THE CHINESE CIVIL WAR EXPLAINED - CHINESE CIVIL WAR DOCUMENTARY PART 1 - TEN YEAR CIVIL WAR
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 01. 2019
- The Chinese civil war, a three decade long conflict that still divides the Chinese people, is an essential aspect of the History of China. In this Chinese civil war documentary, I talk about the first united front between the communist party of china and the kuomintag, and the Ten Year Civil War that followed.
If you would like to make a donation, here is my paypal : paypal.me/historyofchina
Many thanks !
PART 2 : • THE CHINESE CIVIL WAR ...
= tags =
Chinese civil war
ten year civil war
civil war china
chinese civil war explained
chinese civil war documentary
guerre civile chinoise
guerre civile chinoise documentaire - Zábava
Never realized how crazy this era of China was until you went into detail about it. Nice job
Thank you ! I'll make many more videos of the early 20th century in China :)
朋友，不是我故意難為這位視頻製作者，這是假的中國歷史。This is fake history. This is Communist history in China.
I found your series on the Taiping Rebellion to be very revealing. I run a channel on geopolitical and historical topics, and I have a proposition for you. Is there a way to get in touch?
Hi, thanks a lot ! You can contact me at this address : history.of.china1@gmail.com
History of China Thank you. I just sent you a mail, let me know if you’re interested. We can work out the details.
Well this is juicy. Can't wait to see what becomes of this collaboration.
The comment that started it all. The greatest, most ambitious crossover in history. I am so grateful to have found this comment and thread, CaspianReport was the one who introduced me to this great, severely underrated channel.
@@deinekes9 Ambitious indeed
I’ve read about this era of Chinese history, and watched more than a few documentaries. This is the best one ever. Clear coherent narrative with an excellent grasp of detail and the grand historical context.
Thank you so much for granting this fan’s wish! Awesome video. I can’t wait for the next parts!
And once again, I love your videos, please keep at it, because I'm sure you'll get the views you deserve eventually :)
Hi, thanks so much for your enouragement :)
Just found your channel after hearing your feature on Caspian Report-very solid videos, you deserve more subs!
Thanks !
Thank you so much! Very instructive:)
Thank you for making the ONLY English speaking video on youtube about this era without PRC propaganda.
I would love to see a sprawling tv-show with all the betrayals, intrigue and conflict of this civil war in it. I know so little about it, living in the west, but it is arguably the most significant conflict from the 20th century, aside from the world wars.
I agree there is a great potential ! Unfortunately, most films or series made on the subject are produced in the PRC so have a terribly biased view towards the CPC, and usually are somewhat inaccurate
Yeah watching this video (which is great) i realized that if you don't have any background it's kind of hard to follow.
Because of the current political climate, i wonder from which country a neutral documentary series/dramatization could be made.
To put it short: YOU ARE BY FAR THE VERY BEST👍👍
I am 2 years late but I just wanted to say thanks for this. I have always been interested in this topic
I'm glad you enjoyed it :)
Merci à toi.
A great series on China. Thanks.
Glad you enjoyed!
Thanks for this vidéo ! Could you make an another one about the 2nd sino-japanese war ? And about the continuation of the civil war till 1949 ?
Thanks again !
Glad you enjoyed ! I definitely will cover the 2nd-Sino Japanese war some day. I already finished covering the civil war, here are parts 2 and 3 :
czcams.com/video/yfxeFlLWHD4/video.html
czcams.com/video/ikNqJ41wcQI/video.html
Good video, I'm excited for the next episode! What books would you recommend for learning more about the Chinese civil war?
Thanks, glad you enjoyed ! The thing is, the vast majority of books focuses on the second part of the Civil War (1945 - 1949) and generally ignores the first part (1927 - 1937).
There is the book "The Kuomintang and the Chinese Civil War : 1927 to 1949" (2017) by G. P. Douglas, but it doesn't go into precise detail and seems a bit biased. Still a good overview though.
I also found this online thesis that is very complete : scholarship.shu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3416&context=dissertations
For the second part of the war, I would recommend Odd Arne Westad's "Decisive Encounters : The Chinese Civil War, 1946 - 1950" (2003), which is also a good overview of the conflict.
Hope this helps :)
@@History_of_China nice list
Now I know what Kuomintang is and who chiang kai shek was. Thanks you.
No problem ! I will soon make the final part of this series that will explain what they become :)
Would you have an primary source, your series on the Chinese Civil War was so good I decided to do a history project on it for my leaving cert
Always be on the lookout for history writing with an agenda... For full transparency, it would be interesting to see what bibliograpy you used for this video essay.
Agreed
I find this channel is telling the truth. Not biased.
Chiang Kai-shek was support by the British and the U.S. while Mao Zedong was supported by Russia. This video seems distorted.
4:30
I recall reading in the book, "The Generalissimo", Chiang Kai-shek had no hand in the taking of Wuhan, which was taken by the more left wing factions of the National Revolutionary Army while Chiang and more right wing NRA soldiers went east, aiming for Shanghai and Nanjing.
And it was Wang Jingwei and other left wing KMT members who had declared Wuhan for the capital, not Chiang, who was actually opposed to that decision as he declared the real capital to be Nanjing after taking it in 1927.
Long live Sun Yat-sen !
You forgot to mention to the May 4th Movement, cause give birth to the Chinese Communist Party. Chang Kai Shek also attend military academy in Japan.
I deliberately left it out in this vid, otherwise I would have wanted to talk about the reasons of the movement and it would have taken too much time. I have mentioned the event it other vids, but will make a special May 4th Movement video :)
Concerning Chang Kai Shek, same thing, I will most likely do a biography some time.
Who needs Mister Beast when we got this channel
do you happen to have any video question/guides for the parts 1-3 I use this in my World history classes
Hi, I'm not really sure what you mean. Could you elaborate?
how can I get the pdf materials with the text context of your videos?
I'm afraid I don't have the script anymore for these videos
Where can I find the music used in this video? Especially the piece played 9:00 in!
Nevermind I found it! It's 赴戰 To Battle!
do you know the song playing from 7:30
What about Liu Bei's documentary since you done Cao Cao and Sun Quan.
I will do one ! Just need to make at least part 2 of the Chinese Civil War first :)
@@History_of_China Great thanks so much!
Which enraged his father who punished him severely
how long does it takes to make 1 video?
Hi, it would be at least 2 weeks if I have enough free time, otherwise maybe up to a month or so :)
What movie is that footage from?
The movie footage is from the film "The Founding of a Party
" (2011). I also used parts of it in my video about Yuan Shikai.
Rest of the footage is historical authentic images:)
@@History_of_China Thanks my dude, its a crime how under appreciated your channel is!
8:10
Looks like the Axis of War: the First of August film did a splendid job to recreate that scene
Quick question: why were the communist opposed of the left wing faction of the KMT and the northern expedition?
Not all communists were opposed to the left wing KMT and Northern Expedition. Those who were probably just didn't trust the KMT after Sun Yat-Sen's death, since Chiang Kai-Shek was clearly not a communist/left wing sympathiser, and were purged during the 1296 Canton Coup. Keep in mind that the communsits answered to the commintern, while the KMT was strongly independant
Sebaikx di beri tex bahasa indonesia bos
Communist Party in Shanghai on April 12th: Anybody else hearing the Evil Morty theme?
Chiang on March 21st when Communists looted foreign concessions: Why are you gay?
But why were there warlords in the first place? Is there a vid on that? I feel like I walked in half way through a movie 😂
Not yet! There will be eventually
Chiang Kai-shek, the 12th April 1927 : "execute order 66"
@Soren G communism is the best thing on earth ahah
@Soren G sorry but this is a mainstream argument which is unefficient. How many death with capitalism ? Everyday ? I mean your point can be used for EVERY economic system. If you want to argue with me please study your topic and use strong arguments... not things that can be said by a children under propaganda
@Soren G by example : with the Taiping rebellion, there has been 30 millions death. Could the empire be account responsible for that only because it was an empire ?
Now knowing qhT China went through, it wS a,feat for CPP to build China to the global paer itcua today making Chinese self sufficient in foid, education
And I thought Game of Thrones was a complicated political cluster fuck.
Got is literally the rose war
I wondered why the Kumingtang originated in Canton but they weren't Cantonese peoples?
It might date back to when Sun Yat Sen was constantly on the run between Canton and Hong Kong. Dr. Sun was on the Most Wanted list by the Qing government for his “rebellious” activities so he needed a quick and efficient escape to Hong Kong (and maybe even travel to Japan and the US) which was a British colony at the time.
Sun Yat Sen was leading a defunct group, from Canton before joining KMT@@jacksonleung4479
Correction: Chiang 蔣介石was trained in Japan not Russia. His oldest son 蔣経國was educated in Russia.
Do you personally think that Chiang Kai-shek was a good leader, overall, and better or worse than Mao? I know MANY Westerners especially Americans seem to attack and criticize him a LOT these days, do you think they are being objective??
我是中國人。蔣中正乃是民族英雄，怎能與共產主義者相比？西方有些人說他獨裁，那是你們的價值觀，自由主義的價值觀。只要做對的事，獨裁也沒有什麼。
蔣中正為人非常自律，早上6點一定會起床，晚上9點一定會睡覺。自從22歲起，每天不間斷的寫日記，直到89歲去世。持續57年。請問，你能做到嗎？
蔣中正日記，今天已經存放在美國斯坦福大學，你自己去讀。再來評價這個人。
西方人在共產主義者的宣傳污衊下，扭曲真相，以訛傳訛。可恥。
@@alienslui8863 但如果這個男人允許民主選舉，也許西方歷史學家會尊重他，而不是批評他。還有，他殺台灣平民呢？(I'm using Google Translate, bro)
@@ArnoldTeras 什麼平民，那是赤化份子。
選舉，就你們這智商，給你選票你能選擇對？民主真的一定對？
@@ArnoldTeras 自由主義者把一個具有兩面性的詞語當作絕對真理。要明白，人民永遠是愚昧的，真理只掌握在英雄手中。一味的媚民，只會萬劫不復。
看完你們的視頻，發現你們受共產主義者的宣傳太深。你們所謂的“中國歷史”，其實就是共產主義在中國的發展史。
要想了解中國歷史，還是看中國人怎麼講。
How is this propaganda? Explain please.
@@jordyj4126 How？聽我解釋：
影片開始，為什麼要強調1921年中國由軍閥統治？中國由軍閥統治早就有了，自從1913年。為什麼只講1921年，是因為在這一年，共產黨建立。
第二點。當時的中國地圖，有一個“西康省”，這個西康省在四川省西面，西藏東面。視頻裡的地圖有嗎
@@jordyj4126 確切的說，這個視頻的地圖是共產黨人統治中國後的地圖。
當時地圖上有“察哈爾省”“熱河”“綏遠”，在東北部，有9個省，地圖上有嗎？
@@alienslui8863 pretty sure in 1921 china was still divided by many warlords around china and yuan shikai gov already collapsed meaning no actual gov is established yet. And 2nd he was talking about chinese civil war after yuan shikai collapse.
@@jordyj4126 但是，為什麼要強調1921年，1915年中國內戰就爆發了。
CCP propaganda
and so? Vietnam and China were once communist countries, and now they are both capitalist
@@ericlai1659 China is very much still communist
Aww, does it hurt hearing the truth about your precious KMT?
Nguyen vietcong dog think chiang loved them🤣🤣🤣
@@oscarstrokosz2986 PRC will fall.
This’s the version of CCP over Chinese Civil War