Is Karachi facing an Economic Genocide? | Ali Zaidi Vs Shabbar Zaidi | Part-01 | Z2

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 27. 06. 2024
  • "Is Karachi facing an Economic Genocide? Part 01" Watch a candid discussion between former Federal Minister Ali Haider Zaidi and Former FBR Chairman Shabbar Zaidi.
    -----------
    MM News TV - The Unbiased Perspective
    MM News is a subsidiary of the MM Group of Companies. It was established in 2019 with the aim of providing people of Pakistan access to unbiased information.
    -----------
    Follow us on:
    Website: mmnews.tv/
    Twitter: / mmnewsdottv
    Facebook: / mmnewsdottv
    Instagram: / mmnewsdottv
    -----------
    Watch Previous Episodes:
    Ep 01: • Establishment or Govt:...
    Ep 02: • Pakistan Hasn't Change...
    Ep 03: • Corruption: The Ultima...
    Ep:04: • FBR Should be Shut Dow...
    -----------
    #shabbarzaidi #alizaidi #federalboardofrevenue #z2 #fbr #imrankhan #pakistaneconomy #pakistaneconomycrisis #imrankhan #isi #povertyline #tax #psdp #establishment #businessmen #bureaucracy #naidqasid #pakistanipolitician #pakistanipolitics #govtemployees #pansion #sindhwastemanagement #karachi #genocide #economycrisis #dataanalytics #economicgeography #economyofpakistan #muradsaeed #corruptioninpakistan

Komentáře • 91

  • @farooqham
    @farooqham Před 7 dny +12

    Let shabar zaidi speak please

  • @tariqsheikh5945
    @tariqsheikh5945 Před 7 dny +8

    Why don't you implement the LAHORE RESOLUTION
    IT CALLED FOR INDEPENDENT MUSLIM STATES.
    Yes, STATES...PLURAL...

  • @muhammadsaqib2961
    @muhammadsaqib2961 Před 7 dny +12

    Plz shabbar sb. Tell Ali sahab don't speak much....

    • @ahaanmisra4892
      @ahaanmisra4892 Před 5 dny

      Ali sahab seems to have created this channel only because he has no other avenue to release his pent up 'gubar'! Is bechare ko koi bula kar baat kar liya karo

    • @GhOusyt
      @GhOusyt Před 5 dny

      agree

    • @zaf7794
      @zaf7794 Před 2 dny

      What Ali zaidi spoke about Karachi is correct

  • @shahidkk2460
    @shahidkk2460 Před 7 dny +6

    APNA SOOBA APNA IKHTIYAR MUHAJIR SOOBA ZINDABAD

  • @syedabuzar4628
    @syedabuzar4628 Před 6 dny +3

    Zaidi still speaks like he’s on tv, he should use his free speech to the fullest

  • @hassan_lodhi
    @hassan_lodhi Před 7 dny +4

    Kindly Shabbar sb ko bat complete krne dia krein

  • @HadiMash-zl3dj
    @HadiMash-zl3dj Před 7 dny +3

    Outstanding sir only say truth
    Karachi city like a dustbin know a days

  • @shehryarshahid7966
    @shehryarshahid7966 Před 7 dny +2

    An eye opener for all of us .. good show .. keep it up👍🏻

  • @sukkurdiaries8887
    @sukkurdiaries8887 Před 7 dny +3

    ISI m bhi extra employees appoint kiye gae hain, 2 chefs ki zaroorat hai, 2 extras m bhi hain... Army m bhi 7.5 lacs m bhi kitne kaam K Hain, aur kitne faaltoo... salaries, pensions to state, awaam, taajiro ne dene hain, Kisi judge general politician, Civil afsar ne apne pocket se nhe...

  • @saleem2347
    @saleem2347 Před 5 dny +1

    Is it possible to mute Ali Zaidi (a.K.a yahan goli maarna yahan) in this video?

  • @jawwadnizami4439
    @jawwadnizami4439 Před 7 dny +2

    Both personalities speak well. I must suggest that they must give realistic solutions as well.

  • @muhammadsaqib2961
    @muhammadsaqib2961 Před 7 dny +2

    Last sentence was good whole program by shabbar sb.

  • @abdulwali4920
    @abdulwali4920 Před 7 dny +1

    this is what happens with the country whose deciion makers are jokers

  • @fahadahmed6372
    @fahadahmed6372 Před 6 dny +1

    1100 arab ka package kahan hai? kpt me punjab k domicile par naukri q di? ALI ZAIDI sb??

  • @ansarmahboob5713
    @ansarmahboob5713 Před 7 dny +1

    Sir when government gave nothing to common people. Why impose heavily taxes on people.

  • @mzs9262
    @mzs9262 Před 6 dny +1

    He is keep is “Akhri Batt , Akhri Batt”

  • @AsimKhan-ub5mj
    @AsimKhan-ub5mj Před dnem

    AA. Please is bat par program karain kay agar hum default kr jain to kia ho jay ga? Hamara adhay se ziada federal budget (9000 Billion Rs) sirf qarzon par interest payments main nikal jata hai. Kasay chalay ga mulk is tarah jab kuch bachta hi nai hai baki chezon kay liay?
    Kindly default par program karain aur batain kay default kay bad kia hamaray qarzay aur un par interest maf ho jain gay?

  • @usmanshakiir
    @usmanshakiir Před 7 dny

    Thank you Sir

  • @nijoftdc
    @nijoftdc Před 7 dny +1

    Very informative appreciate that

  • @TheVvoiice
    @TheVvoiice Před 7 dny +2

    I was waiting for zaidi sb

  • @al-hamid3998
    @al-hamid3998 Před 7 dny +4

    PTI failure in Govt. Was that there was no member of elected PTI, who had a working experience in govt.departments.

  • @kashifhayatpti1580
    @kashifhayatpti1580 Před 7 dny +1

    Good initiative all the best

  • @FaisalKhan-wf8ys
    @FaisalKhan-wf8ys Před 6 dny +1

    Asim Munir, Bajwa, fauj.

  • @firozebukht8207
    @firozebukht8207 Před dnem

    Karachi is badly hit by economically. Taxes utilize to pay the government employees, pensions, pay & Perks of the Assemblies and all the budget spends on politicians the remaining used for maintenance works only.

  • @vherlekar
    @vherlekar Před 7 dny +1

    Reminds 👆me of the "Yes Prime Minister" sitcom - episode "Patron of the Arts" (available on Dailymotion app) -- 😁 demonstrating Govt wastage -- it's like CANCER in Pakistan!!

  • @danishsiraj8242
    @danishsiraj8242 Před 7 dny +1

    Lo aj phir gir gir bat khtam bilawja tex ka tnta kion laay is episode men sedha bat shrow whan se krte jo end pr ki

  • @manekkapur8889
    @manekkapur8889 Před 7 dny

    Karachi known as City of Lights

  • @AHMEDSAZIZI
    @AHMEDSAZIZI Před 5 dny

    Umeed thee app PURA SUCH bolay gaay @Shabber sahib per bahoot mayosi hoi.

  • @Asimpen
    @Asimpen Před 7 dny

    I’ve just played it and liked it already because i love this series. So i like before listening in case i forget.

  • @mzs9262
    @mzs9262 Před 6 dny +1

    Tired of listening to ALI ZAIDI only ! he should start stop watch if he want to speak only

  • @deepakpasi4417
    @deepakpasi4417 Před 7 dny +1

    What nonsense!!

  • @AliAhmed-ku3wz
    @AliAhmed-ku3wz Před 7 dny

    great video 👍 👌

  • @syedabidali3
    @syedabidali3 Před 7 dny

    Sir kab or keasay saheee hooogaa?

    • @ahshah2745
      @ahshah2745 Před 7 dny

      Why not u guys shake Murad Ali Shah.
      How far will he polish / lick Zardari's dash dash dash.
      Where will he take his this mount of wealth.
      Nawab of Hyserabad was one of the richest man of world at his time....where is he now?
      Nawab of Bahawalpur and all other rich people of just 50 years back where they are now.
      Why not u guys learn from the history.
      Why people when get into power forget that their will be over too sooner or later.
      PooeZardari is mentally sick. Why not Murad Ali Shah takes the nail of wisdom?????

    • @ahmedvoice1763
      @ahmedvoice1763 Před 7 dny

      حیرت ہے آپ صحیح ہونے کی امید لگائے بیٹھے ہو۔

  • @ibratnak
    @ibratnak Před 6 dny

    These politicians always prescribe a top-down approach where they recommend drastic changes in governance and administration. That's another way of saying: vote for me, I'm better than the current lot, I'll change everything. The real solution is in bottom-up approach where change begins from the grassroots and moves up. It doesn't require a seat at the table, just a couple of highly motivated individuals.

  • @aaash4540
    @aaash4540 Před 7 dny

    Good job

  • @mahmoodahmad3775
    @mahmoodahmad3775 Před 5 dny +3

    علی زیدی بھائی! جب آپ کوئی بات ختم کرتے ہیں تو شبر زیدی صاحب کو بولنے دیا کریں۔ آپ بات کاٹنا بند کریں یہ اچھا نہیں لگتا۰ اور آپ بہت زیادہ یہ کرتے ہیں

    • @PakNetaverse
      @PakNetaverse Před 3 dny

      Inko ni samaj ayegi q k PTI walay hain ye kisi ko bolne ni dete sirf khud ko theek samajte hain

  • @vikasb1400
    @vikasb1400 Před 7 dny

    nice

  • @ssjavaad
    @ssjavaad Před 6 dny

    Yaar why can’t Ali Zaidi keep his mouth shut!!

  • @abduljabbarabduljabbar9109

    Sub se bara masla peace hai.peace ho jai Karachi sameet poory Pakistan ki econ0my strong honjaigi.

  • @TheVvoiice
    @TheVvoiice Před 7 dny

    Haq sach hy

  • @adnanahmed560
    @adnanahmed560 Před 7 dny

    میری تجویز یا التجا ہے کہ کوئ ایک ایسی مہیم چلائ جائے جس کا ایجنڈا یہ ہے ہو کہ ملکی اداروں کیا احتساب یا کم از کام ھساب کتاب مانگا جایے اور اس مین کوی سیاسی جماعت حصہ نا لے اور نہ ہی سیاسی رنک دیا جایے۔ علی بھای نے بہت اچھا کیا جو ایک پرچہ نکال لیا۔ بس ایسے ہی یہ پرچہ عوام لے کر کھڑے ہوں جو کہ ؐمالک ہیں اداروں کے اور وہ کچھ اور نہیں بس حساب لے لیں۔ اور کچھ نہیں۔

  • @Th3L0st0ne
    @Th3L0st0ne Před 7 dny

    what are you talking about Ali Zaidi bhai. I think you are confused by what is FBR.. it is not the FBR building in Islamabad. it is all the offices in the entire country

  • @ibratnak
    @ibratnak Před 7 dny

    Economics is the art of satisfying unlimited wants with limited resources. The solution Pakistani economists give to a 1000 rupees problem is to reduce 10 rupees worth of extravagant spending in a 100 rupees budget. Pakistanis don't know the art of creative problem solving, but find creative ways to highlight that problem. Perhaps a reallocation of creativity might help?

  • @lifewithfarrukh7691
    @lifewithfarrukh7691 Před 7 dny

    Mujy ye samj nh ata jab "Ali Zaidi sahab" "Federal Minister for Maritime Affairs and port" they tb inhony Karachi ke Domicile rakhne wlon ke leay jobs kyun nh nikali, ya Karachi ke nojawno ko ak bhe job kyun nh di khawa wo kesi bhe zaban ka hota but Karacho domicile hota but ye ye log power me hoty hain tb kuch or vision hota hy zameen py he nh aty.

    • @fahadahmed6372
      @fahadahmed6372 Před 6 dny

      tab isney punjab k domicile par jobs nikali thi, not even sindh

  • @shazeemalichishty7322

    AZ keep it up

  • @shahidkk2460
    @shahidkk2460 Před 7 dny +2

    MUHAJIR SOOBA ZINDABAD

  • @PR-pu7pv
    @PR-pu7pv Před 6 dny

    You are telling reality of pakistan but telling reality of india, pakistan and Bangladesh 😂😂😂❤
    Same to same with some difference 😅😅

  • @discoverywithjaffery
    @discoverywithjaffery Před 6 dny

    oh bhai jab ap government mai thay tab kahan thay ap log. Tab ye batein karte na. Jo b government mai hota hai tab kuch nahi bolta. Bus jese he govt se bahir hotay ho mazoolmiat aur awami maslay bayan karna shuru.

  • @vikasb1400
    @vikasb1400 Před 7 dny

    Looks like FBR is another Wadhera

  • @blacknwhitenblue
    @blacknwhitenblue Před 7 dny

    Karachi has been facing economic ostracism since atleast 2008....but why is Shabbar sb doing this podcast with this joker? Is it because both are Zaidi?

  • @faraz6602
    @faraz6602 Před 7 dny

    Ali bhai shabar bhai se nhi karin tafree apki lagta hai izat karty hain bohat varna yeh halky mai nhi hai ..... shabar nhi babar sher hain yeh

  • @zopashagha1397
    @zopashagha1397 Před 7 dny

    One expert and one over emotional person, it's not a way to conduct an analytical program. Please have intellectuals.

  • @peterkesh
    @peterkesh Před 7 dny

    Host is very annoying. He tries to be smart but.....God bless him. I wish he acts and speak more maturely. Unnecessary moving his heavy body and talks too much.

  • @keyboard4786
    @keyboard4786 Před 5 dny

    Asal ma Pakistan ke Daly Khoni Generals Dushman ha Sab Sobon ke

  • @Fays424
    @Fays424 Před 7 dny

    plz zaidi chup ho jao, shabbar ko bolney do

  • @vikasb1400
    @vikasb1400 Před 7 dny

    Ghost Pension😮 ???

  • @Fays424
    @Fays424 Před 7 dny

    Zaidi shabbar ko bol ney do

  • @awaiskhanofficial2586

    Ali zaidi agr itna bolna h to akele program kro

  • @japanbb4436
    @japanbb4436 Před 5 dny

    I got alot respect for shabar zaidi... but ali zaidi is big time munafiq........

  • @faraz6602
    @faraz6602 Před 7 dny

    shabar nhi babar hain yeh uchal uchal k layty hain yeh loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee you shabar bhaiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

  • @shahidkk2460
    @shahidkk2460 Před 7 dny

    ALI ZAIDI SAHAB AUR SHABBAR ZAIDI SAHAB KUCHCH KERNA HE TO APNI MUHAJIR QOAM KE LIYE KUCHCH KER LO SUB APNI APNI QOAM KE LIYE KERTE HEIN AAP LOG DOOSRON KA SOCHTE HO AUR APNI QOAM KO NUQSAN POHANCHATAY HO KUCHCH TO GHEIRAT KA MUZAHIRA KARO

  • @alykhan2941
    @alykhan2941 Před 7 dny

    Lol aisay masoomo ko tarah keh raha hai jaisay naya aya hai Ali Zaidi 😂

  • @GuzzarAwan
    @GuzzarAwan Před 7 dny

    O bhai 😅 tum log Podcast banaakar so jaogey honaa kuch nhi .
    Punjabi jarnail aur civil servant ko tum logo se koi matlab nhi

  • @raheemkhan7809
    @raheemkhan7809 Před 3 dny

    Ye ali zaidi khud chor hai isko kaha bitha diya podcast me

  • @hamzaaslam9919
    @hamzaaslam9919 Před 7 dny

    Lora bhi TUjhe tajurba nhi ha shabar zaidi ko bol ne dia kr beach beach me bol ta rehta ha

  • @ahmedafb
    @ahmedafb Před 7 dny +1

    Shabbar is making good money on these talkshows :)
    Mashallah when he was responsible, he didn't do anything..
    When he is not responsible, he is doing a lot on talkshows and make extra cash

    • @jattjamesbond1122
      @jattjamesbond1122 Před 7 dny

      Well he guide IK but IK love bajwa at that time so nothing to talk about 😏

  • @m.usmananwar3573
    @m.usmananwar3573 Před 7 dny +1

    ali zaidi to khud louta he wo kis mun se economy ki baat kr raha he. is k abu whiskey ne tabah kya he sb