You’ve Been Lied About Heera Mandi | The Real Heera Mandi | Syed Muzammil Official
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 05. 2024
- Netflix India debuted a new series titled "Heeramandi: The Diamond Bazaar," helmed by director Sanjay Leela Bhansali, portraying the essence of Heeramandi in a fictional historical narrative.
This production delves into the authentic cultural backdrop and importance of the locale, offering viewers both entertainment and insights into its rich heritage.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Links to our Social Media Channels:
Instagram: /realsyedmuzammil
Twitter: /syedmuzammilofl
Facebook: /syedmuzammilofficial
TikTok: /realsyedmuzammil
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#Heeramandi #lahore #Bollywood
My uncle told me real history of Heeramandi & it depicts everything that you're telling us. Punjab had a rich culture in art, music, dance & folklore full of colors which was destroyed in Pakistan but fortunately preserved in India. In Pakistan the artist is called 'Kanjer' & the same artist is being treated with respect in India. I can assure you if Heeramandi was directed or produced in Pakistan, it would've been banned even before the release. You won't even get to see the trailer of the series. Finally with series, I hope some kind of sense will prevail in minds of majority of Pakistanis.
So true
"Unfortunately "???
Fortunately it was preserved in India.
Unfortunately yeah, go n visit the pages of female Pakistani actors, Pakistani talibans bash em for not wearing full clothes and call them names. This is the mentality of 95% Pakistanis here
@@chandaniberry9369 When I read the comment first time I also read "Unfortunately" then I read it again and saw that it was written as "Fortunately" itself.
If you notice his comment DOES not show edited as well... its just us reading it incorrectly.
Absolute reality
Best part about it is he is referring British India as Hindustan and owning the history that belongs to him. Unfortunately Pakistanis don't own their history
Sunan an-Nasa'i 3959
It was narrated from Anas, that the Messenger of Allah had a female slave with whom he had intercourse, but 'Aishah and Hafsah would not leave him alone until he said that she was forbidden for him. Then Allah, the Mighty and Sublime, revealed:
"O Prophet! Why do you forbid (for yourself) that which Allah has allowed to you.' until the end of the Verse.
सुनन अन-नसाई 3959
अनस से वर्णित है कि अल्लाह के रसूल के पास एक दासी थी जिसके साथ उन्होंने संभोग किया, लेकिन 'आयशा और हफ़सा ने उन्हें तब तक अकेला नहीं छोड़ा जब तक कि उन्होंने कहा कि वह उनके लिए हराम है। तब अल्लाह, शक्तिशाली और उदात्त ने प्रकट किया:
"हे पैगम्बर! आप उस चीज़ को (अपने लिए) क्यों हराम करते हैं जो अल्लाह ने आपको अनुमति दी है।' आयत के अंत तक।
@@Search_Exmuslimsahil_on_yutube So?
@@Search_Exmuslimsahil_on_yutubewhat's wrong with that?
Mujra culture and Mughals culture is definitely his Pakistani culture
It's refreshing to hear a Pakistani young man speak the truth. Great work young man. May God support you in your endeavour ❤❤
6:20 why are you making women look like innocent victims here?? Kisi ne unko la k waha ni bithaya balke wo khud apni marzi se aayin thin...those women are fully responsible for their own actions and are at fault.............and I am not talking about trafficking here ....
11:00 don't call it a profession...they take advantage of men's se*ual nature to loot and rob men of their hard earned earnings.....
Is it true
Counter Violent extremism
In Hindu religion, dance forms like Bharatnatyam and Odyssey have actually evolved from temples,it was a form of worship. So the artisans performing dance or singing classical music were always respected in the society.
Even today, in many hindu families, if a girl is learning dance from the guru, her 'Ghungroos' are secred and kept in the mandir along with the deity murtis.
Kindly use the spelling Odishi / odissi. Odyssey was an epic by Homer. Thanks for mentioning Odishi though.
@@swaroopsubudhi9567might had been auto corrected and he just didn't realise that..
@@a-pandey54321 yes, that did cross my mind. Just wanted to at least give the correct spelling for anyone who might not know about Odishi.
Have a great day/ night. ☮️
@@swaroopsubudhi9567 same to you Bhai 👍
Syed Muzammel, sir, you are most worthy gem in this Himalayan subcontinent. Salute to you from Nepal !!
This is how we not accept our history 😢you are great man ❤🇮🇳🇮🇳
Bhaijan aapse comment karne se aur baat karne se dar lagta hai aapke liye masala Nahin Ho Jaaye Pakistan mein Baki Ham aapse Dil Se Pyar Karte Hain
Aur bhai sahab aapse direct contact karna ho to kaise karen Kuchh Apne Hindu bhai Baithe Hain unke koi help ho sake ham
Masla ap ke liye hoga humare pass democracy hai @@mahendrarar340
@@mahendrarar340 Just like Pakistanis should stop focussing on Palestine and focus on helping their own citizens (Hindu/Muslims/whatever else), Indians should also focus on their own citizens(Hindu/Muslim/etc..) and not on Pakistanis.
@@mahendrarar340सुनन अन-नसाई 3959
अनस से वर्णित है कि अल्लाह के रसूल के पास एक दासी थी जिसके साथ उन्होंने संभोग किया, लेकिन 'आयशा और हफ़सा ने उन्हें तब तक अकेला नहीं छोड़ा जब तक कि उन्होंने कहा कि वह उनके लिए हराम है। तब अल्लाह, शक्तिशाली और उदात्त ने प्रकट किया:
"हे पैगम्बर! आप उस चीज़ को (अपने लिए) क्यों हराम करते हैं जो अल्लाह ने आपको अनुमति दी है।' आयत के अंत तक।
I am Hindu from J&K . And i am happy to know that there is an Intellectual like Syed Muzamil.
Pakistaniyo, Please Listen and follow people like him so that some progress happen in your country.
bro love u... from karachi....i just hope k hindus yahan khush rahen... take care
Mate keep you mockery to yourself. There are a lot of people like him in Pakistan. Again dont tell us what to do, specially from an indian plagued with issues yourself. You are in a occupied region at the moment, i rekon take your own advice.
What kind of progress do you think India has and Pakistan doesn't? 70 crore indians can't read write or speak English even though indian regions were colonized by the British for 180 years. Pakistani regions were last to conquer and even then 2 out of 4 provinces of Pakistan that is KhyberPaktunkhawa and Balochistan was never under full control of British. Pashtuns and Baloch never stopped attacking british. British didn't build anything there.
68 crore Indians are poor to dirt poor ( $5 to $1 a day). The dirt poor indians 21 crore are living worse lives than 3 crore poor of Pakistan. India has the biggest slums and poverty stricken population. It is number 1 country in prostitution, STD's infections, child marriages, dowry deaths and female infanticides. It is listed among top 3 most racist and dangerous countries for women and labor class. I never understood what are Indians racists about anyway? Every USA, UK $billionaire has given bheek to poor public of India since 1952. Bill Gates just gave $400 million to hungry kids of India in 2019. All aid to pak is political and goes directly to ISI because rich billionaires know that Paks public condition is not that bad. Get out of godee media.
@@muzstriker5417 सहीह अल-बुखारी 5068
अनस ने रिवायत किया:
पैगंबर (ﷺ) एक रात में अपनी सभी पत्नियों के साथ यौन संबंध बनाते थे, और उनकी नौ पत्नियाँ थीं।
Progress your country first please
1:55 Hira Singh Dogra was not a Sikh. He was a Hindu Rajput. Sikh Empire doesn't mean every name you hear was a Sikh. There was a great contribution of Dogra Rajputs in establishing the Supremacy of Sikh Empire. In fact, Hira Singh's uncle Gulab Singh Dogra also founded the Dogra dynasty of Jammu and Kashmir. Maharaja Hari Singh was the last ruler of this dynasty.
Yes right he is hindu 😊
He was the biggest traitor namak haram of the Sikh empire. He betrayed the Sikhs to the British in order to become king of Kashmir.
Hira?
Singh is Bling 😂
@@AlphaZuluKilo hasi kis chis ki aayi be tujhe 🧐
about reviews coming out of pakistan about the heeramandi series: I find it amusing when people showcase their knowledge by fact-checking the story in series. it is a piece of art and it isn't meant to be a literal retelling. the story is a combination of exagerrated themes like womanhood, power, resistance, and survival of the tawaifs, portrayal of the weak nawabs, deceitful nature of the british, and homage to freedom fighters, creatively knitted into 8 episodes series. after listening to muzammil, i now think its not even an exaggeration. 5/5 stars for its entertainment value and highlighting the important themes. great production
well said
Heeramandi's women also sacrificed for the independence of the country during the British era but I don't think so Pakistan values and respects them.
6:20 why are you making women look like innocent victims here?? Kisi ne unko la k waha ni bithaya balke wo khud apni marzi se aayin thin...those women are fully responsible for their own actions and are at fault.............and I am not talking about trafficking here ....
11:00 don't call it a profession...they take advantage of men's se*ual nature to loot and rob men of their hard earned earnings.....
We Don't 😂 #IndiaKMKB
@@mike-oj7syYahi karta reh jayega bhai, aise hi tumlog barbad ho. Bhagwan bhala kare tumhara.
Muzammil you have drastically changed my mindset .❤
Aise mind set ke Pakistan mein aadami ho sakta hai Aisa Maine Socha nahin tha
he is the best really maza ajata hai facts n logics love him
Sunan an-Nasa'i 3959
It was narrated from Anas, that the Messenger of Allah had a female slave with whom he had intercourse, but 'Aishah and Hafsah would not leave him alone until he said that she was forbidden for him. Then Allah, the Mighty and Sublime, revealed:
"O Prophet! Why do you forbid (for yourself) that which Allah has allowed to you.' until the end of the Verse.
@@mahendrarar340सुनन अन-नसाई 3959
अनस से वर्णित है कि अल्लाह के रसूल के पास एक दासी थी जिसके साथ उन्होंने संभोग किया, लेकिन 'आयशा और हफ़सा ने उन्हें तब तक अकेला नहीं छोड़ा जब तक कि उन्होंने कहा कि वह उनके लिए हराम है। तब अल्लाह, शक्तिशाली और उदात्त ने प्रकट किया:
"हे पैगम्बर! आप उस चीज़ को (अपने लिए) क्यों हराम करते हैं जो अल्लाह ने आपको अनुमति दी है।' आयत के अंत तक।
6:20 why are you making women look like innocent victims here?? Kisi ne unko la k waha ni bithaya balke wo khud apni marzi se aayin thin...those women are fully responsible for their own actions and are at fault.............and I am not talking about trafficking here ....
11:00 don't call it a profession...they take advantage of men's se*ual nature to loot and rob men of their hard earned earnings.....
In India we still appreciate Classical Music and Dance.
And it is forbade in our religion so we don't appreciate it simple dumb
Muzzamil sir I visited Heera Mandi in January , 2016. because I read madam Fouzia Syed book Hira Mandi. I wanted knowledge about Hira Mandi.i appreciate Mr. Muzammil from u.s.a.
Sir, I want to bring a fact into notice that proves your point right. Across South Indian States traditional dance is still considered respectable because South states had minimum influence of invaders as compared to North.
Such a great point.
South has minimum impact from invaders but it has devidasi tradition which is inherently inhumane for women.
@@KarmazovPlease look up J. Sai Deepak's view on the Devadasi tradition if you are willing to consider a view different from the conventional and imposed.
@@Karmazov Wrong! Devdasis were girls who used to dance for Gods and tell religious stories through their dancing. It was after British invaded India that they turned it into s*x work.
सुनन अन-नसाई 3959
अनस से वर्णित है कि अल्लाह के रसूल के पास एक दासी थी जिसके साथ उन्होंने संभोग किया, लेकिन 'आयशा और हफ़सा ने उन्हें तब तक अकेला नहीं छोड़ा जब तक कि उन्होंने कहा कि वह उनके लिए हराम है। तब अल्लाह, शक्तिशाली और उदात्त ने प्रकट किया:
"हे पैगम्बर! आप उस चीज़ को (अपने लिए) क्यों हराम करते हैं जो अल्लाह ने आपको अनुमति दी है।' आयत के अंत तक।
The best Pakistani commentator. Sophisticated erudite and enlightening.❤
Temples in India (and even in then Pakistan) were places where different kinds of arts were nurtured, because Arts like music and dance were a medium to reach the divine as per Sanatan Dharma.
I am from India and right now I finshed heeramandi and now u made video on it 😊 thank you 🎉
I will n0t agree with Mujjamil. l like my old Heera. I would like to work in old Heer∆❤
Hi
That was the algorithm at work. All your data is compromised
P0rndian 🇮🇳 spotted @@riymusic9741
6:20 why are you making women look like innocent victims here?? Kisi ne unko la k waha ni bithaya balke wo khud apni marzi se aayin thin...those women are fully responsible for their own actions and are at fault.............and I am not talking about trafficking here ....
11:00 don't call it a profession...they take advantage of men's se*ual nature to loot and rob men of their hard earned earnings.....
Britishers destroyed ancient hindu cultural and Islamic cultural practices but after partition Pakistan took this destruction to the next level . In India all traditional Hindu and Islamic music and art is preserved with no partiality . Shahadat Hasan manto and many other people who are considered as taboo in Islamic countries is still very popular and respected in India . In India we have many problem but at least india is very diverse in opinion , culture , art and political ideology .
PUT EVERY BLAME ON BRITISHER OLD MUSLIM MENTALITY🙄
Us Indians and Pakistanis are dieing to go England and live live British style life suit and boot black hat tie boot
Islamic culture is also foreign! Why keep it?
This diversity helps you Indians to deal in foreign countries.
@@jahidhosssin54456 Native Indian/Hindu culture teaches tolerance which helps Indians live peacefully in other countries too. But tolerating a foreign culture in the name of diversity is as good as creating problems for ourselves
Thanks once again for brining the right content forward. Much love from India
It is a brilliant clarification of Heere Mandi. Talking about Sradhana's Begum Samroo by a Pakistani young man is a pleasant surprise. Congratulations to Syed Muzammil.
Have you seen the church at Sardhana ?
Dear Muzammil, thank you for creating awareness around dance, culture and art - As a Kathak student, I am proud to learn this dance form and I am originally from Lahore and the child of the 80s when I was scared to learn Kathak, because of intense pressure of studies and somewhere at the back of my mind I always wanted to learn Kathak - at age 47, i am learning it, loving it and giving my girls full freedom of choice to learn any art form they like -
Thanks for being the progressive man who appreciates art form and respects women at large who want to learn Kathak and Bharat natyam-
Search for Adam Seeker and Sahil ExM
Irfan sir you are great I read many books about Heera Mandi which was real culture of our old India. For Acknowledge I visited Heera Mandi and Tibbi mahalla and many shoe shops January 2016.i read madam Fouzia Syed book ‘Heera Mandi and many column of magazines print in Indian languages with respect of culture not hatred . Love from u.s.a.
All these dances kathak, bharat natyam, kuchipuri are south India dance from andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu. South actress lije HEMA MALINI, JAYA PRADA, REKHA are expert in these dances and were successful in indian hinfi film industry on the basis of dances
Kathak is from LUCKNOW......my city😊
Respect mam ! Dancing is totally haram in islam if you want to do this type of stuff you can go to India 😊 thanks
Syed Muzammil is a gem .
Brilliant,
Being Lahori, learned more about this topic in this video than i ever had watching & hearing all the negative connotations about this place.
Thank you, Muzammil, for your hard work.
Gazwa E Hind Zindabad 💪🏻😍☪️
Brilliant talk, as usual! More strength to you!
At 2:20, (Being an Architecture student) We visited NCA Lahore back in 2015. And a person did a thesis over restoration of Heera Mandi's heritage buildings. And he narrated all of this to us what you're saying. He also told us that 'Tawaif' was used to be a title of an efficient Dancer and it was given as certification just as 'Aalimaa' used for a woman who is well learned at Religion. Well done work sir ji.
6:20 why are you making women look like innocent victims here?? Kisi ne unko la k waha ni bithaya balke wo khud apni marzi se aayin thin...those women are fully responsible for their own actions and are at fault.............and I am not talking about trafficking here ....
11:00 don't call it a profession...they take advantage of men's se*ual nature to loot and rob men of their hard earned earnings.....
tawaif means gifts - among them women given by vanquished king to conquering king or smaller chieftain to bigger ruler
@@TheGrimStoic gift is tahaif not tawaif
@@shees9847 correct - tohfa tahaif sath mein tawaif
I want to read that thesis
Intellectuals are beyond nationality and religion . Grand salute Syed Saheb.
90% of what he said is a LIE.
I will show it with Documents & evidences that he is lying from his teeth.
Extremely grateful to you for this beautiful video .Please continue your good work.This is like a breath of fresh air.
Brilliant!!!
I don't have words to tell how much I admire you
Syed Muzammil you are Gem of Pakistan and your every vlog is most popular in India.
You are very intelligent and raise the social issues and disclose the facts bravely.
Many thanks to you from India.❤❤❤❤
I suggest you please watch Moon Jutt He is also doing his best content from Pakistan like Dhruv Rathi in india
Syed muzammil is a gem. polite, decent, genuine and intelligent person ❤️
Absolutely
I will n0t agree with Mujjamil. l like my old Heera. I would like to work in old Heer∆❤
Pakistani playboy Syed Muzammil Shah
Namaskar Sheetal , kasa kai chala aahe? Jai Maharashtra.
Really ?? Lol
I find him dumb, arrogant and 'I know it all' types
Thank you muzzamil..really appreciate for these insights
I was off your big critique brother but I also admire that you are the best critical thinker in Pakistan.
Investigative journalism doesn't exist in the Print media across the World. Your data accumulation and presentation is no match. Your one of the best guys across the border.
I suggest you please watch Moon Jutt He is also doing his best content from Pakistan
I'm sure you're a very loyal and proud Pakistani, but had you been in India you'd have been appreciated a lot for your knowledge and ideas Muzammil! 🇮🇳
Knowledge has no boundaries 😉
I suggest you please watch Moon Jutt He is also doing his best from Pakistan like Dhruv Rathi in india
@@timehouse5551 dhruv rathi ???
Are you serious??? He is nothing but just a mad dog
Just like they respect Ravish Kumar
He then might be a critique of extremist parties and politics hence would get a label of Anti National
Salute from india to telling me real truth🇮🇳
Mein ne Aaj tak kisi b CZcamsr par comment nai kiya magar aaj ki es Documentary pe comment kar raha hun aur sath mei salute karta hun, well done brother
We as Pakistanis have left all of our heritage and cultures and dont own them and dont let anyone else own them because they are ' against their extreme religious and societal beliefs'. I wish we can display our history proudly once again.
6:20 why are you making women look like innocent victims here?? Kisi ne unko la k waha ni bithaya balke wo khud apni marzi se aayin thin...those women are fully responsible for their own actions and are at fault.............and I am not talking about trafficking here ....
11:00 don't call it a profession...they take advantage of men's se*ual nature to loot and rob men of their hard earned earnings......
Islam is more important than any type of so-called cultural things
Not only culture u all have left your origin DNA 🧬 only because u all got converted to Islam ☪️ what a pitty
Acha pakistani history ka ap ko bahot kheyal ha
And what about our muslim history
R u interested in it also
@@shafaqatali6388isiliye art pakistan me dead ho gaya hai
Pakistani youtubers mein pahle youtuber hain aap Jo bahut hi sensible baten karte Hain
The great interpretation of the old era of India by the Muzzamil is asset for the people to understand the actual history of the subcontinent.
you somehow always get to the bottom of everything. Great job. Keep it up.
Ye iqbal wohi murshid he jisne khud gaya tha "sare jahan se acha hindustan hamara"
"cheen o arab hamara hindustan hamara Muslims hain ham watan hai sara jehan hamara"
@@Logicalsane lol - Cheen o Arab Tumhara, Hindustan Tumhara... Delusions...
Usne bhi desh ka batwaara kiya tha
Gaddar pehli train se nikal Gaya, sare Jahan se achha keh ke.
Ye gaane ke baad, Pehli train se pakistan nikal gaya. 200 IQ move.
Excellent analysis. Love your open views and thorough research. Respect from India.
Beautifully explained, thank you for this video!
Same thing Happened with Devdasis in India, when islamic Morality came to India.
India was a free sex society before the Muslim invasion. Thanks to 330 millions bhagwans the free sex culture is booming again in India.
That is not true. It was Hindus who were against both the Devadasi system, and Mujra culture
Hindus were supporting of both. What is wrong with prostitution ?
@@user-tf1cn9ve5n That is forced upon vulnerable women.
Devdasi system is quite old but devdasis were temple artists n they were paid for these devotional services by the Royal families who supported temples. During Chola period n some Thanjavur scriptures show that Devdasis were land owners who maintained temple properties n had lot of respect. All the southern classical dance forms like Bharatnatyam, Odissi, Kuchipudi are the temple dances performed to praise the God. After islamic invasion n after fall of Vijaynagar, in 16th century, temples lost Royal support n devdasis were used for wrong purpose. British tagged the devdasis as prostitutes bcoz by that time, they were actually forced into prostitution.
Syeed Bhai aap ki iss article nay dil jeet Liya bahoot koob jis tarah scientifically Heera Mandi par rousani dali tarefay kabil hai .❤❤❤
Gem of a blogger. A very educative video. I had no idea about the background of Hiramandi. I'm grateful to you.
Thank you for this 🙏🏻 very well interpreted
Regarding current Pakistani society:
Bandar kya janey adrak k swad.
Pakistan is not for civilized human beings.
Mashallah❤, music and dance are haram🤗😍😎
@@richardsking in that case
💃💃💃💃🕺🕺🕺🕺🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼👍👍😎
@@tariqsheikh5945 exmuslim hai kya
Ex muslim sahil samir zafar adam kuranwala ko suno
Sunan an-Nasa'i 3959
It was narrated from Anas, that the Messenger of Allah had a female slave with whom he had intercourse, but 'Aishah and Hafsah would not leave him alone until he said that she was forbidden for him. Then Allah, the Mighty and Sublime, revealed:
"O Prophet! Why do you forbid (for yourself) that which Allah has allowed to you.' until the end of the Verse.
ہم ہیں بے فیض ادیبوں کے ادھورے مصرعے
اور وہ میر کے دیوان پہ چھایا ہوا شخص
Just respect and love from huripur kpk❤
واہ! بہت اعلیٰ۰ شاعر ؟
Absolutely fantastic podcast and research brought to us by you Syed. बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद 🇮🇳
Syed ji
You are gem in the world.
Great Great respect from India.
Superbly informative and articulated. Well done!
Muzammil you are one of the finest journalists in Pakistan. God bless you!
One of the finest of south east asia
loved the balanced narrative, keep up the good work!
Thanks Syed for such a nice video! Good luck!
I am From Lahore
Absolutely truth it is
Thanks 👍
feeling sad for you that u r from Lahore
Sunan an-Nasa'i 3959
It was narrated from Anas, that the Messenger of Allah had a female slave with whom he had intercourse, but 'Aishah and Hafsah would not leave him alone until he said that she was forbidden for him. Then Allah, the Mighty and Sublime, revealed:
"O Prophet! Why do you forbid (for yourself) that which Allah has allowed to you.' until the end of the Verse.
Search for Adam Seeker and Sahil ExM
@@rahulthaware9117kyu tuny kya apni behn ki shadi karny thy Lahore mai ju sad hu Raha hai at least udhar Gaye Ka mut nhi piya JATA
@@rahulthaware9117feeling sad your ammi was also from Lahore diamond mandi. 😍
Thank god India mein toh folk aur classical dance aur music forms ko continue kar rahe hain.
But they can't be comparable to mujras by trafficked women in brothels
There is an area called Mahboob ki Mehendi in Hyderabad Deccan during Nizam era. Take up that area in your next talk. Love from Hyderabad ❤
Mister Muzammil, I really appreciate you brother... Thank you so much for your efforts.
Excellent and informative as always Muzammil... Keep enlightening the masses!
A very well researched and balanced post. Thanks for shedding light on this
My fvrt spot hiramandi
Pooja
6:20 why are you making women look like innocent victims here?? Kisi ne unko la k waha ni bithaya balke wo khud apni marzi se aayin thin...those women are fully responsible for their own actions and are at fault.............and I am not talking about trafficking here ....
11:00 don't call it a profession...they take advantage of men's se*ual nature to loot and rob men of their hard earned earnings.....
भाई मैं एक भारतीय हूं 🙏🏼 Kanjar शब्द को मैंने कई पाकिस्तानियों के मुँह से सुना है । काफी नफरत से वो इसे बोलते हैं । भारत मे Kanjar को गाली के रूप मे नही बोला जाता । हां उस बिरादरी को सेंधमारी के लिए जाना जाता था अतीत मे । फिर वे लोहार का काम करने लगे ।
Apne yahan isko sexwork type ki gali ki tarah to nhi bolte par isko bola to yaha pe bhi galat tarike se jaata h .
Best video I saw to date on this topic. I was searching frantically for a video telling the accurate history. thank you so much for such an informative video.
Saddat hassan mento is very good author. We can read his work . he also highlighted relevant work
So many instances of Victorian and Christian prejudices distorting the very meaningful and good practices of the subcontinent to denigrate them and show them as low and vulgar.
As a Kashmiri Hindu, it is refreshing to see that there as some Pakistanis who are intelligent, articulate and appreciative of their ancient Indic cuture. Hope you are able to educate the radicals in Pakistan who have grown up hating all non muslims and India.
#IndiaKMKB
syed Muzammel, sir, you are the most worthy gem of our Himalayan subcontinent. salute to you from Nepal !!
Syed brother, contest for Pakistan elections,I'm sure you will win it... Pakistani youth (those who are studying) will all vote for you..... Pakistan need people like you..
😅
Win tow Imran khan ne bhi kiya tha 🤣
Nehi win karega..though he deserves..molla log aur vai log milke Hara dega inko..
Sunan an-Nasa'i 3959
It was narrated from Anas, that the Messenger of Allah had a female slave with whom he had intercourse, but 'Aishah and Hafsah would not leave him alone until he said that she was forbidden for him. Then Allah, the Mighty and Sublime, revealed:
"O Prophet! Why do you forbid (for yourself) that which Allah has allowed to you.' until the end of the Verse.
Dude u know Pakistanis would never support him unless he starts selling religion like imran khan does 😆
this should million views pretty soon Great work Muzzamil
Amazing information , india and pak we both are one .. love from india ♥
No we're not.😂
Two Nation Theory says we are not.
Once again Muzzammil, I really like the variety of topics that you speak on, the misconceptions that you shine the light of truth on, the acceptance of your common history with India which cannot be denied rather accepted to understand the intricate complications in the sub-continent.
Well done!👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
You explained so well. Thank you.
Heera singh dogra was not a sikh ,but as his name suggests a dogra from Jammu,my hometown,muzammil.
Is he hari singh nalwa??
@@Logicalsaneno.h is general.heera singh dogra was brother in law of ranjit singh
@@INDIANATHEIST526 his name is dogra for godsake,dogra is the ethnic name for people of jammu. He was related to maharaja gulab singh of J&K. His father was raja dhian singh ,even sikh wiki mentions him as such,and lets say you are right even then being someones brother in law doesnt take away their paternal identity .
@@Logicalsane hari singh nalwa was a different person,thi is heera singh dogra
Thanks for explaining the story of Heermandi.Love from Bangladesh.
Excellent research, and brilliantly presented Syed Muzammil Sahab.
Wah 👏 Thankyou for making this video kash log samajh sakein apki baat
Aap samjh Gaye aage propagate kijiye
man what clarity. Love you syed from india.
Instead of blaming, Pakistanis should be thankful to Sanjay Leela Bansali for making this movie. They should educate themselves with true history.
Thankful😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Sanjay Leelas bajirao Mastani was also a big lie
Educated saare hindutwa main hain 🤣🤣🤣..lakh di lanat teri baat pe
Pta nahi kyun in Indians ko apni baji zaroor paisa karni hoti hai yahan aakar . Bhai jao aur dhuruv Rathee se kuch seekho whatsapp Universities ke duffer Indians
Ye lukhnow ki heera mandi /bazar e husn hai , lahore ki nahi hai. India ko mashoor kero aurton ko exploit kernay per, Pakistan apna kaam khud ker lay ga . Aye baray thekay dar .
Appreciated! Good piece of information!
It’s always a pleasure watching your work. Thank you so much for this immense knowledge.
WOW! What an educational video. I learned a lot today. Thank you Sir Muzammil sahib.
6:20 why are you making women look like innocent victims here?? Kisi ne unko la k waha ni bithaya balke wo khud apni marzi se aayin thin...those women are fully responsible for their own actions and are at fault.............and I am not talking about trafficking here ....
11:00 don't call it a profession...they take advantage of men's se*ual nature to loot and rob men of their hard earned earnings.....
blame the farmer not the plum. resent Islamic teachings not only Pakistanis
Rightly said... Gumrah howe log
Islam toh har Khushi ke khilaf hai
confused philosopher confused philosophy. islam is mostly copy paste religion. thankfully i am an exmuslim atheist.
Bhai Aap Kabhi India aayen Aapka Swagat hai. Aap jaise Acche Vyaktiyo ke Liye Bharat ka Dil Hamesha Khula hai.
From India. Always love your podcasts. Always on facts and unbiased. Well explained. Hope youth of Pak follow you.
#IndiaKMKB
Thank you for highlighting this misconception
Eagerly awaiting for your videos
I assure that you will make a video on it ❤
❤ from India...apka content kafi informative hai aur quality b kafi achi h
Appreciated❤
Great Sir❤
There were many such locations in pre-Independence India. Sonagacchi in Kolkata, Kanchanwada in Madras / Chennai, several parts of Lucknow and Aligarh, Kamathipura in Mumbai etc. You are spot on about there not being just prostitution. There were many cultural performances with musicians, dancers and more entertaining the elite. Indian movies of the 1950s celebrated these performers in songs like "Nazar Lagee Raja Toray Bungalay Par" etc. In Madras, as late as the 1970s you could bicycle or walk through Kanchanwada and listen to the practice of musicians and dancers getting ready for some event or the other. The tradition died not because it was banned, but because the musicians and the dancers got work in the growing film industry. I know Madras / Chennai better than other cities in India because I was born and grew up there, but even when I left a little more than thirty years ago, the performances took place. They had migrated to the large weekend mansions owned by the wealthy on East Coast Road and the Old Mahabalipuram Road. Perhaps, if Pakistan had a viable film industry, an adventurous filmmaker could offer an accurate depiction of what happened right at the original Heera Mandi location.
Mashallah....Well done.....Allah pak ap ko seht de ....himat de Sach bonny ki......Ameen
Thanks
I am always watching you and listening you Thank you brother
Waoooo i don't think after this video i need to watch Heera mandi. You explained it very well. ❤
Very well explained 👍👍 We should respect and preserve our History. 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Thank you, Muzamal, for educating us.
مزمل بھائی بہت شکریہ یہ تجزیہ میں امید کرتا ہوں ہر پاکستانی سنے ہم نے اپنی ثقافت کو خود پر حرام کر لیا، نقائص کی اصلاح نہیں کی جو کسی اور زرائع سے ہماری تہذیب میں در آئی۔۔ ہمارے بڑوں بزرگوں کا شکریہ جنہوں نے ہیرامنڈی کی اصل تاریخ ہمارے سامنے رکھی جس میں تخلیق کاروں اور ثقافتی سرچشموں کا ذکر سب سے زیادہ ہے۔۔اور یہاں ہیرے کی خرید و فرخت ہوا کرتی تھی پہلے یہ پرانی انارکلی میں ہوا کرتی تھی بعد ازاں ٹیکسالی کی طرف اسے آباد کیا گیا جیسے آپ نے ویڈیو میں بتایا۔۔ ماہ راج کتھک جو عدنان سمیع زیبا بختیار بشرا انصاری اور کئی نامور اداکاروں کے استاد رہے ہیں ان کا گھر بھی وہیں تھا اور دنیا بھر سے آرٹسٹ ان کے پاس ملنے آتے تھے ان محافل میں فیض احمد فیض احمد فراز جوش ملیح آبادی اور نامور لکھاریوں کا آنا جانا تھا۔
This heeramandi thing got more fire Especially in India, after Sanjay leela bhansali's 200cr project , which became very hit on Netflix, or else most of us indians didn't knew about this pre independent thing.
It a HIT - My ass
Heeramandi is a place in Lahore pakistan now,
This place seen different era/ rulers & fascinating colours in history..... Mughal Raj, British Raj,Sikh Raj, 1947 independence time, after 1947 as Pakistan
This place was served as cultural hub performing arts, singing, dancing, literature, writing urdu,poetry, paintings etc
This place also used grain market during sikh Raj,
This place was also famous for twaif / prostitution,
This place is now shoes market 😊 hotels and restaurants!
I have not watched and don’t plan to see the web series but does it match muzammils version
I believe in muzzammil version and calling bhansali production hit is challenge to your mind
@@vivekpatil007bro Bhansali ke production Hira mandi Ke reality sae bhut door haa. As a Lahori I'm living in Lahore.
@@mike-oj7sy thats what I thought
I have no plans to watch this web series
Awesome! I appreciate the way you have described Heeramandi..
I am one of your regular listeners I am always amazed by the style of your narration. You communicate things without references with such a conference as if it is the only way history is to be judged???
Could you explain real history with facts?
I have seen your few videos. Still i can't believe you are from Pakistan.your each & words is true. I m from meerut.You have lots of knowledge. First i salute your mother father than i salute to you. I like your way of talk, your voice (with base) gud video. Lots of love & God always bless you & your family ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👍 8:33
That's the problem"I can't believe" that's how you reduce pakistani intellect to just stereotype
Matlab ap pakistan ko kya smajhtay hain.