From Singur to Sandeshkhali - Why Bengal Continues to Bleed | PART 1 | Akash Banerjee & Poulami Nag
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 07. 2023
- The Results of the West Bengal Panchayat Polls are rolling out and TMC is set to dominate the polls - but that victory will be marred once again by massive violence - the levels - that no other part of the country sees.
Why has Mamata Banerjee failed to control this violence - is it her fanning the anger ?? - or is it that Bengal is seeing another cycle of violence with BJP now hitting back at the TMC with greater force?Why is Violence so pervasive and even acceptable in this eastern state?? - Why is it that people are willing to die for Panchayat Level Elections ... Bengal as we will see has a very different makeup and way of operation.
THANKS A TON to Poulami Nag for pointing me in the right direction with all things Bengal / giving me critical points and overview / helping the team with the research.
FOR ALL THINGS BENGAL - please follow her awesome channel
/ @hothatjodiuthlokotha
⛔️ BECOME A DESHBHAKT MEMBER - / thedeshbhakt ⛔️
Unlock MEMBER ONLY: 1) Chats 2) Discord Server 3) Special Episodes
👕 DESHBHAKT MERCH - India's First Line of Socially & Politically aware tees 👕kadakmerch.com/thedeshbhakt
📧 BUSINESS ENQUIRIES - contact (at) thedeshbhakt (dot) in 📧
** SUBSCRIBE / FOLLOW US **
Twitter :- / thedeshbhakt
Instagram :- / akashbanerjee.in
Facebook :- / akashbanerje. .
Podcast - anchor.fm/thedeshbhakt
Credits :
Writer : Akash
Thumbnail : Khursheed
Graphics : Mehul
Editor : Tushar, Khursheed & Ritam
Producer : Sahil Likhar
#mamatabanerjee #westbengal #akashbanerjee
PAYMENT KAHA SE AATI HAI?!! - perhaps the most common question we get!!! 😜
Well clearly its not BJP / Congress / AAP or TMC - because we managed to piss them all!!!
The fact is that we are small independent team - running on some ad. rev / some sponsors - but primary subscription driven. So do support us on YT or join us as a member on www.patreon.com/thedeshbhakt.
If not - your comments / likes / shares help to get the word out!!!!
Kitna bheju bhai?
❤
My Bharat is growing 🤩 BJP 2024 Jai Hind 🇮🇳♥️🔥 #MakeInIndia #BharatWantStableGovernment
Luckily v9no.
Payment pheley leftist ppl sey ati thie aab suscriber aur follower sey aati ha 😭
I’m not a supporter of any political parties, I just want my West Bengal to be safe from this kind of stupidity.
Then choose Congress or aap or any other party but never bjp
@@Atheist503 no political party is good. Sb ke sb chor hai sale!
@@Atheist503I will better choose NOTA than choosing congress and AAP...over BJP
@@Atheist503❤day Bengal me tmc hai bjp nahi
@@adwaitvedant3297 Actually there is no alternative of TMC . BJP is the second version of TMC
Honestly, being a Bengali, I am ashamed of our politicians.
1971 मे बंग्लादेश मे मुसलमानो ने 30,00,000 हिंदुओं को मारा और 30,00,000 हिंदू लड़कियों को रेप किया और sex slave बनकर बुड्ढी होने तक बेचते रहे.. एक से दूसरे मुसलमानो के पास...!
Don't be ashamed, politics in every state is violent, it's just lobbyism that keeps it underreported.
Don't be people needed to be awake or else nothing can help.
Politicians comes from Bengal society only not from sky, why blame politicians only. Look deeper it's the mejority society which is in rot from refugee crisis situation since 70s era.
As a Bengali if we want to stop this violence vengeance political culture started from 70s era. We have to vote out all parties one by one in each & every 5 years. Or create a hung assembly.
How Dhruv Rathee consciously avoids these subjects and you are choosing them to address, says a lot of difference between your directions.
yeah...great observations!!
The fact you have to depend on CZcamsrs and not on mainstream media shows how Indian people as a whole is a Joke 😂
@@nickblue11Yess...where the mainstream media is funded and controlled by these political parties
Yeah if you observe more you'll got to know that he doesn't even live in india and making videos based on india and he's supporting a particular political party since very long but people are neglecting that
His most of the videos or you can say all are biased
@@soiiiii23 yeah...it's perfectly true that he is a NRI and also have a foreign wife or girlfriend whatever...he rarely comes to India to shoot vlogs but pretends like he is in INDIA...fully biased with some propaganda argument...this dhruv rathi kind of people is more dengerous than a terrorist for Indian integrity!
As a Bengali I can say that Bengal is more dangerous than Pakistan or Afghanistan there is no safety for either common people or Hindu
It's concerning how Hindus being the majority religion in every state, still needs protection. BJP brainwashing at its best.
Very true. It's common people who are getting hurt.
Yes. CAA, NRC and UCC is more needed for West Bengal and Assam.
@@autodidact3070 Exactly
@@autodidact3070 use your brain mr.
For criticising TMC without any biasness, this man gained my respect ❤
Thanks for the unbiased video. I hope you make more of such videos, which highlight the real issues.
And the so called "victims" turned out to be fake. Why is it that almost everytime conveniently in all elections that BJP is destined to fail or failed, the winners do "violence", which always is followed by "demand for president rule, CBI, NIA, NCW" and what not, none of phone ultimately never are able to establish anything but just a myriad of PR against the rival new state govt ?
🔴 *Bimarus online* : _"There are 10 crore illegal Bangladeshis in India because of West Bengal. There are no jobs in West Bengal. Why do bengalies come to Delhi, Mumbai, Bangalore?"_
*Bimarus offline* : _Forging documents to occupy opportunities in Bengal and other states while fearmongering Bangladeshis and Bengalies to hide their own overpopulated demography crowding in Bengal and other states to occupy opportunities_
FOOD FOR THOUGHT.
Ram Navami Communal Clash happens in a city where Durga Puja processions are far more extensive with no communal incidents.
A crowd of only men wearing saffron , swords ,lathis ,pistols and bulldozers take out procession , push police and barricades and then claims muslims attacked them in the Kolkata, to which they post videos and photos, not even related to Kolkata but delhi Riots and none, not even Akash Banerjee questions why?
He doesn't ask a single time, why did a innocent religious procession of Ram Navami had no woman, no kid or old in it, but only adult men with weapons. Doesnt it tell enough that it was preplanned to deliberately give a bad picture of West Bengal?
But why do these things?
Sudu politics er jonno? Foreign Investment aatkiye nijeder state e sei investment gulo ke koraateo to ei incident gulo kaaj kore. Joto Bengal ke durnaam , badnaam koraa hoy, totoi FDI ke West Bengal e invest koraateke aatkaano jaai. Aar state ke leech kora jaaye.
@@S.Ghosh_221can u tell me who is killing people in Durga Puja in Bangladesh.😂
As a bengali, we live with goons. We all live in a state where dystopian future is quite visible. God only knows. 😢
Bengalis are corrupt, violent and worthless bunch of people who seek pride by raking the name of Bose and Tagore. Their criticism of Marwadis-Gujaratis is laughable to say the least.
Bhadralok
Abhi kaisa hai waha haal?
Modi's regime won't change anything
Welcome to TMC and left
Being from Assam, I had the privilege of witnessing College Elections in Asutosh College, South Kolkata and I was goddamn naive at that time in 2009-10 when I got to know how bloody violent a mere college election can become. At the end of the violence, one poor fellow was left with a smashed eye with a flying brick falling in his left eye (I think that fellow was in English Honours and his name was some Souvik Hazra). I was stuck inside a pharmacy outside that college with the shutters down and it was dark inside and all I could hear was "Maar Bokaaachodaa" ) . After that incident I left Kolkata and Bengal and never looked back. Now more than ever , I feel ever grateful to my grandfather for deciding to migrate to Assam instead of West Bengal from then East Bengal in 1947.
Bengal is really become waste bangal and become a beemaru state= Intellectl arrogance has a collateral damage too. A REAL REAL FILTHY STATE INDEED.
Assam burns now,(grandfather must be spinning in the grave)
@@sudhirchopde3334 First thing first, I don't know in which multiverse you got the news that Assam is burning 🤣 I think you are mixing Manipur with Assam , don't blame you, maybe your education system failed you. Second, we are Hindus and we perform Antim Sanskaar not Bury the dead like the Miyaa Community. So, you exhibited your own intellectual level by your shitposting 🤣🤣🤣🤣
As a JU student that's just normal 😅
@@sudhirchopde3334 his grandfather is a Hindu not Muslim like yours.
Being a bengali I totally agree to you Akash that this is the present condition of Bengal. I pray and hope soon this ends in Bengal pls pls god🙏🙏
Maturity is when you realise TMC is even more dangerous than BJP and Congress Combine😂😂😂.
When bjp come to power in bengal, u will see all r f**king same
That is i agree tmc made things bad to worse
Jo bjp ko vote dega usko mar denge aase log hai ye
Tmc is not dangerous brother ......they became greedy for power
30 rupess petrol in 120 rupess .. 65 rupesss master oil is 210 rupesss eveything is 200 % more expensive since 2014 and we are searching for other political treat then BJP
I am from West Bengal but this is now a real problem in Bengal. This election violence is ridiculous.
Being a bengali from Odisha. I would say your CM and your state's people should learn from us...
Or chuno didi (rndi) ko😂
@@shubashnagre8288ro real people in WB are good but ,both tmc and bjp are chutiyas, infact all bjp leaders in WB are fraudsters of TMC
@@shubashnagre8288 what does that statement even mean???....Who is us?....You are in Odisha so us would mean locals there..not you
Is this violence real Or just propaganda from Godi media?
A heart felt thank you from a Bengali living in West Bengal, my grandfathers then my parents used to story tell these blood based political history of Bengal. But I never thought I myself would also live through these. This is the first video I came across of yours. And subscribed to your channel in about 10mins off the video. Respect.
Amader songhei eshob hoe keno? 😢
You'll tell your grandkids
No such deaths and violence in hills of Darjeeling and Kalimpong...it's just about mentality
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
bhag ja yahan se @@shreeyanksinghvi7748
Born and brought up in bengal and its devastating to see a state like Bengal going this way.
I'm not with any particular political party but tmc is ruining the bengal.
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
As a Bangali I can say
This is the Harsh reality of West Bengal 🙂
Don't listen him bro he is just a librandu like those andhbhakts librandu of congress always try to manipulate things
@@Baap_E_allahthen u don't know the political influence here in West Bengal
You guys vote TMC and then complain about its policy...
@@erasernet900we dont have to vote. TMC votes for us. Lol.
@@EvilSapphireR thats West Bengal's problem... Not BJP's... How the heck is he accusing BJP of doing violence... Where most of the states under BJP never had any form of violence
Being a resident of Bengal who has seen Bengal Politics quite closely i can assure all that this episode is so well researched and correctly analysed that you don't need to go anywhere to understand Bengal's current political & social situation. Just watch this episode, not once but repeatedly if you are to know Bengal in its current perspective.
पश्चिम बंगाल में केवल गुंडों का शासन है और यह सच है। मैं एक ग्रामीण हूं, वर्तमान व्यवस्था को जानता हूं,😢 यह पंचायत का वोट हमारा है गांव में टीएमसी की मुझमें किसी भी विपक्षी दल के ख़िलाफ़ खड़े होने की हिम्मत नहीं थी, गुंडों ने बूथों पर कब्जा कर लिया और सारे वोट दबा दिये. अब हमें वोट देने नहीं जाना पड़ेगा, बिना वोट दिए ही वोट जीत लिया जाता है, ऐसे खेला जा रहा है (खेला जाएगा) 😅😂 सचमुच हम बहुत बुरी स्थिति में जी रहे हैं👎😭
Nothing to understand because listening would not benefit Bengal's ground reality
Change bengal ( Protest)
@@NewstatePlayer100hange India..
1. Stop destroying nature in the name of development.. Development doesn't only mean roads and factories
2. Believe and have equality between men and women. For the past 70 years, we have come from this a lot, but more needs to be done.
3. Discourage superstition.
4. Build up the education in all government school. It's the taxpayers money. Build up agriculture infrastructure so that a farmer can live a decent life throughout the country. More agro based industries.
5. More cold storage so that farm produce is not wasted.
6. Create a compassionate ideology.
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
@@shreeyanksinghvi7748 nyakra beche kotodin chalabe. na kinle nijeder gola-kata-kati hobe, aar aborjona kombe :D .... shob halal jobai :D
A big bow to your entire team. U explain every issue in the simplest possible way that it can be understood by even an individual with less than average knowledge of politics. I cannot even imagine the amount of effort that goes behind the screen. Kudos to your dedication and passion.
@PippOtBut the thing he ... whatever he said he 100% true...living in Bengal i can relate to his video
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
Wtf @Chilli_potato12
@Chilli_potato12where did you get all this stuff?
When we were kids, me and my friends used to avoid schools and tution on voting days. As a kid I never understood why but later on I got my first hand experience
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
@@shreeyanksinghvi7748 bro ur asking an atheist to switch religion? Switch from what? I was born hindu but soon realized I love practicality more. Moreover religion has nothing to do with progress, it's our own collective effort that pushes our state forward. Yea I've seen many hindu muslim riots in other places but where I live there's no muslim, hindu, Christian collony as such, like other places. I have friends from all of those religions, and really enjoy eid, durga puja, 25th dec together. In fact my business partner is Christian. So keep ur suggestions to ur self and dont give it anyone.
@@Cursedkidmusic see how Bangladesh is progressing how failed u are ?? bankrupt beggar state
see how Islamist Bangladesh who was poor going ahead of atheist and secular waste bengal
u know we kicked out and committed genocide against atheist secular Bengali hindu so called bhadralok we got rid of u so we progressed
Extremely important video! As a Bengali who has just moved out of the state, I feel bad when Bengal is called the scam capital of the world. As mentioned in the video, when the youth don't have jobs, they're only left with two options - move out or give in to unconventional ways which are mostly criminal in nature. At this point, the only thing I know is that TMC has to go, it's a disease which has left our state dry and destroyed for decades to come, but no more. Period!
U took the name of TMC and u didn’t get heart 😂😂😂
@@myvlogs638 check the older comments...it's not older.
@@myvlogs638some one is getting triggered when mentioning there beloved chor TMC...!!
TMC ar cpim er moddhe kno difference dekhte Pai na just notun wrapped package hoye eseche
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
As a Bengali,thanking you for this episode.
@@Izone-es3mq don't be Sad don't vote for BJP they are doing nothing for their workers
@@IceSword-ox5vuchange party every 5 years. BJP next time, another party after next time.
@@IceSword-ox5vu that's why change party constantly
@@IceSword-ox5vu
Toder chubhendu ke bol bichi te dom thakle 355 lagate
Nahle bujhbo setting puro
@@IceSword-ox5vu
Ar BJP ke vote dibi?😂
Ora ro first ei 35% vote minus kore election e name
My senior is working in TATA grp in Kolkata and he knows the reality who is destroying Bengal he says he feels like he is living in Bangladesh and always feels threat for his life
Sir, your analysis are brilliant I am a Bengali and I think behind the fall of Bengal, one of most important reason is people awareness, yes there are most of the people is educated but they are not purely educated, they are merely educated, and the other reason is dumb politicians, who knows only money instead of economic growth of the state, this would lead to the downfall of the state, it is sad reality, so we need that types of politicians who knows how to develop economy of the state instead of how to grab money and property in a corrupted way😢
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
Sir, I'm from West Bengal...Let me share a short story which will help you understand my state...In 1998 my father got selected in a recruitment process of irrigation department but didn't received the appointment letter,when my father contacted the office they said we need 2 lakhs or else you will not get the appointment,at the end my father didn't got the job because we didn't pay...today we are in 2023 and i'm looking for jobs now there are no job notifications from past 3-4 years whatsoever and those which were conducted are in court trial or corrupted in every possible way...!!!This is a suffering of a middle class family in bengal.....IRONY!!!
Pure desh ka yahi haal h 😅
Leave India.
Meanwhile Yogi baba- hum exam ka notification hi nhi denge to paper leak nd selection process me corruption hi nhi hoga
The situation in Pakistan is better than Bengal 🥲
Vai not that masters students are driving toto
That's the Perfect Analysis Sir.... আমিও বাঙালি ..আপনিও বাঙালি....তাই বাংলার ব্যাথা অনেক গভীরে গিয়ে আঘাত করে....
ধন্যবাদ এত স্পষ্ট ও পরিষ্কার ব্যাখ্যা দেয়ার জন্য....🙏
I am from rural area of bengal ... the sentence that this guy said "clash to parties mein ho rhi hai common log kyu mar rhe hai isme ... becoz of papi pet..." this statement is 100% true ... rural side mein logo k pass income ka kuch hai hi nhi ... unko existing party 2 ruppee kilo rice , 2 rupee kilo wheat deti hai ..unke lie to didi bhagwan hai ....woh log isse zada kuch soch bhi nhi pate hain... Ab agar woh existing party to hata de aur naya party ne ye sab band kar diya to woh log kya karenge....
when u have 30% muslim and remaining 70% are muslim appeaser like akash banerjee then your state is doomed forever,
Great Analysis and Narration of the Political Scenario of WB... for the last few decades 👍👍
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
Sad to see our state , which was once known for unity, non-violence , decency and harmony, getting turned into a land of blood overflows 💔💔
It was never bro..Political violence is common in bengal Bengal was never politically stable and peacefull its nothing new ye sab 1947 se hi chalta aa rha hai political violence is normal in bengal
The land where Direct action day celebrated.....where most violent attacked happened against zamidar rich Hindus poor Muslims wow land of peace 🕊️
Bhai Khisti diye kotha Bolbo kichu Mone Korish na.
Laurar Bal, Unity, Non-violence, History ki Twitter ar Tumblr diya porsosh, Left ra sala Strike kore kore state tar gar mereche, Ar amader Didi Laura Roktor Nodi boyiye diyeche, chodnamo marish na beshi
@@deadshotneo6339the land where the spark of freedom once created which in turn give freedom to our country meanwhile northern hindu kings supported British in wars. Bengal is a land where we beat England national team in a ifa shield in 1911 without even wearing a boot.
Bengal is peaceful but northern political parties even bjp hire people from other state to do violence in Bengal.
You're just trying to tell it's a bad state because your favorite political party don't win here. Also West Bengal's per capita gdp in twice that of Uttar Pradesh not tell me which state is worse. And by the way the person capita gdp data is provided by home ministry so u at least believe them I guess. 😂😂
lol bengal and kerela was always known for violence.
As a resident of West Bengal I can vouch for this video. As a matter of fact, this is by far the most analytical, informative and unbiased video I've ever seen. I could have written 50 pages about so many things, but rather I'd request everyone to watch this video instead, no matter which political ideology you support.
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
Most of the violence took place at my subdivision. My area counts under municipality but we all witnessed what happened nearby panchayat areas. Ballets were thrown in the drain, some were completely stolen.
I am a supporter of Sanatan Dharma thereby support BJP and I am from UP. Firstly, I am very thankful that we are safe from such violence and secondly that you addressed this issue and made a video.
According to some bjp kattar Hindus : Sanatan dharm = Bjp
Muslim = congress and opposition 😂😂
I have nothing to say to this type of men
U r a moron if u support bjp because of ur religion lol . UP yogi ha ? Abhe yogi ka criminal history dekho zara Google karke . 😂
From “what Bengal thinks today, India thinks tomorrow “ to this. It is really hard to digest that this soil, once produced elite poets, cinematographers, scientists, freedom fighters, spiritual leaders.
We need our poschim bongo back to where it belonged.
if u want that u should kick out illegal immigrants, kick out islamic extremism and kick islamic terror apologists like Akash who refuse to acknowledge the elephant in the room
Islam is the reason. Deport all Muslims to Bangladesh
What's happening in Bengal today will happen in India tomorrow..😊😊😊
Bengal has elected fascist govt in 2011 and india elected fascist govt in 2014 so it's true and bengal saw riots in 2021 I think india will see riots in 2024
@@doraemonandshinchan2156
Bjp working for Indic identity and secure our indigenous culture and religion. There is no room for appeasement politics in Bjp governed States. And Bjp working model is Capitalist. It's mean promoting industries, businesses and startups culture. On the other hand, other parties just a sample of designed & pseudo Secularism approach.
There is a popular saying in Bengali _
" Gram Bangla jaar, Bangla taar."
Which translates as_
" Those who has a strong domination in rural Bengal, Bengal is theirs."
Wonderful video! You (Along with most other research videos) just reinforced the primary reason behind Bengal's woes .... CPM
Well done boss! Always support for truth! Thank you for the video! Great job. Huge fan! btw I am from Bengal.
As someone who's parents are from West Bengal but are now living in Delhi, I wholeheartedly agree that we need a reform in WB. Hopefully with less violence.
Being a Bengali during the election is like being in a PvP map, you just need to pick the right team.
There is no right team 🤷🏻♂️
@@noneofyourbusiness4397i think me meant powerful by saying right team. Like support tmc while in Bengal and support bjp while you're in up. There still no garunte you will safe but Chance's will be higher than usual. 😅
@@noneofyourbusiness4397 there needs to be a government to have control on crime, otherwise the society will crumble, even if there are no right team, u need to pick a side to make a government
I am from West Bengal,
Yeh hingsa k liye Central v jimidar hai. Opposite party ka vote k waqt koi security nahi hai .
Marne do Bengal ko.......
@@anjanmondal8363any political murder in UP elections? Don't compare incomparable.
Main bhi North bengal se hu or yaha ka haal bhi yahi hain ..
Sir sach me aap jitna bhi baat bata rahe hain ye sach hain ....
Aap bahut aachi tarah se research karke ye video banaye hain....
Very unbiased opinion from history to present day. Unless jobs are created, people will have time to associate with such parties.
convert to islam u feel everything is ohk see how muslim are happy with tmc
Although I am a Bengali but i will not hesitate to say that Bengalis can do anything when it comes to Politics 🙏
Vikhari😂
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
@@shreeyanksinghvi7748u filthy chuslim lover..... U are the worst of vermin
I am from Andhrapradesh and I didn't know about bengal violence until now. Thanks to akash sir for giving information about lots of issues in national politics.
I'm a CPM superstar and in last 10 Years ,No free and fare election happened, in 2018 election 38% areas were uncontested
🤣source bhi jo chuna hein tune, tumhara calibre pta chal gaya
@@stormgg4052 to tu yaha kr raha hai jab sab fake hai to ?
Mt dekh
And AP is heaven on earth 🌎
@@MrMeetmeagainYess if compared to cheap states like UP and gujtat
Earlier bihar & up was know for such violence, now bengal has surpassed Up & bihar in this regard.
Sir thanks for sharing the bloody truth.... Aap ne jo kaha is video me ekdom sahi kaha.... Unfortunately I am belong from West Bengal... We r really shame for this face... Pray 🙏for get well soon bengal... Thank you sir
The irony of the matter is now bengal needs someone visionary. We used to deliver visionary people to the whole country and that's probably why the quote "What Bengal thinks today, India thinks tomorrow" was famous. Now we need visionary people desparately
Yeah, but the people will not vote for them. 😢
wasn't that quote for punjab, on a side note i see a lot of bengalis taking jobs here in punjab tho
@@ydid687 bro people from Punjab, Bihar, up also coming to Bengal but we don't say they are taking our jobs. This is discriminatory. Else every state also shouldn't allow other state people to work. And no, that line wasn't for Punjab. Because in the past Bengal had so much glory , Oscars Nobel prize etc etc etc...
@@ydid687 nope. This quote was from Sir Gopale Krishna Gokhale as Bengal was the hotspot of Indian Nationalism during the British Raj. All valiant nationalists like Subhash Chandra Bose, Deshbandhu Chittaranjan, Khudiram Bose, etc. were born in Bengal and revolted against the British Rule. Calcutta was the capital of India under British Raj for decades and when they sensed Calcutta was full of nationalistic sentiments, they shifted the capital to New Delhi. Gokhale said that because ideas of nationalist sentiments and movements were all hatched in Bengal.
@@bodhisatwachowdhury8763 i'm not shaming migration
i was just commenting on the dilapidated plight of the bengali rural landscape
i didn't know punjabis were seeking jobs in bengal (except from the scammers who are regularly trolled by Jim Browning and all)
As Bengali, Really its very painful to see what Bengali is today..
One's upon a time .. everyone says
What Bengal think today, India will think tomorrow..
Stop All political violence
Stop giving vir to TMC
@@FactsFever98 No matter what educated bengalis do to not vote TMC the villagers always vote TMC because they are brainwashed.
Lawda Maharashtra has always been decades ahead of everybody else ♥️
That's no longer the case
I am from the village Of Bengal, truly speaking,I can feel how much the poor and farmer people are brainwashed, can you realize how much it painfull when neighbour aunti says you Lakshmir Bhandar is more important so we should vote to Mamta didi, but they don't understand the critical logic behind lakshir bhandar schme, they really don't understand the importance of job, income etc... etc..Need a change immediately
Sir sach manie Aaj Tak ek matra apka yeh video Hain Jo Maine ek bar vi skip nahi kia...pura video dekha ..aapka research ekdum sahi hai...
I am from West Bengal, you are absolutely right 👍
The best CM we ever had was our first CM Bidhan Chandra Roy, its downhill from then and now we have reached rock bottom
I too agree. 👍
Agree. I hope Congress regains foot in Bengal again, because those who are still with Congress in Bengal are upright and steadfast in their support to Congress in the face of fear of violence from TMC and ED/IT of BJP. TMC is same as BJP in terms of authoritarian tactics. The goons of TMC are joining BJP in fear of ED, IT.
Bidhan Chandra roy was one of the corrupt CM we had
Bidhan Chandra roy was helping the wealthy families to plunder the poor sections of the society
@@prasenjitphilosophy762 jitna vi bacha hua hey wo left ke vaje sey hi hey
I'm from Bengal and I'm shameful for this situation 😢
I have a newfound respect for this guy because he did not shy away from criticism of TMC
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
Me odisha se hu,hamara state garib state list me ata hai,lekin danga na ke barabar hota hai,islia khush hu,lekin padoshi bengal me bahut dange hota hai😢
I am from West Bengal and a student of political science. Your analysis is very factual and valuable.
If up beats westbengal and becomes per capita richer will you give bjp chance iam not saying give chance but bjp tmc all are same we should be clever to vote and teach politician lessons of working 😀
Thanks for this well researched episode. As a local staying in kolkata for last 2 decades, I do not rely on social media or whatsapp much for genuine news, but we get to hear about harsh reality from people coming in the city from grass root levels, from villages and suburbs to work as drivers, maids, gardeners, cooks etc. and what we are witnessing every single day with our own eyes. No one can buy or sell lands in areas adjacent to main Kolkata without giving hefty commissions to local goons who are identified mostly as immigrant muslims, which cannot happen without support from ruling party. Agencies supplying housemaids, nurses or security guards have been instructed to give priorities to muslims, which means now if you are hiring a guard or cook for your household from agency, chances are very high that you will have to give access to a muslim whether you want it or not. Poor men want to send their gorwn up daughters away from home or employ them in some decent household where TMC goons will not abduct them at their will. This year during bakri id, some socities in Kolkata has opposed to bringing and open killing of goats inside the premises which is uniquely happening for the first time. Seems our CM is measuring the depths of you-know-what. The whole city has been turned into a slum, with millions of immigrant muslims (mostly) having been license to sit and do business on every available footpaths. This is destroying the businesses of age old bengali or other businessmen and traders. When she cannot provide employment for the existing literate or semiliterate youth of Bengal, how can she make it worse by allowing crores of illegal immigrants only and only for her own selfish need!! And the man who is publicly known as her "nephew", Abhishek Banerjee, is the biggest mafia at this moment. Whether it is cow or sand or coal or gold, no smuggling can happen without his permission. What is happening here is clear indication of indulging in communal appeasement putting all other communities at risk, like it or not. CPM also used to appease to some extent, but never had we felt so threatened or compelled to put up with political atrocities. I am not a political person, I support any good work done by any political party for greater mass.
Vote them out of power. Isn't that the easy way?A cultural renaissance may be tougher to achieve and non feasible at the moment.
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
@@shreeyanksinghvi7748 Kya kahna chahta h re? Saaf saaf likh
@@dhananjaypathak3374 mai bol raha hoon Bengali ko ki musalman ban jao , muslim appeasement karke kya milega
People of West Bengal...❤
👇
Very true and harsh reality. We really need to change the government and it's policies in order to save our state from more drowning. We need employment and business opportunities here in this state
Being a congress leader in india is risky
Being a BJP leader in west bengal and kerela is fatal
bethke gyaan dene me: PROFIT
absolutely wrong.. most of the killings are between TMC itself.. everybody wants ticket.. if they dont get they become independent candidate.. bass marpitai shuru..
20 muslims got killed in this bjp should be happy TMC is doing there job
😅😅..
2050 : A M uslim party Rule West Bengal and their intention is trying to join west Bengal and Assam with Bangladesh. Then No Bjp TMC CPIM Exist. I gurantee 100%..
Deshbhakt is defining the true meaning of journalism....no partiality... only facts.♥️ love and respect to Akash da and team deskbhakt
@@ajinkyanarayanpure2209Oyee dumb fuck, any proof to back ur statement ? 🤷🏻♂️
@@ajinkyanarayanpure2209And you totally biased with bjp😂
@@Nav.ed.Your comments are consistently biased against the BJP, and you often fail to provide a balanced view of the party's policies and actions.
@@Nav.ed.Abey Congress k Landiye...tu toh rehne de..!! Tere jaise MadhrasaChap se gyan lene ki naubadh nhi ayi ab tak..!!💥
@@ajinkyanarayanpure2209 in my opinion media should play bigger role than opposition in a healthy democracy ❤
Gokhale said: what Bengal thinks today India thinks tomorrow.
But😢 now I realise that it reversed 😢.
As a bangali I am very disappointed ☹️ for distraction of Bengal by the brutal politician. We should think as early as possible and give power to honest politician.
'we are bangali ,we can rebuild our Bengal .
I know how exactly voting happens in West Bengal. Learned directly from presiding officers, but people are still helpless .
Your observation is absolutely right. I am from Bengal.
I am from murshidabad (most effected district by political violance) for me it is not uncommon to see political violance. It become a tradition to do violance in election specially in panchayat and every political party do this. One of the two major reason is
UNEMPLOYMENT and ILLITERACY.
murshidabad is mostly muslim, so it's obvious
@@swapnanilchakraborty3016 You Must be one of those people who lives in kolkata and thinks they know everything.
But sorry to say that you have no knowlegde about ground reality.
Violance has no religion.
@@clare1598 violence does have a fuckin religion, it comes from bangladesh and myanmar, before you get started with your woke and degenerate bs, lemme body u
@@clare1598e is absolutely right and your pnt too but the fact of the matter is that he is somewhat true. I have observed grnd reality of bengal this is happening dur to rohingya muslim. So i would request you to kindly come out of your strawberry world😂 and gather some gud pnts
@@akshatsingh8857 @akshatsingh8857 I live in a place where 90% of the population is Muslim and 10% is Hindu, and we have been living here peacefully for decades, so you can try your best to convince me.
Here is a good example:
Indonesia is a Muslim country, but the people are good and peaceful.
By the way, a small tip
Maybe you should invest your time to correct and learn English rather than blaming other religions.
O my God !
What a excellent research 👌
I'm also from Bengal.
All the informations are 100% true. Very informative.
This is the real corrupted Bengal.
convert to islam see how muslim tmc is happy with muslim
Excellent analysis, thanks for this video 🙏🏻
Thank you Akash - this is quality journalism that India is screaming for. Unfortunately the mainstream media is bought out
Hinduphobic Deshdrohi Banergy exposed on "Engineer explains" Channel
Anti India Anti Hindu Akash journalism
🇮🇳This is simple. Why there is violence every time in wb during election.??
*When there are no resources of jobs, parties become a place to earn money* 🇮🇳
The only truth
Too good presentation.
Hope you give us more.
I'm from Bengal.
Outstanding thinking.Thanks a lot for this great analysis.🙏🌷💐
convert to islam see how muslim are happy with tmc
RESPECT for this channel....people like you are the reason I still believe in Democracy!
Hamare eha awo protest karne ka sahas nahi haa....apka Ghar tor daga electric kat danga market nahi jane danga utha la jake mara ga democracy maya belive nikal jaya ga...
Thanks for covering the recent Bengal politics Akash and team! Please consider making an episode on the recruitment scam as well.
So sad to say being a proud Bengali, this what sucks in Bengal. No job, no development, no growth and henceforth we helpless civilians have to migrate to other states for livelihood. This govt should fall, and may be a bet could be taken with hopes not too high.
I am from WB. Eha par paisa se nahi sirf 1 palte Biriyani se vote kharida jata hey.
I`am from West Bengal. You tell that absolutely 100% 👍
I am from Purba Bardhaman, West Bengal
The situation is same, you mentioned.
Booths(vote day) are captured. Counting day also booths are captured.
They are doing anything that they can do.
Rigging is happening in count centers as well.
Democracy is in drain (gutter)
I am only 19 years old but seeing these things I feel stupid in Bengali😢
Thank you for making such detailed video😊
In 2018 election 38% seats were uncontested, 45 people died from Nomination day 😞
Here tmc is divided in two groups...they are the main reason for violence.
I am from westbengal.. I truely appreciated with you.
Jo bhi bol rahi hoo ussee kafi jada violence and corruption hota hai iha😥
when u have 30% muslim and remaining 70% are muslim appeaser like akash banerjee then your state is doomed forever,
Dada you are really making owesome videos.....your last video on manipur was also good, you are realy talks truth. Now a days there are no patriesms anywhere. by the way I'm from Bengal. Thank you dada.....
Thanks Akash for making this episode. I was always keen to know political history and system of West Bengal and you cleared many of my doubts.
Yaha tmc ka gundaraj kayam ho chuka hai... Jo seats normal voting bataya ja raha hai woh v asal me woh v jabardasti ya chhappa vote k jariye hi hasil kiya .....
Samajwad sare samashya ka jad hai. Jaha jaha samajwad faila, authoritarian government sthapit hui. Bihar me jangal raj ke roop me to Bengal me gundaraj. Hame samajwad ko jad se mitana hoga.
Ye samanta ke nam pr garibi bata hai samajwad ne
@@Izone-es3mq ghanta.... Ye tustikaran jyasa kuchh nahi hota... Ye ek political term hai only .... Asal me tmc sarkar me hai aur woh kisi v kimat me Bane rehna chahti hai... Isliye gundaraj aur corruption ko badhawa deti hai ... Tustikaran se tumlog yeh samjhate ho ki muslim o ko bohut kuchh diya jata hai jab ki aisa kuchh v nahi hai... Muslim o ko kuchh nahi milta ... Isliye sahi mudda chhodke tumlog dhyan mat bhatkao...
@@RafKing convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
From bengal i can ensure one thing that this state is doomed now,State election Commission to state Police and even BDO officers are also Curropted and prejudiced towards TMC.
Bhg be
Exactly
@@stxfdt1240tor Babar bichi phulgoluchi pala bara Bangladesh aae gudmarani.
It's too early to such comment.
And this is not tmc's faulty.. this is bengali people mentality.
Jo bhi aaya aur ayega khayega..
@@mrsomen3155 aage UP te Kheto akhon kono khaba khabir scene nai ulto paper leak hole abar starting theke hoye ar amader Bengal aae jokh ar moto manus ar rokto kache puro proof ar Sathe log Dhora porche TMC jate hi hobe Nahole galo Bengal.
Today I am very much pleased by watching your way of exposing not only TMC but the so called "bhodrolok" Left Fronts... Yes this is the bitter truth of Bengal Politics.... Want you to stay politically neutral for future and exposing each & every political party like this.....Jai Hind 😊❤
Namaskar 🙏 I am a Bengali and I am 19 years old. Last year panchayat vote was my first vote in my life. But they didn't let me vote.front of my eyes they put guns on everyone's heads and forcefully propagated voting. Riots and ammunition fights all around. I mean like a nightmare.😢The soil where India's first freedom struggle started, where all the great freedom fighters were not born. Today that May is in the face of destruction. The mole is slowly ending. So my request to all my countrymen please save us🙏
This episode is brilliant.. this is the lived experience and reality in Bengal... I have been cribbing about this political scenario which is killing Bengal... Political domination i.e. dadagiri by party people and their pet goons and corruption are playing a decisive role in rampaging the socio-economic fabric of this state. Even state machinery like police is just a puppet in the hands of these political players. The level of corruption and violence is just unthinkable. Thank you for this episode.
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
Hey DB! Just wanted to drop by and say how much I appreciate your content. Your videos are always insightful and informative. Keep up the fantastic work, and I'm looking forward to what you have for us in the future.we are with you.
❤❤
Ekdam correctly explained.. Most neutral analysis on Bengal politics
😢 Excellent summarisation of the whole situation.
I'm a Bengali but when I see my state being so corrupt it pains me.....I always want Bengal and Bengali to rise high but this current situation is really a matter of concern now!
convert to islam see how Bangladeshi are progressing see what is there to become crypto muslim or muslim appeaser become real muslim
Mai bengal se hu or yeh sab aam bat hai. Central force ko to use hi nehi kiya gaya???
🥲🥲🥲
🤯🤯🤯
😮
@@sauron2000000matlab central force hota hai to chappa vote nehi hota easily, but central force ko baitha diya the koi bhi buth mai nehi duty diya gaya. Sirf WB police(jo didi ka chakar hai)hi tha.
Election commissioner doesn't send the list of sensitive booth to the central force ...
The video is very true. I am from Bengal & I got a revision of political shenanigans of here.
convert to islam u feel everything is ohk see how muslim are happy with tmc
Aap jaise research kiye h sabbasi to ban ta h, ek dam sahi baat bole h, love from bengal ❤aise hi kaam krte rrahi h😊
Thank you Akash and team DB for such hard work and detailed episodes ... 🙌
So true . Be healthy ,stay blessed because Threat comes after truth .
What Bengal used to be and now look at the situation. Only way forward is economy. Make economy stronger for the people of Bengal😢
Apne bangal ka mudda utha k bohot hi achha Kam Kiya hai sir 🙏🙏🙏
Hats off … what a episode. No rubbish, only speaking facts and true data . Not taking anyone’s side always being neutral. Excellent video. In the end i am also from kolkata , just hope someday we will see a video with a thumbs “THE UPRISE OF NEW BENGAL”
Akash ji, I'm from Bengal and the situation is totally chaotic... Police are being assaulted, beaten with bamboo sticks, on the other hand some of them are supporting criminals in rigging. Today in a Panchayat a CPIM member was winning so the TMC member literally tore the bunch of ballots, swallowed half of the paper and threw rest 😂, it's hilarious and shocking at the same time. On 8th hooligans assaulted poling agents, beaten them violently, put water in the ballot box, threw ballot boxes in ponds, put election documents on fire. Destroyed Booths, killed civilians and bombing was the most common matter of this festival. TMC is only highlighting that 11 of their members were killed but it's mostly because of internal conflict of the ruling party as well as due to resistance from other parties. Note that TMC will never ask questions to the state election commission for their loss because the commission itself is just a mere puppet of govt. The same goes for the police force, they have to follow the order. TMC knows their endgame is near, that's why they're trying to stay in power by hook or crook, but that's not gonna work for long now that people are realising their true faces.
I'm from West Bengal... And I totally agree with you
I am from delhi but my grandparents from west bengal,when i always come here this is the question I always ask myself,why here politics was so dirty so today I got the answer after watching your video
Thank you♥️
I am from West Bengal 😢😢😞💔and I can assure anyone that every word is true in this video... Logo ko marke pitke vote me scam karke jit jate ha😞💔
The base of falling, declining of W.B was first-time, made by Mr caning and his police -system.
I am a Bengali and I was born and bred in South Kolkata. Now, let me tell you something this is going to be a bit lengthy however if you read the entire comment you would be able to get the message I have tried to spread you will then be able to see it from a different perspective.
In Kolkata you will find everything but not jobs this is the reason why most of the people get relocated to other cities. It is really hard to get a job here because there are not many corporate companies that are here unlike other cities like Hyderabad, Bangalore, Gurgaon, Pune and NCR Region. Working in a corporate sector means the salary that a corporate employee gets is due to outsourcing the business so basically the money is coming from abroad and since most of the people are leaving Kolkata for a job and relocating to other cities therefore the people who are from Bengal are currently staying and earning as well as spending in that city which is obviously helping the GDP of that particular state to grow.
During the Pandemic there were a lot of people who lost their job due to COVID-19. However on the other hand there were also so a lot of people who got jobs because most of the companies who all are located in cities like Bangalore, Hyderabad, Gurgaon, Pune were offering jobs which can be worked from home. People who cannot relocate to other cities due any reason and are jobless due to the less infrastructure and less availability of the corporate companies in Kolkata could now work from home for the companies which are located outside Kolkata and as previously mentioned the salary which they were getting from abroad by working in an MNC company were being spent in the city of Kolkata.
The only way to make an immediate effect on the GDP of Kolkata can be done only if all the companies located in the other cities start offering work from home, that way people who are jobless in Kolkata could earn money and spend in the city which will impact as an improvement of its GDP.
The more you spend in the city the better it is for its growth. That is how every sector works, even if you look at it from the tourism perspective it is believed that the more tourist visits a particular place the better it will grow, look at Dubai, Singapore, they all have built their empires in such a short time span because these countries are tourist oriented and attracts tourists therefore they were able to grow because the tourists bring money and spend it in the city. Similarly the example I gave of employment through work from home is legit and can be implemented.
Let me know in the comments below if my analysis is wrong or if you have any better ideas to spare.
when u have 30% muslim and remaining 70% are muslim appeaser then your state is doomed forever,