@@Gangstergil3 they didn’t really count it because it didn’t directly link up to Kevin Debruyne‘s goal and besides Real Madrid have won three champions, leagues with eight offside, goals, in important games
on top of that nowadays it's so automatized that there are virtually zero errors when the ball is out, it's one of the few things you can trust in the game
52 years ago , I slid through the mud, stopping the rolling ball just over the line. My fullback kicked it away downfield and we went on to win the cupfinal (2-1). For 40 years I lived with shame of that fake victory, until I had the fule explained and think now the ball wasn't totally over the line..... now I sleep easier.
As long as you your feet don’t touch out of bounds if you jumped from inbounds. You’re still considered part of the court. You can’t be standing 15 feet out of bounds and then jump and throw the ball because you’re considered part of out of bounds. It’s a very good rule. The ref puts the ball in play and it stays inbounds until it connects with an object or person who last touched out of bounds.
No matter how you change the rule, there is always a moment the ball is in and the next it's out. So there's no fundamental difference where the ball is ruled out, as long as it's consistent.
It looks like a weird rule when the ball is rolling (different to tennis or volleyball that look at the area of ground contact). But it makes a lot of sense when looking at a ball in the air.
It makes sense. There is no way to tell if half the ball or one third is out. It needs to be all out or nothing out. It is a matter of choice. But if for goals the ball needs to be all in, it makes sence that in these cases the whole of the ball needs to be out.
When you think about it, what would be a better alternative? You need a rule that can be applied as consistently as possible and when you think about the alternatives, this is probably the best one, or the least bad one if you prefer.
This is absolutely right.. the rule is „the line does belong to the room it surrounds“ simple as that.. therefore for example it is a penalty when the foul does happen on the line of the box.. because the line belongs to the room it surrounds…
Once you see green in between the ball and the line it's out. That's why you also have rule that line can't be painted green and the ball can not be green.
From above, the circumferance of the ball is in, but the actual surface of the ball is not on the line. Never thought of it like that before. The same can be said for goals.
I wish my refs understood this, saved a ball from going out for a goal kick, then passed to my teammate and the ref called it out even though the ball was still halfway over the line
I’ve been trying to teach that to people I am playing with for the past 20 years when playing pickup. People are calling it out while it’s not. It’s stopping the game and it’s preventing good plays to happen. It’s has been too frustrating, too many arguments. I pretty much gave up in the recent years. Sometimes I’ll say something, but I don’t insist anymore.
Makes sense tennis has basically the exact same rule where the line isn’t the end of the field/court but simply where the field/court ends while the line is still considered in.
Tennis is completely different though. In tennis it's about the area that contacts the ground, in football it's about the projection of the ball on the ground. This males the rule applicable to airborn balls as well.
It makes complete sense. Here in the land where football was created (ENGLAND) this has always been the rule and isn’t difficult to understand. The whole ball needs to be over the line to be a goal or out of play. What doesn’t make sense is a game you call football that is mainly played with your hands. Now that’s weird.
It’s like being 5 again learning the rules of the biggest sport on the planet. Still, it’s nice to see people finally picking it up in some parts of the worlds.
As someone who just got into Futbol hardcore 2 years ago I never went and decided to figure this out I just went ahead thinking my eyes were deceiving me😂
I wasn’t confused about this, but because the ball is round would that mean that at some point the ball isn’t actually touching the line it’s just over hanging the line?
Its weird that people still dont get it despite the goal line technology's existance for so many years, which is working on that exact principle. Its literally the same thing
Exactly what he said “in FIFA” not your league. Different rules can apply. To be fair that is a scuffed rule. The angles and lighting and even how good the paint is, can affect in and out of bounds lol
what is so hard about the whe ball over the whole line? the hard part is realizing the the outside edge of the line extends upward so that even when the ball is in the air...the same rule applies
the Japan goal against Spain is probably one of the most notable recent incidences of this rule.
the ball seemed out from an angle but from the top view it was shown to be in. This rule really came into play with that goal
I think the Man City vs Real Madrid was quite recent
Yea
@@Gangstergil3 they didn’t really count it because it didn’t directly link up to Kevin Debruyne‘s goal and besides Real Madrid have won three champions, leagues with eight offside, goals, in important games
@@user-wx4tq3ss4nok let's not forget the robbery committed against Chelsea in 2009 Barcelona should've never won
That one piece of grass keeping the ball in play:
It was the whole reason who Japón beat Spain
That grass made history
well they shit all over spain lets be real lol@@Yoan162
@@Yoan162TF is Japón
One piece??
I never thought this was controversial. I thought that's just common sense
for real :)))
The only reason this is controversial is due to the point of view
on top of that nowadays it's so automatized that there are virtually zero errors when the ball is out, it's one of the few things you can trust in the game
Probably people think that because in other sports the line is out that its the same in every sport.
In basketball if the ball doesn’t touch the floor outside of the court it’s still in if you can reach it. So could be confusing to some Americans
Literally no one was ever confused by this
52 years ago , I slid through the mud, stopping the rolling ball just over the line. My fullback kicked it away downfield and we went on to win the cupfinal (2-1). For 40 years I lived with shame of that fake victory, until I had the fule explained and think now the ball wasn't totally over the line..... now I sleep easier.
..... Americans.
It's literally common knowledge
When u racing or jumping or alot of other sport you step on line you out
@@marinokrajina3773 yeah but nobody is confused about this particular instance
Bro channel name is VAR 💀
?
I like the channel - Bangbro's 💀🕳🕳
AYO
Lmao 😂😂
Cavani wants to know his address
I like how Americans slowly discover real football
Better
😂
Slowly but surely!! 🎉🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🎉
White Americans to be correct.
It’s the same in basketball not hard to grasp
I love the way cameraman fakes shock while completely not caring
nobody gets this wrong bro.. wdym 😂
Americans
Except a certain Soviet ref in 1966
Most parents need to know this when they’re yelling on the side line that it is out
Makes perfect sense, best sport for a reason
Japan vs Spain be like
That 7 year old who thinks they are Sergio Ramos: It’s out when I say it’s out
And in basketball, you can literally be outside the stadium entirely, but as long as your feet don't touch the floor, the ball is still in play
As long as you your feet don’t touch out of bounds if you jumped from inbounds. You’re still considered part of the court. You can’t be standing 15 feet out of bounds and then jump and throw the ball because you’re considered part of out of bounds. It’s a very good rule. The ref puts the ball in play and it stays inbounds until it connects with an object or person who last touched out of bounds.
Bro was cooking when nobody was hungry🔥🔥🔥
"Bro there is no way this is Right."
Spain: Exactly
No matter how you change the rule, there is always a moment the ball is in and the next it's out. So there's no fundamental difference where the ball is ruled out, as long as it's consistent.
I need to show this to my friend
It looks like a weird rule when the ball is rolling (different to tennis or volleyball that look at the area of ground contact). But it makes a lot of sense when looking at a ball in the air.
I subscribed for these little pieces of information that we really want to know!!
Not just tutorials on how to play
We also need game knowledge
bro was waiting for this moment his whole life
ur better than VAR😂
There are many people that need to see this
I hate when people say the ball is out when it skims the line
As a non-soccer/football fan, I love rules like this. Just keeps the game going and makes for less stoppages
it's really funny to me, in rugby you grasp de touch line and you are out
Man says most people get thisbwrong and then takes 30 seconds to explain the most basic rule in football😂
It makes sense. There is no way to tell if half the ball or one third is out. It needs to be all out or nothing out. It is a matter of choice. But if for goals the ball needs to be all in, it makes sence that in these cases the whole of the ball needs to be out.
That ball knowledge 😂
When you think about it, what would be a better alternative? You need a rule that can be applied as consistently as possible and when you think about the alternatives, this is probably the best one, or the least bad one if you prefer.
This is absolutely right.. the rule is „the line does belong to the room it surrounds“ simple as that.. therefore for example it is a penalty when the foul does happen on the line of the box.. because the line belongs to the room it surrounds…
this also apply to goals the whole ball needs to go through the line
I like how most people assume that the whole reason for car is for fouls etc and GOALS but it’s used for this as well (and the rule of it)
Wow, who knew! That's craaaaazy 😂😂😂
Americans be like: oh 😂
This also applies in the goal line right?
yes
No
@@stupiditiusmaximus yes it does
@@mhdrizwan8401even %1 is enough for a goal
@@bugrasevinc9696yes just like stones clearance v liverpool 2019 i think
Camera man refuses to believe this sorcery
similar to AFL, as long as a mm of the ball is touching sort of thing, it is still in
you could just think that the line has an invisible wall going up and if the ball is still touching then its in.
Once you see green in between the ball and the line it's out.
That's why you also have rule that line can't be painted green and the ball can not be green.
For them to use a ball but treat it like a box is crazy 😅
From above, the circumferance of the ball is in, but the actual surface of the ball is not on the line. Never thought of it like that before. The same can be said for goals.
The line when i play:
me seeing this just after the Newcastle saga
I knew these anyways
"no way bro", "you trippin bro", "bro there's no way".
I wish my refs understood this, saved a ball from going out for a goal kick, then passed to my teammate and the ref called it out even though the ball was still halfway over the line
and dont forget, play to the whistle
Nawhh bro roastes fifa ref 💀
I’ve been trying to teach that to people I am playing with for the past 20 years when playing pickup.
People are calling it out while it’s not. It’s stopping the game and it’s preventing good plays to happen.
It’s has been too frustrating, too many arguments.
I pretty much gave up in the recent years.
Sometimes I’ll say something, but I don’t insist anymore.
Makes sense tennis has basically the exact same rule where the line isn’t the end of the field/court but simply where the field/court ends while the line is still considered in.
Tennis is completely different though. In tennis it's about the area that contacts the ground, in football it's about the projection of the ball on the ground. This males the rule applicable to airborn balls as well.
I need to show this to the refs and coaches in my league 😢
Refs need to understand this
Think of it like a pingpong table with the line around the edge.
Me when someone complains about the ball going out
Me trying to be mitoma: No that wasn’t out! There was still 0.0000001% still in play!
“The whole of the ball has to cross the whole of the line”
I played with this guy who thought a goal was only scored if it hit the net
Saving for when someone tries to tell me the ball is out
If ref isn’t paying attention its still in
As a football player I can relate
They better put a GPS in that ball
It makes complete sense.
the fact that even 10 year olds knew this
I already knew that but sometimes VAR is wrong😂
Bro discovered football💀
If someone says that "theres no way thats true" show them the Japan goal vs Spain
It’s actually frustrating how many people don’t know this
Looooool you definitely are from North America
@@charliezone9723 Yeah I’m from the USA and a bunch of the refs get this wrong 🤦🏽♂️
Hojlund goal should have counted
thats because the ball is a wide sphere so like the ball is already out but you can’t see it bc of the wideness of the ball
That is for big intl games in local games if that happens then boot war will start. Some kungfu hustle thing
Okay who didn't know this to explain it
It makes complete sense. Here in the land where football was created (ENGLAND) this has always been the rule and isn’t difficult to understand. The whole ball needs to be over the line to be a goal or out of play.
What doesn’t make sense is a game you call football that is mainly played with your hands. Now that’s weird.
Dang they changed this rule? It used to be, atleast in my country, that if the ball is more than 50% out of the line, it is fully out
Wait till he finds out the player can stand out of the line and still play the ball that's on the line 😅
All of my refs need to know this bro
Bro at school when I play football everyone thinks it's out but I'm like bro the whole ball has to be out to actually be out.
I hate how when I casually play with my friends they never abide this shit. Every time the ball touches the sideline they call out
Is that same for the goal line?
Line is part of the field. Compare to disc golf where line is not part of field. If ball/disc touches field, it's in.
Same as tennis only even if 1 little hair of the tennis ball is on the line the ball is in play
"The whole of the ball must cross the whole of the line."
This is a actuall rule which can be useful in some situation if you do it right
What about if that in the goal line is it the same it doesn't count till the whole of the ball goes in?
It’s the same, it’s only a goal when the ball has wholly passed over the goal line.
It’s like being 5 again learning the rules of the biggest sport on the planet. Still, it’s nice to see people finally picking it up in some parts of the worlds.
In rugby if the ball is on the line, then it is out
As someone who just got into Futbol hardcore 2 years ago I never went and decided to figure this out I just went ahead thinking my eyes were deceiving me😂
I wasn’t confused about this, but because the ball is round would that mean that at some point the ball isn’t actually touching the line it’s just over hanging the line?
"Crazy.." "How is that possible..". It's the same rule for tennis, volleyball...
There is no way any frequent football player doesn't know this.
Its weird that people still dont get it despite the goal line technology's existance for so many years, which is working on that exact principle. Its literally the same thing
Basket:hey ya got your foot out!
Is it the same rule for goals. So many times my friends said it was a goal on the line
EA when it’s on the line: nah it’s out
Arsenal needs to see this
Exactly what he said “in FIFA” not your league. Different rules can apply. To be fair that is a scuffed rule. The angles and lighting and even how good the paint is, can affect in and out of bounds lol
This rule is crazy. Instead of looking at the ball from above, look at it from ground level, the point of contact with the ground. The bali s OUT.
The ball doesn’t have to make contact with the ground to be out.
What if the ball is in air and out of line but somebody brought it back into the field....so is it a throw in or not
this is common sense even among the 4th graders 😂
Mazroui vs RM: yes
what is so hard about the whe ball over the whole line? the hard part is realizing the the outside edge of the line extends upward so that even when the ball is in the air...the same rule applies
the cameraman def calls the sport soccer