CANADIAN JOB NUMBERS: Private sector slows, civil service grows under Trudeau
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 08. 2024
- Sun political columnist Lorne Gunter on how under the Justin Trudeau Liberal’s, the expanding civil service is dragging down the Canadian economy.
Im so sick of this government
Private is sick of paying public jobs.
But Turdeau isn't sick of it.
it's outright theft and transfer of wealth to a subset of the population in order to hold onto political power
@@saltymonkey8874 I'm pretty sure that is his goal. Everything he does is sinister. He works hard not only to undermine our prosperity, our culture and our freedoms but also everything our forefathers built.
Every country has Private-Public its called Communism, CGTN The Point-Hub-Heat, RT International Africa Summit-SPIEF, Telasur, Middle East Eye, Shanghai Eye, TRT World.. Reporterfy Media-Cyrus Janssen
Every country has Private-Public its called Communism, CGTN The Point-Hub-Heat, RT International Africa Summit-SPIEF, Telasur, Middle East Eye, Shanghai Eye, TRT World.. Reporterfy Media-Cyrus Janssen
Kevin O'Leary, " I want to pick my words carefully. Trudeau is the very very very worst PM ever."
"our country is run by idiots"
@@stuomsen5094 And Traitors.
😂😂😂😂
@@stuomsen5094 haha
Possibly communist?
Carbon tax, sales tax, gst, hst, payroll tax, etc.....tax on everything. They're just squeezing middleclass
Basically if you have a job. It's give me all of that. It's a stick up at this point.
They’re attempting to tax their way out of the problems they themselves created by massively overspending.
Welcome to Communism
Don't forget rain tax lol
Not just that, they take Employment Insurance and then when you need what you pay for they deny you. So im done paying into E.I and I’ve told my employer that.
I'm counting the days until we get our country back.
Good luck with that. Canada will never be what it was
Looool it's done bud
I think we're too far gone for that. My neighborhood is slowly turning into Mogadishu. I'm in the process of moving to a small town to live out my remaining years with Canadians.
@@Redneckboy991 the only way to escape that. Move further and further away from the city. Exactly what I did. I'm on my fourth move already. It's tiring.
@@robhersey1796 Crazy
Justin Trudeau: easily the worst Prime Minister in Canada's history.
What would you expect with him being just a part- time drama teacher and snow boarder instructor?
Made the most money in history
@@chachingchaching3278For who?
I have my doubts if Trudeau understands the simple words you used. Too much for him to comprehend!
@@davidmorton9722the club .... durrrp😅
I'm 71 years old and I have never voted Liberal once in my entire life. Am I proud? Damn right!
Good for you! I'm only 32, but I can say the same. I do remember being called a racist nazi back in 2015 for refusing to even consider a spoiled, unqualified trust fund twat to be pm.
🎉
We won’t know the true damage of what Trudeau has done to Canada, until he leaves.
What he did to Canada is criminal and needs to be held accountable.
Deport him to his home country, Cuba.
Not just Trudeau, but the Liberal voting corroborators!
That's true & I can almost bet that it's worse than we figure.
It's Called " weaponized incompetence " .
Klaus Schwabb has said you don’t need to invade a country with a military, you just need to put people in power that will not enforce laws and push the WEF agenda.
That’s exactly what we have in Canada.
Our economy is afflicted by uncertainty, housing troubles, foreclosures, global shifts, and the aftermath of the epidemic, all of which contribute to instability. To restore stability and drive growth, all sectors must urgently address rising inflation, slowing GDP, and trade disruptions.
The US dollar is losing value due to inflation, while other currencies are gaining strength, creating uncertainty. Nonetheless, many people remain confident in the Dollar's perceived safety. I'm concerned that my 420K retirement funds may lose value, therefore I'm looking for other financial stability.
With my stressful career, I don't have time for investment analysis. For seven years, a fiduciary has managed my portfolio, responding to market situations, ensuring for effective navigation and informed decisions. Consider taking a similar plan of action.
Do you mind if I ask you to recommend the coach you employed? It seems you've figured it all out.
My CFA, 'Leah Foster Alderman', is a well known figure in her field. I recommend looking into her qualifications further. She has extensive knowledge and is a treasure trove for anyone seeking to manage the financial markets.
Thanks. her handler was simple to locate and appears to be extremely capable and adaptable. We scheduled a phone conversation.
100,000 a month so they will vote for Truduh. Can we please secure our Federal election to only Canadian citizens only being able to vote by having to show Canadian citizenship?
What we actually need is an electoral collage. Right now, Quebec and Ontario hold all the cards. they have since Canada officially got a constitution. Each election is the same. 85% of Canada votes out the Liberals, Quebec and Ontario vote them back in.
An electoral collage would give each province x number of votes... so say 1 each. That is 10 and 2 territories, so we need one tie breaker. We would quickly see Canada go back to being one of the best countries in the world. Each province would now have a say. Do you really think P.E.I. has a say in the shaping of our country? Oh... Its no longer Trudeau.... now its Turdeau or Turd-water. Prime minister turdwater.
Since when have non-citizens been eligible to vote?
If i had my way I would onnly allow immigrants who have filed at least 10 tax returns be allowed to vote
@@InvisibleHotdog since always . new comers only have to show proof of where they live and a drivers licence . You don’t need to be a Canadian citizen to get a drivers licence . If they don’t have ID you can claim your ID and address in writing and have someone that knows you vouch for you … it’s so wrong and it needs to change
@@InvisibleHotdogsince Trudeau dictator is running the show
Just what we need, bigger government to provide slower and poorer service to Canadians. Thanks Comrade Trudeau.
He ain't no comrade of mine...! FJT and anyone else who supports him and his idiocy.!!!
7 layers of management per federal front line worker?? That's brutal!
That's Trudeau.
The country is being ran by Peter Pan and other cartoon characters.
Aladdin and Princess Potato.
cartoon characters or horror movies characters?
The woke have eliminated Elmer Fudds except in the government.
Freeland looks like a wicked witch she's just missing the broomstick and pointy hat
More like zoolander and the village people
In other countries you work for the government if you’re dumb and can’t make it in the private sector. In Canada, it’s a badge of honor.
I know, the dullards are doing best by holding everyone else back on flimsy DEI and Net Zero Carbon excuses.
A quick calculation shows us that the cost of the civil service increase costs Canadian tax payers north of 8 billion dollars annually. This is money that doesn't go into social services or to pay off the national debt or to hospitals or to the military.
Ya how about money I could keep in my pocket instead of getting crushed by taxes. This right here is the reason canada is shit because people like u think we need public services
isnt that what the gst is for.
@@user-vc9fw5su3jNope the GST was pay off the debt but after Mulroney Chretien another liberal Marxists that put GST into general revenue to pay fro his spending. All Liberal gov’s run deficits. Ban the Liberals.
civil servants do not increase prosperity. In fact, it's quite the opposite
He’s increased the size of the public sector so much because he knows they’ll vote for him.
Did he because we got no one new in our office? Where are these workers please we would like to assign them some work?
It's not a government, it's a syndicate.
We feel your pain Canadians, Trudeau is a disgrace and should resign in shame.
That’s exactly what happened in Argentina, big government with the largest civic servants , big spenders , lots of welfare ,job for nepotism galore if you knew anybody working for the government the whole family were in the government payroll, they lost the control of spending , fancy travel ,meals in luxurious restaurants at the cost to all the taxpayers and this is exactly what is happening in Canada. The Trudeau government is abusing taxpayer money when Trudeau went to the meeting of the G 7 ,spent 250.000 dollars in food and entertainment they have to stop the abused to taxpayers,
Are all the jobs going to FOREIGN BORN WORKERS like in the US? I'm going to guess; YES SAR PLEASE SAR
Not all and they are better workers than ours according to my relatives who work in the food service industry.
which jobs are they taking that you want? they brought in 20B of their savings from overseas to Canada. Canada's trade surplus with the US last year was $60B. It's true the government miscalculated and brought in too many people which is lowering standard of living for all the middle class and lower...but that's not the crux of the economic issue if one has a brain
Yeah, they only hire foreigners now. This idiot saying they're better workers has obviously never had to deal with them. Today I was handed a warm 'iced' coffee, but at least I got a straw unlike the day before. This is probably about the simplest order and they struggle to not screw it up. And it's like that at almost every fast food joint. They put their fingers inside your cup when they pick it up to fill it, and hold the lid with their gingers on the top and bottom. I doubt they wash their hands because that's not their culture, which is why they always shake hands with their left and using your right hand is considered offensive.
Service Canada will be soon known as Service India!
95% of the jobs in every fast food place, Walmart and other places in my home town are now all immigrant workers. The people who worked in these places for years (some I knew worked in Walmart for 20 years) are now gone, either because their hours were cut so much they had to quit,or they were let go. My uncles grandson got his first job in A&W and he was the only non-east indian there. They did their best to make it so miserable for him to quit. He was 16 years old. How are Canadians born and raised in this country supposed to get work when so many entry level or private sector jobs are now only given to new international students or immigrants?
Allowing 100,000 people into the country every month. Ask yourself- how is that in any way logical? It's not. So what's driving this decision?
Oligarchs on one hand that want cheaper foreign workers for jobs they can't export and continuously increasing consumer consumption due to increasing population. Then there's the leftists that want to replace Canadians so it works for them too.
My explanation of the actual facts was censored. That's how I know I was on target.
Incompetence at its finest. Spoiled rich kid never had to count or worry about $, for him $ was easy.
Then he lies when he adds like 40% to ALL CAD $ EVER, in less than 2 years, and says, that doesn't cause inflation. It does, called Quantity Theory of Money, so either PMJT is a LIAR, OR he is clueless and incompetent? Either way he needs to step down. Worst PM EVER LOL
It’s all about importing Liberal votes.
part of bringing this many people is to drive down the wages. they are willing to work for less money especially in the construction and trucking industry. i was talking with a drywall guy and asked him how long he will be in Canada, he said 1 year. then said international student and laughed. i was talking with a red seal steel stud guy. he was saying the wages in his trade are already coming down.
The jobs numbers are up!! We just hired 5000 new gender enforcement and compliance officials
Each one with their own support staff, and 7 layers of management.
@@mattwood852 of course otherwise who's going to bring them their gender fluids when they get thirsty?
He's already hired all his Liberal student staffers for the summer.
All these federal workers AND NOTHING EVER GETS DONE 🤦♀ Along with all scandals and incompetencies never seen before
Prosperity is only for the elite, entitled and the party faithful. All shall bow down to the leader
Government employment has never been higher than under sparklesocks.
@@AllRequired and or “daddy crosslegs”
You're right on!
I am so disgusted with how our tax dollars are being squandered under these ndp/liberal so called civil servants.
It's been three years now that I have been after my MP, here in New Brunswick, to get me what I paid for from the IRCC.
THREE YEARS!
Trudeau has run his course. Go spend your millions and get out of my government!!! RESIGN!
Things are going per the WEF plan.
Could also be why were 2 TRILLION IN DEBIT
Services have gone down
Thanks for posting this information!! No wonder work is so hard to find.
Civil workers are the most incompetent workers ever and I’m tired of paying them! DEI needs to go. Hire smart competent people
Private sector $25, public $45 more accurate. Especially if you take out the unionized trades that get all the public contracts.
Too many taxes. People are pissed
The public service is bigger than welfare.
Yes sir , any type of government job will do . Why do you think Trudeau hires so many government employees . Thats right .
It is a telling signal when public sector employment growth outstrips private sector employment growth. And it is not a good signal. However this deviation in employment growth is a direct result of Mr. Trudeau's failed economic policies compounded by the reality government service delivery is declining. More people, more expense, but less productivity is also a telling signal. We continue to live in the upside down world of Mr. Trudeau.
Federal civil servants do not pay federal income tax. The money they pay in income tax comes from the gavernment and they just hand it back. It is better to privatise much of it.
Federal, provincial, and municipal employees all get their money from the taxpayers. Nice pensions too.
Canada has too many people in the wagon, and not enough people are pulling it.
@@-Ordinary-Average-Guy Next is taxes on unrealized gains.
@@-Ordinary-Average-Guy Guess who's actually pulling it.
Yup,,,,I call it, recycles private sector taxes.
Ummmm.. i hate em too. But they do lose money in taxes like everyone else.. remember, there are 7 layers between workers and ministers.. NOT ALK FEDERAL EMPLOYEES ARE CORRUPT
Vote the Beggars out.
Working from home is fine as long as there are consequences for poor performance but this is the Government so of course there isn't. Ditch all the empty buildings and start letting people go who don't preform.
No working from home isn’t fine! The productivity is about 46% on most studies and if it was so productive why has Trudeau hired 45,000 more gov workers? 2000 just to manage the carbon tax we all didn’t vote for?
@@kennordsfan1494 did you even read what I said. Countless industries have made working from home work. Only difference with them is if you aren't performing you're let go. Why should government work be any different. Set quotas and make sure they're met. It's pretty simple.
There is no such thing as accountability in a civil "service" union job
When Pierre become PM unemployment rate will go up. Government employees out of a job.
Good
I know 8 government employees that work from home. Full pay, full benefits and sit by their pool or lake everyday sipping margaritas.
It’s ridiculous
Some.. Dont spread lies like liberals
Thanks for your thoughts, Lorne!! Always good to hear.
With the current wave of immigrants , “student visa/workers” and illegals entering the workplaces getting their wages subsidized to the tune of 70% ... what chance does natural born citizens’ children have as they leave grade 10-13 looking for part time summer work ?
The problem is quite evident.
This is absolutely ridiculous that there's lower amount of jobs available. And civil service workers should be going into the office 5 days a week, not 3 days a week.
Thank you for educating Canada
great reporting
That explains the 25 percent.
finally someone said it ... brilliant reporting
Thanks Lorne. Haven't heard a word about this over at the CBC. Maybe they're all on vacation? I've listened to educated teachers tell me how the taxes they pay contribute to the GDP and help add jobs....people who went though university.
@@saltymonkey8874 not sure they could grasp that and hoist it aboard
It only means that GDP per capita is declining because they're not growing the economic pie but only dividing it.
the GDP is in fact shrinking
once the real rate of inflation
is taken into account.
its not 2 or 3%
but more like 8 to 10%
at the moment.
last year it was probably closer to 20%.
Why can't anyone just come out and say why this is a massive problem? If your paycheque is completely paid for through the government you are not a taxpayer. Your wages are paid exclusively by those who do pay taxes. Your $45/hr income is paid for in full by others who do pay taxes. The most generous take on this is that you have some of your taxpayer-funded income clawed back. I fully understand that we need some government jobs but a vast number of those who work in the public sector are a drag on our economy and need to go. Furthermore, public-sector unions are insulting to those whose wages have to go to funding their members.
justinder is hiring his countrymen to make sure they vote for him. He also gives money to subsidize the wages of the countrymen he imports.
Just the politicians on the tit of our tax money. Nothing new. I think I just need to get a job with the government. Doing nothing useful for the people of Canada.
Sorry but not totally true.. CFIA protects us.from bad food. Customs try to keep bad people, food, bugs etc out.. Try not to use too big a brush when hating.. you becom liberal
I wish I made $45 an hour. I've been in the same industry for 20 years and I only make $21, and I'm scrapping by on that.
I’m worried. The construction company I belong to has been in business for 30 years and is always busy at this time. We are slow every crew..
Exactly! And, they make up a big chunk of his voting base, especially the Ottawa gang.
Thank you this is so crazy!
Absolutely correct!
Agree, they are incredibly incompetent from the top down. I doubt the CPC will be much better, but we have to try something that is different. Desperate times call for desperate measures.
You are spot on. But why does it need to be explained. Do people not understand the economy?
You go Lorne.
very well said
Yep that’s why I can’t get a job! Im not “one” of them :(
keep trying sir.
do not give up.
Hey Lorne, can you please assure us that Boissonneault won’t be re elected! Western Canada and Edmonton thanks you in advance!
I really am miffed why anyone would come to Canada voluntarily. We have no housing, no work and is insanely expensive. Other then poverty, censorship and woke authoritarianism, what does Canada offer?
Better than aa gaza tent?
I recall reports being out into mailbox once a month while previous months report was never looked at . The cycle keeps going
Stop conflating "New Canadians" with Temporary Residents. Just because someone resides in Canada does not make them Canadian. New or otherwise.
A "New Canadian" is someone who has obtained Canadian citizenship through naturalization. A Temporary Resident has a work permit, study permit, or tourist visa and is not permitted to reside in Canada permanently unlike a Permanent Resident and Canadian.
New Canadian and Temporary Resident are not synonyms. They are clearly two distinct legal status.
Thank you for providing this information.
One of many reasons Lorne there are piles of reasons however this surely is a serious one not to be ignored.
Seven layers of management! That hasn't been seen in the private sector for 3 decades. What is the problem with the Federal government, healthcare, and education? All 3 have 7 layers of management. This has to stop. Notice how the IT delivery is a problem in all 3 domains as well. Could be related.
Interest rates should never have been near zero, let alone stayed there for many years. The stock market used to have a viable alternative in bonds and GICs, because interest rates were moderate. As you aged, it was prudent to have more money in guaranteed vehicles. Lowering rates for so long exploded the rich poor divide because anyone who could qualify was leveraging hard on real estate or even investing, creating historically nonsensical P/E ratios that continue today. I don't see any short term solution possible, because banks are allowed to extend amortization longer instead of letting the market correct, becauase they chose not to stress test at reasonable possible rates for over a decade. Did they really not think rates would rise in 25 years?
I having been saying this for years. My parents have been saying this all my life and my father worked at a crown corporation and was a union steward.
when you have a country managed by clowns you get a circus
incontinence like incompetence, usually comes back to tarnish you
The more the Federal government hires, the worse the delivery of services gets. Enough already.
Government bureaucracies grow, while the tax base shrinks. Ottawa logic.
Economic Brilliance!
My wife has been looking for 7 months and hasn’t been able to find work. She’s Canadian born and being passed over for FOBS. GTFO Trudeau!
Good point. Now imagine the odds of getting a job in our woke government if you're a hetero-white male.
If you aren't willing to consider that this is all part of a larger choreographed system, you need to pay more attention to what is going on around you.
And we still don't know who the traitors are sitting in the house of commons.
I’m so sick and tired of Trudeau and his band minions!! Please Tell me there’s a way to get him out!!
Who trains these new bureaucrats? Is their even an organizational chart available? Are they even set up with job descriptions and duties?
Nine years ago I was on track to retire at 60. Im 58 now and dont think I'll ever be able to retire. Thanks Justin 🖕
25% of Canadians work for the government. You could not get a passport last year. You stand in line for a drivers license.
Everything has an expiration date. The Liberals have gone sour. We need something with better flavour. I like what conservatives has to offer.
Both sectors are killing the economy !
How much has the federal government grown in the last 9 years?
Thank you for your great videos! Trudeau needs to go!
We all deserve so much more as Canadians and for our governments, both Liberal and NDP, to continue to spend recklessly and grow the size of government at unprecedented rates only to secure their futures and the futures of their friends is disgraceful. It’s time for Canadians to start speaking out and demand better government and get their spending under control. We the people live with budgets but the governments seem to believe they have no budgets and they have cart blanche to do as they want. Our tax money is ours and it should be spent for the betterment of Canadians!
We need a strategic plan and fast to turn this around and once again become the promise land Canada once was. We have one of the richest countries in the world and yet we sell our natural resources, our lands, our waters to other nations who are stealing from us blind.
Please help yourselves and start to speak up to your local MP’s so we are all heard and not hearing just the voices of the very vocal minorities.
God Bless Canada and may we rebuild this once great nation.
The private sector is seeing a slow down because people are more focused on just putting food on their tables than having anything done. I will tell you as someone who is on a disability pension that hasn't even come close to keeping up with inflation it is getting very difficult as a single person to afford utilities and put food on the table just for me and buy dog food for my emotional support dog. Meanwhile Trudeau tells us that we get more back in the rebate than we pay, well I can tell you thats a lie, just for my heating and fuel I spend roughly $1200/yr, if I was working it would be closer to $2000/yr. But when you add in the hidden costs on electricity and food price increases your average person/household will pay closer to $3500/yr.
Research has shown that when a government reaches about 35% any further increase in size REDUCES the effectiveness of the services provided. A negative return on investment.
Agreed.
What's to worry.. Just pay more taxes so the government staff numbers can grow.
It's a lose lose recipe!
CRA was suggesting a 2-3 hour wait for a GST question!
In BC layoffs and business closing all over. Industrial and commercial with lease signs
In classic Trudeau fashion, the more he spends, the worse things get for Canadians.
The Liberal insiders keep getting richer
And that's just the feds. What about the provincial and municipal civil services? In the USSR everyone worked for the government, too.
Not only do the private sector jobs fund the public, the private sector jobs create the stuff that's currently in short supply / high cost (housing, food, infrastructure). The govt prints money, hires most of the workers, and regulates private enterprise out of existence. It's a tragedy