Why Moff Gideon Recognized Luke Skywalker IMMEDIATELY

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 12. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 1,5K

  • @johnbutler1323
    @johnbutler1323 Před 3 lety +2691

    From the perspective of every surviving high level Imperial officer, Dart Vader, the Emperor and Luke Skywalker went into a room and only Luke Skywalker came out alive.

  • @Dream0Asylum
    @Dream0Asylum Před 3 lety +1510

    [He attempts to kill himself ...]
    Judging from that positioning, he was probably going to accidentally complete his Darth Malak cosplay.

  • @ortspoon2160
    @ortspoon2160 Před 3 lety +1086

    In short, he's the guy who literally killed his boss. Gideon's definitely going to panic seeing the man come for him.

    • @isaacgraff8288
      @isaacgraff8288 Před 3 lety +95

      Literally killed his boss, and there really aren't that many people with a green lightsaber capable of mowing soldiers like that.

    • @AnakinGroundcrawler
      @AnakinGroundcrawler Před 3 lety +19

      To borrow a little Johnny Cash, 🎵when The Man comes around 🎵

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro Před 3 lety

      His boss isn't dead and Luke is his apprentice during that time.

    • @AnakinGroundcrawler
      @AnakinGroundcrawler Před 3 lety +12

      @@TheRezro for the apprentice part, not in canon.

    • @kungolaf4499
      @kungolaf4499 Před 3 lety +7

      @@AnakinGroundcrawler And in Canon it is explained that Palpatine is indeed "dead" for some time. He just is resurrected.

  • @darthveatay
    @darthveatay Před 3 lety +478

    Considering that Gideon looks old enough he likely served in the clone wars. He might have seen the abilities of the jedi first hand. That would explain his fear even more

    • @kevinmcdonald6979
      @kevinmcdonald6979 Před 3 lety +76

      Solid theory. Gideon is old enough to remember the Jedi.

    • @doomi8210
      @doomi8210 Před 3 lety +16

      He's old enough to even have lived as a dentist

    • @dannyluo6635
      @dannyluo6635 Před 3 lety +2

      Huh good point, never considered about it before!

    • @greatkhan393
      @greatkhan393 Před 2 lety

      @@doomi8210 alright gamblers, let’s get gambling

  • @leppyslego8587
    @leppyslego8587 Před 3 lety +367

    The fact that Gideon was willing to off himself means that he’s apart of something greater. He has a higher up, someone such as Moff Gideon wouldn’t take his life if he were the last hope for the empire

    • @jneumy566
      @jneumy566 Před 3 lety +37

      Either that or he was so scared of a Jedi coming his way, which I wouldn'cry blame him for. He was panicking, he tried to off Bo, Grogu, and then himself in some desperate effort to still kinda win

    • @danielkorladis7869
      @danielkorladis7869 Před 3 lety +16

      He's probably also afraid of a war crimes trial.

    • @theevildrummingsithlord1492
      @theevildrummingsithlord1492 Před 3 lety +17

      Thrawn...that's the only person left. Or someone like Rae Sloane/Gallius Rax.

    • @18Krieger
      @18Krieger Před 3 lety +28

      @@danielkorladis7869 I dont think he is afraid of that. He is too important. He was confident the entire time until Luke showed up. Its quite likely that he fears that Luke could get informations that could threaten the greater picture.

    • @billclark5055
      @billclark5055 Před 3 lety +1

      Umiya's COMING BACK BABY! WOOOH. Dark Lady of the Sith is back with a lightsaber whip and two personal royal guards. And she gonna fight Jedi Leia and two Rebel Honor Guards. You heard it here first.
      Katarn's gonna come back too and drop out 20 years later after Mara Jade dies and 5 years before TFA.

  • @Aknight292
    @Aknight292 Před 3 lety +226

    It's simple really, Luke Skywalker to the empire at this point is what vader is to the rebellion. Luke even mirrored vader's scene in Rogue One.

  • @Taneth
    @Taneth Před 3 lety +327

    Attacking Bo-Katan was an act of desparation. He's going to die, might as well take one of them out with him.
    Well, that didn't work. The baby then? Shoot the baby and they'll kill him. Denied.
    "Fine, I'll do it myself!" Denied.

    • @thoriated
      @thoriated Před 3 lety +22

      I think the reason he went after Grogu is that he would be trained by the Jedi and become a threat to the future of the Empire.

    • @billclark5055
      @billclark5055 Před 3 lety +8

      @@halmalcom7382 Its not that annoying. He probably just went on a mission. Its a big galaxy or maybe he dropped out. I still want to see Mara Jade and Kyle Katarn in this. Katarn can drop out but theyll need to kill Mara within 25 years of Endor. That way Luke can marry her a couple years later and they can have a 20+ year marriage before she dies. Buf she can still get a bunch of cool showings and still live to be about 50.

  • @zulu4791
    @zulu4791 Před 3 lety +1692

    Wait. We have seen someone commit suicide. The guy who electrocuted himself.

    • @tanith117
      @tanith117 Před 3 lety +219

      Also every 2 bit thug who tried to pick a fight with Mando.

    • @darthdystopian4550
      @darthdystopian4550 Před 3 lety +256

      I was wondering why Gideon wouldn't have a shock pill with him like that Gozanti-class cruiser captain, if he was going to try and off himself.
      My answer is that Gideon was so confident in himself, as well as the Dark Troopers, that he didn't need one.

    • @zulu4791
      @zulu4791 Před 3 lety +149

      @@darthdystopian4550 I thought it was also because he never assumed he’d be captured. The cruiser captain kills himself because he’s been captured and doesn’t want to get tortured by Moff Gideon. But Gideon was much less afraid of his higher up.

    • @stolpskott38
      @stolpskott38 Před 3 lety +22

      Yes, and I will believe Luke Skywalker tried to kill himself in ESB.

    • @totallynotjeff7748
      @totallynotjeff7748 Před 3 lety +38

      @@stolpskott38 I don't think he wanted to die necessarily, he just wanted to get away from Vader by any means necessary.

  • @Zminator1986
    @Zminator1986 Před 3 lety +446

    Reads video title.
    He's ISB, assume he knows everything.

    • @crashmoar290
      @crashmoar290 Před 3 lety +6

      Why did I have to scroll so far for this answer?

    • @James-nm6de
      @James-nm6de Před 3 lety +12

      @@crashmoar290 I was thinking the same, especially when Luke is one of the top worst enemies from the empire.

    • @coolstuff1959
      @coolstuff1959 Před 3 lety +8

      How many isb agents does it take to change a lightbulb
      2 one to chamge it and one to accuse him of treason

    • @coolstuff1959
      @coolstuff1959 Před 3 lety +1

      In ither words they dont trust anyone even there own

    • @Acrophobia2
      @Acrophobia2 Před 3 lety +2

      The empires CIA

  • @adthetree
    @adthetree Před 3 lety +411

    I kinda know the basic answer to this one but: “Why did the mon cala do such a horrible job fixing the razor crest?”

    • @silentdrew7636
      @silentdrew7636 Před 3 lety +62

      1000 credits isn't much to work with.

    • @lyndsaybrown8471
      @lyndsaybrown8471 Před 3 lety +11

      He knew what was coming

    • @spamviking
      @spamviking Před 3 lety +71

      Just because you're from Detroit doesn't mean you can fix a Chevy.

    • @titantantisunthorn9222
      @titantantisunthorn9222 Před 3 lety +4

      But they’re supposed to be GREAT architects tho

    • @noahbathgate7133
      @noahbathgate7133 Před 3 lety +19

      @@titantantisunthorn9222 that’s like saying all Dwarves know how to make Mithril armour

  • @Rensune
    @Rensune Před 3 lety +644

    Is it because Luke is The Most wanted Man in the Empire?
    Nah, he's just a Secret fan

    • @derrickstorm6976
      @derrickstorm6976 Před 3 lety +7

      He had sekret intellikense

    • @TedRader
      @TedRader Před 3 lety +4

      @@derrickstorm6976 intellijence 😄

    • @lyndsaybrown8471
      @lyndsaybrown8471 Před 3 lety +6

      Moff Gideon: If I get to see Luke Skywalker. I could die a happy man.

    • @zeppelincraft1443
      @zeppelincraft1443 Před 3 lety +2

      I find it strange Luke is intimidated by the "man wanted on twelve systems" and only in the next few days he would be the "man wanted on EVERY system"

    • @stinkyfungus
      @stinkyfungus Před 2 lety +1

      Feared...not wanted.
      The imperial remnant wanted NOTHING to do with luke skywalker.
      They were scared shitless of him, the last thing they wanted to do is try to catch/kill him or even get his attention - and have luke friggin' skywalker showing up on their doorstep.
      By the time of the mandolorian - the empire was really not much more than An unusually well equipped group of loosely allied crime syndicates.

  • @isaackim7675
    @isaackim7675 Před 3 lety +1130

    Imagine Boba Fett meeting Luke after all those years

    • @georgschmidt1252
      @georgschmidt1252 Před 3 lety +127

      This would be very uncomfortable

    • @mr.s2005
      @mr.s2005 Před 3 lety +90

      Well they really didn't interact that much..only one little fight and luke wasnt the one who knocked him into the pit. In legends I think Bobba went after Solo again and while he obvious hated the jedi, dont recall him going after luke.

    • @silentdrew7636
      @silentdrew7636 Před 3 lety +49

      @@mr.s2005 they met at least once or twice before that in canon. There was the time they fought in Obi-Wan's house, which ended when Obi-Wan's wooden chest flew across the room and hit Boba in the head.

    • @mojothemigo
      @mojothemigo Před 3 lety +33

      From what little I gleamed, Mandalorians do try on some level to separate their ego in fights and look at coming away from where either or both almost died in a similar way a lot of people disagree and one convinces the other. Not sure how much Boba Fett was taught in the more philosophical parts of Mandalorian culture, but I would imagine a lot rubbed off on him. In the end, Boba might be impressed and be able to laugh it off and similarly with Luke and his understanding, stoic Jedi mentality. Han Solo or Chewbacca on the other hand might start shit, argue, and wouldn't trust him

    • @MrHaloman95
      @MrHaloman95 Před 3 lety +11

      Well...Well if ain’t Skywalker, who would’ve figured we’d cross paths again after the mess you made on Tatooine. Too bad Solo and the Wookiee aren’t here, would’ve loved a better payback... Guess you’ll have to do.. [ pulls out his rifle firing quickly ]
      Luke Blocks 2 shots with his lightsaber with ease
      *Boba fires his jetpack missile*
      *Grogu holds missile in air before safely disarming it*
      *Mando and Bo restrain Boba*

  • @danielhughes5932
    @danielhughes5932 Před 3 lety +124

    Whether he knows if it is Luke, I'm sure he knows who Luke is. But most importantly, he knows his ace in the hole - his whole reason for believing he still had the upper hand - his dark troopers, mean nothing to ANY jedi.
    Gideon KNEW his own victory was imminent, until that moment.

    • @williamflowers9435
      @williamflowers9435 Před 3 lety +19

      I think lesser Jedi would struggle with that many Dark Troopers the way many were killed by Grevious. But when faced with a Master like Kenobi, Grievous’ speed of multiple attacks couldn’t overwhelm them. By this point, Luke is becoming what Anakin would have at full potential

    • @danielhughes5932
      @danielhughes5932 Před 3 lety +1

      @@williamflowers9435 weren't 1 or both of the first 2 generation dark troopers force sensitive?

    • @atedinahalf6288
      @atedinahalf6288 Před 3 lety +4

      @@danielhughes5932 its over Daniel, I have the high ground.

    • @xylonus
      @xylonus Před 3 lety +3

      @@williamflowers9435 Anakin in full potential is godlike, but here Luke is probably more powerful than ROTS Anakin

    • @Callofdutymaster22
      @Callofdutymaster22 Před 2 lety

      @@danielhughes5932 nah, they started as modified clones after the clone wars ended

  • @chasetoyama8184
    @chasetoyama8184 Před 3 lety +106

    “Our favorite blue admiral.” Eck, Thrawn is the only blue admiral we know of.

    • @dannybeads3672
      @dannybeads3672 Před 3 lety +8

      And also favorite

    • @meatloafisgood2374
      @meatloafisgood2374 Před 3 lety +2

      Ar’alani

    • @chasetoyama8184
      @chasetoyama8184 Před 3 lety +1

      @@dannybeads3672 I mean, I guess you are right, at least he is my favorite Imperial admiral (Yularen doesn’t count, when we see him in Rebels he is a Colonel, so I consider him a Republic admiral but not an Imperial admiral)

    • @marcanderson6034
      @marcanderson6034 Před 3 lety

      @@meatloafisgood2374 who?

    • @meatloafisgood2374
      @meatloafisgood2374 Před 3 lety

      @@marcanderson6034 she’s a Chiss admiral

  • @effen_aey_man
    @effen_aey_man Před 3 lety +280

    There was a guy who literally episodes before that broke a suicide tooth in his mouth

    • @literatemax
      @literatemax Před 3 lety +25

      Ah yes the palpatine pill

    • @remuslazar2033
      @remuslazar2033 Před 3 lety +11

      @@literatemax unlimited....power??

    • @owenkasaboski6902
      @owenkasaboski6902 Před 3 lety +12

      No, limited brain power

    • @Vandicoup
      @Vandicoup Před 3 lety +24

      And we've seen suicides multiple times in The Clone Wars and Rebels (if I remember right). But definitely in TCW. Such as that one man that Obi-Wan chased down and tried to get information from then the dude said a final sentence and jumped off the ledge onto Mandalore's glass pavement. There was also a twi'lek who jumped off the balcony of the Zygerrian Queen's castle because she couldn't take it anymore of being her slave and getting "processed" again for "bad behavior." Also, not to mention, when Clovis purposefully let go of Anakin's hand in order to save Padme and he also fell to his death AND this here may not be suicide but it was definitely solicited suicide: Maul in S7 begged for Ahsoka to let him go, to let him die. And plenty other actual suicides all throughout the animated SW universe. ;)

    • @effen_aey_man
      @effen_aey_man Před 3 lety +3

      @@Vandicoup Great example, I was just saying the one that would have been the freshest in peoples memory

  • @M0CC3R
    @M0CC3R Před 3 lety +1819

    Easy: he was a huge Luke fanboy.

    • @ace_v2905
      @ace_v2905 Před 3 lety +44

      So... I hear you make some killer chili.

    • @thomasseeger3685
      @thomasseeger3685 Před 3 lety +8

      Him and everyone else

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro Před 3 lety +6

      Considering that Luke is his boss, yes he is...

    • @JaelaOrdo
      @JaelaOrdo Před 3 lety +8

      I heard he keeps Luke’s old x-wing helmet in his quarters on his ship. Supposedly he talks to it, what a weirdo.

    • @Cheattoe
      @Cheattoe Před 3 lety +6

      No he’s a Palpatine fan boy, you always know that asshole who killed your old sugar daddy who gives you a dark saber

  • @mostlycensored7668
    @mostlycensored7668 Před 3 lety +39

    "Never seen anyone kill himself"...
    Ignores 4 episodes ago when Moff Gideon says "you know what to do" and officer kills himself.

  • @argop4518
    @argop4518 Před 3 lety +31

    The moment that X-wing landed, Gideon started hearing boss music.

  • @MattWeberWA
    @MattWeberWA Před 3 lety +96

    Not Mando related, but I'd love a video about the first hundred days of the Empire. That transition from republic to Empire is fascinating, and undercooked in what I've read.

    • @evanthompson211
      @evanthompson211 Před 3 lety +17

      I think that might be covered in the new bad batch animated series .

    • @kungolaf4499
      @kungolaf4499 Před 3 lety +8

      Bad Batch animated series. And by extension the Clone Wars. The Republic is looking pretty Empire-y by the time of Season 5 of the Clone Wars, they just have Jedi wielding laser swords command them.

    • @perjulianlundbergtande8956
      @perjulianlundbergtande8956 Před 3 lety

      Hate undercooked stuff myself :(

    • @arashimiyazawa8165
      @arashimiyazawa8165 Před 3 lety +1

      @@kungolaf4499 Quoth Maul: "Too late for WHAT? The Republic to fall?! It already has, and you just can't see it!"

  • @Alrucards
    @Alrucards Před 3 lety +66

    "Assume that I know everything." Moff Gideon

  • @LordBaldur
    @LordBaldur Před 3 lety +72

    To the empire, this man blew up the Death Star, killed Vader and “killed” Palpatine. This guy is a pariah.

  • @LEGIONBRICKS
    @LEGIONBRICKS Před 3 lety +616

    Short answer: because it’s Luke Skywalker.

    • @gusguy00
      @gusguy00 Před 3 lety +1

      yup

    • @davidty2006
      @davidty2006 Před 3 lety +3

      Slightly less Short answer: because all the other imperials told him.

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro Před 3 lety

      Actual answer: Because it was his boss 0-0 (dead serious)

    • @obijuanquenobi1911
      @obijuanquenobi1911 Před 3 lety +4

      Because Luke took a stop by Los Pollos Hermanos one day

    • @robhenry7896
      @robhenry7896 Před 3 lety +6

      Oh my god it's Luke fucking Skywalker

  • @caolan3202
    @caolan3202 Před 3 lety +71

    If Din is now mandalore, but has broken the code of the children of watch then will the children of the watch actually obey and follow him as mandalore?(another mando civil war between main mandos and splinter groups?)

    • @JaelaOrdo
      @JaelaOrdo Před 3 lety +12

      Honestly they shouldn’t follow him, not just because he broke their code but also he’s not really Mandalore material.

    • @shanewebb3341
      @shanewebb3341 Před 3 lety +44

      Well they followed maul who wasn't even mandalorian so id assume so.

    • @caolan3202
      @caolan3202 Před 3 lety +16

      @@JaelaOrdo reluctant leaders are the best leaders

    • @caolan3202
      @caolan3202 Před 3 lety +2

      @@shanewebb3341 it's changed from just death watch tho it's more of a cult now

    • @shanewebb3341
      @shanewebb3341 Před 3 lety

      @@caolan3202 Well yes but they are descendants of them and were not entirely sure of what their history is relating to them. And also they were very traditional so they would have to follow him unless someone else could beat him in combat for it.

  • @Turanic1
    @Turanic1 Před 3 lety +66

    I am sure a lot of imperial officers on Endor who last seen Luke with Vader had his image and details stored in imperial database as NO1 most dangerous/wanted man in entire galaxy and not long after the Second Death Star is down, while both emperor and Vader are missing, they could actually perceive Luke as another sith Lord easily

    • @brian.hanifin
      @brian.hanifin Před 3 lety +18

      I agree. I believe he knew Luke was on the Death Star with Vader and I think this of a terrific explanation of how.
      Further I believe he suspects Skywalker killed BOTH Darth Vader and Darth Sideous! Which make him scared shitless!

    • @silentdrew7636
      @silentdrew7636 Před 3 lety +9

      Assassinated, not missing, and Luke would be the most likely suspect if there are any records of his presence their.

    • @danielkorladis7869
      @danielkorladis7869 Před 3 lety +8

      ​@@silentdrew7636 Yeah, as another commenter mentioned, when Darth Vader and Luke Skywalker both went into the throne room to see the Emperor. Only Luke knows what happened in there, because he's the only one who walked out (albeit dragging Vader/Anakin, who died a short time later). If I was an imperial officer, I'd be scared, too.

  • @joshuacotton2326
    @joshuacotton2326 Před 3 lety +21

    Cover why luke said there was a bond between grogu and din while Ahsoka called it an attachment. I think the difference is very telling about their views on Jedi attachments

    • @JB-1138
      @JB-1138 Před 3 lety +11

      Well, Luke did grow up with a home and family. Ahsoka did not.
      Luke's perspective is surely more relaxed on the subject of family and attachments.

    • @MonkeyJedi99
      @MonkeyJedi99 Před 3 lety +5

      @@JB-1138 Also, Ahsoka is a product of the Republic era of Jedi, and Luke has a spotty indoctrination over a couple of short courses, plus some ghostly correspondence lectures.

  • @hiddendesire3076
    @hiddendesire3076 Před 3 lety +4

    1:44 Actually when Luke and the Emperor are fighting. No other rebels are on the deathstar so the blaster fire is of either troopers shooting each other for spots on escape pods or shuttles, or them offing themselves fearful of the pain from the explosion.

  • @nyechapple5332
    @nyechapple5332 Před 3 lety +47

    "Hey boss, remember that guy who took a fighter jet to destroy the attack moon? And then went on to kill muderman 9000 Vader and lightning fist Empy? Hes outside and wants to chat"
    Gideon: " *nope* "

  • @badgamemaster
    @badgamemaster Před 3 lety +62

    Maybe in the eyes of Gideon, Luke is the one who killed Vader at the Emperor...

    • @danielkorladis7869
      @danielkorladis7869 Před 3 lety +17

      @@leomanolis8701 yeah, but he's the only one who knows what happened in the throne room. All anyone else knows is that only one guy survived whatever went down, and his name is Luke Skywalker.

    • @zadokmotorfreight2423
      @zadokmotorfreight2423 Před 3 lety +10

      @@danielkorladis7869 Exactly. Imagine knowing that Luke went into a room Darth Vader AND the Emperor.... and the only one to walk out.... is Luke. Whew, that's enormous!!

  • @rafaelfarias4359
    @rafaelfarias4359 Před 3 lety +18

    He knows that what was coming was the man who destroyed the Death Star.

  • @grantdporras
    @grantdporras Před 3 lety +11

    “A friendly piece of advice, assume that i know everything” -Moff Gideon

    • @JMB_Knight
      @JMB_Knight Před 3 lety

      Well that explains it
      He knows who Luke is and how powerful he is because everyone thought he killed the Emperor and Vader

  • @Svnfold
    @Svnfold Před 3 lety +35

    Luke, Emperor Palpatine and Darth Vader walk into one room and only Luke comes out alive. 🙄

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro Před 3 lety

      Luke's Master is still alive... only his predecessor
      died there.

    • @meatloafisgood2374
      @meatloafisgood2374 Před 3 lety +1

      Gonna be honest the way you said it made it sound like the set up for a joke

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro Před 3 lety

      @@meatloafisgood2374 Yeh, I'm shocked that so many people know about Dark Empire, but still are in denial of what actually happen there, or that it was foreshadowed in Empire Strikes Back.

  • @jayb8934
    @jayb8934 Před 3 lety +9

    I agree that it's likely that Gideon knew it was Luke, but he didn't necessarily have to. I think just seeing a jedi (or anyone else who was capable of it) make short work of his Dark Troopers would be enough to explain his panic.

  • @Hans-hy5jp
    @Hans-hy5jp Před 3 lety +10

    *Gideon 20 minutes prior to Luke arriving to Mando:*
    "Assume that I know everything"

  • @OwentheKingofDudes
    @OwentheKingofDudes Před 3 lety +5

    Consider Moff Gideon's age & career. He was most likely a young Republic Navy officer in the Clone Wars, & would have seen Jedi in action, maybe even worked alongside them, like Admiral Yularen or Tarkin in that one episode. That would also explain his familiarity with the Jedi.

  • @amwitty_
    @amwitty_ Před 3 lety +26

    Reddit spoiled Luke for me, but I still smiled ear to ear when that X-Wing flew by

    • @TheTendermen
      @TheTendermen Před 3 lety +5

      Twitter and CZcams did it for me, and yeah I had the same reaction

    • @literatemax
      @literatemax Před 3 lety +9

      Imagine looking at the internet before watching the episode

    • @deep.space.12
      @deep.space.12 Před 3 lety +4

      I hate it when people put spoilers in the title...
      Meanwhile Eck does an excellent job avoiding spoilers.

    • @literatemax
      @literatemax Před 3 lety +3

      @Some Guy 99 Sounds like a clickbait jerk

    • @theinfiniteanomaly4364
      @theinfiniteanomaly4364 Před 3 lety +5

      I purposely avoid social media untill after I've watched a movie or TV show.

  • @marcobarbosa2335
    @marcobarbosa2335 Před 3 lety +7

    Great vid! Continue watching you for years to come!

  • @meatmaster85
    @meatmaster85 Před 3 lety +3

    I just love how this conjecture actually matters. I love searching for details that inform the future plot and The Mandalorian pulls this off so well.
    I can't wait for Thrawn, and I can't wait for your analysis when it happens!

  • @patrickfrost9405
    @patrickfrost9405 Před 3 lety +34

    I think it's kinda funny that Luke is now the King of Mandalore after ripping the Manalorian's heart straight out of his chest.

  • @jamesharrison5851
    @jamesharrison5851 Před 3 lety +11

    I like how far its going as in showing how high ranking officers will take there own lives to keep the the empires secrets, loving this gritty side of starwars

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro Před 3 lety

      Like who Luke was at that point? They were killed so they wouldn't talk...

    • @jamesharrison5851
      @jamesharrison5851 Před 3 lety

      @@TheRezro who luke was wasn't a secret by any means, im pointing towards what things might be in store for us next.

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro Před 3 lety

      @@jamesharrison5851 The secret was on which side he was at that point. It is why he simply didn't order Dark Troopers to stand down.

    • @yourstruly4817
      @yourstruly4817 Před 3 lety +1

      *their

  • @kingfernando4804
    @kingfernando4804 Před rokem +2

    Can we take a second to appreciate the acting by Giancarlo Esposito? Very few people can pull of that look of sheer terror.

  • @ThnkEnjinn
    @ThnkEnjinn Před 3 lety +12

    Gideon knew Grogu is key for Lukes rebuild of the order... He knows how powerful Grogu really is... prolly also from his mediclorian count.... Thats why he tried to kill him....He tried to kill himself becoz he didnt want to be captured and interogated... About Thrawn....

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro Před 3 lety +1

      You are aware that this show take place 9ABY? And what happen 10 ABY? Short answer is... he did recognized Luke for simple reason of him being his boss. It is clear that Din would need fight with Dark Empire and Palatine's apprentice in next seasons.

    • @JMB_Knight
      @JMB_Knight Před 3 lety

      Holy Crap!🤯

  • @Alexman113
    @Alexman113 Před 3 lety +7

    I never interpreted this as him knowing who Luke was specifically, more that a Jedi was making short work of his super powerful robot army and that he had lost. I am guessing he also knows something so he couldn't risk having his mind read which is why he attempted suicide.

    • @kwgrid
      @kwgrid Před 3 lety +1

      Didn't he have that 'look' before the dark troopers were dispensed with? Someone said, "It's a Jedi" and he freaked out. I agree with your last statement.

  • @BooooClips
    @BooooClips Před 3 lety +18

    Traitor

  • @Just_Adrian_
    @Just_Adrian_ Před 3 lety +4

    When that X Wing showed up I was like that one Chris Pratt gif where he gets super excited and started fanboying so hard

  • @Krispe
    @Krispe Před 3 lety +10

    Hey bro I just tweeted at you but I’m gonna comment it here as well. While I disagree with your take, I feel SWT’s response to you was unwarranted and anyone attacking you is completely unjustified. You’ve always stood up for what’s right and haven’t shilled for Disney in my eyes, and I believe that you don’t ever deserve any kind of hate. I love your content bro, keep your head up, don’t let this get to you.

    • @Krispe
      @Krispe Před 3 lety

      @@hashimrahman51 Liking a movie doesn’t make you a shill genius, defending a company when they do something clearly horrible is a shill. Like Pablo, or then stealing fan art.

  • @KuraMad2000
    @KuraMad2000 Před 3 lety +42

    Nah Gideon wasn't trying to kill himself. He was trying to blow his jaw off so he wouldn't have to answer any questions. If he was really going to kill himself, he would have chomped down on one of those self electrocuting tooths, you know, the ones where if you listed closely to it while it's activated, you can hear a tiny emperor's voice saying "Unlimited Powah!!!!"

    • @markonikolic7957
      @markonikolic7957 Před 3 lety +3

      He probably doesn't have one. I mean it wouldn't make sense for the plot, how would they stop him from killing himself in that case?

    • @Pigeon249
      @Pigeon249 Před 3 lety +10

      @@markonikolic7957 he has the confidence that he wont be captured so he doesn't need one. Aswell as the lack of superiors to punish him.

    • @boggless2771
      @boggless2771 Před 3 lety +6

      @@markonikolic7957 yeah why would a leader of Gideon's caliber have a suicide tooth. Thats something subordinates have.

    • @Vaith
      @Vaith Před 3 lety +2

      Yeh based off the angle of the blaster it would have just blown his jaw off maybe, but it's a blaster so it might kill him anyways based off how they work. If that was a real life gun it would have just blown through his mouth and not killed him, would be really painful though. It's probably that he was trying to kill himself though and just a failure of acting/directing that he held the blaster that way. I figure he thought he could bullshit his way out and was confident with the DT's he would escape, but when Luke shows up he realizes he can't escape no matter what so tries to kill himself instead of being surely captured. I doubt he knew 100% it was Luke though, maybe, but I feel he would have the same reaction had it been Ahsoka or anyone else mowing down his super powerful DT's. An unpredicted factor showed up, and he failed to forsee it. He was doing a heccin panic.

    • @danielkorladis7869
      @danielkorladis7869 Před 3 lety

      He probably didn't want to stand trial.

  • @juancabardo21
    @juancabardo21 Před 3 lety +4

    Luke to the Empire: Went into the throne room and was the only one who came out alive.

  • @Aidenaman
    @Aidenaman Před 3 lety +6

    Great job keep up the good work man!

  • @Echo-kq5gp
    @Echo-kq5gp Před 3 lety +11

    Hiii I love your content

  • @joab757
    @joab757 Před 3 lety +9

    The dude was responsible for taking down the 2 scariest people in the galaxy!

  • @pirobot668beta
    @pirobot668beta Před 3 lety +9

    "Assume I know everything."
    If true, then the Jedi who pilots an X-wing can be no one else but Luke!
    It also tells why Gideon was terrified at a personal level: A Jedi Master just might be able to read his mind!
    Gideon's stunt with the blaster wasn't a real suicide attempt.
    He hesitated just long enough to be disarmed after he shot at Beskar clad warriors!
    A token display of defiance with little chance of causing any real damage...Gideon doesn't do half-measures.
    He wants to be seen as a high value target, he even says as much!
    Despite the setback of losing Grogu, the cruiser and the dark saber, this is still Gideon's game.
    I think Gideon is gonna get played for a sucker...The Firefly episode "Trash" comes to mind.
    The crew scammed a scammer by acting like they were falling for the scammers plot.
    Mando and company know Gideon is trying to play them, and so they will go along with his narratives, see where it goes.
    Gideon would never betray his masters, but if he thinks he is winning, he will gloat and tip his hand!
    He loves his monologues...his arrogance blinds him.

    • @brmo6232
      @brmo6232 Před 3 lety

      I think your right they’ve been so careful with details they wouldn’t just stop at a suicide attempt that wasn’t even a real attempt. Why would he shoot beskar wearing people. He had the DARKSABRR... he has fought mandalorians obviously. He wants to instigate bo Karan to kill din and then escape in the chaos

    • @FallenRingbearer
      @FallenRingbearer Před 3 lety

      I love his monologues too lol.

  • @JessWLStuart
    @JessWLStuart Před 3 lety

    Well presented!
    I love how you don't add supposition to your commentary without clearly labeling it so.

  • @Jedi_Spartan
    @Jedi_Spartan Před 3 lety +33

    6:48 How, he's only in an X-wing. At least Grogu could sit on Luke's lap, Gideon not so much.

    • @senatorluxbonteri6065
      @senatorluxbonteri6065 Před 3 lety +10

      Strap him to the ceiling

    • @darthdystopian4550
      @darthdystopian4550 Před 3 lety +18

      Like when Obi-Wan went to arrest Jango Fett to take him back to the Jedi Temple.

    • @pills-
      @pills- Před 3 lety +9

      TBF, Gideon IS flying his own means of transportation :D
      Plus, there's always some "outdoor" seats on the X-wing. All it takes is a little bit of rope and an environmental suit...

    • @Jedi_Spartan
      @Jedi_Spartan Před 3 lety +9

      @@pills- good point. Although for the second point, I doubt that the standard environment/space suit can withstand hyperspace.

    • @rahul327
      @rahul327 Před 3 lety +9

      @@pills- Even if Luke leaves the Arquitens to Bo-Katan, he could easily call Leia and have a CR-90 sent to his coordinates pretty sharpish

  • @OTee1998
    @OTee1998 Před 3 lety +1

    I think Gideon was going to kill Grogu because he knew how devastating it would be to have him as an enemy, trained by Luke Skywalker. Or it could be the scenario, “If we can’t have him, nobody can.”

  • @Quake3131
    @Quake3131 Před 3 lety +9

    These titles are so funny, the next video will be “Why The Mandalorian REALLY Cried When Grogu Left! (Secret Revealed!)”

  • @cancerstinks1
    @cancerstinks1 Před 2 lety +1

    The fear in Gideon’s face was extremely palpable

  • @jaredsundberg1081
    @jaredsundberg1081 Před 3 lety +4

    If Gideon is threatening just imagine how terrifying Thrawns gonna be

  • @GEEKICIDALTENDENCIES
    @GEEKICIDALTENDENCIES Před 3 lety

    Great job....well thought out!...I really appreciate how you kept your theories grounded and didn't try to over reach or push some sort of "fan fiction"!!

  • @bhsx
    @bhsx Před 3 lety +4

    We saw the captain of the frigate kill himself with an electric tooth... So yeah, we've seen it, and he actually finished the job.

  • @christopherkaylor2940
    @christopherkaylor2940 Před 3 lety +2

    The theory since Gideon was ISB and knew about Luke makes sense, the fact no one asked for Luke's name was interesting, but guess they were all stunned how Luke went through the Darktroopers like a lightsaber.

  • @mrsleepparalysisdemon9863

    Moff gideon: I fear no man but this thing *points at Luke* it scares me

  • @nicholaibrchner2374
    @nicholaibrchner2374 Před 3 lety

    I just freaking love your outro! The look of what is coming next in the Corgi's eyes is so darn cute!

  • @Slender_Man_186
    @Slender_Man_186 Před 3 lety +4

    Simple, as Gideon said: “assume I know everything.”

  • @matthewdunlap3700
    @matthewdunlap3700 Před 3 lety

    I’ve watched so many of your videos idk why I’m just now subscribing but I swear my favorite Star Wars videos have been you. Much love man much love.

  • @pedeede
    @pedeede Před 3 lety +23

    Remember: "Emotions are not for sharing" - Pablo Hidalgo - Lucasfilm Story Group.

    • @Stringer13ell
      @Stringer13ell Před 3 lety

      werd yes he agrees with a sarcastic sentiment aimed at the person pablo was talking to. And?

    • @wingzero771
      @wingzero771 Před 3 lety +3

      @@Stringer13ell not sarcastic. He’s just back-tracking after all the backlash.

    • @rainmaker2338
      @rainmaker2338 Před 3 lety +1

      Remember, sarcasm doesn't exist

    • @Stringer13ell
      @Stringer13ell Před 3 lety

      @@wingzero771 those two things arent mutually exclusive

    • @RoboticPope
      @RoboticPope Před 3 lety

      Hidalgo has always been an A hole and liar. Even if he was trying to be sarcastic (I don't believe it), he is in the wrong. Being sarcastic towards your customers is unprofessional behaviour.

  • @Omegaroth666
    @Omegaroth666 Před 3 lety

    I feel like I may have said this before, but I'm saying it again. The bass in your intro music sounds so amazing from my killer sound system in my car. 😊

  • @KheptlaxaXonu
    @KheptlaxaXonu Před 3 lety +16

    Be careful about recording your emotional reactions, Pablo might disapprove.

  • @mmraf1
    @mmraf1 Před 3 lety +2

    Dude was Sith CIA, of course he knew

  • @alex1311t
    @alex1311t Před 3 lety +3

    My theory: Moff Gideon is slightly force sensitive and sensed Luke's presence. However, Moff Gideon is not strong in the force and isn't that force sensitive like Jedi and Sith were. That's why Gideon wanted Grogu's blood and studied it. He thought by studying and using blood with a high m count, he could increase his force sensitivity

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro Před 3 lety +1

      We see that when he resisted Grogu...

  • @MasonWhite0304
    @MasonWhite0304 Před 3 lety +1

    Could you please do a video on the full history of the darksaber? Love your vids!

  • @michaelgibson4067
    @michaelgibson4067 Před 3 lety +15

    Wishing you all a safe and splendid holiday season! ☮️😉👍

    • @kyle18934
      @kyle18934 Před 3 lety

      @@leomanolis8701 be the first to comment and say something witty

  • @srtcsb
    @srtcsb Před 3 lety

    Have really enjoyed your Mandalorian coverage. Really like the doggie outro also.

  • @jayweber3022
    @jayweber3022 Před 3 lety +56

    Could he be somewhat force sensitive?
    Edit: because he seems to know everything about the surroundings

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro Před 3 lety +10

      He is. He clearly could resist Grogu.

    • @basedeltazero714
      @basedeltazero714 Před 3 lety +1

      ​@@hypervolt9987 Partly that, but Luke would be the most prominent if not the only Jedi he knows about. They're supposed to be extinct... except, y'know, for that one that killed the Emperor. And Vader.

    • @unitedstatesofamerica9948
      @unitedstatesofamerica9948 Před 3 lety

      Also explains why he's more fearful - he knows the advantage being force sensitive provides, so he can grasp the magnitude of the extreme amplification of that in Skywalker.

  • @FQP-7024
    @FQP-7024 Před 3 lety +11

    Hey won't you make a video on Star Wars Theory getting bashed on Twitter already??? Come on man don't be one of those guys that lick boots for nothing

    • @rainmaker2338
      @rainmaker2338 Před 3 lety +3

      Unlike Theory, Eck doesn't milk drama for money and views. You're on the wrong channel for that

    • @FQP-7024
      @FQP-7024 Před 3 lety

      @@rainmaker2338 it's not that, it's to defend a fellow creator from the idiotic stuff Twitter throws at them, we can't allow ourselves to stay on the sidelines while one is clearly being attacked

  • @michaelgibson4067
    @michaelgibson4067 Před 3 lety +31

    *"I hate that we have to wait 2 yrs to see the series again though!!!"* 🤔😭😭😭

    • @Turanic1
      @Turanic1 Před 3 lety +7

      2?

    • @michaelgibson4067
      @michaelgibson4067 Před 3 lety +6

      No episodes of this series next year its been announced instead we're getting the Casian Andor series, The Obi-Wan Kenobi series and Boba Fett series! 🤔

    • @Nicholas-Aguirre
      @Nicholas-Aguirre Před 3 lety +3

      And Bad Batch

    • @DasBuck
      @DasBuck Před 3 lety +1

      @@michaelgibson4067 where did it say that? I thought they confirmed it and Boba for next year? I must’ve missed it somewhere?

    • @michaelgibson4067
      @michaelgibson4067 Před 3 lety +1

      @@DasBuck You most likely find it on Mandalorian information season 3 but other CZcams creators have brought it up too! Have a good one!

  • @rapterslayer
    @rapterslayer Před 3 lety +1

    Love your vids dude

  • @iam_FLAME
    @iam_FLAME Před 3 lety +14

    Love theory and eckhart, but eckhart had a bad take in my opinion. Theories response to the tweet was kinda immature lol. I don't think it matters much if pablo was being sarcastic or not, cause it's a bad look either way. Wish theory and eckhart could get along cause I love both channels.

  • @rossgauthier6352
    @rossgauthier6352 Před 3 lety

    Another fantastic video Eck!!!

  • @GianniAriella
    @GianniAriella Před 3 lety +6

    Hi EckhartsLadder!
    How are you and the fam?☺️
    I hope all is well. For your next video, if you could talk more about why Luke Skywalker finally came back. I mean I know Luke Skywalker heard the call from Grogu thru the force but he could’ve just ignored it because he might’ve had other pressing matters to attend to but he did not, he eventually came by the end of season 2 in the last chapter of it. How does this tie in to The Last Jedi? I need your thoughts on this, please! I really wish your Mandalorian series would not have to end for now lbvs.
    Thank you,
    Gianni🤟🏾😌

    • @kyle18934
      @kyle18934 Před 3 lety +1

      If you don't mind me answering, in the last jedi we hear that Luke created a new jedi order. However been solo had hate in him and Luke did a dumb dumb and tried to kill him. This led Ben and his friends, the knights of Ren to fight the other students. So Ben kills all of the others and then leaves. Luke feels destroyed and that his life work failed so he leaves.
      That's my take on it anyways

  • @dresdenwarlock7978
    @dresdenwarlock7978 Před 3 lety +1

    When the VHS copies of the special editions came out I watched the trilogy EVERY DAY for a year or more.

    • @dresdenwarlock7978
      @dresdenwarlock7978 Před 3 lety

      @Tony J Yeah! It helped that I had my own VCR and TV in my room, but yeah, those VHS's got WORN DOWN.

  • @Luis_luis_luis
    @Luis_luis_luis Před 3 lety +10

    Guys SWT and Eckharts are not at war, stop going to eachothers channels and raging at eachother, we are the reason that this problem is gonna last so long cuz us toxic fans wont let the youtubers move on. We are only doing harm to our youtubers by keeping the fire going.

  • @halrox247
    @halrox247 Před 3 lety +5

    I wish you’d list the sources of the background video in your uploads. Usually I can tell and recently it’s often been Squadrons but I didn’t recognize it this time and it looks amazing.

    • @evanrice916
      @evanrice916 Před 3 lety +2

      I know some of the footage is from the animated short EA did for Squadrons.

  • @Aw12ish.
    @Aw12ish. Před 3 lety +23

    Been subbed for years but Aye man as a big mostly star wars channel you should really be sticking up for star wars theory and Twitter is toxic

    • @xSuperFryx
      @xSuperFryx Před 3 lety +4

      Why? Pablo didn’t insult him.

    • @Aw12ish.
      @Aw12ish. Před 3 lety +3

      @@xSuperFryx yes he did

    • @mattmills9647
      @mattmills9647 Před 3 lety +2

      @@Aw12ish. he shouldn’t need to have the same opinion as STW just because they’re both Star Wars channels

  • @RedJet-bq6fq
    @RedJet-bq6fq Před 3 lety

    My theory is that the dark troopers were programmed with a protocol to detect any Jedi present on the light cruiser (probably a lightsaber/kyber crystal detector?) and when the dark troopers stopped punching the blast door, they went into that defense protocol. Moff Gideon recognized this change in action soon after.

  • @deep.space.12
    @deep.space.12 Před 3 lety +9

    I just realized that, they should have let him pull the trigger, and Gideon would only be missing a jaw 🤣

    • @bananaboat30plus87
      @bananaboat30plus87 Před 3 lety +1

      Hard to extract info from some one who can't speak

    • @danielkorladis7869
      @danielkorladis7869 Před 3 lety

      they probably want to put him on trial for his war crimes

    • @basedeltazero714
      @basedeltazero714 Před 3 lety

      Eh, as plasma weapons blasters have some explosive effects. I would... not count on that.

  • @shawnbrown7057
    @shawnbrown7057 Před 3 lety +3

    Moff Gideon knowing who Luke is makes perfect sense. Why almost everyone else doesn't seem to know who one of the great heroes of the rebellion is doesn't make any sense. It would have been all over the holonet about him firing the shot that destroyed the death star at Yavin and surely they would have heard about his involvement in taking down the second death star too.
    I have a theory on that:
    ...What the general public might not know about is Luke being a jedi.
    He didn't really master his force powers until training on a secluded backwater planet with Yoda. After that, he only really started heavily using his force powers at Bespin against Vader (and lost). Not many people, if any, saw that happen. His biggest public display of force ability and where he started calling himself a jedi was against Jabba the Hutt's gang on Tatooine. Only Boba Fett was there to see that (and he conveniently wasn't with the boarding party). Most of the other witnesses died in the sail barge explosion or in the belly of the sarlacc. The few remaining probably don't get off Tatooine much to tell their tale. The Ewoks believed the levitation of C3P0 was magic from their angry god... That leaves only the closed room in the second death star with only Vader and the Emperor to witness Luke's full jedi ability.
    Long story short, It's plausible not many people know about Luke's jedi powers. Sure, seeing a lone X-wing might make them think of the famous rebellion hero they heard of. Seeing a jedi might make them question that thought since Luke might not be widely known as one.

    • @Bzhydack
      @Bzhydack Před 3 lety

      I was thinking the same. Galaxy probably knows Luke as Rebel Hero, but not as a Jedi. Maybe most people know him only just by name, not by face, so this can explain why Cara Dune not know him. She would recognize him, if he would told his name.

  • @ontasbulent5709
    @ontasbulent5709 Před 3 lety +11

    Luke was the only known surviving Jedi during the imperial era. The emperor must have informed his Moffs like that’s guy you should be careful of. He is the biggest threat to the empire

    • @andu1478
      @andu1478 Před 3 lety +2

      vader knew about Cal, Ashoka, Kanan, and Ezra

  • @imperialadvisoraremheshvau3788

    Omg !!! You wore a black turtleneck and one black glove too !!! I did that a few times at age 12, but my go to was olive green soldier uniform since I was 7 and I was pretending to be Grand Moff Tarkins successor/son.

    • @imperialadvisoraremheshvau3788
      @imperialadvisoraremheshvau3788 Před 3 lety +1

      Moff Gideon’s Gozanti Captain actually successfully kills himself on screen a few Episodes ago. In the novel The Truce at Bakura it is alluded that every Imperial warship has an ISB agent to ensure the Commanding Officer will never surrender an Imperial warship.

  • @TheWanderer2287
    @TheWanderer2287 Před 3 lety +6

    I’d love to see some speculation videos on what we could see in The Bad Batch, or maybe even a video on the Purge Troopers from Jedi Fallen Order?

    • @Alrucards
      @Alrucards Před 3 lety +2

      At this point I like to believe the bad batch are going to be similar to some clones from Legends. Clones like certain commandos and Arc troopers questioned and didn't execute order 66. Even after the jedi purge these clones fought in the defense of Kamino against the Empire or disappears into obscurity.

  • @peterfrancis2330
    @peterfrancis2330 Před 3 lety

    John Skywicker is a man of focus, commitment, sheer will... something you know very little about.

  • @PenguinofD00mxxx
    @PenguinofD00mxxx Před 3 lety +5

    Gideon is definitely working with a larger organization. For the purposes of "Restoring Order to the Galaxy"

    • @Hidensee
      @Hidensee Před 3 lety +1

      Hope for Empire of Hands under Thrawn.

  • @leevilassila6374
    @leevilassila6374 Před 3 lety

    An idea for a video- Destiny 2 the hive lore or the fallen lore. Yes there are many youtubers who have made videos of those but you have this extraordinary technique all of your videos stay in my mind because they are so well organized and making them simple. Love your videos keep it up lad.

  • @danielrose7566
    @danielrose7566 Před 3 lety +17

    Video idea: what If Luke arrived to Gideon's cruiser before Mando and the gang

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro Před 3 lety

      We see his arrival...

    • @rahul327
      @rahul327 Před 3 lety +3

      Gideon threatens Grogu with the darksaber...
      Luke: *Force Yoink* Now what, Imperial?

    • @SleightlyPersonal
      @SleightlyPersonal Před 3 lety

      As in coincidence? ‘Cause he’s only there to pick up the child, so he couldn’t be there first for that.

  • @Shadowcam00
    @Shadowcam00 Před 3 lety +1

    I think Gideon tried to shoot Grogu to remove him as a future threat. A powerful Jedi with a long life-span is a huge obstacle for a rebuilt empire in the long-run.

  • @mitchelllake9684
    @mitchelllake9684 Před 3 lety +3

    He sensed Luke the same way Grogu sensed Luke. Remember, he said, “I have his (Grogu’s) blood!” He had been injecting himself with Grogu’s blood, and as a result, had started developing sensitivity to The Force. Why would he do this? To become strong enough to defeat Admiral Thrawn and seize control of the remnants of the Empire.

    • @darkninja2772
      @darkninja2772 Před 3 lety +4

      I am not quite sure if Grogus blood would make Gideon force sensitive but I actually like this theory more than the whole Emperor Palpatine ressurrection bullsh*t. I hope they don't connect the Mandalorian and the Ahsoka show to the sequels but create a new story that takes place years before episode 7.

  • @Omniseed
    @Omniseed Před 3 lety +1

    He probably was trying to avoid getting his mind read by Skywalker, whose true capabilities would certainly only be speculation to someone like Gideon.
    Thinking he was at the end of his part in the galactic turmoil and could only sabotage his allies by remaining alive could explain the attempted killage

  • @markstol2033
    @markstol2033 Před 3 lety +5

    He knew about his legendary fried chicken

  • @khajiitimanus7432
    @khajiitimanus7432 Před 3 lety

    That outro, though.... haha! Had me chuckling.

  • @BooooClips
    @BooooClips Před 3 lety +14

    Boootlicker