Trebuchet. EPIC FAIL? Not yet......
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 09. 2024
- I started this film meaning to tune my trebuchet to make it throw to the best of its potential - instead I saw how dangerous it really is and how close it must be to self destruction. I also test a camera dart with mixed results and what would have been the death of another GoPro....
So now I have to extend the arm to try and save my machine.
If you would like to support this channel, visiting my sites really helps as does signing up to the news letter on the websites, either one is fine.
Production replica weapons are available here todcutler.com
And T shirts and Merch todsworkshop.creator-spring.com
Custom pieces are available here todsworkshop.com
You and GoPro seem to have a love-hate relationship. Brilliant content as always.
Thanks and to be fair I love them, they hate me.
@@tods_workshop If Graham treated you the way you treat it/him/them, you'd hate it/him/them too...
@@tods_workshop I'm sure the company LOVES you, Todd! Certainly the shareholders do..
@@tods_workshop you need to get them to sponsor you :P
@@tods_workshop exactly... Hence... Love/hate relationship.. lol
hi tod.
you know how you hook the dart to the sling on your trebuchet , i think the war darts you showed last vid are suposed to be hooked on the barb of the dart just like you did here. could you try that in a video next? if you try it i suggest wipping the dart head on with some glue and thread. the diagram of the dart throwing stick and string is depicting that i think. try it out. also if you throw the war darts the way you were doing last vid you should wrap the string around the dart twice or thrice. this will impart spin on the dart giving it stability in flight ending your tumbling problems. i have been throwing spears and darts like this for years and works well or very well. hope this helps you miss your chickens :)
i love your channel and fine work tod. three thumbs up!
What I love about this channel is the quality of commentary like this - thank you. What really annoys me though is the very obvious parallel and that I didn't see this - again thank you. Absolutely it may work, so lets find out shall we?
Those wide angle shots are amazing, I can’t believe how well the first dart worked, well done sir.
Thanks and I was pleased but the second was a disaster - I will nail it eventually
@@tods_workshop more tail weight possibly... Or different release finger angle
@@tods_workshop Can you mount the GoPro on the tail section.? That would increase the chances of survival, or possibly use a parachute of some kind to at least get half of the footage of the flight and save the GoPro.! Where there is a will...
Titanium!
'Come to bed, darling.'
'Later, I've got to calibrate my trebuchet...'
Can't decide wether I want it to break or not. On the one hand its just a beatiful machine and a lot of work was put into it obviously. But then again, if it does break I have the sneaking suspicion that you'd go even bigger on the next one and thats always a good thing.
Plus, how often in your life do you think you'll get a chance to see an actual trebuchet tear itself apart?
Look up colin furzes trebuchet series if you want to see a massive one self destruct.
We've still got to consider the fact that trebuchet were considerable feats of engineering back in the days, and considerable engineering feats require precision, but most importantly, experience. They failed more times than you even tried, so it's only natural missteps happen, even if we got the tools to improve much much faster!
It's quite humbling to realize that the siege engines of history were made by the biggest nerds of their day, whose feats are difficult to replicate even with modern information.
Also centuries before the basic laws of motion we now learn in 9th grade, so was a loooot of trial and error
@@r3dp9 one thing to remember though, this machine was built by engineers in their spare time. Neither Tod nor and of the other crew are professional trebuchet makers, its all about calculations and trial and error, and he only has one trebuchet.
In medieval times though, the trebuchet-maker had one job - making trebs. He will have started learning how to make them from the age of seven or so, and will have been making trebs until the day he died. His father would have been a trebuchet maker all his life. His grandfather would have been a trebuchet maker all his life. His entire family would have existed purely for the purpose of one thing - making trebuchets. They all knew that if just one of their trebuchets failed in a battle, it would not be 'CZcams Gold', it would have been a one way trip to the gallows.
@@MollymaukT Do people not just inherently understand the laws of motion though?
@@Debbiebabe69 So there would have to be a constant demand on trebuchets for entire generations or the family would starve to death? That is unlikely, because the "trebuchet maker" could not choose his customers, he would make siege engines exclusively for his lord. I don't think, that such trebuchet dynasties existed.
It was a team effort. Medieval lords employed "thinkers", who where mathematicians, engineers, astronomers (or astrologers), architects and sometimes also artists. Those kept their knowledge secret, teaching mostly single students as their successor. If siege engines were needed, it was their responsibility, to come up with plans (from their own mind or from the knowledge of their former master). There were other people, who produced the parts and even other people, who assembled and operated those machines on the battle field.
That "every-time I messed around with the trajectory I made it worse" really hits close to home - when you try to improve things and they just deteriorate, so familiar...
I'd never heard of trebuchet darts before, really interesting
Another snippet from Mariano Taccola
@@tods_workshop How about flaming arrows from a trebuchet? :D
@@romaliop Don't make me link the Lindybeige flaming arrow vid.
@@tods_workshop Mariano wrote his work, totally unaware that in the future, more people than he ever met in his LIFE, would be interested, and studying the meanings in full colour, fidelity sound, and instant communication, across the worlds globe.
He would be STAGGERED.
What an epic series Todd. The energy of the trebuchet is awesome. Almost on par with your own energy when ‘loose’ the projectile.
Thanks and here is your very own customised one to cherish LOOOOOOOOOSE!
When you added the cage to the dart it moved the center of mass forward. You need the dart to be longer or the fins to be larger to compensate. Or start from scratch with all that in mind :P
You can prototype this - very loosely - with a scale model. Make a small analogue with the proportions you are testing, tape pennies to it or something till the COM is in the right place. Then tie a string to the COM and spin it around your head and see how much it tumbles. This will let you know if you're in the right ballpark.
Or you could, you know, do a lot of math. :P
There's also an issue with aerodynamics here. A front basket and cup system works well as a sacrifice, but it probably creates some significantly strange points where air is going to divert through and alter the trajectory. It wouldn't be historical in the slightest, but a thin plastic sheet/dome across the top might help alleviate some of the issues.
Did I just spot a Kerbal Space Program player here :D?
in any case great work, that everyone may enjoy that machine as long as possible!
I am in no hurry for the trebuchet series to be over. I can't wait to see how this whole thing evolves over time.
Here's an idea: Try a variety of "cluster munitions" ^^ I don't know how many plumbatae you have lying around, but I do wonder how many you could through from a trebuchet and how much they would disperse
You just hate GoPros, don't you?
@@mnk9073 Sometimes when you fail to hit the target, you have to realise that quantity has a quality all of it's own ;)
The treb we used in Caerphilly castle in the early 90ies shot concrete gate post tops that had a hole throu the middle . someone had the great idea of putting string on a cork so when they landed in the moat we could retrieve them .never did get them out so future divers might wonder who put the pile of concrete balls in the same place!
That sort of thing is always a bit tiresome. You do everything you can to solve the problem, but nobody ever gets round to the last 1%
I usually find the fails more fascinating than the successes. This is no different. I am no longer under the illusion that siege weapons are 'primitive'. Primitive in material, perhaps, but not in engineering or application.
I suspect a 'master' was amazing. Look up 'a master gunners handbook' for the depth of knowledge these guys had.
Matt Easton did a sword review that included footage of a "test until destruction". If this series turns out to be be something similar, that would really fantastic!
As always, great video!
Morning Todd, glad to see you doing the dirty work. Stay safe
I remember NOVA or some other PBS science/history show did some experiments with trebuchet's back in the early 00s. They had found that putting wheels on the trebuchet let it rock back and forth and dissipate the energy instead of the frame shaking itself apart. If I remember correctly, they did the experiment because of a manuscript illustration with wheels, and a historian involved thought that must have been an embellishment because they wouldn't cart trebuchets around between sieges, they'd build them on-site.
Yep, can’t remember the show but I’ve definitely seen something along those lines. It seemed a bit counter intuitive but having wheels on an un-anchored base did make a substantial difference to the performance and longevity of the trebuchet.
@@Oldtanktapper In modern artillery there often is a system for the barrel and breach to move back under spring pressure, not just to work the reloading system but also to dampen the recoil and stop the gun from chewing itself up.
They also help with the efficiency of the throw. With wheels the counter weight drops closer to vertical instead of in an arc, which transfers more energy to the throwing arm.
You should check out some of the more modern trebuchet designs that are optimized for efficiency. There are some really weird designs like floating axles that allow the counter weight to drop absolutely straight down.
I´ve also seen it! I think you mean this one: czcams.com/video/QVO8VznqMeQ/video.html
Its amazing to see, the trebuchet is huge and they built a wall section just to shoot at it!
Would love Todds thoughts on this, especially about the wheels.
@@KanaiIle Yes, that's it! I forgot Stacy Keach was the narrator.
As well as the angle, you want to release when the sling is in line with the arm. No idea how that can be tuned without messing up the angle at the same time. Projectile mass, counterweight mass, sling length and release pin seem like the 4 variables you can control to help with that.
There are just so many things to adjust I suspect you have to end up with "good enough"
I love your work ... that wonderful hinterland between madness and genius. I salute you, SIr!
Absolutely love this Tod, great stuff. I thought that the shot you did sideways on showed more like a 55 degree launch angle. Without seeing more footage from the first shots that it's hard to tell the original release angle, but I'm sure your adjustments increased the angle.
Quite possibly, but it is all old hat now that I have to lengthen the arm
@@tods_workshop Please make a video of the process of making the brace for the extension. It would be a treat to see how you plan and execute it.
Love the trebuchet videos man! Thanks for making them and keeping us along for the journey
Hell yeah! Don't give up! This is by far the most interesting piece of military history that we don't know enough on. Beautiful engineering. I can't wait to keep learning
It is the gift that keeps on giving, I just hope it survives long enough to get some real information out of
It's been said before by many folk, and will be said again. But..... I bloody love this channel!
Amazing how far we've progressed over the years,very clever this though back in the day.i love you videos my friend
Im so excited every time i watch any video in this Todd's catapult series. TY very much 😮😍
It is impossible not to love your heroic curiosity and effort to investigate. In the 19th century most inventions and scientific discoveries resulted from such efforts. Today you reveal realities hidden behind assumptions of institutional academia. And with such humility and good humour. Truly inspirational. ( Also, as a son of a blacksmith, I have to say the quality of workmanship on Tod cutler knives & etc. Is outstanding.)
Thanks - that is very kind and appreciated and I am just so privileged to be able to take the time to investigate and mess about with this stuff
You turned the trebuchet into a giant whip bow. Very nice!
I love this channel.
You and horsie knight guy are so super chill to watch.
When doing experiments, there are no failures, only results.
Mr Tod Cutler,
When the machines arise and revolt agaist their human masters,
(as is inevitable)
The gopros are coming for YOU!
Love your work.
This was really interesting, thank you very much 👍
I'm looking forward to more videos with this amazing piece of engineering.
I hope you and everyone here have a great weekend
Cheers from Denmark
Thanks and have a great weekend in Denmark too! I am off to the pub shortly for some of that legendary warm English beer.
Honestly , any kind of beer would do right now for me. I work as a butcher in a supermarket here and I've had a lot of coleagues down with Covid already in 2022. This is my first weekend off this year... I just want to sleep, after a beer or two that is 😆
I’d love to see this series continue for quite some time, especially trying to hit a specific target should be interesting. Nice film, Tod!
Few people in modern times will ever experience that moment of cold terror when they realize the trebuchet has launched the projectile straight up.
run.
3 times so far....And that is why you never stand behind them
Oh yes indeed, twice under the remnant walls at Berwick upon Tweed quite a few years ago as part of the displays associated with the anniversary of the Battle of Halidon Hill. It had been designed by the local museum curator and built in a local school. Let’s be charitable and describe it as slightly under specified and designed by eye rather than calculation. To be fair it did work fine a few times, (if somewhat prone to the shakes on release with the energy going into the machine rather than the release). The projectiles were overripe musk melons which would still have caused a lot of damage if we had not scattered very quickly and being splatted with rotting melon flesh was no fun at all. I learned a lot about safety radii, public protection and my agility that day…..
I love that you explain everything, I wish the mainstream TV (now youtube I guess? Or Magellan TV?) shows went into the mechanics like you do instead of the drama factor
"Absolute Rubbish" 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I love this channel! Keep up the great work Tod!
You could use one of your patented firebombs to fine tune the release angle. The smoke trail it leaves behind should show the angle of the projectile.
Very nice to be able to follow this project through ups and downs. Looking forward to seeing the next step!
Really enjoy how you try something, change something, try again, change it say the hell with it and put it all back to square one. BUT that is how you figure out how to make things better. I really hope you get the GoPro dart working as that would be epic film footage.
Finally! A step by step tutorial on how to tune my Trebuchet!
Wondering if you could throw something that will take a high refresh GPS sample to a data logger, that would let you try different settings and have the data points in 3d for height, angle (potentially an accelerometer etc as well would be interesting).
Make a nice Google earth fly through as well
"The length of the sling,
and the angle of the pin,
on the end of the arm"
This sounds like the beginning of an old, british drinking-song.. =)
Excellent video!!! Keep up the fantastic work!!!
Tod and Throwing Darts, name a more iconic duo.
Seeing a trebuchet destroy itself (as I'm sure the real things did occasionally) WOULD be some awfully unique CZcams, you gotta admit it!
Love seeing things not work easily - makes me feel so much better about my projects
Man I love this series! Keep up the awesome work!
Cheers!
If the trebuchet survives the modifications, might l suggest a fluro paint job on the projectiles. That will make them stand out more on the wide angle shoots. I'm enjoying these experiments with the trebuchet a lot.
Loving seeing these series of videos! Cool to see how it’s coming along
Talk to Mr. Brandt.
Set the rig on top of a single layer of rollers-cribbing, probably 10-foot segments of scrap telephone poles - you want the trebuchet base to roll smoothly forward and then back on the rollers.
That should reduce your torquing problem and limit the strain.
And I must comment on Tod's wardrobe, very Renaissance and surprisingly up to high fashion standards. Simultaneous sigh of a genius and, maybe, a polite unspoken request for patronage. I like and respect, as many other positive character traits. We all can learn something here. Plus, he has a destructive device to experiment with.
My hoodies that seem to get so much interest are a result of artificial fibres around lots of grinders and changing them just makes for more new holes faster
Fine tuning a Trebuchet can be tricky, alot of trials and mishaps but all worth it for a great shot.
Really shows why having the best engineer, a king could get, commanding and inspecting everything in relation to you war machines, would have been necessary on you war campaigns.
Building a successful trebuchet, would not be something you just slap together.
👕"Trebuchet: for when you absolutely, positively have to destroy every castle in the kingdom"👌🏻nice one, Tod👌🏻🤣
6:12 That rabbit/ pheasant must be thinking this is an unconventional hunting method.
The slower, full side-on view was so satisfying
So cool that you show when things fail. Now we can all watch thing ( hopefully) improve.
Its all part of the process, but just so slow because this thing is so darn big and its just me
lol Todd that documentary style voiceover was actually pretty fun.
Thanks- I do need practice though; harder than I thought
Oh look; I appear to be pleased! One of the best phrases I've heard recently.
My understanding is you want your bullet loosing at something like 35° above horizontal. I tried building a whipper at one point, and it's surprisingly difficult to nail down a precise tuning
Wow that was a lot of shaking. I sure hope that when it explodes under it's own power, no one gets hurt. Maybe start triggering it from a little bit further away?
You got to put wheels on the trebuchet. As they absorb the excessive energy. This will stop the weights from flying out and the shaking of the structure.
Just give it some thought.
Great series of Siege engines.
Can you imagine the force between the axles and the frame though?
@@Debbiebabe69
Surprisingly the wheels move back and forth absorbing the huge counter weight. The axles main problem is the whole weight of the trebuchet.
Gave that poor bunny at 6:10 a heart attack haha
Perhaps you could collaborate with Steve Mould? A switch and strobe on the arm and a pressure switch on the sling would be trackable on the screen and give precise angular measurements.
Wheels. Best thing I know to encourage a better transfer of energy from weight to projectile
Great video. Love the 101 as well :)
Hey bud love the videos!
Friendly feedback you mention a pin and adjusting it to change the angle of release. While I think I can assume what you meant I have zero idea what you actually meant. I’m not that smart but if I’m wondering figure others might be as well.
Ty for showing me your adventure regardless!
Phew - the trebuchet survived! That's the most important thing, wouldn't want to see Tod with a broken heart!
I'm loving this series. What other whacky historic tech can we get someone to hire Tod to make so he can get all excited playing with it?
Great series, thanks!
I love the Trebuchet Videos. It is really like a toy for men. Yes, this does sound stupid, but I can't find a better description. Just like building something with twigs in the woods and it works in the end doing whatever, yet it is adult and it is trying out physics, engineering, you name it. So much fun.
Thanks and part toy, part obligation on a cold January day when it needs mending
Tuning these can be frustrating. Modify hook, sling, or sling rope length separately as each affects throw distance in odd ways. Weight thrown and counterweight changes will affect everything else. Lashed up some for Scouts. Threw pumpkins, weighted exercise ball, and buckets of walnuts. Never had a failure myself but have witnessed a few. Scary.
@Todd maybe just try some drag-streamers attached to the back end of the dart?
I have wondered the same - would look cool too and much lighter
You probably need some sort of mechanism to smooth the deceleration of the go-pro when it hits the ground. Shocks, springs, etc. Another option that may help would be to have some sort of sacrificial part connecting the go-pro enclosure to the shaft or rest of the head. It would be much easier for it to survive if it weren’t for the entire mass of the dart shaft trying to shove its way through where the go-pro is. One option would be for the shaft to be attached to the head at a slanted section joined by a sacrificial part: the force of impact breaks the connection, and the shaft slides off the angled surface and hits beside the head and gopro. The other, probably more complicated option would be to have the go-pro ejected from the head and be deflected to the side to ideally roll laterally away from the point of impact. I’ll throw together some (bad) drawings. The second idea might work decently well the more I think about it, while being more easily reusable… and I also don’t have much knowledge on techniques using sacrificial parts.
Hi Scott, You are right about deceleration and if this were onto concrete I would agree, but damp soil will allow for an acceptable deceleration, but I think I will move toward a more disposable camera for this.
One thing that's fascinating about these videos, especially when things don't work like they were supposed to, is that it's in a very real sense recreating history before our eyes.
The engineers designing and testing ye olde trebuchets would have faced many of the same challenges you do, or at the very least tuning each individual trebuchet for the task at hand.
So not only do we get an insight into how a working trebuchet looks and sounds like, but we get an insight into the design process and what the challenges are. :)
Also, i love the attitude of "Trebuchet survived, projectile was rubbish - back to the drawing board." :)
Thanks and glad you like it and the idea is to show the process and so hopefully I am doing that
Love the landy 101 in the back.
You're also tuning your presentation as well as the machine as you go along. Soon, we'll be able to enjoy multiple wide angle and slow motion shots of a flaming GoPro dart, and I look forward to it.
good work. nice demonstration. what is the shooting distance? with a heavier counterweight? did you manage to get a movie with the gopro ?
Can you adjust the sling length until you find the best results, then adjust the pin separately until the best results or will those differences affect each other, so that if you change one you would have to change the other to maximum results?
You could, but they are interrelated. I have a suspicion that actually the difference in distance between a 40, 45 or 50 degree loose would be pretty minimal, so I think I have been getting a bit concerned with exactly what angle, and should be more concerned with making the thing last
@@tods_workshop doesnt a low angle shot give the trebuchets more time to accelerate which would make up for the less optimal ballistic trajectory?
@@tods_workshop One more thing to consider is wind - I've read that it's better to use a slightly lower trajectory for a headwind or crosswind, as the longer the projectile is in the air, the more time the wind has to affect distance and aim (and in a crosswind, preserving your aim means throwing into the wind a bit to compensate, so it can be considered as similar to a headwind in terms of distance.) Also, as wind resistance slows the projectile's forward speed more the longer it's in the air, the optimum should always be just a little lower than 45 degrees in calm weather, but never higher unless you have a strong tailwind (or unless you're trying to e.g. drop your shot just over a curtain wall, at which point you need more verticality close to the impact point - but that's a separate question.) :-)
Wheels probably act as a shock absorber, as well as the range being better.
Oh, the trebuchet is shaking itself to pieces? Because the leftover energy has no way to dissipate? Jeez, if only a million people had commented to tell you that you need to mount it on wheels to prevent that. You aren't going to move it anywhere, but that doesn't matter because the wheels are shock absorption, not transport. You're going to wear muddy ruts in the ground, unless you think with your medieval brain, just as good as a modern one, and put runner boards or paving stones under your wheels.
As long as I'm nitpicking... further/farther. You make further adjustments to the machine, to attempt to throw farther. You cannot throw further, it is a metaphorical distance while farther is physical distance.
That narrated section was pure gold. Probably the only possible improvement to your presentation style would be to leave out the audio and voice over your actions. "Oh look, I appear to be pleased." Brilliant.
Wonderful contraption and footage..........your jacket though..............:)
I do believe there is a point of diminishing returns on that counter weight.make it to heavy and it reduces efficiency after a set point
tod sometimes people use a hammer to bend the pin a bit to adjust fine aim.
Honestly, slinging stuff is cool; but the real interest for me is seeing a craftsman tweaking and refining his tools. Lovely little video and rather interesting too!
You need a quad bike to jet around the field quicker and a couple grunts to winch it unloaded while staking the impact site.
One giant dart is nice, but can you fire multiple plumbata?
Many put a bar with several hooks on the arm to have the bits seperat so they don't mess with one another
It will come, but first I have to make it safe
Cool
Who doesn’t want their own trebuchet, very handy for storming the castle!
Was just thinking drone footage - and well, if the drone takes a hit you will probably be the first to use a trebuchet as a surface to air weapon.
That is a nice idea and I did ask the drone pilot later that day about it and at £1800 for the drone I decided to be safe
I built a little 1.5 ft long trebuchet and even it is a blast to launch stuff from.
just to wonder. could it relate to frequencies, so that little changes doesnt actually hit the spot enough to do a better throw. anyway, im so hyped for all that ur gonna do with it!
i could be wrong but i think historic ones were some times on wheels to move them yes but also to take out some of the shock when used worth looking .into good video
Nice job! That was great!
G'day Tod,
Loving the trebuchet series. I see in the main arm of the trebuchet there are three other holes for the basket to connect to. Have you experimented with those, or would they just worsen the performance?
Beautiful woodworks, nice!
I would only adjust the pin angle to change the release. Sling length should stay the same. Best way from my experience.
You're awesome Todd. Keep it up!
Really enjoying this series, thank you.
Poor Graham, though. 😅
Hey Tod iof this Trebuchet destroys itself please make a crowdfunding campaign for a bigger Trebuchet. Can't live without Trebuchet.
Nice plan
Hi Tod, as regards release angles, could you put a sheet of cardboard (perhaps disk shaped) on one of the uprights, then have a magic marker at right angles to the arm, held onto the arm with a "holder" as the arm rotates, it traces a circle on the cardboard, now, have it set up with a very light line (fishing line ?) from the magic marker to the part of the sling that slides off the hook.....that way, when the sling releases, no more line on the cardboard....should then be simple to see where the release occures.... of course, with all your experience with cross bow triggers etc, my guess is you will come up with a better way to "disengage" the magic marker........
Possible idea for future video
Bowling balls are uniform in shape and size, but vary considerably in weight. Test how the trebuchet throws heavy, light and mid weight balls. Lighter should start faster but be more affected by air resistance then heavier balls.