Gupta in US vs Gupta in India: My reasons to stay in India and Prakash's reasons for not!
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 07. 2024
- Reasons Why I Chose to stay back in India for my residency while Prakash wants to pursue his in US.
0:00 Introduction
2:17
Reason 1 Residency in Medical fields ie Med/Peds/Derma/ Radio are comparable in top Indian colleges - AIIMS/PGI to US.
6:50 : Prakash’s views: Residency in US i better as its much more structured
7:36 No hierarchy in US
9:24 Reason 2
Why I found the process of USMLE be long and tiresome
10:48 Prakash- Why USMLE though tiresome is still better than Indian PG
13:04 - Family matters!(3rd reason)
17:21 4th Reason - Why India is much more happening than US, US gets boring!
23:42 Indian Residents are paid better than US!
25:20 US residents live hand to mouth !
28:20 But Salary of US attending/consultant is much much more than Indian Professor !
29:25 Prakash’s major reasons to move out
35:00 Why money should be the last consideration - its good in both US and India.
2:17
Reason 1 Residency in Medical fields ie Med/Peds/Derma/ Radio are comparable in top Indian colleges - AIIMS/PGI to US.
6:50 : Prakash’s views: Residency in US i better as its much more structured
7:36 No hierarchy in US
9:24 Reason 2
Why I found the process of USMLE be long and tiresome
10:48 Prakash- Why USMLE though tiresome is still better than Indian PG
13:04 - Family matters!(3rd reason)
17:21 4th Reason - Why India is much more happening than US, US gets boring!
23:42 Indian Residents are paid better than US!
25:20 US residents live hand to mouth !
28:20 But Salary of US attending/consultant is much much more than Indian Professor !
29:25 Prakash’s major reasons to move out
35:00 Why money should be the last consideration - its good in both US and India.
thats the best decisionu have taken to serve ur motherland , hats off , the other guy is money lover
@@sckumar6812 ye sab phaltu ke batein tab bolna jab healthcare system ke sath kabhi kaam karo, first they will overwork you , then they will beat you
@@sckumar6812 money lover doctors nhi balki dusri field ke hote hai.
Ek baar karke dekho mbbs , aur phir pg ...
Residency mei torture hote hai doctors pe ..
Seniors alag se waat lagate hai ..
So pls stop calling doctors as money lovers ..If you don't know anything , it's best to keep your mouth shut.
@@Dr.Anshu-vmmc fir b paise ke liye marwate h na sab 🤣
@@Dr.Anshu-vmmc kaam chota ya bada nhi hota bas income hona chye , ye sabse jaruri cheez h
0% click bait
0% nonsense fillers
100% Ground base facts...
Tysm bhaiyas...again every student hopes to have seniors like you both❤❤❤
great video sir
And sir I am your subscriber too.
You are the reason for my US dream.
U r the reason for my USMLE JOURNEY sir thank you 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Are madaan ji 😂😂😂😂
Well thank you for this amazing session...it cleared a lot of myths and doubts personally for me.
Keep up the good work sir
Some of the absolute best content in the academic fraternity here at youtube.
Thanks for this video ❤️
I was so very tempted by the Coca Cola the whole time, I immediately need to get one now!😂
And thank you so much for this insightful video! Really grateful!
Bro it would be a black water
@@harshgupta2362 but still it's better than sprite and dew
Be like Christiano Ronaldo 👍
Extremely helpful...Thank you!
Very well said and discussed. Thoroughly enjoyed it. Love the initiative, effort and time spent in educating others and putting up such videos.
The broader point being, such videos are so informative for someone who is planning to take up medical field after 12th, thinking of settling in US. Thanks to both the doctors for sharing their perspectives.
The education, intellectual level of doctors are high here with both being AIIMS caliber. And thats < 0.5 % of medical students each year. And to hear their perspectives and imbibe these into someone who is not AIIMS caliber and is an avg student is best left to the persons interpretation.
I thoroughly enjoy Dr. Aditya's blogs. I really appreciate the time and energy Dr. Aditya puts, to come out with such videos, given such a hectic life he has. Hats off !! and looking for more such video contents.
Thank you for bringing out such a good content for youngsters. Appreciate your efforts
What a gem of a video this is...I was stuck between usmle and neet pg....finally I choose neet pg... thankyou both of you doc. ❤️
great video format for the topic sir. loved it
Sir, This video was Very Informative. Thank you very much!!! Sit please start a series of PLAB also..
I personally feel although US does provide u financial gains , later in life when u are mature enough and financially stable , money doesn’t make you happy anymore . You miss your parents , your friends , your people and you really question ur life decisions but you can’t do anything about it. Speaking from personal experience. Thankyou!
You can always return u known, no one is tying you to US
But it is something a little bit harder
@@tihorjar8997
Money will bind you
💯💯💯💯
U r not a tree , u can always migrate to a place u like at any point of life ...
You are the comparing the best case scenario in India (AIIMS PGI) with the US. Compare state and private colleges (where you might have to pay for residency) with a mediocre residency program in the US and you will realise how much better it is in the US. Even assuming better finances while in residency in India, the attending salary is so high that you earn 10 years worth of Indian salary in a year in the US.
I always highlighted my reasons to stay in India- and as said towardss the end - the decision is personal. Youre right - avg residency program in US> State Medical college in India. Also salary comparison is unfair even as attending due to higher cost of living. Attending salary should be compared with someone in Private practise as attending in US in private institutes.
@@DrAditya2935 Absolutely. At the end of the day, this is a personal decision and clear cut reasoning cannot be given since people's priorities are different. I disagree regarding the money part because even with high taxes and high cost of living, savings will be much higher in the US allowing you to retire early, if you want to.
You raise valid points, we have only covered our perspectives in the video. But we also highlighted in an earlier video, going to US is a very heavy expense in itself and not everyone is able to afford that, even if they are meritorious. Hence, portraying good salary later on is half of the story. Not counting the emotional and sociocultural toll it brings you on the way. It’s best to consider many other things if finances are not an issue for you.
czcams.com/video/TRidq6S0eUg/video.html
In US doctors have much more respect than what an average doctors gets here
Pls also start a PLAB/UKMLA series like this!!!
czcams.com/users/DrAshishBamania
Yess plz.
Mainly PLAB.....
@@bitwadrudas1130 that's same
Mrcs?
Thanks for this valuable video
Thanks bhaiyaa 🥰
Sir what pattern do you prefer for Mcq practice in neet ug physics and physical chemistry.? Repetitive cyclic practice or always attempting new questions.
Thank you Dr Guptas! This was a very helpful video.
and yes even i'm craving coke now 😅
Aditya bhaiya I would love to see a video from you in which you'll be sharing your foreign experiences and pictures of trip.
Doctor on world tour is quite desirable
Great content!
very informative and helpful video Dr. Gupta and Dr. Gupta😁
GREAT CONVERSATION
Thnks for this info
Ttqsm bros you’ve cleared all my doubts 😊😊
Loads of love❤❤❤❤
Keep going
U are inspiring lot of people
My best wishes😊
The points you’ve made is very accurate tu about comparison between Delhi and a sun urban areas of the states but getting into any medical school In Delhi is highly competitive. So purely as a matter of lifestyle, an average person would have a better lifestyle in an average American city than an average Indian city because that’s where most of the population is going to go
they are comparing brightest of Indian MBBS, among .1 percent
I can't stop binging on his vids! He has such a charming personality. He looks so much younger😂
Useful discussion...But Kindly provide subtitles sir,we can understand everything you had discussed
Dr. Aditya please can you do something about locked questions on your quora profile after the monetization drive by quora plus subscription. It will be quite helpful as you provide a good perspective to things.
+1
What you can do is copy the link then paste them in a TOR browser and open it.long process I know but the only option I found useful currently
Sir plz tell us about 1st year book list which will be helpful for neet pg also
Always been my fav sir♥️♥️ plz teach neet ug many more chapters i rlly loved ur teaching
😍😍😍woww
Pls make a video about required electives! Is it the same as 1 yr internahip period?
I’ have seen Prakash for a while, he will be amazing neurosurgeon some day !
Avg Doctors even dentists in US drive Tesla / Porsche . In india avg doctor life is middle class .
Except dentists/orthodontists aren't looked down upon at in those countries. In fact getting into dentistry is really competitive over there, unlike in India. Dentists aren't even considered as doctors worthy of respect. We really do have some toxic limitations that needs to be eradicated.
@@Nancy-pw5lv the reason for that is dentistry is considered a separate field. In India, most people doing dentistry are those who couldn’t get into MBBS. Unless this changes and the public perspective changes, the mindset will stay the same. Dentists earn good in both places.
@@Nancy-pw5lv exactly!
@@Nancy-pw5lv Look down forget that in US even a plumber is given as much respect if not more as doctors. There is no discrimination among profession.
In India plumber isn't even considered human ( I don't know what they are considered) sick twisted mindset that's what explains all the fights concerning religion and all that crap. The country going down the drain very sad.
While younger upcoming generation are busy in TikTok and Instagram bs.
Leadership is missing if this continues soon we will see people walking pass someone bleeding in the street and don't bother at all while others look around and capture photo to put in their what'sapp status or Instagram or other social media crap.
Sir can you make a video on resources of 3 rd and final yr !!! And the strategy for this two year!!
First view nd 1st like 😍😍
Sir, can you please, if possible, include insights into United Kingdom ? Many students are actually searching for medical careers in UK these days and it would be really helpful !
czcams.com/users/DrAshishBamania
Exactly
Yes sir plz…about nhs!!!!
yess please!
NHS is in a crisis
Good afternoon sir I am a Pg Aspirant with interest to take General medicine . As my rank in INICET is 135 UR and 1300 neet and I am confused whether to take pediatrics in AIIMS ( mostly Raipur ) or should I take medicine in State College ( mostly which I have never heard of). Kindly guide me sir .
I am from Raipur and I have seen AIIMS raipur. The facility here is very good. all departments very good
Hello Sir,
I am aiming to crack AIIMS for my MDS but it’s preperation include knowledge from Sr ship papers …can you please tell how can I get them
Plz make video on INI-SS/ super speciality entrance preparation..
Could you please do this kind of similar video with someone doing residency in U.K.?
Awesome discussion..but i still feel confused
Me too.
Aditya what about about KULDEEP SHARMA dr.k from placebo????
Sir, any discussion on Plab will also be helpful, your views???
❤❤
Interestingly, you both look slightly unhappy while discussing these points of India vs USA. At the end of the day, happiness is a state of mind, it comes from internally. Rememebr, grass is always green on the other side. I am grateful to you both to share this video with us.
Man, these videos are made after a tiring day of work, we are not professional youtubers, nor do we have the time or money to invest in mic/ dslr/ professional video editing. That being said, instead of focusing on the video’s mood, you should focus on the content. Whatever content the video has, is gained after many personal experiences that cannot be acquired from books.
@@jonaskahnwald7394 as a viewer, I will notice everything from mood to affect to thought process and thought content. I see my friends who are in USA drive BMW or Audi right from residencies and I drive Baleno after saving tons of money. My seniors in India treat me like shit. USA residents have iPhones and I have OP. My friends and family members are jealous of me bcz I am a doctor. My patients yell at me and their relatives can beat my anytime. My friends and relatives are not going to save my life.
@@freespirit8791 lol😂😂what a lie
@@freespirit8791 Exactly , Full of Pessimism , Negative thinking , spreading negative vibes everywhere , So u attract Negativity in ur life .... U r not a tree that u hv to spend whole life in same place , u can always go wherever u feel happy , instead of crying here ... And only U r responsible for such pity life u r telling here , by ur attitude .. Others r happy here too ....
@@freespirit8791 not every doctor in india makes a ton of money like AIIMSonians
Gupta ji ke ladke macha rahe hai🤣
Sharmas getting jealous
Plz make video for uk and other country like canada
sir just saw your interview with ndtv that your father one you are an epitome self sacrifice and discipline…….
Mujhe bhi dekhna h, if it's inspiring, please provide link.
@@roteekhaekoho czcams.com/video/nvd64ymb_M0/video.html
Thanks, I watched it today. Yep more respect to Dr. Gupta and his father's ideology of giving back to society
@@roteekhaekoho pleasure is all mine dear :D
Hey Aditya bhaiya, just a little suggestion
Whenever you upload a long video like this, add timestamps.
Sabtar please check the pinned comment by Sir.
Nice video
Thank you so much for such elaborative video. I was exactly looking for this.
May I please know one thing though, if we move to US, what is the minimum time after which we can call our family to stay with us permanently.
Very complex and complicated issue, you will need legal advice for this.
@@jonaskahnwald7394 ohh.. but is there something like if you buy a property there you and your family get early visa?
@@deepikauppal there’s an investment cut off for getting green card, yes. But I doubt that includes your parents. Get legal advice on that too.
@@jonaskahnwald7394 Okay.. thank you for the info :)
I think only way to quickly get the american citizenship and buy property there is to marry to an american citizen
1st seen, 1st comment, 1st like😃❤️🥰
what about UK ? what difference will be there compared to the US and India ?
Can you please please include UK too!
PLAB series plsss
🥺💕
Sir books for first year pr vedio bnaado 😅
Pls make videos for plab
I would rather stay back in India .
I don't know why but I just can't go outside to live I can go for vacations buttttttttt still I am attached to India and I just can't leave her (India) she is like my mother and I can't leave my mother. You would most probably earn more there but I can do with less money but satisfaction is imp ,I just can't sleep peacefully in any other country............: /
So true....
You can definitely sleep peacefully here with the fear of getting beaten by some patient's relatives.
being a doctor and drinking coke is kinda meh, unless there's something else in it...nonetheless very informative video, thanks
Coke isn't good for health 😛
Excellent video Dr. Gupta. This is the most relevant content for our scenario. My daughter wants to pursue medicine. She is currently in 10th grade. We have USA green card and living in India. She is clear that she wants to become a doctor(Neuro surgeon) and also clear about settling down in India. But we are in dillema between doing medicine from USA vs India. What would you suggest? I think getting into AIIMS or any other top med school in India is super hard, compared to that getting into an equivalent med school in USA is not that hard. but considering she wants to live in India post her medical education is making this decision difficult. how hard will it be for her to come back to India practice in India pot her USA education(undergrad etc.. from USA). Or it's better to give NEET UG and study in India itself.
take the india route if you want her to practice in India. it will save her 2 years(6vs8 in US) and a hell lot of money. also remember that degrees only upto US MD(equivalent to mbbs) and mbbs are inter-reconginzable in both the countries.
Question is
How were u reasonably confident that u would get into AIIMS or PGI!?
How can we have a similar level of confidence
he knew his capacity, he put in the amount of hardwork required to get into aiims. which is probably why he was confident enough and this is the only way we can be confident as well.
Its more of aiims vs usa video. But still us med schools are better.
👍
Gupta are very intellectual
Please make video for plab sir
bhaiya can you please make a video on plab?
PLEASE COULD YOU SO SOMETHING FOR PLAB !?
Simple funda earning post degree much much higher n so is standard of living in USA .nothing to do academic or research.
Sir, first year book list please.
Can u suggest me a good books for usmle .??
Gupta Ji ke ladke macha rahe hain :)
Dr Aditya drinking coca cola .. Ronaldo crying in the corner
I thought Boston was a good city and its been depicted in many popular hollywood movies like Departed and Good will hunting
Boston ain’t bad. It’s just that Delhi metro is much better than Boston T.
V/s Gupta in IGIMS PATNA BIHAR🙏
😂😂
😂
🤣Mai bhi igims se hu
@@sarim5593 usmle ki taiyari kr rhe?
Hello Sir
Will it be possible to come back to India after residency in the US
I know people rarely do that
But the thought of completely moving to the US sacres me
I want to know can I come back to India after residency in the US. I don't want to waste the opportunity I have to train in the US. I am on the verge of matching
Any thoughts/suggestions will be appreciated
Yes 100% you can come back to india or anywhere you want. US medical degree is accepted almost allover the world
How did u go to John Hopkins?
Many people don't choose aiims Delhi for treatment because tareekh pe tareekh...
😂😂😂👍🫡
O. ....oo...Oooo... bhaiya.... ji... coke , or. Pepsi 😀😀😀😀😀3:42 min
Sir
What is MRSH LONDON
Usmle study resources of 1st & 2nd yr are excellent, use this to get clinical knowledge,
Use this knowledge to crack central institute,
For money, there are many other good & ethical ways.
what about plab tho?
Compare US to a state college in india
Then u can see the real difference
Not everyone can get pg in aiims
Neither can everyone clear usmle.
Usmle needs both money and exceptional knowledge.
Only the cream of the crop applies for usmle and even among them a lot of them don't get selected.
@@anubhavsaha3942 why the pass percentage for usmle is 90%?
delhi metro started in 2002 and NYC metro (subway) started in 1904, so there will be difference in material and technology.
so?
@@chad807 so comparison is unfair.
Tbh , the other modes of public transports are still cheaper than NYC . US is economically more powerful so it should have made upgrades ,just guessing this point though..
@@xisc-9umarabdullah679 upgrading the metro is not like upgrading a phone or a car. Also, it is still better than a lot of metros in the world. It is just Delhi metro is still 20 years old . BTW I also like Delhi metro, I travel by metro all the time. Metro can't be te deciding factor here and should not have mentioned in this particular video.
Can you go intro depths of
1) does college matter
2) how to make a cv for the match
3) how to prep for usmle from first year
4) what are other options if us does not work out
Hai are you preparing for usmle
@@mohammadhabeeburrahman5264 i just joined first year so i need a better idea
@@shanthikakudva2158 great me too iam also looking for a person who is in 1 year and is an enthusiastic as me for usmle
@@shanthikakudva2158 which college u are in
Kakatiya medical college warangal Telangana u 😅 just saw the reply in inbox after months and still iam interested in usmle and just trying to find entrance gate how to start pprep what to read how to read and all ....
Apne india hi bhadiya h bhai agar aap aiims delhi m ho but agar apka college bekaar h toh bahar dekho
Sir , big thing you missed waiting period of green card for Indian is lifetime which can effect so many issues of life while you can go to any corner of country in India
If you don’t have a green card, that does not mean you can’t live on visa. It’s more of an inconvenience.
@@jonaskahnwald7394 sir but whole life on visa how much it is creating uncertainty!
@@bhatiarahul18 the waiting period is long for sure, but definitely not lifetime. This is true for people coming from other countries as well. Still, no one lives their entire lives on visa because visas are for limited durations.
@@jonaskahnwald7394 sir i have cleared both steps with 230s range but just saw yt video how indian origined drs in late 40s protest about pending green card . I have chosen to live in my tier 2 hometown over countyside in usa with unpredictabllity and uncertainty of life . I hope india catches up soon or i will have to protest here in my late 40s . Good luck for future !
@@jonaskahnwald7394 who told you it's same for other countries China wait is for 1 day
there can never be honest comparison on public platform, if you don't like some things about your own country you will be called anti.....
hi bro
Are u still on??
I would prefer Indian PG rather Than USMLE Beacause I would prefer being in Indian because Living In US Is Too Much Expensive Than In India & We're Far Away from India (I love India)
living is expensive and income also to high .
@@user-nt3dn4lk9y bro after Deducting tax, food & living expenses the salary is equivalent to Indian Residents
It's My Preferences I'm not forcing anyone!
@@user-nt3dn4lk9y Bro USMLE Is too expensive than Indian PG
Love your country, it doesn't give you crap.
Love your life,it gives you everything
video must be titled justifying why I aiims ranker topper stayed in India.. great way to satisfy your ego.
Bone marrow app was the best😂😂
Is aadmi ko usa boring lagta hai. waah
😂
😂
Be dono gupta mere batch mai bhi gupta nay neet nikal liya .....
Matlab in baniyo.....ne to dominate kar rakhi hai duniya.....
How to find position at a research program for an year in the USA 🇺🇸?
This what I need most
Naye video ka intezaar karo dost, ye bhi bataenge
Salary in state med schools r pathetic . Even salary of med schools faculties r ridiculously low. Pathetic pathetic pathetic
another gupta watching
at 3:40 you opposite to ronaldo....... it's just a co incidance funny