like you said minnie litearlly said the start of super lady was supposed to be for miyeon but miyeon couldn't do it and so then she tried (minnie) and couldn't do it as well she said they all tried but non of them could get the part right.... like if non of them liked the way they did it why should they force themselves to do it?😭😭
Someone needs to give (G) I-dle and Stray Kids a break: JYP and Cube are choosing quantity over quality, and all of us know that both groups can do so much better. Also aren't half of (G) I-dle on a health hiatus? That had me worried. Also i agree, like why a group of TXT size is collabing with another of another of the Sad Tumblr Girl voice, Coi Leray? The only collab i cared for was Anitta, bcuz she has a huge fanbase.
Since Kpop stans don't know what a hate train is i'll leave a few examples: Jennie during 2018 Momoland and 2NE1 whole career Garam Woojin Both Jimin's Wonyoung every other tuesday T-ara Iz*One and Fromis_9 after the whole Produce thing was revealed Girls Generation after Jessica left Sulli Yeri whole time in Red Velvet SinB during Queendom 2 Bahiyyih whole time in Kep1er Nmixx debut era BTS Rookie years
0:23 Superlady could have been better 3:52 Why do K-pop Idole work with Western artists ? 6:11 Jessi, is maybe the problem? 8:58 K-pop fan doesn't know the meaning of a hate train
0:29 I totally respect your opinion but I loved the song . Yuqi's voice is way too deep for the intro and it would have cracked. Minnie and Miyeon weren't able to do it . Soyeon didn't try to hit the note. She actually hit the note . It's not hard to listen to at all for me. I also loved the chorus and the steps. The verses were great. I do agree with the fact it can have a bridge and it would be great. Minnie is not being thrown at the back , nor is Shuhua. It's just that Minnie has been extremely sick recently and Shuhua got the center of the dance break. I don't think the music has gone downhill at all . But then , everyone has a different music taste .
I hate super lady intro, i dont believe minnie and miyeon couldn't hit the notes. Soyeon should stop giving herself lines she cant execute. I feel like shes dragging gidle down. They have yuqi and minnie who write good songs. Soyeons writing is getting tired, we need something fresh, i feel like theyre just milking "im tough woman" concept without actually diving into important issues. Jessi should leave industry, shes not artist, bad music is even worse when she performs it. She makes everyone uncomfortable, she should stop being on internet. Stans need to understand the difference between people not liking music and hating the group.
Sorry, but 1. music tastes may be subjective to personal taste and opinion, but claiming that Minnie and Yuqi could write and produce (G)I-de, and Soyeon's music "seems dry", or that "Jessi should leave the music industry" are such ignorant statements, that it shows that you know nothing about music production quality, or even music in general. Yuqi and Minnie are starting out, and they're doing good, but a good Producer can clearly hear the huge difference between a Minnie song and one produced by Soyeon. A song can be good, but it Hits different with an outstanding production and mastering, which Jeon Soyeon literally always delivers. And this, also confirmed by experienced professional producers. Minnie and Yuqi have still a LOT to learn on music production, to be able to do what Soyeon already can. And Jessi has more talent in a finger, than most 4th gen girl groups together, who need to rely on Labels, outside producers and Songwritersto even bring anything decent out. 🙄 2. Claiming to not "believe" what the members themselves have said about the Super Lady intro, is plain stupid. Sorry to put it that way, but it is what it is. It's like watching the Moon Landing and still claim it didn't happen... but oh well.... there are indeed crazy people for everything 🙄 3. (G)I-DLE, as well as many other Kpop artists, make music for KOREANS in the 1st place. If they have International success, that's a plus and great, but all their lyrics and concepts are marketed towards the Korean market first and foremost, so they will write about issues that THEY experience and need in THEIR society. South Korea is a ultra conservative country, where women are treated as 2nd class citizens, where rapists get 6 months prison time and rape victims shamed and with reputations ruined forever, where women are constantly shamed and treated as less successful than men, in any profession really including the music industry. The "tough women" message that you say is "milked out", may be bogus for YOU who has the freedom to choose your own identity and have an equal voice and opportunity in life and profession, but for Korean women, it's still a very NEEDED message, because their Reality is very different from yours. Artists need to put the messages out that they feel their communities need, so who are we, Westerners, to say that it's not important anymore to call for female empowerment? It's presumptious and arrogant. Just typical stupidity of netizens who have no clue about real life and Real artistry.
@@Pookasoul i think you misunderstood what i wanted to say. I think that them doing im tough woman concept is great, im just sad that they just sing about being tough women without diving more into issues of women in a misogynistic world. Honestly, even tough soyeon is a good producer, her songs are just really getting worse and worse and her english lyricism is a headache. You can see difference in quality of their latest releases and the english debut. I want that or eyes roll are meaningfull but also catchy and work well with the members voices. Soyeon is a bad vocalist. Miyeon and yuqi are awesome, minnie is great. I dont believe they couldnt execute it. Miyeon literally did on mama the high note of the pretty much the same height as the super lady intro. What were seeing is damage control. They knew that soyeon would get backlash for mistreating her main vocalists so they said they couldnt sing it to prevent scandals.
Jisoo Stan's were responsible for Jennie hate train, what you expect when Jisoo had visual role and it get taken by Jennie, while other solo stans were blamed jisoo Stans got away with it
@@Kamelia1311 if u think Lisa don't have hate train then get off internet and most loved member is Jisoo Lisa was constantly hated since 2019 right now her hate almost tied Jennie Jennie, Lisa and wonyoung are the most hated k-pop idol
honestly, i agree with your opinion on super lady, especially on what you said about the high note at the beginning. the thing is that it sounded like soyeon was really hurting her voice by hitting that high note. and if that high note is really hurting her voice, it might be dangerous since it can lead to her vocal cords being damaged. apparently for different vocal ranges, high notes can be different, for example: a high note for Taylor Swift is nothing compared to Ariana Grande's because her vocal range is higher. it would've been cool if soyeon kind of looked for high notes within the members vocal range so that it would be comfortable for them to hit those high notes easily (or at least not to the point that it can strain their voice)
I feel like a lot of your arguments are really conflicting. Like towards the end of the video you said “if you don’t like it move on” but you made an entire section about saweetie and latto when you were uneducated about the purpose of their collabs. You also did this when talking about super lady, saying that you acknowledged that minnie and miyeon were unable to hit that high note in the beginning but still wanted them to do it despite the fact they would mess up their vocal chords by hitting the note or make the note sound bad due to it being outside of their vocal range. I also dislike the way you spoke about saweetie and latto because it’s just incorrect, charts don’t really matter as much as you make them seem. Ice Spice and Ive and whoever else can make a good song and blow up and be #1 on the charts, but they lack long term genuine fans, versus saweetie and latto, who have a more permanent fanbase. it might be small but it matters in the long run, hence why Beyonce is so popular and successful.
6:12 She absolutely is . She's funny sometimes but she doesn't know when to stop even when the person is front is uncomfortable. She should honestly learn to read the room then start interviews . Otherwise she's good as an entertainer.
I love your editing😍but please understand what a high note is. Soyeon literally hit those high notes perfectly and the part was given to her 'cause Minnie and Miyeon couldn't do it. +They can't put more money on songs 'cause they make the songs. And they are that kind of artists who wouldn't release a song that they think is bad quality.
I agree the high note at the intro was too jarring... her tone is too high so even though you can hit a high note, doesn't mean it sounds good. It also sounds very strained and as if she's shouting. The song had potential, but it seemed very choppy.
Its good to see that you are atleast saying that it's your opinion while not liking the song cause many youtubers just say that the song was absolute shit and people only like it because G-idle released it or some shit like that. They forget that music is subjective and some people can actually like the music that they hate.
It's really sad but itzy gets hate on everything Now when their music is top tier still the recognition is less compared to their rookie era Mr vampire , born to be were one of the best songs I heard in a while and it is disheartening to see songs like super lady blow up rather than itzy ones Don't come at me I like gidle but from tomboy they are focusing more on mv budget rather than musical creativity same as blackpink
The only thing I have to say about is that I sincerely hope that every group/artist that collaborates with a western sh1t never sells anything again... Period.
Uhm unfortunately there’s some things I definitely disagree with, you have said lots of things that contradicts what you said in the video at later times for ex: the whole saweetie latto thing. You said later : if you don’t like it move on but continue to bash on artists for featuring western artists. Also super lady would them have hit the high note in a song and completely make the song even worse than what you’re saying rn or have someone who is capable of doing it to do it for them. Cause g- idle is going to mess up their vocal cords if they try to hit that note. You may not like the high note but like if you want hope for them to make more music to possibly satisfy you then you’re just going to have to deal with it. Also continuing with super lady don’t get your hopes up it’s like a teaser as it wasn’t even released so just because you get “2nd gen vibes” doesn’t mean it will always be that it’s your own fault for getting your hopes up like that. Only one I agreee with is the Jessi one tbh(not trying to be rude) anyways this comment isn’t meant to be rude just stating my opinion.
Literally, I think non Americans overexcitement how well known Kpop is the general public in the US, they collab with sawatiee and latto to use their name to infiltrate into the general public in US, get into new spaces, both Latto and Saweetie did good in their features, and both have been able to chart, so thats a lie, not sure what fans what youre not getting Ariana, Taylor, Drake, Ed Sheeran, Rihanna, Billie sorry Reminded me of BTS fans crying danny devito didnt know who BTS was, while knowing all these other artists like nsync, one direction etc, but thats the reality hes an old man, theres a level of cultural significance Kpop hasnt got into yet in the US, might be because of language barrier
4:05 Agreed . I loved Back For More by Txt . But I didn't like Happy Fools . IVE's collab was bad . They basically did a cover of All Night by Icona Pop and promoted it like an actual comeback. Saweetie has not charted well in ages. Bella Porch did not impact Enhyphen's sales . If anything, it got them more hate .
gidle hasn't been great since hwaa yeah their new songs are catchy and stuff but they get old sooo fast songs like latata, hann, senorita, lion & hwaa are timeless and even now are good listens
Honestly I love "noise music" but super lady was not it. It's an ok song at it's best but really when the first time i heard it i had to pause because it literally felt too piercing for the ears. It felt like the instrumentals and the vocals didn't go well together. And it definitely felt lacking and that chorus is beyond disappointing. The b-sides are much better tho and dare i say it wife is better than super lady. The concept behind the song is a harsh reality and its amazing that soyeon decided to bring light to this topic but the dilevery is not it.(btw the mv is a slayy)6/10 for me too because its not the worse but i was expecting more. All night was a disappointment. Considering I've's discography, i was like what is this. i never went back to that song since it was released. Also i thought it was a remixx not a remake. It's literally the same as the original song but starship never mentioned that anywhere.
Unpopular opinion, Jimin free falling from the charts wasn’t because billboard it was because y’all fraudulent asses were messed buying and mass streaming the shit out of the song and don’t you dare sit here and act innocent because if it was true that billboard did that to sabotage BTS, why didn’t the rap line suffer from these problems? By the way, love your videos.
You truly don't know much about the situation. I don't wanna start an argument whatsoever but please do some research before stating stuff. Ain't gonna say we ARMY don't mass buy and mass stream but y'all keep denying how billboard sabotages some artists is actually one of the problems. If the music industry wasn't that messed up, I actually understand y'all feelings about ARMY mindset towards charts etc but with how the music industry works we will do anything to put BTS at the top. For y'all charts maybe don't matter but for us, those are the only way we can make people and the industry give some respect and recognition to BTS. People have always belittled them even till now, so of course we will use our ways to make things happen.
@@meilichankan9282 You didn't even talk about the same topic as the original comment. you didn't give arguments about why supposedly bb sabotaged jm instead of simply having put a stop to the fans manipulating the charts🧍♀️🧍♀️ bb said that 80% of jm's units in hot100 came from the massive purchase on the website, while lc at the same time was the #1 debut song with fewer streams in the history of the chart... you just gave a sentimental speech about why fans support their favs when that wasn't the topic
not maybe pookie she IS the PROBLEM i always said it this funny image and stuff imagine if male idol was like that i get it its her personality and stuff but she needs to learn manners . gidle i feel like the song was walmart gidle version of i am the best by 2ne1 with mv and rythm
Ikr they picked at Keeping that fire era. Their new song is not listenable at all, they tried to hype on other groups’ names, but sadly it didn’t worked, hope they will do better with new comebacks
I felt Super Lady was giving me TWICE vibes with the quality of those notes. I love TWICE, but let’s be real here about the fact that they have yet to deliver a quality encore stage for a reason and that’s because JYP forces them to sing outside of their range. Also the amount of nonsensical adlibs - “Ha na dul set” “I’m fearless” “Ready to shoot” like bruh The only song that felt like an actual successful, purposeful collaboration to me with a black artist was XG’s “Left Right” remix with Ciara (and Jackson Wang ofc.) Their collab with Rico Nasty on Shooting Star is a close second as well since it actually sounded smart like Rico Nasty’s style really suits the song perfectly. I’m honestly tired of K-Pop companies trying to slide into the Western market with a collab that makes no sense on a professional or musical level.
we all know why companys make idols collab with these people it's for diversity points and nothing more and none of the kpop x western artist where good so far if they weren't massive singers like blackpink with lady gaga and dua lipa and txts recent one with that duo? i think
When I first heard super lady, I honestly thought it was bad and I was never going to listen to it again. Some parts were good, but the beginning ruined the whole song. It just made me not want to listen to it again. How sad they wasted a lot of money on this video. I agree the song would have been more famous or maybe could have been good if soyeon didn’t do the beginning. That’s y tomboy and queencard did so well cause soyeon didn’t do the beginning.
I was introduced to K-Pop around the beginning of 4th gen, right within EVERGLOW's debut, so there was no nostalgia factor for me with this G-IDLE new song; I also felt it sounded bland and the high notes x rap role switching between Soyeon and Minnie didn't turn out that great. The visuals also lacked color variation and the dance club "hair flip go crazy" choreo also rubbed me the wrong way. I love the girls but this time's comeback really wasn't for me. 2:56 - I also heavily agree with this. G-IDLE went through a "concept loss" after Soojin left, her being such an elegant main dancer and pivotal to hold the group's past mysthic, mysterious and emotional concepts together, they were amazingly executed, and it balanced it out nicely with Soyeon's boldness. After that they managed to get over the hate and remain relevant by playing the "concept chameleon", which is... Risky, I'd say. There were many incredible songs, but this lack of consistency can only take you so far. It's pretty normal and expected for them to have an odd release once in a while. "You can't always win", as they say.
@@Lixxies_brownie fr people would have shit on them and will never forgive them for releasing it 1000s of the video and comment would there about how they unstan them cause their song is shit but it's gidle it's okay
@@Lalisa-manoBANGS-arestable Fr soyeon needs to take a break and create another lion or even nxde imo I honestly feel she isn’t thinking straight with this comeback super lady was good…but it could be better
@@Lixxies_brownie yess after tomboy blow up she just want to add as much as english possible even when she don't the language well and it's turn out to nothing but cringe and meaningless when she goes like what should I write she just add random cringe english in between and people eat it up cause it's written by soyeon is about women empowerment Her songs don't make sense anymore just the message behind it Super lady sounds like fail YG concept
@@Lalisa-manoBANGS-arestable Fr I think she should’ve taken the hate they got from queencard and actually understand that people wanted the Korean lyrics not “twerking on the runway” type of stuff Me personally I want a song like oh my god another one I had that on repeat for days idek why it sounded so nice
sis get real, Kpop groups are collaborating with smaller western artists because those kpop groups are small in the west in the grand scope of things, who do you want for them to get, the big names are not trying to ruin their musical images theyve worked hard with by collaborating with some Kpop group when their fans dont take Kpop seriously? Its career suicide
@@Lalisa-manoBANGS-arestable yes, it's so true after 'hwaa' I didn't really enjoyed any song , and they always use the same formula using minnie and yuqi deep voices
@@shivanitomar9873 yeah after tomboy blow up soyeon is just trying to add as much as english possible even when she don't know the language well it turn out to be cringe and meaningless her lyrics no more make sense and she just put women empowerment meaning behind it and people eat it up like it's best song ever I swear if wife or super lady was released by others especially itzy,nmixx, blackpink or babymon people would have shit on them
@@Lalisa-manoBANGS-arestable u say that but if some of the famous songs by these groups were to be released by G-idle, then people would shit on that as well. this argument of "if this song was released by someone else" is the most pathetic argument one can make. And as u can see, u guys are shitting on this even when G-idle released it so what's ur point in saying that everyone is eating this up.
@@hellhound1505 to me there is nothing in this superlady just some cool shots and and no storyline the real empowerment song I think is perfect is XG girl gang give a try and also watch music video too you will see the diff a proper storyline and every thing is vibe
Yeah when I first listened to kpop, Gidle was the worst group I'd ever heard due to the weird lyrics and instrumentals. I like some of their songs but they still haven't grown on me too much.
Hi👋 it's been a while
Hi🙋
You keep deleted my comment I was defending Jessi I guess you can't handle one of her supporters defending her
like you said minnie litearlly said the start of super lady was supposed to be for miyeon but miyeon couldn't do it and so then she tried (minnie) and couldn't do it as well she said they all tried but non of them could get the part right.... like if non of them liked the way they did it why should they force themselves to do it?😭😭
thanks for saying that. I wanted to comment that too that there is a reason why Soyeon sang the intro and not someone of the vocal line
Someone needs to give (G) I-dle and Stray Kids a break: JYP and Cube are choosing quantity over quality, and all of us know that both groups can do so much better. Also aren't half of (G) I-dle on a health hiatus? That had me worried.
Also i agree, like why a group of TXT size is collabing with another of another of the Sad Tumblr Girl voice, Coi Leray? The only collab i cared for was Anitta, bcuz she has a huge fanbase.
Woah woah a health hiatus ? What’s going on?
No really the Anita song was fire and made sense but the coi leray one is questionable imo ?
@@misssunnybae1074 they are really sick shuhua is still on hiatus
@@mimi09126 oh i didn’t know that hope it’s nothing serious
@@misssunnybae1074also Minnie and Yuqi were rushed y the hospital before Super Lady promotions thankfully they're fine now Buy that had me worried
@@Chuu_Vault Thank God
Since Kpop stans don't know what a hate train is i'll leave a few examples:
Jennie during 2018
Momoland and 2NE1 whole career
Garam
Woojin
Both Jimin's
Wonyoung every other tuesday
T-ara
Iz*One and Fromis_9 after the whole Produce thing was revealed
Girls Generation after Jessica left
Sulli
Yeri whole time in Red Velvet
SinB during Queendom 2
Bahiyyih whole time in Kep1er
Nmixx debut era
BTS Rookie years
Sinb, IZ*ONE, Fromis_9 and Nmixx are not hatetrains either. Especially not Nmixx as people criticised their songs and not the members themselves.
Wony "every other day" is so real like my girl can never catch rest
+ITZY since sneakers
0:23 Superlady could have been better
3:52 Why do K-pop Idole work with Western artists ?
6:11 Jessi, is maybe the problem?
8:58 K-pop fan doesn't know the meaning of a hate train
0:29 I totally respect your opinion but I loved the song . Yuqi's voice is way too deep for the intro and it would have cracked. Minnie and Miyeon weren't able to do it . Soyeon didn't try to hit the note. She actually hit the note .
It's not hard to listen to at all for me. I also loved the chorus and the steps. The verses were great.
I do agree with the fact it can have a bridge and it would be great.
Minnie is not being thrown at the back , nor is Shuhua. It's just that Minnie has been extremely sick recently and Shuhua got the center of the dance break.
I don't think the music has gone downhill at all . But then , everyone has a different music taste .
I hate super lady intro, i dont believe minnie and miyeon couldn't hit the notes. Soyeon should stop giving herself lines she cant execute. I feel like shes dragging gidle down. They have yuqi and minnie who write good songs. Soyeons writing is getting tired, we need something fresh, i feel like theyre just milking "im tough woman" concept without actually diving into important issues.
Jessi should leave industry, shes not artist, bad music is even worse when she performs it. She makes everyone uncomfortable, she should stop being on internet.
Stans need to understand the difference between people not liking music and hating the group.
Sorry, but
1. music tastes may be subjective to personal taste and opinion, but claiming that Minnie and Yuqi could write and produce (G)I-de, and Soyeon's music "seems dry", or that "Jessi should leave the music industry" are such ignorant statements, that it shows that you know nothing about music production quality, or even music in general. Yuqi and Minnie are starting out, and they're doing good, but a good Producer can clearly hear the huge difference between a Minnie song and one produced by Soyeon. A song can be good, but it Hits different with an outstanding production and mastering, which Jeon Soyeon literally always delivers. And this, also confirmed by experienced professional producers. Minnie and Yuqi have still a LOT to learn on music production, to be able to do what Soyeon already can. And Jessi has more talent in a finger, than most 4th gen girl groups together, who need to rely on Labels, outside producers and Songwritersto even bring anything decent out. 🙄
2. Claiming to not "believe" what the members themselves have said about the Super Lady intro, is plain stupid. Sorry to put it that way, but it is what it is. It's like watching the Moon Landing and still claim it didn't happen... but oh well.... there are indeed crazy people for everything 🙄
3. (G)I-DLE, as well as many other Kpop artists, make music for KOREANS in the 1st place. If they have International success, that's a plus and great, but all their lyrics and concepts are marketed towards the Korean market first and foremost, so they will write about issues that THEY experience and need in THEIR society. South Korea is a ultra conservative country, where women are treated as 2nd class citizens, where rapists get 6 months prison time and rape victims shamed and with reputations ruined forever, where women are constantly shamed and treated as less successful than men, in any profession really including the music industry. The "tough women" message that you say is "milked out", may be bogus for YOU who has the freedom to choose your own identity and have an equal voice and opportunity in life and profession, but for Korean women, it's still a very NEEDED message, because their Reality is very different from yours. Artists need to put the messages out that they feel their communities need, so who are we, Westerners, to say that it's not important anymore to call for female empowerment? It's presumptious and arrogant. Just typical stupidity of netizens who have no clue about real life and Real artistry.
@@Pookasoul i think you misunderstood what i wanted to say. I think that them doing im tough woman concept is great, im just sad that they just sing about being tough women without diving more into issues of women in a misogynistic world.
Honestly, even tough soyeon is a good producer, her songs are just really getting worse and worse and her english lyricism is a headache. You can see difference in quality of their latest releases and the english debut. I want that or eyes roll are meaningfull but also catchy and work well with the members voices.
Soyeon is a bad vocalist. Miyeon and yuqi are awesome, minnie is great. I dont believe they couldnt execute it. Miyeon literally did on mama the high note of the pretty much the same height as the super lady intro. What were seeing is damage control. They knew that soyeon would get backlash for mistreating her main vocalists so they said they couldnt sing it to prevent scandals.
I agree with the hate train one because what do you mean "lesserafim hate train" ?? 😭 where is the train?
Jennie ,garam ,wonyoung, sulli ,bts in 2017, blackpink in 2018 was the actual hate train
Don't forget to add Lisa and momoland
Facts!!!!
Jisoo Stan's were responsible for Jennie hate train, what you expect when Jisoo had visual role and it get taken by Jennie, while other solo stans were blamed jisoo Stans got away with it
where was the hate train exactly? she was always the most loved member@@Lalisa-manoBANGS-arestable
@@Kamelia1311 if u think Lisa don't have hate train then get off internet and most loved member is Jisoo
Lisa was constantly hated since 2019 right now her hate almost tied Jennie
Jennie, Lisa and wonyoung are the most hated k-pop idol
honestly, i agree with your opinion on super lady, especially on what you said about the high note at the beginning. the thing is that it sounded like soyeon was really hurting her voice by hitting that high note. and if that high note is really hurting her voice, it might be dangerous since it can lead to her vocal cords being damaged. apparently for different vocal ranges, high notes can be different, for example: a high note for Taylor Swift is nothing compared to Ariana Grande's because her vocal range is higher. it would've been cool if soyeon kind of looked for high notes within the members vocal range so that it would be comfortable for them to hit those high notes easily (or at least not to the point that it can strain their voice)
The way the FIRST one made me literally GASP
Super Lady's chorus was such a let down for me. Especially since I loved how it opened. You give me a high note, I am IN.
I feel like a lot of your arguments are really conflicting. Like towards the end of the video you said “if you don’t like it move on” but you made an entire section about saweetie and latto when you were uneducated about the purpose of their collabs. You also did this when talking about super lady, saying that you acknowledged that minnie and miyeon were unable to hit that high note in the beginning but still wanted them to do it despite the fact they would mess up their vocal chords by hitting the note or make the note sound bad due to it being outside of their vocal range. I also dislike the way you spoke about saweetie and latto because it’s just incorrect, charts don’t really matter as much as you make them seem. Ice Spice and Ive and whoever else can make a good song and blow up and be #1 on the charts, but they lack long term genuine fans, versus saweetie and latto, who have a more permanent fanbase. it might be small but it matters in the long run, hence why Beyonce is so popular and successful.
6:12 She absolutely is . She's funny sometimes but she doesn't know when to stop even when the person is front is uncomfortable. She should honestly learn to read the room then start interviews . Otherwise she's good as an entertainer.
I love your editing😍but please understand what a high note is. Soyeon literally hit those high notes perfectly and the part was given to her 'cause Minnie and Miyeon couldn't do it. +They can't put more money on songs 'cause they make the songs. And they are that kind of artists who wouldn't release a song that they think is bad quality.
Maybe she really hit those notes perfectly, but her voice is unpleasant to make highnotes, it sounds like she’s just shouting her lungs out
I agree the high note at the intro was too jarring... her tone is too high so even though you can hit a high note, doesn't mean it sounds good. It also sounds very strained and as if she's shouting. The song had potential, but it seemed very choppy.
Its good to see that you are atleast saying that it's your opinion while not liking the song cause many youtubers just say that the song was absolute shit and people only like it because G-idle released it or some shit like that. They forget that music is subjective and some people can actually like the music that they hate.
.... she literally did say that (it was trash/shit) in the Jessi section what are you talking about?
People actually like Queencard and Wife? Those songs are torture for my ears.
It’s implied that it’s their opinion since it’s their video
It's really sad but itzy gets hate on everything
Now when their music is top tier still the recognition is less compared to their rookie era
Mr vampire , born to be were one of the best songs I heard in a while and it is disheartening to see songs like super lady blow up rather than itzy ones
Don't come at me I like gidle but from tomboy they are focusing more on mv budget rather than musical creativity same as blackpink
The only thing I have to say about is that I sincerely hope that every group/artist that collaborates with a western sh1t never sells anything again... Period.
Uhm unfortunately there’s some things I definitely disagree with, you have said lots of things that contradicts what you said in the video at later times for ex: the whole saweetie latto thing. You said later : if you don’t like it move on but continue to bash on artists for featuring western artists. Also super lady would them have hit the high note in a song and completely make the song even worse than what you’re saying rn or have someone who is capable of doing it to do it for them. Cause g- idle is going to mess up their vocal cords if they try to hit that note. You may not like the high note but like if you want hope for them to make more music to possibly satisfy you then you’re just going to have to deal with it. Also continuing with super lady don’t get your hopes up it’s like a teaser as it wasn’t even released so just because you get “2nd gen vibes” doesn’t mean it will always be that it’s your own fault for getting your hopes up like that. Only one I agreee with is the Jessi one tbh(not trying to be rude) anyways this comment isn’t meant to be rude just stating my opinion.
Literally, I think non Americans overexcitement how well known Kpop is the general public in the US, they collab with sawatiee and latto to use their name to infiltrate into the general public in US, get into new spaces, both Latto and Saweetie did good in their features, and both have been able to chart, so thats a lie, not sure what fans what youre not getting Ariana, Taylor, Drake, Ed Sheeran, Rihanna, Billie sorry
Reminded me of BTS fans crying danny devito didnt know who BTS was, while knowing all these other artists like nsync, one direction etc, but thats the reality hes an old man, theres a level of cultural significance Kpop hasnt got into yet in the US, might be because of language barrier
3:43 it's really unfair to say 'most of us think so' when it's clearly not the case, 40% said meh but 60% said it's good for them
exactly. And in the comments they also said that it took 2-3 listens but it grew on them later. Also, some just voted for "haven't listened to it yet"
4:05 Agreed . I loved Back For More by Txt . But I didn't like Happy Fools . IVE's collab was bad . They basically did a cover of All Night by Icona Pop and promoted it like an actual comeback. Saweetie has not charted well in ages.
Bella Porch did not impact Enhyphen's sales . If anything, it got them more hate .
i really liked latto's part in seven it was pretty nice you didnt like it?
Just not a big fan but it’s not that bad just not that memorable
Imo Soyeon need's a break for a few comebacks, music isn't as great any more
Personally I feel her songwriting is poor
gidle hasn't been great since hwaa
yeah their new songs are catchy and stuff but they get old sooo fast
songs like latata, hann, senorita, lion & hwaa are timeless and even now are good listens
Honestly I love "noise music" but super lady was not it. It's an ok song at it's best but really when the first time i heard it i had to pause because it literally felt too piercing for the ears. It felt like the instrumentals and the vocals didn't go well together. And it definitely felt lacking and that chorus is beyond disappointing. The b-sides are much better tho and dare i say it wife is better than super lady. The concept behind the song is a harsh reality and its amazing that soyeon decided to bring light to this topic but the dilevery is not it.(btw the mv is a slayy)6/10 for me too because its not the worse but i was expecting more.
All night was a disappointment. Considering I've's discography, i was like what is this. i never went back to that song since it was released. Also i thought it was a remixx not a remake. It's literally the same as the original song but starship never mentioned that anywhere.
berry
@@user-nu3kl8ez4u strawberry 😶
Unpopular opinion, Jimin free falling from the charts wasn’t because billboard it was because y’all fraudulent asses were messed buying and mass streaming the shit out of the song and don’t you dare sit here and act innocent because if it was true that billboard did that to sabotage BTS, why didn’t the rap line suffer from these problems? By the way, love your videos.
You truly don't know much about the situation. I don't wanna start an argument whatsoever but please do some research before stating stuff. Ain't gonna say we ARMY don't mass buy and mass stream but y'all keep denying how billboard sabotages some artists is actually one of the problems. If the music industry wasn't that messed up, I actually understand y'all feelings about ARMY mindset towards charts etc but with how the music industry works we will do anything to put BTS at the top. For y'all charts maybe don't matter but for us, those are the only way we can make people and the industry give some respect and recognition to BTS. People have always belittled them even till now, so of course we will use our ways to make things happen.
U need more research
@@meilichankan9282 You didn't even talk about the same topic as the original comment. you didn't give arguments about why supposedly bb sabotaged jm instead of simply having put a stop to the fans manipulating the charts🧍♀️🧍♀️ bb said that 80% of jm's units in hot100 came from the massive purchase on the website, while lc at the same time was the #1 debut song with fewer streams in the history of the chart... you just gave a sentimental speech about why fans support their favs when that wasn't the topic
not maybe pookie she IS the PROBLEM i always said it this funny image and stuff imagine if male idol was like that i get it its her personality and stuff but she needs to learn manners . gidle i feel like the song was walmart gidle version of i am the best by 2ne1 with mv and rythm
What do u think of X:in new song. It was cringe imo
Ikr they picked at Keeping that fire era. Their new song is not listenable at all, they tried to hype on other groups’ names, but sadly it didn’t worked, hope they will do better with new comebacks
@@WET-n-FIRM yeah their new teaser sounds decent. Lets see how it will turn out
I felt Super Lady was giving me TWICE vibes with the quality of those notes. I love TWICE, but let’s be real here about the fact that they have yet to deliver a quality encore stage for a reason and that’s because JYP forces them to sing outside of their range. Also the amount of nonsensical adlibs - “Ha na dul set” “I’m fearless” “Ready to shoot” like bruh
The only song that felt like an actual successful, purposeful collaboration to me with a black artist was XG’s “Left Right” remix with Ciara (and Jackson Wang ofc.) Their collab with Rico Nasty on Shooting Star is a close second as well since it actually sounded smart like Rico Nasty’s style really suits the song perfectly. I’m honestly tired of K-Pop companies trying to slide into the Western market with a collab that makes no sense on a professional or musical level.
we all know why companys make idols collab with these people
it's for diversity points and nothing more and none of the kpop x western artist where good so far if they weren't massive singers like blackpink with lady gaga and dua lipa and txts recent one with that duo? i think
aespa's one is a hate train tho with drama it kinda calmed down
When I first heard super lady, I honestly thought it was bad and I was never going to listen to it again. Some parts were good, but the beginning ruined the whole song. It just made me not want to listen to it again. How sad they wasted a lot of money on this video.
I agree the song would have been more famous or maybe could have been good if soyeon didn’t do the beginning. That’s y tomboy and queencard did so well cause soyeon didn’t do the beginning.
I was introduced to K-Pop around the beginning of 4th gen, right within EVERGLOW's debut, so there was no nostalgia factor for me with this G-IDLE new song; I also felt it sounded bland and the high notes x rap role switching between Soyeon and Minnie didn't turn out that great. The visuals also lacked color variation and the dance club "hair flip go crazy" choreo also rubbed me the wrong way. I love the girls but this time's comeback really wasn't for me.
2:56 - I also heavily agree with this. G-IDLE went through a "concept loss" after Soojin left, her being such an elegant main dancer and pivotal to hold the group's past mysthic, mysterious and emotional concepts together, they were amazingly executed, and it balanced it out nicely with Soyeon's boldness. After that they managed to get over the hate and remain relevant by playing the "concept chameleon", which is... Risky, I'd say. There were many incredible songs, but this lack of consistency can only take you so far. It's pretty normal and expected for them to have an odd release once in a while. "You can't always win", as they say.
Just imagine if super lady and wife was released by itzy,nmixx, blackpink or babymon 🗿🗿🗿
I- they would just vanish..
@@Lixxies_brownie fr people would have shit on them and will never forgive them for releasing it 1000s of the video and comment would there about how they unstan them cause their song is shit but it's gidle it's okay
@@Lalisa-manoBANGS-arestable Fr soyeon needs to take a break and create another lion or even nxde imo I honestly feel she isn’t thinking straight with this comeback super lady was good…but it could be better
@@Lixxies_brownie yess after tomboy blow up she just want to add as much as english possible even when she don't the language well and it's turn out to nothing but cringe and meaningless when she goes like what should I write she just add random cringe english in between and people eat it up cause it's written by soyeon is about women empowerment
Her songs don't make sense anymore just the message behind it
Super lady sounds like fail YG concept
@@Lalisa-manoBANGS-arestable Fr I think she should’ve taken the hate they got from queencard and actually understand that people wanted the Korean lyrics not “twerking on the runway” type of stuff
Me personally I want a song like oh my god another one I had that on repeat for days idek why it sounded so nice
Super lady was complete trash idc how rude that sounds
sis get real, Kpop groups are collaborating with smaller western artists because those kpop groups are small in the west in the grand scope of things, who do you want for them to get, the big names are not trying to ruin their musical images theyve worked hard with by collaborating with some Kpop group when their fans dont take Kpop seriously?
Its career suicide
I think song was trying so hard to be yg nd failed there were no story line
But people will eat it up cause it was from gidle same for wife for me after soojin left gidle rarely release quality music they used too
@@Lalisa-manoBANGS-arestable yes, it's so true after 'hwaa' I didn't really enjoyed any song , and they always use the same formula using minnie and yuqi deep voices
@@shivanitomar9873 yeah after tomboy blow up soyeon is just trying to add as much as english possible even when she don't know the language well it turn out to be cringe and meaningless her lyrics no more make sense and she just put women empowerment meaning behind it and people eat it up like it's best song ever
I swear if wife or super lady was released by others especially itzy,nmixx, blackpink or babymon people would have shit on them
@@Lalisa-manoBANGS-arestable u say that but if some of the famous songs by these groups were to be released by G-idle, then people would shit on that as well. this argument of "if this song was released by someone else" is the most pathetic argument one can make. And as u can see, u guys are shitting on this even when G-idle released it so what's ur point in saying that everyone is eating this up.
@@hellhound1505 to me there is nothing in this superlady just some cool shots and and no storyline the real empowerment song I think is perfect is XG girl gang give a try and also watch music video too you will see the diff a proper storyline and every thing is vibe
Yeah when I first listened to kpop, Gidle was the worst group I'd ever heard due to the weird lyrics and instrumentals. I like some of their songs but they still haven't grown on me too much.
Girl Jessi been the problem the moment she started blackfishing. And her raps are corny but I like her interviews