2023 Audi RS 3 v Mercedes-AMG A 45 S Comparison | Which German giant-killer is the best hot hatch?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 15. 06. 2024
  • Which of these German giant-killers is the ultimate hot hatch? 👉 Full Review: www.carsales.com.au/editorial...
    Enormous power outputs and clever all-wheel drive systems make the new 2023 Audi RS 3 Sportback and Mercedes-AMG A 45 S the supercars of the hot hatch world.
    Both of these high-performance German hatchbacks also remain highly practical, so which is best and can any hot hatch really justify a six-figure price tag?
    Fast Forward
    00:00 Intro
    00:47 Pricing and specs
    02:26 Engine performance
    03:16 RS 3 Interior review
    05:09 A 45 Interior review
    06:54 Infotainment & safety
    07:08 Luggage space
    07:31 A 45 Road test
    10:15 RS 3 Road test
    12:38 Verdict
    Subscribe for the latest advice, reviews and comparison tests 👍
    czcams.com/users/carsales...
    STAY UP TO DATE & CONNECT WITH US AT
    carsales.com.au
    / carsales.com.au
    / carsales
    / carsalescomau
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------
    carsales- Everything you auto know
    Whatever badge on your bonnet, we want you to know, we love cars.🚗
    Shamelessly so.
    That’s why we pooled our decades of passion and know-how into one, easy to get to place.
    So for helpful advice, reviews, comparison tests and everything you auto know like subscribe to the official carsales CZcams channel today. czcams.com/users/carsales...
    #carsaleschannel #rs3 #a45
  • Auta a dopravní prostředky

Komentáře • 42

  • @GregMurnin
    @GregMurnin Před rokem +9

    Both great cars undoubtedly. I got the a45s 3 months ago and it's by far the easiest car I've ever driven. Can't go wrong with either car by the sound of things.

  • @steverobbo55
    @steverobbo55 Před rokem +1

    Great Video 👍👍

  • @Joobkl
    @Joobkl Před rokem +4

    Great review. I ended up getting S3 sportback. Value for money. Enough performance and great daily

  • @billshoe22191
    @billshoe22191 Před rokem +4

    I had much more fun with the A45 S on the track compared to the new RS3 but I can see the argument for it. Both great cars. The front bumper or lack there of on the Audi is a deal breaker to me though

  • @dh-ro6gh
    @dh-ro6gh Před rokem +6

    How does "best" hot hatch = cheaper to buy and service? It should be whichever one is the better at being a hot hatch.

    • @germanengineering204
      @germanengineering204 Před rokem +1

      RS3 is a better overall package, and better long term value to an owner! That was the conclusion of this review, and most others!

    • @dh-ro6gh
      @dh-ro6gh Před rokem

      @@germanengineering204 Its fine if you think it's the better package, but I would rather own the AMG. I rather be excited by sitting inside it and driving dynamics are more exciting. Since when was a VAG product long term ownership better than a Mercedes? In what way?

    • @germanengineering204
      @germanengineering204 Před rokem +1

      @@dh-ro6gh Resale value is the main reason! I like the Benz a lot as well considered buying one!👍

  • @davew5167
    @davew5167 Před rokem +6

    Excellent review. I've driven both, and they are both great cars. I bought the A45S because to me, it felt up on its toes and alive, very much like a real sports car. The RS3 felt less special, maybe more livable and better for every day driving, but who buys a car like either of these for everyday driving?!!!

    • @oggyoggy1299
      @oggyoggy1299 Před rokem +11

      Most people buy these for everyday driving.

    • @luciussander8217
      @luciussander8217 Před rokem +1

      I imagine everyone buys these cars as dailies! I owner, not drove, owned the Merc for almost 3 years and now have the RS3. My view is the exact opposite of yours. LOL. You can keep the hard seats and hairdryer of an engine.

    • @davew5167
      @davew5167 Před rokem

      @@luciussander8217 That's funny. You missed the bit that I own my A45S. You also confirmed my point that the RS3 is more comfortable. Incredible insight! As for the engine note, I've put a full akrapovic system on the A45 and it sounds amazing. Screams at the redline. Would be great if that was a factory solution though.

  • @luciussander8217
    @luciussander8217 Před rokem

    You can display two dials in RS individual. That's the display I have mine in.

  • @RichLion
    @RichLion Před rokem +3

    Once the ECU is unlocked on the 8Y, it will be a low 10sec car with a flash, e85, downpipe.

    • @Jays22b
      @Jays22b Před rokem

      e85 , now we talking. Got me stuffed why it was never allowed oem

  • @scottiewardle
    @scottiewardle Před 15 dny

    You didnt mention the gear shift change on the a45s is far superior and responsive than the rs3. Especially downshifting on command.

  • @luciussander8217
    @luciussander8217 Před rokem +1

    I owned the Merc for nearly 3 years and recently got the RS3 with RS pack and full carbon trim, after an 18 month wait I would add. The Merc, whilst being a great car, comes second in this contest. It was uncomfortable on longer journeys, sounded like a hair dryer and was a bit in your face for my liking. Whilst I liked the interior, my wife hated it. The Merc developed rattles as well and they were not easy to sort out. The biggest thing though is handling, the RS3 is way better and sounds better. Tech in the RS3 is better and you CAN display two dials in the virtual dash. The RS3 looks better too, albeit that's always going to be subjective I guess. I'm much happier with the Audi than the Merc and crucially it feels special, unlike the Merc. Only gripes with the RS3... the B&O is crap, it really is. OK, some of the plastics are cheap, but it is hard to spot them. Last thing, the drive modes are very glitchy - seems there are software issues, but a fix is coming. Nearly 2 years after the car was launched, come on Audi...

  • @jeffstryker1454
    @jeffstryker1454 Před rokem +1

    I think I like the Mercedes better and that interior is nice.

  • @Jays22b
    @Jays22b Před rokem +2

    audi r3 having different wheel sizes, Nah bad move, My amg a45 i rotate the tyre's easy. i got 2 spare tyre's already I can use on front or rear. In a country town, try having a blow out and replacing the tyre!!, I leave old tyre's at parent's in country localions . Audi , I'de have to leave 2 spare tyre's to differnet sizes.

  • @knight2425
    @knight2425 Před rokem +12

    Wait for the Hyundai fanboys to come on and tell us their Hyundai is better than both these cars

  • @fale892
    @fale892 Před rokem +1

    Spotto

    • @GlenKimpton
      @GlenKimpton Před 3 měsíci

      Hahaha you mean spotto spotto

  • @g.m3399
    @g.m3399 Před rokem

    Toyota Corolla GR / Yaris GR # 1

    • @dh-ro6gh
      @dh-ro6gh Před rokem +3

      Number 1 for what? Corolla interior and 1 less cylinder? Sorry, if I can spend the money on an A45S or RS3 hatch, I'm not picking a Corolla.

    • @luciussander8217
      @luciussander8217 Před rokem

      Girl's cars

    • @nickloborec1416
      @nickloborec1416 Před 10 měsíci

      @@luciussander8217 Couldn't agree more. My wife loves her rs3

  • @mvnorsel6354
    @mvnorsel6354 Před rokem

    Totally wasted on me I'm a slow driver. Still no harm to watch.

  • @jagayong9333
    @jagayong9333 Před rokem +2

    You must mean you’re 180cm tall, not 180km tall (4:50)

  • @skids4791
    @skids4791 Před rokem +7

    Audis interior is bland and boring as you can’t get the coloured stitching in the UK. The info system looks awful and old where as the Merc looks stunning inside. I looked at both and pic the. A45 up in 5 weeks. For me, easily the better car.

    • @luciussander8217
      @luciussander8217 Před rokem +2

      Good luck with that. I recently sold my A45S+ and now have my carbon sporback RS3, my God, WAY BETTER and then some!

    • @skids4791
      @skids4791 Před rokem

      @@luciussander8217 I’m sure the drive of the RS3 is incredible but I want more and I feel you get that in a Merc at the moment.
      Enjoy you car mate.

    • @angy97
      @angy97 Před 7 měsíci +1

      A45 big dial vents looks exaggerated and ugly, like RS3 dash

  • @rustygates3367
    @rustygates3367 Před rokem +2

    How did you get to the conclusion that the RS3 was better? You just boiled it all down to price... wtf? and the build/interior of the AMG is certainly better. Carwow did the better comparison...