How to Tell Apart Scottish-Gaelic and Irish Gaelic

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 6. 09. 2018
  • Gaelic is spoken in two variations in Ireland and Scotland as Scottish-Gaelic and Irish (Gaelic). But how can you tell the two, which are separate languages, apart when they look so similar especially to foreign eyes?
    Donate to Alzheimer's Society:
    www.justgiving.com/fundraisin...
    Learn Scottish Gaelic:
    www.learngaelic.net/
    Learn Irish (Gaelic):
    www.duolingo.com/course/ga/en...
    Go Fund My Windmills (Patreon):
    / historywithhilbert
    Join In The Banter On Twitter:
    / historywhilbert
    Enter the Fray on Facebook:
    / historywhilbert
    Music Used:
    Skye Cuillin - Kevin MacLeod
    Feral Dub - Kevin MacLeod
    "Feral Dub” - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
    Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
    Send me an email if you'd be interested in doing a collaboration! historywithhilbert@gmail.com
    #Gaelic #Irish #Gaelige

Komentáře • 2K

  • @user-bi9kj1oh1f
    @user-bi9kj1oh1f Před 5 lety +2105

    This will literally never help me. But I'm still watching this.

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +115

      Give it a go ;)

    • @Tina06019
      @Tina06019 Před 5 lety +48

      Still very interesting, and good for strengthening the mind -- and for having a “well-stocked” mind to help one when lonely or bored.
      Anyway, that’s why I am here.

    • @LuvBorderCollies
      @LuvBorderCollies Před 5 lety +26

      LOL Same here. I'll stick with learning Norwegian. When I hear some Scots talking I can pick up traces of Norse, usually in the cadence. Same with some Danish speakers, I can hear German influence.

    • @skillsessions8547
      @skillsessions8547 Před 5 lety +5

      Ditto lol, but it's so fascinating and exotic.

    • @mskatefish
      @mskatefish Před 4 lety +3

      أحمد أشقر me too 😂😂

  • @synonym1ty
    @synonym1ty Před 5 lety +1551

    So the languages point at each other.
    The Scottish Gaelic points at Ireland and the Irish Gaelic points at Scotland.
    It’s kind of poetic.

    • @seanseanston
      @seanseanston Před 5 lety +50

      That's true... never noticed that before.

    • @ree9389
      @ree9389 Před 5 lety +7

      That is crazy

    • @YuliaHadassahK
      @YuliaHadassahK Před 5 lety +36

      @@bluemooninn Geographically, they're pointing towards each other.

    • @YuliaHadassahK
      @YuliaHadassahK Před 5 lety +31

      What a sweet thought 😊

    • @Plsdontlook
      @Plsdontlook Před 5 lety +45

      They’re doing finger guns at eachother

  • @NadaMajdy
    @NadaMajdy Před 5 lety +539

    I'm Arab and I can't speak neither Scot Gaelic nor the Irish one, but I still watched the video 💚💚 beautiful languages

    • @andykane439
      @andykane439 Před 5 lety +14

      Thank you xx

    • @andykane439
      @andykane439 Před 5 lety +16

      I like arabs worriers like us Irish good history

    • @toqa6735
      @toqa6735 Před 5 lety +28

      Sameee ههه I love their celtic culture since my childhood and me being in love with Disney's brave made it even more intense 👀✨

    • @IamAperson9
      @IamAperson9 Před 5 lety +1

      Thank you

    • @IamAperson9
      @IamAperson9 Před 5 lety +1

      But England still have northern Ireland I'm also a bit Welsh I think up ireland

  • @mcswordfish
    @mcswordfish Před 5 lety +418

    I scored 100% in the test, but I cheated by being a fluent Gàidhlig speaker.
    In terms of mutual intelligibility, I (as a Skye-man) can converse fairly well with a friend from Munster, though it is helped by him living here in Scotland with his kids attending Gàidhlig school (where my kids also attend - we became pals through meeting at kids' birthday parties).
    I really struggle to READ Irish though - when I read anything other than a basic sentence in Irish, I cannot really fathom it. However, if I then read an Enlglish translation, I'll have an "I see what you're doing there" type moment, and it makes sense.
    Finally, your pronounciations were pretty spot on though. Very impressive effort from a non-speaker. And thank you for your words of support for our languages - they can have a future, but it will be an uphill struggle, so all support and encouragement is greatly appreciated.

    • @afonsoferreira2652
      @afonsoferreira2652 Před 5 lety +7

      Hey, I wanted to send a message in GAELIC language to a girl I like saying "This book is to remind you the first person you kissed." can you help me? She loves Scotland

    • @ailinos
      @ailinos Před 5 lety +2

      Maith thú!

    • @saber2802
      @saber2802 Před 5 lety +20

      I hope Gaelic and Gàidhlig make a come back as a form of traditional revival. It's always sad hearing about a language from an old culture dying out. Being that I am Native American, I hope something similar happens to us.

    • @zacharywallace6164
      @zacharywallace6164 Před 5 lety +7

      Chan e ach gum feumadh tu fàs cleachdte ris an litreachadh "ùr" a th' aig na h-Èireannaich o chionn trì fichead bliadhna a-nist, tha e neònach dhuinne is chuir iad às do iomadh litir air a bheil feum againn fhathast an Gàidhlig na h-Alba. Ach chan eil air ach a bhith ga dhèanamh, is thig thu air adhart...
      Dùrachdan bho Uibhist!

    • @jamesoneill3922
      @jamesoneill3922 Před 5 lety +9

      I can understand my mates from Islay across the channel but I can't understand a word of my Mother's Munster Irish.

  • @kierangoddard2198
    @kierangoddard2198 Před 5 lety +501

    The accent is called a fada in Irish.

  • @CrazyMonkey679
    @CrazyMonkey679 Před 3 lety +76

    Respect to my Scottish cousins 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 from Ireland 🇮🇪

  • @monojakennedy_3758
    @monojakennedy_3758 Před 4 lety +238

    What am I as a South Sudanese even doing with this information?
    And why did i even watch it till the end?

    • @Irish780
      @Irish780 Před 3 lety +9

      Last name Kennedy maby

    • @regalsurvivor3418
      @regalsurvivor3418 Před 3 lety +1

      @@Irish780 🤣 got eem!

    • @skellagyook
      @skellagyook Před 3 lety +4

      @Accra Ababa There's also Manx Gaelic (from the Isle of Man).

    • @mitchmcginn4250
      @mitchmcginn4250 Před 3 lety +15

      Because learning about languages is fun and awesome no matter where one comes from! 😁

    • @we-qs2vd
      @we-qs2vd Před 3 lety +5

      Because we love you 😁💚

  • @TheAnthraxBiology
    @TheAnthraxBiology Před 5 lety +367

    As a fluent Irish speaker I think the easiest way to tell is the difference in the amount of "ch" sounds. Irish has far more and we also speak with less melody in our voices. Scottish Gaelic tends to go up and down in pitch and cadence more than Irish which is just a constant barrage of words and CHs.

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +33

      That's a good trick actually - after a while you start to hear the differences as well.

    • @Odinsday
      @Odinsday Před 5 lety +9

      TheAnthraxBiology Scottish seems way more jumbled as well. I’m looking at the Scottish text while listening to it and it’s like I’m concentrating on two different languages.

    • @emmsicles96
      @emmsicles96 Před 5 lety +14

      This has always been my trick as a native Gaelic speaker who studied Gaelige in Galway.

    • @100geemo78
      @100geemo78 Před 5 lety +13

      I think Scottish Gaelic sounds more beautiful than Irish.

    • @dothisjohndothatjohn2754
      @dothisjohndothatjohn2754 Před 5 lety +4

      100geemo78 Outlander fan are you?
      Yawn...

  • @domhnallobraonain6745
    @domhnallobraonain6745 Před 3 lety +61

    Love how the Scottish characters are dressed in brave heart and the Irish guys are dressed in 1916

  • @irishguy9468
    @irishguy9468 Před 5 lety +132

    In the last 14 min I learned more about my native language than my nine years of school where Irish is compulsory

    • @emmyh1468
      @emmyh1468 Před 4 lety +11

      That's so cool you got taught that our teachers in Scotland just complained for one week in English classes about our dying language but never bothered to teach us any but they did teach Scots but most speak that anyway

    • @davidtanphilosophy
      @davidtanphilosophy Před 4 lety +3

      Hello! I know it has been a year but when you say Irish is your native language do you mean you speak it as much or more than English where you live? If so fascinating! -David, Arizona USA

    • @irishguy9468
      @irishguy9468 Před 4 lety +8

      David Tan hi david well where I’m from in Ireland Co Kildare Irish is not spoken much as English but in other areas like Connemara in Co Galway it is spoken by nearly every one in the area areas like that are called gaeltachts and there are a couple of them around the country mainly in the west of Ireland where the language was allowed to be spoken as much of the native Irish people move to the west during the plantations hope this answer your question

    • @adamender9092
      @adamender9092 Před 4 lety +1

      @Dylan Stewart they actually teach French and german her pretty well to be honest

    • @fearmor3855
      @fearmor3855 Před 4 lety +1

      @@davidtanphilosophy the dynamics of where you can speak Irish is pretty interesting, it's more a language you use when you're in company that'll understand it than when you're just out and about per se

  • @bepsi6204
    @bepsi6204 Před 5 lety +660

    Well I can speak fluent Irish and I get a lot of the Scottish Gaelic

    • @cathalodiubhain5739
      @cathalodiubhain5739 Před 5 lety +29

      same here

    • @domhnallobraonain6745
      @domhnallobraonain6745 Před 5 lety +29

      Cé as sibh? Is as conamara mise. Ar fhoghlaim sibh bhur gcuid gaeilge nó ar cainteoirí dúchasacha sibh?

    • @LittleImpaler
      @LittleImpaler Před 5 lety +5

      Don't say that. A lot Irish get mad. LOL

    • @cathalodiubhain5739
      @cathalodiubhain5739 Před 5 lety +11

      Port Láirge, d'fhoghlaim mé go crua é.....

    • @gilleslabhach7904
      @gilleslabhach7904 Před 5 lety +17

      Tha Gàidhlig agam. Chan eil Gaeilge ceart cho furasta dhomsa ach, uaireannan, 's urrainn dhomh ga tuigsinn is 's e cànan breàgha a th' innte!

  • @poundlandbandit6124
    @poundlandbandit6124 Před 5 lety +96

    As a speaker of Irish and since I learned Irish in the Ulster Dialect it’s quite easy for me to understand Scots Gaelic I always felt it was such a shame the language has died in Scotland, it’s the most beautiful language in the world in my mind

    • @SeumasScottMacIonmhainn
      @SeumasScottMacIonmhainn Před 2 lety +39

      It hasn’t died! We still speak it.

    • @craigharkins4669
      @craigharkins4669 Před 2 lety +19

      Not dead yet. Although if things keep going the way they're going. I'd give it a handful of decades left.

    • @McConnachy
      @McConnachy Před rokem +21

      It’s alive in Scotland a Charaid.
      The Scots are just as Celtic as the Irish, and vice versa, but the difference is Ireland is an an independent country, and Scotland is a colony, for now

    • @OnlineRadioSchool
      @OnlineRadioSchool Před rokem +4

      I reckon if Scotland gains independence (while giving it all back to the EU straight after :) that could be a good catalyst.

    • @McConnachy
      @McConnachy Před rokem +10

      @@OnlineRadioSchool when Scotland gains its rightful place as a nation, we will be in a democratic union, where we actually get a seat at the table. The EU encourages all languages. I know older people who were beaten at school for talking in Gaelic. Also, Scotland will get to keep its revenues, unlike just now, where most of it ends up in the tax havens of the Brit Establishment ‘investors’. You need to ask yourself where £12 trillion of Scottish oil revenue has gone? The greatest heist in history?

  • @daithimcbuan5235
    @daithimcbuan5235 Před 5 lety +323

    Yer pronunciation was damn good for a Sasanach (or rather, a Frisian)!

  • @Bulldugned
    @Bulldugned Před 5 lety +51

    Holy shit Hilbert, as a Scottish Gaelic speaker you pronunciation was actually amazing, well done man , glè mhath

    • @IamAperson9
      @IamAperson9 Před 5 lety +1

      I'm Irish part welsh a bit part I think but horrible at each language not accent

  • @dukadarodear2176
    @dukadarodear2176 Před 5 lety +321

    A Donegal fisherman (Ulster) told me he can understand most of what the Scottish Gallic-speaking fishermen say and visa-versa.
    A Munster Gaelic speaker would understand much less I suspect.
    The Irish ('Scot') migration into the Highlands and Western Isles of Scotland gave rise to a culture that survived vigorously until the Highland Clearances and Culloden.
    But thankfully it's making a comeback again with help from the powers-that-be instead of persecution, as before.
    Here in Ireland the language (as a vernacular) is in serious decline.
    Everyone studies it for 13 years at primary & postprimary level but only a small number speak it outside the classroom.
    Very sad to lose such an ancient, complex and poetic language.
    It was adapted to the Latin script much earlier than most European languages by the learned monks in the numerous monasteries in Ireland and Scotland.

    • @kieranfitz
      @kieranfitz Před 5 lety +23

      martin okelly put it this way, in the leaving cert, during the listening part of the exam, you're praying to Dagda that you don't get a Donegal speaker.

    • @Odinsday
      @Odinsday Před 5 lety +5

      martin okelly You guys just need to make Irish a little more widespread. The progress you’ve made so far is impressive. I don’t want to see that progress hindered.

    • @dukadarodear2176
      @dukadarodear2176 Před 5 lety +6

      DustyO'Rusty
      I think we have to ask the Polish people here how they have made Polish Ireland's second language. One thing they seem to be doing is actually Speaking it outside school- on the street and on the trains etc.
      Imagine speaking a language in such places.

    • @SoFloShylockPrankstv
      @SoFloShylockPrankstv Před 5 lety +1

      @@kieranfitz just did my leaving this year. That was definitely the hardest part of the exam for me

    • @kungfuasgaeilge
      @kungfuasgaeilge Před 5 lety +4

      I can attest to the N.Irish/Scottish more or less mutual intelligibility. I really like the twang of the Irish spoken up north, though I think Connemara Irish (close enough to what I learned, and what I've tried to lean towards since) is the most mellifluous. Sorry to say that Dubliners tend to sound like shite in whatever language they're speaking, I always hang my head when I hear Bus Eireann making a balls of announcements bilingually.
      Nice contrast shown here watch?v=PIIAjTEvhIM between the presenter and those interviewed. I think the presenter might be western, but using a sort of Gaeilge 'RP', with the ridiculous vowels.

  • @teeprice7499
    @teeprice7499 Před 3 lety +39

    Nicely done.
    My relatives get a little confused when I talk to them, as my Irish mother taught me her language and my Scottish grandmother taught me hers... and they've mixed into one over the years.

    • @oscarosullivan4513
      @oscarosullivan4513 Před 2 lety +4

      So a creole

    • @teeprice7499
      @teeprice7499 Před 2 lety

      @@oscarosullivan4513 LMAO that's funny!

    • @elspethfougere9683
      @elspethfougere9683 Před rokem +2

      Thats so precious! I wonder if you would allow yourself to be interviewed by accademics in the language, to record what your learned down family lines, it could be really really valuable to them. I dont know anyone personally, I just know if you volunteer it will be well received

    • @teeprice7499
      @teeprice7499 Před rokem

      @@elspethfougere9683 that would be interesting

  • @ThermonucliusTROLL
    @ThermonucliusTROLL Před 5 lety +480

    Connaught is pronounced "Connuckt"

    • @Loreman72
      @Loreman72 Před 5 lety +61

      It's Connacht, with a guttural chi-sound! Just pretend you're hacking up a hairball.

    • @historywithhilbert146
      @historywithhilbert146  Před 5 lety +141

      As I said; "impeccable."

    • @ThermonucliusTROLL
      @ThermonucliusTROLL Před 5 lety +22

      @@historywithhilbert146 I forgave you once I heard you note your potential mispronunciations but it will sadly too late. My obsequiousness to my linguistic heritage got the better of me again.
      Nice use of a semicolon too, it's a lovely sight indeed.

    • @kieranfitz
      @kieranfitz Před 5 lety +8

      Edwin Cheesecake not in Irish it isn't.

    • @grimmfandango832
      @grimmfandango832 Před 5 lety +3

      the thr (fr ) in three is Norman-French. Not Insular Celtic. Same goes for (th) le as in THE. English is the love child of the Pope, Jean Claude Van Damme (he spoke Walloon French in spite of his surname) and Frisia (I can't think of any famous Frisians). English is just weird. Even Scots and Lallans are more logical than English (due to their influence being Norwegian with a bit of Danish i.e. Kirk) Less hybridisation

  • @PasscodeAdvance
    @PasscodeAdvance Před 5 lety +25

    Love from India, don't forget your language and culture!

    • @cokemilk6141
      @cokemilk6141 Před 3 lety +1

      Mmm, i dont get the point in culture.

    • @ADIMM0
      @ADIMM0 Před 3 lety +9

      @@cokemilk6141You must be a brick wall

  • @zXCFXz
    @zXCFXz Před 5 lety +555

    Is fearr Gaeilge bhriste, ná Béarla cliste.

    • @darthvader5830
      @darthvader5830 Před 5 lety +25

      Fíor an ráitis sin

    • @Gaeisok
      @Gaeisok Před 5 lety +23

      I gave my Northern Irish friend a rubber bracelet band thing with that written on it. I think I got it during seachtaine na gaeilge

    • @alexsmyth9621
      @alexsmyth9621 Před 5 lety +4

      An bhfuil tu cinnte

    • @angelcored
      @angelcored Před 5 lety +10

      Ach tá mo chuid Gaeilge agus Béarla briste?

    • @dancing2785
      @dancing2785 Před 5 lety +5

      Dia diut. conas ata tu?

  • @SlimeShows
    @SlimeShows Před 5 lety +30

    Thank you Hilbert! I have begun learning Scottish Gaelic as even though I’m English my 81 year or grandad is from North Uist and grew up mostly speaking Gaelic. Hopefully soon I can have a few conversations with him in it!

  • @Mikey5781
    @Mikey5781 Před 5 lety +10

    Thanks Hilbert, really appreciate the video. I was recently talking with a lady who came into my work from isle of Lewis who speaks Scottish Gaelic and i told her i always wanted to learn. She seemed very passionate about preserving the language. I’ll be sure to mention your video and how passionate you are the next time i see her. cheers

  • @GrantJBratcher
    @GrantJBratcher Před 5 lety +31

    I am glad you’re giving some time to the Celtic peoples writing. Please do more

  • @shaneryan7622
    @shaneryan7622 Před 2 lety +11

    Great video! When I did gaeilge for the leaving cert (Scottish equivalent to A levels). We have to listen to the 3 dialects and answer questions on it, one of the dialects is ulster and when I saw the “ciamar a tha sibh” it’s identical to Ulster Irish, it’s amazin that we have a similar language to gaeilge.. I hope in an independent Scotland we can work together to protect our native languages Alba agus Éire go brath 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇮🇪

  • @allanlank
    @allanlank Před 4 lety +6

    Perfect presentation and an example of why my ancestors gave up Gaelic for English about 400 years ago. However there is a place outside of Europe where Gaelic is spoken, Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia, Canada.

  • @RavenWard
    @RavenWard Před 5 lety +20

    The accent mark bits are correct in Scotland, but Nova Scotia Gaels haven't officially accepted the spelling reforms, and Canadian Gaelic uses the more traditional method of using both accents.
    In practice however the lots of Canadian Gaelic speakers write using the reformed spelling.

  • @kungfuasgaeilge
    @kungfuasgaeilge Před 5 lety +70

    Ooh, a note on 4:05
    In Hiberno-English we retain the (very useful) archaic 'ye' as a plural 'you'. In fact our Irish teacher invariably referred to 'sibh' and related words as the 'ye' form. (pronounced with a high 'i' sound, as in 'be' or 'flee').

    • @kungfuasgaeilge
      @kungfuasgaeilge Před 5 lety +6

      To further confuse things, up in Letterkenny they'd use some cognate to Hilbert's, being 'yizz'. "Where'r'yizz-gwooan?"

    • @qwertyTRiG
      @qwertyTRiG Před 5 lety +9

      Parts of Ireland, anyway. Certainly here in the midlands. I believe that Dublin says "yous".

    • @frankstein7631
      @frankstein7631 Před 5 lety +2

      kungfuasgaeilge
      In the Southern half of the island and is probably slowly losing ground over time.
      Ulster and some accents in Dublin use "yous/youse"(-your yizz being some version of these).

    • @jamesoneill3922
      @jamesoneill3922 Před 5 lety +1

      Youse in Ulster Hiberno-English too.

    • @cianoc8211
      @cianoc8211 Před 5 lety +8

      James O'Neill Dubliners also pluralize your to yizer which is hilarious...”bring down yizer homework and I’ll look at it”

  • @Madfattdeeb
    @Madfattdeeb Před 4 lety

    Thank you for making an uploading this video I found it both educational and fun. I also found the message at the end very touching and relatable.I to have a very close family member who is in the early stages. He is one of smartest people I have known. He was a scientist before he retired. So all my love to you and your family 💜 and thank you again.

  • @DalCecilRuno
    @DalCecilRuno Před 5 lety

    I am so happy! I got all the answers right! 💚💙
    Your explanations were very clear.
    I don't speak either of these language but I've been interested in Celtic languages and culture for more than a decade. Thank you for uploading this. Can't donate but I can share. 💙💚

  • @ciarankelly3726
    @ciarankelly3726 Před 5 lety +62

    Don't really know about Scottish Gaelic but in Ireland anyway we refer to "Irish Gaelic" as "Irish"

    • @johanfagerstromjarlenfors
      @johanfagerstromjarlenfors Před 5 lety +12

      Ciarán Kelly in sweden we refer to irish gaelic as ”iriska” or ”irländska” wich both mean just ”irish” or ”irelandish”

    • @scottwhitley3392
      @scottwhitley3392 Před 5 lety +9

      In Scotland we just use the different pronunciations of Gaelic to distinguish from the two

    • @andrewkavanagh5828
      @andrewkavanagh5828 Před 5 lety +6

      Ciarán Kelly or Gaeilge

    • @jonathandamonte174
      @jonathandamonte174 Před 5 lety +18

      He said that in the video.

    • @singharpan9859
      @singharpan9859 Před 4 lety

      @@johanfagerstromjarlenfors iriska in hindi would mean "of Ireland" or "of irish". But it would be spelled as iris-ka as both being separate words.

  • @GeordiePredator1998
    @GeordiePredator1998 Před 5 lety +11

    So, so close to 100k. Well done in advance H 👏🏻

  • @USkillz
    @USkillz Před 2 lety

    I came here to learn and I wasn't disappointed. You did a great job teaching in this video. Thank you very much!

  • @Odinsday
    @Odinsday Před 5 lety +1

    No joke, I was looking up Irish Gaelic tutorials last night. I saw this in my subscription feed and got excited. :)

  • @briandennis7081
    @briandennis7081 Před 5 lety +7

    I love videos comparing the Celtic countries, this video is right up my alley!

  • @celticanglotx313
    @celticanglotx313 Před 3 lety +5

    I'm currently learning Scottish Gaelic. Thanks so much for the lesson!!!

  • @johnnapier3128
    @johnnapier3128 Před 5 lety

    HAPPY 100,000 SUBSCRIBERS HILBERT!!!! Keep up the good work enjoy you’re channel.

  • @robinisnotkawaii3341
    @robinisnotkawaii3341 Před 5 lety +3

    Awesome video, it is super useful to know the destinctions between the two languages (as I have had my own funny mix ups in the past 🤦) and your pronounciation is very good! I'm glad for the bit at the end, because I was unaware that having a second language could decrease your chances of Alzheimer's. All in all, amazing upload! Go raibh maith agat! Is breá liom tú, mo chara Béarla!

  • @JayJayShadow
    @JayJayShadow Před 5 lety +4

    Wow, thank you so much for the video!
    I've been trying to teach myself Irish for over a year and always wondered, how different the both languages were.

  • @aalin5701
    @aalin5701 Před 5 lety +12

    As someone who speaks Manx Gaelic a little, this video makes it really interesting to think about the three

  • @leoc4013
    @leoc4013 Před 5 lety +1

    Please do more language videos. This was a great one. Thanks

  • @radiomalarkey1584
    @radiomalarkey1584 Před rokem

    Cracking video matey!

  • @jameshasapoint7628
    @jameshasapoint7628 Před 4 lety +3

    This is *so* useful. I am self-teaching myself Irish, but I am increasingly drawn to Scottish Gaelic *also* as it is such a beautiful language. Thank you!

  • @Sage50147
    @Sage50147 Před 5 lety +8

    thanks for the video you inspired me to take up Irish again. Sorry to hear about your family and good luck on the Great Northern Run

  • @yugennationlove
    @yugennationlove Před 3 lety

    I just liked and subscribed 👍☺thank you..I am very grateful 🙏❤

  • @LaFlaneuse0
    @LaFlaneuse0 Před 3 lety

    Very helpful Hilbert. Thank you.

  • @klcpesan
    @klcpesan Před 4 lety +7

    Tha mi à Ìle - I am from Islay, my father always said Irish Gaelic is influenced by Islay Gaelic 😂😂 but it's true, we understand Irish fairly well! Also thank you for sending support to my language, super upsetting when I hear people tell my language is dead and shouldnt be used for many stupid "reasons". Every language is worth preservation, and is indeed a benefit! I live in Aberdeen, the north east of Scotland and we have a thriving and growing Gaelic community here and has been here for the longest time, despite some saying otherwise, so it's not just in the Highlands and Islands 🙂great video!

  • @grainne_roisin1512
    @grainne_roisin1512 Před 2 lety +4

    I speak Irish but I’ve recently begun learning Scottish out of curiosity and have slowly started to blur the two together a bit 😭 so this video was really helpful thank you 👍☺️

  • @Stevathus
    @Stevathus Před 5 lety

    This is an excellent video, the pronunciation was great!

  • @paulaneary7877
    @paulaneary7877 Před 3 lety

    Thank You so much for your time. I appreciate it. My aunt had Alzheimer's, I took care of her for 4 months before she passed away last year. I have Irish and Scottish ancestors. My grandfather full Irish, married my grandmother, full Swedish on my father's side. Scottish comes from my mother's side.

  • @duckslayr
    @duckslayr Před 4 lety +3

    Good video, I am learning Scottish Gaelic at the University of Arizona, and my teacher is from the Isle of Skye and teaches there in the summers.

  • @billyclement5141
    @billyclement5141 Před 5 lety +5

    Great video Hilbert. It's not an easy subject to cover, but you've done a great job. :-)
    An Alzheimers- now that you mention it, while various members of my family suffer from it, none of them are bilingual. Time to dust down those old Gaelic textbooks again, maybe?

  • @ani4787
    @ani4787 Před 3 lety +2

    Tapadh leibh for making this video! I am from India and I am not sure if the knowledge of either of these languages is going to be useful to me but I still love them! And I am learning Scottish Gaelic for fun and its breathy sounds are incredible 🤩

  • @artawhirler
    @artawhirler Před rokem

    Excellent video! Thanks!

  • @evangately4541
    @evangately4541 Před 5 lety +83

    The way he pronounced connaught gave me a stroke

    • @katmuls
      @katmuls Před 5 lety +4

      same. multiple strokes.

    • @gracait
      @gracait Před 4 lety +2

      SAME THO

    • @jgdooley2003
      @jgdooley2003 Před 4 lety +6

      It is actually the correct received pronunciation of the English word Connaught. The province is now spelt "Connacht" and pronounced differently since the foundation of the Irish State and the re-introduction of Irish placenames and usages for institutions and titles such as Dáil for our parliament and Taoiseach for our Prime Minister etc.....
      Both spellings remain in use chiefly in street names and company names, examples being Connaught Telegraph and Connacht Tribune, both local papers and Connaught Street in Athlone.

    • @eamonlyons9933
      @eamonlyons9933 Před 3 lety +1

      Connacht not Connaught

  • @travisscottmiller2727
    @travisscottmiller2727 Před 5 lety +8

    I loved this. I am learning Irish in Duolingo right now and this would be helpful.

    • @laurae7777
      @laurae7777 Před 5 lety

      No point no one talks Irish in Ireland u just need to know the slang

    • @iuilenichleirigh5246
      @iuilenichleirigh5246 Před 4 lety +4

      If you're still learning Irish, try Mango Languages as well. If your local library is partnered with Mango and you have a card with your library, you may be able to get a free premium membership so you'll have access to all of the language chapters. It's far more in depth than DuoLingo is and explains what you're learning as opposed to DuoLingo just teaching what are basically nonsense phrases. (I still haven't figured out what the woman is doing in the fridge.) Also, I hope the lasso commenter didn't put you off learning. There's still plenty of places in Ireland where you will hear Irish used on a fairly regular basis and even in the places where it's mostly English speakers, the road signs are also in Irish. It's a beautiful, surprisingly easy language to learn. One thing that helped me was finding out once I learn the vowel sounds, and the combination sounds (bh, ch, dh etc), no matter what word I see them in -- even if I've never seen the word before I'll still be able to pronounce it. That took a lot of the stress of trying to learn a different language off my mind.

  • @brendankeane5725
    @brendankeane5725 Před 5 lety

    Lovely video. Thank you for doing it.

  • @Raxacoricofallapatorius
    @Raxacoricofallapatorius Před 3 lety +1

    My uncle has a house on Eriskay which is an island close to Barra. When I visited him up there, we went to the pub on the island and everyone was speaking Scottish-Gaelic! I'm now thinking about learning it because it's such a fascinating language! Great video by the way, always wondered how to differentiate the languages!

  • @jamessheehy2752
    @jamessheehy2752 Před 5 lety +4

    Great job man as an Irish man I can say you did very well

  • @connor735
    @connor735 Před 2 lety +3

    1. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
    2. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
    3. 🇮🇪
    4. 🇮🇪
    5. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
    6. 🇮🇪
    I DID IT! I'm not fluent in Scottish Gaelic but I know a good amount! I'm From Argyll and I am learning the language along with many others, Thanks a ton for this video mate boosted my confidence quite a bit! 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🙌

  • @patrickodonnell4109
    @patrickodonnell4109 Před 2 lety

    Very interesting. Glad I watched this video

  • @christianalima
    @christianalima Před 4 lety

    i'm proud of myself!! :)) Thank you for the class!

  • @MountainDragonMedia
    @MountainDragonMedia Před 2 lety +4

    I always wondered if Irish and Scottish Gaelic speakers would be able to communicate easily. Thanks for explaining this!!!

  • @KnowHistory
    @KnowHistory Před 5 lety +26

    Is this NativLang?! Great video Hilbert :D

  • @chickenman8272
    @chickenman8272 Před rokem

    Your pronunciation is perfect!

  • @kyrawinroth
    @kyrawinroth Před 5 lety

    Love this video. I did get 1 wrong, but in my defense it's 3am here when I stumbled upon this video. Please keep it up!

  • @SlippyCyppy
    @SlippyCyppy Před 5 lety +31

    Mate, we watched this in Irish class 😂😂

  • @aoifemcneill3714
    @aoifemcneill3714 Před 5 lety +8

    Hi Hilbert! As an Irish person living in Scotland, I've noticed another one: While words can be the exact same in pronounciation, they can be spelt differently, such as ceilí and ceilidh being the most commonly found. í (Irish) and dh (Scottish) is quite common.

    • @talideon
      @talideon Před 5 lety +2

      That's down to spelling reforms on the Irish side, though.

    • @talideon
      @talideon Před 5 lety +2

      @Ollie O' Brien, yes and no. The various Gaelic languages were effectively a single languages up until the Early Modern Irish period, but diverged with the loss of the common standard of Classical Irish and the fracturing of the dialect continuum caused by the Ulster Plantations. No one language can in any way be said to be derived from one is the others; all three are siblings.

  • @BrilliantLove2
    @BrilliantLove2 Před 5 lety +1

    Thank you for this! 😊

  • @kyrgyzjeff4550
    @kyrgyzjeff4550 Před 5 lety +1

    Hey, Hilbert, I know this has nothing to do with the video but I think it will be very interesting in the near-future to do a video on the Guelphs and Ghibellines conflict in Italy. It would make a great video. Keep up the great work, William of Nassau’s great descendant!

  • @imperialinquisitormaximusv3645

    FINALLY, the answer to my life-long question.

  • @seaherne
    @seaherne Před 5 lety +4

    Connaut 🤣 aght= Oct in that word
    Awesome video. The Irish accent is called a fáda :) I've actually never seen much of Scottish Gaelic, so this was really interesting.

  • @lone2234
    @lone2234 Před 5 lety

    Didn't expect to get everything right!! XD
    Kinda cheated by having some casual duolingo on Irish for a while now (saying this I don't even keep my streak and took a year bream from it) and I don't even understand half of the irish words but yeah! This is fun! And very happy the profit goes to the Alzheimer Society! You just earned a new sub :D

  • @shannonjayde7224
    @shannonjayde7224 Před 5 lety

    100k Congratulations 🎊

  • @stevenconnor4221
    @stevenconnor4221 Před 3 lety +3

    My Gran and Grandpa were from Donegal, my Granpa only spoke Gaelic but eventualy learned english. But they both said they could understand 80% of Scottish Gaelic and had no idea what certain parts of southern Ireland were saying. Crazy.

  • @JackHeywood
    @JackHeywood Před 5 lety +26

    Solidarity with the Alzheimer's situation, wishing your family well.

  • @DPG214
    @DPG214 Před 2 lety

    Nicely done.

  • @justtippinmytophat2u647

    Full marks, yessir!! Thank you for this interesting video.

  • @theberkanian5927
    @theberkanian5927 Před 5 lety +17

    1- Scottish
    2- Irish
    3- Irish
    4- Irish
    5- Scottish
    6- Irish
    (I swear on the flower of Scotland that I didn't cheat)

    • @innesmacneil
      @innesmacneil Před 5 lety

      Alistair Games he isn’t writing the quotes properly for example, the first on he says ‘sann a an...’ where as it should be ‘ sann as an’

    • @innesmacneil
      @innesmacneil Před 5 lety +3

      Also the second one is Scots Gaelic

    • @innesmacneil
      @innesmacneil Před 5 lety +1

      I should know as I speak it fluently

  • @jamessullivan5864
    @jamessullivan5864 Před 4 lety +7

    I studied Irish back in school and recently started learning Scottish Gaelic I'm finding it very easy

    • @johnmccaughey2722
      @johnmccaughey2722 Před 2 lety +4

      I am from the scottish highlands and think it would be good if they could amalgamate the two languages so that they have a stronger chance of survival.

    • @dylanmurphy9389
      @dylanmurphy9389 Před rokem

      @@johnmccaughey2722I’m from England and would love that ❤

  • @StrathpefferJunction
    @StrathpefferJunction Před 5 lety

    Good video. I speak Gàidhlig and to me, the languages just look totally different. It's really interesting listening to a non-native Gaelic speaker picking it apart like this. Nice one!

  • @marielawlor3124
    @marielawlor3124 Před 2 lety

    Awesome video :-) I love learning Scottish Gaelic 🙂

  • @aodhanmaccuinneagain7413
    @aodhanmaccuinneagain7413 Před 5 lety +8

    I love that your Scottish Gaelic phrase was: Welcome, how are you? What is your name?

  • @laurae7777
    @laurae7777 Před 5 lety +26

    I'm from Ireland but I REALLLLLLLYYYY want to go to Scotland

  • @chasearleshensarling9169

    Youre awesome. Thank you brev!!

  • @zulkiflijamil4033
    @zulkiflijamil4033 Před 2 lety +1

    Slàinte. Tha mi á Malaysia.
    And I am here, in your channel to learn Gaidhlig and Gaeilge. Thanks so much for this lesson.
    🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆

  • @professorpodcast3029
    @professorpodcast3029 Před 4 lety +2

    Where I live in the Angus Region of Scotland the council introduced gaelic into ages 1 to 3 but not into High School or Primary School

  • @geektome4781
    @geektome4781 Před 4 lety +4

    I couldn’t tell which direction the accents were pointing as I listened to them talk on Outlander.

  • @hikaru9624
    @hikaru9624 Před 5 lety

    Thanks for giving the correct pronunciation! Too many people mispronounce the Scottish Gaelic and I've ever heard some folk from universities misspronunce it (granted it was on TV but still).

  • @TheHumanHarribo
    @TheHumanHarribo Před 4 měsíci

    Sciots Gaidhlig is my first language and that accent and pronounciation was absolutely on point, well done good sir i commend you.
    S'e Dduine nan gael a th'oirt a-nise! Slainte a ghraidh :))

  • @susanr6039
    @susanr6039 Před 5 lety +5

    There were not 'grammatical' reforms of Scottish Gaelic. There were orthographic reforms aimed at reducing/simplifying spelling variations first published in 1981. This recommended using only the grave accent.

  • @trishfowlie3145
    @trishfowlie3145 Před 5 lety +4

    One thing I rely on for distinguishing the two languages (apart from my limited Scots Gaelic) is that Irish has rationalised the spelling, but apart from deciding all the accents would go left (which had no effect on pronunciation at all, unlike in French) Scots Gaelic has long long words with far too many vowels! We should negotiate an exchange with Welsh or Polish, languages which seem to be averse to writing vowels.
    I was surprised at first that Scots Gaelic has no words for “yes” or “no” (although “aye” may be used), but then I remembered Latin managed very well without.

  • @swasthikbhat5949
    @swasthikbhat5949 Před 2 lety

    There's an exam for me in couple of days that has no connection to this whatsoever, I was supposed to search for something related to exam and this came in my recommendations so I proceeded to watch this. I dunno man, I'm doing something with my life but I don't think I'd regret this.
    Also, I got a 6/6 lol, no cheating at all. Thanks for some valuable infos hilbert.

  • @nightw4tchman
    @nightw4tchman Před 5 lety +1

    I got all but number 5 right which I left blank as I wasn't 100% sure, until I remembered the sg thing.
    My Grandparents were native Gealic speakers and I've learnt a little through them. You're right about the Islay Ulster blur, the Gealic my Grandmother spoke is different to what BBC Alba uses now.

  • @robbiemontgomery581
    @robbiemontgomery581 Před 5 lety +14

    Two nations, one culture 🍀

    • @Sean-sn9ld
      @Sean-sn9ld Před 2 lety +7

      Not really , Scottish and Irish culture is very different

  • @lonloftonjr.1701
    @lonloftonjr.1701 Před 5 lety +9

    Easiest way to tell from Scot and Irish is that Scots have 15% more ginger hair than irish with 5% ginger hair

    • @PixelsInMySoup
      @PixelsInMySoup Před 5 lety +1

      There's actually more redheads in Ireland

    • @hachwarwickshire292
      @hachwarwickshire292 Před 3 lety +1

      Tried that out .... she slapped me.
      Tesco checkout queue ! She looked Irish ... I was counting her hair

  • @kevinmurphy65
    @kevinmurphy65 Před rokem

    Really good vid. Well done! Although I do know a few History professors that would take you to task by what you referred to as the "Dark Ages". Not really so much referred to that any longer.

  • @michaelhalsall5684
    @michaelhalsall5684 Před 2 lety +1

    Since the spelling reforms of the Irish language the letter V has been added to irish spelling. This occurs in introduced words such as "veain" (van) "vodca" (vodka) "vota" (vote) "both votala" (voting booth) . The right tilting "acute"accent is known as the "fada" in Irish and is used over all 5 vowels. Irish can still be written in the archiac uncial script, which is still used in page headings and shop signs.

  • @johnmackenreillytag
    @johnmackenreillytag Před 5 lety +9

    For the Irish anyways your pronouncation is fairly spot on! Maith an fear, is físeán iontach é seo.

  • @Axegammeray
    @Axegammeray Před 5 lety +12

    Jesus I'm a year late but you should have mentioned that here in Ireland they teach Irish to pupils from the age of 4 as a mandatory subject and in Scotland they don't teach it at all except in separate schools

    • @innesmacneil
      @innesmacneil Před 5 lety +2

      Axegammeray Most schools teach Gaelic in Scotland, and there are more Gaelic Pupils than English in the Highlands

    • @celticcomradelad1850
      @celticcomradelad1850 Před 5 lety +5

      Innes MacNeil That's good to hear. No one should ever let go of their native tongue if they can help it.

    • @Axegammeray
      @Axegammeray Před 5 lety

      Thanks for all the replies, I never thought Scotland taught gaelic! It's great to know tradition is still respected in our ancient countries

  • @nobodyabc7402
    @nobodyabc7402 Před 4 lety +2

    i am fluent in gaelige and am trying to become fluent in gàidhlig. this really helped, thank you!

  • @LouiseEgan
    @LouiseEgan Před rokem +2

    I loved learning how to say Failte/De in both languages and would appreciate more comparisons of Scottish vs Irish pronunciation -- and not quite so immediately the explanations about accents and hyphens.