This story is so good that too bad it never was shown in the original model series. Seeing things from Smodger's point of view was VERY interesting to see :)
What a sad story for Smudger... That little engine never stood a chance on Sodor because of his rushed design and his constant derailing beyond his control. All that only to lose a set of wheels, become a house generator, and left behind rusting away under a mountain full of earth. It goes to show that there are certain disabilities can hold a man or a machine down to the point of obscurity. The saddest part is that he could've told Duke about his condition, but remained smug and opted not to.
Wow, this is a very sad story! Smudger had a mechanical problem beyond repair, then he was turned into a generator as opposed to scrap. Eventually the railway was abandoned, and a boulder(probably not Boulder himself)killed him. 😞
@@fridaynightfunkinfan5627 beyond repair means he cannot be fixed at all, like there was litterly nothing they could do, like saying if someone died, they are beyond repair
I actually have a head-canon to for whatever happened to Smudger😅 In mine, he was found under the remains of the sheds by some boys... and every day when the boys weren't in school, they'd all walk along the old rails to go visit Smudger and tell jokes... but they keep him a secret cuz they're afraid of Smudger getting scraped. It's sorta like Hero of the Rails but more quiet and heartwarming (not that HOTR isn't heartwarming enough 😅 despite that movie making no damn sense when you think about it)
i remember a few years ago, watching a video like this one, where Henry's driver and fireman, abandoned him along a lonely line in his own forest. not out of spite or anger. but to protect him, since the diesels were basically taking over sodor. and just like OP's post, some boys found Henry in the forest, and Henry would tell the boys his life story, and that he's happy now, living amongst the trees and animals.
Wow now that’s what I call a true sad story of Smudger, I do feel sorry for him and I can see how he was after he was killed and haunting the railway as a lonely spectre but I hope he will let go of his past and move on to rest in peace
Poor Smudger, dude. This just makes me feel sad for one of the mid Sodor engines we thought was just another naughty engine who didn’t care if he caused trouble or not. At least we can say the poor lad is free once again.
Wasn't expecting to hear Silent Hill music in this video xD Really glad you adapted it for us too! Gave me a new perspective on Smudger and I still never got over that they just left him there.
Smudger is what I would call "Sodor's Condemned". Engines that underwent hard times and had the unthinkable happen to them. Up there with Timothy, Alfred and Diesel 10.
I wonder how many years Smudger would've served the Mid Sodor Railway as when he was an engine in this timeline? What about Stanley - did he replace Smudger until he got turned into a pumping engine? Would anyone have rescued him?
in my head-canon Smudger arrives on the MSR in 1925 and became number 2 to replace Stanley (the first number 2, who arrived in 1920 but got turned into a pumping engine in 1924) but Smudger got turned into a Generator in 1928 and got scrapped in October 1945
It’s a sad story, of an engine who wanted to be useful, but his faults left him useless. So he was turned into a generator, and then was Left Behind. If my Characters heard about Smudger, they would most certainly come looking for him, his remains.
Well, in other series about mud, he didn’t die. He came back to life because someone came to the railway tour and they found them and they got help for him or something, and they brought them back on the rails.
I remember in the thomas episode grand puff smuger was behind the shed that Duke was telling the other engines stuart and Falcon a story about him but now his ghost rides the rail where he was left behind
I really liked this story, it’s emotional too. Probably why I like it so much. Also just out of curiosity what was the background music in the beginning that you used? Just wondering, because I like it.
Nice adaptation, sorry to say though that this isn't allowed, Narrow Gauge (the creator of the story) has said that people are not allowed to adapt his stories as these videos often get more views and compliments than the actual story that he posted. After looking at the comments here, I can see why he's done it. I'd suggest taking this video down before we lose the entirety of "Horror on the Rails" before it's too late. -Elias
@@chariotstudios2019 The pinned comment was posted the very same day as the OP's. I'd say there's a 50/50 chance he didn't read the pinned comment because it didn't exist at the time he posted this.
Now before anyone jumps down my throat, I have asked and received permission from Narrow Gauge to adapt some of these stories
That's good to hear.
This story is so good that too bad it never was shown in the original model series. Seeing things from Smodger's point of view was VERY interesting to see :)
that was a sad story for smudger. 😔
next up Maura-Liath: Engine Of The Ocean
Hola debería relata de la istoria de el hermano de Thomas
@@Mnuelblueykv44Thomas can you speak English?
What a sad story for Smudger...
That little engine never stood a chance on Sodor because of his rushed design and his constant derailing beyond his control. All that only to lose a set of wheels, become a house generator, and left behind rusting away under a mountain full of earth.
It goes to show that there are certain disabilities can hold a man or a machine down to the point of obscurity. The saddest part is that he could've told Duke about his condition, but remained smug and opted not to.
So smudger is dead?
Please just keep this out of the comments. How you see it is how you see it. But these are completely different and unrelated stories
Really?!
@@srcemamino382 yes. Search for Smudger was by T1E2H3, this is by Narrow Gauge
@@paramount3603 that’s two different storylines.
Wow, this is a very sad story! Smudger had a mechanical problem beyond repair, then he was turned into a generator as opposed to scrap. Eventually the railway was abandoned, and a boulder(probably not Boulder himself)killed him. 😞
He wasn’t beyond repair, they didn’t have time to send him to the works nor did they have the parts to fix him at their disposal
@@hitexh3283 Wouldn't that technically be beyond repair to them?
@@fridaynightfunkinfan5627 beyond repair means he cannot be fixed at all, like there was litterly nothing they could do, like saying if someone died, they are beyond repair
wow.....he might have gotten a better death then some of the other ghost engines
I thought he was turned into a generator for being troublesome
I actually have a head-canon to for whatever happened to Smudger😅 In mine, he was found under the remains of the sheds by some boys... and every day when the boys weren't in school, they'd all walk along the old rails to go visit Smudger and tell jokes... but they keep him a secret cuz they're afraid of Smudger getting scraped.
It's sorta like Hero of the Rails but more quiet and heartwarming (not that HOTR isn't heartwarming enough 😅 despite that movie making no damn sense when you think about it)
Thats honestly very creative, i just think smudger got buried in the rumble and rotted. 👍
@@MrBroToe 🤣 if Wilbert W. Audrey himself was still alive, he'd want that to happen to Smudger. ngl
I like that idea
i remember a few years ago, watching a video like this one, where Henry's driver and fireman, abandoned him along a lonely line in his own forest. not out of spite or anger. but to protect him, since the diesels were basically taking over sodor. and just like OP's post, some boys found Henry in the forest, and Henry would tell the boys his life story, and that he's happy now, living amongst the trees and animals.
Cool headcanon
7:39 Smudger's Whistle
Wow now that’s what I call a true sad story of Smudger, I do feel sorry for him and I can see how he was after he was killed and haunting the railway as a lonely spectre but I hope he will let go of his past and move on to rest in peace
3:34 i know this was most likely unintentional but i like how as soon as smudger said something did go wrong he is covered by the shadows of the rocks
Oh yeah, unintentional but actually brilliant foreshadowing
Yes! I was hoping someone would adapt this story.
I'll be right back with an update on what I think of this video proper.
Poor Smudger, dude. This just makes me feel sad for one of the mid Sodor engines we thought was just another naughty engine who didn’t care if he caused trouble or not. At least we can say the poor lad is free once again.
Wasn't expecting to hear Silent Hill music in this video xD Really glad you adapted it for us too! Gave me a new perspective on Smudger and I still never got over that they just left him there.
Can i swear? You know what Idc, because. 👏its👏about👏FUCKING👏time! About time that i saw a visual adaptation of this story!
I'm literally quaking in my boots rn
Smudger is what I would call "Sodor's Condemned". Engines that underwent hard times and had the unthinkable happen to them. Up there with Timothy, Alfred and Diesel 10.
that's nice that duke deply cares about smudger despite making mistakes
Great adaptation! Would love to see more!
Headcanon: Smudger, Rheneas, and Dolgoch, are siblings.
So are Andrew (the engine who fell from the Old Iron Bridge in Duncan gets Spooked), Skarloey, Tallylyn and Jennings
I wonder how many years Smudger would've served the Mid Sodor Railway as when he was an engine in this timeline? What about Stanley - did he replace Smudger until he got turned into a pumping engine? Would anyone have rescued him?
Same
in my head-canon Smudger arrives on the MSR in 1925 and became number 2 to replace Stanley (the first number 2, who arrived in 1920 but got turned into a pumping engine in 1924) but Smudger got turned into a Generator in 1928 and got scrapped in October 1945
It’s a sad story, of an engine who wanted to be useful, but his faults left him useless. So he was turned into a generator, and then was Left Behind.
If my Characters heard about Smudger, they would most certainly come looking for him, his remains.
I’d love to see more one the ghost of smudger
Well, in other series about mud, he didn’t die. He came back to life because someone came to the railway tour and they found them and they got help for him or something, and they brought them back on the rails.
Looking forward to seeing this 😀
They say that smudgers spirit still roams the old line, hoping that one day someone will find him
I feel bad for duke like what happens when duke goes back to the railway and finds smudger's corpse
Smudger had the same problems like the ALCO C855. Production was rushed + form over function. Also duke seemd not to care about Smudger. Prad...
I feel bad for smudged and even though he hadn’t been the nicest engine I still think he needs a second chance
I always did wonder what happened to smudger i thought he was just left there to rust but i do believe now that he died
You know I would've adapted left behind
But guess you beat me to it
This isn’t horror so much as a tragic tale
That was wonderful. Though duke's "shocked" face kinda looks strange for some reason. =/
Looks like they photoshopped it from his Season 6 face sheet and added pupils.
So...will there be a continuation? A story maybe about his recover or something after Duke is rescued?
That is actually a decent idea, I might write a story like that. Thanks for the suggestion
Great adaptation
11:49 Gives me the feeling like I just got overwhelmed in a mansion infested by zombies, vampires, and werewolves.
Awesome can't wait to see this video
BRO that is AWESOME that was so much better then i thought it would be
This, is amazing.
This reminded me about shed 17 while smudger being removed we seen random red things under him while smudger is lift by cranky
I think it's blood coming out of smudger
Don’t compare this masterpiece to shed 17.
No it cant be blood its like stuck in the little generators thing and its like sticky so it cant be blood but there is still blood@@noobs905real
I remember in the thomas episode grand puff smuger was behind the shed that Duke was telling the other engines stuart and Falcon a story about him but now his ghost rides the rail where he was left behind
what a trully amazing story well done to you and narrow gauge
Smudgers story does need to be told to he isnt forgotten. Wnen i was a kid i did always wonder what happened to him.
The silent hill song at the end very ominous
Poor Smudger…
Was Smudger ever able to make peace?
Nope
I really liked this story, it’s emotional too. Probably why I like it so much. Also just out of curiosity what was the background music in the beginning that you used? Just wondering, because I like it.
Music (like in the original audio visual) is listed in the credits in order ;)
11:45 Dead of the Night’s game over
Awesome video 😄😄
What is the song that the part when engines would say hello to sumdger
RIP smugder
Duncan kinda reminds me of Smudger because they are both troublemakers exept Duncan wasnt used as a generator later on
Post me a link for the Smudger model
Welp. Sir smudger model was created by another model of rheneas so… maybe you know rheneas model i don’t really know but eh good luck on your research
Poor smudger
you forgot to delete the smoke effect for smudger in content creator plus
Narrow gauge said he was no longer allowing adaptations of his stories
what program do you use for the video footage?
If you mean recording software I use streamlabs
@@lukeslocos111 no silly, the game program, if I meant recording, I would've asked a totally different question
@@Lukisquez Ah sorry 😂😅 I use Trainz 2019
@@lukeslocos111 all good, at least you gave an answer, thanks mate
You don’t usually see this one adapted.
Where did you get the models for smudger and duke
Did you ask for permission to adapt this story?
Not to mention he wanted the adaptations to stop.
he did.
@@maxlol4873 i highly doubt you read the pinned comment.
The ending song sounds like the melody from "fluttershy's nusic box" bt the lost narrator, what song is it??
9:56 s.handel's whistle
Very Nice
11:45 the dead of the night game over from black ops 4 zombies
😢
whats is te credit song name
That was good!
Where can I download the MSR map
BLESS AND DOOKIE WHO WORRIES ABOUT A FEW SPILLS?
7:11 what’s goin on with his steam bro 💀
R.I.P smudger
Nice adaptation, sorry to say though that this isn't allowed, Narrow Gauge (the creator of the story) has said that people are not allowed to adapt his stories as these videos often get more views and compliments than the actual story that he posted. After looking at the comments here, I can see why he's done it. I'd suggest taking this video down before we lose the entirety of "Horror on the Rails" before it's too late.
-Elias
Maybe check the pinned comment first, he’s gotten permission, next time read.
@@chariotstudios2019
The pinned comment was posted the very same day as the OP's. I'd say there's a 50/50 chance he didn't read the pinned comment because it didn't exist at the time he posted this.
What if Smudger exploded?
I wanna see dukes reaction to what happened to smudger I dont know I like drama :)
Oh my God
Where did you get the route/routes from?
Listed in the credits
@@lukeslocos111 cheers
Is this shed 17?
No
This has nothing to do with shed 17
You should upload your Minecraft videos to a second account
Bukannya Smudger udah pisah badannya
hey luke’s locos
😍😍😍😍😍
Its like sodor failout
Series 4(1994-95)
Narrated by: George Carlin
Horror of the Rails ll
Project g1?????
No
Shut up
Do a part 2
🎉 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😮
kinda creepy ngl
is that adolf hitler?? LOL
I... Don't feel 𝙝𝙖𝙥𝙥𝙮 or 🅢🅐🅓 or angry... I feel nothing
*meanwhile dead of the night game over plays*