't stop crying out and Luciano gave them another "taste" of Heaven! Bravo!
Wow, I have never heard such a long ovation.
Puccini e Pavarotti...l Italia di cui andare orgogliosi!
fogarty65
Puccini e Corelli ...l'Italia di qui andare orgogliosi !
@raphael44ify As Bono oft said "Others sing opera, Pavarotti WAS opera!" That is why he "owned" most of the roles he performed--he WAS the character. He didn't just sing or act the role, each character WAS a part of either his own personality or a part of his life. Therefore, he wasn't just "acting out" a part but reliving the part of himself the character represented.-----gee I miss him so!
Just amazing, Pavarotti eeks the last ounce of emotion with that trademark tone and ringing top register. Many wonderful tenors will abbreviate some of the notes ans still move you, but the Maestro has the lungs of a giant and such heart. Unique.
When I watch this, I cry. When I listen to this I forget to breathe. I remember what Dame Joan Sutherland said. "Don't forget to breathe!" Never a true word spoken.
yup
@@zmznzbzvzmznzb And when he came in as a young inexperienced tenor, he stood behind Dame Joan Sutherland as she sat on a bench, and when he began to sing, she forgot a couple of her prompts and missed some parts. Her husband said, Joan thats not like you to ever make that mistake. She said, oh mon dio, his voice his voice!!!!!
I return to this performance over and over again , it is like a food that one cannot ever eat enough of nor get overly filled... Bravo Maestro !!!
Exactly
LUCIANO PER ORA SEI DE BEST ❤PIÙ TI ASCOLTO…PIÙ MI FAI VIBRARE L’ANIMA 👏👏🙌🙌🤝🤝🫶🫶👍
You say that because you probably don't know the italian culture ! That's the way it goes, if people enjoy things they express it and it's the beauty of those moments !!! Each concert becomes unique ! We are not in an american professional musical where you'll be able to see the exactly same show four times a day ( emotion against perfection ) ... Grande Luciano, Grande Italia ...
Puccini's music makes you cry even when the piece isn't sad, and if then it is sung by a Pavarottti in voce....
Incomparable. Pienso que es el mejor interprete de esta aria.
I've heard him sing this numerous times. But, to do it in Roma and this well, WOW! The Italians must swoon over him. Such POWER!!!!!
tthe audience asked for another one..no wonder why..however..INCREDIBLE...:D:D:D
i sooo adore this man...:D
PERFECTION !!!
June 2016..... This aria gives me goosebumps everytime I hear it! Gone but NEVER Forgotten Maestro!
il maestro aveva l'eccelso dono di scatenare immense irripetibili Emozioni....grazie
One of my favorites, the pure emotion he projects, both times, makes me want to cry ❤️
What a moment for a grande tenoro...
Grazie MAESTRO di essere esistito!! grande commozione!
Grande....sublime....meraviglioso!!! Grazie maestro Pavarotti
This is just so fantastic. I wish I were Italian
That one oboe. Magnificent
Simplemente me encanta ésta interpretación de Luciano... de las casi 100 veces que lo he visto, no me canso de seguirlo escuchando una y otra vez... que maestría...
Just wonderful
Luciano: Sei il piu grande,Sei il Re! Ancora piango ONI Volta candor ti sento! Maestro!
Incredibile, semplicemente divino.
I have never been so frightened by a performance before!!!! Such beauty and honesty. I love it
bravooooooooo!! Maestro Luciano Pavarotti
Bravo, Grande Luciano Pavarotti!!!
Fantastic Luciano! We miss you!!!! Sei GRANDE!!!!
WONDERFUL. There can be only one... and Pavarotti was That One. Our 20th Century Caruso, Gigli et al - and all combined in one man. He will be forever missed.
It's an encore - that means, that the crowd applauded and asked him to do the aria again. You should definitely watch this opera, it's usually a sopranos' opera, but Pav stole the performance.. ha-ha!
BIS, sing it again.
I saw this on an arts channel, and I'd have to say this is my favorite performance of "E lucevan le stelle." The audience gave Pavarotti a three-minute standing ovation! Miss you, Maestro!
I wish a video existed of the time he got 165 curtain calls, and the audience applauded for well over an hour, how could you clap that long, you could if it was Pavarotti, and I never got to see him live, never even knew he existed. I cant imagine seeing him in person, I think I would implode, evaporate, etc.
Офигительное исполнение! Я много переслушала вариантов этой арии, но Лучиано никто не перепел. Слёзы льются от переполняющих сердце чувств, музыка гениальна!
Обсолютно заслуженные, несмолкаемые овации.
Tat'iana Galkina
''mnogo pereslushala variantov etoi arii...''
da, uverena ?!...
ahahahahahahahahahahahah !
Fleta,Corelli e compagnia ...
@@bodiloto Fleta? Да вы бы еще оперных певцов Древней Греции вспомнили. )))
Thanks for a great production ultimate collection of the best of classical OPERA- most tenor delight by PAVAROTTI, MISS MY FRIEND God BLESS HIS SOUL WORTHY OF HIS GLORIOUS PARADISE…..
C'est émouvant, une telle communion entre le public et un artiste. seul la musique produit de tels effets, ou du moins les arts vivants. Viva Luciano
Excellent post. I appreciate sharing the encore and the applause in between, ppl cut off their clips too early. thanks.
Dear, sweet Luciano.
Bravo Maestro !
He was Pavarotti, we can't imagine him different.
Thank you Maestro! Immortal preformance!!
Luciano lives on! it seems Puccini had him on his mind when he composed this masterpiece, Grazie maestro
I keep returning to this video ,please never ever remove it. Must find a way to get this video out to everyone. Good things are worth repeating over and over....
This is absolutely marvelous!
E lucevan le stelle...
ed olezzava la terra...
stridea l'uscio dell'orto...
e un passo sfiorava la rena...
Entrava ella, fragrante,
mi cadea fra le braccia...
Oh! dolci baci, o languide carezze,
mentr'io fremente
le belle forme disciogliea dai veli!
Svanì per sempre
il sogno mio d'amore...
L'ora è fuggita...
E muoio disperato!
E non ho amato mai tanto la vita!...
He and his voice will be treasured forever by all. This performance has me shaking. So brillliant~ Non better than 'our' Pav~! BRAVO MAESTRO~!
GRANDE MAESTRO GRACIAS
fantastisch
Just Great! R.I.P. Maestro
First time i heard maestro singing this aria I was frezzed , couldn't explain my emotions, iI could make mess i room break things or sing loudly , only a maestro could do this :D
Amazing, Bravo maestro! We miss You!
Pavarotti, I listening everday this voice , live forever, unforgetable Maestro !!!
He encored E lucevan le stelle one Saturday afternoon at the Met with Maestro Levine. I was there!
Wow. That is rare. At that time, the Met very rarely violated its policy of no encores
That was Rome with all those crazy Italians. I loved it. The Italians FEEL what others do not.@@commandert5
from Jose' "Timo" Sepulveda.......I am devoted to Placido Domingo and consider him to be the greatest tenor of his generation.......BUT DEAR GOD, LUCIANO WAS OTHER WORLDLY!!!! That mighty voice will outlive Caruso's....unbelievable. Puccini stands head and shoulders above all other operatic composers.
Placido Domingo knew he was no match for Pavarotti. He is not the greatest, you can talk about anything to compare, but no one compares with Pavarotti, more tears cried for his performances than any other will equal, no. matter how long they sing.
@@ellenlyons7413CORELOLI,DEL MONACO......
At his best! Makes me cry each time!
Watch 5:33 ff., this is how we artists celebrate the long applause! Close your eyes, hear it, feel it, suck it inside, keep it, that is what leads us on the stage!
Phenomenal performance. I remember watching this and being blown away. Thanks so much for uploading.
You saw this, tell us all about that. those of us who never SADLY AND TRADGICALLY (sp) never saw him sing live.
Meravigliosamente meraviglioso
Il rimpianto della mia vita, è esser nato troppo tardi, e non poter più ascoltare dal vivo quella voce celestiale... spero solo di poterlo sognare un giorno...
Piango ma sento allegria. I sit quietly in reverence listening to this voice, this interpretation and feel that we are so blessed to have witnessed the genius and power of Pavarotti. A voice like this, a power of interpretation like his, live forever.
Best Version of this Song!!! BRAVO Luciano!! BRAVO!
No
magic...just magic...
The master at work ... 🇺🇲
Beautiful aria!!! We miss you forever and ever!!!
REMEMBER THIS IS AN OPERA, VIRTUALLY UNHEARD OF WITHIN CONTEXT OF OPERA. EVEN CONDUCTOR OREN WAS AMAZED. Tosca usually is the soprano's opera, however this Time PAVAROTTI Stole the performance. Notice when he acquieced how the applause increased. He sang the encore just as 'FULL OUT' as previously done. Difficult to do he returned into the character when he moved from the wall at the pivotal time. Completion he received almost all the bouquets and another standing OVATION.Ihave on LASER DISC.
Magnifico Luciano❤❤❤
I love him!!!!!!!
Ah, the agony, the horrible pain!!!! I LOVE IT!!!! Somebody find the Kleenex.....................and he did it again!!!!!!
Incomparabile
BIS .............sing it again Maestro.
What I like best about 'Big Pava' is his uncomparable voice. You make a good point though, he showed up the critics who were all waiting to to fault him.
Maravilloso Luciano!!!!❤❤❤
So beautiful! Heavenly! The voice of the angels! Luciano will never be forgotten...or replaced.
Pavarotti for ever
Incredible appearance and vibrato, we all still love and miss you, Maestro!
Cómo se le echa de menos...
Que privilegio de voz .
This is one of the best of Pavarotti's E Lucevan"s videos on CZcams-thanks for posting! Just wish the text were not there to intrude
Pavarotti was and is my inspiration, But there will be others. Not like Pavarotti, cause we already had one. But there will be others that will be legends too! I hope so ,for the opera profession we need them for are art to survive the MTV culture! I like MTV , but are art requires audience particpation and focus.. and well its hard to get the 17-30 yr olds to focus for 2 hours!! We will need voices like Prices and Pavarotti's to continue this art. And we will have them.
God bless you Maestro !!
Браво, Лучиано
Os grandes interpretes nâo morrem apenas passam para outro universo Bravissimo Luciano !
Pavarotti, I thank you!
Que belleza de cancion se canta con el Alma y el corazón como solo es Señor lo hacia
The time of this performance was sure past Pavarotti's prime. And he had become the most popular operatic artist in the world. He sounded great. Performances then, when he wasn't "climbing up" any more, were for audience's entertainment. He was terrific. So why not encore?
Bravo !!!! the unique !!! Pavarotti !
Who Gives a Rat's ass, with whom he sang.. Im just glad he was able to share his voice with the Millions who enjoy his music.. Im not an Opera Expert... i know this.. but i dont have to be to enjoy true Talent.. This Man Had Talent..