History Buffs: Master and Commander

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 17. 09. 2016
  • History Buffs is back! To thank you all for your patience while I've been away on holiday, I'm starting off with Master and Commander!
    SUPPORT HISTORY BUFFS ON PATREON
    / historybuffs
    HISTORY BUFFS MERCH!
    history-buffs-shop.fourthwall....
    ● Follow us on Facebook: / historybuffslondon
    ● Follow us on Twitter: / historybuffs_
    Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World is a 2003 American epic historical drama film written, produced and directed by Peter Weir. The film stars Russell Crowe as Captain Jack Aubrey and Paul Bettany as Dr. Stephen Maturin. The film, which cost $150 million to make, was a co-production of 20th Century Fox, Miramax Films, Universal Pictures, and Samuel Goldwyn Films, and released on November 14, 2003 to critical acclaim. The film's plot and characters are adapted from three novels in author Patrick O'Brian's Aubrey-Maturin series, which includes 20 completed novels of Jack Aubrey's naval career.
    At the 76th Academy Awards, the film was nominated for 10 Oscars, including Best Picture. It won in two categories, Best Cinematography and Best Sound Editing and lost in all other categories to The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King.

Komentáře • 10K

  • @pigpig252
    @pigpig252 Před rokem +598

    I think what I love most about Master and Commander is that it's not really a film about war, it's a film about friendship, duty, and loyalty, with the backdrop of war

    • @TroubleToby3040
      @TroubleToby3040 Před rokem +9

      Just like The Fast and the Furious franchise!!

    • @ShonanMiura
      @ShonanMiura Před 10 měsíci +6

      Absolutely. While the action and seamanship scenes are amazing, equally awesome are the scenes of just conversations happening in the wardroom and elsewhere.

    • @johnbiggans3514
      @johnbiggans3514 Před 8 měsíci

      I thought this video way to short it was such a great movie compared to other shows you’ve done also your giving American audiences way to much there would of been boycotts and crazy people on the news I don’t think it would of helped at all in America

    • @soxman444
      @soxman444 Před 8 měsíci +2

      It's the quintessential "Dudes Rock" movie, and will forever be celebrated as such

  • @Darthbelal
    @Darthbelal Před 4 lety +2918

    If they made more movies like Master and Commander, I'd actually go to movie theaters......

    • @jamesward9646
      @jamesward9646 Před 4 lety +25

      Being a fan of the books I tend to agree but they (movies) need to be closer to O’brians stories!

    • @Konductt
      @Konductt Před 4 lety +70

      sadly the average consumer isnt anything like us, and they will continue to pump out hollow movies lacking substance.

    • @stupidtreehugger
      @stupidtreehugger Před 4 lety +5

      Please don't use the term: "pump out". I can barely control my pack of dogs as it is

    • @thomasedgington6223
      @thomasedgington6223 Před 4 lety +8

      One of my favorite movies ever

    • @thomasedgington6223
      @thomasedgington6223 Před 4 lety +1

      @@Konductt I've grown fond of fan films these past years

  • @douglasmccarthy8914
    @douglasmccarthy8914 Před 2 lety +1184

    This is one movie that despite knowing the outcome, you can watch over and over again. LOVE IT!!

    • @bshocks
      @bshocks Před 2 lety +5

      Yup!

    • @erigon0448
      @erigon0448 Před 2 lety +1

      My dream is to fly over the rainbow so high

    • @XxMasterSasorixX
      @XxMasterSasorixX Před 2 lety +6

      I have watched it 8 times in the last 3 years

    • @davidhughmiller
      @davidhughmiller Před 2 lety

      @@XxMasterSasorixX Watt chef it for the first time ever a few nights ago. Wished I had watched it sooner.

    • @timpower4922
      @timpower4922 Před rokem +2

      A true re-watchable movie for sure. I wish we got more movies like this these days.

  • @EricJohnson-xy3vj
    @EricJohnson-xy3vj Před rokem +409

    Being ex-navy, I really enjoy seeing how many of our naval traditions and terminology come from the royal navy. I also like the subtle reference that the doctor, as a naturalist, being permitted to explore the Galapogos Islands, would have predated Charles Darwin by several decades. This is one of my favorite movies.

    • @coldlakealta4043
      @coldlakealta4043 Před rokem +11

      Darwin had a better press team ... really

    • @SergyMilitaryRankings
      @SergyMilitaryRankings Před rokem +10

      @@coldlakealta4043 Darwin was one of the greatest scientists of all time

    • @sigmasquadleader
      @sigmasquadleader Před rokem

      @LadyGaGa is hot
      The point you missed is so far away, it's hosted on Vimeo.

    • @starfishsystems
      @starfishsystems Před rokem +14

      It's instructive, really. Darwin was one of a great many naturalists in a period of flourishing of that discipline which coincided with extensive exploration by sea. But he managed to do something more than collect and classify specimens. That was his genius, but it was well received because of the particular context of investigation in which it took place.
      Newton and Leibniz contributed something similar to mathematics by (independently and coincidentally) developing the calculus. But there was a context to their efforts as well. Mathematicians were playing with the idea of limits as well as looking for solutions to equations involving change over time. And they were actively corresponding with each other and publishing their results.
      Another important similarity between mathematics and the natural sciences at the time was the good fortune of having a privileged class with good education, ample free time, financial resources, and a certain amount of political influence all at its disposal. Without those opportunities, no amount of personal genius could be expected to make a significant mark on the thinking of the day.
      A roughly similar argument can be made for the classic philosophers of ancient Greece. These weren't peasant fishermen. There had to be a setting in which at least some of the general population could take substantial time out to stop and think, rather than toiling constantly for basic survival.
      Altogether, it makes a fascinating study of cultural tipping points.

    • @MozTS
      @MozTS Před rokem

      @@SergyMilitaryRankings and a secret jew

  • @toddcott9510
    @toddcott9510 Před 4 lety +2126

    This must be most underrated and overlooked film of all time.

    • @toddcott9510
      @toddcott9510 Před 4 lety +6

      @@RegulareoldNorseBoy Nothing like a huge enough hit.

    • @RegulareoldNorseBoy
      @RegulareoldNorseBoy Před 4 lety +49

      @@toddcott9510 it is a damned fine movie. Lovely lines. She is in her prime ;')

    • @alkohallick2901
      @alkohallick2901 Před 4 lety +3

      Great movie!!!

    • @elliotadams3402
      @elliotadams3402 Před 4 lety +12

      @@RegulareoldNorseBoy huge critical success too, nominated in ten categories at the Oscars, loads elsewhere too in a year dominated by LOTR.

    • @7vanave
      @7vanave Před 4 lety +12

      It’s not underrated or overlooked, it’s just not that popular anymore.

  • @konradslush
    @konradslush Před 5 lety +2919

    One of the things I respect the most about this film was the decision to leave out all cringy love-clichés that you find in almost every movie out there.

    • @PaulZink
      @PaulZink Před 5 lety +150

      I'm trying to remember, but I don't recall a single woman being among the characters (not counting the native women when the Surprise anchors at a Pacific island).

    • @wokehumanist958
      @wokehumanist958 Před 5 lety +45

      What about the beautiful native woman who eyes Aubry at the beginning? Talk about a love scene...

    • @konradslush
      @konradslush Před 5 lety +110

      @@wokehumanist958 Yes, but that was like just 6 seconds, and didn't have any other purpouse than to refference that a lot of native women had relationships with seamen and explorers.

    • @wokehumanist958
      @wokehumanist958 Před 5 lety +37

      ​@@konradslush Yeah I know. It was a very short scene and not at all related to the plot. I thought it was interesting that they included it though. An interesting little addition to the film, that added some life and character to Aubry. Not consequential but just enough to add some nuance to Jack's character.

    • @Cramblit
      @Cramblit Před 5 lety +108

      The only love Cliche in Master and Commander is the resounding and loyal love the captain had for his ship, and that's not a bad cliche.

  • @ashscott6068
    @ashscott6068 Před 2 lety +477

    The amazing thing is: The most unrealistic thing about this movie, is how quickly that guy carved that model of the Acheron

    • @davidkantor8064
      @davidkantor8064 Před 2 lety +25

      And where did he get the Elmer's glue?

    • @JesusProtects
      @JesusProtects Před 2 lety +38

      I think the part where they disguise as whalers is not realistic. That boat is very different from the usual whaler boat.

    • @artbagley1406
      @artbagley1406 Před 2 lety +58

      Model of SHIP not carved; was pieced together. The carpenter on board Surprise would have had some glue of sorts plus the wood scraps for the model.

    • @davidstefano2709
      @davidstefano2709 Před rokem +16

      Nah, the most unrealistic thing is Russell Crowe's bowing technique. Even for an actor faking it, it's really bad. Which is surprising, given he was tutored specifically by Richard Tognetti.

    • @alfbeef5880
      @alfbeef5880 Před rokem +8

      Why we have the internet and televisions and hobbies of sorts to keep us busy back in them days they had nothing like this that dude could probably carve that thing in a week if he you put his mind to it

  • @captainyossarian388
    @captainyossarian388 Před 2 lety +59

    The Constitution deserves a great Hollywood movie. She even had an incredible escape when she was becalmed while being pursued by the British navy.
    Incredible that she sits in Boston harbor to this day, is sailed out every July 4th, and is open to tours. You can smell the lovely aroma of Oak in her hull.

    • @HoseTheBeast
      @HoseTheBeast Před 6 měsíci +3

      And she still has her own oak forest, can’t remember which state it is in but the forest is ussed to supply wood for her repairs.

    • @Menuki
      @Menuki Před měsícem +2

      @@HoseTheBeastthere’s actually 2 forests, one north one south. To accommodate her demand for both white oak and live oak.
      It was the naval equivalent of laminated armor

    • @N4TER4DE
      @N4TER4DE Před 14 dny +1

      Got to take a tour almost 15 years ago. It was awesome!

  • @chrisjanwust
    @chrisjanwust Před 7 lety +7505

    How we have 9 spiderman movies, yet no Master and Commander sequel, is beyond me.

    • @Oberstgreup
      @Oberstgreup Před 7 lety +387

      Master and Commander appeals to an older audience. Older audiences won't see the same movie 10 times in the theater and won't flock as reliably to a sequel. And it was pretty expensive to make.

    • @namjoonssexybrain1679
      @namjoonssexybrain1679 Před 6 lety +59

      Chrisjan Wust There are only 6 Spider-Man movies. The last one was pretty great. I would love a Master and Commander sequel, that would be amazing. (Get it? Like the Amazing Spider-Man.)

    • @zuzanabicikova2528
      @zuzanabicikova2528 Před 6 lety +107

      +Christjan Wust Because the movie didn't make as much money as the studio hoped for. It's that simple. I love M&C. I went to see it twice at the theatre and I bought the DVD the moment it came out. I would love to have a sequel but I understand why there isn't one.

    • @1IbramGaunt
      @1IbramGaunt Před 6 lety +137

      Zuzana Bicikova true but he's also right about the older audiences thing, this movie just didn't attract enough younger viewers despite being probably the best naval war movie ever made. Sodding millenials

    • @Nantosuelta
      @Nantosuelta Před 6 lety +31

      I really wanted to see a sequel as well, but the other factor to consider is how exorbitantly expensive it is to shoot an entire film at sea. It's about the most costly environment to shoot in, and would end up costing an ungodly sum. The first films budget was 150 million, and the sequel would most likely cost significantly more than that.

  • @LordHoth_09
    @LordHoth_09 Před 4 lety +796

    This movie is in a group, a very small group of underrated movies that deserved vastly more attention.

    • @t4rv0r60
      @t4rv0r60 Před 3 lety +9

      im in dire need of underrated movies. plz name me a some of the movies, that belong in this very small group

    • @Stewpkiddable
      @Stewpkiddable Před 3 lety +3

      @@t4rv0r60 rounders

    • @Porshadoxus
      @Porshadoxus Před 3 lety +3

      @@t4rv0r60 Greyhound will now be in this list.

    • @Luca-bv5ic
      @Luca-bv5ic Před 3 lety +14

      @@t4rv0r60 the duellists

    • @dakjones
      @dakjones Před 3 lety +8

      Due to the state of current affairs Hollywood will never make another like this.

  • @rangedlime
    @rangedlime Před 3 lety +494

    The scene in this film where they talk about Horatio Nelson and their admiration for him is just such a brilliant scene as someone who bloody loves Horatio Nelson. To not only entertain the fact that this is how those in the navy saw him, but that it could be seen almost as an homage to the man from the filmmakers just warms my patriotic soul

    • @painiscupcake5433
      @painiscupcake5433 Před 3 lety +30

      Blakeney is basically a young Nelson-in-the-making. Missing right arm and all. The captain giving him the book, is basically saying "Hey, it's not so bad. Nelson also lost his right arm and look what became of him".

    • @davesy6969
      @davesy6969 Před 3 lety +15

      You should try reading one of Lord Thomas Cochrane's biographies, or the Autobiography of a seaman by himself. He was in danger of becoming more famous than Nelson for his exploits.

    • @jhtsurvival
      @jhtsurvival Před rokem +1

      You should just read the Patrick Obrien books. There's like 25... they're way better than the movie. This movie combines aspects of like 10 different books into what I would consider to be nonsense. The chase of the enemy ship was actually an American Friggate in the books during the war of 1812. And if memory serves me proper, they lost the battle and get captured... it's tough because the book Master and Commander is nothing like this movie except the same ship name and then "The Far side of the world" is like the 12th book or something... which is also nothing like the movie except maybe the sailing around south America...

    • @topshots0074
      @topshots0074 Před rokem +4

      I'm from Bolivia (landlocked country) and I truly admire the work of Horatio Nelson and the royal Navy. I'm just about to finish reading Roy Adkins book Nelson's Trafalgar which is amazing! This movie really inspired me to buy a book because of the way they mentioned him! I usually never read a book except for school.

    • @theresadoll5374
      @theresadoll5374 Před rokem +1

      James, if you are not also a fan of Winston Churchill’s favourite movie, “Lady Hamilton” I’m going to tut tut and also cry a little ;)

  • @tjn1559
    @tjn1559 Před 3 lety +538

    I always enjoy the Galapagos scenes, where the doctor has to leave his discoveries behind. I wonder if he was made off of Charles Darwin.

    • @d.scottjohnstone6813
      @d.scottjohnstone6813 Před 3 lety +86

      I am glad I ran across your comment! With my degree in Biology with a core emphasis in Genetics (tho quite awhile ago) Mr. Charles Darwin was mentioned just a "few times" during my studies. I think the ships doctor, who, because of some on deck antics, accidently took a bullet and nearly lost his life, was almost definitely Charles Darwin in his early years. Galapagos Islands? The obsession and collection of newly observed creatures and where they fit in (class, phylum, etc...etc...). You tell Me? Haha....I thought of Charles thru out the whole movie! Great flick!

    • @JeffreyDeCristofaro
      @JeffreyDeCristofaro Před 3 lety +16

      Those scenes were definitely fascinating, particularly the appearance of the Galapagos Iguanas. I've always been used to watching those lizards, which are among my favorite animals, on TV documentaries as a kid, and seeing them in the film added more to the immersive feeling of the period, the exotic locales and fauna being characters all their very own.

    • @andrewpandrew7786
      @andrewpandrew7786 Před 2 lety +12

      @@d.scottjohnstone6813 also the actor plays Darwin in a different movie as well!

    • @d.scottjohnstone6813
      @d.scottjohnstone6813 Před 2 lety +2

      @@andrewpandrew7786 Cool! Any idea what the other movie is? And many thanx for the reply by the way from balmy Las Vegas Nevada!

    • @TomDestry
      @TomDestry Před 2 lety +9

      @@d.scottjohnstone6813 In case you've not found out yet, the other film is Creation, starring Paul Bettany.

  • @SiGUYE
    @SiGUYE Před 4 lety +645

    And Russell Crowe sounding American, British, Irish and New Zealander all at the same time?
    We all Love you Russell.

  • @pawlpoche8736
    @pawlpoche8736 Před 3 lety +187

    I was a sailor for 6 years. All the changing of watches, call to general quarters, the officers eating together, the marines handling rifle fire, every detail was reminiscent and great 👍

    • @ThePrader
      @ThePrader Před 2 lety +7

      I too was a sailor. I also enjoyed those same scenes. As an American sea officer I only wish we had been allowed to drink on board. I was lucky enough to be seconded to the Canadian DDH-266, HMCS Nipigon, while serving on an Admirals staff. We had a regular bar in our wardroom. How to make war, but civilized. I almost switched to their navy-LOL.

  • @Ahivalaostia88
    @Ahivalaostia88 Před 3 lety +74

    The music in this film is fantastic.

  • @davidstefano2709
    @davidstefano2709 Před rokem +141

    The most underrated part of this film is the accuracy and excellence of the score. Aubrey and Maturin were accomplished musicians according to the books, and Weir apparently took great care in choosing the music they played together. All very plausible - the most recently-composed work they play was from 1780, all of it would've been quite well-known and well-distributed. The only pre-composed work that isn't accurate was obviously the Tallis Variations, but as it was non-diegetic, it turned out to have been the perfect companion piece for the scene it was used in, as heartbreaking as it was and gets a pass from me. And I thought Iva Davies and Christopher Gordon's original work was brilliant.

    • @rhyswilliams4146
      @rhyswilliams4146 Před rokem +1

      The music selection is excellent. It's unfortunate that Russel Crowe looks nothing like he's playing the violin. It's one of the worst depictions of playing a fiddle I've seen in film. The rest of the picture is superb!

    • @f1zz-k1d89
      @f1zz-k1d89 Před rokem +4

      @@rhyswilliams4146That’s interesting, because apparently he was actually playing the violin in that scene- as well as Bettany actually playing the cello!

    • @casedistorted
      @casedistorted Před rokem +4

      @@f1zz-k1d89 Yea it's kind of like Hawkeye in the first Marvel's Avengers film. He has very very bad form, so they cut out shots of him actually firing arrows so you can't see it in the finished film.
      Crowe is playing the song but he didn't have a ton of time to learn it too. So with the time he had and the fact he's actually playing it is quite impressive.

    • @xactlee
      @xactlee Před rokem

      Nice, thank for the information

  • @diegorincon4673
    @diegorincon4673 Před 4 lety +130

    I like how the movie isn’t just cannon and swords. It really shows how BRUTAL naval combat really is.

  • @MisterTutor2010
    @MisterTutor2010 Před 7 lety +361

    My favorite line from the movie is "To wives and sweethearts. May the never meet.".

    • @MidlifeCrisisJoe
      @MidlifeCrisisJoe Před 6 lety +31

      Typical sailors . . .
      That's probably the best line in the original Austin Powers.
      "No, I meant did you use a condom?"
      "No-hoho. Only sailors use condoms baby!"
      "Not in the nineties Austin!"
      "Well they should those filthy beggars, they go from port to port."

    • @Loverrover
      @Loverrover Před 6 lety +11

      the original Ghostbusters has the best line about fellow sailors when The marshmellow man shows up and they can't figure out how to defeat him Bill Murray says, " We're taking this Stay- Puft guy all wrong. He's a sailor, he's in New York, if we get this guy laid we're ok!"

    • @annalieff-saxby568
      @annalieff-saxby568 Před 4 lety +5

      Really? My favourite is Lucky Jack's "And remember, Surprise is on our side!"

    • @trooperdgb9722
      @trooperdgb9722 Před 4 lety +7

      There is a toast for each day of the week.... to be offered up at a Mess Dinner after the Loyal Toast. (Which of course is made SEATED in the Commonwealth navies...) Saturday is "Sweethearts and Wives"..just that. Some wit will always add "may they never meet" but it is NOT part of the toast. The other toasts include "Ourselves " (Subtitle : as no one else is likely to concern themselves with out welfare) "A bloody War or a sickly season" (Kill off the senior officers to allow promotion) " A willing foe and sea room"... It was delightful as a young RAN officer in the 1980s to be continuing a tradition so old.....

    • @ThePrader
      @ThePrader Před 4 lety +1

      That is an honest to god navy toast. But my favorite, one I heard regularly when I was a naval officer was " to a short and bloody war and quick promotion!"

  • @realrobh
    @realrobh Před 7 měsíci +24

    One of my favorite movies of all time. I can watch this over, and over again.

  • @Tonyblack261
    @Tonyblack261 Před 3 lety +32

    Master and Commander is an amalgam of scenes from the various Patrick O'Brian books. O'Brian goes into great detail, in his books, to describe the Royal Navy and how things worked aboard a Man-o-war. I love this film, because it remains faithful to the book . . . for the most part.

  • @fuflang
    @fuflang Před 3 lety +627

    My favorite part of this movie as a sailor is the vocabulary that is used. Not dumbed down at all.

    • @Euthymia
      @Euthymia Před 3 lety +60

      Yes! I was also delighted to hear them use the term "larbord" for what we would now say "port," or even in some cases "left." Period correct, as it wasn't until 1844 that the RN switched to "port" (according to Wikipedia).

    • @thomasklausen4596
      @thomasklausen4596 Před 3 lety +19

      A balm to the sailor's soul in the era of "Pirates of the Caribbean" and suchlike.

    • @MichaSennin
      @MichaSennin Před 3 lety +3

      @@Euthymia well, you learn everyday. thanks!

    • @jedpcuk
      @jedpcuk Před 2 lety +2

      Yep, as an ex-killick Bunting I could not agree more !

    • @XxowendanxX
      @XxowendanxX Před 2 lety +1

      @@thomasklausen4596 think of this as the day you ALMOST caught Captain Jack Sparrow

  • @mrcat3493
    @mrcat3493 Před 3 lety +137

    One of Russel Crowe’s finest performances. It’s a beautifully filmed movie too.

  • @samernammari8785
    @samernammari8785 Před 2 lety +34

    The engagement between the Speedy and El Gamo is actually the inspiration for the one between HMS Suprise and the Cacafuego in the first book of the series, Master and Commander. Thanks for making this episode-- both the movie and the book series are my favorite!

    • @sgt.oddball7556
      @sgt.oddball7556 Před 2 lety +4

      HMS Sophie, HMS Surprise doesn't make an appearance until the 3rd book.

    • @samernammari8785
      @samernammari8785 Před 2 lety +2

      @@sgt.oddball7556 right! The lopsided sloop! I haven't read the books in ages.

    • @HarryFlashmanVC
      @HarryFlashmanVC Před rokem

      Cochrane was an absolute legend. Founded half a dozen South American navies and remains a hero in many including Chile

  • @deniseeulert2503
    @deniseeulert2503 Před 2 lety +14

    I remember when I first saw this movie. During the one battle, with all the fog and smoke, Aubrey sees the flash of a cannon and dives to the deck, taking a crewmember with him. THEN you hear the roar of sound. The attention to detail was phenomanal. I once saw something like this. On July 2, 1977, I was at Ft Lewis in Washington state, and the US and Canadian forces held a joint national day celebration. The 1812 Overture was played, with 105's for the cannon. They were of course far enough away that one could see the jerk for the firing mechanism, and cover your ears to muffle the sound.

  • @SerCorydonRivers
    @SerCorydonRivers Před 5 lety +305

    I loved the end when the French captain posed as the docter and gave him his sword. I think it was him showing the guy some respect before making a clever escape, showing he too was a clever captain just like jack

    • @ach3909
      @ach3909 Před 4 lety +42

      Might even be the more clever of the two. He surprised the "Surprise" TWICE, coming up on them with the weather gage, first on the fog bank at the start and then from behind them on their run south. Then when Aubrey sprung his trap and cought the French unprepared, they were able to prepare an ambush for the English boarders in the confusion of the opening of that battle.
      And to quote doctor Stephen
      "He fights like you Jack."

  • @paulandresen8671
    @paulandresen8671 Před 4 lety +598

    The lesser of two Weevil’s

    • @Schluge96
      @Schluge96 Před 3 lety +32

      He who would pun would pick a pocket.

    • @frankstippel5988
      @frankstippel5988 Před 3 lety +3

      @@Schluge96 In German: Wer kalauert, klaut auch.

    • @diogov8
      @diogov8 Před 3 lety +1

      In portuguese "em chuva de pica escolhe a menor e senta"

    • @alvarohernani6645
      @alvarohernani6645 Před 3 lety +1

      Sadly i didn't get the joke till i watched the original version.

    • @TheBarroomHero321
      @TheBarroomHero321 Před 3 lety +6

      TO THE LESSER OF TWO WEEVILS!!!

  • @dwilson2212
    @dwilson2212 Před 2 lety +20

    If it hadn’t been for lord of the rings this film, I would hope, would have had so much more recognition. There are so many more books in the series this is adapted from and I would love them to be made in this style again.

  • @michaelgomez3044
    @michaelgomez3044 Před rokem +79

    My great great great grandfather was Captain of the USS Constitution from 1851-1853, this is one of my favorite movies. When I first saw it, I knew the Acheron was based on the Constitution.

    • @VitaKet
      @VitaKet Před rokem +1

      Gomez? Yea... I don't think so.

    • @nicolasuribestanko
      @nicolasuribestanko Před rokem +22

      @@VitaKet Why not? His maternal ancestry might have been American. We're not just descendants of our fathers.

    • @michaelgomez3044
      @michaelgomez3044 Před rokem +17

      @VitaKet Great Great Great grand father on my mother's side. John S. Rudd. You have no idea what you are talking about. He was also commandant of the Washington Naval yard. An American flag was flown over the Constitution on my birthday commemorating my relationship with my famous ancestor.

    • @michaelgomez3044
      @michaelgomez3044 Před rokem +16

      @VitaKet Try to research your own ancestry one day, you might find something interesting.

    • @sigmasquadleader
      @sigmasquadleader Před rokem

      Vitaket Jefferson-Freeman

  • @paulthompson5968
    @paulthompson5968 Před 6 lety +1044

    Humbly speaking, this movie goes down in cinema history as one of the most under-rated and ubder-appreciated movies of all time. Indeed, the movie bordered on masterpiece. It also has an outstanding soundtrack, similar to Amadeus and The Mission. Sometimes I feel embarrassed that the culture in the States prefer DC-type super heros over quality history films as this. Your analysis and praise for it is worthy and well deserved.

    • @jasonfenton8250
      @jasonfenton8250 Před 6 lety +9

      "Bordered on masterpiece"? I've not been able to stop thinking about it for a couple days.

    • @plartoota4584
      @plartoota4584 Před 6 lety +14

      Paul Thompson culture in the states? You mean culture in the world?

    • @krashd
      @krashd Před 5 lety +34

      No he means culture in the States, if it was culture in the world then we Brits would not tolerate so many movies where we play the antagonist to America's protagonist, but we don't have the same "I'm only watching this if the hero is an American" attitude. Though to be fair I do not even believe Americans have that attitude, it's just that their distributors do and their distributors would rather churn easily-digestible muck on to an American audience whenever possible...
      The book is about the true story of the HMS Shannon taking down the much larger, much more heavily manned, much better gunned USS Chesapeake but some suit in an office decided to speak for 300 million Americans when he said "Nah, let's make the movie fictional, we Americans don't enjoy history unless we're winning." and that statement would be insulting to me if I were an American and seen as dumb by my own movie industry.

    • @radiofreak66
      @radiofreak66 Před 5 lety +25

      Believe it or not, there's a lot of Americans out there like myself DYING to see history or fictional war films/video-games through the eyes of another nation, even if it means opposing Americans.

    • @HasanibnSabah
      @HasanibnSabah Před 5 lety +5

      Hell yeah brother...thumbs up to you for mentioning Amadeus here...what a great pairing of films!

  • @gregcampwriter
    @gregcampwriter Před 7 lety +35

    Point blank range comes from the French point blanc--the white circle at the center of a bullseye target. It's the range at which a ball will hit the center without doing a hold-over, using the sights without adjustment. A rifle's point blank range is usually over two hundred yards, for example. Point blank doesn't mean only within conversational distances.

    • @tSp289
      @tSp289 Před 7 lety +16

      Did not know that. A lot of old phrases lose their original meaning though. E.g. 'There'll be hell to pay is not only about getting in serious trouble, it is about having something extremely difficult to do and nothing to do it with, from the phrase "There's hell to pay and no pitch boiling". Hell being the name of the longest seam on a sailing ship, 'pay' meaning to caulk or waterproof the seams, and pitch being the tar used to do so.

    • @ferofax
      @ferofax Před 7 lety +7

      And here I was thinking point blank meant the muzzle practically touching the target.

    • @Slechy_Lesh
      @Slechy_Lesh Před 7 lety +2

      How strange. May I add 'raining cats and dogs' - apparently flooring was so bad in most homes in medieval times - just rushes and a plank by the door to stop the rushes going out via people's feet - that animals would congregate in the rafters. Dogs is pushing it but I can imagine cats, geese, chickens up there. And sometimes the rafters would collapse, raining animals etc onto anyone underneath

    • @Epicshadow123456789
      @Epicshadow123456789 Před 7 lety

      ferofax, if you're a bad enough marksman it does!

  • @theresadoll5374
    @theresadoll5374 Před rokem +24

    My Grandad, who served in the British Royal Navy in BOTH world wars, also stood as part of “the thin red line” as it were. This film is stirring, inspiring, and ... timeless. In the best sense of each of those terms.

    • @AverageAlien
      @AverageAlien Před rokem +3

      No need to say "British Royal Navy." It's simply THE Royal Navy

    • @scottwallace5239
      @scottwallace5239 Před 4 měsíci

      The thin red line was the argyll and Sutherland highlanders during the battle of balaklava in the crimean war

    • @georgejones8481
      @georgejones8481 Před 2 měsíci

      Served in Crimea, WW1 & WW2?

  • @topshots0074
    @topshots0074 Před rokem +29

    I'm from Bolivia (landlocked country) and I truly admire the work of Horatio Nelson and the royal Navy. I'm just about to finish reading Roy Adkins book Nelson's Trafalgar which is amazing! This movie really inspired me to buy a book because of the way they mentioned him! I usually never read a book except for school.

    • @kwanman5146
      @kwanman5146 Před 9 měsíci +1

      Reading will set you free.

    • @stuartmccall5474
      @stuartmccall5474 Před 5 měsíci

      From your part of the World, I thought you would have been more inspired by the actions and successes of Admiral (Lord) Thomas Cochrane RN who played a not insignificant part in quite a few South American Nations, like Chile and Brazil, gaining their independence from the Spanish and is today more revered there than in his home country of Scotland.

  • @EarlyCrowd
    @EarlyCrowd Před 7 lety +1378

    So.. Letters from Iwo Jima next?

  • @stanbartsch1984
    @stanbartsch1984 Před 3 lety +332

    This film inspired me to read the entire series of books - and I can't thank it enough for that!

    • @jameshunter5485
      @jameshunter5485 Před 3 lety +18

      Patrick O’Brian’s Aubrey Maturin series of novels created a cult following as they were written, published and desseminated. Like the movie they inspired, was their attention to detail, historical accuracy and above all the fleshing of their characters. Glad you.enjoyed the books as I did.

    • @exidy-yt
      @exidy-yt Před 3 lety +11

      Excellent. I hope you're not the only one because it's the best series of books i've ever read. Not just best historical fiction series, BOOK series. Like James Hunter above said, the attention to detail of getting the timeline and the personalities right is just stunning to behold and a joy to read.

    • @exidy-yt
      @exidy-yt Před 3 lety +9

      @B H Hell yes. The only areas it slows down in is the frustrating love triangle between Jack, Stephen and Diana Villiers. It takes far too long to resolve and Jack to marry Sophie (no thanks to her mum) and Stephen to marry Diana, but they aren't TOO painful to read. Many other side stories (Padeen Coleman's addiction to tincture of opium without even knowing it's name leading him to knock over an apothecary and get his ass transported to Van Diemen's land and it's result on Stephen is particularly a good one) add to the drama, but it's the naval scenes, wether happy sailing, stormy weather or full-on battles (especially the last 2 together) that make the books impossible to put down.

    • @ColoradoStreaming
      @ColoradoStreaming Před 3 lety +2

      @@exidy-yt As good as these are, I am going to have to nominate the Flashman series as the best historical fiction series. Nobody could bring historical characters to life like George MacDonald Fraser.

    • @vardito10
      @vardito10 Před 3 lety +2

      so great aren't they!

  • @HankD13
    @HankD13 Před rokem +35

    I think this really is one of the greatest movies of all time for a military history buff. I have read all of O'Brian Aubrey-Maturin books and was so pleased how faithfully this movie kept to their tone. Stay to true to some truly wonderful source material and you can make wonderful movies. It is a masterpiece, and I can only agree wholeheartedly with your comparison to the "based on a true story" drivel like Braveheart. Historical accuracy and entertainment.

    • @marclynch314
      @marclynch314 Před 10 měsíci +1

      David Threlfall as Killick was an inspired choice. I can't but picture his face when I'm rereading O'Brian.

  • @amykelly4904
    @amykelly4904 Před 2 lety +11

    Love this movie - I watch it every time it’s on TV. I think Max Pirkis gives such a terrific performance as Blakeney, especially for one so young. Really a highlight of the movie for me.

    • @midshipman8654
      @midshipman8654 Před rokem +1

      I think something more films should really take notes of from the likes of this movie is that pretty much every single second of the film is entertaining and engaging in some real very immediate way. there are a lot of films that have protracted scenes that are only really interesting once, and afterwads they feel like a slog. in this film, you actively enjoy the in the moment actions of each scene.

  • @ainslieberrafella
    @ainslieberrafella Před 4 lety +226

    I saw this film in the cinema when it was released and aside from being a simply brilliant film one thing that really stood out to me was the quality of the sound editing. The creaks and groans of the wooden ship were a subtle factor but it added an incredible degree of verisimilitude to the film, and this is exemplified particularly in the last scene as Aubrey and Maturin are playing their Boccherini duet and we're blessed with a beautifully rendered final shot of the Surprise in a vast ocean in fading light, the Acheron barely visible on the horizon. As the musical piece ends we are left with the noise of the ship and the wind in her sails, and the trill of knowing the hunt is back on again. It really is cinema at it's finest and I recommend watching it with a fully equipped home-cinema 5.1 audio set-up.

    • @kenanacampora6648
      @kenanacampora6648 Před 4 lety +6

      You write magnificently. How about you write the sequel. Trill. Nice! 😬🚬👍

    • @profwaggstaff
      @profwaggstaff Před 4 lety +3

      I also thought the sound was incredible. I think it was in the behind the scenes footage that they explained how they tested recording cannonballs being shot overhead. In the end, they used the real sounds of cannonballs ripping through the air.

    • @jeffnelson1672
      @jeffnelson1672 Před 4 lety +3

      @@profwaggstaff and Ainslieberra, Yes, great sound throughout. The sound of the ordnance was especially amazing.

    • @rickhood7570
      @rickhood7570 Před 3 lety +1

      With the surround sound turned up at home the battle scenes with connons almost blew out the windows, I recently just watched the DVD again, loved the movie and amazing sound to go with it.

    • @ColoradoStreaming
      @ColoradoStreaming Před 3 lety +1

      @@profwaggstaff Supposedly they made a point to not use any "Canned" sound effects. For the storm scene they took a pickup truck and put a grill in the back and a bunch of ropes and stuff and drove it 80mph down the the freeway with mics to get the wind noise.

  • @bluebaron4298
    @bluebaron4298 Před 7 lety +265

    Where's Enemy at the Gates?
    You know you want to.

    • @dobypilgrim6160
      @dobypilgrim6160 Před 7 lety +30

      Jeeze what a joke of a movie. historically worse than Braveheart.

    • @romulusnuma116
      @romulusnuma116 Před 7 lety +46

      would be fun to see him rip it apart tho?

    • @reddeimon475
      @reddeimon475 Před 7 lety +19

      it is funny when many Americans describe Soviet soldiers using Enemy at the Gates movie when the movie is made by American. when Russian makes WW2 movies American calls them propaganda

    • @dobypilgrim6160
      @dobypilgrim6160 Před 7 lety +4

      Red Deimon I actually really like Russian and Soviet war movies. And I'm an American of course. The manpower available for those movies was spectacular.

    • @reddeimon475
      @reddeimon475 Před 7 lety +10

      Doby Pilgrim i agree, now i am waiting for Christopher Nolan "Dunkirk" movie. i wanna know how British fought in WW2

  • @thedrunkenelf
    @thedrunkenelf Před 3 lety +18

    I know this is considered overlooked, but I’m an English teacher in Australia and we studied this movie with year 9. We compared it to the poem Rime of the Ancient Mariner. It was cool to introduce the students to this movie.

  • @MrMorelloJr
    @MrMorelloJr Před 2 lety +106

    The philosophical and scientific ideas discussed by characters in the movie also delightfully resonate with the modern ideas that dominated western thought at the time.
    Darwin’s work would come as a result of naturalist expeditions like we see in the film, and it was also a time of political upheaval where ideas like freedom, anarchism and democracy circulated among intelectuals. Simply an outstanding attention to detail from the filmmakers.

    • @ashleighelizabeth5916
      @ashleighelizabeth5916 Před 2 lety +2

      Indeed. One can see an aged Jack Aubrey and Maturin making the Galapagos voyages of Darwin in HMS Beagle in some alternate reality from our own after the conclusion of the Napoleonic Wars....

    • @midshipman8654
      @midshipman8654 Před rokem +5

      And I like how nuanced it was about it too, it gave more than one position dignity in how they were portrayed as well as rather blatent flaws as well rather than going after some narrow metacommentary moralism.

    • @benjameshowden
      @benjameshowden Před rokem +1

      It's the depth and detail of the source material; which the filmmakers did an excellent service

    • @drlca6601
      @drlca6601 Před rokem

      the focus on humanism is great when it is done subtly.

  • @bhf4u
    @bhf4u Před 5 lety +818

    as a side note.... you can thank the British for USS Constitution still being in the shape she is in. a common practice of the British was to make a full set of working plans (blueprints) of all captured ships. in January of 1815 the British captured the 44 gun frigate USS President . her construction was the same as that of USS Constitution.at the end of the 1990's the USS Constitution was in bad shape. rot had weakened her to the point where just towing her was a concern. it was decided that she would be "refit" and unlike other maintenance done on her, this work would be done in a manner to restore her to her original condition and form. the plans made from the captured USS President were found in British archives and used as the basis for rebuilding USS Constitution.

    • @brianwrynn3109
      @brianwrynn3109 Před 5 lety +64

      Interesting. Thank you Queen Elizabeth.

    • @stephengalindo6340
      @stephengalindo6340 Před 5 lety +57

      @@brianwrynn3109 yeah, thanks mom for helping is rebuild that car we used right after we moved out against your will lol

    • @NinjaTyler
      @NinjaTyler Před 5 lety +24

      bhf4u that’s a really intelligent military move and surprised this wasn’t done with more militaries

    • @scribblerjohn1
      @scribblerjohn1 Před 5 lety +34

      @@NinjaTyler The Brits gave a lot of thought to naval matters, and for good reason.

    • @DarkAnd1000
      @DarkAnd1000 Před 5 lety +24

      @@NinjaTyler Might be due to time and cost reasons.
      Lesser naval powers would be hard pressed to find the drydock and port space to place a captured ship while its studied and analized, prefering to just press it into service or sell it to another nation for cash.

  • @b.l.1289
    @b.l.1289 Před 5 lety +342

    You know your legacy is secure when you're given the title "The Sea Wolf" by both friends and foes.

    • @TommyCurrell
      @TommyCurrell Před 4 lety +18

      You know your legacy is lame when everyone calls you the sea cow

    • @franmadaraki616
      @franmadaraki616 Před 4 lety +13

      Just like Erwin Rommel as the Desert Fox

  • @Dougfunny37
    @Dougfunny37 Před rokem +58

    My father (R.I.P. big guy) LOVED this movie. Between this and gladiator russel Crowe dominated the dad movies

  • @lacavadeguillermo2942
    @lacavadeguillermo2942 Před 3 lety +12

    For me, best "historical" navy movie ever. Period. I can watch it 3 times back to back without getting bored. The first DVD I bought in Christmas 2003, with special packaging (navigation map included) is one of my more dearest treasures. Great video, great analysis. Congrats!

  • @A_Eichler
    @A_Eichler Před 4 lety +154

    Peter Wier. The reason a story like this was executed so finely as a film, should not be overlooked.

    • @Axgoodofdunemaul
      @Axgoodofdunemaul Před 4 lety +6

      Don't forget Patrick O'Brian. His novels are amazingly sweet to read. That sweetness went right into the movie.

    • @milescallamy6815
      @milescallamy6815 Před 4 lety +2

      @@Axgoodofdunemaul His novels should be turned into an HBO series, but i don't know how much HBO would be willing to make a series that doesn't have tits every third scene.

  • @Wayzor_
    @Wayzor_ Před 3 lety +82

    Sea Wolf may be the coolest nickname to have ever existed.

    • @Kevs442
      @Kevs442 Před 2 lety +5

      I'm going to go with "Laser Face".

    • @PaulRudd1941
      @PaulRudd1941 Před 2 lety +3

      @@Kevs442 had lasers been invented during the age of sail I am sure he would have gone with that.

    • @D1str1ct
      @D1str1ct Před 2 lety

      He was also called El Diablo when he fought against the Portuguese in South America, when he freed them from the Empire. With one ship he took the entire fleet and made them sail home. Theres a good kings and generals channel that does a documentary on him. Its on youtube.

  • @thebluedragon07
    @thebluedragon07 Před rokem +6

    Ok, I didn't notice this at first but it fits so well. When they disguised the ship as a whaling ship, they named it Syren (Siren). What a fitting name to use to lure the Acheron in close for its demise.

  • @bryanfox5457
    @bryanfox5457 Před rokem +5

    This was one of the few movies I literally knew nothing about going in, and after seeing it realized it's one of my favorite movies ever. It's one of a handful of movies I wish I could forget then "watch again for the first time." A masterpiece of storytelling.

  • @shadowphoenix8962
    @shadowphoenix8962 Před 5 lety +279

    The only thing bad about M & C is it had to end,no sequel.

    • @scorpio66invt
      @scorpio66invt Před 5 lety +3

      NO SHIT !!!!! WHERE THE F*** IS M&C 2??

    • @nippy7425
      @nippy7425 Před 4 lety

      Don’t ruin the movie

    • @Otswartz
      @Otswartz Před 4 lety +2

      Read the books. There is a whole series.

    • @sparrow56able
      @sparrow56able Před 4 lety

      this film doesn't need a sequel, period

    • @bchadaway7469
      @bchadaway7469 Před 4 lety +2

      William Myers Master and Commander was intended to be the first of a series, but it flopped. Ocean going stories are notoriously expensive to film - you can basically assume that any normal production cost will be multiplied when filming on the water. But if they make money, like Jaws did, there will be sequels. Unfortunately, this one didn’t.

  • @dominantasmr578
    @dominantasmr578 Před 3 lety +55

    I had this movie on DVD growing up as a kid, I always was haunted by the part when the character drowns himself and his face is staring up at the viewer going down into the ocean.

    • @malcomlovejoy
      @malcomlovejoy Před rokem

      Dom..He was a wuss better to cut your losses, his hesitancy would have jeopardized all those souls

  • @sweisbrod6109
    @sweisbrod6109 Před rokem +9

    I was the captain of a sailing ship (the Barque Lioness) for five years. Master and Commander is "technically " very accurate. I certainly appreciate all the effort to keep even the little things real.

    • @stuartmccall5474
      @stuartmccall5474 Před 5 měsíci +1

      Are you aware that many months before the first frame of the movie was shot, the cast were divided up into their roles and specific places in the gun crews and rigorously trained in that type of activity as with the rest of the crew in general seamanship by the Director David Weir? The cast actually eat separately, crew from NCO and Officers from this "training" time so the command structure is realistic. That's why the movie is so realistic, the crew weren't acting, they were doing it.

  • @laserbeam002
    @laserbeam002 Před 3 lety +7

    Master and Commander has been one of my favorite movies of all time since it first came out. I have it on DVD and have watched many times. Thank you for posting.

  • @heavypen
    @heavypen Před 4 lety +133

    Master and Commander is incredible because the source material is so utterly fabulous. Three cheers for Patrick O'Brian.

    • @jimmywrangles
      @jimmywrangles Před 4 lety +7

      I've read every book.

    • @kennethfharkin
      @kennethfharkin Před 4 lety +3

      ans three more for Cochrane!

    • @BarrioFabulous
      @BarrioFabulous Před 4 lety +6

      @@jimmywrangles So I have I. Toward the end of O'Brian's life, I was keenly awaiting the next. The fragmentary "21" is heart-breaking for its incompleteness.

    • @greggrobinson5116
      @greggrobinson5116 Před 3 lety +5

      Yes. Several times. And anyone attempting to translate the books into film would know that historical accuracy down to the finest detail would be absolutely imperative. I know of no other books that are so excruciatingly exact and yet so immediate and alive.

  • @binglamb2176
    @binglamb2176 Před 4 lety +256

    I often wished they could turn the novels into a multi-year historical TV epic like Outlander or the Sharpe series.

    • @binglamb2176
      @binglamb2176 Před 4 lety +1

      @Kirbe Strom I was not aware of this series. It looks like something I need to read! Thanks for the tip.

    • @gerrytinder3602
      @gerrytinder3602 Před 4 lety +16

      I have read Patrick O'Brian's Master and Commander series three times. These books have absolutely ruined for me any other sea sagas from the age of wooden ships. None can come close to the scope or breadth or humanity of Mr. O'Brian's works. If you want 20+ novels that transport you into the realm of the golden age of British sail I unreservedly and confidently recommend these.

    • @binglamb2176
      @binglamb2176 Před 4 lety +3

      @@gerrytinder3602 Agree. None better but I still have a soft spot for my early foray into the world of the classic age Royal Navy through Forester's Hornblower stories.

    • @fernandomartin-gullans7095
      @fernandomartin-gullans7095 Před 4 lety +13

      Check out the Horatio Hornblower miniseries from 1998.

    • @thedude7450
      @thedude7450 Před 3 lety +7

      If you like Master and Commander you will like the Horatio Hornblower series. It was outstanding.

  • @Aquatarkus96
    @Aquatarkus96 Před 3 lety +6

    The music and sound fx mixing of this movie is literally perfect. A good surround sound system is necessary to get the full effect of cannon balls whizzing past and wood splintering.

  • @yazmon4515
    @yazmon4515 Před rokem +8

    With Patrick O'Brian, being one of my favorite authors, I was familiar with the scenes in the movie and naturally could tell that they were drawn from several books. It did not detract from the movie though since even an old salt recalling sea stories to youngsters could mistake which event happened in which battle, of which there were many. I did worry that by taking a lot of cool parts from several books lessened the chance of other movies being made from the series. Still, I'm glad we have this one.

  • @neilpemberton5523
    @neilpemberton5523 Před 4 lety +96

    The best laugh in the movie, as first written by Patrick O'Brian- "There I have you,' cried Jack. 'You are bit - you are completely dished. Don't you know that in the Navy you must always choose the lesser of two weevils? Oh ha, ha, ha, ha!"

    • @simonmorrison8570
      @simonmorrison8570 Před 3 lety +24

      There’s another lovely little quip from the book. I’m paraphrasing as I can’t find the book but, after Stephen has amputated the young midshipman’s arm he says to Aubrey ‘I know his father. He’ll be very proud’ to which Aubrey replies. ‘I know his mother, she’ll be livid’.
      Superb stuff from O’Brian

    • @JimBrodie
      @JimBrodie Před 3 lety +9

      I love the Nelson dinner party anecdote. Classic end-of-the-pier joke.

    • @roguepsykerhaaker4813
      @roguepsykerhaaker4813 Před 3 lety +1

      @@simonmorrison8570 that was in the movie too, which is nice

    • @mitigate385
      @mitigate385 Před 3 lety +1

      He who would pun would pick a pocket.

  • @kaloarepo288
    @kaloarepo288 Před 7 lety +407

    Love the music of Bach and Boccherini as used in this film.

    • @joannagodfrey5111
      @joannagodfrey5111 Před 6 lety +9

      Music is always a theme throughout the books

    • @chrisholland7367
      @chrisholland7367 Před 6 lety +6

      Kalo Arepo Also used was sir Ralph Vaughan Williams Fantasia on a Theme by Thomas Tallis
      During the burial at sea

    • @DuxCorvan
      @DuxCorvan Před 5 lety +4

      I absolutely loved the historical music, although I must point that its use, although not at all anachronistic, is far from authentic. I'll explain myself: 1) Bach's music wasn't completely forgotten by 1805, but only his keyboard work and specially his "Well Tempered" preludes and fugues had significant difussion outside Germany. His sacred works were a staple mostly in his native Thuringia, and his cello and violin works were quite unknown. 2) Corelli concertos were published in 1714 and were a BIG hit in Britain, influencing a whole generation of composers like Handel, Geminiani, Avison or Boyce, but almost a century later were decidedly out of fashion. Still the most likely of the film choices. 3) Boccherini piece was part of some divertimento written for Spanish noblemen about 1795. Although certainly contemporary it was a relatively obscure piece outside Spanish noble circles by then.

    • @mlembrant
      @mlembrant Před 5 lety

      COOKIEEEESSS!!

    • @scc970
      @scc970 Před 5 lety +8

      In the books the characters go out of their way to search out obscure works that are technically difficult to play. It is acknowledged that they are almost unknown by their contemporaries and totally out of fashion. As such the music chosen for the soundtrack is authentic to the main characters and theme of the ongoing story.

  • @davidedgar6787
    @davidedgar6787 Před 2 lety +31

    I am obsessed with all Patrick O’Brians books.
    Whilst I was in the US I made a deliberate detour to see USS Constitution In Boston.
    I was devastated that she was in dry dock at the time with everything above here lower masts removed. I couldn’t go below decks only wander on her main deck.
    I begged the sailors guarding her hatches to let me below, saying I’d come all the way from Australia to view the ship but it wasn’t to be.
    I’m still so glad I got to have a walk on her decks. Beautiful Ship.

    • @Jkim890
      @Jkim890 Před 2 lety +1

      Such a shame, sorry to hear that you missed such an amazing opportunity. Hope you get another chance some day!

  • @Xycomm
    @Xycomm Před 3 lety +7

    I once visited the U.S.S Constitution on a family trip to Boston. Though at the time I was too young to fully appreciate the value of where I was it was still an incredibly massive and impressive ship.

  • @scottm9010
    @scottm9010 Před 4 lety +65

    I feel that historical accuracy IS entertaining. I want a film to transport me to that time.

  • @carljuvy
    @carljuvy Před 7 lety +478

    I know this is late but I review on Das Boot would be nice?
    It's probably the best U-Boat film ever. Like ever.

    • @TheStapleGunKid
      @TheStapleGunKid Před 7 lety +36

      Of course he should cover that one, as well as its polar opposite, the god-awful "U-571".

    • @TheStapleGunKid
      @TheStapleGunKid Před 7 lety +4

      Yep, which is why I'm hoping Nick covers U571 eventually.

    • @thitran1362
      @thitran1362 Před 7 lety +4

      yasss, U571 it would be fun for him to do a video one

    • @alexandarvoncarsteinzarovi3723
      @alexandarvoncarsteinzarovi3723 Před 7 lety +5

      Wait that movies is REAL!? :D
      I thought it was just a meme or gimmick!

    • @neilwilson5785
      @neilwilson5785 Před 7 lety +33

      Yes, Das Boot. My uncle served in a U-boat and says it is accurate. Especially the bits where it goes from very quiet, listening for the RoyalNavy on headphones, followed by the mad panic and 'ALLLAAAARRMMMM!!' when destroyers are detected. If you haven't seen it, do so.

  • @TD-2011
    @TD-2011 Před 3 lety +4

    Thank you for explaining Hollom singing, no one believes me. Now I have more proof!

  • @Generalofmetal
    @Generalofmetal Před 2 lety +13

    A friend of mine who is a pirate re-enactor owns one of the cannons from this movie. It's a very well done piece and is a functional cannon

  • @franug
    @franug Před 4 lety +118

    I saw this movie yesterday and loved it!! They don't make movies like this anymore...
    I actually said to my husband that the story reminded me of Lord Cochrane; being Chilean I know a bit of his adventures, so it's cool to know the movie was inspired by him😊

    • @shagrat47
      @shagrat47 Před 3 lety +2

      I can absolutely recommend the books by Patrick O'Brian, if you liked the movie. The Film is very condensed and there is a lot more background and storytelling combined with a brilliant depiction of naval life and death in the book series.

    • @davesy6969
      @davesy6969 Před 3 lety +3

      There are many places named after him in south America, and the Chileans hold a yearly service in his honour at Westminster cathedral.

    • @ashleighelizabeth5916
      @ashleighelizabeth5916 Před 2 lety

      @@shagrat47 I second that. Indeed several of the books towards the end of the series parallel Cochrane's adventures in Chili.

  • @RamdomGuy1337
    @RamdomGuy1337 Před 5 lety +150

    Man i am still bummed they opted out of another movie. Master&Commander might very well be one of my favorite movies out there.

    • @patrickbrennan1317
      @patrickbrennan1317 Před 5 lety +5

      Heinz Guderian no they would rather make superhero movies which are just silly versions of pagan myths

    • @Euripides_Panz
      @Euripides_Panz Před 5 lety +4

      And Pirates got FOUR $equel$.

    • @simonferrer
      @simonferrer Před 5 lety +1

      Heinz Guderian I had never heard of the books, but when I saw "Based on the Novels by Patrick O'Brian" in the end credits, I decided to check them out. The novels are absolutely fantastic in my opinion, and follow the careers of Jack Aubrey and Stephen Maturin from 1800 (Master and Commander) to 1815 (Blue at the Mizzen). The Far Side of the World is book 10 in the series. If you liked the film and haven't read the books, I definitely recommend them.

    • @chatteyj
      @chatteyj Před 5 lety +1

      @@simonferrer Are they really that good? Is there any sex, plot twists or high drama or is it just plain sailing?

  • @amygeyer1166
    @amygeyer1166 Před rokem +5

    We had this movie on dvd when it was released. At the time, i was kinda turned away early on with the surgery scene so didn’t really give it much of a chance, but my daughter(a tween at the time and later recipient of a master’s degree in history) was in love with it.
    I think I’ll give it another chance on this Sunday afternoon😀

  • @thatonetrashcan1681
    @thatonetrashcan1681 Před 2 lety +6

    When I first watched this movie I remember the part that made me absolutely love it was when the crew sang Spanish Ladies. My friends could agree I was quite more than happy then

  • @hewen8199
    @hewen8199 Před 3 lety +70

    "Emotionally confusing" is a red herring. It's about money; they made the decision they thought would get them the biggest audience.

    • @Mayakran
      @Mayakran Před 3 lety +9

      Yes. And now that China (and the CCP) is a major player in the movie market, they’re going to become even shallower to appeal to/not offend the most people. This is one reason I’m interested in late Soviet films; while they couldn’t exactly openly criticize the government, they didn’t have to worry about appealing to the masses because the party funded their movies, not the market.

    • @trentmacdonald6283
      @trentmacdonald6283 Před 3 lety +15

      This was a film in production shortly after 9/11 so it definitely would've be a gamble to cast America in any sort of villainous light. Also, given the anti-French sentiment ("freedom fries") that was manifesting in America at time of release, this change is understandable to me if I imagine the point of view of Hollywood producers.

    • @MacakPodSIjemom
      @MacakPodSIjemom Před 3 lety +2

      @@trentmacdonald6283 Also, this was shot 17 years ago, when self hatred and non-patriotism still wasn't a thing as it is today. Notice that these days nobody films big budget movies where your (whichever it is) side is good and the enemy is bad, it all has to be nuanced not to offend anybody, with a strong antiwar message.

    • @AttackStart
      @AttackStart Před 3 lety +5

      @@MacakPodSIjemom I haven't noticed. Any examples? I'm not sure the recent Afghan war movies have been terribly nuanced. Taliban bad and Americans good and all that.
      I haven't seen a lot of Apocalypse Now or Platoons made too recently. What's Oliver Stone and Francis Ford Copolla up to these days?
      #whynosequal

  • @Kyle899
    @Kyle899 Před 4 lety +96

    I love the little details. When the doctor is doing brain surgery and they comment that he’s no surgeon but a physician. Back when a surgeon wasn’t a doctor but considered more of a butcher.

    • @alexisclements3167
      @alexisclements3167 Před 3 lety +3

      In most instances they're still just glorified butchers even today.

    • @cindykq8086
      @cindykq8086 Před 3 lety +1

      And they said larboard instead of port, historically accurate.

    • @HO-bndk
      @HO-bndk Před 3 lety +2

      No, a physician had a degree in medicine, a surgeon had a warrant from the Sick and Hurt board.

    • @thomasnash3064
      @thomasnash3064 Před 3 lety +1

      They were called " bone carpenters"

    • @Steve211Ucdhihifvshi
      @Steve211Ucdhihifvshi Před 3 lety

      They still are known as butchers. Hahahaha

  • @dude97x
    @dude97x Před rokem +2

    Master and Commander takes a shared first place with Das Boot as my all time favorite movie.
    Our family had a sailing boat and we would spend several weeks every summer sailing around our coastal archipelago. Us kids wanted to watch this film multiple times during our voyages, we loved it (and still do).

    • @MikeNewland
      @MikeNewland Před rokem

      Add The Cruel Sea for the triple!!!

  • @chrisl58
    @chrisl58 Před rokem

    LOVED this! Thank you for producing it.

  • @DarkLordLinkOfficial
    @DarkLordLinkOfficial Před 7 lety +48

    Saw this in theaters with my dad when it came out (I was a young kid at the time). Definitely the reason why I love historical films and 1800's nautical history

    • @captinobvious4705
      @captinobvious4705 Před 7 lety +3

      then you would love the admiral : roaring currents

    • @johnnydsnarkangel
      @johnnydsnarkangel Před 7 lety

      God, I would have loved to see this on the big screen!

    • @dashsocur
      @dashsocur Před 7 lety

      My only complaint with The Admiral was the spy sub-plot. It seemed completely unnecessary and disrupted the main story. Aside from that, I agree it was awesome.

    • @WickedMuis
      @WickedMuis Před 7 lety

      If you love naval history and games, you prolly would like the game Naval Action :) it's still in early stages of development but it shows great promise!

    • @DaDunge
      @DaDunge Před 7 lety

      Then why did you like this movie? it's rubbish from a historical standpoint?

  • @jeremybridges6015
    @jeremybridges6015 Před 4 lety +84

    Didn’t mention the music or the “natural science” aspects of this movie. One of my favorite

    • @BjornTheDim
      @BjornTheDim Před 4 lety +7

      Supposedly the first time that a non-documentary film had been allowed to be filmed on the Galapagos Islands.

    • @Hunpecked
      @Hunpecked Před 3 lety +3

      Loved the Galapagos scenes. Darwin would set off on the Beagle less that 30 years later.

    • @yamagata008
      @yamagata008 Před 3 lety +1

      Yes, to me that was quite humorous. Though it is fiction, I found the Darwin like character played by Paul Bettany trumped by war into not completing his research, setting back the theory of evolution by 30 years!

  • @95DarkFire
    @95DarkFire Před 3 lety +23

    9:30 Oh my God, I just realised that they included the spritsail on the HMS Surprise's bow! Which is an insane detail, since ships at that time usually did not have a spritsail.

    • @InventorZahran
      @InventorZahran Před 2 lety +1

      Maybe the spritsail was added as a last-minute attempt to make the ship more maneuverable and slightly faster...

    • @annalieff-saxby568
      @annalieff-saxby568 Před rokem

      As a keen amateur sailor (Mirror dinghy) and Swallows & Amazons fan, I *really* appreciated the sail handling in this film. Damme, but I could feel the ropes!

  • @lowelldevall1348
    @lowelldevall1348 Před 2 lety +8

    I love your series, I am retired US Army. This film made me envious of the kinship and belonging a vessel like this had. For many, they never get to be a part of something small and special like this. It's a bitter and sweet aspect of life that we get to share and be a part of something in this nature. Something that inevitably we must leave, or leaves us.

  • @andrewdarrell4970
    @andrewdarrell4970 Před 7 lety +77

    Now I've GOT TO watch this film.

    • @nimay13
      @nimay13 Před 7 lety +25

      Go ahead, you wont regret it.

    • @korky94
      @korky94 Před 7 lety +18

      it''s outstanding. the music is brilliant

    • @DeciVonW
      @DeciVonW Před 7 lety +2

      Great film! Good Choice!

    • @army310
      @army310 Před 7 lety +5

      AS a SJW I think the should replace the crew with trans women because it is 2016

    • @Synystr7
      @Synystr7 Před 7 lety +1

      Especially for the music.

  • @Haydy5040
    @Haydy5040 Před 3 lety +135

    I've seen the USS Constitution several times in person It's gorgeous.

    • @toddbarney4738
      @toddbarney4738 Před 3 lety +12

      Go to England and walk the decks of HMS Victory. I've done both, and it's like the difference between a great high school football stadium and the Superdome. The Constitution is beautiful and incredible, but the Victory is all that, times 10.

    • @ericstearns170
      @ericstearns170 Před 3 lety +4

      I've been to neither, but I've been on the Constitution's sister ship the Constellation. I've always been a soldier but even I have to admit, she's a beauty. I can only imagine what the other two are like

    • @maceofbass9295
      @maceofbass9295 Před 2 lety +1

      @@ericstearns170 The Constellation is absolutely beautiful. Well worth a visit for anyone in the Baltimore area.

    • @proudamerican183
      @proudamerican183 Před rokem +1

      @@toddbarney4738 Are you British or American?

    • @michlo3393
      @michlo3393 Před rokem +1

      @@toddbarney4738 That's what happens when you compare a frigate to a first rate ship of the line!

  • @user-px8wd2yp1q
    @user-px8wd2yp1q Před 11 měsíci +1

    One of my absolute favorites. Every cast member was perfectly cast and realistic and interesting. Just great.

  • @kentscantlin3907
    @kentscantlin3907 Před rokem

    One of my absolute favorite movies! Thanks for this video!

  • @lynneperry7454
    @lynneperry7454 Před 4 lety +148

    This is a great review and shows the integrity with which Peter Weir treated them. It was a crying shame that there wasn’t a sequel, after all, with 20 books to choose from there was heaps of material.
    Just recently Russell Crowe twitted about how much fun it was to make the movie.

  • @paulhahn5229
    @paulhahn5229 Před 4 lety +578

    Acheron was not a French warship, it was a French privateer. Which means that it wasn’t actually part of the French navy, but had “permission” from the French government to basically be a pirate as long as they only attacked British (or whomever else the French were at war with). The movie even touches on that. Given that fact, it is possible that the captain somehow acquired the Acheron in the US at some point, which is especially likely given that the French and Americans were quite good friends during that time due to their mutual dislike of Britain.
    Also, ships got around. When captured in battle they would generally be put into use by their new owners.
    Neither is truly a great explanation, and I can understand Weir’s reasoning and change in the nationality of the ship, so this point never bothered me that much.

    • @karakorum2007
      @karakorum2007 Před 4 lety +17

      You know, "american" people can´t understand beyond the way that Hollywood tell the stories. The only condition of people to appreciate a movie of this kind is the american always must win.

    • @Quillons1
      @Quillons1 Před 4 lety +46

      @@karakorum2007 When it's your money, you can write a screenplay and make us lose. Until then, live with it.....or don't. The British, to this day, still can't accept the defeats of the Guerriere, Java, and Macedonian. Let alone the defeat of the British squadron on Erie.

    • @peterbstrong
      @peterbstrong Před 4 lety +7

      Nice response Paul and reasonable speculations. Really enjoyed the movie and when the French captain lay dying and extended his hand to Aubrey, that was classic. The dichotomy of the savagery with the chivalry.

    • @Deevo037
      @Deevo037 Před 4 lety +13

      ​@@Quillons1 A fair comment. You only need to see the way the British media of the time (and since) have talked up the Bismark into some kind of supership after the loss of the Hood in WW2. That and they absolutely shredded Captain Leach and the crew of Prince of Wales in the same engagement calling them the battleship that ran despite the ship being deployed before she even had completed fitting out and suffering massive machinery failures during the engagement.

    • @willsmith6946
      @willsmith6946 Před 4 lety +11

      @@Quillons1 To be honest mate, by and large we Brits have never heard of those particular engagements. I suspect they feature more in american history than ours. Besides, they seem to be little more than singular frigate actions...? The actual war was fought against the frogs. Everyone knows this!

  • @TF549
    @TF549 Před 7 měsíci +1

    This type of movie is a gem. No shot any studio makes something like this these days.

  • @oddballlucy
    @oddballlucy Před 3 lety +1

    I'm sure loads of people have suggested it already but I am DYING for you to cover Black Sails!! What a great channel, and I'm so glad you have an ep on Master & Commander :D

  • @naxotogo
    @naxotogo Před 3 lety +23

    the street where a friend of mine grew up (here in Chile) is named lord cochrane. Cool to finally know why.

    • @davesy6969
      @davesy6969 Před 3 lety +1

      There are many places in South America named after him.

  • @Legohaiden
    @Legohaiden Před 4 lety +58

    Master and Commander is one of my Favorite films ever made. Being a Navy Veteran myself its really cool that they use REAL naval bell tolls and whistle calls (they still use those in the Navy when out at sea btw) Hearing the Reveille whistle in the film and recognizing it and what it was made it that much more special I think.

    • @julianwaugh968
      @julianwaugh968 Před 4 lety +3

      Thankyou for your service. I Took a tour of HMS Victory, HMS Belfast and USS Intrepid.
      I was struck by how these ships had so much power and yet be so fragile against enemy fire . Truly the crew were terribly brave who faced not only instant death but die in the freezing sea while being burned to death .
      My Uncle Commander Alfred Garvin of the USS Wadliegh recieved a Silver and Bronze star, one for saving the ship after a torpedo strike .
      I know you are all trained in the art of war, but when you throw in the element of the cruel sea it takes a different kind of stamina.
      For those in peril on the sea , I salute you .

    • @Legohaiden
      @Legohaiden Před 4 lety +2

      @@julianwaugh968 Luckily we were never struck by enemy fire, though an insurgent "craft" more a fishing boat with a big motor, got close enough to fire an RPG at our ship... Lady luck was on our side and it flew high, and over our flight deck striking nothing but air. They tasted the 50 cal's of justice firing 500 rounds of freedom per minute from at least 3 mounted positions.

    • @ColoradoStreaming
      @ColoradoStreaming Před 3 lety +4

      Fun Fact: It was considered extremely unlucky to kill any seabird back during the Age of Sail as they were thought to carry the souls of dead sailors. When the Surgeon was accidentally shot it was because the Marine tried to shoot an Albatross and the bad luck caused him to shoot his own crew.

  • @Heywoodthepeckerwood
    @Heywoodthepeckerwood Před 7 měsíci +2

    I absolutely love this movie.

  • @thebassplayification
    @thebassplayification Před 11 měsíci

    Master and Commander is my favourite film; simple premise plot with fantastically written characters, amazing cinematography, incredible sets, great action. Every scene feels like a chapter in a well written book. Just amazing

  • @charlesbaldo
    @charlesbaldo Před 5 lety +246

    It had Russel Crowe, at the top of his game, any sins are forgiven.

    • @taylort123
      @taylort123 Před 4 lety +4

      @Joe Milosch it had the misfortune of being released at the same time as lotr rotk. Lord of the rings are my favorite movies and master and commander is my second. I was 13 at the time and i think there was a father and son in an otherwise empty theater. no one i know likes the period pieces like i do which is a shame really

    • @davidpomeroy8165
      @davidpomeroy8165 Před 2 lety

      IMO Russell Crowe is one of the most under-appreciated actors around today. He matched the spirit, the big personality, and the sensitivity of O'Brian's Jack Aubrey perfectly. Kudos to him, to Peter Weir, and to all who were a part of making this epic movie. Kudos as well to the History Buff channel, well done.

  • @treizTUBE
    @treizTUBE Před 7 lety +37

    I love this movie. When I saw it in theaters I couldn't believe in wasn't a huge hit. I remember walking out and thinking bewildered, where was everyone and why weren't they coming to see this awesome movie in droves?

    • @fistfulohorde
      @fistfulohorde Před 7 lety +8

      I think it had to compete with 'the return of the king' at the time.

    • @VRichardsn
      @VRichardsn Před 7 lety +12

      It had the awful luck of being pitted against The Return of the King. It is a real shame, because Master & Commander could have been huge if released in a different year.

    • @Knifetrader
      @Knifetrader Před 7 lety +5

      It was planned as the beginning of a whole series of movies as well, which obviously didn't happen with the less than overwhelming box office results.

    • @JackFN_VR64
      @JackFN_VR64 Před 7 lety

      I remember the same and again with the film Gravity. It's because the general public prefer films that are thin on plot and substance and high on explosions and flashy visuals like the marvel franchise, transformers and fast and furious.

    • @barryalexander2909
      @barryalexander2909 Před 7 lety +4

      I agree, massive shame. I think a reason for setting the action in the spring and summer of 1805 was to put Lucky Jack and the crew of HMS Surprise in the right place and time to lead into a second movie covering the Battle of Trafalgar in October 1805.

  • @american_cosmic
    @american_cosmic Před 9 měsíci

    THANK YOU! I always wondered why they all stopped singing, now I get it! Awesome channel, awesome video for one of my all-time favorite movies!

  • @jasonarcher7268
    @jasonarcher7268 Před 2 lety +1

    I love that opening scene, where you see the flashes of light in the fog, before the shots hit home. Most movies miss the fact that sound is so much slower than light.

  • @TheColombianSpartan
    @TheColombianSpartan Před 4 lety +79

    I've been on HMS victory herself when i was on vacation in GB. Truly a magnificent experience. What a ship!

    • @nippy7425
      @nippy7425 Před 4 lety +6

      TheColombianSpartan cool
      I was on the USS Constitution
      I appreciate the ship more after watching this video.

    • @Venezolano410
      @Venezolano410 Před 4 lety +1

      @OneThiccPepeForTwoThickerKekes
      Fuck the USS Constitution.

    • @nickbarton3191
      @nickbarton3191 Před 4 lety +12

      I visited it when I was a kid some 40 years ago. The matelot giving the tour pointed out the brass plaque marking where Nelson fell and said "no wonder he fell here with that bloody big plaque in the way".

    • @simonbutterfield4860
      @simonbutterfield4860 Před 4 lety +5

      @@nickbarton3191 British humour at it's very best.

    • @geminisixx4
      @geminisixx4 Před 4 lety +1

      @@Venezolano410 if you want splinters have at it

  • @severianxi6990
    @severianxi6990 Před 5 lety +16

    this is the best naval adventure that was ever put on film.. i have the blueray and watch it every once in awhile... pay attention to the sound... incredible

    • @felmlee1876
      @felmlee1876 Před 5 lety

      During the movie release, NPR did a long interview with the director. They actually shot canon balls through thick planking and masts and recorded the sound.

    • @demerjr8097
      @demerjr8097 Před 5 lety +1

      not the best,, its good, the best is DAS BOOT, by far

    • @DreadX10
      @DreadX10 Před 5 lety +1

      @@demerjr8097 agree, 1. Das Boot , 2. Master and commander

  • @kashesan
    @kashesan Před 2 lety

    I love this-thank you.

  • @TheCroarty
    @TheCroarty Před rokem

    They even did a good job making it look like they were playing the instruments. Rockin solos back and forth. Excellent.

  • @jasenwright1178
    @jasenwright1178 Před 3 lety +93

    No leading lady lovey dovey scenes and NO swearing noted in this! Amazing !!

    • @sharonmitchell5695
      @sharonmitchell5695 Před 3 lety +2

      There are intimate relationships through out the 20 books. And swearing, though much less than modern fiction. What I thought the movie neglected or could not make room for was full richness of the characters and their relationship. One main relationship, that of Aubrey and Maturin is a prime example of almost not existing. Maturin is a complex and interesting man that was conveyed very thinly if at all. The movie is entertaining while the books are rich and amazing.

    • @FreakTimmah
      @FreakTimmah Před 3 lety +2

      @@sharonmitchell5695 Yeah it really does cut out the whole intelligence aspect of Maturin's character. His political beliefs and intelligence connections are almost always the setup for all of their voyages. It puts Jack and Stephen on equal footing because Maturin's missions are always assigned to Jack and it furthers his Naval career. I can forgive it though since the movie needed a streamlined story.

    • @thomasklausen4596
      @thomasklausen4596 Před 3 lety +3

      @@FreakTimmah What is very enjoyable about the movie, though, is that when you watch it with the books as background, there is not one scene where the characters do something out of line with their book counterparts. When movie-Stephen says "They have their spies, as do we", we nod knowingly. The personalities are dead-on.

    • @TheWombat2012
      @TheWombat2012 Před 3 lety +1

      One swear word. The whalers they rescue, one says they were attacked, and said “F**kin’ pirates!”, quietly. That’s it. It’s slipped in so “naturally” for a bluff tough sailor, that even my elderly mother didn’t complain. Same in the movie “Australia” when after the Japanese attack on Darwin, Hugh Jackmans character goes into a bar with his aboriginal friend (aboriginals couldn’t be served alcohol back then), and when the bartender says they couldn’t serve him, Hugh says angrily “give him a f**king drink!”. Again, it’s one word in the whole film, and it’s done to emphasise a point, nobody complained. There’s swearing for the sake of it, and swearing in context.

  • @orionknight4803
    @orionknight4803 Před 3 lety +18

    I may be 4 years late but I just got to say this movie is fantastic. The last time I watched it was when I was very young. And now that I've been reminded of it i'm desperate to watch it again.

  • @johngifford7725
    @johngifford7725 Před rokem

    It was a great movie. Thank you for making it that much better. I need to watch it again.
    I remember recounting the dinner scene about the weevils to my grandpa. He was a WWII navy guy. Enlisted at 16 and was stationed on a cargo ship from WWI. He heard that recount of the scene and busted up laughing so hard I could barely believe it. I guess some jokes are timeless.
    Great video! Thanks for sharing this. Really made my day.

  • @eugeneerickson6395
    @eugeneerickson6395 Před 2 lety

    I watched this movie many many times and loved every minute of It........think I will watch It again tonight!