#WhiskyInSV
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 07. 2024
- In episode 44 of Whisky in SV, I did a blind tasting of four amazing 18 Year sherried Scotch whiskies: the over-priced Macallan 18, the Tamdhu 18 (a.k.a. the Macallan killer), the Bunnahabhain 18, and the Speyburn 18. I have to admit, I have a lot more Macallans than I am comfortable admitting to, so I was really hoping the Macallan 18 would do well. But, in all honestly, it was just too thin, and could not even stand up to the Speyburn which costs a quarter of what it does. Overall, if you are going to buy Macallan 18, I have to say, just don't! Buy the Tamdhu 18 instead, and both your wallet and your palate will thank you for it. The Bunna 18 is also an amazing whisky offered at a great value but the profile is very different from Macallan. #whiskyinsv • #WhiskyInSV 044: Macal...
To purchase the American Whiskey Glass with Whisky in SV logo, you can go to whiskeywhisdom.com/?via=wsv and select the American Whiskey glass with engraving option and then email support@whiskeywhisdom.com and let them know you want the engraving to be "Whiskey in Silicon Valley" logo.
If you are in California, you can support the channel by buying from Unwind Bottle Shop using my referral link: unwindbottleshop.com/?bg_ref=... - Hudba
Awesome comparison!
Great line-up. Thanks for this. Very informative.
Glad you enjoyed it!
AnCnoc 24 also works in this department. Sherry and bourbon cask, but the sherry shines.
True if we only consider cost range but I wanted to stick yo 18 YOs :) thanks for watching!
@@whiskyinsv Indeed. It was just the flavor profile and the price. I tried many 18+ yo and found that one a good replacement when Macallan went downhill or uphill pricewise.
@@Eunegin23 yup makes sense! Thanks for the feedback!
Great job and comparing.
Cheers 🥃
Thanks!
Nice review
Great job!
Thanks!
I love Speyburn, one of the most underrated. I also like Ancnoc & glen moray 18
Agreed, all three still at great value compared to the big names.
You can't beat blind tastings for removing prejudices and preconceptions, although this is a semi-blind of course. Well done for getting them all correct. I suspect the reason you thought the Mac18 a little 'thin' is more to do with it being the only one which is chill filtered rather than the slightly lower ABV. I think the hint of peat you're picking up in the Bunna 18 is more than likely a result of trace elements left behind in the various production equipment from the heavily peated spirit they occasionally produce.
Makes sense. Thanks for taking the time to point that out! Happy holidays!
Great video. Just found your channel and subscribed. Cheers
Thank you!
Excellent review and presentation! Well done! ☺️👍
Tamdhu 18 is not available in Mumbai, India. So I will have to get it from Dutyfree soon.
Cheers
Tamdhu is $390 from where I’m from🤦🏻♂️ just slightly cheaper than Macallan which is $430. Just bought the speyburn 18, hoping to try it soon.. I saw reviewer say the speyburn 18 taste like a Glenlivet 18 on steroids😂
That is too bad that Tamdhu pricing is getting on par with Macallan, but honestly between the two, I would take Tamdhu any day. Speyburn 18 is not as good as Tamdhu but it can be had for way less money, so value wise it is a no-brainer for sure. It is a solid dram.
Great content. Really enjoyed the format and always respect blind tastings. I just picked up a bottle of the Speyburn 18 that I sampled at a local festival, so I haven't had a chance to really dig into it yet, but based on just one nose/sip I instantly saw the quality/value in it. I also had a thought that it might be a really good alternate to Highland Park 18 but it's been awhile since I've had a HP18. If you have both open, try a side by side and let me know your thoughts. HP18 is $75 more than Speyburn 18 in my market. (Eastern Canada) Cheers!
Thanks! Enjoy!
I have a HP18 but havent opened it yet. Will do that soon based on your comment
I recommend Glendronach 18 as well
Yeah that is a good one for sure but getting too pricey
yes like all other whiskies too. at the moment its 148 Euro per bottle.
@@whiskyinsv
I was recently debating which two bottles to buy out of these : Bunna 18, Tamdhu 18, Mortlach 16, Tobermory 21, Ledaig 18, Craigellachie 17.
Which two would you pick?
Really depends on ur preferences and prices you can acquire them at but personally I love the Tamdhu 18 the most followed by bunna 18!
@@whiskyinsv I had the Tamdhu 15 and thought it was the closest to the old Billy Walker Glendronach 18.
How different is the Tamdhu 15 from the 18?
@@SaltyCuban I havent tried the 15 yet unfortunately. Sounds like a great endorsement though!
For some reason bunna 18 it 400 here in Illinois
That is insane!
Try the Ledaig 18 year old.
I have it. I didnt want to try it with these as these are not peated.