Best Chainsaw Brand (ROUND 1 of 2)? Milwaukee vs DeWalt, Makita, Ryobi & WORX
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 10. 2020
- BRANDS TESTED: Milwaukee, DeWalt, Makita, Ryobi, and Worx. Let's test 5 brands of lithium battery powered chainsaws: All of the chainsaws compared against each other and against a 16-inch Stihl MS 170 gasoline chainsaw. The chainsaws competed in 3 tests which include 2 cutting speed tests on 4x4 lumber and one test on hardwood. All of the saws were also tested for battery charge time, no-load run time, noise level, and no-load sprocket/chain speed.
➡ Thank you very much for supporting the channel: / projectfarm
➡ An easy way to find past videos along with products tested: bit.ly/2FCrBpk A big thanks to Jim for putting this together.
➡ Merch: www.Project-Farm.com
➡ Click here if you'd like to subscribe: / @projectfarm
➡ As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
➡ Products Tested In This Video (in no particular order):
Milwaukee: amzn.to/35tPTeF
DeWalt: amzn.to/3AhA0oM
Makita: amzn.to/37I9hqX
Ryobi: amzn.to/2G0HGWG
Worx: amzn.to/3kqHbEk
ROUND 2: • Best Battery Powered C...
ECHO: amzn.to/37d9KRh
EGO: amzn.to/3gNXDxh
Oregon: amzn.to/3n91B61
WEN: amzn.to/3oEkONk
Husqvarna: amzn.to/2JWMqyk
Laser Tachometer: amzn.to/3ozdINn
Videography Equipment:
Sony DSC-RX10 III Cyber-shot Digital Still Camera: amzn.to/2YdXvPw
Canon 70D Camera: amzn.to/31b5Gy0
Azden Microphone: amzn.to/34d3DLE
Go Pro Bundle: amzn.to/30XI3Zr
This video is only for entertainment purposes. If you rely on the information portrayed in this video, you assume the responsibility for the results. Project Farm LLC - Jak na to + styl
Round 2 video testing chainsaws: czcams.com/video/9WDaTwEwhTk/video.html
Publishing a day early this week again to see if it continues to work well. I’m definitely going to put together a round 2 video to include the saws made by “outdoor equipment” manufacturers, like Stihl, Husqvarna, Echo, etc and compare them to the brands just tested. Which brands should I test? Never a sponsor and I always buy everything tested. So, thank you all very much for supporting the channel and for your video ideas! Also, a big thank you to Jim for putting together a quick access video library, which includes a list of products tested. bit.ly/2FCrBpk
Here's a vote for the Greenworks 60v to test.
Your Monday uploads always makes Monday a better day
@@sparks6666 I second this, but also their 80v version because I have those batteries for my lawnmower already.
It would be awesome to see the Bauer brand on the test
Please make a vid about portable bandsaw blades! My Dewalt 20v deep cut bandsaw seems to eat Dewalt brand blades every 3-5 cuts.
I'm in Brazil, in a fairly big city. Living in a 40m2 apartment, I have absolutely no need for a chainsaw. Still watched till the end. 😅
Thanks for watching!
@@ProjectFarm Thank YOU for the great content! :)
@@ProjectFarm jj8i889
You may need a saw to cut up carjackers
there is always a use for a chainsaw
Project farm is the purest being on this site and we must protect him at all costs 🙌
support his patreon
He is a national treasure
Ehhh......... AvEs channel though.......?
Should tell him to lay off the ads a little bit, for that I'd say AvE is. Doesn't pack his vids with ads 👍
@@factorycut2072 Download the Brave browser, works awesome
I no longer go to Consumer Reports to learn about products! Project Farm is my go to source! Thanks again!!!!!
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
Ok, I'm not sorry. This is BY FAR the absolute BEST review and comparison of products with tons of info, facts and tests. Well done sir !!! I wish more comparison and review videos were made this way. Hats off 👍🤟
Thanks so much!
Agree
I hope everyone appreciates this guy... he goes out and buys all of these chainsaws and takes the hours to film these videos, while in each video, achieving the same amount of enthusiasm and determination. You can tell he is not lazy and is very driven to just give people an honest view, it’s up to you if you decide to listen. Thanks project farm for your, once again, enlightening videos. Your videos help me make decisions in more ways than I can count. Keep up the great work, and I hope everyone supports you and keeps you entertained. Thanks for everything,
Jacob
I will probably never use about 99% of the things he tests on this channel, but I watch EVERY video because they are so damn fascinating.
He is the hero we don't deserve!
Imagine the insane amount of profit for something that's technically cheap compared to income damn
Yes, but based on estimates of views/subs, he rakes in $5k/mo on the low end. $20k/mo on the high end. Still good effort, but not exactly charity out of his own pocket.
@@jooper99 $ 91.7K - $ 550K
Project Farm income
$ 1.66K
LAST 7 DAYS
ESTIMATED EARNINGS
$ 6.85K
LAST 30 DAYS
$ 26.5K
LAST 90 DAYS
I would disagree otherwise
Unlike most youtubers who cram a 15 minute video into 45 minutes, you cram a 45 minute video into 15. Bravo.
Thanks for watching.
Just tell me who won in 1 min
Excellent job comparing. I just got rid of my gas powered chain saw and replaced it with a Ryobi. It does a great job. I only use it occasionally and for light jobs.
Ryobi is 100% the best lower price brand in my experience
@@trilla1378my dads been a “general maintenance” guy (does everything under the sun) and he’s a cheap man, so ryobi has been his bread and butter. also became mine by default.
I can say I have the Ryobi I put through a lot over the course of two years and it is still going strong. It's nice just slapping a battery in something and being ready to go.
Really, sounds better than gas and oil and repairing the pull cord before you can even crank the thing. 👍
Two things i find surprisingly nice when using electric chainsaws: zero hastle startup and silence between cuts.
Thanks for sharing.
Indeed. For home use these are ideal. No more fucking around with chokes and yanking that cable a billion times to start.
No mixing fuel. No draining the fuel in winter. No motor maintenance. But I still would rather have my stihl. I can throw it in my truck with a gas can and not worry about running out of battery.
@@DT-kr1km Battery's are never an issue for me , I have replaced 6 different gas powered yard tools with EGO brand tools, all use same battery, Do not miss gas powered equipment at all. Just grab it slid in one of many battery's I have and GO! Stihls are nice saws though except for all the extra stuff. Ego chain saw you do not even need tools for bar, Cant lose them. I have owned stihl and johnsrude , both good saws, but now I am done with gas.
@@steviemack9 - I probably should have explained better. I have a ego mower and a Dewalt trimmer. Both are great. But you CAN'T stick a battery chainsaw in the back of a pickup for a week, throw it onto the 4 wheeler, strap it onto the snowmobile and expect it to work right. Batteries do bad when it's 10 degrees out. They do bad when you don't have multiple batteries readily available. They do bad when your one charger is home and you are at the lake with a dead battery. Besides for the price of an extra battery I can buy a new saw. Home tools are great for batteries. Working tools in adverse conditions, not so much.... yet anyway.
Man, the professionalism of these videos are insane, definitely the most professional accurate tests on youtube, no bias, just preformance, love to see it and keep doing what you do
Thank you very much!
I bought into DeWalt's ecosystem a while ago, and I cant tell you how impressed I have been. Where they don't compete with Milwaukee or Makita, they make up for it in other areas. Overall, they have been a great addition to the garage to replace some older tools that got swiped out of my work truck. I do use a chainsaw frequently, though not for long periods of time while at work, and I bought the DeWalt 16" saw and it is every bit as good as this review makes it sound. The only complaint I have with it isn't the safety, as you do get used to it (their circular saw has the same style safety) it's that the batteries don't release easily and sometimes feel like after use, they get stuck in it. That's probably not a big deal to a lot of you younger people, but an old man like me gets pretty tired by the end of the day, and fidgeting with the release on my saws isn't what I want to do when I just really want to get packed up, put away, and go home.
Thanks for the feedback.
I bought the dewalt. And the expensive batteries. I would still fight with them gas powered and disregard what you say. If this is your living. I think you would be more truthful. I have a family to feed. And any new chain is going to be aggressive to cut through anything. But how will it do with pecan trees? Oh your family is going to go hungry..
@@wegmandan thats oddly aggressive. yes, I do use those tools for my work, and I'm just saying it as I see it.
2 and 4-cycle saws have their place, and if I was going to use a saw for longer or larger cuts, I think common sense would tell me to use a conventional chainsaw. For my purposes, the DeWalt saw works more than great. I have had it for a while now and it gets the job done every time. no complaints.
My family doesn't go hungry, and I'm not being disingenuous. I don't use a chainsaw for hours on end every day, but I do use it at least a few times a week while working on some of my commercial properties. No complaints yet.
@@JSTaylor556
I was wondering about the longevity of the electric saws and if they were made to last.
I'm old , retired, and don't use a saw very much at one time, and might not use it again for a year or longer. Lol
I have a gas powered chainsaw, but a year without using it and it won't crank at all .
Just wondering 👍
@@tlee9484 the little dewalt I have has been running just fine for a few years now. (Or at least close to two years). Keep the chain sharp, bar oil handy, and the battery charged (I do recommend a flex volt battery for it) and it'll do its job.
Like most DeWalt tools I've purchased, it's tough, does the job and keeps doing it over and over.
I'm sure the same could be said for Milwaukee, makita, or any other reputable brand out there.
Every Makita tool I've used has been extremely well designed and manufactured. They have a perfect balance of convenience and capability. They're just all around useful tools. Definitely my favorite brand.
Thanks for sharing.
Extremely well engineered fragile tools Makita in a nutshell
Having owned many DeWalt, Milwaukee and Makita tools, I must say I agree 100%.
@@jwanilpatel3223 they're not fragile
@@jwanilpatel3223said everyone that owns Milwaukee about Milwaukee
I'd like to be Project Farms neighbor when he has a yard sale.
William Schroeder
You gotta wonder what his neighbors actually think when he is running all that equipment at random hours of the day. Also don’t forget when he runs the RV lol
Thanks for watching.
You'd never need to mow your own lawn
Yah until you need a lawnmower or a small engine 😂😂
And NEVER let him borrow your lawn mower!
Honestly, this is one of the best channels in the entire CZcams universe. I would trust your reviews over most anyone, including Consumer Reports.
Wow, thank you!
Agreed.
Agreed, PF, you do an excellent job at reviewing. Two thumbs up, brother!
Definitely agree 👍
Consumer reports seems to be too much "bought and paid for" for me to trust
Man this was an expensive and comprehensive test. Lots of time and cost between saws, replacement chains, lumber, chain oil and time. Thank you for the god tier review. 🙌🏻
You are welcome!
You are actually awesome at this. I really liked your methods of comparison, specifications, and final recap. You have an excellent voice with no distractions or impediments. Well done sir.
Thanks!
I’ve had the makita saw for a minute and it’s great for limbing and some in tree stuff. I still mix up 2 cycle and splash a little on my shirt collar and pants for nostalgia.
Eau de deux de l'essence? >.>
I own this saw too. My wife uses it more than me after I drop the tree. My big stihl was getting too heavy for me.
Lol at least you still got the bar oil to make a mess!
Thanks for sharing!
This man is the BEST reviewers I’ve ever found on CZcams this man takes no sponsors and buys everything with his own money so the tests aren’t bias and bases all his results with testing he is truly one of the best reviewers i’ve seen
Thanks so much!
Yes he is I like it to how he's no sponsorship and how he tests there claims
@Joe W ya that's what makes his reviews useful
Hi, I know this video is 3 years old but still appreciate it. One suggestion, please, ALWAYS wear your chaps when handling chainsaws! Especially on video! Help show people they should be using their PPE! I’m a first responder, do you want me showing up and ask you if you were wearing chaps and you say no. Because my first question is why not? “They’re uncomfortable, I didn’t feel like it, I’m safe if couldn’t happen to me.” Chaps are SO effective at preventing serious injury or death! Please always wear your chaps, and keep doing the amazing work you’re doing sir! I value your channel as a reliable resource!
Thanks for the constructive feedback.
Thank you for such an excellent review! The weighted bar test was especially useful, taking out user-driven variation. And the battery work-to-charge ratios were a great addition!
Thanks and you are welcome!
I'm only half way through this fantastic video and cannot believe how much money you spent on these products to test them. Hopefully your Patrons covered most or all of the cost, since you provide such amazing testing videos :-) A++
Thank you very much! I couldn't put together expensive videos like this one without the Patreon support! I spend every penny of it and even more to fund the videos. As support has increased, the amount I can spend has gone up.
@@ProjectFarm Do you sell off any of the tools after testing them? You could probably recoup some of the cost by putting what you aren't going to continue using on ebay or letgo.
@@HariSeldon913 Good point. Tools that survived his tests in excellent condition, could be sold on offerup for 75% of the new cost. Sell them as demo or testing products.
Not to mention you can recoup 90% of the cost by selling them on ebay. In fact, he could make a lot of money by creating a projectfarm ebay account and auctioning off the tested stuff. People would bid multiples of the tool's value just to support PF.
@@tarstarkusz YT gets 10%, and more off PayPal, then you need ship it....based on what I see in his videos, he's too busy for all the extra running around. I'd say offerup the way to go.
Project Farm: the perfect place to go "no, I've never wondered that, but now I'm curious and need to know!"
Thank you!
Cant wait for this channel to hit 2m subs by this year.
Just seeing this now as we've had a stormy January with a lot to cut in the yard. Thanks for the information. The charts are **very** appreciated. Realize products change over time though just seeing what you're looking for in a saw is useful. Many thanks!
Great thorough review by testing each saw under different conditions. Keep up the very informative work. It really helps out consumers when trying to make the best educated and economical decisions when purchasing power equipment. It really helped me make my decision. Thank You
Thanks and you are welcome!
The Makita comes with FOUR 5.0aH batteries and a dual charger... That actually takes a big chunk out of the price tag in terms of value added if you have Makita tools or want Makita tools.
👍🏼 Agree! 😎
Ive got alot of Makita tools and Dewalt its a real toss up for me to decide which one to buy maybe ill wait till a few more reviews come out on the dewalt but may roll with the Makita just for those extra batteries
@@timking7496 get the Makita , get rid of the safety chain and get a full chisel chain. I just had to cut massive branches on a oak tree before the last hurricane. The 14 inch makita with the archer full chisel chain cut branches thats diameter much bigger than the height of a 5 gallon bucket and it cuts the oak like a hot knife going thru butter.
Great point. The value of the Makita is hard to beat
@@kindakool2529 where you from?
Do I have a chainsaw? no
Do I need a chainsaw? no
Do I watch project farm and doing nothing better with my time? yes
Thanks for watching!
Everybody needs a chainsaw!
@@sjsjr86 Same goes for a truck.
Me exactly, just like the content.
stefantrethan yep and another one and another one now i have seven chain saws😂
Thanks for that video mate. You are by far the best at doing what you do, that I have seen on CZcams or any other platform for that matter. I really like how thorough you are in your review process. I can only imagine that it must take sometimes several days to produce and edit some of these videos. That’s a huge effort mate.
Great job 👏
Thanks and you are welcome!
I bought the 16” Makita as I am team blue anyhow but this video was great. Great Service to the Public. Thanks Sir!
Thanks and you are welcome!
Todd, since you're not tired of doing such a great job coming up with test ideas and spending the $$$ to do them,
*then I'm not tired of saying how much I appreciate your efforts.* God bless.
@TRUST CHRIST OR GO TO HELL! // Although that's true, your delivery misses the mark Biblically:
“Behold, I send you out *as sheep* in the midst of wolves; so be shrewd as serpents *and innocent* [or as one translation puts it]: as *"inoffensive as doves"* [Matt 10 v16; also see Col 4 v5, Phil 2 v15]. Remember; you may be the only form of Christianity, or Jesus that ppl may see/hear.
Try *"sharing"* the truth with ppl instead of *yelling it at them* which even turns me off as a Christian. Share this:
*The Gospel of Jesus Christ:* www.gty.org/library/sermons-library/81-96 - www.gty.org/library/sermons-library/80-296
The way this guy is able to come up with ideas to take the human inconsistencies out of the testing is so awesome. Seriously can’t argue with the results he finds. Nice work man.
Wow, thank you!
Totally agree. My wife and I are both retired chemists and the first time I saw one of his postings I forwarded it to her with a subject line "This guy understands experimental design". The tests are objective, reproducible and verifiable. Kudos Project Farm.
Who doesn’t enjoy scientific method?
@Swim Fan hey now. No politics on this amazing channel.
@Swim Fan oh look, another lefty who has no regard for facts or truth.
Great comparison. Like you style, no nonsense. Subscribed and getting ready to watch part 2. Thanks pal!
Dude, these videos are so thorough, and useful. Thanks for all the hard work!
You are welcome!
You solve all average men’s questions and for that thank you
You are welcome!
And woman. I've been looking to buy one strictly for fire wood and I think I'm going to go on for the Ryobi, for my needs. Thank you so much I enjoy your Channel.
Thanks for spending your hard earned money to give us all these answers we can't find unbiased from anywhere else but you. I know some of these videos probably get pricey.
It also amazes me how you come up with some of the tests you do on the videos too.
Thank you!
This is an amazing channel, doesn't show bias and does actual tests, very scientific, I don't think I would have the work ethic or patience to always do good tests and better videos, sometimes I watch even if I'm not looking to buy
Thanks!
Not knowing much about tools, this channel has helped me a lot. Your professionalism and attention to details makes it easy to buy the right tool. Thanks for all your hardwork.
You are welcome! Glad to hear!
I would love to see the 16" EGO included in the comparison.
Thanks for the video idea.
I have some other ego tools and the advantage is that all ego batteries can power all ego tools.
Ego is the one that would have dominated all of them.
ego is garbage unless u make six figures, and u live in a mc'mansion that takes up 3/4 of the footprint of the land u own, and u think driving a musk e.v. while still flying in a 747 to bring ur family to disneyworld on vacation is the way to save the world.
@@robertthompson3447 as is the case with almost all brands now, so that is not really an advantage over any others.
I’d note egos main disadvantage is their overall lack of tool selection.
Sure they offer a hedge trimmer, about everyone does, but Milwaukee and Ryobi offer 3-5 different models of hedge trimmers. Do they even offer a SDS hammer drill? Everyone else offers at least one if not two models. Ego is limited to homeowner grade, light duty lawn tools. If you want to be limited by selection of tool choices, ego is a good choice. If you actually want to utilize the same battery across different tools, choose about any other brand and you can cut a tree, drill a hole, light an area, pump water, plane a board, inflate a mattress, hot glue some crafts, fix a clogged drain and drill some concrete, ALL with the same single battery.
Battery compatibility across different tools is an advantage you absolutely cannot claim to have over any other brand while using ego. They are the hands down losers of that category. 👎
I foresee a lot of Christmas Coasters being given this year ;)
lol
i read that, walked away. came back and read it again... still didnt get it... time passes... oh, its not that project farm sells coasters, its the log... ok im a moron,,, i seriously pictured "project farm" coasters
@@philtripe same here, lol .
Yeah, but most split in half.
I threw my brand new 18" Oregon bar and chain on my Ryobi (my broken Poulan Pro wasn't using it any more) and slapped in a 6 amp hour battery I could not be happier with the saw. When you consider start time and re-start times of gas saws, the vibration, noise, smell and mixing fuel, Battery saws are awesome. I did not know about the long recharge time. The 6 AH battery lasts so long, I can cut up a 30' tree without issue. I use the same batteries for my string trimmer, blower and lawn mower.
It cuts chucks out of the tree and gets clogged up a bit and I need to clean it out from time to time.
I recently picked up that same model of dewalt saw and have been very impressed with it so far. I knew coming into this video that it is a pretty good saw but the results here actually surprised me. It did better than I anticipated.
Great choice!
“We’re gonna Test that”. Imagine hearing that and your job depended on it.
Thanks for sharing.
Manufacturers suddenly get nervous on hearing that :D
everyday life as a prototype engineer.
And that fear is exactly what marketing people deserve. They deserve to not being able to sleep at night because they lie all the time.
Imagine being one of the selected competitors! :)
I’ve had the makita for over 3 years. I bought so my wife would leave my stills alone. Then I realized that it really was a serious chainsaw. I’ve cut dozens of 10 inch trees down and limbed/cut up the trees. Mine has two 5 amp hour batteries. It’s been a great little saw.
Great feedback! Thank you
I agree. It doesn't replace my 2 stoke saws but I sure do use them less often now that I have my Makita saws. Keep the blade sharp and they are great.
I can't begin to express my thanks for doing this video. This is knowledge that I can use while thinking about the best bang for my buck battery operated chainsaws. Great job.
Thanks and you are welcome! Glad to hear!
Loved the summaries at the end! Helped a lot.
Thanks for the feedback.
Am I the only one who gets excited when he says “we’re going to test that”?
lol
Game on!
You can hear the chuckle in his voice, it's so evil haha
I’ve heard the 18” EGO chainsaw is the best! Too bad it didn’t make your review. Best reviews around!
Next time! Thanks for the suggestion. Thanks so much!
Agreed, please do Ego! I have the weed whip and edger, and I love it. I’d like to get more Ego, but your review would help!
I'll add to the requests for the EGO. I have it and while I think it cuts slower than my similarly sized Husqvarna, for sheer convenience, it's left the husky collecting dust on the shelf.
Another vote for Ego saws. They have two very different saws. The two shorter saws, 14” & 16” operate with a slower chain speed about 6,700 rpm. The 18” is advertised at about 11,000 rpm.
Another vote for the EGO 18", just got one on clearance at HD since the brand is moving to Lowes
Just re-watched this vid from 2020. I bought my Makita lithium 24 v shortly after this video, maybe 6 mo or so after you posted. Already had some Makita LXT stuff, so your vid convinced me to try the Makita. After almost 3 seasons I am so pleased with its ease of operation I haven't taken out my Farm Boss once. It replaces my great running Stihl MS 271 Farm Boss. I only use them occasionally, and always put up my Stihl running it out of gas so nothing in system while stored. It still is finicky to start, but keeps running well. Its only use will be going out in the field/woods with others for longer cut times. Thanks AGAIN. I'm so very happy with my Makita electric.
great review , I've been Thinking about a EC and you've made the decision and choice easier.
Thanks!
My husband and I think that you should review EVERYTHING! Very informative, fast and straight to the point! Great job!
Thanks so much!
@@ProjectFarm Yeah, review which mayonnaise is best!
This must have been expensive man. Thank you for all your work
Yes, credit card limit reached, lol
@@ProjectFarm do you try to return everything ? I would.
@@ProjectFarm jeez man, you didn’t have to do that, you won’t get that money back from CZcams!
@@connorssmallengines6663 www.patreon.com/projectfarm :)
@@ac.creations EBay
Keep up the good comparisons. They are really helpful when making these purchases. Thanks
Thanks, will do! Glad to hear!
Thanks for sharing your results. I’ve got a Ryobi 18 volt chainsaw on the way for delivery. I know that it’s not the same, but all my tools are Ryobis, cause they all share the same batteries. That’s why I purchased it. I’m glad to see that the better model did well in your tests. It makes me feel that my 18 volt , 10 inch chainsaw will be ok. Keep up the great work! I’m always looking forward to seeing your tests
Thanks, will do! Thanks for sharing.
Brands:"sales pitch here"
Project farms: ohh were gonna test that
Thanks for watching!
I am realizing that the marketing gas worked on my with Milwaukee. In may cases, the budget brands perform better.
@@numskull1015 the budget brands are always trash.
No one tests tools like Project Farm! You're doing the world a service!
Thanks so much!
Glad you like the Makita, I use that for quick and light duty jobs and have a few older stihls for medium - heavy duty work
Mate keep doing these honest reviews, and your channel will remain solid.
Cheers from down under!
Thanks, will do!
Could you do angle grinders next specifically 4 1/2
Great video idea! Thank you
@@ProjectFarm Be sure to get a couple cheapies vs. the $100+ tools, because I think the bang-for-the-buck is worth knowing!
@@ProjectFarm Cordless! I have a preference. I'd like to see how it holds up outside my work experience. Thanks for the great tests!
@@ProjectFarm +1, the brushless cordless grinders!
This time test the Ridgid ones too, I love both my plain brushless and Octane versions.
You do a great job on your audio mixing, I particularly enjoyed not having to hear the gasoline powered chainsaw.
As usual your methodical well-thought-out testing gave a good and fair evaluation.
Thank you very much!
LOL. As a battery-powered outdoor tool fan, I particularly enjoy not having to hear the gasoline engine when I'm actually working, not just watching. (Still, great point about the audio mix.)
Your reviews are the best on CZcams by far especially since you aren't affiliated with any of the brands you text, so you are like a breath of fresh air on the net...😊
Thanks and you are welcome!
Another great video. Love how you explain the test sequence and compare apples to apples without corporate influence
Thanks!
Wife : Honey, I've lost 10lbs!!!
Project Farm : We're gonna test that!
lol Thanks for watching!
@@ProjectFarm Come on Todd, be brave and agree this is something you need to put together. Or is my remote arm chair bravado doing the talking here
@projectfarm have any review of Kobalt 80v chainsaw?
As a former professional Logger I really enjoyed this comparison. The most important factor in chain saw operation is how sharp the chain is ; remember even a factory sharpened chain is too dull for productive cutting and it's a real craft to do it by hand. I would like to see you test different chain sharpeners and see if they match up to professional hand sharpening. Thx again.
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
hand sharpening it is definitely a craft you need lots of practice at. I was taught by a couple or lifetime loggers and journeyman trimmers. they made it look easy. I was definitely not as good. lol
Me too ... I have that gift for hand sharpening
There is a huge difference between an electric sharpener and somebody who can hand sharpen a chainsaw. While I was doing Residential tree trimming I had a boss who had been in the business for 20 years who showed me how to hand sharpen a saw and I was blown away by how quickly he could turn a dull blade into A good cutting blade. He could do it on the saw without a vice in about 10 mins on a 15” bar! However, No matter how good you are it’s still sucks to hand sharpen a Stihl MS 661 with a big 36” bar. That’s the one we all dreaded!
@@ryanbrockmiller1648 The new handsharpening kits from Stihl/Pferd are outstanding, you really dont have to be a pro to handle them and the result is good. Especially, when youre out in the woods, they come very handy. Greets from germany
forget about how great this video,he still reply to each and every comment even after 2 years,hats off sir
Thanks! Thanks for watching!
I was watching that no one has much of home owner brands like Skil/ crasftman / Bauer test for jigsaw/ sanders / circular saw / drills / with their blades or bits - impact drills / comparison maybe in a future project your able to do such a comparison . Love your videos they have so much to teach us
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
Here, let’s spend $1k to make a video about electric chainsaws.
Me: watches both ads without skipping.
Thanks so much!
Wait so if u skip an ad he dosnt get paid?
@@ajlr4413 he gets paid, but less.
@@ajlr4413 Just play all of his videos on a playlist overnight if you feel guilty.
Both ads I watched shit on men. As per usual.
I've been researching battery powered saws for several weeks now, so your comparison was perfectly timed, for me;-) Thanks for awesome and unbiased product reviews and comparisons!
You are welcome!
@Dcon : So, will you buy one of the ones tested ?
@@critter3745 more than likely the Makita. The extra batteries that come with the saw are very appealing since they cost $149 a piece at Home Depot. This makes the pricey Makita a bit more of a bargain. I have an 18" gas saw as well but find the battery version a quick, easy and quieter option for smaller jobs around the house.
Love all your reviews..no bullshit. No rambling. Stright to the point .awesome job man👍
Thanks!
Good thing I'm not in a competition lol! I committed to Milwaukee years ago when only DeWalt and Milwaukee were the main considerations for commercial type work so it looks like I'll be plenty satisfied sticking with my chosen brand. Cool video...
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
Now, THAT'S how you do a review...love the categorized fact summaries. Factual and to the point w/o alot of preamble. Excellent work.
Thanks!
@@ProjectFarm tt
...ditto!
Wow. Legitimate tests, to the point, comparison graphs, detailed all the main features of each item... This may be the best comparison video I have EVER watched.
Wow, thanks!
I just have to add a note about those EGO brand battery tools. Starting with their 21" lawnmower with a 7.5 amp battery, I was impressed. Bought it new when it was the only one using a 56 volt or higher battery with a fast charger (noisy charger to start but who really cares). I added a blower, line trimmer and chain saw over a few years and am still quite amazed at their utility. The biggie here is that all these tools will operate with any of their 2.5 amp and higher rated batteries. When I need the most work out of a tool, you know I go for the 7.5 amp battery, grabbing a smaller one to finish a job if necessary. And after all these years, I've still not had a battery failure, a test you haven't mentioned. Love your video tests.
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
I absolutely love your channel and I really appreciate the hundreds you have saved me with your "We're Gonna Test That"! Do you ever sell the used usable equipment or even some of the unusable stuff? Some people really like the memorabilia. Idea for testing if you haven't done it would be the sharpness of router bits and length of run time. Thanks for the magnificent channel Sir!
Thanks and you are welcome! Glad to hear! What tools I don't save for future episodes I donate in my community.
Incredible. I was shopping for a chainsaw an hour ago and stopped because I was undecided about the performance of battery-powered saws. And then, here you are... Thanks so much for making things clear and for all you do
You are welcome!
I'd like to see the 18" E-GO in a comparison with Dewalt and Stihl.
Thanks for the video idea.
Id be curious too on the ego. I have the 21" mower and also the leaf blower. Both perform very well as egos battery system seems to be very powerful. I love my milwaukee stuff, but they don't make a lawn mower, so for me it would be between the ego and milwaukee since i already have lots of tools on these two platforms. Keep up the great videos!
@@firebird327tpi I have the 18" inch EGO and it is an absolute beast. EGO hands down make the best products
@@firebird327tpi The real competition should be between EGO and Greenworks. EGO is headed to Lowes and Greenworks to Home Depot.
Both are serious saws.
I Cut a 19" core tree with my 18" ego and it cut through like butter, about a dozen 17-19" dia. cuts on one 5aH battery.
Absolute beast.
Another excellent video and great comparisons! Love this channel!
Thanks and you are welcome!
I noticed at 11:01 chain looked loose. Great videos and thanks for all your effort.
Thanks and you are welcome!
Sell a t-shirt that says we're going to test that!
yeah he needs to sign up at tee spring
This guy has the best content on CZcams
Wow! Thanks! Thanks for watching!
I’m cracking up😂. Just about every cut was the sentence “I stalled the saw”. Love it. You’re my favorite content creator
Thanks!
So I watched part two first, a lot has changed since. Any chance for a round three? Thank you for the great content, informative as entertaining👍👍
Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for the sugestion.
Would've been interesting to see a comparison with the EGO line and Stihl Electric line, but a great video nonetheless!
Second this. Have the Ego CS1800 18" saw and would like to see how it compares to the competitors.
Great recommendation! Thank you
Don't forget Husqvarna
Another nod to test the Ego saw. Have their Mower, power head with string trimmer and edger. Think their battery packs are good, if you take care of them.
@@sethsalberg3678 very weird. I have all three of those and the hedge trimmer. Very happy with all of them and I'm very interested in getting the chainsaw with the 5 amp battery, so I have one to swap with the mower. I use the 2.5 amp battery with the other 3.
As a test engineer I certainly appreciate the methodology you apply to this and your other tests. Keep it up.
thats good reviews man...good job project farm
Thanks!
Thanks for including where the saws were made!
You are welcome!
Idea: automotive Degreasers store bought vs alternatives (oven cleaner, homemade, diesel, dawn, etc). A showdown bracket.
Great idea, don't forget about gasoline though lol! Boy does gas clean like nothing else. Wonderful solvent.
Thanks for the video idea.
@@Zourkoskey and the safe, environmental alternative ... Simple Green
@@philtripe Don't believe everything you read on a label. While Simple Green is low toxicity on it's own, Simple green in conjunction with petroleum is much more toxic than the petrolium itself. We are talking about de-greasing an engine here, it's not going to be environmentally safe.
@@philtripe Never tried it. Idk about eco friendly but if I am using (mostly) old gasoline, its free and otherwise would just be used to to start fires with. Now of course gasoline is not appropriate for use indoors unless you really like the overwhelming odor of gas. Oh and not to mention you can clean paint brushes with gas to. Wonderful stuff!!! Plus its way cheaper than any purpose built cleaner like simple green.
All in favor of a Project Farm auction of tested equipment say, “aye”.
Dibs on the Makita.
I'm amazed at how much effort you put into this video! Fantastic. Thank you very much....
Thanks and you are welcome!
You are great explaining this the best I ever seen anyone do thanks so much
Thanks and you are welcome!
I love how you go all out to ensure user input isn’t biasing the results. The weight hanging from the front of the bar was brilliant! Happy to be a Patreon
I appreciate that!
Based on this info I'm going to stick to my gasoline powered husqvarna chainsaw. The average run time was a big deal breaker, I need mine to run for hours after a storm breaks down big trees/branches. Might seem weird for a young lady to work with a chainsaw but in todays world I can't afford to get a professional to deal with such things.
Love your channel, its super informative for me and helps loads with getting quality tools and accessories that last me a lifetime! Thank you!
There is nothing wrong when girls know how to handle tools. On coutryside it was quite normal to everyone to be able todrive tracktor and do farmwork. My cousins started to operate when they could push clutch down and operate levers.
You are welcome! Thanks for the feedback.
It's possible to bring along more batteries, just as one would bring more gas. Four 12Ah Milwaukee batteries would go for 4 hours according to the no-load projections, though I wish there had been some kind of load test to get close to real world. If I were going over two hours, I'd probably use gas similar to how you are thinking. Cheers
Ahhh. But the smell and symphony of a gas powered saw...
@@eshxplorn the price of those batteries would buy me 130 liters of fuel which would last me around 10 years on my Ms170.. Just saying.
Awesome comparison video as always!! Thank you!
Thanks and you are welcome!
Best review ever. Really help me decide on best saw for my budget.
Thanks! Glad to hear!
YOU ARE AN ANIMAL. The work this takes is so admirable. Just unreal.
Thanks!
@@sweatlord7 Doesn't matter if he does
@@ProjectFarm I didn’t know what to get I was almost set on a ryobo, then I saw the milwaukke was only 100 more, and we already have like 6 battery’s
@@nicholasfry8695 yes definitely stick with the same platform
@@sweatlord7 what does that have to do with anything? Stop hatin!
All the money your spending on giving us this content is deserving some serious sponsorship. Love you stuff buddy, keep it coming...🤜🤛
Thank you!
If he gets sponsored, then viewers might claim he has bias towards particular brands. I appreciate the unbiased approach and for that reason is why I subbed...plus his videos are AWESOME!!
He denies all sponsors to ensure he stays completely unbais
@@coastaku1954, I understand that and I know that, hes said it multiple times, but the guy deserves it.
@@tedharveyiii5194, I do agree with you about the unbiased approach, but if anything I hope the comments keep him energized because this has always been a channel worth watching.
i love the video format, right to the point, thank you
Thanks and you are welcome!
Another great video! Love your channel; thanks so much!!
Thanks and you are welcome!
The people that dislike these vids must be brand only people who think That one brand is the best and you can’t tell them any different
I definitely trying to deliver the best possible tests and product reviews!
I'll admit I was one of those people. Until Mr. Farm's video on duct style tape. 👍
I liked the video. But 5.0ah vs. 1.5ah and 2.0 is not fair comparison. Should had 2.0 or 1.5 battery on the Milwaukee. The Dewalt and Ryobi would have a had higher output with higher capacity batteries. This goes for any another tool. 5.0 and 1.5 ah batteries are not equal.
Best comparisons I have seen on CZcams. Great work!!!
@@SwiftGQ thats true, but thats how they came in the box so I guess that has to reflect the price/performance
I am so impressed with your video layout, testing methods and for the volume of questions you answer in the comments. Fantastic job keeping the soul of youtube alive! This is exactly what people need videos on, appreciate what you do, seems like you enjoy it too!
Thank you very much!
You Sir are a public hero. Thank you. I'm trying to decide on a chainsaw this week
Thanks!