Indian Classical vs Pop - Girish Karnad - In Memories - Sur Sangam Debate Scene

A memorable scene of Girish Karnad from Sur Sangam, where he takes on a group of young people and gave them a demonstration on Music and discuss Indian Classical & Pop Music.
Girish Karnad - In Memories

[@runooravi4881]

This clip should be made compulsory in all schools and all universities as a part of Cultural Studies. Proud of my heritage 🙏🙏 Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@pranavkumarchoudhary]

No word which can describe power of shastriya music...

[@chandrasekhar-B]

That's SPB for you..all versions of this clip. That rock song, thereafter Girish Karnad's version .

[@BTMDiaries]

Awesome! I remember I used to enjoy this debate as a kid, in original and Hindi version also.. thanks for sharing. Great tribute to the legend

[@ManojSharma-cx7gp]

अद्भुत संगीत

[@ishhaatt569]

Movie (pandit ji says) - all music is equal, we can’t decide what’s better. Comments - pop music is bad, classical is better. 🤦‍♀️

[@niteshacharya8723]

सुर ही जीवन हैं
जय शंकर 🙏🏻

[@RamBalak0123]

बाप - बाप होता है ।
बेटा - बेटा होता है ।।

[@vinayakanjarlekar3705]

Great girish karnadji
Sangit great

[@jaydash1925]

RIP ... #SPB sir🙏🙏🙏🙏💖💖💖💖

[@vineshcoonjul7618]

4:03 dialogue why bollywood of this generation does not understand this ......

[@PankajKumar-gv4cw]

Best scene and true message.

[@consortiumaqua4340]

Hindustani classical music is the best

[@voicingdreams573]

I love girish karnad

[@abhinavgoswami9556]

Dekhiye, maine classical seekha h aur ab m rock music krta hun, rock gaane ka ek alag temperament hota hai, vocal distortion, growl, belting, wagarah, ye sab seekhne m samay lgta hai, ek aisa vyakti jisne classical seekha h, wo distortion aise achanak se nahi kr skta use us cheez ka riyaz krna pdega, 6-7 mahine, tb jaake wo us cheez ko seekh payega, aur waise hi, ek rock vocalist, taanein wagarah nahi le payega, use us cheez ka riyaz krna pdega, dono apni jagah kathin bhi h aur aasaan bhi
Dusri baat ye hai ki pehle girish karnad ke character ne pop sangeet ka mazaak udaya, usko "cheekhna-chillana" bol ke, tab un logon ne shastriya sangeet ka mazaak udaya
Kya ek classical musician jazz kr skta h aise achanak se, the answer is NO!! Usi prakar jaise ek jazz musician achanak se classical nahi kr skta........
Kshama chahunga thoda lmba ho gaya, pr ye baat batana zaroori tha!!

[@arslanpower]

There is a thing bro a classical musician can pick any style with ease.. it won't be right away but much quicker.. but for jazz musician it would be a long journey to pick indian classical

[@abhinavgoswami9556]

@@arslanpower jazz musicians are very well trained and understand music to crazy depths.....i have seen jazz musicians nail classical music in just a few months. They understand modes....they are skilled at improvising.

[@arslanpower]

@@abhinavgoswami9556 classical music is not just about the Ragas.. it's about their proper treatment I highly doubt if a jazz musician would say proper taans and other ornaments much easily .. it would take him a long time to ace it.. even most classical musicians are more into semi classical than pure classical forms like dhrupad or khayal style..

[@abhinavgoswami9556]

@@arslanpower ya but those ornaments are embedded in ragas only.....jazz musicians understand mood, chalan, purvang, uttarang, note combinations and various other subtleties very well. Ragas are those moods, chalans and ornamentations. So I believe they are well equipped to ace classical music.

[@akashdhar9412]

Paschimi Sangeet per naachne wale yuvaon Ko Shastriya Sangeet Koi mahatva hi nahin Rakhta hai. Aise Logon per ek hi kahavat Lagu hoti hai, " Bandar Kya Jaane Adrak Ka Swad".

[@shivambharodiya7261]

@@alokraj468 तो फिर सोना जारी रखो।

[@zMukulSingh]

🙏❣️

[@Shambhavi1111]

Raag darbari ❤❤❤

[@sudhirpatil3706]

🙏🙏🙏

[@sarojcharanparhi5198]

😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣 Classical song me kuchh alaga hi bhaba hota hai isko sunne se Rongte khade ho jate hai . Classical song ki jay ho

[@manoramamannu235]

Sangit k sagar में Jo doob गया so doob gaya!..

[@suryakaroshi9178]

Inka dance💃 dekh kar hasiarahi he

[@Kattarsanatani1999]

2:05 onwards ye kya tha bhai🤣🤣

[@sapnapancholi7452]

Pop nahi paap lagta hai pop k sun ne se😂

[@alokraj468]

Kisne kaha?. Indian classical music mei rakha hi kya hai?.

[@ayushkumarmishra6011]

​@@alokraj468chit ki mnn aur aatma ki shanti sakhsat bhagwati maa saraswati ka vaash hain isme

[@alokraj468]

@@ayushkumarmishra6011 jisse kisi ko fayda nhi hota duniya mei. Jaake Michael Jackson ke gane sun. Usme bhagwan ka pooja se badhkar duniya ke problems ko btaya gya hai

[@zroth3734]

Copied from some movie I can't remember...
Shankaramanim or something

[@pavanjha]

Official Hindi Remake of Shankara Bharanam

[@zroth3734]

@@pavanjha thanks a lot

[@prasadnatu2492]

Telugu movie

[@sabrinarishikesh137]

Pop is the best! King of Pop Micheal Jackson! 👑

[@poonamsethiya7332]

Yes it is but people should not look down to classical music

[@alphabetsongs3665]

Pop is best but without indian classical musical it would never exist. The big buildings are like pop music and the bricks which are used to build the building are Indian classical music
😁

[@Bhadrudu]

POP only focuses on exciting nerves, while Indian classical soothes the mind. POP songs won't be remembered for long and easily will be forgotten. But Indian classical music songs are still there after thousands of years because they are divine.

[@kakalimukhopadhyay15yearsa48]

I also used to think that before .
But the feelings I feel after listening to Indian classical is unmatched .
Specially after listening to the songs of Kishore , Rafi , Manna and Mukesh .
My favourite ' Zindagi Kaisi hai Paheli ' , ' Zindagi ke safar mein ' , ' Kahin door jab din dhal jaye ' , ' Tu iss tarah se meri ' and ' ' O majhi re , apna kinara '

[@alokraj468]

Michael Jackson is best. Classical songs don't even motivate or give me goosebumps. Music is something that can change the feelings or can make you dance. And compared to pop classical musics are bad.