Hamza Yusuf interrupted at Islamic convention
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 09. 2024
- Prominent Muslim scholar Hamza Yusuf faced opposition at the Reviving the Islamic Spirit Convention in Canada for his stance on Israel’s war on Gaza. Some people in the audience interrupted his speech, accusing him of undermining the Palestinian cause.
In 2020, Yusuf received a wave of criticism for publicly supporting the UAE’s choice to establish relations with Israel, a decision that was widely criticised by many Muslim religious authorities.
Yusuf has previously courted controversy by positing blame on the Palestinians for their suffering, mocking the Syrian uprising, and for having referred to the UAE as country that was “committed to tolerance”.
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEas...
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye
When injustice becomes law, then RESISTANCE becomes DUTY
Resistance can be in action, not just in words.
Unfortunately after all his great Dawa work, Hamza has sold out Palistine and part of Islam
screaming is not resistance
True
Exactly
Protesting in silence is the weakest of protest. It's kinda pathetic for people in power to do this.
Ya
He is not advocating for it. He has been speaking out publicly against Israel for years as he is doing in this video. People are taking his words out of context shaytan is trying to divide the ummah. STAND FIRM TOGETHER. You’re acting like he’s the king or something he is an old man who has brain trauma and has been through a lot brought many to Islam.
For powerful people to not speak out against wrong-doing makes them complicit with those that are doing wrong!
He is using and saying very Christian ✝️ concepts
"Sometimes its the means for survival "
"Sometimes its absolutely necessary to suffer in silence "
"But it doesn't mean it's final "
This is ✝️ concepts and ideology.
I'm assuming the Muslims in the audience recognised this and that's what got them going
Uttered spontaneously, the phrase "We sometimes have to suffer in silence" can be prone to misunderstanding when taken out of context. It appears there's a determination to misconstrue Sheikh Hamza Yusuf's words, yet he transcends being a mere punching bag. What he likely intended was to convey the profound magnitude of our helplessness despite our earnest desire to assist. In the context of the ongoing genocide, the notion that sometimes we must endure suffering in silence reflects the shared experience of individuals grappling with anger and sorrow. It signifies a collective wish to contribute more than our current efforts permit, but alas, we find ourselves constrained.
No suffering in silence. If there is injustice, speak up at the top of your lungs. Show up, show out and resist.
What he's saying is that all you can do is only that, which is suffering in silence, since you cannot do much about it.
@@koroglurustem1722then he should stop calling hinself a sheikh if he is that coward.
@thoraadam9049 fine. Can you do anything more to immediately stop the genocide? That's the point. We need to act, but not scream or lose our sanity. Allah is greater. That's the meaning of suffering in silence.
@@koroglurustem1722 mate do yourself a favor and stop typing, you're making yourself look like a fool the more you talk. The world movement is doing more than we thought it would, it's moving world powers at the moment. It's slow I know but the boycott forced the ceo of McDonald's to speak out and forced Starbucks to close their branches and move out of multiple countries. The marches are putting pressure on many political parties. We need a looooot more and more action on the ground but doing the available is the least we can do for our people.
*_Under international law Gaza is still considered occupied since 2005, and has been since 1967, since Israel still has not transferred sovereign powers, and instead maintains control over the Palestinian Authority’s ability to function effectively. Examples: water and electricity, airspace, supply of civilian infrastructure, etc...._*
The illegal European occupation of Palestine is the sole cause of the the 75 year conflict. Scores of U.N. resolutions condemn Israel's human rights abuses and illegal occupation of Palestine, making the racist Israeli Manifest Destiny religious claims patently absurd:
Part 1
1947:
November 29: Resolution 181: Recommending partition of the Mandatory Palestine into Arab and Jewish states, and international status for the City of Jerusalem.
1948:
November 19: Resolution 212: Assistance to Palestinian refugees
December 11: Resolution 194: Conciliation Commission; protection of and free access to Jerusalem and other Holy Places; Resolves that the refugees wishing to return to their homes should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date, and that compensation should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return and for loss of or damage to property which, under principles of international law or in equity, should be made good by the Governments or authorities responsible
1949:
December 8: Resolution 302(IV): Assistance to Palestine refugees
December 9: Resolution 303(IV): International Regime for Jerusalem
December 10: Resolution 356: Jerusalem
1950:
December 2: Resolution 393: Assistance to Palestinian refugees
December 14: Resolution 394 (V): Calls for Arab-Israeli peace negotiations, and a solution for Palestinian refugees.
December 14: Resolution 468: Reduces financing for an international regime in Jerusalem.
1952:
January 26: Resolution 512: Report of the United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine.
January 26: Resolution 513: Assistance to Palestinian refugees.
November 6: Resolution 614: Assistance to Palestinian refugees.
November 25: Resolution 660: Report of the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine refugees (UNRWA).
1953:
November 27: Resolution 720: Assistance to Palestinian refugees.
November 27: Resolution 766: Accounts of UNRWA.
1954:
December 4: Resolution 818: Assistance to Palestinian refugees.
December 4: Resolution 879: Accounts of UNRWA.
1955:
December 3: Resolution 916: Assistance to Palestinian refugees.
December 3: Resolution 964: Accounts of UNRWA.
1956:
December 21: Resolution 1081: Accounts of UNRWA.
1957:
February 27: Resolution 1091: Palestinian refugees.
February 28: Resolution 1018: Palestinian refugees.
December 12: Resolution 1191.html: Palestinian refugees.
1958:
December 12: Resolution 1315: Palestinian refugees.
1959:
December 9: Resolution 1456: UNRWA.
1960:
December 18: Resolution 1545: Accounts of UNRWA.
1961:
April 21: Resolution 1604: Palestinian refugees
October 30: Resolution 1636: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 20: Resolution 1725: Palestinian refugees
1962:
December 11: Resolution 1789: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 20: Resolution 1856: Palestinian refugees
1963
June 27: UN Special Assembly Resolution 1874.
June 27: UN Special Assembly Resolution 1875.
November 6: Resolution 1890-C: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 3: Resolution 1912: Palestinian refugees
1965:
February 10: Resolution 2002: Palestinian refugees
December 13: Resolution 2047-C: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 13: Resolution 2048-C: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 15: Resolution 2052: UNRWA Report.
1966:
October 26: Resolution 2139-C: Accounts of UNRWA.
November 17: Resolution 2154: Palestinian refugees.
1967:
July 4: Resolution 2252: Humanitarian assistance in the 1967 war.
July 4: Resolution 2253 (ES-V): Condemns Israel's measures to change the status of Jerusalem as invalid
July 14: Resolution 2254: "Deplores" Israel's failure to abide by UN General Assembly Resolution 2253 (ES-V)
July 21: Resolution 2256: The Situation in the Middle East
September 18: Resolution 2257: The Situation in the Middle East.
November 16: Resolution 2264-D: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 19: Resolution 2341: Palestinian refugees
1968:
November 1: Resolution 2380-D: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 19: Resolution 2443: Establishes the Special Committee to Investigate Israeli Practices Affecting the Human Rights of the Palestinian People.
December 19: Resolution 2452: UNRWA Report.
1969:
December 5: Resolution 2522-D: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 10: Resolution 2535: UNRWA Report. "Reaffirms" the "inalienable rights" of the Palestinian people and requests the Security Council to take "effective measures" to force implementation of previous UN resolutions
December 11: Resolution 2546: Condemns Israeli "violations of human rights and fundamental freedoms" in the occupied territories
1970:
November 4: Resolution 2628: Urges the speedy implementation of UN Security Council Resolution 242 and recognizes that "respect for the rights of the Palestinians is an indisputable element in the establishment of a just and lasting peace in the Middle East"
December 4: Resolution 2653-D: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 5: Resolution 2727: Calls on Israel to implement the recommendations of the UN special committee investigating Israeli practices in the occupied territories
December 7: Resolution 2656: Establishment of a working group for the financing of UNRWA.
December 8: Resolution 2672: UNRWA Report.
December 15: Resolution 2728: Report of the Special Committee to investigate Israeli practices affecting the Human Rights of the population of the Occupied Territories.
December 16: Resolution 2729: Report of the working group on the financing of the UNRWA.
1971:
November 8: Resolution 2756-D: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 6: Resolution 2791: Working group for the financing of UNRWA.
December 6: Resolution 2792: UNRWA Report. Calls for the implementation of UN General Assembly Resolution 194, stresses the "inalienable rights of the people of Palestine", and calls on Israel to stop resettling the inhabitants of Palestinian refugee camps.
December 13: Resolution 2799: The Situation in the Middle East.
December 20: Resolution 2851: Report of the Special Committee to investigate Israeli practices affecting the Human Rights of the population of the Occupied Territories. Condemns Israeli practices in the occupied territories.
1972:
November 9: Resolution 2912-D: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 8: Resolution 2949: The Situation in the Middle East.
December 13: Resolution 2963: UNRWA Report.
December 13: Resolution 2964: Working Group on the financing of UNRWA.
December 15: Resolution 3005: Report of the Special Committee to investigate Israeli practices affecting the Human Rights of the population of the Occupied Territories.
1973:
October 17: Resolution 3053-D: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 7: Resolution 3089: UNRWA Report.
December 7: Resolution 3090: Working Group on the financing of UNRWA.
December 7: Resolution 3092: Report of the Special Committee to investigate Israeli practices affecting the Human Rights of the population of the Occupied Territories.
December 17: Resolution 3175: Permanent sovereignty over natural resources in the occupied Arab territories.
1974:
October 14: Resolution 3210: Invites the PLO to participate in General Assembly deliberations on the question of Palestine.
November 12: Resolution 3227-D: Accounts of UNRWA.
November 22: Resolution 3236: Recognizes the right of the Palestinian people to regain its rights, including the right to self-determination and the right of return.
November 22: Resolution 3237: Observer status for the PLO.
November 29: Resolution 3240: Report of the Special Committee to Investigate Israeli Practices Affecting the Human Rights of the Population of the Occupied Territories.
November 29: Resolution 3246: Affirms the legitimacy of armed resistance by oppressed peoples in pursuit of the right to self-determination, and condemns governments which do not support that right
December 16: Resolution 3330: Working Group on the financing of UNRWA.
December 17: Resolution 3331: UNRWA Report.
December 17: Resolution 3336: Permanent sovereignty over national resources in the occupied Arab territories.
1975:
October 30: Resolution 3370-C: Accounts of UNRWA.
November 10: Resolution 3375: Invitation to the Palestine Liberation Organization to participate in the efforts for peace in the Middle East.
November 10: Resolution 3376: Founding of the Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People (CEIRPP).
December 5: Resolution 3414: Calls for economic sanctions and an arms embargo on Israel until it withdraws from all territories occupied in 1967 and grants the Palestinians their "inalienable national rights".
December 8: Resolution 3419: UNRWA report.
December 15: Resolution 3516: Permanent sovereignty over national resources in the occupied Arab territories.
December 15: Resolution 3525: Report of the Special Committee to Investigate Israeli Practices Affecting the Human Rights of the Population of the Occupied Territories.
1976:
November 23: Resolution 31/15: UNRWA Report.
November 24: Resolution 31/20: Expresses deep concern that no "just solution" to the "problem of Palestine" has been achieved, refers to the problem as the core of the Middle East conflict, and reaffirms the "inalienable rights" of the Palestinians, including the right of return and the right to national independence.
November 29: Resolution 31/22-F: Accounts of UNRWA.
December 9: Resolution 31/62: Calls for an international Middle East peace conference under the auspices of the UN and co-chaired by the United States and Soviet Union.
International law is only to keep everyone in chains except the west
jesus to back to trolling after your X mass?
@@punapeter Identify what part of the original coment is trolling. Internet Trolling is defined as:
creating discord on the Internet by starting quarrels or upsetting people by posting inflammatory or off-topic messages in an online community. Basically, a social media troll is someone who purposely says something controversial in order to get a rise out of other users . . . On every comment thread there are users who say something like “this video sucks,” *“you don’t know what you’re talking about,” or the classic “five people need to get their brains checked!”* referring to the number of people who have disliked that video . . .
Someone who argues a point is not trolling. *Someone who makes a wild and unwarranted* comment about that person’s mother IS trolling. Someone who brings something off topic into the conversation in order to make that person mad IS trolling.
Hanson, James, "Trolls and Their Impact on Social Media," (Univ. of Nebraska-Lincoln)
unlcms.unl.edu/engineering/james-hanson/trolls-and-their-impact-social-media
Uttered spontaneously, the phrase "We sometimes have to suffer in silence" can be prone to misunderstanding when taken out of context. It appears there's a determination to misconstrue Sheikh Hamza Yusuf's words, yet he transcends being a mere punching bag. What he likely intended was to convey the profound magnitude of our helplessness despite our earnest desire to assist. In the context of the ongoing genocide, the notion that sometimes we must endure suffering in silence reflects the shared experience of individuals grappling with anger and sorrow. It signifies a collective wish to contribute more than our current efforts permit, but alas, we find ourselves constrained.
No turning back or being silenced.
We've all been quiet for far too long.
Deceived and lied for too long....while innocent children & folks lost their lives to terrorist crimninal states
Ha Ha Ha 😝
Hazrat Khabbab(ra) relates, “Once we expressed our troubles and hardship to the Holy Prophet(sa). At the time, the Holy Prophet(sa) was sitting on his sheet, reclining in the shade of the Ka‘bah. We submitted before him, ‘Will you not seek help for us? Will you not pray to Allah for us in these difficult conditions?’ The Holy Prophet(sa) replied:
“‘Look here! There were people before you, for whom a ditch would be dug and he would then be placed inside it. Then a saw would be placed on his head, cutting him into two pieces, yet this could not deter him from his faith. Or, his flesh would be clawed off from his bones and tendons with iron rings, yet this could not hinder him from his faith.’ The Holy Prophet(sa) then stated, ‘By Allah! Allah will surely fulfil this work (meaning his mission would surely be fulfilled). He will surely fulfil the purpose for which I have come. There will be times of ease as well.’ He further stated, ‘This will be to the extent that a rider will travel from Thana to Hadhar Maut.” Thana and Hadhar Maut are two cities in Yemen and it is said that the distance between the two is 216 miles. In any case the Holy Prophet(sa) stated, “That the rider will undertake this journey and he will be afraid of none other than Allah”, or he said, “He will only fear his sheep being attacked by a wolf.” The Holy Prophet(sa) then stated, “You however are showing impatience.” In other words, this could only be achieved by demonstrating patience. This is a narration from Bukhari
Okay, then the war should continue?
Listen to Scott Ritter. Israel has already lost. In multiple ways. Prayers to Palestine... 💓..
Scott Ritter has consistently been an idiot on Ukraine since he first opened his mouth about it, he's a hyperbolic verbal gambler. According to Scott the Russians would have their special op wrapped up by now, Speznatz would wipe out all the Ukrops, etc so on. He's a bullshitter, like you.
Ammin
Whenever I feel pessimistic about the state of affairs, Scott Ritter is one of the people I tune to. His optimism about the current state, and future is definitely refreshing
@@Raydaruckuz Very well said, my Friend. Thank you, Bless you. 💗
@@jupexx2052 💓💓💓💓💓
The whole world is seeing the TRUTH about the illegal occupation. There is no turning back. The world is now knowing what Palestinians have been going through for 75+ years. Blessings, Everyone..🧡.
Brother you’re everywhere I respect your hardworking in running the comments with the truth
@@Billzloveschelsea Thank you, my Brother. Love and Respect for you. 🧡
@@FilmSpookMasha’Allah brother. You’re absolutely right, enough is enough with occupation and genocide. The entire western foreign policies are controlled by z!onist agenda who’ve a vested interest to try to demonize the Palestinians and any resistance while also stealing western taxpayers money.
May Allah REWARD you for always speaking up for the truth brother. Much love and respect.
The whole world saw that it was the United Nations that approved the establishment of the state of Israel, and then the Arabs launched a war. If you didn't start the war, Palestine would be much bigger than it is now. You can immigrate to Europe and the United States, but you do not recognize the right of Jews to live in Israel.
നന്നായി പറഞ്ഞു...അഭിനന്ദനങ്ങൾ
No to silence around violence and abuse!!!!!!!! Shout from the rooftops for those who need your voice to be raised for them!!!
Yes, but it is not just talking it is also action I think is what he is suggesting.
@@pinkpickledcauliflower9he needs to clarify in details on any of whatever he wants to say or otherwise confusing or misinterpreted, because he's considered a big figure or name
It's interesting how people derived their own meanings from that. I personally took it as a message for those who are far away from the battle.
It's ok to be silent and donate to the cause than start chanting away and losing your job.
@@Rlouis367Here is the whole video Dear Plz Don't Disrespect Our scholars of islam plz first do proper research Her is the Real whole video czcams.com/video/pzs7BuFhZGg/video.htmlsi=uFXbKdoJmy03qepH
@@nomenall1918he is no schoIar. He sided with Bush in 2001 and sided with Trump in 2019. He is an agent.
And what is it with you? You do not fight in the cause of Allah and for oppressed men, women, and children who cry out, “Our Lord! Deliver us from this land of oppressors! Appoint for us a saviour; appoint for us a helper-all by Your grace.” (Quran 4:75)
czcams.com/users/shortsc5XAiYSP_d0?si=Jj17LGtwqtbCSR21
The one who is silent about truth , is a devil .
Shut up
Hamza Yusuf is beyond you and I in Islam knowledge they didn't even let him finish
@@hogman3543 correct
Free Palestine Stop Genocide
Al Jazeera and Middle East Eye are excellent sources for Real Journalism. Thank you everyone for supporting and helping these important videos get out to more and more people. Love and Truth wins.. ❤🧡💛🧡❤
❤
Yikes, biased media outlets that feed into your antisemitism...
@@punapeterIsraHELL is an apartheid state as stated by the UN ..IsraHELL has oppressed and bombed palestinians from past 75yrs and each time palestine was attacked and bombed the UN just provided them "condolence money and humanitarian aid " without any justice, and also little to no media coverage..and now that IsraHELL got attacked,they start calling everyone terrorists!!!typical nonsense of an OCCUPIER...
Uttered spontaneously, the phrase "We sometimes have to suffer in silence" can be prone to misunderstanding when taken out of context. It appears there's a determination to misconstrue Sheikh Hamza Yusuf's words, yet he transcends being a mere punching bag. What he likely intended was to convey the profound magnitude of our helplessness despite our earnest desire to assist. In the context of the ongoing genocide, the notion that sometimes we must endure suffering in silence reflects the shared experience of individuals grappling with anger and sorrow. It signifies a collective wish to contribute more than our current efforts permit, but alas, we find ourselves constrained.
Al Jazeera is funded by Qatari royal family. Qatar has been normalising ties with 🇮🇱
Allah never ever told us to suffer in silence anywhere in the Qur'an, yes he did ask us to endure the hardships with patience and seek his help through prayers, but he clearly told us that if we're being oppressed unjustly then we have every right to fight back in self defence, to fight against the injustice that was done to us especially if its a matter concerning our children, our family and our land
Hazrat Khabbab(ra) relates, “Once we expressed our troubles and hardship to the Holy Prophet(sa). At the time, the Holy Prophet(sa) was sitting on his sheet, reclining in the shade of the Ka‘bah. We submitted before him, ‘Will you not seek help for us? Will you not pray to Allah for us in these difficult conditions?’ The Holy Prophet(sa) replied:
“‘Look here! There were people before you, for whom a ditch would be dug and he would then be placed inside it. Then a saw would be placed on his head, cutting him into two pieces, yet this could not deter him from his faith. Or, his flesh would be clawed off from his bones and tendons with iron rings, yet this could not hinder him from his faith.’ The Holy Prophet(sa) then stated, ‘By Allah! Allah will surely fulfil this work (meaning his mission would surely be fulfilled). He will surely fulfil the purpose for which I have come. There will be times of ease as well.’ He further stated, ‘This will be to the extent that a rider will travel from Thana to Hadhar Maut.” Thana and Hadhar Maut are two cities in Yemen and it is said that the distance between the two is 216 miles. In any case the Holy Prophet(sa) stated, “That the rider will undertake this journey and he will be afraid of none other than Allah”, or he said, “He will only fear his sheep being attacked by a wolf.” The Holy Prophet(sa) then stated, “You however are showing impatience.” In other words, this could only be achieved by demonstrating patience. This is a narration from Bukhari.
Absolutely!
True
I don't think he is suggesting we not resist oppression, it is more like talk less do more.
True 🙏
Even a dog has right to defend themselves against suffocation.
That occupation has been a suffocation. No one takes extreme steps unless they think that’s the way to make a difference. An entire people cannot be oppressed for 75 years without a reaction.
I get your good intentions .. but plz realize this is a clipped sentence for unknown purpose .. passing a judgment on a man based on a clipped sentence is like the Zionist clipping oct 07 out of context. May Allah unit us
Well said!
Hamza, nearly the entire world is unified in their position against the atrocities being committed by Israel... if you’re out there, please clarify your position.
I dont understand.What did he say?
@@BobBilly506People saw a small clip of him saying something out of context and are rallying against him.
@@BobBilly506Please refer to his past comments wrt Masjid Al Aqsa, interview with Kim Iversen and a few others.
He has always been opposed to Israel
@BobBilly506
Yes can someone elaborate please.......
We should shame on ourselves. Even non muslims are more vocal than our so many famous Muslim scholars
For those who keep it silent and keep it in the Heart , that is the weakest of Faith
Patience is the name of Allah. Practicing it is remembering the all mighty.
@@SimonDeSousa-j5s remaining silent against oppression is the weakest of Faiths
@@SHAMzila85 In the Qur'an, Allah the Most High said: “And be Patient. Surely, Allah is with those who are patient.” I listen to the Quran.
@@SimonDeSousa-j5shave you ever read sura nisa ayat 75? Do you not think we should raise awareness of this ayah?
@@SimonDeSousa-j5s Salam. Being patient does not mean not to raise our voice or do nothing about injustice. Both should be done. The Quran is full of verses about defending ourselves against those who chase us out of our homes. But at the same time, we should be patient with the suffering. Allah says regarding fighting: if you suffer, they also suffer.
We should not rebel and be mad against Allah because something bad is happening to us, but we should stop injustice with our hands when we can do so. If not, with our tongue and if not, in our heart and this is the weakest of eman
And Allah knows best
I would not consider Hamza Yusuf as a mainstream Muslim scholar. Suffering in silence is only honorable in personal not social or global ordeals. The Palestinian cause is now a global war between good and evil, and anyone who denies such fact lacks humanity, and anyone who lacks humanity can never be a true Muslim.
Hamza Yusuf and many other Muslim scholars are actually IDF assets.
He is using and saying very Christian ✝️ concepts
"Sometimes its the means for survival "
"Sometimes its absolutely necessary to suffer in silence "
"But it doesn't mean it's final "
This is ✝️ concepts and ideology.
I'm assuming the Muslims in the audience recognised this and that's what got them going
This is being taken out of context! He has protested and rallied against Israel publicly for decades and its what he’s doing here in this public speech! He goes on long tangents and brings up many different ideas and discusses them. Please stop dividing the ummah!!!
It is your subjective opinion. Do not tell about the whole world. We all know and support Palestine. The best way is not to fall for the fitnah of zionists which is everywhere. Do not let them to fool you. Currently, making dua, boycotting their products and finding a way to make a donation to them are the best means of resistance from our side against evil.
Theres a stage of silent suffering and there is a stage of active rebellion....
Prophet Muhammad pbuh and his followers persecution in Makkah was a silent suffering initially until they migrated to madina and allah commanded them to fight (active rebellion).
Am no scholar but suffering in silence is an option on an individual level, but if a whole community is being bombed i dont think they should suffer in silence, I cant imagine if am the grand mufti of gaza i tell my community to suffer in silence, it makes no sense,
People have to protest injustice in which ever means necessary in Sharia, yes mistakes can be made but the intention is what matters
the fact that he cannot condemn an oppressor speaks volumes.
Are you living on Mars? You're on planet Earth, CZcams exists! Hamza Yusuf has always condemned Israeli occupation and has always defended Palestinians. In his last discussion with Chris Hedges, you can see that he is absolutely the reverse of what you think he is. It's a shame that Muslims can still be fooled by media disinformation.
It’s that white privilege
Now can Muslims stop supporting him. I've been saying for years that he was a snake in the grass
He condemned them. He said our principle is justified. I’m not a normalizer. He said now it’s a question of means, and suffering in silence is not final.
Your little mind cannot comprehend what sheikh said
We will not be silenced. Palestine will be free 🇵🇸❤️
Lol nope. Its not going to be free precisely because of such delusional approach.
@@szymonfandrejewski7984 "because of such delusional approach." Then what would be the right approach?
I respect sheikh Hamza, I learnt so much about Islam for him, and here’s my feedback: it’s not what you said sheikh that is the problem, it’s what you didn’t say. You have a powerful voice that can validate and support the Palestinian cause. Your voice and position is a privilege and a responsibility. I would have loved the opportunity to share my perspective with him. I hope he receives my message.
The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever among you sees evil, let him change it with his hand. If he cannot do so, then with his tongue. If he cannot do so, then with his heart, which is the weakest level of faith.” Sahih Muslim 49
Please don't listen to these western deviant speakers. There are many like him. Their trying to change Islam.
Follow the real scholars. The likes of Sheikh Al Albani, Sheikh bin baaz, Sheikh ibn Uthaymeen etc.
۩ Abu Dhar said, "I was with the Prophet ﷺ one day and I heard him saing: “There is something I fear for my Ummah than the Dajjal.”
It was then that I became afraid, so I said: 'Oh Rasool Allah! Which thing is that?" He ﷺ said, “Misguided and astray scholars.”
Musnad Imam Ahmad, hadith - 21334 aur 21335. Shaykh Shu'ayb al Arna'ut graded it sahih li ghayri (authentic due to corroborating narrations) in his tahqiq of the Musnad Imam Ahmad.
@@Therebelliousprince001 Albani who?
@@bayusagara3630 in his post I see Shaykh Arnaut. He was a great scholar in Syria, of Albanian origin. Not to be mixed with Albani.
Did you respect him when he compared the prophet Muhammad Sallahu Alayahi Wa salaam to Buddah saying you should learn about both? Did you like when he said Al aqsa should have a temple built upon it and the extremists are the ones who don’t want it? Now telling Palestinians to die in silence what do you like exactly
Stupid is knowing the truth seeing the truth but still believing the lies. Liberty and justice for Palestine 🇵🇸 Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤️
❤
There was a time when his lectures actually benefitted the Muslim Ummah. Then came a point after 911 when he started defining specific branches of Deen in a different way. Unfortunate
The same case with Yasir Qadhi.
The early scholars of Maliki, Shafii, Hanafi and Hanbali used to say nothing on important matters when summoned by Caliphs. They did not remain silent out of fear but avoided divisive entanglements. Scholars of today need to take lessons from them.
I am beginning to lose faith in some of these you tube sheikh. They confuse the basic teaching of Islam by their 'scholarship ' and academic research. I'm going to stay and try my best to practice the 5 pillars.
You guys are wahabi liars. "Sometimes after 911" you was a child then or not even born
@tazimudinali1853 I'm sorry to break it to you brother but most of the famous yt sheikhs, Muftis etc are deviants and cowards. Stick to the real scholars like Sheikh Al Albani, Sheikh Ibn Uthaymeen. Sheikh salih Al Fawzan etc
We have suffered in silence long enough, we just need to have the courage to fight back. Patience is gonna kill us slowly.
Hazrat Khabbab(ra) relates, “Once we expressed our troubles and hardship to the Holy Prophet(sa). At the time, the Holy Prophet(sa) was sitting on his sheet, reclining in the shade of the Ka‘bah. We submitted before him, ‘Will you not seek help for us? Will you not pray to Allah for us in these difficult conditions?’ The Holy Prophet(sa) replied:
“‘Look here! There were people before you, for whom a ditch would be dug and he would then be placed inside it. Then a saw would be placed on his head, cutting him into two pieces, yet this could not deter him from his faith. Or, his flesh would be clawed off from his bones and tendons with iron rings, yet this could not hinder him from his faith.’ The Holy Prophet(sa) then stated, ‘By Allah! Allah will surely fulfil this work (meaning his mission would surely be fulfilled). He will surely fulfil the purpose for which I have come. There will be times of ease as well.’ He further stated, ‘This will be to the extent that a rider will travel from Thana to Hadhar Maut.” Thana and Hadhar Maut are two cities in Yemen and it is said that the distance between the two is 216 miles. In any case the Holy Prophet(sa) stated, “That the rider will undertake this journey and he will be afraid of none other than Allah”, or he said, “He will only fear his sheep being attacked by a wolf.” The Holy Prophet(sa) then stated, “You however are showing impatience.” In other words, this could only be achieved by demonstrating patience. This is a narration from Bukhari.
@@shaqirisquarepants8940read surah hajj verse 39
True
No way, people must not be silent when genocide is committed ,when we see injustice
Israel understands only one language: armed resistance. It has been dragging negotiators like docile sheep, in exchange of privileges, from negotiation to negotiation.... Madam Mahmood Abbas and her daughters in PLO, know that. Afghanistan made Americans fly like rats by fighting, same thing for Vietnam, same thing for Iraq, sane thing for France after 132 years occupation in Algeria. Palestinians are not fighting Nazis. They are fighting the whole world, Arab countries included.
Interesting you say that considering once Egypt renounced violence, Israel was happy to give away land for peace. For the same reason they made peace with Jordan and have been normalizing relations with other Arab countries. However, if you look at the history of the Palestinian leadership -- whether their antagonism since the beginning of completely legal immigration of Jews in various riots and massacres, the Civil War in 1947, Black September in 1970, later moving to Lebanon and being the main cause for the 1982 war, continuous terrorist attacks, suicide bombings, plane hijacking against completely civilian targets over all those years, a reasonable person would realize where the obstacle to peace really lies, even when accepting wrongdoings by Israel and Jews.
I do think that we have to voice ourselves in a respectful way, but not silence ourselves.
We need to come together and be on the same path. We are stronger united as one.
I love Palestinian ❤️
That's really disappointing. We can not be silenced anymore!
So?
@@noum3877 your hasbara will no longer work.
Hazrat Khabbab(ra) relates, “Once we expressed our troubles and hardship to the Holy Prophet(sa). At the time, the Holy Prophet(sa) was sitting on his sheet, reclining in the shade of the Ka‘bah. We submitted before him, ‘Will you not seek help for us? Will you not pray to Allah for us in these difficult conditions?’ The Holy Prophet(sa) replied:
“‘Look here! There were people before you, for whom a ditch would be dug and he would then be placed inside it. Then a saw would be placed on his head, cutting him into two pieces, yet this could not deter him from his faith. Or, his flesh would be clawed off from his bones and tendons with iron rings, yet this could not hinder him from his faith.’ The Holy Prophet(sa) then stated, ‘By Allah! Allah will surely fulfil this work (meaning his mission would surely be fulfilled). He will surely fulfil the purpose for which I have come. There will be times of ease as well.’ He further stated, ‘This will be to the extent that a rider will travel from Thana to Hadhar Maut.” Thana and Hadhar Maut are two cities in Yemen and it is said that the distance between the two is 216 miles. In any case the Holy Prophet(sa) stated, “That the rider will undertake this journey and he will be afraid of none other than Allah”, or he said, “He will only fear his sheep being attacked by a wolf.” The Holy Prophet(sa) then stated, “You however are showing impatience.” In other words, this could only be achieved by demonstrating patience. This is a narration from Bukhari.
czcams.com/video/pzs7BuFhZGg/video.htmlsi=mapBSMRLkRujxxeE
That's not what he was seeing listen to his whole speech.
I would have never imagined my entire life that a person like Hamza Yusuf would say something like that with a smile on his face 💔
He used to be my fav sheikh till now 💔
Did you listen to the whole speech? Or only what these clowns want you to listen to?
Hamza Yusuf was speaking at a high level and most ppl don't understand what he was saying.
It's sad. Now you all are attacking him.
@@EbNorth I love Hamza Yusuf. I agree we need to listen to his entire speech before judging. He has immense knowledge so he deserves our attention.
Have you heard what he told about us in Syria?
@@AbwibrahimOwhat did he say?
If you have 5% of the patience that Gazans have, you will not be making this comment. Do some research before you jump on the wagon.
Tq Palastine, you showed us the true colors of some states and some individual... Please keep my faith to the right path ya Allah...
He’s been fighting against Israel for decades stop letting shaytan divide the ummah
Schut up you Evil 😝😡
"They planned, but Allah also planned. And Allah is the best of planners"...
"Behold, the help of Allah is near"
Verily, with hardship comes ease'
You can't defeat a people that know that death is not the end
Indeed, to Allah we belong and to Allah we shall return.”
Allahu Akbar
Ameen
Im not really seeing why people feel the need to call Shaykh Hamza out.
So his Zaytuna talk soon after 10/7, his public discussion with Chris Hedges on the history and current Palestinian situation a few weeks ago, his signed Zaytuna letter soon thereafter, and his numerous talks over the years weren't speaking out on the Palestinian cause?
He is using and saying very Christian ✝️ concepts
"Sometimes its the means for survival "
"Sometimes its absolutely necessary to suffer in silence "
"But it doesn't mean it's final "
This is ✝️ concepts and ideology.
I'm assuming the Muslims in the audience recognised this and that's what got them going
@@PhyuckYu420 I have heard other shuyukh in other context/circumstances also convey these ideas. These are not Christian ideals. They depend on the situation. Makkah is a good example.
@@Reewnat and after this the Ordinance to fight was sent by Allah (meccan period)
I’m sad to see people falling for a slandering campaign similar to what our mother Aisha went through .. how can people judge someone based on a clip and ask the world not start history from Oct 7 .. context matters … ALWAYS!
Cherry-picked. Cut and paste.
10000000% and who will benefit from this division. And who will pay the price for slandering and dividing on the day of judgment
Silence is complicity
- Bethlehem Pastor
In Islam .. it’s say something good .. or be silent.. in Islam .. change in you’re heart if you can’t in you’re hand .. in Islam .. seek excuses for your bothers .. especially when you don’t know full context .. so yes sometimes silence is complicity but not always
Silence is complicity if you are silent against someone else's oppression. Not if you are silent in your own ordeal
Unfortunately, i have heard another so call scholar say that B D S was haram. How can we stay silent in our pain? The world will not stay silent nor forgive.
لا تسمع لهؤلاء المنافقين. فهؤلاء هم علماء السلاطين
Not so.much BDS was haram, as a US born and raised muslim, living in the ME and traveling for the past 15 years. There is massive oppression done to themselves in muslim, no.rule of law and procedures, a simple polce report can be a nightmare, etc. Sudan mass rape and genocide, Pakistan kicking out afghans,torture methods. The truth will set you free but at first will cause you much pain. That pain is the internal realization of injustice to ourselves, countries like Algeria are such corruption and red tape admin all manual that some people want colonialism back in the sense of infrastructure. The la Pasteur institute in Algeria main public health lab has not changed since was built by France some minor changes. How come Germany, Japan recovery from devastating wars, why can not religion and Islam be used to create and develop, we are always playing the victim hood role and play the external forces blame card, which is true,however using this as a lack an excuse. Produc8ng own products or.high end products, cars, phones, etc all are dependent and will remain in a consumer slave role.
We Muslims are to blame to
for this. We have turned away from the Quran and the Sunnah and have adapted western ideologies. We have normalised major sin in our societies. How can we expect glory and victory?
@@Therebelliousprince001 most of the sins are normalized by the authority. And there are lots of brothers and sisters who refrain from sins . It's not necessary that they will always come in front of us. The destruction of a whole Civilization through sins only happens when the authority introduces it. No layman has power to destroy the sanctity of Muslim Civilization.
@servantofthemerciful3511 I don't know what you mean but one major sin that has spread is le's'bia'n'is'm amongst Muslims school girls in muslim countries.
There are multiple reports of thousands and thousands of them being found in the UAE, Pakistan and the whole of the MENA region. Even in Makkah there were cases found!
And this l'es'b'ia'n culture is accepted and normalized amongst girls in these countries.
Research on it.
I'm so glad people spoke out. Too many times these learned people say BS and think people won't call them out because of their stature
Yaa Rahman free Palestine 🇵🇸
Aameen
Sometimes, it better to suffer in silence? Thats the weakest form of opposition.
We need scholars speak about Palestine, i admire sheikh Omar Suleiman and others.
Omar Suleiman, the one who went supporting the LGBTQ+ and holding hands with them, is that who you talking about? They are all fake scholars for hire.
Omar Suleiman is probably worse than Hamza
He owns a whole institute trying to change Islam. Shame on him.
The same Omar Suleiman who performed pagan rituals with the rainbow crew?
There is a reason le's'b'ian fe'mi'nist hijabis and niqabis love Omar Suleiman
@@Therebelliousprince001 a lot of non muslim support Palestine too, so? I sad if muslim scholars just silent like nothing happen to the Gaza and Palestine.
This video is taken out of context, I Advise everyone before judging someone to verify, specially that those clips are cut and put together as one disgusting hate story.
I’m a Palestinian who listened to many of Sheikh Hamza Yusuf lectures, my first reaction to this video was “ This is not him “ I had to verify , I attached the link to the full video for everyone to see below.
On the Contrary, he said I want Free Palestine.
Be carful to share a video before knowing the full truth as you are helping those who benefit from our division and who wants us to doubt our scholars.
“ O you who have believed, if there comes to you a disobedient one with information, investigate, lest you harm a people out of ignorance and become, over what you have done, regretful”
الحجرات :6
czcams.com/video/pzs7BuFhZGg/video.htmlsi=QuaU0eHG-uGufzo3
I can't believe people did this to him, this honestly breaks my heart. I've benefited so much from his knowledge as well.
If it's out of context then why is the crowd reacting in that way?
@@ahsanmiah7539 A group of maybe 2-3 people in the back yelled and then others yelled "we love you Sheikh Hamza Yusuf!" and everyone cheered and the speech continued as normal. That is the parts they cut out, you can find the full video on yt.
Because not everybody came in to the speech at the same time probably.@@ahsanmiah7539
This is the comment Ive been looking for. Yusuf is constantly being critisized by the muslim community for literally no reason, in spite of the fact that he may very well be the most influential muslim scholar in the American world right now
*Uttered spontaneously, the phrase "We sometimes have to suffer in silence" can be prone to misunderstanding when taken out of context. It appears there's a determination to misconstrue Sheikh Hamza Yusuf's words, yet he transcends being a mere punching bag. What he likely intended was to convey the profound magnitude of our helplessness despite our earnest desire to assist. In the context of the ongoing genocide, the notion that sometimes we must endure suffering in silence reflects the shared experience of individuals grappling with anger and sorrow. It signifies a collective wish to contribute more than our current efforts permit, but alas, we find ourselves constrained.*
*حسبنا الله ونعم الوكيل*
*لا حول ولا قوة إلا بالله*
Allaah knows best . I learned from scholars thsy We should give the benefit of doubt to Muslims, may be that Sheikh meant by this the state of rest of the ummah who is suffering in silence and not . helping Palestinian enough. May Allaah make us extend the help to oppressed which can help them enough. Uptil that time keep connected to the cause through Dua , Tazkia , charity and boycott.
@@romana8889The prophet pbuh, and all the prophets and messengers were 1 men, with true faith as their divine shields and voice, and with this alone Allah SWT opened the doors of empires for them. When we talk about constraints and focusing on personal spirituality, although important, but sadly for me is often a brush off. Sometimes we lose sight of intention, and how Allah SWT can open up avenues towards this, it just requires removing constraints and strong, sincere iman
Thank you for your comment. What he said was absolutely true and there are many examples of this in the Quran and sunnah. Allah protect us from being petty, argumentative and abusive with one another. Our egos are out of control. Astaghfirullah.
What profound crap is this. He knew exactly what he was saying. The problem is except for those who almost worship him, he thinks everyone's going to fall for his crap. The ummah is seeing him for what he is... A mouth piece for these rulers
czcams.com/video/pzs7BuFhZGg/video.htmlsi=mapBSMRLkRujxxeE
He didn t say anything to support palestinians, just philosophical cowardice words
Yes, that’s all he is. Just full of academic nonsense. I would like him and his family to be shipped over to Gaza to stay and see how they fare.
I just don't understand, how can anyone even say stay silent? I hope I have misinterpreted Mr. Hamza.
He is using and saying very Christian ✝️ concepts
"Sometimes its the means for survival "
"Sometimes its absolutely necessary to suffer in silence "
"But it doesn't mean it's final "
This is ✝️ concepts and ideology.
I'm assuming the Muslims in the audience recognised this and that's what got them going
he is a zion agent..
@@PhyuckYu420this has nothing to with christianity but with a lack of common sense. You can’t just suffer in silence for 75 years when you’ve been humiliated and oppressed to your core. When oppression spreads, to resist it becomes a human duty.
They didn't post the full video, I couldn't hear all of what the Sheikh was saying or even one word of what the protestors were saying.
Yet they are praised for good reporting?
No, you haven’t misinterpreted him. He wants the Muslims to be like silent ghosts, and just bury their heads in academic Sufism. He is payed and funded by the United Arab Emirates. He’s not to be trusted.
The silence he refers to is our powerlessness to challenge Israel in a material way. It's that very recognition of powerlessness that makes us turn to Allāh with more sincerity.
This is a time for more unity amongst us, not less. Don't misconstrue what he said on purpose.
Remain silent, but you won’t have that luxury on the day of judgment
Palestinians didn’t want us to be silent. They been sharing videos and stories not to preach to the choir but, to raise awareness to those who had been manipulated by propaganda and expose those who are complicit.
Did he say we need to suffer in silence ?! What on earth is he mumbling about!
This is why short videos clipped from a long speech isn't effective & could be taken out of context like in this case.
Then what did he mean cause it was so cryptic even i didnt understand@@koreannyangtiger
۩ Abu Dhar said, "I was with the Prophet ﷺ one day and I heard him saing: “There is something I fear for my Ummah than the Dajjal.”
It was then that I became afraid, so I said: 'Oh Rasool Allah! Which thing is that?" He ﷺ said, “Misguided and astray scholars.”
Musnad Imam Ahmad, hadith - 21334 aur 21335. Shaykh Shu'ayb al Arna'ut graded it sahih li ghayri (authentic due to corroborating narrations) in his tahqiq of the Musnad Imam Ahmad.
@@koreannyangtigerhe has no point he’s a deviant sufi scholar who’s just told the Palestinians to die in silence, he’d be a shaking wreck if he had 5 minuets in Palestine, we must stand and listen to our brothers and sisters not tell them to shut up
@@Therebelliousprince001 It is about Salafis a.k.a Wahhabis
This video is cut and paste and is such a vile misrepresentation of Sh Hamza's full speech...i was there at the conference and can testify that everyone in the audience supported what he said, it was just a handful who were rudely interrupting based on misinformation.
Can you summarise what Sh Hamzah said?
This video does not paint him in a favourable light. I'd be disappointed if this was the extent of his message.
He wants to share Al Aqsa compound, and he is a sufi commiting shirk. This is not a sheikh.
@@DamnedTearsa true Muslim should give the benefit of doubt to other Muslims and don't easily assume him committing shirk and therefore a kafir
@@aaamie4650 There are videos and his own statements, NOT out of context. Stop doubting everything just because they speak eloquently...
@@DamnedTears typical goof making takfir on a scholar in the youtube comments. fear Allah
This guy should listen to himself talk sometimes. It doesn't sound real.
Stop! This is shaytan trying to divide the ummah and turn us against each other! He has been speaking out against Israel for decades! And he loves blacks his favorite people are Mauritanians he studied with! He has brain trauma and his clips were taken out of context! What does attacking one of our 2 billion brothers/sisters benefit us? Nothing! Stop it and go pray! Think about what you’re doing and saying!
For you, may be. Try to be more wise. In sha Allah, Allah will give you more hidaya, knowledge and logic.
He can hear himself talk, he's a deviant who has no shame. Simple as that
Okay, Mark Hanson of Walla Walla, Washington State. 😒
This guy is considered the West’s most influential Islamic Scholar and personally I find it really interesting he seems eager to condemn Arab and Black resistance.
He beloved by the west, because he is so called liberal
It describes the state western Muslims are in.
You seem eager to blast someone that has probably done more for the Muslims and the ummah in his lifetime that you have. Check yourself!
He isn't as popular as people assume I don't know what he has done or is said to have done but I don't really follow or listen to his work
This is the time when the righteous become righteous. He came short.
This scholar is a blessing to this ummah, unfortunately we won’t recognise it until it’s too late.
Say who?
@@MohamedAhmed-lc6ch say me
you can't tell these "muslim" youth anything. won't pray far but will attack one of our great scholars
pathetic
@@NewSmithsonian lol great schoIar. He is a great sellout. Why he supported Bush post 2001? Why he worked under the orange man in 2019? Why is he a member of WEF? He is always on the US' side.
I heard him talk about Palestine the week after the Israeli attack started so I don’t what they are talking about “being silent.” He is literally standing right behind a Palestinian flag what is silent about this.
The United States should end military aid to Israel.
1. Military Aid to Israel is unnecessary. Israel is a very prosperous country and more than capable of paying for its own military.
2.Military aid to Israel is a security risk to the United States. Israel has been selling American developed military technology to China for more than a decade. These sales have been instrumental in the modernization of China's military.
3.Military aid to Israel is a diplomatic liability,
4, Military aid to Israel is illegal under American law. Israel's human rights violations disqualifies Israel from receiving military aid under the Leahy law and Israel's refusal to allow inspections of its nuclear sites or sign the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty makes any aid to Israel illegal under the Symington Amendment.
Since when law is applicable when it is about Israel?
@@mersingjohor2826 The Symington Amendment exists, and Israel is in clear violation of it.
@@tylerdurdan7128 Too many US's or international laws Israel had violated or in violation.
They know and they don't care. They already have the number 1 superpower's nuts tight in their grip.
Suffering in Silence is what Palestinians have been doing for the last 75 years...
Good thing most people are watching the full version and not your short edited clip
He is recommending the whole ummah should suffer in silence , its not only Palestinians suffering, colonialism and capitalism has engulfed our all muslim lands and we have come to a point where our scholars tell us to stay silent....
I have never trusted him
Abu Dharr reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Verily, you are in a time of many scholars and few preachers. Whoever leaves a tenth of what he knows will be ruined. There will come a time for people of few scholars and many preachers. Whoever adheres to a tenth of what he knows will be saved.”
Source: Musnad Aḥmad 21372
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
Wahhabism was created by the West and the real reason of this innovation is to destroy the root of Islam.
soldiers of various gods are killing babies...
This account has to be a troll with that LGBT looking picture and that fake sounding username. Either troll or FBI honeypot account.
@@ahmeda.3198 Looks like we have a butthurt Hamza Yusuf Fanboy here. 😂🤣
@@Therebelliousprince001 Gay is calling people somebody’s fan boy when he went and found a fellow LGBT wearing make up and posted that as his picture. Either FBI, troll, or deep in the closet.
There are always people who find pleasure in dragging other Muslims down and think they’re doing the rest of us a favor. Hamza Yusuf is better than all the haters combined.
The Muslim world needs to be unified in the solution to the problems it faces. The Islamic solution is and always has been the resumption of the Islamic way of life through the re-establishment of the khilafah state. Any other solution is a false and unislamic solution.
This is absolutely Not right and disrespectful towards a Very kind - highly respectable - valued scholar of our Umma!
Its Very easy to give advise on "political" views and so and so do this in a such way without having context and knowledge of the events.
Sheikh Hamza is Very honorable and sincere to His Umma and community. We need to appreciate what we have during these Very difficult times instead of creating fitna and nifaq. I Beg You.
Tjis Video should not have even been posted!!!! Period. If so, then please upload the entire presentation for the support and respect and prayers He is given and Deserves.
"Whoever sees a crime, let him use his hands to stop it. If he cannot, let him raise his voice. If he cannot, let him say it in his heart, and that is the weakest of faith." -Prophet Muhammad (saw)
Hamza Yusuf is an Israeli collaborator with UAE complicity in the genocide against Gaza and Palestinians !! He is a mufti on UAE ruler court who has recognized fascist Israel
You cant prove that
Ittakuwallah
@@TheUneducatedTeacherwhere ya been? All well documented in glowing western media
Makes sense. The UAE is the worst "muslim" country in the world.
akbar120 How much money did you get from Zionists?
No justice No peace! Shout it loud.
Unless you want to give Israel a helping hand that is.
Please please my sisters and brothers, it's extremely important to be united and unified, the one and only thing that break us or fall us apart is our infighting and disagreement, we can't afford more infighting any more, so please please please STAY UNITED. United and collective we stronger.
what you resist, persists, what you tolerate tends to grow and what you look at disappears!
DONT FALL for SLANDERING COMMENTS,!!!!!!!!!! sooooooo many comments slandering him .. I went to their other comments .. they are NOT Muslims, fake profiles, or pro-Is. Adding comments like “he showed his true colours” etc !!! I can’t believe that someone is creating a campaign against our beloved IMAM in a such deceiving manner .. what will they gain!!!!
Very very disappointing to hear this from someone as influential as him … Gaza war has revealed the true faces of everyone
Hamza Yusuf brought me back to Islam and we cannot harm our ummah anymore so anyone who protests him needs to shut up and rethink their priorities. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
He is using and saying very Christian ✝️ concepts
"Sometimes its the means for survival "
"Sometimes its absolutely necessary to suffer in silence "
"But it doesn't mean it's final "
This is ✝️ concepts and ideology.
I'm assuming the Muslims in the audience recognised this and that's what got them going
@@PhyuckYu420those are not exclusively Christian concepts so stop spamming everyone with that nonsense in this psyop to divide the ummah of Islam. Christ is Palestinian and a Muslim prophet. And Christ didn’t even suffer in silence he whipped the corrupt leaders in the temple with the cat of nine tales which is exactly what we all need to do. 🇵🇸
@@End_Zionism deny all you want....these are Christian concepts and that's why the Muslims called him out!
"Suffer in silence"?? It's like asking women accused of witchcraft by church, not to cry or shout in pain and agony when they were burned alive.
@@desig23who is calling for k!Iing innocents?? You are conflating defending one's self to k!Iing of innocents. Your So called shaykh HY wants us to do nothing when z==nists come for us.
i think he is normalizing
Since you think .. not sure .. this is a moment where silence is better than talking .. because if this accusation is false .. and leads to slandering similar to our mother Aisha slander .. how will you face Allah??? May Allah unit us
Yes, he wants Muslims to stay quiet and bury their heads in academic Sufism, which is actually not even considered Islam by many scholars. Someone should send him and his family to live in Gaza for a couple of months and see how quiet he remains.
He is fully funded and supported by the United Arab Emirates . That’s how he rose to power and influence in the US so fast.
Don't be shocked if he starts claiming that not liking the KKK is the same as being anti-Christian.
Mauritania became the last state to abolish slavery, in 1981. In 1990. 99% Muslim.
So what’s your conclusion? And where you able to make it based on a clipped half of a sentence .. Im asking based on the assumption u have good intentions and seriously care about not slandering anyone yet standing by the truth
@@Darkangel01966Christian Europeans also owned African slaves and took to many countries to work for their masters. In Pakistan there is an African minority who were bought there by the British during colonial times. Everyone knows about the trans Atlantic slave trade. Slaves from Africa were sold and sent work in the Caribbean, North and South America in inhuman condition. It was continued till the 19th Century. Around 2 million slaves died while traveling in the Ocean. Also slavery in the US wasn't abolished just because people were good hearted. Slavery was only completely stopped after a war took place. Learn the history properly before spreading misinformation. You Christians used your religion to gain public support for slavery and colonizing different countries. Try to come up with a better argument.
@@FrostKaiserAbsolute idiot, Christianity was used to destroy slavery 😂
@@FrostKaiserAlso even you muslims done slave trades aswell and used your own religion to excuse it , such as the arab slave trade 😂
Telling the Palestinians to suffer in silence?! Send this guy to Gaza and see how quiet he stays astaghfirullah, sitting in the lane of kufr lecturing the champions of this ummah as they’re genocided what a ridiculous claim, we should listen to the cry of the oppressed and aid them any way you can seeking the pleasure of Allah
He is using and saying very Christian ✝️ concepts
"Sometimes its the means for survival "
"Sometimes its absolutely necessary to suffer in silence "
The Bethlehem Christian Pastor from Palestine said, silence is complicity
What a hypocrite? Stating silent is collaborating with Oppressor.
We may not agree with Shaykh Hamza Yusuf on certain aspects, but he's one of the most sincere and brilliant Muslim scholars in the West... Thanks to him Islamic sciences are taught in the US. Thanks to him there's today a college (namely Zaytuna College) that's playing a major role in making Islamic culture and philosophy part of the American academia. People seem unaware of this fact. Not agreeing with someone doesn't mean denying his commitment for his religion. No one has the right to accuse him of betraying his principles. I personally don't agree with his views about Palestinian resistance and some other political issues (who am I to agree or not agree with such an amazing intellect) but I do admire his work and listen to his lectures that remain intellectually priceless. Shaykh Hamza Yusuf is a beacon of Islamic knowledge in the West. No one should deny this.
By the way, recently, his discussion with Chris Hedges shows to which entent he is ethically and spiritually committed to the Palestinian issue...
Well said.
Remember that this guy was an advisor to Bush after 911 and was responsible for changing the name of the war against Afghanistan and Iraq from 'operation infinite Justice' to 'operation enduring freedom'
To make it more appealing.
He is learned, don’t know bout the rest of the jokers posting against him
I hope you all realise he’s done more for the Muslim community than any of the people writing negative comments about him here.
Done what other than pacify musIims to become defeatists? Why is he an 'agenda contributor' to WEF and what agenda is that?
That’s a generalisation and baseless at that.
@@Umme-45 how is that generalised ? This guy has so many lectures online with hundreds and tens of thousands of views, he’s changed so many people’s lives including my own. He’s also done so much to change western perception of Islam and invite more people to it.
This makes me question Hamza Yusuf’s intention, and with whom his loyalties lie
Watch his video with Chris Hedges before questioning Hamza Yusuf's intentions. The video is titled: The Hundred Years' War on Palestine with Journalist Chris Hedges & Pres. Hamza Yusuf
I think people need to understand that he is trying to explain a message of hope. People are protesting and shouting but it does not end the occupation or war. He doesn’t state that it is wrong, but he wants to explain that after a year, we maybe won’t shout as hard as we do now, but we should not lose hope because we know what will happen in the end. So if you suffer, even if it is in silence, justice will always serve in the end.
On top of that. It is extremely disrespectful to shout at a scholar of such degree like the people in the public did. You have to control your emotions and maintain good manners, especially in a place like that.
May Allah guide us all.
❤
i was a big fan of hamza yusuf until now.very much disappointed with his response in this time of ummah.hope he retracts his statement soon. #fromtherivertotheseapalestinwillbefree
You should watch the whole speech before writing your comment. You should watch Hamza Yusuf's last discussion with Chris Hedges about Palestine before saying you're disappointed. A real Muslim should be careful when drawing conclusions. A real Muslim shoud make sure that media is not misleading him/her.
Would love to hear the WHOLE lecture to know the context in which he's bringing this up before I jump the gun & start commenting upon this clip only (which is shocking to hear by itself).
This man is knowlegable, so I don't expect this only from him.
Allaah knows best what is in the hearts
We were silent for 75+ years. This occupation and oppression have to end now. We can't even do anything except raising our voices and making dua. If we even stop doing that How Allah will ever forgive us!
I will post the full video link soon, not this edited misrepresentation
This is too short of a clip to understand what was said. Sh Hamza clearly said that he's not a normaliser. Let us hear the entire clip before pointing a finger.
I used to call this thing cheikh Hamza. Basically he's just asking Gaza's people and those who ache with them to suck it up and suffer in silence.
One of the wisdom of crisis like Palestine is that Allah seperates the good and the rotten. He shows us who's standing with the truth and who's standing on the other side. So indeed Allah is all knowing and all wise.
Reminder, 'scholars' like Hamza Yusuf are madkhalis. 'Suffer in silence' is what the other madkhalis have been saying in the last month's.
Shame on these 'scholars'
I disagree with some of Sheikh Hamza Yusuf’s actions but heckling a scholar like this is unacceptable.
Many scholars and layman have criticized him, and perhaps his cooperation with Zionists will be a stain on his legacy. Nonetheless, scholars must be respected for their knowledge and criticized with adab.
I agree.
You’ve gotten away with a lot, Hamza. This new generation is not gonna let you get away with your shady tactics and verbiage.
But the new generation is okay with lg'b't and fe'm'in'is'm?
I’m referring to the new generation of practicing Muslims who understand the Deen.
His message doesnt resonate with those killed and being oppressed now
This new generation lacks hikmah
This man spoke for a min but said nothing other than a bunch of political sentences that made no sense. Shame on him.
Be careful from whom you learn your religion from!
Why did Hamza Yusuf accuse the noble resistance of not following the teachings of Islam by taking hostages? Very dishonest of a Muslim Cheikh to say such a thing in a time of war. Didn't the early Muslims take Sabaya? I question Hamza Yusuf's silence alongside Abdulhakim Murad, are you guys not part of the Ummah.
Ya’ll, please stay away from backbiting. You can disagree without doing that.
Not only does it give room for conniving people to sow division (and get you to do evil) but it also could lead to you owing that person your hasanat on Yawmul Qiyamah, and don’t let it it be more than one person either…
Sheikh Hamza Yousuf is a blessing for our generation. May Allah give him the best reward in both worlds. ameen
Sh Hamza did a podcast on the 100 year war in Palestine with Chris Hedges. They discussed the atrocities and a Palestinian guest gave an action plan for bringing about change.
no one should ever suffer in silence ...EVER
Common people waving a few flags and attending a few marches think they've done more for the ummah than this man 😂 ask yourselves when did you last wake up in the night and protest directly to Allah with tears in your eyes?
Yall misunderstood what hes said. Some people let their emotions get the better of them and lose rationale in their argument. Anyone who knows Shaykh Hamza Yusuf knows that what hes being made out to have said isnt what he actually said.
If you don't have doubts about this guy, you should think again.....