8:45- 50: He clarified the Kashmir issue in one go in front of an anchor who definitely didn't like it. 👏🏻 Also, the way he explained about the BOOK and the fear instilled because of that book and the past. His simple statements demolished intellectuals narrative. Amazing!! 👏🏻👏🏻 "Don't change the demographics."
There is no question of worshipping people. But if anyone is truthful, he could/should be appreciated. Also, as I find the statement logical, I agree with him. You may or may not find it relevant.
This is how intellectual people talk....not like most of the educated fools who just shouts and try to win debates😂....which we can see that in our ' great ' media
@@pretty948 yea..... Hurry spokes the truth without being diplomatic or any pretension because he don't need minority votes to run his house. But tharror needs to have them by their side. Intellectual is subjective for many he is just a useless guy with no leadership abilities and behave like a Victorian.
Prannay Roy is clearly uncomfortable with Sadhguru's clarity & tries to butt in unnecessary with some stupid remarks. Glad that Sadhguru handled it in mature manner.
YEAH THIS SAD GURU SAYS HE HAD A PAST LIFE IT SEEMS AND HIS WIFE DIDNT COMMIT SUICIDE BUT IT WAS "JAALA SAMADHI" AND THIS BASTARD CLAIMS HE WANTS TO PUT A SMILE ON EVERYONE'S FACE WHILE HAVING THE MOST UGLIEST FACE IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND AFTER GAUTAM BUDDHA
@@unitedbeast6614Sadguru the wife killer is talking peace and humanity.... not sure whether you are an Andhbhakt in its most pure form or struggling to acquire common sense.
Such an insightful discussion in the context of today's India, Sadhguru and Sashi Tharoor are assets of our country. Polar opposites but with a humane and civilized approach to such controversial respects.
No matter how old a person is saying a lie, it will remain a lie. Sadhguru has been a wanderer for a long time. He knows a lot. He speaks with high confidence. But, he confidently says the wrong things.
It seems that the debate is not between Sadhguru & tharoor but between anchor & Sadhguru.....Tharoor is listening peacefully but anchor has his preconceived notions about Sadhguru & he is trying to prove him wrong
if there is one loser of this debate, it is the worthless anchor who did not even understand a word what Sadguru said and might have lost his fees also because Sadguru did not let him touch even a little bit on sensitive issues which was set for.
This is possible what Sadguru was trying to imply throughout this debate. This shows Guru's clear conception of India while Sashi miserably failed to fathom it. This differentiate Sadguru from others who claim to be Mr. Know alls.
I have grown an enormous amount of respect for Sadhguru ji, after seeing this one. I can't express it in words. No one can handle and shut those Hyenas in the way he did. Absolutely calm and composed, and spewing out sense out of his mouth, in the most sincere and intellectual way one can 🙏🏻 God be with us 🙏🏻 Shiva shambho 🙏🏻
@@Joshi431-13 Seeing your subscription I can tell you are a bloody leftist and a commie who has been brainwashed to the core that it is never coming back.
He has such clarity. He has the capability to clearly distinguish one topic from another. Amazing to see how Pranoy Roy is throwing totally unrelated topics in between.
Pranoy wants to annoy the panelists particularly Sadguru by constantly beleaguering him with banal irrelevance. As a host, as to what he is trying to convey to the audience beats me. Annoy Roy might be a suitable appellation for him if he continues in this vein.
Shashi Tharoor is so poised, well educated and intelligent. Sadhguru is wise and calm too. But the anchor, dude made me uncomfortable sitting from my home looking into the screen. Quite weird.
Don't you see Shashi Tharoor hypocrisy? He says congress distorted history to make those early Islamic marauders look like heroes and call it nation building. An now he speaks completely contradictory here.
That is because Anchor was desperate to show that he is smarter and wiser than other debaters, and desperate for beef eating, although his grandfathers and forefathers might not have touched or smelled the beef, may be he thinks only by eating beef he can prove how smart he is
So basically Sadguru is saying that Dalits should never forget how Brahmins treated them. Dalits should not hate the contemporary Brahmin population, but should never forget !
India is democratic country... If Sadhguru say we should not forget history.. Numbers should not increase... Then what will Sadhguru say about Surdas history, lower caste demolition and injustice.
@@harivs7219 Not have three wives & 4-5 kids with each of them. That's what he meant, but you clearly didn't get it & you seem to support changing demographics by certain minorities.
I dont know what demographic change he is talking about.. Hindus produce as many muslims are there every 10 years. I dont know what they are afraid of.
Sadguru always comes across to me as someone that talks more than he makes sense.. there are times he makes sense, but the sense he makes is general sense and knowledge that others say and that others already know.. but unless he himself says it then it doesn't make as much sense, or the truth is not really known.
always enlightened by Sadhguru's wise points : Religion is foreign to India. Correct. India follows a dharma to accept all and does not limit to one set of rigid beliefs.
Actually there is not any static and rigid laws and beliefs in hinduism. Hinduism is a collection of several religions that were practiced by people of different ethnicities and creed in the subcontinent who had their own gods. Hinduism is so uncertain that anyone can change it by the needs of time it kept on being influenced by the beliefs of different tribes and creeds that came in contact with the subcontinent. If you will ask several hindoos a question they all will differ in their answers. Like if you ask some hindu regarding eating cow meat some may say its allowed to eat while some wont agree. Some may say there are 33 crore gods while some may say its monotheistic. Its just a sugarcoated khayali pulao with gets changed and remorphed with whats trending with time. Long before hinduism was said to be peaceloving and peaceful but now there is also a very warmongering and angry version of hinduism gaining popularity. In western world hinduisn is represented with a different image and hinduisms in the nation is totally different.
@@aliibrahim6407 actually it doesn't, do share if you find it any of the thousandssss of book you have read to interpret my relogion. As you said there aint any rigid laws, so please dont contradict yourself. Talk logic!!
I have grown up in and around Mazid walls, the things that are thought or preached now different, in remote places and villages the harmony is still there, i wish the harmony spreads across the country
Ha ha ... He is Pronoy Roy with Leftist ideology ... He tries to mould discussions in those direction ... Unfortunate for him Sadhguru turned him to a joke
If not gorgot after forget there is no meaning since the wound never cure if not forgot if wound not cured then we have to keep on scratch it it is not good for health.
@@akbarkazi1406 whatsapp university ka bahana mat banao....har cheez me whatsapp university ghusa dete ho.....facts pe baat kro......or agar whatsapp university ke alawa or koi bahana nhi ata to zahar kha ka jaan de do...lekin whatsapp university ka randi rona mt ro....whatsppp university ke nazayaz aulad....
So this youtube video is mostly filled with Hindutva supporters. No wonder Sadhguru is surely BJP stooge as well pretending not to have political stance...
@@vanessahargreaves528 same way journalist seems to be a Congress Stooge and pretending to not to have any bias. I think you must have surely observer that .
From the internal security perspective some amendments can be made in the IT act where spreading hate or criticizing the religion can be punishable offence. Spreading hate or mocking religion is at its peak during many Hindu festivals. If a different community is going to mock the religion of others then surely it will led to agitation between them
When this Sadguru cannot answer a question he will either talk over the person or say that we will come to that later. You know the word for people who love themselves .....
Sadhguru is technically right. But I guess the challenge for a country is presenting the truth of certain invasions without vilifying any community. Many Hindus feel the anger reading the history of temple destruction, forced conversions. And many Muslims feel like they are being incriminated for something they didn't do. I feel and understand for both of these and the solution I think is in the present and working towards the future of a united, prosperous India - being modern and yet sensitive to each others' culture.
Hindus dont hate Muslims for what their forefathers did. They hate the govt sponsoring Madrasas and fertilizing the same cycle, for covering up ethnic cleansing of Hindus in Kashmir, for giving special laws to Muslims that dont align with India, for not letting Hindus even legally claim temple lands that was unfairly taken from them, for giving waqf board most land in India only next to railways and defense, for politically perpetuating caste divide, or leaving Hindus with no rights in Pakistan, for allowing illegal immigation, missionary mafia and more. Otherwise Khans and Akhtars and Kalams have always had full support.
Muslim feels they are being discriminated for things they didn't do? Ask any Muslim how proud they are of the people who killed, raped and converted their ancestors. That's the reason for mistrust against them.
@@durgasisodiya4295 It's impossible to despise your point , some of these anchors are so blunt , they continue asking stupid doubts and opine with either side . But , gladly we have intellectuals like Shashi Tharoor and Sadhguru , who can think logically and are not kidnapped by their emotions and personal preferences . They ponder long about the problem, reflect their thoughts and give pragmatic solutions to most of them. By the way , I am a great fan of both of them!!🙏🙏
I am a Bangladeshi. Shahi Tharoor is one of my favorite Indian politician and writer. First time when I heard that he completed his PhD at the age of 21 I became wondered. He speaks unstoppably and show statistics how the British raj looted in Indian subcontinent. To mine he is an idol of India and a spokesman for minority communities in India like as Aurundhuti Roy. God bless him
The fact that the whole talk show/debate is happening in English makes me laugh even more. Also that I'm typing in the same lang😆. We people are hillarious, sacchi. P.s - I respect both the speakers (fyi).☺️
Britishers themselves suffered from their own class wars. Colonialism was classic case of crony capitalism!!! Few in UK benefitted from colonial loot and not general public. General public when got chance, voted for guy (Attlee) in 1944 and made him PM who promised freedom to India in his election manifesto
@@vanessahargreaves528 so the point here is , large group when given a chance/power chose compassion. Small group/individual when has unchecked power often turns narcissistic (Churchill/queen Victoria/ directors of east India company)
Bhai wo chale gye we are have but mugle khud to chale gye but jinko convert kiya tha wo yahi rh gye . Jo shashi tharoor bol rha h yaha rh gye muslim wo yaha nhi rhe wo sab convered h jo vi yaha h
Why its not like that ispite 0f what ever you do is your business ,just at least listen to each other accept what ever good both have. Its a type of learning.
Wonder if there is no believe system that human puts so much effort to seek for the answer or truth, then why is there need of path? when one can figure by his/her own doings rather believing in something that has meant nothing for him. And after all... doing all sorts of things in one's life why does one feels afraid of dying. Why is there a question where will I be or would go if I die.....!!! Anyways loved it and yes we must not forget what had happened and must not also keep in heart cause it can toxicate our mind. Peace and harmony that's what this world is in need of.
Sadhguru is getting bombarded with facts and true academic intellectuality. Sadhguru does not know history in detail as much as Shashi does and neither does he understand economics. He is more of a high-thought philosophical person.
@Ishan Nasnodkar 4453 watched it, Shashi was not specialized in certain topics, but Shashi did not give WRONG info, Sai had logic, but Sadhguru gives you wrong unscientific info. There is a huge difference. Sadhgurur was once saying he saw some people raising DEAD ALIVE. I am surprised educated people even take these Sadhus seriously. Sadhguru is just a bit more sophisticated version of Baba Ramdev, but not as learned as people think he is. He has answers for everything, I want to know if he did PhDs in all the topics he talks about .
@Ishan Nasnodkar 4453 You would say that because you are biased with your religious beliefs and patriotism. Sadhguru is not an academic person, he does not refer SOURCES, he does have specialization in any particular subject apart from meditation, philosophy, etc. but he pretends to be a JACK OF ALL CARDS - just a sophisticated version of a politician convincing people..
Why do journalists and politicians like Tharoor only discuss and debate with Hindu gurus? I rarely see them taking up Gurus from other communities with the same passion and put them under the same level of scrutiny.
@@themadraseye he also answered it. There is difference between religion and dharma. Go and catch an islamic scholar and debate with him. He will give you a taste of everything that is wrong with abrahamic religion
What's amazing about Shashi Tharoor?? Where ever he goes he tries to establish empathy and sympathy for the Muslims, and talking about his 'imaginary' islamophobia, and how loving and caring the Brutal Islamic rulers have been, he very strategically tries to manipulate the history to suit his agenda.
Idk why congress doesn't make guys like shashi tharoor their leaders they did same with bose and lohia and patel and doing same now I mean he is a true centrist who actually does respects and want to refine our culture
then same can be applied to caste issues and conflicts there were ugly things happened to oppressed castes, should they remember and keep always a doubt on oppressors castes??
@Cash Money Neither but the fact that you make such cheap commentary on religion highlights what a disgusting vile bitch you are. Your mother should be embarrassed to have you for a child.
@@neema843 Because it is a secular and diverse country . Perhaps you need refresher course in India's history and foundation and if you can't tolerate other religions ,get the fuck out of here.
@@neema843 I'm not a Christian but your words actually make me laugh because of how idiotic you are . Who the hell are you to comment on other people's religious choices ? I hope you consult a psychiatrist and get yourself checked maybe that will cure your stupidity but the hatred in your heart well that will always remain with you.
I can't understand this philosophy that we shouldn't forget the wrongs of the past but should forgive them. Forgetting or not remembering is an essential step towards forgiveness.
Sadguru is right.. we cannot forget the past. Thats why history books are written.. but can forgive the wrong doings of past generations. That itself is a big sacrifice of current generation.. by reading and remembering history, hopefully the current generation don’t allow aggression and brutal rule of others in india any more
@@Red.bulldozer3 The mogul emperors invading India and committing atrocities are past events that are unlikely to be repeated in the future as India has sophisticated defence capability against invasion of any kind. So, whats the big deal about not forgetting history? Japan has moved on from the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings by the USA and is the better of it for it- so should India move on from Islamic invasion and not be paranoid about a repeat of it as there are so many challenges facing the country that each one of us should focus our attention and energies on.
shashi taroor : arabs, they stayed and became us ". This is what some radicals wont understand. But thank god sashi taroor said it right. That's the quality of taroor
@@mrinmoybaidya6821 i think you should learn, unlearn, relearn few subjects. Before you think about arabs think about west! And think what they had done to us? After all these damages done to india, they simply said 'sorry'.!!!. History has turned upside down by them. So that they can blame arabs!!
Went through the comments. Most of them supported Tharoor and Sadguru. Respect to all the commenters who looked at the logic behind individual speaker and not taking one’s side. This is real india these are real Indians. 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Religion and rules books are different There should not be any restrictions on any living beings on this earth... because the mind cannot be controlled by others or himself/herself... and that is why there are no restrictions in our religion... only we have to understand what to do and what not to do, based on the results of others or ours...Very proud to be a Hindu...
How Mukesh Ambani led India's JIO make INDIA's first MAKE IN INDIA 5G
czcams.com/video/H6q9pHKIg7I/video.html
what the hell english
Sashi is seems to be student of Sadguru ji
Sadhguru is an utter rubbish.
Thank. Thank the. Hi hj. I. Jo. I. Johooho ooj. Pop. is. J oh no jojoba o. P. H
At the cost of lakhs of crores of rupees and at the cost of BSNL
That's what really educated man is....Sashi Tharoor didn't interrupt when Sadhguru was speaking...but the anchor did....
Pranoy sounds like Rahul Gandhi here!
Anchor seems highly prejudiced about sadguru
As he constantly trying to depict sadguru as a Hindu
@@aucklandrenalcare7345 superb observation.
Correct. Most of the Gurus are like this. They are afraid of people who are well educated.
When ask about what religion you believe, this Sad Guru says he doesn't have any religion 🤣🤣🤣🤣
This is called a real debate
Not like Indian news channel debate 😂
Great respect for both the legends
🙏🙏
Exactly bro. So crap just shouts and trashing on others
When Knowledge and Wisdom meet together
🥶🥶
Just go and watch Jaggi v Javed akhtar debate ..
His wisdom was exposed..
@@harshvardhan_012whether whatever exposed or not, one thing is clear, wisdom will never come to you
8:45- 50: He clarified the Kashmir issue in one go in front of an anchor who definitely didn't like it. 👏🏻
Also, the way he explained about the BOOK and the fear instilled because of that book and the past. His simple statements demolished intellectuals narrative. Amazing!! 👏🏻👏🏻
"Don't change the demographics."
Wow........you must be really easy to impress.
@@RakhiSingh-kj5ok And why are you hard to convince ?
@@stutipathak4602 well maybe because i don't worship people......just listen and think and you can find countless arguments against either side.......
There is no question of worshipping people. But if anyone is truthful, he could/should be appreciated.
Also, as I find the statement logical, I agree with him. You may or may not find it relevant.
@@RakhiSingh-kj5ok People like you make women community getting abused. You always simp for enemies.
This is how intellectual people talk....not like most of the educated fools who just shouts and try to win debates😂....which we can see that in our ' great ' media
Absolutely correct
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Btw what if he debate with Arnab Goswami who can win 😂
For this audience, this works.
For other audiences, and thick skinned people who hide behind niceties, only shouting works.
It's more about patience and mannerism as compared to education lol
Respect for both Shashi and Sadhguru. Different opinions but nice to watch different intellectuals have have deep conversations
Except for one of them isn't an intellectual
@@pretty948 yea..... Hurry spokes the truth without being diplomatic or any pretension because he don't need minority votes to run his house. But tharror needs to have them by their side. Intellectual is subjective for many he is just a useless guy with no leadership abilities and behave like a Victorian.
@@pam4840 I was referring to sad guru
@@pretty948 I mean he is but ok
@@pretty948 Y
Superb! Gentlemen to the core. It's a long time since I saw two people talking different views with such dignity.
Thoror gentleman 😂😂🤣🤣🤣 who wanted to change name of Diwali toh a muslim name .
Sashi is highly influenced by Gandhi's philosophy of appeasing minorities, He is Jr. Manishankar Aiyer
Prannay Roy is clearly uncomfortable with Sadhguru's clarity & tries to butt in unnecessary with some stupid remarks. Glad that Sadhguru handled it in mature manner.
YEAH THIS SAD GURU SAYS HE HAD A PAST LIFE IT SEEMS AND HIS WIFE DIDNT COMMIT SUICIDE BUT IT WAS "JAALA SAMADHI" AND THIS BASTARD CLAIMS HE WANTS TO PUT A SMILE ON EVERYONE'S FACE WHILE HAVING THE MOST UGLIEST FACE IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND AFTER GAUTAM BUDDHA
Sadguru is fake.
@@rafdjislampura6454 because he speaks truth and your not civilized enough to work for peaceful humanity
@@gautamraj6911 jeevantha samadhi was very common thing in eastern cultures for long. You first read our history
@@unitedbeast6614Sadguru the wife killer is talking peace and humanity.... not sure whether you are an Andhbhakt in its most pure form or struggling to acquire common sense.
Should people eat beef?
*"I Am not responsible for wrong food choices of people"*
That's how fools avoid answering 😁
Jerin Raju fools are those who eat beef
@@Rahul97115 homo sapiens survived till this age because of meat.Read some science instead of mythology.
@@xy1877 Homo Sapiens are evolved from Homonids who were veg. U read the science buddy
Nobody in world has right to decide what person should eat and what not . Your belief keep it to your dont impose on someone else
Such an insightful discussion in the context of today's India, Sadhguru and Sashi Tharoor are assets of our country. Polar opposites but with a humane and civilized approach to such controversial respects.
I really respect Shashi Tharoor Sir. He never gets bitter in conversations.
This is the true illustration of , "When elders are talking you shouldn't intervene."
That's very common in our Indian community, speaks of the culture...head strong, arrogance.
I hope Prannoy roy has read your statement...
Haha somewhat true but I guess as a journalist it's his job. And he was probably nervous...
No matter how old a person is saying a lie, it will remain a lie. Sadhguru has been a wanderer for a long time. He knows a lot. He speaks with high confidence. But, he confidently says the wrong things.
@@ra3jualaga45adi This is not called arrogance, this is called respect. If you don't know Indian culture, just learn it..
It seems that the debate is not between Sadhguru & tharoor but between anchor & Sadhguru.....Tharoor is listening peacefully but anchor has his preconceived notions about Sadhguru & he is trying to prove him wrong
….and the anchor is an idiot to boot
The anchor was claver he caught his mistakes
The anchor failed to prove sadhguru wrong.l.
if there is one loser of this debate, it is the worthless anchor who did not even understand a word what Sadguru said and might have lost his fees also because Sadguru did not let him touch even a little bit on sensitive issues which was set for.
@shafiq beig true ...it's great to hv pepl like u
One can see the difference... how Sadhguru ji behaves when someone else is speaking, and how others behave when Sadhguru is speaking his thing.
Please talk about the contents of the speeches.
Waah!! Its a delight to listen to two highly intelligent people discuss any issue at hand.
Such debated need to happen. Its not about what side you are. You get logics from both ends in a civilized manner.
Indian mathematician Guinness World Record video.
czcams.com/video/JifypC_frlc/video.html
Without NDTV anchors
@@jimmygeorge2102 like bharka Dutt the Butt
@@jimmygeorge2102 people who watch tv won't watch it as they watch for drama and fun ! Not for actual news
This is possible what Sadguru was trying to imply throughout this debate. This shows Guru's clear conception of India while Sashi miserably failed to fathom it. This differentiate Sadguru from others who claim to be Mr. Know alls.
Barely a debate between Sadhguru and Shashi - just a smart, respectful conversation here. Would like to hear them speak more often together
I have grown an enormous amount of respect for Sadhguru ji, after seeing this one. I can't express it in words. No one can handle and shut those Hyenas in the way he did. Absolutely calm and composed, and spewing out sense out of his mouth, in the most sincere and intellectual way one can 🙏🏻
God be with us 🙏🏻 Shiva shambho 🙏🏻
respect based on what? LOL
Hes a murderer
@@Joshi431-13 Seeing your subscription I can tell you are a bloody leftist and a commie who has been brainwashed to the core that it is never coming back.
@@Joshi431-13why don't you elaborate
This is a very respectful and peaceful debate. This is what a real debate looks like. They are focusing on the subject unwounded by personal prides.
He has such clarity. He has the capability to clearly distinguish one topic from another. Amazing to see how Pranoy Roy is throwing totally unrelated topics in between.
Bad host.
He's part of NDTV. That's them doing what they've been doing.
Appeasement and forgetting everything happened.
scumbag host.
Agreed. And there's no convincing answer from jaggi
In what way is the anchor's simple, direct question, unrelated !?
anchor has interrupted Sadhguru way too much ..all the comments made by anchor shows his biased opinion.
You r an intelligent women. Country needs women of u r kind.
I love the way sadhguru explains problem and solution❤️🙌 and feel little bad when the anchor interpreted it was disturbing.
classic example of Education vs wisdom.
Pranoy wants to annoy the panelists particularly Sadguru by constantly beleaguering him with banal irrelevance.
As a host, as to what he is trying to convey to the audience beats me. Annoy Roy might be a suitable appellation for him if he continues in this vein.
He is doing his jounoulistic duty
@@mirzaraza1359 yeah, holy duty to peddle their agenda...
No one is God , just fooling people around
Shashi Tharoor is so poised, well educated and intelligent. Sadhguru is wise and calm too. But the anchor, dude made me uncomfortable sitting from my home looking into the screen. Quite weird.
Yess
Don't you see Shashi Tharoor hypocrisy? He says congress distorted history to make those early Islamic marauders look like heroes and call it nation building. An now he speaks completely contradictory here.
I can assure you that the anchor is more human than other two. Only one among these three who hasn't killed his wife.
That is because Anchor was desperate to show that he is smarter and wiser than other debaters, and desperate for beef eating, although his grandfathers and forefathers might not have touched or smelled the beef, may be he thinks only by eating beef he can prove how smart he is
@@Ksgggg wait...what!?
So basically Sadguru is saying that Dalits should never forget how Brahmins treated them. Dalits should not hate the contemporary Brahmin population, but should never forget !
India is democratic country... If Sadhguru say we should not forget history.. Numbers should not increase... Then what will Sadhguru say about Surdas history, lower caste demolition and injustice.
If Dr. Tharoor turns on his "beast-mode" switch, then the entire panel is done. He knows himself that he is unbeatable in a debate.
Binil B
Well to be a good debate you got to be a good listener..and a person who can understand
Shashi can't stand against swamy 😂😂😂
Tharoor is deliberately avoiding an argument bcz he knows that the person Infront of him is stupid.
@@xy1877 dude sadguru can help you lead better Life, not Shashi
ha ha.....so true
Am i the only one who noticed that guy who's trying not to sleep during sadhguru's speech?🤣😆
He's trying hard.
Literally me
🤣🤣🤣
You are underestimating the power of sadhguru to send someone into deep meditation!
Me in morning online class
,😁😁
Such a eyes-comforting debate 💕👌
Both Sadguru and Tharoor proved they were epics. But Prannoy made a fool of himself
Sadguru is right on the button, don't change demographics things will be much better.
so you are not going to breed and get kids since Jatti Jaggi said so ? lets see if you follow that.
@@harivs7219 then you dont understand what demographics mean .
@@harivs7219 Not have three wives & 4-5 kids with each of them. That's what he meant, but you clearly didn't get it & you seem to support changing demographics by certain minorities.
nothing will happen if people respect eachother view and dont violence against eachother
I dont know what demographic change he is talking about.. Hindus produce as many muslims are there every 10 years. I dont know what they are afraid of.
Shashi tharoor knows when to speak
He knows nothing ... Dh
@@Babujack360 well he knows much more than you
You should watch full video 😂 he don't know anything 😝
Sadguru always comes across to me as someone that talks more than he makes sense.. there are times he makes sense, but the sense he makes is general sense and knowledge that others say and that others already know.. but unless he himself says it then it doesn't make as much sense, or the truth is not really known.
@@Babujack360 but these two know one thing well, how to kill their better half and get away with it.
8:28 🤣🤣🤣 person sitting right behind sadguru...... Made my day😆😂😂
What happened to earlier Post
always enlightened by Sadhguru's wise points : Religion is foreign to India. Correct. India follows a dharma to accept all and does not limit to one set of rigid beliefs.
Actually there is not any static and rigid laws and beliefs in hinduism. Hinduism is a collection of several religions that were practiced by people of different ethnicities and creed in the subcontinent who had their own gods. Hinduism is so uncertain that anyone can change it by the needs of time it kept on being influenced by the beliefs of different tribes and creeds that came in contact with the subcontinent. If you will ask several hindoos a question they all will differ in their answers. Like if you ask some hindu regarding eating cow meat some may say its allowed to eat while some wont agree. Some may say there are 33 crore gods while some may say its monotheistic. Its just a sugarcoated khayali pulao with gets changed and remorphed with whats trending with time. Long before hinduism was said to be peaceloving and peaceful but now there is also a very warmongering and angry version of hinduism gaining popularity. In western world hinduisn is represented with a different image and hinduisms in the nation is totally different.
@@aliibrahim6407 haha. Toda research karo bhai conclusion pe aane se people. Ek book hi todi hai Hinduism me.
@@aliibrahim6407 I am glad our religion is interpretable in multiple ways, and dont teach people to kill for what goes against it unlike a few others.
@@arpitagautam4066 lol but still its followers kill on the basis of choice of food.
@@aliibrahim6407 actually it doesn't, do share if you find it any of the thousandssss of book you have read to interpret my relogion. As you said there aint any rigid laws, so please dont contradict yourself. Talk logic!!
In my opinion, anchor is not appreciated for his interruption and moreover this isn’t the first time, he did same with Mr. Abdul Kalam sir
Well thats the way how to question as a journalist. Its the art of questioning unlike propagating which is nowadays done by most of the journalist.
@@aliibrahim6407 You don't speak when someone else speaks.You speak after he has completed what he had to say.That is basic etiquette.
I have grown up in and around Mazid walls, the things that are thought or preached now different, in remote places and villages the harmony is still there, i wish the harmony spreads across the country
Hope such intellectual and peaceful conversation take place between different religious leaders, which can bring harmony in our country
Anchor is so immature..he is trying to divert continuously..really embarrassing to have such journalists representing top news channels..
He is Pronoy "James" Roy head of ndtv
What you think from the head of ndtv
@@aloksahu5660 he is head without proper head.
You needs modia... 😂😂
Ha ha ... He is Pronoy Roy with Leftist ideology ... He tries to mould discussions in those direction ... Unfortunate for him Sadhguru turned him to a joke
@@shayarino.1176 🤣🤣🤣
Very well said , we must forgive but never forget.
If not gorgot after forget there is no meaning since the wound never cure if not forgot if wound not cured then we have to keep on scratch it it is not good for health.
@@pilloobaba272 ancestors died but their ideology is still alive...dont you know that they want to convert india into gazhwa e hind...
@@vikashraj6564 that's sounds like the most evil shit
@@vikashraj6564 who told you this ? 🤣 WhatsApp University ?
@@akbarkazi1406 whatsapp university ka bahana mat banao....har cheez me whatsapp university ghusa dete ho.....facts pe baat kro......or agar whatsapp university ke alawa or koi bahana nhi ata to zahar kha ka jaan de do...lekin whatsapp university ka randi rona mt ro....whatsppp university ke nazayaz aulad....
@11:19 Absolutely true
Amazing, two intellectuals discussing ideas.
They should do one with subramanium swamy and shashi tharoor.
Pronnoy Roy, we would appreciate if you posed the same questions to all those Separatist leaders in Kashmir.
Awesome bro!! This anchor is pathetic
Same thing bro he said Ishwar Allah tero Naam but he forgot the whose name is mentioned before Ishwar Allah
So this youtube video is mostly filled with Hindutva supporters. No wonder Sadhguru is surely BJP stooge as well pretending not to have political stance...
@@vanessahargreaves528 same way journalist seems to be a Congress Stooge and pretending to not to have any bias. I think you must have surely observer that .
“There were no ships” lmao
From the internal security perspective some amendments can be made in the IT act where spreading hate or criticizing the religion can be punishable offence. Spreading hate or mocking religion is at its peak during many Hindu festivals. If a different community is going to mock the religion of others then surely it will led to agitation between them
When this Sadguru cannot answer a question he will either talk over the person or say that we will come to that later. You know the word for people who love themselves .....
Sadhguru is technically right. But I guess the challenge for a country is presenting the truth of certain invasions without vilifying any community. Many Hindus feel the anger reading the history of temple destruction, forced conversions. And many Muslims feel like they are being incriminated for something they didn't do. I feel and understand for both of these and the solution I think is in the present and working towards the future of a united, prosperous India - being modern and yet sensitive to each others' culture.
Hindus dont hate Muslims for what their forefathers did. They hate the govt sponsoring Madrasas and fertilizing the same cycle, for covering up ethnic cleansing of Hindus in Kashmir, for giving special laws to Muslims that dont align with India, for not letting Hindus even legally claim temple lands that was unfairly taken from them, for giving waqf board most land in India only next to railways and defense, for politically perpetuating caste divide, or leaving Hindus with no rights in Pakistan, for allowing illegal immigation, missionary mafia and more. Otherwise Khans and Akhtars and Kalams have always had full support.
@@mewtubeofficial True
Well said Vivek bhau
Muslim feels they are being discriminated for things they didn't do? Ask any Muslim how proud they are of the people who killed, raped and converted their ancestors. That's the reason for mistrust against them.
well said
Anchor in his mind: Okay, I have to interrupt in between so that I sound intelligent.
It didn't seem like a debate. Rather it was a rational discussion between two great thinkers.
How come Sadhguru is saying Islamic invasion???? In that case, would you call Emperor's Asoka's conquest as Hindu conquest??
This anchor is such a disgrace. Trying to interrupt most of the times...
Absolutely 🙄
@@durgasisodiya4295 It's impossible to despise your point , some of these anchors are so blunt , they continue asking stupid doubts and opine with either side . But , gladly we have intellectuals like Shashi Tharoor and Sadhguru , who can think logically and are not kidnapped by their emotions and personal preferences . They ponder long about the problem, reflect their thoughts and give pragmatic solutions to most of them. By the way , I am a great fan of both of them!!🙏🙏
Yes
Like arnab goswami
It’s not a monologue. Sometimes the anchor needs to keep control of the discussion. People tend to drift off.
He is biased that's it
When shashi tharoor started speaking ,, I have to open my subtitle🙂
True😂😂
😂😂
Right😀
I am a Bangladeshi. Shahi Tharoor is one of my favorite Indian politician and writer. First time when I heard that he completed his PhD at the age of 21 I became wondered. He speaks unstoppably and show statistics how the British raj looted in Indian subcontinent. To mine he is an idol of India and a spokesman for minority communities in India like as
Aurundhuti Roy. God bless him
What about tasleema nasreem
It will be glad if bangladesh also cares for their minorities !
@@user-yn8gm3fb1t he will not say anything in this
And for me it's Tasleema
The fact that the whole talk show/debate is happening in English makes me laugh even more. Also that I'm typing in the same lang😆. We people are hillarious, sacchi. P.s - I respect both the speakers (fyi).☺️
Britishers themselves suffered from their own class wars. Colonialism was classic case of crony capitalism!!! Few in UK benefitted from colonial loot and not general public. General public when got chance, voted for guy (Attlee) in 1944 and made him PM who promised freedom to India in his election manifesto
I didn't know that, thank you for sharing this.
Yes in 1945 March the British parliament passed law for the withdrawal from all colonies.
So?
@@vanessahargreaves528 so the point here is , large group when given a chance/power chose compassion.
Small group/individual when has unchecked power often turns narcissistic (Churchill/queen Victoria/ directors of east India company)
The infrastructure built by looted money helps the general public of UK
This is real debate procedure not like media's debate 🙏
Shashi is awesome, I honestly didn't think India had many decent politicians
Don't live in the past. Live in the present and plan for the future. Don't try to settle old scores or you will be trapped in the past.
When sadhguru said spiritually and religion is a dimension which should never be organised, I bowed to him. 🙏 Respect for sadhguru
Can you tell me what or rather how you and sadhguru define spirituality? The definition and understanding is varying from person to person.
@@GauravKumar-vu9td so shut up your mouth and mind your own business
@@dhsfjsh4736 talk about nonsensical bullshit. If asking a doubt is so triggering for you, how could you possibly fathom anything Sadhguru said?
@@GauravKumar-vu9td Sadhguru is hypocrites
Just like any other religious preacher
@@cineverse442 Far better than your PEDOPHILE ALLAH
1:10 Sadhguru: if there was no world war 2, brittish also would have stayed back
So you want British India back?
Yes that's the fact
Bhai wo chale gye we are have but mugle khud to chale gye but jinko convert kiya tha wo yahi rh gye . Jo shashi tharoor bol rha h yaha rh gye muslim wo yaha nhi rhe wo sab convered h jo vi yaha h
He's right, ww2 was a big reason for British retreat
Yes he is right.... infact if civil disobedience movement wouldn't had stopped British definitely had flee in 3rd decade of 20 century...
What a beautiful debate! Lots of things to learn and observe.
Amazing how Guruji keeps his focus while speaking and still makes a point in spite of interruptions.
Prannoy Roy shouldn’t make snarky remarks. Unfortunately in this interview Roy displays his bias.
That he is an over rated moron comes clearly in this.
He has his pro communist and pro Xian bias
A man of knowledge vs A man of words ...
Who is man of knowledge here
@@colorsofchennai9405 Sadhguru is a man of knowledge
@@VishalKumar-lk1pt 😂
@@VishalKumar-lk1pt yeah right, the guy who thought ships didn't exist during the Mughal time is the man of knowledge lol
Sadhguru : man of wisdom
Why its not like that ispite 0f what ever you do is your business ,just at least listen to each other accept what ever good both have.
Its a type of learning.
Wonder if there is no believe system that human puts so much effort to seek for the answer or truth, then why is there need of path? when one can figure by his/her own doings rather believing in something that has meant nothing for him. And after all... doing all sorts of things in one's life why does one feels afraid of dying. Why is there a question where will I be or would go if I die.....!!!
Anyways loved it and yes we must not forget what had happened and must not also keep in heart cause it can toxicate our mind. Peace and harmony that's what this world is in need of.
It's so difficult to choose ones thoughts when both the ideal of life are at same stage.... shashiji and sadguru 🙏🙏
Sadhguru is getting bombarded with facts and true academic intellectuality. Sadhguru does not know history in detail as much as Shashi does and neither does he understand economics. He is more of a high-thought philosophical person.
@Ishan Nasnodkar 4453 watched it, Shashi was not specialized in certain topics, but Shashi did not give WRONG info, Sai had logic, but Sadhguru gives you wrong unscientific info. There is a huge difference.
Sadhgurur was once saying he saw some people raising DEAD ALIVE. I am surprised educated people even take these Sadhus seriously. Sadhguru is just a bit more sophisticated version of Baba Ramdev, but not as learned as people think he is. He has answers for everything, I want to know if he did PhDs in all the topics he talks about .
@@adad-ec6ht everything you said is a lie.
Pro ide proof or delete your comment if you cannot prove
@Ishan Nasnodkar 4453 You would say that because you are biased with your religious beliefs and patriotism. Sadhguru is not an academic person, he does not refer SOURCES, he does have specialization in any particular subject apart from meditation, philosophy, etc. but he pretends to be a JACK OF ALL CARDS - just a sophisticated version of a politician convincing people..
@@unitedbeast6614 1000% correct.
What a great debate... Smooth n understandable, this is real debate by educated people
Very very nice conversation between two intellect. Such a brilliant person.
i like they are not disrespecting each other because for their different opinions and calmly understanding each others view
It's not even a debate
Both of them simply have different ways for the same destination
Why do journalists and politicians like Tharoor only discuss and debate with Hindu gurus? I rarely see them taking up Gurus from other communities with the same passion and put them under the same level of scrutiny.
The so called sadhguru has stated in this debate that he does not want to associate with any religion.
@@themadraseye he also answered it. There is difference between religion and dharma. Go and catch an islamic scholar and debate with him. He will give you a taste of everything that is wrong with abrahamic religion
Why not with just Hindu gurus? If what is being discussed is fine and thought provoking, lets not worry to which religion the gurus belong.
Because deep down they know that..... He or his followers won't ever thrash them violently....
Very well put.
Just imagine for a few seconds how it would be, if Osho was sitting and speaking in this debate.
"What religion are you?" Beautiful answer by Sadhguru..
His thoughts on organizing a belief system into a religion is so true.
Not so true, he is inflencing into his community😂😂Tricky man😂😂
Sadhguru And Shashi Tharoor Both Are Amazing.....❤️
What's amazing about Shashi Tharoor?? Where ever he goes he tries to establish empathy and sympathy for the Muslims, and talking about his 'imaginary' islamophobia, and how loving and caring the Brutal Islamic rulers have been, he very strategically tries to manipulate the history to suit his agenda.
And Pranoy sir too😍
This is the first time I understood Mr Tharoor.
Such a deep and calm conversation shows their intellect
I almost wanted no confrontation between the both the persons I like :D
Out of nowhere the anchor says "which religion are you?" "Is it ok to eat beaf?" Wtf
Very stupid of him.. Either an attention seeker or did not want Sadhguru to hijack his show..Very Barkha like😂😅
Understandably Difficult for respected Satguru to answer the question about beef
Finally a Very nice and Intellectual conversation, Which we can hear without Noice pollution
@@abhimitty6372 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼❤️❤️
Idk why congress doesn't make guys like shashi tharoor their leaders they did same with bose and lohia and patel and doing same now I mean he is a true centrist who actually does respects and want to refine our culture
Insecurity about their seat thats what destroyed the scamgress
True
That's the fucking reason I hate Congress
Shashi Tharoor is just like the others white washing crimes of muslim
Such restraint.... civil discussions. Very nice.
And there comes debates aired on live TVs "chaos chaos 💥💥"
I really accept the Jaggi Sir point ..need of the hour...
Both are well informed educated and awesome🔥
Is this the longest time Shashi Tharoor has stayed quiet 👀
Debate should be like this....offering solutions...
then same can be applied to caste issues and conflicts there were ugly things happened to oppressed castes, should they remember and keep always a doubt on oppressors castes??
Why the hell pranoy Roy keep interrupting Sadhguru so many times...maybe because he is too afraid to accept the facts..
Sadhguru is only idolized by idiotic imbeciles like you.
@Cash Money Neither but the fact that you make such cheap commentary on religion highlights what a disgusting vile bitch you are. Your mother should be embarrassed to have you for a child.
@@neema843 The only person who needs to leave is nincompoop like you little bitch.
@@neema843 Because it is a secular and diverse country . Perhaps you need refresher course in India's history and foundation and if you can't tolerate other religions ,get the fuck out of here.
@@neema843 I'm not a Christian but your words actually make me laugh because of how idiotic you are . Who the hell are you to comment on other people's religious choices ? I hope you consult a psychiatrist and get yourself checked maybe that will cure your stupidity but the hatred in your heart well that will always remain with you.
Ohh hats off to Sadguru for how politely he handel that irritating anchor.🙏👍
What is irritating about him?
I can't understand this philosophy that we shouldn't forget the wrongs of the past but should forgive them. Forgetting or not remembering is an essential step towards forgiveness.
Well said.
That certainly Shows the Biasness Of Sadh Guru...If you don't forget it, keep reminding yourself of It...how the heck can u forgive?
That's beyond retarded. 🙈
Sadguru is right.. we cannot forget the past. Thats why history books are written.. but can forgive the wrong doings of past generations. That itself is a big sacrifice of current generation.. by reading and remembering history, hopefully the current generation don’t allow aggression and brutal rule of others in india any more
@@Red.bulldozer3 The mogul emperors invading India and committing atrocities are past events that are unlikely to be repeated in the future as India has sophisticated defence capability against invasion of any kind. So, whats the big deal about not forgetting history? Japan has moved on from the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings by the USA and is the better of it for it- so should India move on from Islamic invasion and not be paranoid about a repeat of it as there are so many challenges facing the country that each one of us should focus our attention and energies on.
shashi taroor : arabs, they stayed and became us ". This is what some radicals wont understand. But thank god sashi taroor said it right. That's the quality of taroor
They dont became us, they wanted us to be one of them forcefully,brutally.
@@mrinmoybaidya6821 i think you should learn, unlearn, relearn few subjects. Before you think about arabs think about west! And think what they had done to us? After all these damages done to india, they simply said 'sorry'.!!!. History has turned upside down by them. So that they can blame arabs!!
@@shajipk8676 Its nt only the fault of West every invasion is responsible for cultural ,religious , economical ruins of India.
@@mrinmoybaidya6821 what was the GDP % pre, post west rules? Just give me few facts.?
@@shajipk8676 what u want to prove?
Went through the comments. Most of them supported Tharoor and Sadguru. Respect to all the commenters who looked at the logic behind individual speaker and not taking one’s side. This is real india these are real Indians. 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
This is what a debate should be. Two icons
This kind of debate is the true expression of tolerance.
Religion and rules books are different
There should not be any restrictions on any living beings on this earth... because the mind cannot be controlled by others or himself/herself... and that is why there are no restrictions in our religion... only we have to understand what to do and what not to do, based on the results of others or ours...Very proud to be a Hindu...