Tigerclaw would rule the forest, Squirrelflight, Leafpool, Jayfeather, Lionblaze, Hollyleaf, and more kin of him would not exist and major plot points made by him would be gone.
then many warrior cats we know may have never existed. jayfeather, hollyleaf, lionblaze, squirrelflight, leafpool, etc. tf would fall apart. scourge would take over thr forest. ravenpaw would die. brokenstar would have never died.
What if Lionheart didn't die?..... What if.. Rusty // Firestar didn't go to the clan? What if... Bluestar wasn't the leader? What if..... Ravenpaw didn't leave the clan What if... Tigerclaw actually killed Bluestar on the thunder clan path? What if.... Silverstream didn't die giving birth? What if... Graystripe didn't know Silverstream? What if ... Tigerclaw wasn't the deputy What if... Tigerclaw was friendly? What if ... Firestar was clan born? What if... Redtail fought back from Tigerclaw attack? What if.. Tigerclaw didn't send dogs to kill Bluestar? What if .. Cinderpelt was okay and is a warrior? What if.. Firestar didn't become a warrior?
And if Firestar was clanborn, Cloudtail wouldn't exist and he would not be so shamed by Tigerstar and Darkstripe. Also the fight between Longtail and Firestar wouldn't exist.
What if Scourge was successfully adopted into a loving home..? Scourges story is so sad and he would have been adopted if his siblings didn't convince him to run away cus ppl love tiny kittens!!
I’m not there yet, I’m on the last book of TNP (starting) but mine is.. what if feathertail didn’t die? The tribe would probably just all die. And Stormfur wouldn’t stay at the tribe, Crowfeather also would still love her and have kits with her instead.
He would probably become leader and wage war ON EVER CLAN, and even except his little rouge clan into camp. I can only imagine how bad it would be for Fireheart though.
More what ifs: What if Firestar joined another clan? What if Ashfur wasn't killed? What if Leafpool didn't have kits? What if Firestar couldn't save Bramblestar from the fire when he was a kit?
My What ifs: Villains: what if scourge didn’t run away/get bullied by ruby and socks (I haven’t made it to far into the books so he’s the only villain I know most about) Fire’star: what if he stayed with smudge Tiger’star: what if he didn’t become a traitor or kill anyone and was a generally nice character
Here are some of my random what-ifs What if Goosefeather wasn't so crazy with prophecies? What if the ice never broke under Flametail? What if Jayfeather wasn't blind? What if Tigerclaw got a different mentor? What if Snowfur survived? What if Bluestar didn't save Scourge? What if Lionblaze got the the snake before Honeyfern? What if Daisy stayed at the barn? What if the new prophecy cats never went back to The Tribe of Rushing Water? What if the new prophecy cats never found midnight? What if Leafpool didn't find out that there were badgers attacking Thunderclan? What Ivypool was the third cat? What if Dovewing didn't find out about the beavers? What if Mudclaw became leader? What if Pinestar never left thunderclan? What if Bluestar didn't choose Oakheart over Thrushpelt? What if Bluestar gave the apprentices their warrior names? What if Mothflight neved found the moonstone? What if the twolegs never destroyed the forest? What if Greystripe never found Millie? What if Greystripe never found the clans? What if Greypaw never found Rusty? What if Starclan didn't allow Tigerstar to be leader? What if Brokenstar was never leader? What if Yellowfang didn't have kits? What if Spottedleaf survived? What if Cinderpelt never got injured? What if Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Hollyleaf actually WERE Squirrelflight's kits? What if Brackenfur became deputy? What if Skyclan never got driven away? What if Crookedstar stayed friends with Bkuestar during the sunningrocks battle? What if Thistleclaw and Snowfur were never mates? What if Lionblaze survived? What if Windclan was never driven away by Shadowclan? What if Mosskit survived? What if Stonefur survived? What if Bluestar knew that Thistleclaw wouldn't have became deputy? What if Moonflower chose Sunfall?
@@Sky_Editzz23 ohhhhh yeah I read that book in German more than 2 years ago so it’s a little confusing (translating the names into English is a *pain* 😫)
What if Pinestar never left? Then maybe, just maybe, he might’ve been a good father to Tigerstar and would’ve taught him to be kind. Maybe Tigerstar would’ve never hated kittypets because his father would’ve never left to become one. Maybe Pinestar would’ve chosen a good mentor for Tigerstar instead of Thistleclaw-who taught Tigerstar most of his ambitious and deadly ways. Maybe, just *maybe*, Tigerstar could’ve ended up good.
What if..Mapleshade's kits never died? My theory: Mapleshade wouldn't have been driven to insanity, but she would've began to hate appledusk for loving reedshine, she might try to kill reedshine or appledusk, but she would still live longer either way, if she doesn't kill appledusk nor reedshine, she would've not gone insane, and she would've lived happily in starclan with her kits.
What if feathertail didn’t die/save the tribe? I think: The tribe would all die at some point, Stormfur probably wouldn’t stay there, Crowfeather would’ve had kits with Feathertail instead of Leafpool. (Imagine what they’d look like?)
Tigerstar would most likely become leader then accuse fireheart of the murder and exile him from the clan, then he would take over and fireheart probably couldn’t do much about it since Tigerstar was now leader of Thunderclan.
What if rusty never went into the forest?, what if smudge went instead?, what if firestar was a medicine cat?, what if they didnt need to move to a new home?, what if the clans lost to blood clan?, what if princess was a clan leader and not a kittypet?, what if brambleclaw didn't exist?, what if firestar failed to help everyone, what if he was in another clan, what if feathertail never died?what if cinderpelt was a warrior or even made leader, what if graystripe didn't mate with silverstream, what if raven paw never left. What if silverstream didn't help Graystripe out of the water?, what if tigerstars kill attempts worked out?, what if bluestar was never leader?, what if all the clans had different leaders?, what if the thunderpaths never existed?, what if..it was all a dream and rusty is still at home with smudge..
What if.. Rusty wasnt Firestar but smudge would go in the clan? Bluestar didnt die but Firestar would? Bluestar wasnt leader but was queen? Snowkit wasnt taken by hawk? Tigerstar wasnt deputy? More what-ifs will be added soon
ALL of my “ What if..(s) “ What if Tigerstar killed bluestar? What if Redtail fought back? What if Ravenpaw didn’t see tigerstar killing redtail? What if tigerstar killed bluestar on the thunder path? What if Cinderpaw(pelt) was never firestars apprentice? What if darkstripe didn’t feed sorrelkit deathberries? What if Firestar was clan born?
What if it was a dream? What if RavenPaw listened to TigerClaw and went back? What if TigerClaw died from the rock? What if Bluestar kept her kits? What if Graystripe never came back? What if Stormfur never left? What is Stormfur *was* the prophecy cat to kill SharpTooth? What is Brook never liked Stormfur? What if BrambleClaw liked Brook? What if Fireheart never became deputy? What if RavenPaw was the one to find Rusty? What if TigerClaw got mad and scared Rusty away? What if Firepaw was Tigerclaw’s apprentice? What if the cats who were trapped by two legs were never saved? What if Cinderpelt never died? What if Ashfur and Squilf got to together? What if Tawnypaw never left Thunderclan? What if TigerClaw wasn’t evil? What if the clans didn’t leave forest in time? What if the cats who saved the clans died? What if Midnight was evil?
Firestar still would have caught on I believe because of Tigerstar's nasty attitude towards him and also because of the incident with CinderHeart and the Thunderpath
What if... RavenPaw never saw TigerClaw kill RedTail? BlueFur never gave up her kits? CinderPaw never ran out on the ThunderPath? PineStar never gave up his clan life up to be a kittypet? SunStar made ThistleClaw deputy?
I feel like Tiger star would try to say that Fireheart did it and as he used to be a kitty pet and tiger star was trusted by blue star. I feel like most of the clan would believe Tiger star 😮
What if tigerclaw wasn’t evil What if blue star didn’t give up her kits What if fireheart never felt a connection with the forest What if cinderpaw didn’t lose the use of one of her legs What if longtail never got into a fight with fireheart and didn’t rip off his collar What if thunder clan wasn’t desperate for warriors What if silverstream never died What if cinderpaw listened and didn’t go to thunder path What if cloud paw never joined the clan What if fireheart never saw his sister What if rusty ( fireheart name at the time) kept on running from gray paw when they first met
What if Tigerstar never died by scourge? Yet they say warrior cats is for kids, Silverstream died by giving birth. Tigerstar (1st) got his underbelly ripped open. Ashfur got his head literally smashed into rocks by Hollyleaf. So much more to name, endless fighting, endless death, endless sickness. It gets sad sometimes.
What if the clans left the forest after scourge warned them to leave before 3 days passed? And what if they ended up unintentionally settling in skyClan's former camp, and boris, cherry, leaf, scratch, and all the other cats living in that area end up joining the clans, but not skyclan?
FireHeart would be blamed for it and probably exiled and TigerClaw would take control over ThunderClan. Knowing the power he has now he would not stop. He would start unnecessary battles and only focus on gaining as much strength and power as possible.
Tbh i dont to much would change cause she dies anyway just not from him. I think the biggest what if would be what if goose feather was never born? He affected crooked star which had a huge impact on the characters which led to Oakheart which leads to bluestar which leads to goodefeathers prophecy which leads to firestar and on and on and on
What if Sol became a warrior in skyclan What if thunderclan got deafeted What if tigerstar never died What if scourge had a son What if firestar was a villian What if apple dusk didnt cheat on mapleshade More at 50 likes
"At the end of his ninth life firestar closed his eyes, expecting to be welcomed by starclan, awakening to the sound of pellets in the food dish "Rusty!" His housefolk called"
Credits in read more.. And read more for my opinion
I miss you 🥺 -Ghosty
I need to know were you watch it
The biggest what if is what if (rusty) firepaw never joined thunder clan and stayed a kitty pet?
where do you fimd the book?
@@Solar0nAll4s I bought mine the book sets off of Walmart but the book sets can get to be 20$-40$ depending which series
Then he would probably become Leader and Tc might accuse Fireheart when he was trying to tell them that Tigerstar did it.
ooh ✨dRaMa✨
@@7NG3L533 I have an idea that this is a reference to hazbin hotel, right?
@@frosty_artz yeah
“ don’t leave, Rusty! “
“ ok “
OMG
HELP
What if it was just a dream....
Then most of the books won’t even exist 😭
@@Rustyscorner2OMG
I think the BIGGEST what if is, what if FireStar never joined thunderclan?
Chaos ^u^
D.E.S.T.R.U.C.T.I.O.N
Tigerclaw would rule the forest, Squirrelflight, Leafpool, Jayfeather, Lionblaze, Hollyleaf, and more kin of him would not exist and major plot points made by him would be gone.
WHAT IF RUSTY WOKE UP STILL ON HIS BED AND THOUGHT EVERYTHING WAS A DREAM? 😱😱
Then the clans wouldnt exist because Jayfeather was never born
This is the biggest one I can think of in the fisrt series “What if Fire’star stayed as a kitty pet and never went into the forset?
The books wouldn’t be a thing
@@CALICO_ON_PAWSyeah, and the clans would fall because of the “fire will save our clan” prophecy.
Yes
Watch the "Next up forever" MAP
it explains a lot
@@Only_Critical fr
The biggest what if is..
What if rusty stayed as a kittypet?
then many warrior cats we know may have never existed. jayfeather, hollyleaf, lionblaze, squirrelflight, leafpool, etc. tf would fall apart. scourge would take over thr forest. ravenpaw would die. brokenstar would have never died.
@@LumiAthenanumberonefan huh. Big thought.
@@LumiAthenanumberonefan yes though the books could still continue with it being about cats rebelling or running from the dangers
I feel like he would be caught tbh if not then thunderclan would either get destroy or driven out I think?
Yeah I agree.
What if Lionheart didn't die?.....
What if.. Rusty // Firestar didn't go to the clan?
What if... Bluestar wasn't the leader?
What if..... Ravenpaw didn't leave the clan
What if... Tigerclaw actually killed Bluestar on the thunder clan path?
What if.... Silverstream didn't die giving birth?
What if... Graystripe didn't know Silverstream?
What if ... Tigerclaw wasn't the deputy
What if... Tigerclaw was friendly?
What if ... Firestar was clan born?
What if... Redtail fought back from Tigerclaw attack?
What if.. Tigerclaw didn't send dogs to kill Bluestar?
What if .. Cinderpelt was okay and is a warrior?
What if.. Firestar didn't become a warrior?
@Al3xxTh4tTh3r1an oo good one
For Cinderpelt's case, there would probably not be a medicine cat if Yellowfang still died.
And if Firestar was clanborn, Cloudtail wouldn't exist and he would not be so shamed by Tigerstar and Darkstripe. Also the fight between Longtail and Firestar wouldn't exist.
@@elementalheartportals true
@@elementalheartportals also ture
What if Rusty said no and joined Bloodclan instead…?
If Tigerclaw would be leader in ThunderClan, it will be a big chaos😅
What if…
Silverstream never died.
Nearly tears came out because of this but there was more painful scenes…
What if
Scourge was successfully adopted into a loving home..?
Scourges story is so sad and he would have been adopted if his siblings didn't convince him to run away cus ppl love tiny kittens!!
What if...
Yellowfang didn't go back into the fire with Fireheart
What if...
Cinderpelt never got hit
What if...
Fireheart chose kitty-pet life over clan life?
@@Ripples_dragonsthen my life wouldn’t exist.
(For the Firestar one)
Mine is
What if BristleFrost didn’t die?
I literally cried all night bc of that 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
BRO I SOB SO FRICKING HARD EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. I READ THAT PART
I’m not there yet, I’m on the last book of TNP (starting) but mine is.. what if feathertail didn’t die? The tribe would probably just all die. And Stormfur wouldn’t stay at the tribe, Crowfeather also would still love her and have kits with her instead.
Every time this is brought up I start crying bc she didn’t even get to go to starclan🥺😭
@@dead16668Also the three wouldn’t have been born
@@Looniest nah literally TODAY I finished a light in the mist and the last like 6 CHAPTERS I WAS CRYING 😭 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
He would probably become leader and wage war ON EVER CLAN, and even except his little rouge clan into camp. I can only imagine how bad it would be for Fireheart though.
More what ifs:
What if Firestar joined another clan?
What if Ashfur wasn't killed?
What if Leafpool didn't have kits?
What if Firestar couldn't save Bramblestar from the fire when he was a kit?
What if Sol didn’t do a bad thing and stayed in the clan?
Nothing probably much
Some giant what ifs:What if Rusty never Had that dream?,What if Smudge also joined the clans?
Another one is "What if RavenPae never told anyone about TigerClaw's murder? "
“Well then fire will save our clan”
-BlueStar
FIREpaw coming in the next day
What if Firestar didnt suspect Tigerclaw..
My What ifs:
Villains: what if scourge didn’t run away/get bullied by ruby and socks (I haven’t made it to far into the books so he’s the only villain I know most about)
Fire’star: what if he stayed with smudge
Tiger’star: what if he didn’t become a traitor or kill anyone and was a generally nice character
The biggest what-if is 100%… what if FireStar never joined Thunderclan..?
Heres a good one I would say,
What is Crowfeather didn't save Jaypaw from drowning that one time in The Sight?
OH YEAAAHHH, DAMN
What if..? Redtail didnt die and the other clan was friendly!?
Here are some of my random what-ifs
What if Goosefeather wasn't so crazy with prophecies?
What if the ice never broke under Flametail?
What if Jayfeather wasn't blind?
What if Tigerclaw got a different mentor?
What if Snowfur survived?
What if Bluestar didn't save Scourge?
What if Lionblaze got the the snake before Honeyfern?
What if Daisy stayed at the barn?
What if the new prophecy cats never went back to The Tribe of Rushing Water?
What if the new prophecy cats never found midnight?
What if Leafpool didn't find out that there were badgers attacking Thunderclan?
What Ivypool was the third cat?
What if Dovewing didn't find out about the beavers?
What if Mudclaw became leader?
What if Pinestar never left thunderclan?
What if Bluestar didn't choose Oakheart over Thrushpelt?
What if Bluestar gave the apprentices their warrior names?
What if Mothflight neved found the moonstone?
What if the twolegs never destroyed the forest?
What if Greystripe never found Millie?
What if Greystripe never found the clans?
What if Greypaw never found Rusty?
What if Starclan didn't allow Tigerstar to be leader?
What if Brokenstar was never leader?
What if Yellowfang didn't have kits?
What if Spottedleaf survived?
What if Cinderpelt never got injured?
What if Jayfeather, Lionblaze, and Hollyleaf actually WERE Squirrelflight's kits?
What if Brackenfur became deputy?
What if Skyclan never got driven away?
What if Crookedstar stayed friends with Bkuestar during the sunningrocks battle?
What if Thistleclaw and Snowfur were never mates?
What if Lionblaze survived?
What if Windclan was never driven away by Shadowclan?
What if Mosskit survived?
What if Stonefur survived?
What if Bluestar knew that Thistleclaw wouldn't have became deputy?
What if Moonflower chose Sunfall?
I think I need to reread the books help 😭
Like, who is moonflower and who is Sunfall????
@Lu_ni_co They are from the super edition Bluestar's Prophecy. Moonflower is Bluestar's mother, and Sunfall/Sunstar was the leader before Bluestar
@@Sky_Editzz23 ohhhhh yeah I read that book in German more than 2 years ago so it’s a little confusing (translating the names into English is a *pain* 😫)
What if...
What if redtail survived..?
I think the biggest "what if" of Warrior Cats is: "what if the clans never made it to the lake territory"
What if feathertail didn’t die?
Or riverclan stayed behind in the old forest
Or Jayfeather wasn’t blind
The BIGGEST one is probably
“What if yellowfang didn’t hesitate to kill brokenstar?”
I mean he would die anyways@@AceRox-pi7vk
The warrior cats story:
*becomes short*
One of my biggest what-ifs is: what if Fireheart/Firestar and Graystripe never met?
What if Pinestar never left?
Then maybe, just maybe, he might’ve been a good father to Tigerstar and would’ve taught him to be kind. Maybe Tigerstar would’ve never hated kittypets because his father would’ve never left to become one. Maybe Pinestar would’ve chosen a good mentor for Tigerstar instead of Thistleclaw-who taught Tigerstar most of his ambitious and deadly ways. Maybe, just *maybe*, Tigerstar could’ve ended up good.
IKR WOULD'VE CHANGED A LOT 😭
What if brumblepaw had escaped to go to the shadowclan with tawnypaw?
What if Jagged Peak never snuck out?
What if..Mapleshade's kits never died?
My theory:
Mapleshade wouldn't have been driven to insanity, but she would've began to hate appledusk for loving reedshine, she might try to kill reedshine or appledusk, but she would still live longer either way, if she doesn't kill appledusk nor reedshine, she would've not gone insane, and she would've lived happily in starclan with her kits.
What if
Scourge missed TigerClaw..?
What if rusty being in the forest was a dream?.. and at the end of the series he woke up…
What if Firestar never joined thunder clan is the biggest what-if ever in warrior cat history.
I’m a warrior cat
No u Ryth fan
no.
what if Rusty decided not to come to the forest..?
i would be crying all night 😭
OH MY GOD WE NEED A AU IF WE DONT ALREADY HAVE ONE
What if Blue Star never even died?...
My biggest what if is…
What if Scourge (tiny) never left his twolegs?
What if Scourge killed Firestar and Firestar had no remaining lives..?
What if feathertail didn’t die/save the tribe?
I think: The tribe would all die at some point,
Stormfur probably wouldn’t stay there,
Crowfeather would’ve had kits with Feathertail instead of Leafpool. (Imagine what they’d look like?)
My list of what if’s:
What if…
Bluestar never found Rusty?
Swiftpaw survived?
Tigerclaw didn’t kill Redtail?
Rusty and Smudge switched places?
What if firestar died on the journey through the mountains? Who would take over since greystripe wasn’t there?
Firestar probably would have been kicked out, and the clans would eventually fall apart 😀
Tigerstar would most likely become leader then accuse fireheart of the murder and exile him from the clan, then he would take over and fireheart probably couldn’t do much about it since Tigerstar was now leader of Thunderclan.
What if Ravenpaw never saw Tigerclaw kill Redtail? That’s a big one for me fsr
What if:
-Rusty never survived in the scene where Longtail almost strangles him?
Mine is what if Smudge joined ShadowClan and Rusty became Bloodclan’s leader? (Idk if it’s original lol)
What if rusty never went into the forest?, what if smudge went instead?, what if firestar was a medicine cat?, what if they didnt need to move to a new home?, what if the clans lost to blood clan?, what if princess was a clan leader and not a kittypet?, what if brambleclaw didn't exist?, what if firestar failed to help everyone, what if he was in another clan, what if feathertail never died?what if cinderpelt was a warrior or even made leader, what if graystripe didn't mate with silverstream, what if raven paw never left. What if silverstream didn't help Graystripe out of the water?, what if tigerstars kill attempts worked out?, what if bluestar was never leader?, what if all the clans had different leaders?, what if the thunderpaths never existed?, what if..it was all a dream and rusty is still at home with smudge..
My biggest warrior. Arts what if is……. What if the ancients never left the lake?
War❤
What if..
Rusty wasnt Firestar but smudge would go in the clan?
Bluestar didnt die but Firestar would?
Bluestar wasnt leader but was queen?
Snowkit wasnt taken by hawk?
Tigerstar wasnt deputy?
More what-ifs will be added soon
Both Bluestar and Firestar died....
Also it was Snowkit who got taken by the hawk, I don't mean any offensive btw just pointing that out👍
@@TheAnnukki yea
@@TheAnnukki Ty I forgot :D
@@1-_Anuskaa_-1 yw! :>
ALL of my “ What if..(s) “
What if Tigerstar killed bluestar?
What if Redtail fought back?
What if Ravenpaw didn’t see tigerstar killing redtail?
What if tigerstar killed bluestar on the thunder path?
What if Cinderpaw(pelt) was never firestars apprentice?
What if darkstripe didn’t feed sorrelkit deathberries?
What if Firestar was clan born?
What if it was a dream?
What if RavenPaw listened to TigerClaw and went back?
What if TigerClaw died from the rock?
What if Bluestar kept her kits?
What if Graystripe never came back?
What if Stormfur never left?
What is Stormfur *was* the prophecy cat to kill SharpTooth?
What is Brook never liked Stormfur?
What if BrambleClaw liked Brook?
What if Fireheart never became deputy?
What if RavenPaw was the one to find Rusty? What if TigerClaw got mad and scared Rusty away?
What if Firepaw was Tigerclaw’s apprentice?
What if the cats who were trapped by two legs were never saved?
What if Cinderpelt never died?
What if Ashfur and Squilf got to together?
What if Tawnypaw never left Thunderclan?
What if TigerClaw wasn’t evil?
What if the clans didn’t leave forest in time?
What if the cats who saved the clans died?
What if Midnight was evil?
Firestar still would have caught on I believe because of Tigerstar's nasty attitude towards him and also because of the incident with CinderHeart and the Thunderpath
Why is nobody talking about how Tigerclaw sheated his claw on the beat 😔
What if Fireheart refused to go to the thunderclan and stayed instead at the twoleg town?
What if Mothflight never got saved from the dog? What if the badgers never attacked
Smudge is still waiting..
What if stone teller kept her dream to herself?
(dotc)
I just read blue stars death scene and I was crying when I read it, so I understand what you mean
What if… Rusty said no?
What if...
RavenPaw never saw TigerClaw kill RedTail?
BlueFur never gave up her kits?
CinderPaw never ran out on the ThunderPath?
PineStar never gave up his clan life up to be a kittypet?
SunStar made ThistleClaw deputy?
I feel like Tiger star would try to say that Fireheart did it and as he used to be a kitty pet and tiger star was trusted by blue star. I feel like most of the clan would believe Tiger star 😮
What if ivypool Continued to train in the dark forest but she was loyal to them?
What if tigerclaw wasn’t evil
What if blue star didn’t give up her kits
What if fireheart never felt a connection with the forest
What if cinderpaw didn’t lose the use of one of her legs
What if longtail never got into a fight with fireheart and didn’t rip off his collar
What if thunder clan wasn’t desperate for warriors
What if silverstream never died
What if cinderpaw listened and didn’t go to thunder path
What if cloud paw never joined the clan
What if fireheart never saw his sister
What if rusty ( fireheart name at the time) kept on running from gray paw when they first met
What if all of this is just Rusty's dream? And when TigerStar kills FireStar he wakes up
What if Tigerstar never died by scourge? Yet they say warrior cats is for kids,
Silverstream died by giving birth.
Tigerstar (1st) got his underbelly ripped open.
Ashfur got his head literally smashed into rocks by Hollyleaf.
So much more to name, endless fighting, endless death, endless sickness. It gets sad sometimes.
What if the clans left the forest after scourge warned them to leave before 3 days passed? And what if they ended up unintentionally settling in skyClan's former camp, and boris, cherry, leaf, scratch, and all the other cats living in that area end up joining the clans, but not skyclan?
What if...
Scourge was the main character and instead of being chased off by tigerpaw he joined the clan and became medicine cat?
the actuall biggest what if is:
WHAT IF THE MOONSTONE WAS NEVER FOUND
What if the snowstorm never came to that mountain...
What if...
JayFeather never interfered with the war between the dark forest and starclan?
FireHeart would be blamed for it and probably exiled and TigerClaw would take control over ThunderClan. Knowing the power he has now he would not stop. He would start unnecessary battles and only focus on gaining as much strength and power as possible.
My what if: What if…
LeafPool left thunderclan for CrowFeather?
… y’know I really dunno.. but uhhh.. they definitely won’t let Leafpool join the clan so.. They’d live somewhere else is my conclusion!
Tbh i dont to much would change cause she dies anyway just not from him. I think the biggest what if would be what if goose feather was never born? He affected crooked star which had a huge impact on the characters which led to Oakheart which leads to bluestar which leads to goodefeathers prophecy which leads to firestar and on and on and on
What if
Sol became a warrior in skyclan
What if thunderclan got deafeted
What if tigerstar never died
What if scourge had a son
What if firestar was a villian
What if apple dusk didnt cheat on mapleshade
More at 50 likes
"At the end of his ninth life firestar closed his eyes, expecting to be welcomed by starclan, awakening to the sound of pellets in the food dish
"Rusty!" His housefolk called"
Not to bad if I say so myself
What if…
*Bluestar didn’t sacrifice herself?*
Hear me out. What if Rusty refused to join?
What if….
Hawkwing didn’t trust darktail?
What if…
Jagged peak never ran off?
What if...
Scourge had a good family and didn't go into the forest...
What if....
Rusty listened to Smudge?
What if...
*Rusty stayed as a kittypet?*
My friends birthday is 4th of July.
What if....
Blue'star never gave up her kits?
What if… the villians were the good guys and the good guys were the villians?
ALL HAIL THE KINGGG
what if hawkfrost and brambleclaw teamed up?
What if
It was just a dream....
Good 4th of july
I wish i could read warrior cats because i can't find one book🤨
What if smudge joined the clans??
What if tigerstar and scrooge were still alive?
What if.... Fire star was never curious... And didn't go to the forest...