Palestine: 50 Years Of Occupation: Former Israeli soldiers reveal army methods
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 06. 2024
- Israel's 50-year military rule in Palestine has led to questions about the conduct of some Israeli soldiers. Around 12-hundred former soldiers have formed an organisation and testified about violent methods used against Palestinians. It's called "Breaking the Silence" and TRT World's Iolo ap Dafydd spoke to some of them.
Subscribe: trt.world/subscribe
Livestream: trt.world/ytlive
Facebook: trt.world/facebook
Twitter: trt.world/twitter
Instagram: trt.world/instagram
Visit our website: trt.world
It takes a lot of courage to admit your wrongdoings and speak out against it.
That's what I am wondering why not muslims in mass do not admit and correct their wrong doings through out the world.
The ones who you see ISIS and all those terrorist groups in the surface are all NOT MUSLIMS.
@@bidyutchatterjee7195 what are you on about??
@@ilyaandrienko9956 stop being but hurt and spamming the comment section smh it’s really embarrassing and sad to see
@@sageofsixbowls9773 innit
These guys are brave, they acknowledge they where wrong.
As a human being its the right thing to do
Thats what EVERY HUMANS SHOULD BE..
@Night Parade
Did they invade your country
Did steal your land
Did they kill you loved ones and babies.
DONT act as if you dont know that it is palestine, and that what the zionist are saying and the state they want is a fabricated lie.
@Night Parade yes. They are innocent. The land Israel occupies is Palestinians. They have every right to defend it.
@Night Parade night parade; huh I’m dumb ok ain’t got eyes 👀
@Night Parade "and the palestinians are innocent? 🙄🙆🏻♂️" Those who are innocent, are innocent. Those who aren't, aren't. Ever since the XVIIIth century, it has been increasingly a feature of Western ethics systems and criminal justice systems to place the responsibility on the individual, and not on entire community. Now, do you aspire to these ideals?
Native American tribal members stand with Palestine 👊🏽💯💥🇺🇸
Heroes 💞
Thank you💓💓💓
Why don't you chase the Europeans back and reclaim the lands you owned?
@@MifazEM don't push. let's appreciate the fact that they support palestine and mind your own business.
@@MifazEM let greeks come claim back their anatolian peninsula
My country the Philippines gave safe haven to 1000 Jews fleeing the war in Europe in the 1940s. Now I join my voice no matter how small to those asking for compassion for Palestinians. They have a right to live and be treated like human beings. We knew what it's like to be ruled and occupied by hostile invaders. My heart goes out to any people in the world denied of basic human rights.
Thanks, sis. Filipinos have been so silent about this. Those who talked didn't read anything beyond the mention of religion. I was starting to grow hopeless if we would ever speak up. You're the first fellow Filipino I've seen who expressed support to Palestine.
@@luciferbroke7875 I am in the middle I am still not done with my research but this war, this missile attacks has to stop asap. I have a question though who really owns the land that the Palestines lived? Is it the Israelis? Or Palestines?
Love and respect for you sister, the same thing if not more wosre is happening to Muslims in Kashmir that people should be awared about the Indian government has been butchering people of kashmir for lore than 70 years, pray for them sister
@@pumpkindiamond994 Unfortunately that's difficult to answer... You would have to look at the history of that region from at least 2000 year's ago & work your way up to 1947...pause & consider the multiple owners (Empires) that ruled over that region and the history of mankind how we control or take over a region.
@@pumpkindiamond994 Google 1948 Palestinian exodus - to find out.
Like Norman Finkelstein said "if you have any heart, you'd be crying for the Palestinians". Thank you for speaking the truth.
Two honorable human beings. If u cant see these are whistleblowers then you are blind as hell. Whistleblowers regret what they were ordered to do and speak out AGAINST it. Always support whistleblowers. Blaming ALL Israeli’s is like blaming all whites in America for slavery. Its ignorant to do so, when you had many many whites who gave their lives to abolish slavery and free people from slavery. Also the underground railroad needed those white families to succeed in helping the people escape from slavery. But do u think they teach any of this in schools? Of course not because divide & conquer is the oldest trick in the book. If you blindly hate & generalize all people into one group, then your no better than those who hate you.
@@JoeHunt. troll
Yep and millions of honarable moms dads teens young adults kids and college students massacred
@@2k5mike Exactly. Thats why its important to have jews like these speaking out against it because unlike what we are taught to believe its not true that ALL jews support that horror being committed. There are many jewish groups loudly voicing their protest against that injustice & murder. Once ppl stop allowing themselves to be divided and speak unified against oppression will things change.
@@driver55 yea but who cares. tell that to the millions of innocent whole familes that where indiscriminately massacred.. they didnt stop and think... "oh lets go after these guys because they are bad"....time to do the same to whoever is in that plot of land until they all scatter just like they did to the whole middle east. they are crazy...and they think they are fighting god....they know exactly what happened and what the real true book is.... and that god spread them through the land because they where bad thats why they had no homeland.....and now they are like "oh yea god? take this"...and they are doing it purposely to the people of the true book lol...they are in denial still thinking they are the chosen ones but they arent anymore because of how bad theyve been ever since jesus came....they said no new religion we are the chosen people!
@@2k5mike No we should care. It DOES matter. Your blaming a whole group of people for the criminality of the elite that control govt’s. You obviously dont know the history of who and why they created Israel. Elite families i wont mention here. They trick and brainwash many, NOT ALL jews to follow their lies blindly. This isnt about religious dogma, about who has the so called sacred book or who so called are the chosen people.
When you speak out of hatred then you become no better than them. Its like when people blame the whole white race (what ever white means, its ridiculous), for the murder of native americans or black people (black ppl another ridic label), when many many whites fought & died trying to liberate them. This bull crap of us vs them is EXACTLY the divide & conquer tool that has been used against humanity to separate us. Wars, racism, bias, genocide, etc is all created and maintained through fear & ignorance. Hate comes from this lack of understanding the politics behind this division. Its beyond religion!
There is an ILLUSION OF DIVISION that rules this world. This illusion is fostered by our mainstream news media that is controlled by the elite also.
You want to place blame, then place blame on where Israel gets its biggest funding from, and that is the United States. BILLIONS of dollars. Its very easy to only blame ALL jews. When Americas corruption spreads around the world can you blame ALL Americans, NO. Then when politicians & the people in America & other countries speak against zionism, they are labeled anti Semitic. They call us conspiracy mongers. They call us unpatriotic. They call us paranoid. They control us by making us FEAR & HATE one another. There is NO chosen race or group. We are the tree of humanity with many different ethnic branches. But we are still humanity, family. When crimes are committed do not blame a whole race or group, because then you are no better. Seek to bridge brotherhood & sisterhood with those that seek justice, that know criminality & injustice, that are HONEST & HONORABLE.
We must raise our conscious above our low consciousness political structures, & institutions. Extremely low consciousness structures. What are the philosophical & theological implications of this situation, this endless war and murder the war profiteers engineer & benefit from.
It is not enough to just involve yourself in a SUBCULTURE identity. Cult is within the word culture. If we cant get beyond this tribalism of division, then we are destined to end up destroying everything.
The human family is a beautiful garden with many beautiful flowers. Within all those plants is the life force, the energy, that makes life happen. THIS IS OUR POINT OF COMMONALITY. What is beautiful about this is it’s universal! We must find a point of commonality, of oneness, that transcends even humanity. At the root of all of this is a deeply spiritual, problem. Not religious, but spiritual! The essence is spirit. We are all within a conscious field, & the awake being shining a light within all of us. Transcend what the demagogues and warmongers want us to be.
We should all be ambassadors of the truth & peace.
The motto should be, ONE UNIVERSE ONE PEOPLE This is an operative philosophy and it’s ancient.
If we dont learn this and continue the cycle of hatred, revenge & separation, then we ALL will suffer its consequences. Period.
Reread clearly what i have stated here and see the bigger picture. The internet is plagued with people constantly spewing hatred & creating more & more division and not knowing real history & how to improve it. All we have are people joining groups vs other groups and are only stuck on revenge based on this idea of absolutism. Childs play is over when do we grow up as humanity.
DO NOT STAY STUCK IN THE REDUCTIONIST VIEW OF REALITY. -Daniel Sheehan, Constitutional Lawyer
May god protect them for being honest
Aameen
@Storm We don't want Muslim states to run secularly. Keep your ideas with you
@@grandpamemes2072 no you want oppression and murder.
@@sb1361 Religion provokes oppression and murder? Where?
@@grandpamemes2072 Israel
They are brave enough to admit that what they were doing is wrong. Respect to them.
If you do good, you do good for yourselves; and if you do evil, [you do it] to yourselves
(Al-Quran 17:7)
❤❤❤❤❤❤
So true. You can see that most Israeili soldiers have post traumatic stress but no one talks about it. Its because when you have a human being, your soul will torment you forever. That is the price they pay which is a heavy price
You quote the verse 17:7 incomplete and out of context.
"Allah" talks to the children of Israel:
[17:4] And We gave (Clear) Warning to the Children of Israel in the Book, that twice would they do mischief on the earth and be elated with mighty arrogance
Therefore the children of Israel get punished:
[17:7] If ye did well, ye did well for yourselves; if ye did evil, (ye did it) against yourselves. So when the second of the warnings came to pass, (We permitted your enemies) to disfigure your faces, and to enter your Temple as they had entered it before, and to visit with destruction all that fell into their power.
Not a very peaceful message after all :(
@@slippingsnake
And [recall] when We took the covenant from the Children of Israel, [enjoining upon them], "Do not worship except Allah ; and to parents do good and to relatives, orphans, and the needy. And speak to people good [words] and establish solat (prayer) and give zakah (alms)." Then you turned away, except a few of you, and you were refusing.
And [recall] when We took your covenant, [saying], "Do not shed each other's blood or evict one another from your homes." Then you acknowledged [this] while you were witnessing.
Then, you are those [same ones who are] killing one another and evicting a party of your people from their homes, cooperating against them in sin and aggression. And if they come to you as captives, you ransom them, although their eviction was forbidden to you. So do you believe in part of the Scripture and disbelieve in part? Then what is the recompense for those who do that among you except disgrace in worldly life; and on the Day of Resurrection they will be sent back to the severest of punishment. And Allah is not unaware of what you do.
Those are the ones who have bought the life of this world [in exchange] for the Hereafter, so the punishment will not be lightened for them, nor will they be aided.
And We did certainly give Moses the Torah and followed up after him with messengers. And We gave Jesus, the son of Mary, clear proofs and supported him with the ruh-ul-Kudus (Spirit of the Holy / Angel Gabriel). But is it [not] that every time a messenger came to you, [O Children of Israel], with what your souls did not desire, you were arrogant? And a party [of messengers] you denied and another party you killed.
(Al-Quran 2:83-87)
O Children of Israel, remember My favor which I have bestowed upon you and fulfill My covenant [upon you] that I will fulfill your covenant [from Me], and be afraid of [only] Me.
And believe in what I have sent down (the Quran) confirming that which is [already] with you (the Torah), and be not the first to disbelieve in it. And do not exchange My signs for a small price, and fear [only] Me (God).
(Al-Quran 2:41-42)
2 over,on 3rd quran says 17:8
Speaking the truth is hard. I salute these two individuals.
A genuine human exist when they admit their mistake.
For the first time I'm seeing two brave humans here who have a heart ❤
Yep. I hate to see what will or has cone of them after this interview 😕
Really..Do you know that even animals have good hearts..and they love their keepers..🐈🐎
@@wishingtomarryagain2052 agree ! It's so heart breaking to see humans treated worst than animals in this case 💔
@@Waterskates Allah is the protector and He always protects pure hearts! InshAllah they will be fine 🙂
It's just astonishing to me how these videos about these subjects have veeery low views
It should come as no surprise. The media is already bought and paid for by the same people propping up the terrorist apartheid state of 'Israel.'
I tried sending these videos to my friends in UK and apparently some of the vids criticizing Israel says "not available in your country". The number of those videos probably grow larger by the minute.
@@luciferbroke7875 Ask them to try using a VPN. Or better yet, just upload the video to the cloud and share it from there.
@@A-KDJ i actually responded to your comment here yesterday and it got deleted
@@luciferbroke7875 trying using p@lésťíņè
it takes courage to speak up against the policy of your own country. Huge respect for both of you.
She’s right, if the Palestinians don’t get the protection, they won’t either regardless of how advance you are...
*70 Years Of Occupation*
Arabs invading in 600 ce doesn't justify Israelis expelling people in 20 and 21 century. We live in a new era, wake up.
@@SatishReddyMuddana stfu
@@SatishReddyMuddana hahah
@@SatishReddyMuddana you belong to the streets
@@SatishReddyMuddana yeah in your dreams
How come this is not viral?!
Respect for these two. Indeed a good person is not the one who doesn't make mistakes, but the one who admits he made a mistake, regrets it and trying to prevent it for happening again.
Respect! the lady even bravely mentioned "like all other OPPRESSIVE REGIME, they fail to sustain"
“Every Empire crumbles” remember that people.
Yes, maybe one day Islamism will be gone for good
@@Mizerableklaha that will never happen
@@Mizerableklaha islam is a religion... I wonder what kind of maps are you using.
Yes.
Great empires like the Assyrian, Babylonian, Roman, Persian and Ottoman that engaged in wars against Israel are now in Wikipedia yet the Israelites are still here so use your intellect and find out why.
Mark Twain was a lot smarter then you and he couldn’t answer this.
united states will forever ... i think
This is what heroism looks like, stand up for what’s right, especially when it’s hard.
What these two people have achieved in thier statements is far beyond what they can even imagine. Congratulations
The fact that they speak the truth. God bless them.
"Unveiling the Mystery
The heavens are gradually brightening
Though the winds have yet to desist
I vowed to the Creator to make the truth known
Neither winter’s cold nor summer’s heat shall deter
Quickly rouse, for Dafa [Great Law] is finally here to save us!
I yearn to spread the good news far and wide
This is what we have awaited over many lifetimes
This is what our ancestors enjoined us to find
And this is why humanity now exists
The followers of Dafa point to Heaven’s way
Before descending here most lives were divine
The eons of reincarnation were all for this day
2018"
Master Li Hongzhi (Hong Yin V, from Falun Dafa teachings)
"As long as Palestine has no security we are not going to have security as well"
Israeli soldier
Their feeling guilty over their and realise they mistake to said truth
The truth will come out no matter what Allah Almighty most High loves the truth .nothing but truth. .Takbeer Allah Almighty is greatest of greatest. Thank y guys 🤲🤲🤲😪😪😪Free Palestine 🤲🤲🤲😪😪😪just matter off tym Allah Almighty help is near 🤲🤲🤲
From someone who doesn't have any relations with whats going on. ( me ) i take my hat off to you for being so brave any speaken the truth.
Respect for these 2 human beings
Wow, someone speaking about morality these days... so rare. Congrats.
Thank you TRT and those speaking up! 👏👏
I respect you guys so much for your courage.
May allah protect our brother and sister for telling truth and risking there life and livelihood.
Aameen.
They are not risking their lives. Israel is not Iran or Saudi Arabia
appreciate how difficult it must be for them to speak out against their own regime, kudos
May God help these two young and brave people. Once you begin admitting wrong, it is an omen of a good thing.
With more true people like you your country will achieve peace and harmony.
"You look at Israel as if they are Superman, but they are really Homelander" - Bassem Youssef
Glad to hear you speaking out as it was, that is humanity, thank you for sharing, it takes courage & conscience to be your guide.
It is great to hear former Israeli soldiers exposing the "only democracy in Middle East!". Bravo!
Yes, and proving that statement, these men and women do not need to worry about the mukhabarat breaking down their doors and night to punish them for it
Just waking up to what is really happening.. I feel ashamed I was duped by my media..
Thank you, it isn’t too late
@@intalmdr4627 I'm sharing everything I know about this with everyone I know... I'm so saddened to know that my country, Canada, and especially the USA that sends billions of dollars to Israel to fund this... We need to stop this and stop the apartheid, the occupation, the genocide.. The right to exist for the Jewish people should not come at the cost of the extinction of a people.
@@KyleRuggles
I really appreciate what you are doing.I live in the U.S and it’s heart breaking what the lawmakers are doing and what the majority of the population here believes, it’s a sad reality.Again 🙏 😊
thank you, your comment have made me believe that we should not give up in sharing the truth in a good way, because somewhere someone's heart will open up for it, we just don't know yet.
@@KyleRuggles Thank you, i m not a Palestinian but it really frustrated me how the media manipulated almost the whole world about this issue. You are brave and smart enough to see the truth, never too late. There are still plenty of people out there who don't. God bless you
May Allah guide them to the straight path. Amin
Amin🤲🏻
آمين يا رب العالمين.
Ameen.
To the question asking whether she thinks that the oppression will end, her "inevitably" has my heart. Hope glows in the dark tunnels of despair and agony.
50 years who?! Its since 1948 🇵🇸✊
50 years of West bank lol
@@dokkanblox9695 koyak eh?
Why does media spread don't such news and just blame Palestine if they raise voice
Thank you so much you two. May god bless you. Really appreciate it.
Why no one sharing this !
There's immense pressure from Israel on all social media to censor unfavorable posts about it, they're spending millions of $ on it
This is an old video although not outdated
People should watch this video now more than ever.
Two very brave and self dignified human beings
they chose the right thing to do regardless of faith and religion
TRT World - Your work is absolutely amazing!
So brave of them to speak out like that
Every human beings does have a sense of humanity, but some of them try so hard to live without it.
BRAVE PEOPLE RAISED IN AN EVIL ENVIRONMENT SPEAK OUT AND BREAK THE CYCLE!
Well done, we need more soldiers to come forward. And they absolutely were bang on the money with what they said.
This two individuals just earned my full RESPECT
True heroes! They could just stay silent, but they have the courage to speak out.
Sad that this never went viral like how celebrities announcing their pronouns do
They aren’t the only soldiers that have come forward as there are plenty of other videos of ex IDF or some refusing to join the army. Some have committed suicide and have depression. Day in and day out having these young kids forced to mandatory army.
💯🎯
@@dinasun3 I seen one of those, it’s sad
Thank you brave souls. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
As an Arab I do want to thank these beautiful souls for speaking the truth. Israelis and Arabs are human beings. We want the same things for our families. Palestinians want to live in peace in their own homeland. Free Palestine.
I have respect for these two enlightened human beings 👍🤲 for speaking the truth and standing up for justice along time coming but finally got there👍💝
Everyone can not lift the weight of moral burden.
That's humanity.
He refused to go the easy route offered to him by the reporter, by saying he only did what he was ordered. His ackowledgement of his own agency in the army and his condemnation of his own acts is so brave and paves the way for others to accept their pasts while determining a different future. Both of these good souls give me hope.
Come on world! Look .. this is the truth
I hope they are safe! This takes courage!
Brave people…deserve respect ❤❤❤
After committing such a horrific atrocities now u realised the facts this is not the first time people come out to speak, it has happened many times
They saw the real truth 🙌 finally someone from inside to tell the truth 👍
That’s the true care of humanity
They are braver than others
They have moral ethics and I appreciate them for being true and kind personalities
Thank you Frima and Dan for speaking the truth. You demonstrate the highest bravery.
THANK YOU, thank you for coming forward and talking about the Israeli army's attitude to this immoral occupation!!
Thank you for this interview
Moral price of security
"there can not be an occupation that will be moral or conduct itself in a good way"
wow it was refreshing to hear some honest words
Well done, your parents should be proud 🇵🇸🇵🇸
This was 6 years ago poor Palestinians suffering for so long....and these guys were ok with it until they woke up
It’s when you don’t feel guilty for your wrongs is when your soul is in trouble.
Respect to those who stand for the truth and talk against oppression
Reveal or no reveal..Allah sees and watch everything..many thanks for sincere thoughts to support the Muslims & Palestine people..May Allah open your hearts to enter Islam which is the best rewards for your good deeds..for your lives in this world and here after..May Allah bless you both endlessly
takes great courage to speak up against what you've been conditioned to be right. we all have to do this at some point and face our complicity in various injustices. I salute them and all former idf soldiers who spoke up.
We need more people like you.
Well done for speaking out.
The last words she said already started on October 7 2023
Allah bless these people for their honesty ameen.
Truth can never be suppressed, lies and falsehoods will fall of the cliffs.
👍👍👍👍well done the bravest are the ones whom admit to wrongs and feel guilty about what they have done
HUMBLE SOULS MAY ALLAH AZZAWAJAL GUIDE THEM TO THE TRUTH❤❤❤☝🤲🤲🤲🤲❤🇵🇸❤
Ya rabbi Amin 🤲🏻
Inshallah
Thank you for siding with the truth ,specifically when you were part of the crime but then listened to your heart and didn't sell your soul.
I hope God will always protects you two.... Aamiin
The bravest people I have ever heard and seen on screen - what a revelation.
Some of them are human beings ,!!!
They are really honest and humane personality for civilized society 👍
Respect to you both ⚘
And all the others like you.
Thank you brave people.
TQ so much for speaking up. You are indeed people of conscience and may God lead you to the right path.
All we have to do is look at history no occupation ever lasted wise words.
I hope this occupation ends in our lifetime.
The are indeed courageous to speak out, my Allah give them true guidance.
May they be rewarded for their bravery to speak out.
Two decent human beings. Respect in telling the truth.
Thank You to these People for speaking out, that takes courage!
Thank you! You are smart, brave, and caring! You represent integrity and good values! Breaking the silence for sure brings you hate from cowards, but stay strong!!! The world is learning the truth, and it’s thanks to brave people like you!
Nothing has changed, only worsened.
then we need to pray harder... hope is still alive no matter how small and faint it is... ❤🇵🇸❤