Jubilee's Trans vs Conservative Video is WILD (Pt.2)
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 09. 2024
- Jubilee's Trans vs Conservative Video is WILD (Pt.2)
Watch part 1 here: • "Trans People Are DELU... 😁
Personal Links:
Link To Donate: / samanthalux
Instagram: / _samanthalux
Twitter: / _samanthalux
TikTok: / _samanthalux_
Honestly these little Jubilee conferences are the fakest, most performative thing ever. The point of these conversations should be to meet a middle ground between the two but the moderator never really does that. They just let both parties ping pong their beliefs back at each other and go home. They left the debate feeling the exact same way they did when they came into it, so what was the point ?
i think sadly debattes nowadays are more for entertainment then actually finding any meaningful middle ground
@Ville Your mother cares
I don't think they have any chance of coming to a middle ground anyway
@Ville why’re you mad? because trans people exist?
reddit replies larp
As someone who was born female at birth I was always considered "manly" because of my shoulders, hands, feet and voice especially since I'm shorter then the average female, people really need to understand that woman are not all petite and fragile or things like that. Just like men aren't all strong.
@@PodreyJenkin138 except that's a societal beauty standard constructed by men. It was seen to be a woman if you had more body weight and bigger b00bs to feed kids (seen as a good potential mother) back in the day and petite women were looked down upon back then... So these images you created in your head is irrelevant because if someone identities as a woman, then they are. So now cis tom boyish women aren't women now?
Seriously. I’m a cis man. When I was in highschool I was getting bullied by a bigger jock guy. My cis female friend caught him pushing me and grabbed him by the neck, slammed him up against the fence (with one hand) and told him never to come near me again. This was a guy who was captain of the hockey team. She was a shorter, bigger girl yet she whooped this guys ass
Another example. My best friends sister was bullying him. I stood up to her and she kicked my ass. Yet according to conservatives as a cis man I have a biological advantage over her. Me (at the time) a 150 lb bean pole at 5’9 and her 250lb stacked at 6’.
@@AngelDRose I'm a trans woman who is 5'4 so HA! I got you beat lol As far as the weight thing, I need to lose some of that though
@@jonnaking3054 🏆
So sick of people hiding behind religion, who think the first amendment = they can dehumanize people and call it Jesus.
Same tho
It works the same way in reverse - Freedom of religion and speech = Homo-theology.
Jesus was the scapegoat that died for humanities sins, like the LGBTI+ minority is the scapegoat in heteronormative culture, and the black sheep in plenty of patriarchal heteronormative families living in heteronormative and patriarchy cultures.
Like Satan is the black sheep of the divine family mythology.
The binary of monotheism needs the antagonist/nemesis as the black sheep, and scapegoat of the mistakes of the supreme sky daddy.
Monotheism rose from henotheism which came from polytheism. And the Abrahamic faiths are not the first nor the oldest monotheistic religions / cultures. But then you need to know and understand what you are talking about.
I studied theologies. You need to understand what you are up against.
Jesus was not straight, he got killed for going against those with power (High priest, temple cleansing) and being not straight, Judas kiss, in a garden outside the city walls with naked men running around. Cruising didn't change in our sub-culture. Pasha custom/traditions and prisoners, why he got "betrayed" at that time - so the custom was a way out for the hailed messiah of the people. But they failed him, Jesus Barabbas a killer got that - in Jewish traditions homosexuality was a greater sin than killing. Allies that leave you hanging dry.
Philia vs Phobia - still the struggle we have today.
Like language evolution there is religious evolution - they are not hiding behind religion but ignorance and a history of power (abuse).
Also there are the mythology aspects, more than historic aspects - there are so many readings of what it means.
Esoteric, occults, sub/secret societies. Just pain history - humanity and the struggle for autonomy / human rights.
Call them out for what they are - false prophets and the goats, not the sheeple of Jesus. Freedom of speech, freedom of religion.
Also sick of the Jesus people pretending to give two figs about science, nature, and logic to dunk on trans people. It's like, bro, there's more evidence to substantiate and validate people's gender identities than there is to support your belief in *and* particular interpretation of the Bible.
It's quite funny how I learn more from comments than from school (the comments in this comment section)
@@dinosaysrawr I agree, however not fully. Most Jesus people do pretend to also give two figs about science, nature and logic. Agree there is more evidence for gender identities than the support of an all mighty invisible sky daddy, duh! But if the theology points out this sky daddy is a concept, I have not problem using logical and scientific supported interpretations.
I understand how it came to be, what is can entail. Like how the bible came to be, not a god writing it but people, etc. It being written and translated, and re-translated, and updated, and the linguistics updated over times etc.
Elohim is plural thus gods, The bible states the gods created adm, man is ish in Hebrew. We know early Judaism wasn't monotheistic, but henotheistic.
We know Emperor Constantine created the Roman Catholic Christian religion, by merging other popular religions into a new one. Sol invictus and others. A scientific approach on religion. Like we do with evolution of language and linguistics, Indo-European roots, same goes for the evolution of religion/cultures.
It is clear you also have your biases on what religion is or isn't and a monolithic view on all its diversities.
As a biological female who has VERY HIGH LEVELS of testosterone in my body, when I was in high school, I was one of the best weight lifters in my entire class, even when compared to men. My squat was 160lbs and my bench and deadlift were both 140lbs. I was also just... absolutely terrible at sports. I was horrific. I have asthma. You would not want me on your team.
Message of this anecdote: There is more that goes into whether or not you are good at sports than just if you're biologically female or not ❤️
trust me, as a biological male, with low levels of testosterone in my body, I still have way more testosterone than you. Also, that's your particular highschool... that didn't mean you could dominate most highschool boys in the world and in fact it would be nothing close. also, woman mature a lot faster than men. High school is NOT your peak level of strength. You are a fool
That doesn't explain why biological men are GENERALLY a lot better at sports but ok
@OfficiallyTrust Issues true
@@juantronftw I said it was an anecdote lol I know sharing my personal experience isn't "factual evidence."
@@officiallytrustissues5411 I agree! It's pretty dumb to gender physicality.
I bet Jubilee could do “Racists vs POC” and the comments would defend the racists saying “iT’s JuSt ThEiR oPiNiOn!1!1!1!1!1!1!”
Fr 😂
That’s the major flaw of middle ground. Jubilee pits people defending their right to exist against people who are against their existence, and then expect them to find a middle ground???
Yeah, these videos are so gross to me because it presents the two sides equally as though being a bigot is a totally legitimate position to have. Like when they had flat earthers and cosmologists on like yeah this is totally a position we should take seriously, maybe we could have some kind of understanding between scientists and lunatics.
I have an anegdote about this. I remember in the 1st year of my uni some dude said that all of us girls wish to be r*ped by immigrants. And I said, obviously, that he's just extremely fucked up for saying that. Then some w o m e n in my class defended him saying he has the right to his opinion
They literally made a video between religous people ( Christians, Jews, and Muslims and other religions ) vs Satanists. I agree that racist vs POC's is a absolute braindead thing to debate on, but making religous people that belive in good moral ideas vs Satanists who believe in evil behavior is not a good idea. There is no middle ground between worshiping a god or believing in reincarnation which are good things, and worshiping the embodiment of evil.
"Gender identity sexual orientation non of that matters to a God that loves all"
THAT'S WHATI'M SAYING!!!!!!!!
@Ville you have 2 brain cells btw. There are 2 sexes and a gender spectrum as gender is the persons deeply held inner feelings of what gender they feel within themselves.
@Ville_x Gender ≠ sex (gender is not the same as sex/gender doesn't equal sex) and there are 3 sexes: female, male, and intersex, and there are many, many genders :)
Not tryna be rude btw lmao
@Ville haha 😝
@Ville_x welp, idk how to help you there mate 💀-
(Bro screw grammar 😭)
@Ville_x oh damn it did- I just saw that lmao (I thought it was another that got deleted lmfao)
Personally, I find the whole "big differences between the sexes" is funny, because who do you think we are? Cutout cookies? There are so many different types of body types, and they overlook that.
@@PodreyJenkin138 yeah but sex scientifically just isn't binary. You can be a "certain body size" and have higher testosterone levels than your sex "should have" and etc etc. There's so many variations that a person can be outwardly and on the inside that it really is a silly argument. Plus, what about intersex people?
@@PodreyJenkin138 Male and female are sexes. Man and woman are genders. There aren't only 2 sexes in existence.
Not to mention.. you can have a biological advantage as a cis woman over other cis women. But we don't gatekeep sports that way because it doesn't make much sense..
I mean, who would win in a casual game of one-on-one basketball: Danny DeVito or Gwendoline Christie?
@@dinosaysrawr lol, I bet many people would pay to see that 😂
Anybody that uses the Religion argument against Trans People really needs a lesson on how Religious Freedom works.
I’m a Christian and you don’t even need religion to explain that the trans ideology is wrong. To reproduce, you need a biological man, and a biological woman
In the juiblee video someone said that 60-70% of ppl grow out of GD. But everything iv read says the opposite that you don't grow out of it. So where the hell did she get that statistic.
There was a study that said children who experience gender dysphoria grow out of it similar to those rates but if you actually look at the study there was a clear difference in trans kids and kids who just didnt like being a boy and if it persisted to early puberty less than 1 percent will grow out of it on average
It's like one study and the person referencing it and using it to support their opinion is overlooking a lot of what the study found/was.
The study that says that is *really* wack. They classify 1/4 of their subject pool who didn’t respond when contacted again as having “desisted”, which is obviously an absurd thing to do in a scientific study. They also seem to have a poor subject pool in the first place with many not even fitting requirements to be seen as trans in the first place, so their “desistance” isnt even what it claims to be.
@@ChespinCraft exactly
@@johnmatthews4717 bullshit. give me your supposed source, bud
One of the things that kills me about so many of these Jubilee videos is that the conservatives on the panel aren’t just random people. They are usually part of some conservative political group or think tank so they come armed with all the talking points and media training that the other regular people on the panels don’t have. They’re ready to come on and dominate the conversation and spread their nasty propaganda, not have any kind of honest discourse.
Conservative "debate" = Astroturfed performance art. As long as they are algorithmically "popular", platforms gonna platform.
Glad many others are starting to notice that too, I got blocked from their channel for saying similar things and pointing out how some females can hold misogynistic/ patriarchal views and how misogyny also affects trans women too.
All you said was that the conservatives were more prepared. But if you are going to come on a debate, you should be prepared. Also I don’t think the panel was necessarily uneven in people that were educated and made good arguments. From my perspective there was 1 trans woman and 1 conservative woman that made valid arguments and seemed to know what they were talking about. The rest on both sides made flaky claims that showed a lack of thought in their arguments.
@@byerika The OP said _nothing_ about one side being more prepared. They said one side was more media savvy which is different.
You can prepare and study all you want but if you're not accustomed to speaking in public you may stumble over your words or not be able to explain your point clearly and all that preparation was for naught.
Dominate lol, they were intimidated by that goliath gender dysphoric man
24:35 when you talk about "a lot of men too" it meant a lot. As a man who's been a SA victim, it's nice to see it being acknowledged because it's not often talked about. I also agree, a lot of Trans and Cis women face the same issues, and it makes no sense why they can't support one another. I'm not trans, and TBH I can't say I fully can even understand the concept properly (though between you and Sam Collins I have a better understanding) because I'm cisgendered and I know I can never fully put myself in that mindset, but as a gay guy I know how it feels to get hatred for something you can't change. I know how shitty it feels when all you want to do is live your best life and others put you down for it. I'll always support trans, LGBT+, and anyone else's rights because in the end of the day, why not? If a person wants to transition it doesn't affect my life in any way. It doesn't change anything about me or my personality. And if it's what makes someone happier, if that how they feel their life is the best, then I see no reason to have a problem with that. I just don't know why people can't just grow up and realize that everyone deserves the right to be happy and live their life in the way that makes them have the best quality of life
Thanks you! -trans girl teen
Very well said! I'm sorry to hear that you're a victim of SA. Unfortunately I am too, and as Samantha said, a lot of people are which SUCKS. But atleast we can suffer together I guess. It's nice to know you aren't alone in a shitty situation. - a bisexual teen.
@@MHS-ql7ee what does that even mean
@@MHS-ql7ee wtf is that
@@jennatransgirl “you’re trauma isn’t as important as mine” is a toxic mindset to have. I was SA just as much As anyone regardless of gender identity and that’s the point I was trying to make. Was that it was nice to see ALL victims included. We’ve all been through the same tragedy, and we should all be there to support one another. No one SA victim has had it the worst because we’ve all been through the same struggle and we should all be there to support one another. We can’t compare trauma because we don’t know the extent of everyone’s individual trauma. We don’t know every last detail that everyone went through. So it’s important to support other going through similar situations. To understand other POVs on the situation can how we can help everyone, not just ourselves. I hope that made sense
“Male wingspan male handsize” bruh, some women are taller than me with bigger hands and wider wingspans. Are they not allowed to enter women’s sports?
@Say No To Dieversity and there will be men who are smaller and weaker
Not after they’re on hrt, no they aren’t 😂
If this was a major problem, it would reflect in the results.
Have a good day/life fam
@Say No To Dieversity LOL who?
@Say No To Dieversity LOL. I liked this comment because it was funny.
You’re factually wrong and that was a bold statement
There still biological women.
What is with Amala? Young people with gender dysphoria aren’t “blindly affirmed.” Determining whether or not medical intervention is necessary is an extensive process. Doctors aren’t handing out hormones to any kid who says they feel like a different gender for the first time.
My friend needed a letter from a mental health professional to get top surgery in their mid-twenties. Even adults can’t just walk in to a clinic and get life-changing medical treatment. It is a deeper consideration than that.
What's with her is that she's a professional far right propagandist. As in its literally her job that she does for a living. She works for Prager.
Also, she'd pitch a fit if a health professional didn't "blindly affirm" her various beliefs and desires with regards to herself. If a therapist started using intense Socratic questioning to evaluate the veracity of her cishet identity and the origin of those "beliefs," she deffo would not appreciate that!
Depending on the state you live in, it can be as easy as one phone call with planned parent hood to start hormones. Some states are more strict, yes, but I believe she’s referring to the states that don’t have as many safe guards. I’d encourage you to look into the policies in other states!
@Ville_xthen get it
These terfs are infuriating. im a cis het dude that has osteoporosis and very poor bone density and muscle mass due to liver disease (I got a life saving transplant on Christmas Eve. But even now I only weigh 138 pounds at 6 foot 3”). So does this bigtime think that I’m less of a dude?!?
They are not TERFS and we should stop calling every transphobic woman a TERF.
TERFS are trans exclusionary radical feminist. Although radical feminism is inherently transphobic. Make no mistake, radical feminist who call themselves "trans inclusionary" mean that they include TRANSMEN and any AFAB "trans identified" people, in other words they reduce afabs to being female and still hate transwomen..
The women in this video are conservatives. Conservatives are almost always anti feminist or at the very least won't call themselves feminist. The Prager U woman in this video, is certainly NOT a feminist and definitely not a radfem since Prager U is very anti feminist.
@@johnmatthews4717 If it's relevant to the topic they do.
@@johnmatthews4717 nice dudes can and do use those labels, your worldview is obsolete
I do agree with you, but these women arent terfs. They are tran misogynists.
There were no TERFs in this video. None of the transphobes were pretending to be feminists.
I read the title “Jubilee vs Trans”, and that may as well be the case.
fr 😭😭😭
Like i wouldn't say Jubilee and the people that run it are inherently transphobic or hateful (I'm gonna guess it's mostly ran by left leaning people) but it's gross that they go out of their way to prop up hateful bigots and poorly moderate these videos for the same of being "neutral"
@@sarahenchanted i just think they chose the wrong questions and people possibly
@@millaaaaa I think it is more than a possibility when you chose professional media people/debaters from conservative institutions, I would like to see these conservative women up against some intelligent trans women who debate professionally and obviously you are right Jubilee do frame things the wrong way.
@@sarahenchanted whatever their individual beliefs are the content they create is obviously designed to prioritise clicks and outrage over decently moderated discussions that actually change opinions or find their way to a middle ground.
You are stronger than I am to react to all of this. I may have to follow this up with a Heartstopper palate cleanser. Thank you for having these discussions about stuff like this.
Trans women have been allowed to compete in women’s events in the Olympics since like 2004.
Number of gold medals won by trans women since then = 0
Number of silver medals won by trans women since then = 0
Number of bronze medals won by trans women since then = 0
Number of trans women who EVEN QUALIFIED = 1
Yup, we’re out here dominating.
But muh spoooooorts 😰😰😱😱😱
These people complaining don’t even watch women’s sports 😂
One of my 12th grade students in Texas has to play on the girls tennis team as a trans man despite having been on t for quite a while. He has a beard ffs! The state says that F on his birth certifcate is the only thing that matters. Conservatives are the ones making boys compete on girls teams.
Now that's just plain out stupid in my opinion-
And making trans men use the Women's Room. Speaking of making people uncomfortable.
Making trans men use woman locker rooms and bathrooms. Yes that will make cis woman very comfortable.
@@realMacMadame right??? these conservatives are idiots they act like trans people don’t look like the gender they identify with. how would you feel if a trans man bio woman came into a woman’s bathroom and had a huge beard and was a big muscly dude with a masculine face 😂 it’s ridiculous their logic is so flawed. same with a woman like samantha going into a man’s bathroom it wouldn’t make sense at all
@@realMacMadameyet conservatives still say they dont want men in womens spaces
This intro was so chaotic I love it 💀😭💅
@Ville they said that they loved it?
@Ville apparently the 29 people that liked my comment. Plus it’s a comment section, I can do what I want (within reason)
“Your toe hair is longer than the average female so obviously you’re going to be significantly better at Olympic underwater basket weaving!😡”
Honestly I wish that was an Olympic sport lol… it sounds dope as hell
one of the conservative women is amala ekpunobi, who is...interesting. and its so weird seeing the conservatives being people who have platforms on youtube and the trans people are just day to day people. it made me sad when people were saying the trans black woman was rude when no one was really listening to her. and religion and politics shouldnt be together, you cant say something nasty and hide behind Jesus, when if you LITERALLY read the bible all of the homosexuality is talking about grooming because men would groom young boys into their religions and their sexual rituals and things like that and God loves everyone, no matter what, and He made you to be gay and trans. They use it as an excuse to be hateful
While I disagree with a lot of what Gina said, I did so deeply relate to how she talked about her struggles not wanting to be transgender. It doesn't matter what you try or how much you try to be Cis, it doesn't change who you are, and we have tried everything over the course of over a century exploring the issue. Gender affirming care is the most effective to help people who are transgender, as well as those who turn out not to be transgender find that out and deal with their issues as well.
I am glad I finally was able to accept myself and I am legitimately happy with myself for the first time.
@Ville okay? So if someone needs another procedure to live a happier life, should they be denied it?
okay truscum
@@brendanfarnham2869 The best treatment for people with issues is just that. That doesn't mean anyone's identity is invalid without it. Thankfully there are people that are able to accept themselves and just be without any intervention, therapy or other medical intervention. I just relate to Gina in the fact I was not one of those people and I needed the outside help. I do not gatekeep who is transgender or not based on struggles, procedures, or other superficial reasons.
I appreciate your commentary on these horrendous "debates". Feminism has always been hated and attacked. In fighting hurts us more. My feminism includes Trans Women ❤️
as A trans woman Ily
As a queer Christian, I hate how people use religion to justify bigotry.
its literally built into your religion
or wait lemme guess, the old testament genocides aren't relevant because something something jesus old law, right?
those very-hated male shrine prostitutes, identifying effeminate males as sinful/unholy, that's just, noise introduced translation, right???
fellow queer Christian here. its disgusting to watch these people put us down and honestly makes me ashamed to be a Christian sometimes
I'm sorry but it's not possible to be a queer Christian.
@@rs4208 bro if you are against queer people why are you even on this video, seeking out comments to reply to
@@lukas.andrew Simply taking a look, that is all... I wasn't seeking comments to reply to. I like to see what people are saying on the complete opposite side to my beliefs.
Concerning trans women athletes I was on the fence about the subject until I heard a trans woman athlete say that she feels more disadvantaged. It is because she transitioned as an adult and had basically a male sized body with the extra bone structure etc. But now she no longer has the testosterone to drive that body. She feels like a truck in which a four stoke engine has been installed. I had never considered that before.
@Ville no they dont they mean trans women
@Ville_x your transphobic comments are not welcome here. Stop spewing your hate speech.
@Ville and I mean get your nipples strapped to a car battery.
Yeah but estrogen helps conserve your bone density, and there bigger lung capacity, wing span, bone structure, etc.
Everything in life has a cost. Sometimes it’s not one you can see easily
It's ~interesting~ to me that people who complain about trans women in sports never mention sports where having more body mass, being taller is a disadvantage. Like in figure skating, where jumps are generally easier for shorter, more petite people. Even male skaters tend to be on the shorter side when compared to men in general. Still, assigned sex at birth alone doesn't determine how tall etc you are, people are different. And sports are already not fair because some people are just better at some sports due to their biology (like you need to be tall to professionally play basketball and so on). HOWEVER biology alone doesn't determine everything like nobody is a successful athlete because of their bone density.
Also anti trans stuff often targets recreational sports, sports for children where it's not about being an athlete, winning scholarships or anything it's just people having a hobby or being on a school team. It's really sad and no matter how much they talk about fairness, this ain't it.
I also think it should be up to the organizations and professionals of each sport to determine criteria about trans people competing. Which they already are, as trans people in sports aren't a new thing. And it's a small percentage of athletes so people who talk about trans women dominating sports are clearly lying or listen to people who are.
Speaking of figure skating, Canada has just announced that Pair and Dance events will be between two people, not necessarily a man and a woman.
wanna know something? men are stronger and faster naturally, we got bigger lungs and more to our advantages, and when you try to put a women in mens sport your ust asking to lose lol women should be in their own sports and men in their own sports,
@@mariomario820 the only reason we even have women's sports is because women started beating men and the men couldn't handle it. Try again.
@@realMacMadame your joking right? Please tell me your joking...
@@mariomario820 You're
as a cis woman, hearing these transph0bes say stuff like "[trans women] have higher bone densities! and bigger hands! and whatever the fxck else" makes me feel so uncomfortable and i think dysphoric tbh?? i used to be insecure about stuff like my literal normal sized hands just cos they arent like small and ""girly"" and it's because of these people. the fact they can make a cis person dysphoric should be proof enough how wrong they are
@mrmattyplay02 uh
The exact opposite is true when that girl says that rape has become so bad bc of sexual liberation, it’s much more likely someone who has a lot of shame revolving their sex life will assault someone than someone who is sexually liberated and therefore fulfilled/wouldn’t need to do something like that, to say it’s the peoples fault who are more comfortable going home w someone is LITERALLY victim blaming; THATS disgusting.
And that's not even the worst victim-blaming I've seen related to this Jubilee video. Check out what the person in this video says at after about 53 minutes of the video. She says she's not saying that men have the right put their hands on women, but that women need to stop dressing in ways that put them at higher risk of tempting men. I called her out on it and she basically claimed that she wasn't saying that women are inviting assault but that women's shouldn't dress in ways that could invite danger. I haven't a clue how she could say she isn't saying that women are inviting assault
czcams.com/video/hGT4oWW-uiY/video.html
@@technoloverish the reactor?
@@technoloverish it makes me sad that so many women have ingrained misogyny and hatred towards women in them, they’re harming themselves and others. i think actually the rates of internalised misogyny are really high for women you wouldn’t expect it to be so high, same rates as men actually
I actually was on an episode of Dr. Phil recently with Amala (the bible thumper lol), and I can say that she and the other women who represented the right side kept interrupting and attacking (not discussing, not arguing, they were attacking) the 2 left side representatives on the "stage". They wouldn't even let them talk and it got so bad that Dr. Phil had to cut them off in order to be able to go onto commercial break. During the break, they even still talked and were trying to keep the argument going. It was supposed to be a debate, but it turned into a war scene. I even commented on camera relating what they were saying to the LGBTQ+ community experience and feeling safe having teachers who supported us (it was being talked about at the time), and they immediately tried to manipulate what I said to their side and I was just screaming in my head, "THAT'S NOT WHAT I SAID!". You could tell they weren't there to have a discussion...
@Justin the other girl was doing most of it, but she was NOT helping the situation at all...
Most of humans dont want to have a conversation. Its way too difficult for them to accept the fluidity of our world. A voice is not to be believed but to be understood
Amala is an atheist/agnostic (her own words lmao)
Aliya was the Bible thumper.
@@byerika yes. She’s not religious she was not the bible thumper
A lot of cisgender people experience dysphoria as well. Cisgender boys and men often experience dysphoria when they have gynecomastia, to the point that we have gender-affirming surgeries for them. Those are completely normalized, even though it is the same procedure that transgender men receive for the same purpose.
@Ville_x I don't think they made any mistakes, so I'm pretty sure its normalized and not normal /nm
@Ville So your argument is an appeal to normality? If your argument is because something is more "normal" that it is necessarily better, then that is logically fallacious.
@Ville_x So, a man having tits is normal? Good to know.
If I were a super-villain, I'd use a giant ray to induce gender dysphoria in everybody on the planet for 72 hours, just for fun. I think it'd be a nice educational experience for most of the planet.
@@dinosaysrawr devious but genius indeed
the lady named Amala actually works for PragerU and has a video were she shames plus-size people
doesnt surprise me
I'm not sure where you are getting that inference from. She's never shamed any chubby/plus-size people. She simply said that obesity is unhealthy lol... which is true.
@@PodreyJenkin138 depending on how you use the label fat for someone, they may or may not mind. The problem is, is when you are using it as an attack on this person, when you don’t even know them personally. The words that are used are usually considered more polite than just saying “fat.” People who are overweight aren’t just “lazy.” They could be unable to exercise, perhaps due to injury or a physical condition they may have. Even mental. Maybe their body just processes food differently? Perhaps they have diabetes or some other kind of problem with their blood sugar. Or even medications that they ((HAVE)) to take? Have you not considered those as possibilities? Or do you not see them as people who all have different lives, just like you do?
@@fenggula7890 It's not "true" though. Being obese can increase your risk of certain diseases but, if you don't, have any of those diseases you aren't unhealthy just because you are obese. If she had said that obesity *can* be unhealthy, that would be true.
Not surprised
"If I think I'm fat from body dysmorphia, that doesn't mean I need to lose weight"
okay but my gender dysphoria reminds me I have breasts that I don't want and don't align with my identity; are they just an illusion? do I actually have a male body but my dysphoria is making me think otherwise? no? then stop comparing body dysmorphia with gender dysphoria 😑
(youtube pls comment this under the right video this time sjskh)
If people have body dysmorphia especially if it leads to an eating disorder, they can get treatment. They get the best treatment that science can give them. It's the same if you have gender dysphoria. It gets treated. And in neither case is the treatment to say "you don't accept reality so get over yourselves" like that one girl tried to imply is how gender dysphoria should be treated.
@@antiwoke310 ignoring the opinions of experts in favor of your own feelings is delusional
NO EXACTLY ! ive experienced and still do experience both. the body dysmorphia is my brain lying to me about a) the size of my body and b) the size that i should be. the gender dysphoria is my brain saying "this real, tangible part of your body doesnt align with your gender, its uncomfortable."
I keep praying that LGBT people will be more supported by those who claim religion. especially as a Christian myself, I find it so disturbing when I see people use religion as a crutch to put others down or advocate for restricting basic human liberty. and also, I have never once heard a convincing argument for it being sin anyway. and even if it was sin, and was outlawed on that basis, to be consistent, we would have to go after all medications and procedures and accessories that change how a person looks or functions "naturally", like painted faces, painted nails, hair color, hair pieces, braces, wigs, penis enlargement, breast augmentation, botox, viagra, ... the list could be long, it's a slippery slope. but I think most people would agree outlawing those things would obviously be unethical and a severe overreach of government. additionally, sin or not, I find it incredibly hypocritical to ask for religious liberty to practice how I wish, but then try to take another's right to live and practice their life how they wish(whether I agree or not), as long as they hurt nobody else, obviously.
tell me if your a real christian do you know about sodom and gamora?
@@mariomario820 I believe the sins of Sodom were spelled out pretty well in Ezekiel 16:49 KJV, and it was nothing to do with being LGBT. it was "pride, fulness of bread, and abundance of idleness"... and they also did not "strengthen the hand of the poor and needy". so basically it was pride, gluttony, sloth, and greed not helping the poor and needy. taking it as written does not support the way most people twist it. and again, even if it was sin, I find it incredibly hypocritical to ask for religious liberty to practice how I wish, but then try to take another's right to live and practice their life how they wish(whether I agree or not), as long as they hurt nobody else, obviously. so as a Christian, and at least trying to be a decent human being, I would not stoop so low as to advocate for the destruction of basic human liberty.
@@linaraepaksa it was not only that,because if it was only pridfullnes then every city would be destroyed
@@linaraepaksa there was much more to it
finally a normal religious person who doesn’t use their religion to hate minorities ❤
I love when I hear transphobs say these talking points to me personally because they have NO clue who they are talking to.
I was put on spirolactin(to bring in estorgen) and metphormin (control "excess" hair growth and block testosterone, is usually given to males as a hormone blocker)
I am a cis woman and I stopped after a year, got on those again, and stopped. I felt alot weaker and I quite like how the testosterone makes me gain muscle doing less at the gym lmao. I was also going thru a version of male and female puberty (a couple periods a year, filled in curves, facial hair, breast growth)
The body is so wild its hard to put everyone in a category.
I don’t understand, what are you biologically?
@@The_Top_J they said they are a "cis woman", someone who the doctor presumed to be a reproductively functional female of the species at birth and they currently still identify with the associated social role. The "biological" label is not very useful in edge cases, as you can for example have XY chromosomes and still be able to birth children with 0 medical interventions -- what would you call a person like that?
@@tjrgwnfktwbag XX’s can give birth. XY’s cannot. Go back to school
@@tjrgwnfktwbag a medical malfunction
A mistake in the non binary just like how humans are born without legs or hands or autistic
My cis sister is taller than me, has bigger hands and feet than me, and is a hell of a lot stronger than me. I'm a trans woman. So... I don't deserve a chance at sports because of that (I don't even like sports just fyi)?
Two of my cis sisters are way more athletic and taller than I. I wouldn't even get the thought of attempting to beat them at anything
I think you meant cister 😎👌.
I'm an AFAB trans man, my height is 5'3 my wingspan is 5'7, I would have been like that if I was a cis woman, yet I really don't think that gives my unfit ass much of an advantage in sport even if my knees didn't dislocate in a calm breeze.
@Ville_x man*
@Ville you're obsessed
I feel you as a tiny AFAB masc nb person
@@PGOuma what
@Ville_x tf 💀?
“Twist Gods design?”
Okay, as a non-believer, I try to be fair to everyone’s beliefs, but I already know I’m going to regret listening to that woman. Better get some aspirin. Maybe whiskey.
I’m a Christian, so I believe God created a man and a woman because we balance each other out, but since you are a non-believer, you don’t believe that. However, nature intended there to be a man and a woman to reproduce. It’s how this race continues to live and thrive
@@bjroo Female and a male, also trans people can still reproduce 💀
@@bjroo there is no god. stop forcing your beliefs on other people 😂 the universe created us. and that is MY opinion. just like how you think god existing is your OPINION
@@bjroo nature also invented mental illnesses and gender dysphoria are you going to ignore that as well? and don’t act like humans have been thriving we live in an awful world and depression rates are really high
@@Ava-nf2qq
The universe created you? So then you assume that universe have some sort of intelligence? However be, humans do have intelligence quotient and are really complexly made. Which would assume that it had to come from a more intelligent and more complex source...
I'm trying to tell you that if you believe the universe created you, then that is your God. The universe. With a mind of its own and with its own complexity and design much higher than ours. At the end of the day we all believe in a God. Not the same God, but we all believe in a God.
What you said in the beginning about it being "off balance" is absolutely correct! In many of Jubilee's videos which are styled like this for the more right wing/conservative side they tend to pick people who are actual right wing pundits or talking heads who have much more experience debating in this manner. Even when they are saying total BS (which is everything they say) they know how to deflect counter arguments very well unfortunately. Jubilee should be ashamed of themselves and their videos are anything but "equal middle ground."
So maybe the trans community needs to start choosing activists who can actually debate and make logical points rather than ones who make total clowns of themselves and the rest of us like the non-binary couple that went on Dr. Phil to debate Matt Walsh. But i'm sure my opinion would be considered ableist and classist.
@@dr-ozone The trans community doesn't pick people for Jubilee videos, Jubilee does.
@@chaosspawn5491 I understand that, but the trans community selects activists, of which Jubilee picks for their videos.
@@dr-ozone Jubilee goes out of it's way to stack the deck against trans people mate. Thy aren't going to pick the activists, even if they, which they do, because they would actively push back against jubilees biases, and Jubilee doesn't want that. Jubilee is status quo propaganda. That's why they favour Conservative/reactionary rhetoric so much.
@@dr-ozone No they don't. Trans people decide to be activists on their own for various reasons, although one of them is usually bevause of all the people who act like they'd rather they not exist. Just because Dennis Prager picked Amala to be able to say racist shit about black people, women, and young people while claiming it's not bigoted nonsense because shes acting against her own long term self interest doesn't mean some random minority group does.
the trans sports question is so weird, its a way to make trans peoplw feel less like what they identify as.
When you go on hormone blockers, your athletic ability will go down.
But this also makes it seems like they think all men are good at sports, its a stereotype for sure.
@Ville suck a cactus
sports should be weight classed or something in my opinion, I'm a cis woman and I'm just under six feet tall, and I'm larger than a lot of cis men. You shouldn't be bound to your assigned sex at birth because there's so much variety in people, this would open opportunities up for trans and cis people who don't fit the male or female ideal for that sport! much love Samantha, great video!
I love how she shoots down the thing about statistics like they don't matter, but then throws it back at her like statistics only matter when they're in her favor. Like, no. Either give some actual facts based on research, or just shut up. At this point we all know all you're doing is making assumptions based off nothing.
Hey girl. I’m 27, a freshly out trans woman & 6 months into my transition, and I just discovered you and your channel last week. Leaving a comment here because I’m not on social media, and I’d really like to express the connection and hope and light you and your stories and reaction videos have given me. I recognize that right now I’m one of 1,000 comments on this particular video alone, but somehow you’ve managed to help me feel and see how special and safe I am being me. I live in a relatively small town, and in a lot of instances I’m the first and only trans person folks here know or have met, and you, your channel and story sharing are one of my rare instances of connection to a sense of community and belonging that my heart and soul deeply need. Thank you for being authentic, for being educated, for being open minded, and passionate. You have a light, a bright one, and I wish you only continued and great Love experienced in that Light radiating out from you.
Blessings,
CJ
WHY 👏🏻 ARE 👏🏻 WE 👏🏻 ASKING 👏🏻 TRANS WOMEN 👏🏻 TO ANSWER 👏🏻 FOR 👏🏻 THE PREDATORY BEHAVIOR 👏🏻 OF 👏🏻 PREDATORY MEN 👏🏻
like, the two groups are not related. it makes my blood boil. trans women are not the villains.
Exactly, transgender people are not villains at all
7:00 no one tell amala that the “slippery slope” she was talking about is a type of logical fallacy, basically meaning it’s an illogical argument
"We're talking about data that's overwhelming" BUT YOU AIN'T GOT NO DATA 😂🤣
I despise Alama with a passion I talk to her once over Snapchat she refuses to admit when shes wrong and gets angry when you call her out sis is trying to be the next Candace Owens
She does not have Snapchat. Nice try tho
@AQW Romio she did at one point I didn't say it was recently
This was a while back and she's only gotten worse tbh
@@aqwromio5107 lmao stfu pick me
During a family holiday in 2003 my cousin (male) and I couldn't lift the battery my uncle needed for his sailboat. He came and lifted it by himself and carried it in. So 2 men are not capable of doing together what 1 other/older man did by himself. Embarrassing facts, but it doesn't change the fact of the matter - individuals are different. We had other talents than lifting a battery.
Any argument that brings religion into a discussion is automatically invalid, unless it’s a discussion about religion
Samantha dresses her videos up in a glorious sheen of cuteness and glam but they cut through politically like no others. She is a genius and literally saving lives with her analysis.
Samantha, Truly is a genius.
@@rhymerlegend2717 Don't be so sad Crymer Leg End, trans people will defeat the transphobes.
nobodys sad lol, its just hilarious looking at clowns like the youtuber
@@supamarx5782 Hi I’m a “transphobe” and would just like to point out how the left calls conservatives faschists but your name is “Supa Marx.” If you don’t know what I’m referring to, I’m referring to Karl Marx, the founder of faschism/communism. Trans people mutilate their bodies and that is something to cry about.
I love your comments on Trans Sports. They are spot on and in total alignment with my own. The only difference is that I am actually in the game - I am participating in them. (Cycling) It pisses me off that people express their opinions who don't have any skin in the game. They don't watch them or participate in them, or take the time to really educate themselves on the real science behind the issues (you have, obviously)...but still feel compelled to replicate misguided myths. Society has been whitewashed to believe that Women's sports are like watching second string male athletes - which is complete bullshit. Anyone who participates in them see's this first hand. We are treated like an obligation at some events, with almost no advertisement at all. This is where the real struggle of women sports is; equality and challenging those long embedded myths. The transgender participation issues are a smoke screen to distract away from the real issues - look at Megan Rapinoe's cause for equal pay, or the issue with equipment at the women's NCAA final a couple years ago. Those are the real problems - not trans participation. There's simply not enough of us (trans) participating to make any significant difference. Oh, and don't get me started on shit like bone density. That makes your bones heavier, but HRT gives you less muscle to move them around - so in reality, this is a disadvantage is just about every sport. And where it may help, (Like weight lifting), it doesn't seem to be holding back any cis-women - so I call bullshit on that one...and people are not thinking it through to its conclusion. Most trans people are a mix of physical attributes. We are not breaking any female size standards anywhere. (I'm tall, but my hands and feet are small - a direct disadvantage for basketball - which is why I sucked at that sport even though people try to force me into it due to my size.) We are all on a spectrum. (BTW - Brittany Griner (cis-woman) is taller than me, but has the hands and feet to match!)
Oh, I could go on and on with my opinions on all of it, but I think you do such a good job of it, I can't add anything more. Therefore, I will stop here and just say thank you for putting out these videos! Love you!
I have body dysmorphia. Surgery isn't going to help me to not hate my body. Ill hate it no matter what I look like. I know this because of working on myself and looking within. Thats why Trans people go through therapy. Just to make sure they aren't misdiagnosed
Love you Samantha love the content you make
I am a cis woman and an athlete and pretty much everything the conservative women in this video said about sports is wrong.
My sport is triathlon. In this sport, it is generally recognized that people get slower as they get older and men are in general faster than women so in the non-professional categories we compete with people who are in our age group and gender. (i.e., my current age group is 65-69 women so those are the only ones I have to beat to get on the podium.) That doesn't mean I haven't beaten men or people younger than me. Of course, I have. Heck, one of the best women triathletes of all time finished in a time that have come in 8th in the men's event at her last World Championships so she beat about 42 other men professionals that day.
That's because athletic performance isn't about who has the strongest bones, biggest wingspan, or even the biggest muscles. All of these physical factors combine with mental factors in complex ways. People with bigger bones might have smaller lung capacity while someone with bigger muscles may find that they need to lose some of the muscle to get faster because being lighter can make you run faster. Also as I mentioned above, women have physical advantages when it comes to endurance sports so a trans woman might actually be at a disadvantage to a cis woman in a 100-mile running event.
Plus many people haven't got the mental strength to push through all the discomfort that comes with doing things like swimming 2.4 miles, biking 112 miles, and running a marathon all in under 17 hours. (That's the Ironman distance -- there are shorter distances too.) People in great shape have DNFed because they freaked out in the swim. Sometimes the fittest guy crashes on the bike or doesn't manage their nutrition properly so end up stuck in a porta-potty or hooked up to an IV instead of finishing.
That's how it works in triathlon but every sport has these sorts of complex interactions. Think of a football player who is strong and can tackle people but can't keep track of the plays so ends up in the wrong part of the field too often so his team loses. Or someone who can dribble a basketball like no one's business but is too short to be able to get past the guards.
Personally, I have no issues competing against a trans woman and, if one beat me, I would just think I need to work harder and get into better shape. These vocal cis female athletes who are whining about being beaten by trans women and suing people over it are poor sports IMO and need to grow up and stop being so entitled. They aren't entitled to win these events and aren't automatically more deserving of the win because they are cis.
Btw, USA Triathlon just added a non-binary category to every event including their National Championships and lets kids under 14 compete in the gender category they identify with--all they have to do is register ahead of time that this is their category. USAT has figured out that being inclusive brings more people into the sport which is the goal of all sporting organizations with any sense.
The only time I disagree with Samantha is on the point that transition should be a last resort only. This thinking inadvertently invalidates non dysphoric trans people who want to transition, and trans people like me who’s dysphoria isn’t debilitating. Someone should not have to be miserable all the time in order to be allowed to do what they want with their own body. To use my own experience, I would be denied top surgery because my dysphoria isn’t “bad enough” to warrant it, despite the fact that I would be happier without breasts. To me that is unfair. Trans people’s right to bodily autonomy should not be conditional on our suffering meeting a certain legitimacy quota. We shouldn’t have to prove that we need medical intervention, which defines transness by suffering, we should only have to want to transition sand believe it will make us happier. Our existence and right to our bodies should be defined by what affirms us and makes us happier, not by how terrible or lives are.
Love the necklace, it’s beautiful.
@Ville_x What? It’s a necklace, what is gross about it? Very strange.
@Ville you're the only gross one here
@Ville_x go away hater
When I watched this video for the first time on juiblee I said the same exact thing "who invited the bible thumper" when ppl use God as an arguement its bcs they dont hv anything intellgent to say. Imo you might as well not talk!
Amen! Im still wondering why the captivity of women in some countries is tolerated and enabled. We villanize North Korea for holding its citizens captive. Yet some country’s hold 50% of their population captive to male handlers. We went through all the trouble of gaining control of Afghanistan only to hand it back to the Taliban who immediately seized control over women like property removed their rights and its illegal for them to leave without male permission. Saudi Arabia will not allow women to leave without their male handlers permission. There are documentaries about adult Saudi women being seized in international airports and returned to Saudi Arabia like property. Wtf? Why is there such a blatant hypocrisy enabling patriarchy?
@Samantha Lux
You probably won't see this comment but your channel really has helped me cope ever since my state Utah passed SB16 & SB93. Thanks for the amazing content.
I just wonder how higher bone density is an advantage? Like yes, it makes you less prone to fractures, but that doesn't boost your performance? Can anyone help me understand?
Having a larger frame places you at a disadvantage if you then can't move that frame efficiently due to, say, cardiovascular issues, a lack of muscle mass, or insufficient oxygen intake, which of course transphobes don't realize or utterly disregard.
They're just employing MANS BIGS THEREFORES GOODS AT ALL SPORTS brain-dead logic, as near as I can tell.
@@dinosaysrawr right?
i hate how people will use the ‘but you don’t have the same struggles as *cis* women’ because when has that ever been relevant. there are so many women in the world and we ALL have different struggles.
I did have to wait around 6months to get HRT because of wait-list, but I didn't need to go to therapy or anything, I go to an informed consent clinic (:
Bruh the wait time in the UK is 4 years 😭
Meanwhile I got prescribed hormones my first meeting. And received the medication a week later. Sure I got lucky cause I am very happy as a woman but it’s dangerous to give them away so easily
@@Xxsorafan ya I got my prescription the same day. It's called informed consent, adults should be allowed to make that decision.
My thoughts on trans women in sports, even if it was unfair, so what? It's also unfair that trans women were denied puberty blockers. So just because a trans woman was denied early transition, this should dominate the rest of her life? Plus there are SO FEW trans women and even FEWER trans women who want to play sports, is it really gonna cause an imbalance even if trans women had an advantage?
Also what's next? If a trans woman who wasn't fortunate enough to have gotten puberty blockers was on a cruise and the boat started sinking, should she be allowed to evacuate onto the life boats with the other women and children? Or should she have to tough it out with the men since TECHNICALLY she went through the same puberty they did and she should be as tough as the men?
Just seems horrible that if you didn't get early transition you're just screwed, doesn't help a lot as far as gender dysphoria either constantly being reminded "You've been through male puberty, we can tell"
You know the one lady is watching Fox News, so glad you mentioned it
"I wouldn't want to go to an affirming therapist to tell me, 'Yes, you are obese and you should get skinnier.'"
That whole premise doesn't make sense. If you were to go to a medical professional regarding your obesity - surely you would want them to acknowledge that you are obese and work towards a happier and healthier lifestyle? So... like acknowledging you are trans and working towards medical and social transition to live a happier and healthier lifestyle?
When that lady said “oh I don’t actually care about sports rly bruv” i laughed so hard
As a "pre" trans lifter, I was 130lbs deadlifting 365. After two months of hrt I failed to lift 225... I was 24... I'm 25 now and just pulled 280.... as the woman I am now, If I reach 365 again its cause I worked 10 times as hard as the dude who lifts too heavy with bad form and cant seem to stop staring at me...
So if the bone mass/density stays the same, but muscle mass diminishes, aren't they at a disadvantage then? Having to lug around higher bone mass than the muscle mass is ideally suited for? It is all on individual levels, the blanked average statements are all fine and well for basics in understanding, but not the specifics. These are complicated issues on individual levels, but simplistic in the basics.
Hate is a Sin, Being trans isn't.
Amen to that💯🙏👏
Gurlllllll, we need an eyeliner tutorial 🔥
I wonder why they always go after trans women🤔 misogyny i guess.
This was about women's sports.
Conservatives are absolutely childish. Everything they spew is subject to the push back they get.
You literally have to forcefeed them information.
@Say No To Dieversity How is that Orwellian? Have you ever read his books?
@Say No To Dieversity You realize Orwell's writings are also propaganda right? The book was written with the purpose to denounce authoritarianism. So is 1984 also Orwellian by that logic? Or do you just not know what that word means and want to use it to sound smart? Also fun fact, calling something propaganda isn't an argument, propaganda is a morally neutral thing and any media pushing a viewpoint can fall under propaganda.
Damn, that was so pure and honest and on point😊😬💯👏
My gods, I got another transphobic ADF add on this
I don't really like the idea of "the same struggles make us women" because there are trans men facing these struggles. There are nonbinary people facing these struggles. I am an afab nonbinary person, I present very femme and I am constantly seen as a woman. Every struggle a cis woman has, I have too. And also I have extra struggles for being nonbinary. I don't get why it isn't enough to simply state the facts. We KNOW trans people are valid. We KNOW gender is not binary. Why is that not enough? It is so frustrating how governments decide based on science except for when Christians/cishet/white people dislike the facts. It is so tiring to hear them say "facts don't care about your feelings" when they only care about facts when they match their opinion. I absolutely am an advocate for stopping the struggle to fit into the cishet norm, stopping to care about them accepting us. We should just be who we are and fight institutions rather than cishets online. They won't ever accept us truly. We have to fight to make new generations understand that diversity is great and wonderful. And we need to build structures to protect us on the way there.
i love how the people concerned about people getting hurt dont really care about the trans people in the sports situation. What about trans men in cis men sports. They dont care about issues like that because it involves caring about a trans person
There have been studies done on bio women's athletic ability in sports compared to bio mens that determined that when bio women are put on teams with bio men, they will begin to preform at the same level of the men. We don't know enough about the biological differences between males and females to say that male bodies are always more athletic or stronger. In fact, in some cases the evidence shows the opposite- that females outperform males. Like with distance sports or anything requiring stamina, females have been shown to consistently outperform males. Female bodies are built to survive. They are much more resistant to disease, MUCH more likely to survive any kind of injury, and much quicker to recover then male bodies. We still do not understand why any of this is though. We don't really understand hormones or brain chemistry at all. We have SO MUCH more to learn. So I just think it's incredibly absurd that we've just taken at face value that bio women are weaker and will always loose in a fight against bio men. ALSO- bone density and brain size and all of that stuff is more closely associated to height then bio sex so I guess tall women aren't women?
In some sports, women are starting to win and beat men. This happens in endurance sports where people do things like run 100 miles in a day. Women's bodies are better suited for that kind of athletic effort.
I saw this quote the other day that was something like ‘god made trans people because true beauty comes from struggle’ I’m not religious but if I was… yes, just yea
So glad you pointed out the flaws in trans exclusion from sports based on the hormone variation within cisgender people!
If they set a measurable hormone parameter for competing in various sports, there will be cisgender people who fail to meet these average hormone specs, not just trans people taking hormones.
I am getting really sick of people, all people, not answering a question and instead using it as an excuse to say whatever dumb stuff they wanted to. Like the thoughts of the original asker don't matter.
Also, it might be better to switch from referencing "educational level" to referencing "done extensive scientific study". When dumb dumbs hear "uneducated" they think I'm calling them dumb when I really mean "this isn't a thing you are studying with real data and scientific methods".
Really those Conservatives have a really big problem with facts over their feelings! And ironically, they are the first complaining about us saying that fact doesn’t care about your feelings, when actually we bring the factual data, and conservatives only are basing their bigotry on their feelings only! How disingenuous, hypocritical, and bad faith, double standards given!
Nothing that conservatives say are "truths' or "facts" all they spew out are lies and conspiracy theories
But that is not the ultimate agenda, the extreme conservative right said they ideally would ban it all together.
Now they come with Swedish input - but Sweden is a social democratic culture, it is not banned, like the USA is trying to do. The cherry picking to fit their narrative is upsetting. In Sweden they get puberty blockers, and hormone therapy at the age of 18. Not 26 as Oklahoma is trying to do, etc.
afab enby here, My bone mass is 4.11kg at 5'7 and my brother and dad who are both taller than me have lower bone mass. Should I not be allowed to play sports with women who have smaller frames than me?
Honestly couldn't finish the last video, it made me too mad. So I feel like this is a "how long can you last" challenge 😅
"Twist GOD'S Design."
Don't wear Glasses, Contacts and Clothes. Don't drive Cars. Don't ride in Lifts. Don't use Stairs.
OMG I CANTTT how do they ALWAYSSS confuse dysphoria and DYSMORPHIA! they are NOT the same
The only people living by gods design are (imo) the Amish. I hate when people use that argument.
Do you cut/dye your hair? Have you painted your nails? Use man made materials or tools? Own a dog? Gotten a tattoo? Are you free to choose your own path in life as a woman?
With the sports thing, only trans woman in sports seems to be the issue that people argue over. There hardly anything if not nothing at all about trans men in sports because, by their logic, trans men will always lose so it isn’t an issue, it’s not unfair because men are biologically stronger so to have someone who, by their logic again, is at a disadvantage, it’s not an issue because it’s the trans mans choice to compete in forever losing competition, but when that’s flipped there is an uproar because suddenly cis woman are at the disadvantage. It really shows that trans people are so looked down on in the sports industry.
Another thing. Is a cis woman wins against a trans woman it’s just a woman beat a woman in a woman’s sport congrats, but if a trans woman beats a cis woman it’s cheering because she was born a man and is therefore stronger and is infiltrating woman’s sport and but the cos woman at an unfair advantage. It’s such bullshit
Yes, nobody are complaining about trans men are competing against cis men.
Cis woman here: I'm 5'10; my dad's side of the family are mostly pretty tall. I have naturally large hands and feet, larger even that most cis men that I know, because I'm tall, but am the LEAST athletic person I know. 😂
hoenstly samantha, i wish that u could be invited to these platforms, because u are so articulate and what you say is based on real arguments or let's say, better arguments. although i don't agree wirh everything 100% i would really love to see u on these platforms, representing trans people, btw ur content is really interesting and it makes me feel better that there's activists out there who speak up for us like u do
I'm was homeschooled all the way through and came from a very religious household. Didn't stop me from being gay and trans.
Oml I want to be in one of these videos bc I have a perfect argument for every one of these questions, especially being 5'1" and super skinny, I'm literally weaker than most people in general so it would throw miss conservative for a loop lol
Trans 5’1 and skinny too let’s gooo ❤️ literally poke holes in everything they say
"I have religious friends or whatever"
😂😂😂
When she talks about differences like bone density, wing span, and whatnot these are also differences we see in race. Black people have denser bones than Caucasians who have denser bones than Asians. Similar differences are seen in wing span. Really while 13% of the US is black over 70% of the NFL is black and over 80% of the NBA is black. Much more of a present "advantage" than is seen in the transgender community. This is still fair and unless you can unbiasedly apply this standard she is being hypocritical.
Exactly! If we follow this kind of logic to its natural conclusion, we'll be banning people of certain races and ethnicities from various events due to their "unfair" natural advantage. White supremacists would probably LOVE that.
I don’t know if it’s just me but the “no trans women in sports” arguments always seem to make cis women in sports out to be weak and demeaning. It reminds me of the idea that a large percentage (I think 60%?) of US men believed they could score a point against Serena Williams. These women in sports are not average women. They have their own advantages based on their biology (muscle composition, height, etc), and they’re usually specialized in their sport. To say that any trans woman is just automatically better than a cis woman at sports is kinda disrespectful to the cis women who have trained hard at their sport. It sees trans women as men and just assumed that cis women are going to lose no matter what
For some reason, I got a commercial for a concealable holster, where one of the lines was literally, "If you wanna wear a dress, if you're a female, it works for that too." BLEH. At first I thought it was for tools or something, like plumbing, but quickly found it was for a GUN. OMFG whyyyyyy.
Amala implies that Finland is supposed to be a good example of how to treat gender dysphoria all the while our current legislation requires trans people to literally show a certificate proving they're sterile before being able to legally change their gender but alright, sure, yea good example :)))))) I mean we are atm working to change that and it looks like that's gonna be changed but it wasn't a good system to begin with. And even then it feels like the government is doing the bare minimum because of "potential abuse factors" which are real but I don't think they're nearly as likely as our opposition parties feel. Finland is definitely a lot better than a lot of other countries about trans ppl but thank god we're finally trying to catch up to some level of legal acceptance :D
Swed here and i can confirm Sweden and Finland are really good trans friendly countries.
I would love to see you in a panel opposite BLAIR WHITE!!! U WOULD DRAG HER, EVER SLIGHTLY AND POLITELY 💁🏽♀️
I would not have blamed you for just leaving this at one part nor even be bothered by it.
This man is trying to disrespect this beautiful female
my wife was size 11.5 in mens shoes. She would walk right out of them now because her feet got so much smaller. Her hands are smaller. She is almost 3 inches shorter. I'm 5ft2 with arthritis and autoimmune issues, I could easily beat my 5ft9 wife in any strength activity now. I hate the "male body" bologna because my wife's body changed so much just with hormones.
how does she know her bone density didn't change? Did she weigh her bones?