Who Sang The "The Destruction" High Parts Best?
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 08. 2024
- Watch the other videos of the original series "Who Sang It Best?" here: • Who Sang It The Best?
Follow me on my social media accounts!:
► Twitter: bit.ly/2Cy2QFJ
► Instagram: bit.ly/3C2P77N
► TikTok: bit.ly/3A9BLWd
#carrie #broadway #theatre
I think Keaton’s choice to allow herself to scream was a really intelligent move. With these big notes I think we can feel pressure to sing them beautifully rather than authentically. A music director told me once that something “didn’t need to sound pretty” because I wasn’t pushing the piece emotionally. The screams are so well executed and bone chilling.
I’m also obsessed with how Evelyn Hoskins slides up with the ensemble. It’s so damn good.
Try doing it 8 times a week 😩😩😩
Keaton made me shiver from her voice especially the “Doesn’t everybody get it right” I felt scared and addicted to her voice
Angel Gonzales omg the bootleg pf her's on CZcams is so amazing
It did made me shiver
Purple is Fetch same
It made me go deaf lol😂🤣😂🤣
copycat brain lol you can’t sing any better
keaton!!! she bought so much frustration and you could literally see her character and the toughness at the end of each perfect note brought a new level of frustration to the character
I'm probably A loser You can hear it! The roughness at the end of every note! It's awesome!
I'm probably A loser agreed
It’s free real estate
Yes. She portrays the role perfectly. She should the lead actor on the actual Broadway production.
Carrie, looking at downtown Chamberlain: "It's free real estate"
I love Keaton because she not only is a PHENOMENAL singer, she puts so much emotion into her character and it makes everything seem so much more personal and deep and real!
If you watch the whole version, her arm gestures when she's killing everyone are so good. The ones I saw here weren't as forceful or with the beat
She can stop her shrieking are is a big problem for her keep hurting herself by hurting her voice she’s hurting my ears it makes me My deaf ear bleed
@@jillianvicic3282 I'm pretty sure she does that on purpose.
If you watch her, she's literally yelling at the people around her, so it'd make sense for her to use distortion here. Your voice distorts when there's a heck load of vocal fold contact.
Best acting goes to Keaton Whittaker
👏👏👏👏👏
Yep
I love herrr
Ana Becerra seriously though she's ridiculously good
TRUE
Keaton she introduced me to Carrie the musical and she just plays the character so well
Dj Ne Same here! She captures such a raw emotion
Sameeee
I disagree even Sissy spacek did a better job than her actually Sissy spacek is literally one of the best portrayals of Carrie ever kaeton could never top her
copycat brain I disagree
@@kawaiimarshmallowlover9011 that subjective opinion is irrelevant to the subjective criticisms I'm giving out
Keaton may not have had the right notes but she KILLED THE EMOTION! Made me have goosebumps
I think she did. But purposefully added the squeaks.
Me too
She might have been sick or her throat could have been sore because playing a character like Carry more than once a week can be very stressful on someone’s voice
She did it on purpose?
@@lailafallon573 yeah for emotion. it really shows that she's frustrated, and filled with anguish.
i still dont undersrand why they removed "god has seen you sinning just begining pray for your salvation from damnation" its such a powerful verse if delivered correctly
100% agree. That line is very important for multiple reasons.
That is part of the song “And Eve Was Weak”.
@@jcm9097 why is it
@@JacobSanchez I'm pretty sure what they mean is that psychologically, Carrie ends up becoming just like her mother, a traumatized psychopath and eventually murderer (because she sings her mother's line)
Abigail Shamrell it used to be included in the destruction as well
Riverdale did Carrie and removed all the best songs WTF?!
INCLUDING EVE WAS WEAK
Fadhil Ramadhani this song was either too demanding or they didnt have a place to put it in the ep cus they seemed to have woven the songs from the musical into the plot. im just glad they did not do grease lol
I don’t think they had enough time so they just put the most well known songs
Fadhil Ramadhani
I’m gonna rant on that.
They also removed all good singing
I love Molly Ranson's version, but Keaton's will always be my favorite. She looks and sounds so innocent, which is why she makes the perfect Carrie. But in her destruction scene, she sounds so angry, which completely fits and I've never seen someone portray it that incredibly.
Whittaker adds a little bit of a scream element to it, which is an interesting choice. Ranson's high notes are the most controlled and clear, though.
It’s not more about how controlled it sounds though the frustration of Keaton fits the character of the rage Carrie was feeling
My Brain: You watched this already
Me: But Carrie....
My Brain: Please no
Me: *Watches anyways*
Was it worth it
I’ve watched this vid too many times lol
Same
Same.
Me too
I actually love Evelyn Hoskins’ different key. That “doesn’t anybody ever get it right” is so resonant and gets right into your bones which I think is so important for this moment
Evelyn’s version is definitely my favorite
That’s a different key? I would have liked to sing my version in another key lol. Would have been a chance of me doing it better haha
She’s amazing
Yes, it's in a key I can actually sing! Us altos deserve to be Carrie too, lol
Keaton was more emotional than rest and just the spirit of Carrie as well as Evelyn and Molly ... Emily Lopez somehow just chilled me to the bone!!!! but Tiana was good too but not how Carrie should sound in my mind... but all in all they all did their best!
Keaton is the example of how a musical performance isn't about belting and doing perfect notes, but to let emotions express through it. Her screams were chilling.
Thank you so much for including me in this!!!!
Rose Riley You were really good!!
By far my favorite!!!! ❤️
You were so goooddd
Yours was so beautiful!!!
Rose Riley YOU HONESTLY BLEW ME AWAY you really know how carrie was meant to be played!
My favorite was Keaton Whittaker. I loved her emotion that nobody else had quite enough of. But everyone was amazing
AJ thank you!
AJ same
I love Carrie so much! It was the 1st book I read by Stephen King (who's one of my fav authors) so I was skeptical about the musical at first. But it really surprised me (not you 1988 version). I get chills at the "Doesn't anybody think that I hear?" part.
Meanwhile there's me being complete trash for the '88 version. I'm such a sucker for dated 80's music.
You have to admit though, the “Eve Was Weak” reprise in the original version of the destruction is fantastic!
Chase Fowler HELL YEAH!! That's sorely missing from the revival.
LOVE SK!!!
Carrie is still the only Stephen King book I've read
Evelyn , Keaton, Rose and Molly are my favs.
Madame Corgi Thank you!!!!
Madame Corgi Yes!!! They’re so good omg
I can totally get behind that.
Evelyn's was flawless... But it was only a C
I love the lower key in Evelyn's. It fits so well, her voice just soars.
We all gonna ignore how amazing Evelyn Hoskins sounded? Oh my God I'm obsessed with the harmony, it's a little lower too which idk why, but sounds amazing.
that's actually the original key/how it was written for the 1988 version (linzi hateley sang it in that key as well!) they raised the key and made it more vocally demanding in 2012 for the off-broadway revival, and I guess it just stuck around for all productions post-2012
I thought something was different now I know why haha. No wonder my voice was breaking so bad lol
I think the lowered version sounds fantastic, the original is a very grand, Carrie completely losing her mind. This version is almost creepy, it’s like she’s slowly preparing everyone for what’s about to happen.
the 2015 southwark london production is my absolutely favorite production of carrie!!!!
carrie the musical is so underrated! i don't why people hate on it so much :(
I love the musical, too, but it gets a lot of hate because when it premiered in 1988, a lot of the songs were different and it flopped quickly. But now that it's coming back in revivals with different songs, it's getting popular again.
Fun fact: this show closed after five performances despite being sold out every night.
It’s definitely misunderstood
Because the creative team in 1988 didn't go with an American Company and decided yet again to let the British produce american story's they really new nothing about, and turned it into a big farce and didn't play it straight either from the book or the film. He saw it as a greek tradity and not a show about religion and about high school and how much girls would have killed other girls to get to go to the prom. The UK from my understanding didn't have proms or do them. The songs from back then were awesome, and would have all worked out, if they had not made everything white, from costumes to set pieces, and the choreographer should never have played the gym teacher also. They brought in adults to play kids, and their Billy was way to old to be in high school and having a relationship with Chris. And then we finally get an American production and they cut out all the great songs and replace them with stooped up to date songs. the story takes place in the 1970's and they should have stayed there, bullying is bullying no matter how much you try to update it. They should have kept Don't wast the Moon in a driven, and they should have kept the original do me a favor, and the workshop virsson of them getting ready for the prom. Along with Carrie working on levitating her bed, and such. You don't have to up date everything that has been written from a certain time period, especaley if its a Stephen King story. I would have cut tommy's song an egal is another bird, and written a better song for him, and put back in the full song out for blood/
I wish this musical can be noticed by more people. Don't get me wrong, I adore most of the well known ones and some of them are on my top ten (along with this one of course) but I wish Carrie wasn't so underrated. Maybe someday it will be well known like the others? I don't know. Hopefully someday It will.
Am I the only one who LOVES Ashley Nicastro’s vocals?
cassidyreadstohouseplants definitely my favorite!!
her voice is so powerful
I love her voice in this song!
Same, here
i love it
FINALLY! SOMEONE ELSE WHO APPRECIATES THE ARTWORK THAT IS CARRIE THE MUSICAL
Also, Molly, Keaton and Rose are my favorites. Keaton and Molly are terrific actresses, but DANG. Rose’s voice gave me chills! Such a beautiful voice!
Antwondi Thank you so much!!!!
@@rosetaylor-riley7474Carrie is one of my dream roles also hi Rose I think you could make a great Regina George in mean girls
Keaton sounds genuinely pissed off at everything and everyone. The Destruction is Carrie's breaking point and she really conveys that perfectly
I feel like it’s a little unfair to compare Linzi Hateley here. The “An eagle’s just another bird” line didn’t exist yet. “Doesn’t anybody ever get it right” wasn’t the song’s climax there, it was the part that came after (that is unfortunately not included in the modern version). Additionally, the part in the 1988 version is in a lower octave, so there’s no high note like in the revival.
Yeah. She definitely gets more powerful (vocally and physically) after that part.
IT'S SO HARD TO CHOOSE THE BEST! I love Molly's acting and the way she hits the notes and her voice soars! But also, Linzi, even if she doesn't belt like most of the others her sound is just so interesting and there's something about her that really reminds me of the Carrie from the book.
But my favorite, at least in this song, is Evelyn! I mean, her screlting just fits the song SO well! I'm actually disappointed that other Carries didn't do it
Linzi has such an interesting voice. Like it's almost nasally in her early career, but not quite. Now it's got this goooorgeous richness to it. I mean *ahem* it's not like i've listened to basically everything I can find of hers...not at all...*shifty eyes*
where did evelyn play the role?
sooper salad Southwark Playhouse off West End!
ALittlePriest Can I just say I love your username and profile picture ;) (No, I totally haven’t been obsessing over Sweeney Todd for months)
.
I had no idea there was a Carrie musical; this channel always teaches me something new!
Wtf you're literally everywhere!!
I literally love all of your comments though
I gotta agree that Keaton is great. She has so much character, and her speeding up, shrieking just fits the character, scene, and song. This song isn't supposed to be sung beautifully. it's a piece of pure anger
I also loved Danielle, Evelyn and Najah.
4:15 let’s just talk about the power of the music
The full orchestra instrumental was easily the best part of the 1988 productions, it's absolutely amazing.
Molly Ranson is genuinely terrifying tho.
Fr Like her eyes.
Although it isn't seen here, Keaton Whittaker's destruction is the best I've ever seen (excluding the movies).
itstobieee It’s on here
@@julesk2629 I think they mean the whole scene, here we can just see Keaton singing.
But in my opinion, Emily Lopez's is the best. Especially for the fact of how unique Tommy's, Billy's and Chris's deaths are.
itstobieee Keaton is the second one they show in the video
Keaton! She threads the needle between a theatrical and musical performance so perfectly. Normally, screeches are too theatrical and take away from the natural transition of musical theatre (normal speech -> singing -> dancing) but with Keaton, the screech builds up from under the note and gives the impression that the rip is an extension of the note and not an interruption or sacrificial move. I’m in love.
My favorites:
1) Evelyn Hoskins (3:44)
2) Keaton Whittaker (0:50)
3) Najah Hetsberger (3:17)
Najahs is the worst by far. She only goes for the notes. Zero emotion.
R F i personally really like her carrie she sang it beautifully but i agree she didn’t have a lot of emotion
R F it also sounds like she was struggling to hit the notes
I Hajah’s just because of the people behind her. They’re supposed to be laughing at her not supporting her
Yes I loved Evelyn!!!!
I was super charmed by Evelyn!
She is the perfect Carrie
her tone quality tho, impeccable
I really like Molly and Evelyn vocally, and I think that Keaton did an amazing job playing the part. They’re all amazing honestly
look! yes keaton may be a lot of people’s favourites, but can we just take a second to appreciate ALL of these women!! They all did an absolutely amazing job with the characters incredibly high notes!
Why is no one talking about Ashley. She was so good!
Molly Ranson is by far my favorite she hits the notes perfectly and get Carrie’s rage down flawlessly.
I want to like Keaton's but I feel like cutting it off so sharply like that might be damaging. I'm not familiar with healthy vocal practices, so I can't claim anything. Is it OK for her to do that?
Kodoku Pierrot I can’t tell if it’s a choice of the voice breaking or her not supporting whilst she’s singing that note. Either way it does add another layer to the character of Carrie!
I think it's definitely a conscious acting choice and someone would have told her not to do that if it was going to hurt her voice I think.
I'm pretty sure she's using vocal fry, so it's not healthy but it's not bad.
Kodoku Pierrot honestly idk but she makes carrie’s character seem so much more emotional and delivered a great performance
It's somewhat of a technique to add those cracks tho
Why is no one talking about Rose
Hannah&Sophia beauty haha that’s me! Thank you!!
Rose Riley not a problem! You are insanely talented!!! Love your belt
Rose Riley
I loved yours! Don't feel left out!
Rose Riley you were the first video I saw of the destruction and oh my god you are a goddess. Amazing.
Rose and evelyn man
Molly is always gonna be Carrie for me, she brings a very special believability to the character that I haven’t seen in any other portrayal. However, second best goes to Keaton- I think her acting is spot on, especially here. The way she sings here is also the next best IMO, along with the way that she shows the complete anger that Carrie is feeling.
I think we can all agree, all of these girls are incredibly talented.
Ive watched this about 15 times in 2 days and ITS SO AMAZING!!! I love Keaton, Evelyn, Rose and Molly, they all bring something really unique to tge character of Carrie.
Edie Davies Thank you!!!
Rose Riley You're very welcome!
why is no one talking about the first girl!!
Ocean K she was my personal favorite
God watching this video makes me so sad because I’m currently in the production of Carrie at my high school as Sue Snell and on the day of opening night it was canceled (with the promise of being postponed but idek at this point) because of coronavirus and like anything related to Carrie at this point is just making me so upset
I'm literally discovering new song/show obsessions thanks to your videos...most of the time i'm skeptical of the show and therefore won't seek out specific songs to check out, but your posts guarantee to sate my appetite for high belting...thank you for doing good work, sir
Keaton, Ann, Najah, Evelyn, and Rose are my favorites!
OtterRonpas Thank you!!!
Yes we gotta give credit for the one an only black Carrie who serves vocals
Michael Yates lol thank youuu!!
Thank youuuu!!!
@@NajahHetsberger no prob cause like you were amazing
i’m so glad you made this!!! i think this musical is tragically underrated
4:06 best one by far vocal range is by far the best her breath control is outta this world
Keaton nailed the vocal part but THE ACTING WAS FLAWLESS. You can hear the characters frustration and anger. SHE DID THAT
Rose's voice is wow ! , she made Carrie sound like she was gonna snap while singing O_O
Keaton was my first Carrie. I'm biased towards her. Plus she's precious
i freaking love how keaton's voice cracks a little, it brings so much more character to the note
I’m auditioning for Carrie and I will use keatons move to make it emotional. Wish me luck!
IMPRESSED OR SCARED?
I'm both! LOL
Great job on this video, I'm loving this channel
Mister Golightly is the radio rebel of the theatre community
KEATON HAD ME SHOOK
3:56 CHILLS BEGIN HERE!
Molly and the girl with the note change to the F#5 😍😍😍
Molly can sustain for her damn life 😩😍
Keaton Whittaker's voice and her acting gave me chills! I also love Linzi Hateley because she's the blueprint for Carrie's voice. Also, The 1988 instrumental did something to me 😩😩. Such a pure 80s powerhouse sound, I loved it.
The girl breaking character on the far left at 3:33 is me watching my friends on stage while I’m on stage with them
Molly Ranson's will always be my fave - her last "I hear" is so clear and on pitch and then the creepy turn she does after!! Perfection!
i like that even though it’s lower, Evelyn still portrays the emotion and power that the others do!
Linzi will always be my favorite in that song. I'm a sucker for her voice, even in Les Miz. She has such a pure tone. Like every note is effortless.
Can’t understand why no one is talking about how amazing Linzi Hateley was??? It seems like people don’t like the 1988 version but that was undoubtedly my favorite one🤷🏻♀️
Okay, Keathon is the best one by far, her acting is just on point and her way of putting emotion on each note is just so beautiful, but Evelyn's notes were so clean and left me wanting more when it was over, so very well done omg, 1000/10 stars, my wig was snatched, my skin instantly cleared and my grades went up.
Ok there all so good but Linzi had the great vocals and amazing instruments to back up the sinning the orchestra made it more scary and I love it
Definitely Molly Ransom. Naijah was a really close second. I love seeing women of color in prominent roles like this. They -more- than deserve it. And she was absolutely phenomenal.
i like evelyn’s just because i can hit those notes lmao
I loved Evelyn Hoskins hold out and how the pit played slower and it gave depth to the music
Things I have learned from this video
- An eagle’s just another bird (until he can spread his wings)
- Nobody ever gets it right
- Nobody Carrie can hear
Evelyn Hoskins, Rose Riley and Keaton are my favorites
epicgamergirl127 Thank you so much!!!
Rose Riley you’re welcome!!! You’re a great singer of my god
Same!!
Evelyn Hoskins is ridiculously underrated
All I say is this
Why is everyone sleeping on Najah? I personally liked her, but it’s your opinion. No worries, no judgment.
I saw the show with Keaton Whittaker and she was fantastic!
I have been waiting for this! Molly will always be my Carrie but Evelyn and Keaton smashed it. But Molly gets extra credit for her Sissy Spacek eyes.
Ok this is off topic but everytime I hear the chorus sings "open your heart" I always hear "Oh Canada" 😂
oh gosh keaton whittaker gave me goosebumps, but linzi hateley will always have a special place in my heart!
Definitely molly. she's amazing in the role as a whole, but especially that part
Was anyone else shocked by Danielle Jenkin's high note on "Hear"? The other singers, after the word "I", went down on the word "Hear", but Danielle sang an even HIGHER note! I was blown away!!
I love Evelyn I think she was amazing and I definitely prefer her voice over the others
I honestly love all of those powerful singers. They were all great!!
keaton!!! so talented!! her emotion & rawness makes it so real
Keaton will always be my favorite! The way she stresses the ending of her words really brings out the character
I love Molly. The first girl and Rose were amazing. But the version with Keaton has Alice ripely ❤️
Jon Mathes Thank you!!!
Rose Riley no thank YOU for being my new hero
Keaton's emotion and Evelyn's strong voice I cannot they are so good
i LOVEEE how Rose Riley waled on “spread its wings” that was AMAZING!!
Even though this may possibly be the oldest, I absolute love Lingi Hateley’s. Second would have to be Keaton Whittaker’s, and third would be Rose Riley.
Keaton the way her voice cracked just sent chills down my spine
Keaton was awesome
Molly is so underrated in terms of the horror factor, she gives off OG Carrie horror
Keaton was my favorite because if you're doing a musical and you have a singing part, you should make sure that you make sure the character is singing, not you and I think she really nailed that and the points where it sounded kind of raspy added onto to frustration and anger to Carrie plus I think her way of performing the song was incredible and stood out from the others to me, and she hit the notes and held them out so I liked that
I loved Keaton, but Nicastro (the first one) has SUCH an INCREDIBLE voice!
Keaton. She screamed and kept control and pitch but so much emotion. She rules.
Anyways, Keaton's my favorite. Her entire portrayal of Carrie is great and I felt like she really struck the golden balance of anger and innocence - I loved the roughness of her voice juxtaposed to the clarity. (:
Evelyn Hoskins held really beautiful notes
Keaton Whittaker had a lot of rage and emotion.
those are my top 2 :)
hi I like Keaton the best
Finally a Carrie the musical video! This musical is so unnoticed and the music is really good! I’m so happy you made this!! I tell people about this musical and they didn’t even knew it existed! But thank you for making this video!
ann davis-rowe and keaton are both really good.