CZ Shadow 2 vs Sig Sauer X5 Legion - If I Could Only Have One...
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 06. 2024
- Thanks for watching! Be sure to leave a comment and a thumbs up if you like the video. If you like what you see, consider subscribing and there’s more content on the way.
Music by Onlap.
you can never have enough beaver.... tail.... great video man!
Hahaha! I see what you did there. Thank you and cheers brother!
I own 14 CZ’s, most Cajunized. The only ones I have two of are regular SP01 and Phantom. One Phantom is bedside gun AND main SHTF rig. I have close to a hundred thousand rounds though CZ’s. They are truly the best pistols ever made
Been waiting for the showdown between these two pistols. Love the videos, very informative & dare I say entertaining, thanks KS. "Lights, lasers, chainsaws, bazookas, tiny ninjas" HA HA, good stuff!
Thank you very much! A fun matchup for sure. Cheers!
Seem like every time I have a plan for range day I end up watching one of your Uploads and I find my self changing my plans all over.
I have way to much work to do on my Glock 460 Rowland and Glock 10mm that are still conversion works in progress but now after watching this I will now add a little CZ shadow Target II fun to the mix and it will make for a very nice day. Once again thank you for you constant influence on my life.
That Shadow Target sounds awesome! Glad to help with the range influence and it sounds like you’ll have a blast (pun intended). Thank you and cheers brother!
Thanks for the video. Been waiting for this review. I’m sure you’ll help a lot of pro gun with this review
Thank you very much! Lots of fun to make. Cheers M
Glad to see the video; I just missed the live chat last night. I hate missing those!
We’ll catch up soon I’m sure brother!
Best video series on CZcams Buddy! Glad to see it posted. I agree with you. The CZ is amazing!
Thank you very much! Yes, tough to top the Shadow 2 at this point. Maybe someday... Cheers!
Nice video thanks for sharing. Sig looking great.
KS, I noticed you shoot with prescription glasses. I just got my first pair and they are progressive. Can you tell me or do a video on how best to adapt and shoot with prescription glasses as I keep losing the sights or targets!! Thanks
Good review KS. I also have both. Sig did a great job with the X5 Legion and it is now my favorite Sig edging out my P226 Legion. CZ Shadow 2 is my favorite handgun, however, the Sig X5 Legion is a close second and a keeper. Your previous review on the X5 Legion got me interested in taking a closer look and then the purchase. Great gun, very pleased. I was not going to buy anymore polymer framed handguns. Ha
Thanks Randy! I do agree about the X5. They really nailed it with the Legion. As for the CZ, it stays the leader of the pack. I’m glad you’re enjoying both! Cheers brother!
Would love to see similar comparisons with the Grand Power X-Calibur in the mix. DA/SA gun with a beautiful recoil feel.
I've been waiting for this video ever since you reviewed the x5 legion! I was at a toss up on which to choose, so thank you for clearing up some of the nitty gritty between the two! It'll be awhile before I can get either one but I'm gonna try to hold them both to see which feels better!
That's awesome Paul! I'll be curious to know which you go with. Thank you and cheers!
Thanks for another great review. I love watching CZ reviews.
Thank you Wayne! Cheers brother!
been waiting on this. i ABSOLUTLYLOVEMYX5. but the shadow is next on my list! great review KS!
Thanks Ranger! The X5 has been a real star around here for sure. Definitely a permanent resident in the collection. Cheers as always brother!
I would like to see CZ vs. Sig P226 LEGION. That would be a good DA/SA CZ vs Sig matchup.
Thanks for the video, KS!
My pleasure Alexander! Thank you and cheers
Great review! Love my shadow 2!
Great reveiw as usual, both top drawer ,out of my reach, personally I would grab the CZ. it screams pure quality & design. Thanx. P.S.
It truly is Pete! Pure quality is a great way to look at it. Thank you and cheers!
Hey man I know this is a apples to oranges question, but if you had to pick between a sp01 tactical that's stock or a Sig p320 full size that has an apex trigger upgrade, which would you pick?? Appreciate the advice and keep up the good work!
Great vídeo, congratulations!!!
I have the X5 Legion and love it but I have not had the pleasure of shooting a Shadow 2. Your videos really make me want to get my hands on one, though.
On a side note, my wife doesn’t care one way or the other about gun videos but when she hears me listening to your videos she always comments on how well spoken you are.
I definitely recommend giving a Shadow 2 a try if you get the chance. Truly an amazing shooter. Your wife sounds very smart by the way! Lol. Thank you and cheers!
CZ ROCKS! I have 4 of them! KEEP ON ROCKING! Great Video as always!
That’s awesome CJ! They do rock indeed. Thank you and cheers!
I have a CZ Shadow 2 and can compare it to a different Sig. The Sig Legion 226 SAO was bought first. I fell in love with everything about that SIG. I usually replace my pistols grips with G10 grips but not this jewel. Well... six months later I bought a Shadow 2. I really never thought it would be my favorite fire arm. It seems that every one of my friends that shoots it loves it and actually shoots a-lot better, fancy that. Lately, I have been referring to it as my desert , thats right, too much of a good thing spoils you. If I could only have one pistol it would be the Shadow!
good stuff!
Is there a good chance we can get a comparison between the Shadow 2 and the TS Orange, or would that be too much of a mismatch?
Hey KS ain't seen you in a while. Just thought I'd swing by and say Happy Thanksgiving👍🇺🇸
Great video thanks
Great video! I had been looking forward to this one. 2 of the 3 top “expensive pistols” on my list. I agree with the outcome, but still put the Langdon tactical version of the Beretta 92 on top. I know you like the M&Ps and wonder your thoughts between a P10F vs a 5” M&P?
That’s cool about the LTT Beretta. I hadn’t though about throwing that in the mix. As for the P10 vs M&P, I’d go P10. Just a little flatter and fits better in my hands. Thank you and cheers!
KSGunGuy I agree with the p10 too, just thought it would make a decent comparison video. I own both compacts and am looking for a full size, and am leaning toward the P10F, cause the trigger, optic ready slide and overall fit(the compact fits my hands better too). Love the M&P texture, but loath that hinge trigger. Once the trigger shoe is replaced that thing is awesome though!
I think you’d be well served with either to be honest. I agree about changing that shoe!
Expensive pistol? U should see the 7.5 pistol. Its a 7500$ handgun
Absolutely your best versus video KS !!!! I would go with the CZ Shadow 2. Living the CZ Life !!!!!!!
Thank you Jerry! The Shadow 2 remains the champ for sure. Cheers!
Probably should compare the cz to a sig p210.... It's not striker fired. Better yet a p226 legion. Honestly, I do like the cz shadow 2. Sig's simply fit my hand better. The x5 legion is more of a competition to the Walther ppq5 in steel frame. I'll pick the Sig over any of these "heavyweight" competition pistols. Love your videos and appreciate your love for the shadow 2
Great vid KS. That Legion actually has me thinking bout a Polymer SIG lol.
Thanks TC! The Legion is tons of fun, though sits on the fence in terms of polymer. Cheers brother!
I have the X5 and the CZ TSO (tactical sport orange).
X5: has a Trijicon RMR and 21 round extended mags. I REMOVED the front sight, it kept hanging up on my holster, the sight is sharp and catchy. This gun is AMAZING to shoot and is my EDC OPEN CARRY weapon.
CZ TSO: has a Trijicon SRO. 21 round extended mags. Orange anodized gas pedal and trigger. I looked at the TSO and the Shadow 2. I hated the LONG trigger on the Shadow 2. I have big paws (hands) so the rear checkering cut into my hand, very uncomfortable. I picked up the TSO... and oh baby! It fit like a glove! The TSO is far better than the Shadow 2.
30 seconds in...I'm rootin' for the CZ Shadow 2! Both are great though. Thanks for sharing!
Right on Christian! Thank you and cheers!
@@KSGunGuy01 And I was right! Both really are very nice... I hope to pick up a Shadow 2 someday.
I think you’ll love it!
Nice, hard to beat the Shadow 2. I have been checking out the 320 X Compact. That may be a purchase down the road.
I put a X Compact frame on my P 320 Sub Compact and WOW! the difference it makes. I wanted a rail which the SC doesn't have and the very nice grip plus 3 extra rounds found my sweet spot.
That X Compact is fantastic brother. I think you’d like it. Thank you and cheers!
So what is the difference between the models of the Shadow, and which is the best value there?
Hope there’s a chance to see a video that helps us distinguish them. I’m not even sure how many variants there are. Sounds like it would be tough duty. - if you could get a group of them lined up!
@T Smith The best Shadow is my opinion is the Shadow 2, more specifically the optic ready. It has a removable rear iron sight plate which allows you to put a RDS in it’s place and then convert back again to iron sights, but I’m not sure why anyone would want to after shooting with an optic. All Shadow’s are based on the CZ75 platform and include the SP-01 Shadow, SP-01 Shadow TR, SP-01 Shadow Orange, Shadow 2, Shadow 2 Orange, Shadow 2 Optic Ready and also includes a few CZ Custom models (though they are not USPSA/IPSC approved), the Shadow Target, the Shadow t and the Accushadow. The Shadow 2 is a result of CZ listening to the competitive shooters that were shooting the SP-01 Shadow who were modifying their pistols and CZ took that data and recreated the SP-01 Shadow, into the SP-01 Shadow 2. With the permanent inclusion of the Optics in the Production Division (IPSC), the optics ready Shadow 2 was born. I started off with a Shadow 2, then started shooting Production Optics and haven’t looked back, I sold my non-optic Shadow 2 and recently bought a second optic ready. THe optic ready S2 is not available in the US because of the weird USPSA ruling around weights, but it’s hands down THE best pistol I’ve ever shot. If you’re looking at picking up a Shadow, you can’t go wrong with the Shdaow 2.
CZ FanGrrl astigmatism would disagree with you
Agreed. Both are definitely winners. Get both.
Well said Guardian! Thank you and cheers!
Hey KS. I’ve looked for those cz grips on LOKs website and couldn’t find them. We’re they a custom order? Do you think they were discontinued? If you know that they are still around can you give a link? Thanks
*were
They were a custom order and I don’t think CZ lets them do it anymore. Thank you and cheers!
I would love to see one of these segments on budget foreign pistols. Like the steyr m9a1 and the grand power q100.. I think both are great and currently budget friendly.
R the budget pistols better value for the money....
Can you conceal carry the cz shadow 2 urban grey? Or let me rather say would you?
I have both. Both are excellent! However, the CZ is better in my view. I am interested in the Accu Shadow 2 or the Tactical Sport Orange. I am not sure which is best if goal is speed and accuracy, with more emphasis on accuracy. Suggestions welcome.
The Accu Shadow 2 looks awesome for sure! Tough to say between that and the TSO, though the TSO is very fast and accurate. Thank you and cheers!
I truly miss waiting for your new videos!
Working on some things brother!
@@KSGunGuy01 🤯
Great vid. I watch your comparison, and Honest Outlaw compare of same guns. Both had same thoughts as seems everyone. I have a Q5. Shoots well. Pretty much decided on X5 L next.
CZ seems to have the rep. Love the look of the X5 L. Just looks rugged. I’ll have check out CZ. No compete so think can/will hold off on CZ for now. Thing is...does the Legion offer much benefit over the X5 to justify $ difference?
Legion vs X5?
@@chrismartinelli9153 sig made a regular P320 X5, however it was discontinued and they now only make the P320 X5 Legion.
(Their custom shops make other non-P320 x5s as well, but those are a different animal and several thousand dollars.)
Nice Vid Brother! Definitely A #CZLIFE 👊🏼 Carry on
Thank you Big J! Cheers!
Big J everyone knows Taurus are way better than CZ .
@@dinergal56 Troublemaker! You Love Hi Point and you know it!
@@ckim6400 Sheesh don't say anything or all the CZ people will run to the stores to trade in their CZ's for hi points !
How about doing a review on Sar USA K12 sports vs CZ shadow 2
Notification for new KS video....Oh yes I stopped what I was doing to watch this one. Great comparison of two awesome firearms. I’ve held both but never fired either. They both make me drool at the gun store.
Thanks James! Truly means a lot brother. Both are definitely great shooters. Cheers as always!
Not really sure why you selected the CZ over the SIg, and it sounded as though the pick was very subjective! Kinda like, I just like blue more than black, i.e., not because the CZ made you a better shooter, but other less specific issues. Can you articulate your top reason for the CZ vs the Sig? TIA
Got booth of them !! Have to agree with u on the winner ..!! 😎👍🏽
Right on! Thank you and cheers!
I shouldn't even vote, but I am not a Sig fan at all and I really like CZs. Although I have never fired the Shadow 2; I have dry fired it at the BX and felt it is pure quality. Great presentation KS as always!!!
Well said Romans! The Shadow 2 is just tough to beat. Thank you and cheers!
Been waiting for a new KS video!!!!
Thank you very much brother! Cheers!
I’m noticing the magazines tend to rattle a bit inside the grip frame. It’s especially noticeable with the 21 round magazine. The extra space sure makes magazine insertion fast! Not noticed any functional problems, just don’t like the rattle.
I haven’t noticed that but I’ll keep an eye out. Thank you and cheers!
Great vid. Honestly I would get the legion. You could put the chassis in a carry option when not wanting to conceal the P320 X5 Legion. You can literally carry the same trigger that you compete with
Next I’d like to see the Sig 320 Legion vs Walther Q5 SF. That’d be a good battle
Rick Hunter I love my q5 match sf. I’m about the pull the trigger on this sig x5.
Yes please. I'm torn between buying one or the other 😭
If you're just talking about the Sig P320, then, it isn't a very goods battle. If you're talking the Sig P320 X-5 legion vs the Walther Q5, then, that is a much better matchup. I own the P320, the X5 Legion P320. The Walther Q4 and Q5, and thew CZ 75 Shadow 2.
Here is my opinion of their performance.
1. CZ 75 Shadow 2
2. Walther Q5
3. Walther Q4 and P320 X5 Legion (tied)
@@coryturner9140 The Q4 is great too.
Agreed. Carry on. Nothing else to 👀 here.
Haha! Thank you and cheers Larry!
I had issues with the shadow 2. Where the checkering stops on the front and back strap sticks out to far and rubbed into my hand terrible. The beaver tail also rubbed into my hand. The cz is going to cost you almost $1200 minimum. The legion $900 and has an optics cut. I have a gray gun spring, keres trigger , and apex trigger bar and mine. Plus talon sandpaper grips. Trigger Is awesome. Almost as good as an apex in a ppq with a 3 pound spring ( what I have my q5 match) . Also i shoot production and like that it came with the shorter mags that work for that class. I have $200 into the trigger and talon grips. A shadow 2 trigger is $300, new grips are $100 and optics/lightning cut is $400. So $1100 vs $2000 after upgrades.
Right on! Sounds like you’ve got the Sig dialed in. Thank you and cheers James!
graynote I had a shadow 2 for a week. It’s the only gun I ever sold. I love cz’s and I assumed I’d love the showdown 2. I held one a bunch of times before buying it. But I’d never shot one till I bought it. I grip my pistols really hard for recoil control. The shadow 2’s transition from checkering to non sticks out to far and would dig into my hand. I had to put tape over the transition section on front and back. I shot the A01-LD and it was great. Much more refined in the checkering. But for $2000 I guess it better be. I’d still have my shadow 2 if it had the same grip as the A01-LD.
KSGunGuy made a huge mistake. Do not put a apex trigger bar or gray gun lighter spring in ( it was actually counter productive) Definitely put in the keres trigger though. It gets rid of all take up and reset.
I must admit I was shocked when you picked the CZ over the Sig. It sounded like a definite bias with slant towards sig through out video
Both guns are great !
Agree. To me trigger is most important. Best trigger wins, given everything else is working properly & the grip fits my hands. However a P226 or P229 Legion would have been a better comparison of features, within the class of firing mechanism. Striker pistols against striker pistols. Hammer pistols against hammer pistols.
With the If I Could Only Have One series, anything goes regardless of manual of arms. Thank you and cheers!
As owner of both myself, AGREE.
I love my pistols
1) HK VP9
2) CZ p10s (ECC)
3) CZ AccuShadow 2
4) Walther Q5 Match SF
5) Sig Sauer P320 XFive Legion
6) NightHawk Shadow customized w/rmr
Vp9 I've been waiting to get to try that. Better then p30l 9?
Very nice comparison with great points. I agree the Shadow 2 is the clear winner.
Thanks Keanon! I do agree on the Shadow 2. Just an awesome package all the way around. Cheers!
@@graynotescartridgebox True. I like both, both are good choices.
I have about 8k through my X5 I added the legion frame a month ago, makes a big difference in competition SC,USPSA , but the Shadow is a excellent HAMMER FIRED GUN...not a fair comparison with the striker fired Sig. Rick's right compare it to the Walther.......
I'd say either one is a winner, as they sport 100% coolness factor! Own both but haven't shot the Legion yet, or anything else in the last 3 or 4 months. I don't know for sure as I have yet to shoot the legion but probably would stick with the S2.
Well said Fu! Can’t wait to hear what you think about the Legion. Thank you and cheers!
since you haven’t shot the legion yet can i have it? lol!
@@bradallen9551 👍 it shoots so nice, I highly recommend it.
Great video as always. When are Tuesday night chats coming back?
Thank you Snowman! We’ll do more Tuesday chats soon brother. Cheers!
keep in mind, you can buy the tungsten grip module for 99 bucks and if you have a 320 already you can just swap the trigger module
more like 250!
@@Scott-lx6yv Holy crap, they went up
At the end of the day I wish I could have either as thanks to CA I don't think either are on the approved roster of handguns as our state knows what is best for us....LOL...Nice pistols as I hope to get to shoot em someday....Good review and detailed info as always sir....Good stuff...
The word “infringe” has been removed from the 2nd Amendment as far as Californians interpretations. Sad day that Americans have given into and submitted to a tyrannical government. The government has no legal rights to pick and choose the firearms that a citizen possess...period!
@@kevcom82 So true but the state of CA has been hi jacked and folks only want free stuff anymore....So sad....
Thank you very much Scott! Good to see you and well said my friend. Cheers!
We would gladly welcome you to Texas! get outta the worst state in the country, lol
@@bradallen9551 Thank you as hopefully this will happen but can't now....
Ks, did you quit CZcams man? Been missing your uploads and haven't saw anything lately out of you! What's gong on?
Good to see you back KS!
Thank you Jeff! Cheers!
We'll see what happens at the upcoming IPSC competition's! I don't think their views will agree with your take on the two pistols!
Uuuuurgh think you just cost me an extra $300 bucks. If I was gonna stump up the extra coin for the CZ should I consider going the extra yard for the 92X performance if I've always dreampt of owning a Beretta?
I love my optic ready Shadow 2 so much I bought a second.
Me too.
If they could bother to send a few to the USA, I'd join you...
If i could only find the rmr optic plate now id be set.
Love my Shadow 2 “it’s like cheating “
I am considering the XFive legion for home defense. Is the trigger too light?
Absolutely not. It's about 5lbs, maybe between 4-5, but not that light at all.
It’s not too light for home defense. Thank you and cheers!
@@graynotescartridgebox, the one at the Scottsale Gun Club was definitively NOT 3.5 lbs. Tim from MAC's wasn't 3.5 lbs. You must have a really good one.
I don't disagree with your pick I just have a difficult time buying a CZ for that price as they all feel like heavy BB guns made in the 70's . Yah I know it's just me but they feel so cheap. LOL. I'll have to get one, good video
Heavy BB guns made in the 70's? I don't know what the hell you're talking about and I am suspecting that you don't know what the hell you're talking about either. Anyone saying a CZ feels "cheap" has never held one. And Tungsten on a polymer frame is far more "cheap" than an all steel gun. I would refrain from commenting if you're not even familiar enough with the products to speak on them properly.
I was hoping that you’d make this head-to-head. I agree that between these two the CZ takes it. I own both of them and for me, the CZ is a “better” looking package but boy that XFive shoots well... Thanks for the video KS!
Well said MD and I agree that the X5 is an awesome shooter! Thank you and cheers!
I'd be happy with either one lol. While I've never shot either and without watching the whole video yet, I'd pick the CZ 😁
They are both awesome for sure Alpha! Thank you and cheers brother!
I sure like that intro. A cannon?
You can never have too many canons, lol. Thank you and cheers!
But of course. #CZforlife :-) Hope you're well.
Thanks 32! Living the dream my friend. Hope you are well also. Cheers!
What about the TSO? :)
I have the Shadow 2 and the X-five non-legion with grayguns kit, CZ is my favorite but the Sig fits my hands very well. I shoot my Canik tp9sfx just as good as both for 1/3 the price!!
That’s awesome and I do agree that the Canik is a sweet deal and great shooter. Thank you and cheers!
I just picked up the tp9sfx cant wait to get it out to the range
Great comparison video of 2 fine pistols. The Shadow2 ruined my outlook of polymer pistols. I'll keep my tricked out G34 and G26 but PPQ Q5 and TP9 SFX will find a new owners.
Thank you WWA! The Shadow 2 does have a tendency to do that, lol. Cheers as always brother!
I'm gonna guess before watching
CZ
I'll just say both
But for that money you could get a DWX and 20 mags 😎
Being a SIG fanboy, I would have to go with the X5. The CZ is intriguing, however...
Great review as always, KS.
Both are fantastic Mohawk! The X5 is definitely a beast. Thank you and cheers!
I agree I own all three the original X5 the shadow 2 in urban grey and now the legion X5. Shadow 2 still my favorite, but the legion version is worth the upgrade over the original!
I agree that the Legion is a great upgrade to the original! Thank you and cheers!
I have to agree, there is a reason why I have yet to go out and buy that pistolthe shadow to is the best budget competition gun on the market
@Kotaboy32 Tactical Amen brother!
Do you still hold this opinion? I see you're shooting a legion now.
The only option I like on the Sig over the S2 is the optic mount. And I’d like to put the Sig up against my TP9SFX or Q5. All bias aside, any would be an excellent choice.
Very good point about the optics cut and I do agree about the other options you mentioned. Thank you and cheers Kev!
@Richard Saunders Canada (and the rest of the world) has the optic ready Shadow 2. The only thing holding it back from flooding the US market is the stupid weight restrictions of 45oz for Carry Optics. I had the Sig X5 briefly, (VERY BRIEFLY), before CZ came out with the Optic Ready Shadow 2 and as soon as I got the OR Shadow 2, the X5 went out the door as did my non-optic Shdaow 2 because a Shadow 2 with a dot, is that good! In my opinion. Big J milled all three of his S2’s for an optic, but I think with milling you permanently end up losing the rear iron sight and you’re pigeon holed into one optic as the slide is drilled specifically for that optic (Optic manufacturers just can’t come to consensus on a universal hole pattern).
@Richard Saunders Give it some time. Either competitive shooters are going to press for change on the rules around weight restrictions or CZUB might end up making a lightened version of the Shadow 2 OR for the US market, much like they’ve modified other pistols like the P09 for the Australian market. I think their hands are pretty full with the international market right now. The OR S2’s sell out as quickly as they get them in, I was one of the first in Canada to get my hands on one and I have not looked back since. Just picked up a Trijicon SRO for my latest one. (I now own two optic ready Shadow 2’s and I barely shoot the P09 or P10F anymore, it’s that awesome!)
CZ reversible mag release?
Guns are scary and looking at those pictures made me cry :) . Really Glock and high point much better when you duct tape a nice rifle scope to them .
Been watching Acid Rock Video's again I see! )
Haha! Thank you and cheers Music!
I would agree
Thanks CCC! Cheers brother!
CZ ....shocker
with 1639 in Washington, its gonna be the Sig for me.
AGREE
I don't have a X5 Legion so I can't compare but I do have a Shadow 2 and absolutely love it...
Tough to beat the Shadow 2! Thank you and cheers!
for the Legion get the Armory craft dual adjustable trigger then tell us about it
Where you been bud??????????????????
What size grip module for that legion???
It’s the one that came with the gun... medium I think. Thank you and cheers!
Blaaaaa, the Sig out does the CZ, having both, the many features of the SIg out do the trigger as the only slight advantage of the CZ...The Shadow 2 will be in the trade out rotation for the next bigger and better gun released.
The Sig is a great gun indeed! Thank you and cheers!
Same bro
Absolutely love my X5 Legion!!!
A great gun indeed! Thank you and cheers!
CZ Shadow, all day!!!!! Great video!
Absolutely! Thank you and cheers KP!
I'll let ya know here come the end of the month when I finally get my C5 Legion. Love my Shadow 2, but I'll see how the 2 match up for myself.
I can’t wait to hear what you think Ty! Keep me posted brother. Thank you and cheers!
Wish this was compared to the CZ Shadow 2 orange