Civilian death toll in Gaza ‘completely unacceptable’ and ‘way too high’
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 05. 2024
- Environment and Water Minister Tanya Plibersek says the civilian death toll in Gaza is “completely unacceptable” and “way too high”.
Her comments follow Western Australia Labor Senator Fatima Payman breaking her ranks with her party to accuse Israel of genocide.
“At a time like this, it’s important to focus not on what we disagree on, but what we agree on,” Ms Plibersek told Sky News Australia.
“I think we agree that the October 7 attacks were horrific - I think we also agree that the civilian death toll now in Gaza is completely unacceptable, way too high.”
Hamas won’t ceasefire though.
what did the bible say about lying randyo5540.
ever
Triggered YT censor 😂
Labor has no clue.
Palestine 🇵🇸 ain't a state so there is no 2 state solution.
The person that came up with that name is the same person that siphoned hundreds of millions of dollars into his own bank accounts that “were supposed to go to the people and infrastructure”. Fun fact, he did business with Israel’s that maintained some of those bank accounts 😂😂😂
That's funny. A well known fascist said something similar about "Jews" not being people. Do you agree?
:I
@@szlava3641
The Romans came up with that name.
Assyria owns the land.
are you an Israel bot
And what would this “2-state solution” look like? And who would be in charge of Gaza? Can she even answer those two basic questions?
It would look like this Coles and Woolworths
Labor and Libs
Carl and Peter
2 states of the same A$$
You don't even understand what this concept of two State means
@@bbbnick9197It would be Gaza and “the West Bank”. BTW, the Palestinians have their own government. Its called the Palestinian Authority. Yeah, its corrupt AF, but at least they have their own “government”. There’s also Hamas in Gaza, but at least they got to vote for a leader in 2006, right?
lol play stupid games win stupid prizes.
What is the Australian government's proposal for Israel to eradicate the terror tunnels and defeat Hamas safely?
Give the Palestinians their land back.
@@nishatjaveen318 They have been offered a 2 state solution many times and keep rejecting it because they prefer being terrorists.
According to statistics, and in particular Natasha Hausdorf. In urban combat, the average combatant to civilian casualty ratio can be as high as 1:9. Though during operations after oct 7th, the IDF's has been 1:2.
War is horrible, and one side is using civilians as a shield.
Prove they are civilians and not Hamas
My reply vanished. I’ll try again.
The numbers are fake.
The numbers are f@ke.
Los numeros are f@ke
Fake figures.
Here we go, how about the digital ID bill happening today?
It was finalised on 10th
Most people don't know anything about it. Just want the government wants
Sky will tell you when it's passed
www.finance.gov.au/about-us/news/2024/digital-id-bill-passes-senate
www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Bills_Legislation/bd/bd2324a/24bd058
They speak of 288 Million being spent on this venture 10th May they finalised the bill
Wait what?!
They chose this on the 7th...no sympathy.
No it ain't
Given the vast and extensive tunnel systems that the terrorist Hamas has constructed, the Israeli response has been remarkably restrained.
Civvies have no idea how well the IDF has done keeping the casualty count as low as they have.
Lets face facts, even by hamas casualty figures, the IDF hasnt killed any civilians for months, and the UN is actually reducing the figures dramatically.
Well said.
Due to the extensive 75 years of oppression they had to build tunnels to escape the Gaza prison run by Israel. Don't worry your friendly Sky will delete this comment
Every city has tunnels, including every city In Australia. Also, Israel has tunnels under every city so what is your point?
@jayrwickerman
...one is reluctant to respond to such an infantile post, but here goes...
What Australian city has tunnels beneath it dedicated to an armed insurrection, loaded with arms, ammunition, food, kitchens, medical facilities, etc?
Your attempt at shifting the subject has failed dismally......
The civilian toll comes from the Gaza Health Ministry who are run by hummus. More and more people are coming to the conclusion that the numbers are fictitious. The figures from the Gaza Health Ministry support this.
Overall figures (previous)
Women 9,500 minimum
Children 14,500 minimum
That's 24,000 minimum
Detailed figures (now)
7,797 children
4,959 women
12,756 total.
That's a shortfall of 11,244 compared to previous.
Yes. the new figures are detailed, as in identified and there are 9,936 unidentified. Even if all 9.936 unidentified are women and children, highly unlikely, you are still 1,308 short.
People should realize the Gaza numbers are manufactured by Hamas.
Do you watch a lot of CSI on TV ,? Do you disect body identification for a accurate write off deaths to please a Smelly suit
Just like that fictitious number on October 7th
No. Yourself?
It’s been debunked. The first figures are correct. Don’t fall for the BS Pete Stefanovic 🤮
Modern day antisemitism:
Civilian toll is too much in Gaza.
How do you know are you a military expert?
I just know it is too much.
How many civilians died?
Too many.
Who said this?
HAMAS did.
Have you confirmed it independently?
No.
How do you know?
I just know.
modern day antisemitism stop killing children.
Yep, and refuses to say how many is an acceptable figure.
“Gays for Palestine” “Transvestites for Palestine” 😆😂😁🤪😀😄😜😋
Well said
That didn’t work out very well in London.
I had a good laugh at the guy who took an advertising truck with a screen on it to one such protest and played the leader of Hamas’ views on the people supporting them.
Whatever you do don't suggest they're not civi's
They're not civvies.
@@Rob-BC😅😅
There's no innocent civilians in Gaza.. Labour have lost the plot
Israel doesn’t want only one state in the region, Israel wants safety. Let’s pray for peace 🤍🙏🏻🇮🇱
You Aussies really needs a minister for water? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
War is bad folks. I hope they come to peace.
'Here are my insanely unrealistic suggestions for peace'. - 🤖
Easy to say when you don't live in Israel, haven't been brutally attacked by terrorists, and aren't actively battling terrorists and other terrorist nations and/or groups in the region.
Let’s look at this from a different angle, while agreeing that all civilian casualties are a tragedy.
UN rule of thumb
Combatants : Civilians
1 : 9
Gaza
1 : 1.2
1 : 2
(Depends on the interpretation of the Gaza Health Ministry figures which are questionable.)
Conclusions - take your pick;
Gaza Health Ministry wildly wrong.
IDF avoiding civilian casualties.
2 states: state of prosperity and state of unrest.
Labor setting themselves up for another Voice caning. Their closed minds never learn😂😂😂😂
What does the Palestinian Military Outfit look like??
Same as Hamas blackie😂😂😂😂🎉
@@aaronaaron6569What does that outfit look like now hurry & prove your lie
@@aaronaaron6569Prove things lazy damn slave
@@aaronaaron6569Hopeless lazy uneducated proven it each time you avoid questions
@@Blackjack_Official same as before blackie😂😂😂😂
Who is the Military beside IDF in this region?
I have proven 8 people do not know
How I can present such responses as IGNORANT DEBT SLAVES it's evident when participating in fiction from Media via speculation & bring no real issues nor factual relevant information on anything
@@Blackjack_Official Hamas😂😂😂
Are you implying that we shouldn’t have fought IS either? They weren’t an official military, neither were the Viet Cong.
We should just let random groups with weapons do whatever they like because they aren’t technically a military if we were to go by your logic here…
She should be sacked along with her protected Muslim hate cohort.
Yes the death toll of Iraqi and Afghan men, women and children murdered by Australian soldiers was far too high also.
Piss off bot
Bot
Evidence?
Comments disappearing.
Someone replied …… .and it’s gone.
Who cares
Sky news in all it's versions deleting comments with strong facts and points.. try it .. welcome to the game of "democratic" media 👍
My comment just got deleted.. i said they keep deleting comments with strong facts and points 😂😂 omg
Hello .. happy new year 😂
What were the civilian casualtie estimates on ww1 and ww2. I will bey its higher then in the province of Palestine.
It was Israel that reneged on the ceasefire deal. Lawyers in the UN are referring to Israel's "genocidal acts in Gaza." It is not the first time Israel has carried out such abhorrent acts in Gaza and the trouble did not start on Oct7!
50 tunnels discovered under the Egypt-Gaza border. Hmmm.
...and the casualty list has been revised, downward for non-combatants, by a lot.
Tanya playing borh sides to keep her Super topped up.
Yeah we get it grub.
Seeding in Victoria different locations cannot speak for why it's happening due to censoring
Did you just give yourself a like 😆
@@WitchDoctor.933No I'm not like you a narcissist twisted deluded Debt Slave
@@WitchDoctor.933And can I like 4 times??? Why speculate to stir??? Why even speak???
@@WitchDoctor.933 4 accounts I think🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@aaronaaron6569Prove I have 4 accounts buddy I cannot make more than one account on any platform FACTS or shut up & do what I state head here for punishment due to lack of knowledge & stirring my mind due to unable to refute factual truth
Have they been able to find and rescue any more of the hostages?
The figures have been revised.. down to half.. isn't she aware of the reduced numbers n not mentioning the hamas numbers. The journalists shud be aware of the latest numbers update. Journalist are not full informed
BS BS &
more BS!
Golen Heights Syria illegal occupation by Israel?????
Blah blah blah😂😂😂
@@aaronaaron6569Because you don't know brainless slave see all you can do is stir scram drongo
@@aaronaaron6569If that link didn't stick go look it up you lazy brainless programmed Debt Slave
@@Blackjack_Official😂😂😂😂hahahahaha little blackie is cranky and offered. Oh no. .
Get your bla ck ass up here Cuz ... let's both play these games😂😂😂😂😂😂 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
@@aaronaaron6569 He won’t show, makes not of noise , but is afraid to show!
To bad