Uncharted Vs Tomb Raider Franchise
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 08. 2024
- We're pitting two of the most epic video game franchises against each other! In this installment of Versus, we’ll be comparing “Tomb Raider” and “Uncharted” to see which is the best treasure-seeking, action-packed franchise. We’ll be comparing each franchise’s strong characters, gameplay, and legacy to decide which one is more worthy of going on a globe-trotting adventure with. Do you prefer the seasoned “Tomb Raider” or the still relatively new “Uncharted?” Let us know in the comments below.
Watch more great Video Game videos here:
Top 10 Video Games That Are Gone FOREVER: • Top 10 Video Games Tha...
Top 20 Greatest Video Game Trilogies of All Time: • Top 20 Greatest Video ...
Top 10 Most Rewatched Video Game Cutscenes Ever: • Top 10 Most Rewatched ...
Test your Trivia Power!
www.watchmojo....
Have Your Idea Become A Video!
wmojo.com/suggest
Subscribe for more great content!
wmojo.com/watc...
Visit WatchMojo Club for Great Deals!
wmojo.com/Watc...
Your trusted authority for Top 10 lists, reviews, tips and tricks, biographies, origins, and entertainment news on Film, TV, Video Games, Comics, Celeb, Music and Superheroes.
#TombRaider
#Uncharted
#TomHolland
#LaraCroft
#NathanDrake
#Film
#VideoGames
#Versus
#Action
Do you prefer the seasoned “Tomb Raider” or the still relatively new “Uncharted?” Let us know in the comments below.
uncharted
Uncharted
I like Uncharted but I prefer Tomb Raider 100%
Uncharted
Uncharted
Lara Croft: I'm the best!
Nathan Drake: No, I am!
Indiana Jones: Amateurs...
😂Jones definitely the best
Ben Gates: Am I a joke to you?
Love Indy but its hard to beat Nates 60+ hours of screentime
Lara could and would kill Indiana in a heartbeat tho lol
@@jayseepea Jones found the Holy Grail, punched and killed both Nazis and Soviets, and helped save the children of an entire Indian village from crazy cultists with little more than a hat, fedora, and a revolver. Lara has a multi-million dollar fortune to help provide her with training and lots of weapons. It's not a case of who would defeat who in a fight, it's a matter of who the better adventurer is and Indiana has them beat...plus he came first so...
Gotta love how they gave Lara croft the character point, because Nathan Drake isn't perfect and makes bad decisions, yet I'm pretty sure Nathan never almost brought about the end of the world like Lara did in shadow of the tomb raider
Well then again I don’t really know any Uncharted game where Nate received a ton of power or used anything like that unlike Shadow of the Tomb Raider. I mean the closest encounter that Nate ever had with something that could make him “invincible” was maybe the sap of the Tree of Life, which can make you become immortal.
Are just a uncharted fan that’s mad that your team lost???
@@thetotozama I'm actually a fan of both 😂
That’s why I put question marks. It’s was a QUESTION
The best character is Lara croft from the classic games
Uncharted was heavily inspired by tomb raider then tomb raider became uncharted
Yes it was inspired by Tomb Raider, but so what?! It dosen't change the fact that Uncharted(deferente franchise) was much more entertaining
@@Wochu-nx4fg tell that to my Sega Saturn.
Gtfo kid 👋 👋
@@Wochu-nx4fg zblazniłeś się trch xD
@@5Ci0N All I said is true and you behave like a kid making a tantrume. Who is a kid here?!
@@radwan9873 W którym momencie? Typek gada głupoty bo faktycznie Uncharted inspirowało z Tomb Raider ale nie było w żadnym momencie w drugą stronę. Tylko pierwsza część uncharted bo reszta to były już tylko drobne poprawki w sterowaniu i podążanie wątkami fabuły bez jakiegokolwiek wpływu ze strony Tomb Raider. W nowej serii Tomb Raider to już zmienia się w grę typu przetrwanie i nie ma tam niczego co zaimplementowali w Uncharted.
I love both games but I’m gonna have to go with uncharted. The story is just way better.
Do you play video games for stories
@@rowanfarmer9029 Yes dude we all play video games for good storylines, good combat systems and good graphics that's how you can make a successful videogame.
@@mohamedfawzy5843 gameplay and graphics are the most important in a video game but it should have some story to it cause most people play for the gameplay and if the story is good for that also but mostly gameplay now this is coming from a og gamer
they didnt even mention character development
if the game doesn't have a good story it is worth playing. Better graphics doesn't make a game good
I love Tomb Raider’s darker tone but Uncharted has more memorable characters.
Uncharted is structured like a Marvel movies. Instantly more palatable for the masses. Lara Croft is a more complex character that has a legacy.
@@kjh4496 But outside Lara I mean? The 2013 game is the only one that comes to mind with memorable characters besides her. Also Larson in the original remake.
@@kjh4496 cope harder. Uncharted has better games with a better story and characters
@@kjh4496 Complex?
A 26 years old game series and I dont even remember "Complex" character of lara.
İn last 3 games they started new to tell the Lara's story.
İn Uncharted 1-2-3-4 we all get new infos about Nate's Backstory.
I think Lara Croft and by extension, the Tomb Raider video game franchise, is what everyone wished they'd be if we were to become a treasure hunter. Famous, successful, etc. But in reality, we'd all be Nathan Drake, just flying by the seat of our pants, seeking greatness from small beginnings, in lands Uncharted.
Great use of the quotes haha
Well, it's more captivating and intriguing to be in Nate's shoes than Lara. Nathan started from nothing as Lara was already the heir of a rich archeologist.
@@hardcorevictor2552well unfortunately they changed that in the reboots.
Though I suppose it could be said.
The first movie is what did the most damage to her game story.
The original Lara Croft when the game's first came out for PS1 and PC came with background information.
she was disinherited by her father for refusing to settle down and be a proper lady of high society.
She chose to get a job as a writer and rented a ran down apartment.
She raided tombs for sport.
Not out of daddy issues 😂
They changed it trying to be more modern? more sympathetic.? perhaps thinking it would make her more of a strong female? On top of the more recent reboot cashing in on hunger games success?Who knows
But essentially we went from a strong female character who chose her own path in life to
A father who is an archaeologist, daughter who hates tombs
yet felt compelled To follow in her father's footsteps ,
Constant whining
.while sneaking around pretending to be katniss everdeen 😂
Tomb Raider sometimes feel like a classic, but Uncharted felt more like experiences.
A classic that didn't go well opus after opus and had to get inspiration from the "experience" to come back, while every Uncharted game launch is to the PS what Zelda is to Nintendo.
I played both Uncharted & Tomb Raider, but Uncharted is definitely my favorite and it’s my childhood game that I love playing most of the time on my PlayStation.
Ive played neither but Lara Croft is way more popular
@@5Ci0N no way
@@5Ci0N nathan drake is uncharted most popular video character
@@Türkiyem-61 lol ok 👌
@@5Ci0N lol i ment playstation sry i Used Auto and then accidently came to uncharted and not playstation
Wouldn't be awesome if they make a game where Lara Croft meets Nathan Drake
Uncharted is clearly the winner here. Uncharted 2 was probably the best experience I've ever had in a video game
Uncharted is brilliant but tomb raider is iconic and built the foundations for modern era video games along with Halo Metal gear solid Mario sonic silent hill and Resident Evil
And of course Lara croft herself Is a video game legend but nathen drake holds his own brilliantly despite not being among the old guard
@@wolfder6661 well, to be fair Lara Croft has been around longer than Nathan Drake & has a much bigger catalog of games
No bruh Tomb Raider is the Winner you Just can't take an L you're no Different than a MCU stan
Fr U2 and 4 solos
@@charles___ lol pretty much everyone knows U2 is the best pure action/adventure game. Only tomb raider 2013 was somewhat close to uncharted. The rest two are mediocre.
I'm predicting this comment section will be a war between fans of Tomb Raider and Uncharted.
I was wrong
Very
@@georgemiller6690 very very
Nathan Drake is more relatable. He makes mistakes and he accepts them. And while it's not like anyone is about to be attacked by Indonesian pirates while looking at Sr Francis Drake's coffin, Nate has loads of relatable things. He has awkward moments, outright downfalls, and some of his decisions stick with him forever. For example, not pulling Sam up in time haunted him with his 'death' for 15 years. Meanwhile Lara is always doing things right, never interested in anything except treasure-hunting, whereas Nate has a love interest, and now a kid.
Nate also had quite a few very underrated allies. Tenzin, Salim, Charlie Cutter, Marissa Chase
Tenzin was the best
A lot of people forget some of the minor characters in the Uncharted games, that had short screen time but still left an impact. Two I can think of are probably Jeff the cameraman and Karl Schafer both from Uncharted 2.
Sully, lol
Jonah: “You’re not Lara Croft.”
Classic Lara Croft: “I am Lara Croft, just not your Lara Croft.”
Doctor Strange: “You knew who Nathan Drake is.”
Lazaravic: “That treasure hunter who’s my enemy.”
Doctor Strange: “And do you think this is him?”
Lazaravic: “No.”
The Tomb Raider (2018) movie is one of the better video game adaptations in recent years. The original Angelina Jolie movies are iconic, but I feel like we don’t talk about how good Alicia Vikander was as reboot Lara Croft.
I’m glad it’s getting a sequel.
@@JuneieBack Me too! No disrespect to Camilla Luddington, but I think Alicia did a much better job at portraying a young Lara Croft - mainly because the movie embraces those classical traits we’ll know and love. She’s sassy at times.
A lot of people hate the survivor era LC because she’s more naive and self-doubting. It’s like no shit, she’s younger, still figuring out who she is, and hasn’t really become the Tomb Raider yet. Of course she’s going to be less confident. And yeah Alicia Vikander was fantastic as LC. Personally after playing the first couple TRs on my ps1 as a kid I didn’t even really get into the franchise until the reboots.
YESS CAN'T WAIT FOR THE SEQUEL
@@carloszestyboy2901 If they ever decide to release ports for modern day consoles, you should play the Legend/Anniversary/Underworld trilogy. Especially Anniversary, as it was a remake of the original Tomb Raider game from 1996.
As a fan of both franchises I gotta go with uncharted
I love both..but there's no way Uncharted could even stand a chance. Tomb Raider has a quarter century of a legacy. She's a video game icon. Drake may be one day..but we wouldn't have drake if we didn't have Lara
iconic=better
Drakes already a iconic character but mostly for PlayStation fans. Xbox and PC never really got a chance to play uncharted unless they got a PlayStation.
Lol uncharted became way more famous in a short period of time. I was blown away by the plot of each series..
Tomb Raider is not that memorable like uncharted
true
@@kro7329 literally no one cares about tomb raider and especially not lara croft. uncharted nowadays is more popular deal with it nerd
I've always found tomb raider to be clunky as hell with meh stories. Ive always loved Uncharted. I prefer the gameplay, better stories, and a graphical showcase of Uncharted. The series has always been a major system seller. The cast is far more memorable than Lara and her butler.
Absolutely love Tomb Raider but I’ve played Uncharted and it’s a cool series as well.
Long live the queen!
ive always found tomb raider to be more fun but uncharted is simply a better franchise in terms of quality
i love the tomb raider franchise......the latest movie was pretty good. i just didnt like the direction the new games went. i didnt like how they did croft's personality and the fact that for some unknown reason they seem to love to put her through pain and make her moan a lot....also didnt like the heavy emphasis on making her a bow girl....like i get it a bow and arrow is cool, but i like her iconic duel pistols more.
I love the bow being her signature weapon. Makes sense for stealth purposes. It is 1 vs like 600 enemies, stealth is the way to go over dual wielding pistols imo.
I honestly love how they put her through hell it just makes me want to her to win more but the moaning that’s just something else 😂
It's tomb raider for me though I like uncharted as well
Haven't played Uncharted yet, but it seriously looks bloody amazing. The Tomb Raider reboot are amongst my favorite games, Shadow of the Tomb raider being my favorite. I think I've replayed it almost 10 times. I'm sure Uncharted will scratch the same itch and be just as awesome can't wait for it to come to pc!!!
I wanted Uncharted to scratch the same itch you mention lol, but it failed miserably in doing so. There's practically not much to explore and don't even get me started on the two, three puzzles that I solved in like a matter of secs. Very rudimentary and simple. So if that's what you want from Uncharted, it won't offer you that. If you want a strong, compelling story with some very good characters and pretty locales, and you're not worried about good gameplay, then you'll be happy. I do hope you enjoy it. I wanted to love that game so much..
@@DragonMistEcstasy well let's see. Tomb Raider like I said is amongst my favorite
@@laptoptweakingtips have your played it yet
@@greenscreenmovieguy5582 yes I have.
Uncharted was one of my favourite games last year! I absolutely loved it
@@laptoptweakingtips well shit ride on glad you loved it 🤘
Gotta give Uncharted Credit if it wasn’t for the Uncharted Trilogy Tomb Raider wouldn’t have stepped up there game and release the 2013 Reboot which bought Lara Back.
it's never ending circle of no Tomb Raider = no Uncharted; no Uncharted = no TR reboot
This is actually a lie the tomb raider reboot was planned during tomb raider legend development back in 2005/6. It wasn’t uncharted at all that inspired the reboot as uncharted wasn’t even being thought of (:! Simple research, hope this helps!
Also if you look up TOMB RAIDER:ASCENSION it seemed tomb raider was taking a more horror approach and more so based upon the film rhona mitra (original model for classic lara Croft) did. (Again this is all very basic research. Square Enix/Crystal releases this stuff to keep fans in the loop of development of TR games from legend to now
@@ladylaracroft9647 I know all of this so you wasted your time im afraid lol ive been on the forums for decades :)
If you look at the core 2006 remake you can clearly see no uncharted inspo because it didn’t exist. You would also know it was a remake, not a reboot so that point you made is a bit moot.
TR2013 very clearly took inspiration from uncharted in terms of gameplay and it would be strange to deny that. Ascension seemed to be more like silent hill or something idk
Boy what-
Tomb Raider still amazing and had the best selling and history in game more then uncharted was.
It never actually feels like a competition, it feels like you pick the winner and work backwards
Tomb Raider ❤️
The new tomb raiders are not even what tomb raider was about, original tomb raider used to be constant puzzles and adventure, having to use brain power at every turn. Now it’s just uncharted raider. Don’t like it. Doesn’t make me wanna come back to play it.
Personally I love tomb raider . Me personally I love tomb raider since I’ve first played anniversary on ps2 then legends on Xbox 360. Tomb raider tho has been an wonderful adventure, the older games were good and overall fun to play. However with uncharted, the characters I like is the brotherly relationship between Nathan and Samuel Morgan/ drake. The uncharted series was good not masterpiece like last of us 1 but good. Tomb raider reboot trilogy series was air grounded, darker which intrigued me by the start, I love Lara Croft. I like Nathan drake.I don’t care who likes who or what’s better or what whatever… I love Lara Croft and I like Nathan drake.There’s no good and bad truths. Y’all opinions have zero affects on how I love these characters. Though I like uncharted, the watchdojo is true to his research, uncharted has been inspired by Indiana jones and tomb raider was created way back in 1996, I miss the OG Lara Croft, but I love the newly rebooted soon unified Lara Croft. She’s like the female version of Bruce Wayne/Batman mixed with Indiana jones and being a archaeologist and tomb assassin, and she’s very beautiful. I’m more invested in the tomb raider reboot trilogy series because Lara Croft has more deep affection of her character development. She’s like playing a female Batman/ Indiana jones like character. Uncharted is a good franchise but sometimes I do often get bored or uninterested in the games. The games have excellent storytelling, but it’s doesn’t interests me at all. It’s bland, boring and it’s like the pirates of the Caribbean. And this is someone whom played all 4 uncharted games. It’s too realism and grounded with no supernatural elements that feels more entertaining than watching people looking for treasure. I don’t understand why people like uncharted? It’s all pirates and treasure. Tomb raider is tomb raiding with cool military organizations and supernatural elements like creatures demons etc. overall this rivalry between the two is stupid, they’re just video games. I don’t fuck with uncharted what much as a lot of video games. I don’t give a fuck about other peoples opinions. I love tomb raider. Though I believe uncharted has better graphics and gameplay, the tomb raider reboot trilogy is superior when it comes to narrative character development and open world with beautiful cultures and religious elements in a globetrotting adventures. I like both but 100% Tomb Raider is superior. It’s an OG everlasting pop culture.
Nah man
Uncharted 4 is a legit masterpiece
@@rickanapaz I agree. I loved both series. Tomb raider origins reboot is over but the series is not over. The new reboot was the origin trilogy not the whole series finale.
Tom as Nathan is the biggest miscast I can remember in a long time 😐
Agreed! I mean the dude is not even British. WTF. Neither is Batman, but there ya go.
@@RareHarmony I think Robert Pattinson showed us in the trailer that he can be a good Batman. I agree with you that Tom Holland was a miscast for Nathan Drake, despite i enjoyed the movie alot because of its good storytelling like Red Notice.
@@mohamedfawzy5843 From what I have seen I have to disagree. Nothing against his acting but his personality it is too bland and dark (yes I know that Batman should be dark, but Bruce should definitely develop feelings and personality,) and Tom is well, a tiny british kid. Pretty much the opposite of Nathan Drake.
@@RareHarmony Yes i know that Tom doesn't fit the character of Nathan Drake and i would rather have Jensen Ackles or Sebstian Stan or even Chris Pratt as Nathan Drake, eventhough the movie was enjoyable like the Rock Blockbuster movies not because of the cast, but because of the storyline.
I've always found it kind of funny how uncharted's protagonists seem to never have any qualms about murdering thousands of mercenaries throughout the franchise.
In all fairness...those people are dicks.
Mercenaries who work for genocidal dictators, one of which even praised Stalin and Hitler
@@Ori_Kohav And Gengis Khan and Pol Pot.
Would you care about someone trying to kill you?
He actually Jokes about it when he kills them. That guy is a psychopath
Seriously, if Sony doesn't get rid of AVI ARAD
Their new cinematic universe won't last long
Tomb Raider all the way !!!
Tomb Raider paved the way for graphics, gameplay and female characters. Lara was also the first 'celebrity' video game character and kind of changed the public's perception of video games being not only for kids. Uncharted didn't do anything new (that doesn't mean it's bad). But without Tomb Raider, there would be a big butterfly effect of how the game industry developed. Without Uncharted? Nothing would really change
I would say the old style of Tomb Raider games revolutionized the game industry, the reboots really haven't done much of anything good at all.
Uncharted perfected what the new Tomb Raider games were going for.
I think Uncharted refined Tomb Raider with a different feel. Instead of a brilliant serious kick ass Archeologist who often times lets her emotions and obsession with discovery get the best of her, we play as a brilliant sarcastic kick ass professional Thief who' often times lets his obsession with adventure and fortune get the best of him.
"Changed the public's perception of video games Being not only for kids"
Have ever played Doom,Wolfenstein,Resident Evil,Prince of Persia?
@@lifeinthehands6972 ask a random in the street and they have not heard of those games babe
@@jayseepea
Resident Evil 4,5,6,7 sold more than any of Tomb Raider games.
Doom and Wolfenstein are the first fps games ever made.
Prince of Persia was the first Motion Capture made video game.
Lol
I dont even know any of 40+ person even heard of Tomb Raider.
But Resident Evil is a popular movie franchise too.
Which grossed over 1 billion(Which is populer than some horror franchises like Alien,28 Days)
Finally watched the Uncharted film. I like that it goes by its own direction, and I also like the different references to the games. I have one nitpick, though. Chloe's character change, I'm not a fan of it.
It's set to be a prequel Era
@@DemonKingNemo Prequel to the game events? Not fitting at all. The plot details of how Sam and Nate separated are very different from those in the game. Same for how Nate met Sully, and Chloe's past with her father.
The film is obviously going on its own direction.
Chloe betrays Nate in the game first too so nothing new with her character
@@lskknl10 Except that it was Flynn who betrayed Nate, not Chloe. She also had legit feelings for Nate and only refused help out of jealousy. Plus she wasn't anywhere loyal to a greedy pirate like in the film.
So yeah, that's a very different character from the film.
You chose wisely.
Even if I were to add more rounds, the results would be the same:
Platforming: Tomb Raider
Art Direction: Uncharted
Level Design: Tomb Raider
Villains: Uncharted
Ancient lore and mythology: Tomb Raider
Characters:Uncharted
@@Elico-du1oi Tomb raider doesn't have to work with characters. The game works with atmosphere and mythology so it doesn't matter.
@@Hear.myvoice this makes 0 sense lmao what
@@JDisclmd A Tomb Raider game is not about the characters.
It's just about Lara and the wild... The levels, the fact that you are alone and you have to do everything by yourself.
Have you ever played a Tomb Raider game?
@@Hear.myvoice yes and the characters god damn matter. So you’re telling me if Lara Croft was an annoying brat u wouldn’t mind it? Because the characters don’t matter right? Just because she’s alone doesn’t mean Characters don’t matter lmao.
Love the early Tomb Raider games! Please bring this back.
I grew up with the Uncharted but the Tomb Raider series is just unparalleled. There are times that Uncharted are just blazing guns with side treasure hunting with story but there is just depth when exploring tombs and Lara’s personality and story makes it stand out.
Personally, I prefer the Uncharted franchise
I prefer the older Tomb Raider games (specifically the first reboot starting with Tomb Raider Legend) as opposed to the new ones. Lara Croft has become melodramatic like nearly every video game character these days. I rather just play with a cool character and learn about them through their actions, not through painfully long cutscenes. The classic Lara was cool, unique and left an impression, while the modern Lara is just as bland as most modern vg protagonists. Plus there's barely any raiding tombs in the latest games because they try so desperately to be a "character driven" game.
Actually one might argue that most video game protagonists these days are way more interesting and complex than they ever were before. And that's because we are in an era where even in Video Games,the gameplay isn't everything and not enough for most people to cough in 60 bucks. Now their stories and characters matters as much,if not more in a lot of cases.
Mass Effect,Gta,Rdr,Uncharted,God of War,Lou,Spiderman,Witcher 3;these are all games with pretty stellar gameplay but that's really not what they are remembered for because now video games have evolved to a point where they are at par with movies and tv shows when it comes to pure storytelling.
Now getting into a more subjective area,I think the Tomb Raider reboot trilogy is also a good example of good storytelling and character work. Not trying to start an argument here but Lara Croft before was mostly a copy paste of the generic male action heroes famous at that time. I do admit that she was a fairly entertaining character due to her sarcasm and wit,but that is also like the most overused and easy to write character trait in history.
And to some people she was merely a sex symbol,which the games surely didn't try to hide or not take advantage of.
Now I don't feel like explaining why the current Lara is a much nuanced,layered,unique and well written character because this comment is getting too long,but atleast imo,being as big of a gamer that I am,I really don't know any vg characters who are similar to her or have even went through the same arc as her.
Again,not saying the current Lara Croft is the best written character ever in a video game...but she still holds up pretty well on her own and does the job of what a good character should do in a story.
If the old Lara Croft worked for you then thats great,I am not against that...but I will atleast share my thoughts on why I like this one more.
I also do believe Uncharted and Tomb Raider should be tied in a comparison.
@@ezioauditore7759 That's why they should stop creating Tomb Raider. I'd rather have it stopped and have its legacy saved, than make it a generic character driven type of game because Tomb Raider is never about that. It's not about CHARACTERS. Gamers these days are obsessed about characters. I'd rather have TR dead than have it altered beyond recognition just to appease the mainstream audience. I don't trust mainstream audience because they like generic games. Games that only ever focus on storytelling. If it was another game, and if they named it differently instead of Tomb Raider, I'll be fine with it. I don't understand the need to use the "Tomb Raider" name when all they did was to butcher it and has 0 resemblance on how a TR game should play. Sad that they have to rely on an existing IP when they could have just easily create a new franchise.... Instead there's a plethora of modern gamers these days who trash the OG TR games and make fun of it, and we have this classic vs reboot fan wars. Also, classic TR fans can no longer make an argument about reboot TR game without the reboot fans feeling personally attacked as if it's them who were being criticized.
I have an easier way of making this list, Tomb Raider came out first and therefore Uncharted copied off of Tomb Raider and almost every single kind of way therefore Tomb Raider is better the end it's the original nothing can beat Tomb Raider
I started the year with replaying the new Tomb Raider games (with finishing Shadow of the Tomb Raider a few days ago) and gosh has the most recent title a great story! I basically kept stalling my story progression to not re-experience the saddest moment in the game. Can't wait for the new series, the new game (and hopefully second movie...).
I am so glad that Tomb Raider won this battle.
Incharted takes the win for me played both series enjoyed uncharted series more .
I will always love both of these treasure-seeking, action-packed franchises, but it was obvious that "Tomb Raider" would triumph over "Uncharted".
they forget an important fact, uncharte with nathan has already died, the saga was closed in the last game, instead tomb raider can continue for many more stories, a tomb raider game with an open world to horizon zero dawn would be epic .
I didn’t like the uncharted story in the first game but as a whole franchise they are fun
I liked the Tomb Raider franchise more
Both feel like action adventure movies
Chloe Frazier: "Victor Sullivan doesn't have any friends. I should know. I'm one of them."
Ron Burgundy: "That doesn't make any sense."
Some ppl in these comments are throwing tantrums geez everyone’s in titled to their own opinions. Personally I have played both tomb raider games and uncharted. I played tomb raider since it was on ps1. I personally like tomb raider more however uncharted ain’t bad. Uncharted was inspired by tomb raider however they made it different . I also really love the fact that tomb raider is a female character.
I love both franchises but I still give the edge to Tomb Raider. TR 3 x 2 Uncharted sounds just right in my book
I personally think Tomb Raider is superior. The characters are much more memorable and iconic,the settings are more creatively thought out and crafted,and the franchise is so much more.... Odder,for lack of a better word. Uncharted doesn't have "here's a gargantuan hole under the Great Wall Of China,oh looks,there comes a dinosaur!" moments. And i think that specific nonsensical strangeness is charming. That doesn't mean I don't like Uncharted (quite the opposite,in fact) but i prefer Tomb Raider in most aspects.
Old Tomb Raider > Uncharted > New Tomb Raider
this is the right answer
Uncharted gameplay is way more fun with the set pieces etc.
the ps1 tomb raider games alone eat up the entire uncharted series. LARA CROFT IS ICONIC AF
Iconic?
More like s_x icon.
I fucking love uncharted and the character of Nathan drake I’m so glad we finally got an uncharted movie hope we get many more
Team Lara >. Team drake
Ill have to disagree Nathan >>>>>>>Tomb raider
Tomb Raider all the way
Sully is the best goddamn character in the franchise.
Nah nate 1. sully2. Elena 3. Chloe 4. Sam 5.
I like both franchises and I for me I will stick with both. To me they both are good.
Uncharted absolutely
Yepyepyepyepyepyepyep!!!!!
Me too man!
Yessir
They both rock. Done and done.
Grew up playing TR; big fan of both franchises.
Uncharted is significantly better. It’s not even close.
Best Story: Uncharted
Best gameplay: Tomb Raider
should have mentioned the fact that Uncharted has some of the most memorable Villains/BadGuys in gaming, definitely adds to why uncharted is better❤
My friend was like fan of Uncharted, until when a movie trailer came up, he completely shook his head and just kept saying "no, forget it"
Which one of these two movies do you think is exciting and worth watching?
As a Tomb Raider lover, Uncharted is worth.
If you love Fast and Furious you should watch Uncharted.
If you love the reboot TR you'll like TR movie too.
I feel like the legacy category was in there just to give tomb raider the win
Every game has a legacy, this has to be mention
That Uncharted movie is an embarrassment 😆 I just hope that Holland was joking when he said he was gonna play Jak in a Jak and Daxter movie next
Old school Tomb Raider > Uncharted in terms of fun
Uncharted > Reboot Tomb Raider in terms of story
I love both so much, but for me Tomb Raider the W here. I actually think in terms of story telling Tomg Raider is better. I was hooked from the start at every game of the trilogy, where's the first 3 uncharted games are hard to enjoy from the start at least for me, not to mention the rest of those games. Uncharted 4 and 5 are so f******* good tho. It's hard man, but Tomb Raider is better at least for me. Heard a new one is on the way so i cant wait. Hopefully one day we get a Uncharted 6.
Tomb raider is great, but it doesn’t hold a candle to the Uncharted series. Uncharted is just so much better. I would love to see a crossover though.
I grew up with Tomb Raider so i'll always have a soft spot for the series and the recent reboot was amazing with a lot more depth to the gameplay. Uncharted has great story telling, acting and action set pieces and is amazing in its own right for its immersion into its world. Theres probably a tad too many put your controller down and watch moments in Uncharted though and not as much depth to the gameplay as Tomb Raider. Both are awesome series though and I hope they keep making them.
I’ve only played the new tomb raider games but all the uncharted games
Uncharted 2 (the best for me) 9/10
TR 2013 (the only one from the trilogy i've played so far) 9.1/10
For me uncharted is the best because it’s a memorable franchise. Tomb raider is really good but after the final game in the franchise is completed… It was left with some potential for being a memorable franchise.
Lara croft is the female version of indiana jones while nathan drake is the male version of lara croft
Played the both. Enjoyed Tomb Raider much more.
I'm an Xbox player so I could only choose Tomb Raider
Idk if I agree here. When I played uncharted, it left an impression on me. I liked the story, the characters, the cinematic gameplay, the mechanics. But tomb Raider felt like it had no personality and was forgettable.
What happens if you combined Tomb Raider's Gameplay, hero, and legacy mixed with Uncharted's Storytelling and Supporting characters?
That's what we will never get from Tomb Raider sadly.
We all know the real winner
Indiana jones
You asked if I agree with your picks. I do not. Nathan is a far more interesting character than Lara.
Tomb raider started this era but uncharted perfected it
You forgot Soundtrack , uncharted theme come always in my mind and start humming the tune
The story & gameplay was better in Tomb Raider Legend than the 2013 prequel not "reboot", and yes her character was weaker in those.
TR2013 is not a prequel. It’s a reboot. TR legend was also a reboot.
The survivor timeline is
Tomb Raider (2013)
Rise of the tomb raider
Shadow of the tomb raider
Legend timeline:
TR legend
Tr anniversary
Tr underworld
Lara Croft Guardian of light
Lara Croft temple of Osiris
Lara Croft relic run
Both timelines have a completely different Lara and origin for Lara.
Also the classic timeline (which is a total of 9 games from 1996-2003) also has a completely different origin and Lara
All together their are 3 different tomb raider timelines
and yet, Tomb Raider franchise being sold due to the fact that new trilogy created whinning baby Lara, who learned nothing till the end of Shadow
Everyone arguing whos better when I know that Indiana Jones is the best
Be ready:
24.qTomb Raider Chronicles
23.Tomb Raider Angel of Darkness
22.Uncharted
21.Tomb Raider Legend
20.Tomb Raider (reboot)
19.Tomb Raider (GameBoy Color)
18.Tomb Raider Curse of the Sword
17.Tomb Raider Prophecy.
16.Uncharted Golden Abyss.
15.Lara Croft and the Guardian of Light.
14.Rise of the Tomb Raider.
13.Uncharted 3.
12.Lara Croft and the Temple of Osiris.
11.Lara Croft GO.
10.Uncharted: Lost Legacy.
9.Tomb Raider Underworld.
8.Shadow of the Tomb Raifer.
7.Uncharted 4
6.Tomb Raider Anniversary.
5.Uncharted 2.
4.Tomb Raider II.
3.Tomb Raider.
2.Tomb Raider III.
1.Tomb Raider IV: The Last Revelation.
Movies:
4.Tomb Raider: The Cradle of Life
3.Tomb Raider (2018)
2.Uncharted
1. Tomb Raider
Uncharted, Nathan Drake is a much more compelling character with a great set of supporting characters with Elena & Sully
if I had to choose one uncharted would win because the characters are so likable and you’re just rooting for Nathan to win although you’re the person that’s playing Nathan
The fact you didn't use Angelina Jolie for Tomb Raider has me disgusted.
After playing all 3 Tomb Raider (reboot) games and Uncharted. I have to say, I prefer the gameplay of *Tomb Raider* over *Uncharted* any day of the week. Namely because the enemies of the Uncharted games are so f^ck*ng annoying to k*ll. They make sudden, weird, highly unnecessary moves making them annoying to kill and more of a chore to kill them than an obstacle or challenge to over come. I NEVER had that problem in Tomb Raider.
Example, they would run right past me about a good 5 feet away, stop, turn around, and shoot a few times then run for cover somewhere else. It’s happened way too many times. OH! And landing clear headshots that should’ve killed them, didn’t register in the game. Wasting more of my bullets and breaking consistency in the game. This happened way more in U3 than any of their other ones. And that right there has taken the fun and replayability of the games for me.
That and TR has better weapons to play with. Thats not up for debate. You can even customize them to fit your playstyle.
Though admittedly, from TR2 - TR3 did drop in quality, story wise. The 1st being the best. And I probably played it from start to finish at least 5 times. PS3 and Definitive versions. Rise of The Tomb Raider was almost if not just as good as the 1st. Especially in gameplay. Shadow of the Tomb Raider was very…meh. Didn’t enjoy no where near as the 1st two in the trilogy.
That being said though, I enjoy the characters from Uncharted over the characters from TR. I love Nathan Drake more than Lara Croft. Though I care more about Lara, of that makes sense. His charisma and wit, makes him so fun to spend time with and makes the Uncharted worth playing Despite the frustrating gameplay. Especially in 3. Elina Fisher, Sully, Chloe Frazer, Charlie Cutter are all brilliant characters and made more of an impact than any of those in TR. And I enjoy the Uncharted story overall over TR.
Tomb Raider is older than Uncharted.
this was unfair to uncharted lol.
we all know tomb raider is better in every way
Except graphics, gameplay, story, dialog, characters, and video games.
Haven't seen the movie yet.
@@RagnarokMic Tomb Raider had a movie since 2001 LMAO
Uncharted had 1
I played tomb raider and I enjoyed the games but I enjoyed uncharted more because its better overall,it has the better gameplay,the better storyline,the better puzzles,the character development is better,this guy is clearly biased.Yes people/critics didnt like the movie but for a movie based on video game they did a decent job with it because it could have been worser then that just look at resident evil its terrible.
Tomb raider is greater than uncharted in every aspect for me
Not in a million years is Lara more interesting a character than Nathan.
Are you guys doing this because of the new Random Encounters video?
I prefer Tomb Raider
That´s right. Lara Croft beats Nathan Drake
Tomb Raider is my favorite adventure game series. I finished Rise of Tomb Raider now I wanna play the 1st game and Shadow of Tomb Raider.
Uncharted as a franchise and Nathan Drake is LIGHT-YEARS ahead of Tomb Raider. There's a reason no one talks about Tomb Raider these days like they do Uncharted.